DOCSLIB.ORG

June 2000 the American Physical Society Volume 9, No

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
June 2000 the American Physical Society Volume 9, No FEATURED ON THE BACK PAGE: David Goodstein on A P S N E W S Education JUNE 2000 THE AMERICAN PHYSICAL SOCIETY VOLUME 9, NO. 6 APS News(Try the enhanced APS News-online: http://www.aps.org/apsnews) Council Statements Focus on Missile Defense, Science Funding t its April meeting, the Council of ploy the NMD is scheduled for the next in the physical sciences. Therefore, the success of important national scientific A the APS approved a statement on few months. The tests that have been con- Council is particularly concerned that the programs. issues relating to the technical feasibility ducted or are planned for the period fall DOE’s science funding remain healthy. The Council urges, therefore, that the DOE and deployment of the proposed National far short of those required to provide confi- The DOE Office of Science is responsible share fully, in FY2001 and in subsequent Missile Defense (NMD) program. dence in the ‘technical feasibility’ called for for the construction and operation of most years, in the funding increases aimed at President Clinton is scheduled to make a in last year’s NMD deployment legislation. major facilities in particle and nuclear maintaining the health of the U.S. scientific decision by this October as to whether to This statement implies no APS position physics, and for many other facilities enterprise. Present concerns regarding man- begin deployment of such a program, with respect to the wisdom of national mis- needed in multidisciplinary research agement and security issues should not although a decision could be made as early sile defense deployment and concerns itself programs relevant to materials sciences, obscure the need for sustaining and enhanc- as August. Some members of Congress, solely with its technical viability.” energy sciences, biology, and medicine. ing the essential DOE-supported science of both parties, have urged the President to Background information relating to the These efforts have been instrumental in the programs.” defer a decision until the next administration. NMD statement can be found on the APS The text of the statement follows. website at http://www.aps.org/ Physics Chairs Meet at APS Headquarters “The United States should not make statements/00.2.html. a deployment decision relative to the Believing that broad-based funding for planned National Missile Defense physics research is critical to preserving (NMD) system unless that system is national competitiveness, the APS Council shown-through analysis and through also approved a statement to that effect intercept tests- to be effective against the at its April meeting, singling out the De- types of offensive countermeasures that partment of Energy (DOE) for particular an attacker could reasonably be ex- support. The statement reads: pected to deploy with its long-range “The Council of the American Physi- missiles. The planned NMD system is cal Society applauds and strongly intended to defend U.S. territory against supports the significant funding in- tens of long-range ballistic missiles car- creases for science contained in the rying biological, chemical or nuclear President’s FY2001 budget. weapons. The ability of the NMD system The nation’s research in physics is to deal with countermeasures is a key broadly supported through several agen- More than 120 physics department chairs spent two days in April at the American Center for factor in determining whether the sys- cies, principally DOE, NSF, NASA, and Physics in College Park. With a conference emphasis on undergraduate physics education, tem will be able to defend against the DOD. The ability of U.S. physics to con- presentations focused on the need for better teaching techniques, curricular issues, careers, threats it is intended to meet. tinue contributing to the nation’s responses to the new engineering accreditation requirements, and ways to improve the A decision on whether or not to de- economic growth and its national secu- physics taught to prospective teachers. Rounding out the program were talks on NSF and DOE funding priorities by Bob Eisenstein, Assistant Director for Mathematical and Physical rity depends critically on adequate Sciences (NSF) and Pat Dehmer, Acting Deputy Director of the Office of Science (DOE), funding for all these agencies. and an overview of the Washington science policy scene by Mike Lubell, APS Director of Inside… The DOE provides the majority of the Public Affairs. In the photo above, Steering Committee co-chair Peter Collings of Swarthmore addresses the gathering. The conference was cosponsored by APS and AAPT. NEWS funding for a wide range of basic research March and April 2000 Prizes and Awards Recipients ..................................... 2 Stunning photos of the winners. Scientific Community Speaks Out on Re- “Creating Copenhagen” at CUNY Symposium Behalf of FY2001 NSF R&D Budget ......... 3 Support grows for the President’s budget. hy did Werner Heisenberg make the American Institute of Physics were co- the meeting ended in acrimony. Nothing Topsy Turvy: Researchers Announce W the risky journey to Copenhagen sponsors of this event. Physicists, historians, is known of why Heisenberg made the First True “Left-Handed” Material ............ 5 Featuring the inverse Doppler effect and in 1941 to visit his former mentor, Niels theater professionals, and members of the visit, or what the two men said to each reverse of Snell’s law. Bohr? What did the two discuss, and why general public alike crowded into the new other, yet it remains a defining moment Satisfaction High for Undergrad did it end their friendship? Was Heisenberg Proshansky Auditorium for the free, day- of the modern nuclear age. Physics Bachelors ...................................... 