The Code of the Debater
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Code of the Debater The Code of the Debater INTRODUCTION TO POLICY DEBATING ALFRED C. SNIDER International Debate Education Association New York • Amsterdam • Brussels International Debate Education Association New York • Amsterdam • Brussels Published by: International Debate Education Association 400 West 59th Street New York, NY 10019 © 2008 International Debate Education Association All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission from the publisher. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Snider, Alfred. The code of the debater : introduction to policy debating / Alfred C. Snider. p. cm. 1. Debates and debating. I. Title. PN4181.S65 2008 808.53--dc22 2008020463 Design by Kathleen Hayes Printed in the USA Contents Acknowledgments xi Introduction xiii What Is Debate? xiii Why Debate? xiii PART ONE: INITIATION Chapter 1. Policy Debate 3 The Policy Debate Experience 3 The Debate Tournament 4 The Resolution 5 Speech Order and Responsibilities 6 Judges 10 The Affirmative Stock Issues: Upholding the Resolution 11 The Negative Stock Issues: Refuting the Resolution or Case 12 Exercises 14 The Code of the Debater 16 PART tWO: BASIC KNOWLEDGE Chapter 2. The Affirmative Case 19 Affirmative Advantages 19 Selecting an Affirmative Case 20 Preparing an Affirmative Case 21 Constructing Your Affirmative Case—The First Affirmative Speech 23 Briefing/Frontlines—Preparation Before the Debate 28 Exercises 30 Chapter 3. The negative Attacks the Affirmative Case 31 General Considerations 31 Organizational Guidelines for Attacking the Case 32 Strategic Willingness to Concede Portions of Case 33 Specific Techniques for Attacking the Affirmative Case 34 Utilizing Challenges 34 Indicting Affirmative Evidence 35 Techniques for Dealing with Stock Issues 36 Clashing with Affirmative Inherency 36 Clashing with Affirmative Impact Claims 37 Attacking Affirmative Solvency 41 Conclusion 42 Exercises 42 Chapter 4. The Disadvantage 44 Components 44 Types of Disadvantage Scenarios 45 Threshold Scenario 46 Linear Scenario 47 Structure of a Sample Disadvantage Argument 48 Other Concepts You Might Find Useful 48 Time Frame 49 Preemptions 49 Advice to Affirmatives: How to Answer a Disadvantage 49 Winning Disadvantages on the Negative 52 Kicking Out of Disadvantages 52 Exercises 53 Chapter 5. The Counterplan 55 Criteria 55 Answering Counterplans 58 Exercises 59 Chapter 6. The Process of Critique 61 Why Are Critiques Valuable? 64 Types of Critiques 66 Answering Critiques 68 Exercises 70 Chapter 7. The topicality Argument 71 Arguing about Definitions 72 Winning with Topicality 72 Making a Topicality Argument 73 Reasons to Prefer the Negative Definition(s) 74 Topicality Can Help with Other Arguments 75 vi The Code of the Debater Answering Topicality 75 Affirmative Topicality Tips 76 Common Responses to Topicality Arguments 77 Reasons Why Topicality Is Not a Voting Issue 78 Exercises 79 Chapter 8. Debate Steps 80 First Affirmative Constructive (1AC) 80 First Negative Constructive (1NC) 81 Second Affirmative Constructive (2AC) 82 Second Negative Constructive (2NC) 84 First Negative Rebuttal (1NR) 86 First Affirmative Rebuttal (1AR) 86 Second Negative Rebuttal (2NR) 88 Second Affirmative Rebuttal (2AR) 91 Timeline for a Policy Debate 93 Before the Round 93 During the Debate 93 After the Round 98 PART tHREE: DEBATERS hAVE SKILLS Chapter 9. Speaking 101 Goals 102 The Dynamic Speaker 102 Applying Dynamism Factors to Delivery 103 Voice 103 Face 104 Eye Contact 104 Body Movement 104 Gestures 105 The Physical Elements of Speech 105 Parts of Your Speech System 106 Caring for Your Speech System 107 Giving a Good First Impression 107 Speaking Drills 108 Breathing Problems 108 Enunciation Problems 109 Contents vii Pitch Problems 109 Monotone or Singsong Delivery 109 Volume Problems 110 Other Delivery Problems 110 Other Drills to Improve Speaking 111 Chapter 10. Flowing 113 The Basics 113 Materials 113 Organizing the Flowsheets 114 Using Symbolic Vocabulary 115 Flowing Speech by Speech 117 Helpful Tips for Flowing 117 Chapter 11. Organizing Arguments 119 Learn to Build an Outline 119 Structure Beyond the Outline 121 Building a Single Argument—The A-R-E Model 122 Put Them Together with Notation 123 Signposting—Staying Organized during Your Speech 123 Organizing Your Refutation 125 Chapter 12. Preparing as a team 127 Partnerships 127 How to Prepare on the Affirmative 128 How to Prepare on the Negative 129 Chapter 13. Cross-Examination 131 Objectives of Cross-Examination 131 Guidelines for Asking Questions 132 Guidelines for Answering Questions 133 Tactics for Specific Cross-Examination Situations 135 Chapter 14. Research 137 The Importance of Research 137 A Debate Research Plan 138 Library Resources 139 Gaining Access 139 Reference Materials 140 viii The Code of the