Result of Technical Evaluation for Packages Under IFB WB-4/703 in MPRCP (Refer Clause 22.6 - ITB of Bidding Document for MPRC Project) S.No

Result of Technical Evaluation for Packages under IFB WB-4/703 in MPRCP (Refer Clause 22.6 - ITB of Bidding Document for MPRC Project) S.No. Dist./PIU Package No. Name of Contractor Qualified/Disqualified Reason for Disqualification M/s Anil Construction Company, Jain Sadan Ashok Nagar 1 MP47WB13 Qualified - Mahal Road, Shivpuri (M.P.)

M/s OSHO Associates, Civil Contractor, 30, Ashok Nagar 1 MP47WB13 Qualified - Satyadev Nagar, Gandhi Road, Gwalior (M.P.)

M/s D.N. Rathi Construction, Diversion Road, Ashok Nagar 1 MP47WB13 Qualified - Opp Maruti Showroom, Guna (M.P.) 1 M/s Siddharth Builders, Rajghat Dam Project, Ashok Nagar 1 MP47WB13 Qualified - District Lalitpur (U.P.)

M/s Bharill and Company, Gali No. 01, Ward Ashok Nagar 1 MP47WB13 Qualified - No. 04, Lake Cily Colony, Ashoknagar (M.P.)

M/s Anil Construction Company, Jain Sadan 2 Ashok Nagar 1 MP47WB14 Qualified - Mahal Road, Shivpuri (M.P.)

3 Ashoknagar-2 MP47WB11 M/s A.K. Shivhare Infrastructure, Biora (M.P.) Qualified -

4 Chhatarpur MP06WB03 M/s Raj Laxmi Construction Qualified - M/s Krishna Construction Co. Jhunjhunu Dahr -3 MP11WB09 Qualified - (Rajsthan) Dahr -3 MP11WB09 M/s Rameshchandra Raghuvanshi, Dhar Qualified - 5 Dahr -3 MP11WB09 M/s Nirman Builders, Baroda Qualified - Dahr -3 MP11WB09 M/s Shree Construction, Rajkot (Gujrat) Qualified -

Dahr -3 MP11WB09 M/s Vyas Associates, Sardarpur Distt. Dhar Qualified -

6 Damoh MP08WB05 Shiv Kumar Tamarkar Damoh Qualified -

C:\Users\mprrda\Desktop\Result_Evaluation_WB4_WB5_WB6_MPRCP.xlsx 19 Result of Technical Evaluation for Packages under IFB WB-4/703 in MPRCP (Refer Clause 22.6 - ITB of Bidding Document for MPRC Project) S.No. Dist./PIU Package No. Name of Contractor Qualified/Disqualified Reason for Disqualification Datia MP09WB01 M/s Patel Construction Pvt.Ltd Biaora Qualified - Turn Over is not equal to estimated Datia MP09WB01 M/s Anuj Tiwari, Jhansi Disqualified 7 cost of the package. Turn Over is not equal to estimated Datia MP09WB01 M/s Badri Prasad Mudgli, Jhansi Disqualified cost of the package. Datia MP09WB02 M/s Patel Construction Pvt,Ltd Biaora Qualified - 8 Datia MP09WB02 M/s Osho Associates, Gwalior Qualified - Dhar-1 MP11WB03 M/s Shree Construction Co, Rajkot Gujrat Qualified - 9 Dhar-1 MP11WB03 M/s Ramesh Chandra Raghuwanshi Qualified - 10 Dhar-1 MP11WB04 M/s Ramesh Chandra Raghuwanshi Dhar Qualified - M/s Krishna Construction Co. Jhunjhunu Dhar-3 MP11WB08 Qualified - (Rajsthan) Disqualified as the turn over is less 11 Dhar-3 MP11WB08 M/s Rajesh Agrawal, Indore Disqualified than PAC as per S.B.D. para 4.4 (A) (9) of I.T.B. Dhar-3 MP11WB08 M/s Niyati Construction Co. Qualified - Dhar-3 MP11WB08 M/s Shree Construction, Rajkot (Gujrat) Qualified - 12 Gwalior MP14WB01 M.s Kushwa Construction Company Gtwlaior Qualified - Gwalior MP14WB02 M/s Osho Associates , Gwalior (M.P) Qualified - 13 Gwalior MP14WB02 M/s Ravindra Singh Tomar, Gwalior (M.P) Qualified -

14 Gwalior MP14WB04 M/s Ravindra Singh Tomar , Gwalior (MP.P) Qualified -

M/s sanjaya Paliya Contractor Prop. SMt 15 Hoshangabad MP16WB12 Qualified No Submission Jayehree Paliya Due to Not submitted of certificate for similar singal work, Bank 16 Hoshangabad MP16WB11 M/s Jyoti Construction Company Harda Disqualified certificate for financing & work Methodology. Single Similar Nature of Work is less 17 Katni MP20WB01 M/s Gyanendra Tiwari Disqualified then 50% of estimated Cost of Package. 18 Katni MP20WB05 M/s Axle Engineering Pvt. Ltd. Qualified - 19 Katni MP20WB06 M/s Axle Engineering Pvt. Ltd. Qualified -