5 trying to learn about Allied progress on long series of events, which included Frayn’s play extends the concept of Number receiving bachelor’s in physics has reached stability. the atomic bomb? Was he seeking Bohr’s lectures on the science and history of the quantum uncertainty to the realm of hu- Writing Workshops Teach Basics of input on the ethics of applying physics to so-called “Copenhagen Interpretation” of man motivations through a series of cyclic Communicating with Public ..................... 6 construct a weapon of mass destruction? quantum mechanics and the subsequent re-tellings of the same event from differ- Physicists received a crash course in writing for the general interest media at the And should history view Heisenberg as a development of the atomic bomb. ing perspectives, and in Blakemore’s APS March and April meetings. hero for purposely slowing or sabotaging The CUNY symposium was timed to staging the actors move about the stage Career Liaisons Gather for Workshop on the German bomb effort, or an incompe- coincide with the Broadway opening of as if they are particles in a quantum sys- Professional Development ........................ 6 tent engineer who failed to understand the “Copenhagen,” an award-winning drama tem. Michael Cumpsty, the actor who Establishing a nation-wide network of liaisons was one objective. key design principles involved? by British playwright Michael Frayn that plays Heisenberg in the Broadway play, These unsolved mysteries provided the won the prestigious Evening Standard was on hand for the symposium, along OPINION thematic framework for a special Award for Best Play in 1998. The play is with actress Blair Brown, who plays That’s It Folks! For the Last Time: symposium in March, sponsored by the inspired by actual events that have in- Margrethe Bohr. A sold-out evening ses- Even More Top Ten Physicists .................. 2 City University of New York Graduate trigued and baffled historians for more than sion featured a panel discussion with Frayn Final round of readers’ thoughts on top ten physicists. Center, entitled “Creating Copenhagen.” 50 years — a 1941 meeting between Bohr and the play’s Broadway director, Michael Letters .......................................................... 4 Both the American Physical Society and and Heisenberg, both brilliant physicists Blakemore. Viewpoint ..................................................... 4 and longtime friends The first session on science offered a Cultural differences: Alan Chodos yearns whose work together technical exploration presenting the ba- for the way it was. had paved the way for sics of quantum mechanics and of the Editorial Cartoon ........................................ 5 Zero Gravity ................................................. 5 the atom, but who contributions of Bohr, Heisenberg and oth- Fourth annual Pigasus awards. were now on opposite ers. Speakers discussed specifics of the sides of World War II. Copenhagen Interpretation of quantum DEPARTMENTS Heisenberg, then chief mechanics and of present views of how This Month in Physics History ................. 3 scientist on the Ger- the wave function yields definite states. The Shelter Island Conference: June 2 - 4, 1947. man atom-bomb They included former APS president Eugen Inside the Beltway ...................................... 3 Michael Lubell anaylzes the budget battles. project, made a covert Merzbacher, Faye Ajzenberg-Selove of the Announcements ......................................... 7 journey at great per- University of Pennsylvania, Anton Zeilinger Membership news; Apker awards; matching sonal risk to see his (University of Vienna), and Brian Greene, membership program; winner of physics trivia. former Danish mentor a physicist at Columbia University and au- The Back Page ...........................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Small Wonders the US National Nanotechnology Initiative Has Spent Billions of Dollars on Submicroscopic Science in Its First 10 Years
    NEWS FEATURE NATURE|Vol 467|2 September 2010 Simulation of the flow pattern for electrons travelling over a random nanoscale landscape. Small wonders The US National Nanotechnology Initiative has spent billions of dollars on submicroscopic science in its first 10 years. Corie Lok finds out where the money went and what the initiative plans to do next. ichard Smalley’s cheeks were gaunt and promised to conduct electricity better than It was a message that Washington was ready his hair was nearly gone when he testi- copper, but also had the potential to produce to hear. US President Bill Clinton formally fied before the US House of Representa- fibres 100 times stronger than steel at one- announced the initiative in 2000, with bipar- tives in June 1999. The Nobel laureate sixth of the weight. Smalley also predicted tisan support from Congress. The initiative R, HARVARD UNIV. HARVARD R, R E chemist had been diagnosed with non-Hodg- that the “very blunt tool” of chemotherapy that has faced some criticism in the decade since LL kin’s lymphoma a few months earlier, chemo- had ravaged his own body would be obsolete — most notably for its slowness to address E therapy was taking its toll, and the journey within 20 years, because scientists would engi- environmental, health and safety concerns H J. E. from Rice University in Houston, Texas, had neer nanoscale drugs that were “essentially about nanomaterials. But it has also created been exhausting. But none of that dimmed his cancer-seeking missiles” able more than 70 nano-related obvious passion for a subject that his listen- to target mutant cells with “As chemists, we academic or government ers found both mystifying and enthralling: minimal side effects.