Debater Online Resources 140 Books 142 Government Documents 142 Internet Research 142 Chapter 15. Evidence 145 Creating Evidence Cards 145 Simple Guidelines for Evidence Citation 146 Evaluating Evidence 147 Evidence Drills 148 Chapter 16. Briefing 149 Titles and Tagging of Briefs 150 Writing Briefs and Taglines 150 Format of Brief Pages 150 Taping Briefs 151 Strategic Considerations—Or How to Make Your Work 152 More Useful Analytical Arguments 152 Analysis Drills 153 Chapter 17. Rebuttals 154 Chapter 18. Adapting to Judges and Audiences 157 Collecting and Using Information on the Judge 157 Types of Judges 158 Adapting to Specific Judge Types 159 Type B Adaptations 159 Type C Adaptations 161 PART FOUR: ENDLESS JOURNEY Chapter 19. The Better Debater? 165 The “Better” Debater 165 The “Not Better” Debater 166 Chapter 20. How the Decision Gets Made 167 Tuna’s Equation 168 Aunt Bluebell’s Scales 170 Contents ix Chapter 21. Cross-Application of Ideas 173 Chapter 22. Evolving Arguments: Strategic handling of Disadvantages 177 Evolving Disadvantages 177 APPENDIXES Appendix 1: videos And web Sites 187 Videos 187 Videos for Policy Debaters 187 Sample Policy Debate (free) 187 Policy Debate Instruction Videos (free) 188 Training Resources (for purchase) 188 Classroom Lecture Series: Critical Advocacy (free) 188 Web Sites for Policy Debate 189 Appendix 2: Sample Flowsheet 191 Appendix 3: Sample Brief 192 Democracy is Not So Good [Frontline] 192 Glossary 195 x The Code of the Debater Acknowledgments While my name is on the cover and I am very willing to accept any and all blame for errors and faults found in this volume, this is certainly not something that I have done alone. Since 1972 I have been gathering and evaluating debate-training materials for my own use. I have stolen every good teaching technique I have ever encountered. One main source I have borrowed from is the Emory National Debate Institute (ENDI). Melissa Wade and the Barkley Forum at Emory Univer- sity have been national leaders in developing training materials for new debaters. Year after year they have refined their materials. The 1999 ENDI policy-training manual was the best single debate training document I have ever seen. My sincere thanks and gratitude to Melissa Wade, Bill Newnam, Joe Bellon, Anne Marie Todd, and all of those at Emory who have worked through the years to produce these materials. Another major source I have borrowed from has been the World De- bate Institute held each summer at the University of Vermont. This pro- gram has also emphasized producing training materials for new debaters for over 25 years. I want to specifically thank the Open Society Institute for its support in this project. Its support for this work in its first incarnation in 1999 as a training text for students and teachers in America’s urban debate leagues was an essential part of the origin of this text. The institute’s drive to bring debate to communities that really need it has been an inspiration to me. I want to thank the many, many novice debaters I have worked with through the years who have taught me what works and what doesn’t. I have, of course, not fully learned this lesson, and I am still ready to learn more. I want to thank Martin Greenwald and Noel Selegzi for providing me with so many exciting debate opportunities. I also want to thank Elea- nora von Dehsen for her assistance with this text. I owe a great deal to Lionel Palardy of the University of Vermont, who kept this text alive be- tween 1999 and 2008. I also want to thank the Slovenian national debate program, Za in Proti, and its director, Bojana Skrt, who hosted me during my 2006 sab- batical from the University of Vermont and allowed me to write in a rich environment. I admire the program’s efforts to promote debate and have gained inspiration from its members. Debate isn’t just another game, and it isn’t just another educational activity. It is a path of critical advocacy that is life changing and empow- ering. As my friend from Malaysia, Logan Belavigendran, has said, debate is not just an activity, it is a lifestyle. I invite you to learn the code of the debater and follow the way of reason. Alfred C. Snider Burlington, Vermont, USA March 2008 xii The Code of the Debater Introduction Chapter 1 introduces you to the concepts underlying policy debate. It describes the basic elements of this type of debate—the structure of de- bate competition, the ideas to be debated, and your role in the debate. After reading this chapter, you should begin to feel at home in this new intellectual space. What Is Debate? Debate is about change. We are constantly engaged in a struggle to bet- ter our lives, our community, our country, our world, and our future. We should never be satisfied with the status quo—surely something in our lives needs improving. Debate is the process that determines how change should occur.