C:\Users\mprrda\Desktop\Result_Evaluation_WB4_WB5_WB6_MPRCP.xlsx 29 Result of Technical Evaluation for Packages under IFB WB-4/703 in MPRCP (Refer Clause 22.6 - ITB of Bidding Document for MPRC Project) S.No. Dist./PIU Package No. Name of Contractor Qualified/Disqualified Reason for Disqualification Katni MP20WB07 M/s Axle Engineering Pvt. Ltd. Qualified - Balance Sheet attached is not signed 20 Katni MP20WB07 M/s MNS Infratech Disqualified by C.A. Katni MP20WB07 Smt. Chitra Sharma Disqualified For short EMD Amount. 21 Morena MP25WB06 M/s Bhagwati Enterprizes Morena Qualified - Morena MP25WB07 Kushwaha Construction Company Gwalior Qualified - Bid capacity not meet out as per Morena MP25WB07 Kushwaha Construction Company Jagdalpur Disqualified bidding document clause 4.6 of Sec. 22 2 of ITB Morena MP25WB07 M/s Bhagwati Enterprizes Morena Qualified - Morena MP25WB07 Dandotia Construction Compnay Qualified - M/s Ankita Construction 22, Sawariya colony Neemuch MP27WB04 Qualified - Nimbahera Dist, Chhittogarh (Raj) 23 Chetak Interprises LTd 396/11Hiran Magari, Neemuch MP27WB04 Qualified - udapur (Raj) Neemuch MP27WB04 Nalwaya Construction Udaipur Qualified - M/s Ankita Construction 22, Sawariya colony 24 Neemuch MP27WB06 Qualified - Nimbahera Dist, Chhittogarh (Raj) Raisen -2 MP29WB19 M/s R.K. Construction Dewas Qualified - Value of singal similar nature of 25 Raisen -2 MP29WB19 M/s Santosh Rai JCB, Raisen Disqualified work executed is less than the required Raisen -2 MP29WB19 M/s Supreme Buildcon Pvt Ltd. Bhopal Qualified - 26 Raisen -2 MP29WB20 M/s R.K. Construction Dewas Qualified - 27 Raisen -2 MP29WB21 M/s Dilip Singh Raghuwanshi Qualified - Rajgarh MP30WB01 M/s Jagdish Verma Qualified - Rajgarh MP30WB01 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd. Qualified - 28 Rajgarh MP30WB01 M/s Ram Prasad Dangi Qualified - M/s RAM PRASAD RATHOR Rajgarh MP30WB01 Disqualified Black listed by PWD CONTRACTOR Rajgarh MP30WB02 M/s Jagdish Verma Qualified - Rajgarh MP30WB02 M/s Shri Hari Guru Kripa Construction Qualified - 29

C:\Users\mprrda\Desktop\Result_Evaluation_WB4_WB5_WB6_MPRCP.xlsx 39 Result of Technical Evaluation for Packages under IFB WB-4/703 in MPRCP (Refer Clause 22.6 - ITB of Bidding Document for MPRC Project) S.No. Dist./PIU Package No. Name of Contractor Qualified/Disqualified Reason for Disqualification 29 M/s RAM PRASAD RATHOR Rajgarh MP30WB02 Disqualified Black listed by PWD CONTRACTOR M/s RAJMARG BUILDERS & Rajgarh MP30WB07 Qualified - INFRASTRUCTURE Rajgarh MP30WB07 M/s YUVRAJ INFRA BIAORA Qualified - 30 Rajgarh MP30WB07 M/s Radheshyam Sondhiya Qualified - Rajgarh MP30WB07 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd. Qualified - Rajgarh MP30WB07 M/s Vinayak Construction Company Disqualified Due to less turn over Rajgarh MP30WB08 M/s Rajlaxmi Construction Guna Qualified - 31 Rajgarh MP30WB08 M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt.Ltd. Qualified - Rajgarh MP30WB09 M/s YUVRAJ INFRA BIAORA Qualified - Rajgarh MP30WB09 M/s Ram Prasad Dangi Qualified - 32 Rajgarh MP30WB09 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd. Qualified - Rajgarh MP30WB09 Govardha Singh Dangi Disqualified Due to less turn over Rajgarh MP30WB13 M/s Ram Prasad Dangi Qualified - 33 Rajgarh MP30WB13 Balveer Construction Qualified - 34 Sagar-1 MP33WB08 M/s Ashok Kumar Jain Qualified - 35 Sagar-1 MP33WB10 M/s Tulsi Narayan Garg Qualified - 36 Sagar-1 MP33WB12 M/s CBS Construction Company Qualified - Satna MP34WB08 M/s ABC associates, Satna Qualified - 37 Satna MP34WB08 M/s Swapnil Singh, Satna Qualified -