    [Show full text]
  • 2008 Annual Report
    2008 Annual Report NATIONAL ACADEMY OF ENGINEERING ENGINEERING THE FUTURE 1 Letter from the President 3 In Service to the Nation 3 Mission Statement 4 Program Reports 4 Engineering Education 4 Center for the Advancement of Scholarship on Engineering Education 6 Technological Literacy 6 Public Understanding of Engineering Developing Effective Messages Media Relations Public Relations Grand Challenges for Engineering 8 Center for Engineering, Ethics, and Society 9 Diversity in the Engineering Workforce Engineer Girl! Website Engineer Your Life Project Engineering Equity Extension Service 10 Frontiers of Engineering Armstrong Endowment for Young Engineers-Gilbreth Lectures 12 Engineering and Health Care 14 Technology and Peace Building 14 Technology for a Quieter America 15 America’s Energy Future 16 Terrorism and the Electric Power-Delivery System 16 U.S.-China Cooperation on Electricity from Renewables 17 U.S.-China Symposium on Science and Technology Strategic Policy 17 Offshoring of Engineering 18 Gathering Storm Still Frames the Policy Debate 20 2008 NAE Awards Recipients 22 2008 New Members and Foreign Associates 24 2008 NAE Anniversary Members 28 2008 Private Contributions 28 Einstein Society 28 Heritage Society 29 Golden Bridge Society 29 Catalyst Society 30 Rosette Society 30 Challenge Society 30 Charter Society 31 Other Individual Donors 34 The Presidents’ Circle 34 Corporations, Foundations, and Other Organizations 35 National Academy of Engineering Fund Financial Report 37 Report of Independent Certified Public Accountants 41 Notes to Financial Statements 53 Officers 53 Councillors 54 Staff 54 NAE Publications Letter from the President Engineering is critical to meeting the fundamental challenges facing the U.S. economy in the 21st century.
    [Show full text]
  • Title: the Distribution of an Illustrated Timeline Wall Chart and Teacher's Guide of 20Fh Century Physics
    REPORT NSF GRANT #PHY-98143318 Title: The Distribution of an Illustrated Timeline Wall Chart and Teacher’s Guide of 20fhCentury Physics DOE Patent Clearance Granted December 26,2000 Principal Investigator, Brian Schwartz, The American Physical Society 1 Physics Ellipse College Park, MD 20740 301-209-3223 [email protected] BACKGROUND The American Physi a1 Society s part of its centennial celebration in March of 1999 decided to develop a timeline wall chart on the history of 20thcentury physics. This resulted in eleven consecutive posters, which when mounted side by side, create a %foot mural. The timeline exhibits and describes the millstones of physics in images and words. The timeline functions as a chronology, a work of art, a permanent open textbook, and a gigantic photo album covering a hundred years in the life of the community of physicists and the existence of the American Physical Society . Each of the eleven posters begins with a brief essay that places a major scientific achievement of the decade in its historical context. Large portraits of the essays’ subjects include youthful photographs of Marie Curie, Albert Einstein, and Richard Feynman among others, to help put a face on science. Below the essays, a total of over 130 individual discoveries and inventions, explained in dated text boxes with accompanying images, form the backbone of the timeline. For ease of comprehension, this wealth of material is organized into five color- coded story lines the stretch horizontally across the hundred years of the 20th century. The five story lines are: Cosmic Scale, relate the story of astrophysics and cosmology; Human Scale, refers to the physics of the more familiar distances from the global to the microscopic; Atomic Scale, focuses on the submicroscopic This report was prepared as an account of work sponsored by an agency of the United States Government.
