Fish Passage and Reintroduction Phase 1 Report: Investigations Upstream of Chief Joseph and Grand Coulee Dams
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Fish Passage and Reintroduction Phase 1 Report: Investigations Upstream of Chief Joseph and Grand Coulee Dams Prepared by the Upper Columbia United Tribes May 2, 2019 Table of Contents 1.0 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................ 8 1.1 REFERENCES.......................................................................................................................... 11 2.0 PURPOSE ................................................................................................................................... 12 3.0 GOALS ....................................................................................................................................... 13 4.0 DONOR STOCK AND RISK ASSESSMENT .......................................................................... 15 4.1 GENERAL METHODS ............................................................................................................ 15 4.2 RESULTS ................................................................................................................................. 17 4.2.1 Donor Sources ............................................................................................................... 17 4.2.2 Ecological Impacts ........................................................................................................ 21 4.2.3 Summary ....................................................................................................................... 23 4.3 REFERENCES.......................................................................................................................... 27 5.0 HABITAT ASSESSMENTS ...................................................................................................... 29 5.1 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................... 29 5.2 INTRINSIC POTENTIAL FOR CHINOOK AND STEELHEAD .......................................... 30 5.3 EDT MODELING OF CHINOOK AND STEELHEAD IN SELECT TRIBUTARIES .......... 37 5.4 LARGE RIVER CHINOOK SPAWNING HABITAT AND REDD CAPACITY .................. 42 5.5 CHINOOK REDD AND ADULT SPAWNER CAPACITY ESTIMATES ............................ 44 5.5.1 Caveats and Considerations ........................................................................................... 46 5.6 POTENTIAL SOCKEYE SALMON SPAWNER CAPACITY IN THE SANPOIL SUBBASIN .......................................................................................................................................... 47 5.7 SOCKEYE SALMON REARING CAPACITY OF LAKE ROOSEVELT ............................. 50 5.8 CLIMATE CHANGE ............................................................................................................... 53 5.9 REFERENCES.......................................................................................................................... 55 6.0 LIFE-CYCLE MODELING ....................................................................................................... 59 6.1 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................... 59 6.2 OVERVIEW OF LCM .............................................................................................................. 67 6.2.1 Natural Production......................................................................................................... 67 6.2.2 Hatchery Production ...................................................................................................... 69 6.2.3 Harvest ........................................................................................................................... 70 6.2.4 Fish Passage .................................................................................................................. 71 6.2.5 Monte Carlo Sensitivity Analysis .................................................................................. 72 6.3 BASELINE SCENARIOS AND KEY LCM MODELING ASSUMPTIONS ......................... 72 6.3.1 Natural Production......................................................................................................... 73 6.3.2 Hydro Operations and Fish Passage .............................................................................. 73 6.3.3 Harvest ........................................................................................................................... 73 6.3.4 Hatchery ........................................................................................................................ 77 6.4 LCM RESULTS ........................................................................................................................ 78 6.4.1 Baseline LCM Results for Summer/Fall Chinook and Sockeye ................................... 78 6.4.2 Summer/Fall Chinook Modeling Variants .................................................................... 81 6.4.3 Sockeye Modeling Variants .......................................................................................... 87 6.4.4 Sensitivity Analysis for Summer/Fall Chinook and Sockeye ....................................... 90 6.5 REFERENCES.......................................................................................................................... 94 7.0 ADULT AND JUVENILE FISH PASSAGE ............................................................................. 95 7.1 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................... 95 7.2 ADULT PASSAGE FACILITIES ............................................................................................ 95 7.3 JUVENILE PASSAGE FACILITIES ....................................................................................... 97 7.3.1 The Floating Surface Collector (FSC) ........................................................................... 97 7.4 RESERVOIR PASSAGE AND SURVIVAL ........................................................................... 99 7.5 CHIEF JOSEPH PROJECT CONDITIONS AND IMPLICATIONS FOR FISH PASSAGE103 7.5.1 Project Conditions ....................................................................................................... 103 7.5.2 Implications for Fish Passage ...................................................................................... 106 7.5.3 Initial Juvenile Passage Facility Concept at Chief Joseph Dam .................................. 107 7.5.4 Initial Adult Passage Facility Concept at Chief Joseph Dam ...................................... 110 7.6 GRAND COULEE DAM PROJECT CONDITIONS AND IMPLICATIONS FOR FISH PASSAGE ....................................................................................................................... 113 7.6.1 Project Conditions ....................................................................................................... 113 7.6.2 Implications for Fish Passage ...................................................................................... 115 7.6.3 Initial Juvenile Passage Facility Concept at Grand Coulee Dam ................................ 117 7.6.4 Initial Adult Passage Facility Concept at Grand Coulee Dam .................................... 121 7.7 FISH PASSAGE FINDINGS .................................................................................................. 122 7.7.1 Chief Joseph Dam........................................................................................................ 122 7.7.2 Grand Coulee Dam ...................................................................................................... 124 7.8 REFERENCES........................................................................................................................ 127 8.0 FUTURE FIELD STUDIES AND RECOMMENDATIONS .................................................. 130 8.1 CHIEF JOSEPH ACTIVITIES ............................................................................................... 130 8.1.1 Testing Key Assumptions ............................................................................................ 130 8.1.2 Interim Fish Facilities .................................................................................................. 132 8.2 GRAND COULEE DAM ACTIVITIES ................................................................................ 133 8.2.1 Testing Key Assumptions ............................................................................................ 133 8.2.2 Interim Fish Facilities .................................................................................................. 143 8.3 REFERENCES........................................................................................................................ 145 List of Tables Table 4-1. Synthesis table for summer/fall Chinook Salmon donors. Attributes and risk rankings for summer/fall Chinook Salmon donors. Highest grand total and weighted grand total scores imply the more suitable donor selection, and were consecutively ranked as the most suitable choice (that is, 1). Weights are assigned to attributes and risks considered more important for species reintroduction. Within UCR: Within upper Columbia River. ESA status: Endangered Species Act status. NFH: National Fish hatchery ............................ 19 Table 4-2. Synthesis table for Sockeye donors. Attributes and risk rankings for Sockeye Salmon donors. Highest grand total and weighted