38 Shajapur MP39WB14 M/s Karada Construction Company, Indore Qualified -

M/s Rajendra Kumar Agrawal, Shujalpur Shajapur MP39WB17 Qualified - Shajapur 39 Shajapur MP39WB17 M/s Arun Kumar Kayal, Shujalpur Shajapur Qualified -

Shajapur MP39WB17 M/s Prabhunath Singh, Shujalpur Shajapur Qualified - M/s Phalodi Construction and infrastructure Shajapur MP39WB18 Qualified - 40 Pvt. Ltd., Indore Shajapur MP39WB18 Amcon Construction Company Qualified - Sheopur MP37WB01 M/s Tulsi Narayan Garg Qualified - 41 Sheopur MP37WB01 M/s Laxmi Chand Company, Gwalior Disqualified 15% liquidity not avaliable

C:\Users\mprrda\Desktop\Result_Evaluation_WB4_WB5_WB6_MPRCP.xlsx 49 Result of Technical Evaluation for Packages under IFB WB-4/703 in MPRCP (Refer Clause 22.6 - ITB of Bidding Document for MPRC Project)

S.No.41 Dist./PIU Package No. Name of Contractor Qualified/Disqualified Reason for Disqualification Sheopur MP37WB01 M/s Laxmi Narayan Agrawal, Jaipur Disqualified Black listed by MPRRDA Tikamgarh MP42WB03 M/s Divine Infra Structure Qualified - 42 Tikamgarh MP42WB03 M/s R.S. Construction Qualified -

Vidisha-2 MP45WB14 M/s Dilip Singh Raghuwanshi, Vidisha (M.P.) Qualified - 43 M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., Vidisha-2 MP45WB14 Qualified - Bioara (M.P.)

44 Vidisha-2 MP45WB17 M/s Dilip Singh Raghuwanshi, Vidisha (M.P.) Qualified -

Vidisha-2 MP45WB19 M/s Raghu Devlopers, Vidisha (M.P.) Qualified - M/s ANV Construction Company, 17, Windsor 45 Vidisha-2 MP45WB19 Estate Chuna Bhatti, Kolar Raod, Bhopal Qualified - (M.P.)

C:\Users\mprrda\Desktop\Result_Evaluation_WB4_WB5_WB6_MPRCP.xlsx 59 Result of Technical Evaluation of Packages under IFB WB-5/704 in MPRCP (Refer Clause 22.6 - ITB of Bidding Document for MPRC Project)

S.No. Dist./PIU Package No. Name of Contractor Qualified/Disqualified Reason for Disqualification

1 Ashoknagar-2 MP47WB12 M/s Siddhart Builders, Lalitpur, (U.P.) Qualified - Bhopal MP05WB02 M/s Vikas Shivhare Qualified - 2 Bhopal MP05WB02 M/s Kushalguru Construction Co. Qualified - M/s Krishna Construction Co. Jhunjhunu Dhar-3 MP11WB10 Qualified - 3 (Rajsthan) Dhar-3 MP11WB10 M/s Rameshchandra Raghuvanshi, Dhar Qualified - M/s Krishna Construction Co. Jhunjhunu 4 Dhar-3 MP11WB12 Qualified - (Rajsthan) M/s Ankita Construction 22, Sawariya colony Neemuch MP27WB05 Qualified - Nimbahera Dist, Chhittogarh (Raj) 5 Chetak Interprises LTd 396/11Hiran Magari, Neemuch MP27WB05 Qualified - udapur (Raj) Neemuch MP27WB05 Nalwaya Construction Udaipur Qualified - M/s Ankita Construction 22, Sawariya colony Neemuch MP27WB07 Qualified - Nimbahera Dist, Chhittogarh (Raj) Nathulal Patidar, Gram Knawati Dist 6 Neemuch MP27WB07 Qualified - Neemuch MVS Infrastructure Ltd Manasa Disst Neemuch MP27WB07 Qualified - Neemuch 7 Rajgarh MP30WB03 M/s Shri Hari Guru Kripa Construction Disqualified Due to less turn over M/s RAJMARG BUILDERS & Rajgarh MP30WB05 Qualified - INFRASTRUCTURE 8 NANDRAM MALAKAR Rajgarh MP30WB05 Disqualified Due to less turn over and Liquid Assets CONTRACTOR Rajgarh MP30WB11 M/s Radheshyam Sondhiya Qualified - Rajgarh MP30WB11 M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt.Ltd. Qualified - 9 Rajgarh MP30WB11 M/s ANV Construction Company Qualified - Rajgarh MP30WB11 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd. Qualified - 10 Rajgarh MP30WB14 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd. Qualified - Rajgarh MP30WB15 M/s ANV Construction Company Qualified -