    [Show full text]
  • Bringing out the Dead Alison Abbott Reviews the Story of How a DNA Forensics Team Cracked a Grisly Puzzle
    BOOKS & ARTS COMMENT DADO RUVIC/REUTERS/CORBIS DADO A forensics specialist from the International Commission on Missing Persons examines human remains from a mass grave in Tomašica, Bosnia and Herzegovina. FORENSIC SCIENCE Bringing out the dead Alison Abbott reviews the story of how a DNA forensics team cracked a grisly puzzle. uring nine sweltering days in July Bosnia’s Million Bones tells the story of how locating, storing, pre- 1995, Bosnian Serb soldiers slaugh- innovative DNA forensic science solved the paring and analysing tered about 7,000 Muslim men and grisly conundrum of identifying each bone the million or more Dboys from Srebrenica in Bosnia. They took so that grieving families might find some bones. It was in large them to several different locations and shot closure. part possible because them, or blew them up with hand grenades. This is an important book: it illustrates the during those fate- They then scooped up the bodies with bull- unspeakable horrors of a complex war whose ful days in July 1995, dozers and heavy earth-moving equipment, causes have always been hard for outsiders to aerial reconnais- and dumped them into mass graves. comprehend. The author, a British journalist, sance missions by the Bosnia’s Million It was the single most inhuman massacre has the advantage of on-the-ground knowl- Bones: Solving the United States and the of the Bosnian war, which erupted after the edge of the war and of the International World’s Greatest North Atlantic Treaty break-up of Yugoslavia and lasted from 1992 Commission on Missing Persons (ICMP), an Forensic Puzzle Organization had to 1995, leaving some 100,000 dead.
    [Show full text]
  • The Legacy of Mildred Dresselhaus, the Queen of Carbon
    The legacy of Mildred Dresselhaus, the Queen of Carbon Zeila Zanolli RWTH Aachen June 7, 2017 - ETSF Young Researchers Meeting, Tarragona Mildred Dresselhaus Laid the foundations for C nanotechnology: Pioneer of experimental techniques to study 2D materials Predicted the possibility and characteristics of CNTs (band structure, …) Low-dimensional thermolectrics: model of thermal transport in nanostructures, energy materials, electronic properties, phonons, electron-phonon interactions, … Her work has been crucial for developing lithium-ion batteries, electronic devices, renewable-energy generators, … [email protected] Millie: Institute Professor at MIT > 1700 publications h-index 135 > 25 prestigious awards 28 honorary doctorates Supervised >60 PhD 57 years at MIT [email protected] How did she started? [email protected] Millie: a tale of persistence 1930: born in Brooklyn lived in the Bronx family of immigrants, quite poor during the Great Depression 1936 ( 6 y): got a scholarship for a Music school and heard about the Hunter College “My teachers didn’t think it was possible to get in. But Hunter sent me a practice exam, and I studied what I needed to know to pass the exam.” at Hunter, Rosalyn Yalow (future Nobel laureate) encouraged Millie in pursuing a scientific career. 1951 (21 y): Bachelor, Hunter College, New York [email protected] Millie as Young Researcher 1953 (23 y): MA, Radcliffe College on a Fulbright Fellowship, Cambridge (MA) & Harvard 1958 (28 y): PhD, University of Chicago on the properties of superconductors in a magnetic field. Daily chats with E. Fermi. “My nominal thesis adviser told me in 1955 that women had no place in physics” I told him that I was not expecting to have others show interest in my work.
    [Show full text]
  • July 2007 (Volume 16, Number 7) Entire Issue
    July 2007 Volume 16, No. 7 www.aps.org/publications/apsnews APS NEWS Election Preview A PUBLICATION OF THE AMERICAN PHYSICAL SOCIETY • WWW.apS.ORG/PUBLICATIONS/apSNEWS Pages 6-7 Executive Board Resolution Thanks US physics team trains for competition in Iran By Katherine McAlpine Legislators for Support of Science Twenty-four high school stu- The APS Executive Board bill authorizes nearly $60 billion dents comprising the US Phys- has passed a resolution thanking for various programs for FY 2008 ics Olympiad team vied for five House and Senate policy makers through FY 2011. The bill would places on the traveling team at for recently-passed legislation double the NSF budget over five the University of Maryland from that strengthens the science, math years and double the DOE Office May 22nd to June 1st. Those and engineering activities of our of Science budget over 10 years. chosen to travel will compete nation. The House of Representatives this month against teams from “Sustaining and improving the passed five separate authorization all over the world at Isfahan standard of living of American bills, which were then combined University of Technology in Is- citizens, achieving energy security into one bill, H.R. 2272, the 21st fahan, Iran. and environmental sustainability, Century Competitiveness Act of Over 3,100 US Physics Team providing the jobs of tomorrow 2007. The bill would put the NSF hopefuls took the preliminary and defending our nation against budget and the NIST Scientific examination in January, and 200 aggressors all require federal in- and Technical Research and Ser- were given a second exam in vestments in science education vices budget on track to double in March to determine the top 24 and research… The Board con- 10 years.
    [Show full text]
  • Commencement Program
    Sunday, the Sixteenth of May, Two Thousand and Ten ten o’clock in the morning ~ wallace wade stadium Duke University Commencement ~ 2010 One Hundred Fifty-Eighth Commencement Notes on Academic Dress Academic dress had its origin in the Middle Ages. When the European universities were taking form in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, scholars were also clerics, and they adopted Mace and Chain of Office robes similar to those of their monastic orders. Caps were a necessity in drafty buildings, and Again at commencement, ceremonial use is copes or capes with hoods attached were made of two important insignia given to Duke needed for warmth. As the control of universities University in memory of Benjamin N. Duke. gradually passed from the church, academic Both the mace and chain of office are the gifts costume began to take on brighter hues and to of anonymous donors and of the Mary Duke employ varied patterns in cut and color of gown Biddle Foundation. They were designed and and type of headdress. executed by Professor Kurt J. Matzdorf of New The use of academic costume in the United Paltz, New York, and were dedicated and first States has been continuous since Colonial times, used at the inaugural ceremonies of President but a clear protocol did not emerge until an Sanford in 1970. intercollegiate commission in 1893 recommended The Mace, the symbol of authority of the a uniform code. In this country, the design of a University, is made of sterling silver throughout. gown varies with the degree held. The bachelor’s Significance of Colors It is thirty-seven inches long and weighs about gown is relatively simple with long pointed Colors indicating fields of eight pounds.
    [Show full text]
  • Millennium Development Holes
    www.nature.com/nature Vol 446 | Issue no. 7134 | 22 March 2007 Millennium development holes The political commitment to helping the developing world is failing to deliver on its promises. The problem is made worse by the questionable evaluation of progress. n 2000, 189 world leaders committed to eight Millennium Devel- few developing countries have any data for around 1990, the baseline opment Goals (MDGs), ranging from halving extreme poverty and year. It is impossible to estimate progress for most of the indicators Ihunger, and rolling back killer diseases such as AIDS and malaria, over less than five years, and sparse poverty data can only be reliably to providing universal primary education. The deadline of 2015 to compared over decades. To pretend that progress towards the 2015 achieve all these ambitious goals is now rapidly approaching. goals can be accurately and continually measured is false. As a rallying cry that has pushed development up the inter national Significant efforts are now being made to improve data collection. political agenda, the goals have been an indisputable success. They Meanwhile, UN agencies fill in the missing data points using ‘model- have also, for better or worse, conferred power and legitimacy on ling’ — in practice, a recipe for potentially misleading extrapolation interests within the international aid machine, in particular the and political tampering. United Nations (UN) and the World Bank. Indeed, the lack of data makes it impossible not only to track But the goals are ultimately political promises, and as such they progress, but also to assess the effectiveness of measures taken.
    [Show full text]
  • The Struggle for Quantum Theory 47 5.1Aliensignals
    Fundamental Forces of Nature The Story of Gauge Fields This page intentionally left blank Fundamental Forces of Nature The Story of Gauge Fields Kerson Huang Massachusetts Institute of Technology, USA World Scientific N E W J E R S E Y • L O N D O N • S I N G A P O R E • B E I J I N G • S H A N G H A I • H O N G K O N G • TA I P E I • C H E N N A I Published by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. 5 Toh Tuck Link, Singapore 596224 USA office: 27 Warren Street, Suite 401-402, Hackensack, NJ 07601 UK office: 57 Shelton Street, Covent Garden, London WC2H 9HE British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. FUNDAMENTAL FORCES OF NATURE The Story of Gauge Fields Copyright © 2007 by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. All rights reserved. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without written permission from the Publisher. For photocopying of material in this volume, please pay a copying fee through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. In this case permission to photocopy is not required from the publisher. ISBN-13 978-981-270-644-7 ISBN-10 981-270-644-5 ISBN-13 978-981-270-645-4 (pbk) ISBN-10 981-270-645-3 (pbk) Printed in Singapore.