11 Result of Technical Evaluation of Packages under IFB WB-5/704 in MPRCP (Refer Clause 22.6 - ITB of Bidding Document for MPRC Project)

S.No. Dist./PIU Package No. Name of Contractor Qualified/Disqualified Reason for Disqualification

Rajgarh MP30WB15 M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt.Ltd. Qualified - 11 Rajgarh MP30WB15 M/s Ram Prasad Dangi Qualified - Rajgarh MP30WB15 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd. Qualified - 12 Sagar 1 MP33WB11 M/s Tulsi Narayan Garg Qualified - 13 Sagar 1 MP33WB13 M/s Jinendra Kumar Jain Qualified - Turnover deficient Maximum turnover Rs. 637.74 lacs. 14 Shajapur MP39WB15 M/s Mahendra Singh Sonti Disqualified Estimated cost of Rs. 643.82 lacs.

15 Shajapur MP39WB19 M/s Krishna Construction, Qualified - 16 Sheopur MP37WB02 M/s Tulsi Narayan Garg Qualified -

17 Vidisha-2 MP45WB015 M/s Dilip Singh Raghuwanshi, Vidisha (M.P.) Qualified -

18 Vidisha-2 MP45WB018 M/s Dilip Singh Raghuwanshi, Vidisha (M.P.) Qualified -

Vidisha-2 MP45WB020 M/s Dilip Singh Raghuwanshi, Vidisha (M.P.) Qualified - 19 M/s Mangal Singh Rajput, Basoda Dist. Vidisha-2 MP45WB020 Qualified - Vidisha (M.P.) Result of Technical Evaluation for Packages under IFB WB-6/705 in MPRCP (Refer Clause 22.6 - ITB of Bidding Document for MPRC Project)

S.No. Dist./PIU Package No. Name of Contractor Qualified/Disqualified Reason for Disqualification

M/s Krishna Construction Co. Jhunjhunu Dhar-3 MP11WB13 Qualified - 1 (Rajsthan) Dhar-3 MP11WB13 M/s Orion Construction Pvt. Ltd. Qualified - Nathulal Patidar, Gram Knawati Dist Neemuch MP27WB08 Qualified - Neemuch 2 MVS Infrastructure Ltd Manasa Disst Neemuch MP27WB08 Qualified - Neemuch Rajgarh MP30WB04 M/s Shri Hari Guru Kripa Construction Qualified - 3 M/s RAM PRASAD RATHOR Rajgarh MP30WB04 Disqualified Black listed by PWD CONTRACTOR M/s RAJMARG BUILDERS & Rajgarh MP30WB06 Qualified - INFRASTRUCTURE

4 Rajgarh MP30WB06 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd. Qualified -

M/s RAM PRASAD RATHOR Rajgarh MP30WB06 Disqualified Black listed by PWD CONTRACTOR

Rajgarh MP30WB12 M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt.Ltd. Qualified - 5 M/s RAM PRASAD RATHOR Rajgarh MP30WB12 Disqualified Black listed by PWD CONTRACTOR

6 Rajgarh MP30WB16 M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt.Ltd. Qualified -

Rajgarh MP30WB18 M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt.Ltd. Qualified - 7 Rajgarh MP30WB18 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd. Qualified - Result of Technical Evaluation for Packages under IFB WB-6/705 in MPRCP (Refer Clause 22.6 - ITB of Bidding Document for MPRC Project)

S.No. Dist./PIU Package No. Name of Contractor Qualified/Disqualified Reason for Disqualification

1)Turnover deficient Maximun turnover Rs. 524.64 lacs. Estimated cost of Rs. 537.08 lacs . M/s Anil Kumar Agrawal, Shujalpur Shajapur-1 MP39WB16 Disqualified 2) Bid capacity deficient Shajapur Calculated Bid capacity Rs. 423.00 lacs. Estimated cost of work Rs. 537.08 lacs.

8 1)Turnover deficient Maximun turnover Rs. 336.79 lacs. Estimated cost of Rs. 537.08 lacs. 2) Similar work of nature deficient Shajapur-1 MP39WB16 M/s Shiv Shakti Shajapur Disqualified Shwon in document Rs. 200.00 lacs (work particulars not given) Required Rs. 268.54 lacs.

M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., 9 Vidisha-2 MP45WB16 Qualified - Bioara (M.P.) Vidisha-2 MP45WB21 M/s Raghu Developers, Vidisha (M.P.) Qualified - M/s ANV Construction Company, 17, 10 Vidisha-2 MP45WB21 Windsor Estate Chuna Bhatti, Kolar Raod, Qualified - Bhopal (M.P.)