    [Show full text]
  • Nobel Prize Physicists Meet at Lindau
    From 28 June to 2 July 1971 the German island town of Lindau in Nobel Prize Physicists Lake Constance close to the Austrian and Swiss borders was host to a gathering of illustrious men of meet at Lindau science when, for the 21st time, Nobel Laureates held their reunion there. The success of the first Lindau reunion (1951) of Nobel Prize win­ ners in medicine had inspired the organizers to invite the chemists and W. S. Newman the physicists in turn in subsequent years. After the first three-year cycle the United Kingdom, and an audience the dates of historical events. These it was decided to let students and of more than 500 from 8 countries deviations in the radiocarbon time young scientists also attend the daily filled the elegant Stadttheater. scale are due to changes in incident meetings so they could encounter The programme consisted of a num­ cosmic radiation (producing the these eminent men on an informal ber of lectures in the mornings, two carbon isotopes) brought about by and personal level. For the Nobel social functions, a platform dis­ variations in the geomagnetic field. Laureates too the Lindau gatherings cussion, an informal reunion between Thus chemistry may reveal man­ soon became an agreeable occasion students and Nobel Laureates and, kind’s remote past whereas its long­ for making or renewing acquain­ on the last day, the traditional term future could well be shaped by tances with their contemporaries, un­ steamer excursion on Lake Cons­ the developments mentioned by trammelled by the formalities of the tance to the island of Mainau belong­ Mössbauer, viz.
    [Show full text]
  • Advanced Information on the Nobel Prize in Physics, 5 October 2004
    Advanced information on the Nobel Prize in Physics, 5 October 2004 Information Department, P.O. Box 50005, SE-104 05 Stockholm, Sweden Phone: +46 8 673 95 00, Fax: +46 8 15 56 70, E-mail: [email protected], Website: www.kva.se Asymptotic Freedom and Quantum ChromoDynamics: the Key to the Understanding of the Strong Nuclear Forces The Basic Forces in Nature We know of two fundamental forces on the macroscopic scale that we experience in daily life: the gravitational force that binds our solar system together and keeps us on earth, and the electromagnetic force between electrically charged objects. Both are mediated over a distance and the force is proportional to the inverse square of the distance between the objects. Isaac Newton described the gravitational force in his Principia in 1687, and in 1915 Albert Einstein (Nobel Prize, 1921 for the photoelectric effect) presented his General Theory of Relativity for the gravitational force, which generalized Newton’s theory. Einstein’s theory is perhaps the greatest achievement in the history of science and the most celebrated one. The laws for the electromagnetic force were formulated by James Clark Maxwell in 1873, also a great leap forward in human endeavour. With the advent of quantum mechanics in the first decades of the 20th century it was realized that the electromagnetic field, including light, is quantized and can be seen as a stream of particles, photons. In this picture, the electromagnetic force can be thought of as a bombardment of photons, as when one object is thrown to another to transmit a force.
    [Show full text]
  • Heisenberg's Visit to Niels Bohr in 1941 and the Bohr Letters
    Klaus Gottstein Max-Planck-Institut für Physik (Werner-Heisenberg-Institut) Föhringer Ring 6 D-80805 Munich, Germany 26 February, 2002 New insights? Heisenberg’s visit to Niels Bohr in 1941 and the Bohr letters1 The documents recently released by the Niels Bohr Archive do not, in an unambiguous way, solve the enigma of what happened during the critical brief discussion between Bohr and Heisenberg in 1941 which so upset Bohr and made Heisenberg so desperate. But they are interesting, they show what Bohr remembered 15 years later. What Heisenberg remembered was already described by him in his memoirs “Der Teil und das Ganze”. The two descriptions are complementary, they are not incompatible. The two famous physicists, as Hans Bethe called it recently, just talked past each other, starting from different assumptions. They did not finish their conversation. Bohr broke it off before Heisenberg had a chance to complete his intended mission. Heisenberg and Bohr had not seen each other since the beginning of the war in 1939. In the meantime, Heisenberg and some other German physicists had been drafted by Army Ordnance to explore the feasibility of a nuclear bomb which, after the discovery of fission and of the chain reaction, could not be ruled out. How real was this theoretical possibility? By 1941 Heisenberg, after two years of intense theoretical and experimental investigations by the drafted group known as the “Uranium Club”, had reached the conclusion that the construction of a nuclear bomb would be feasible in principle, but technically and economically very difficult. He knew in principle how it could be done, by Uranium isotope separation or by Plutonium production in reactors, but both ways would take many years and would be beyond the means of Germany in time of war, and probably also beyond the means of Germany’s adversaries.
    [Show full text]