Item 6 - Appeal Decisions

APPEAL DATE & DECISION BY SITE ADDRESS APPLICATION NO DESCRIPTION DECISION OFFICER/OVERTURNED BY COMMITTEE Land West of Great UTT/13/1043/OP Outline planning application with the details of Appeal Dismissed Dunmow external access committed. Appearance, 25.08.2016 Refused Stortford Road landscaping, layout (including internal access), and scale reserved for later determination. Development to comprise: between 600 and 700 dwellings (Use Class C3); up to 19,300 sq m gross of additional development (including the change of use of existing buildings on site where these are retained) for Use Classes: A1, A2, A3, A4, A5 (retail); B1(a)(offices); C2 (residential institutions care home); D1, D2 (leisure and community uses); car parking; energy centre; and for the laying out of the buildings, routes, open spaces and public realm and landscaping within the development; and all associated works and operations including but not limited to: demolition; earthworks; and engineering operations. Fairfield Site UTT/13/0808/OP Outline application with all matters reserved, Appeal Dismissed N/A Station Road except access, for up to 800 dwellings; up to 25.08.2016 Elsenham 0.5ha of class B1a and B1c employment uses; Bishops Stortford up to 1,400sqm of retail uses; a primary school; Hertfordshire up to 640sqm of Health Centre use; up to 600sqm of community buildings; changing rooms; access roads including access points to B1051 Henham Road and Old Mead Road, a construction access and haul route from B1051 Henham Road, a Waste Water Treatment Works access from Bedwell Road, and provision of a link road at Elsenham Cross between the B1051 Henham Road and Hall Road; a Waste Water Treatment Works and other associated infrastructure, landscaping and boundary

treatment works. Demolition of all existing buildings.

Land West Of Ford UTT/15/2274/FUL Proposed erection of pair of private dwellings Appeal Dismissed N/A Farm with garaging and associated landscaping 25.07.2016 Braintree Road Great Dunmow Essex

Land South Of UTT/16/0059/OP Outline application, with all matters reserved Appeal Allowed N/A Kinvara Business except for access, for the erection of 3 dwellings 21.07.2016 Centre with associated access and parking Gransmore Green Lane Essex

Land At Old UTT/15/3206/FUL Construction of 2 New Residential Dwellings Appeal Dismissed N/A Telephone 26.08.2016 Exchange Weaverhead Lane Essex CM6 2LE

Taylors Service UTT/16/0228/FUL Single storey extension to south west facing Appeal Allowed N/A Centres Ltd elevation providing covered car showroom 29.09.2016 1 - 3 display area Road Industrial Estate Dunmow Essex

11 Broom Farm UTT/15/3760/FUL Proposed new dwelling Appeal Allowed N/A Road 02.08.2016 Elsenham Essex CM22 6LD Land South Of UTT/15/3816/FUL Erection of 7 no. dwellings including new road Appeal Dismissed N/A Oakhanger and associated landscaping 28.07.2016 Friars Lane Hatfield Heath Hertfordshire

Land East Of Glebe UTT/15/3031/OP Outline application with all matters reserved Appeal Dismissed N/A Cottages except for access for the erection of 1 no. 13.09.2016 Royston Road dwelling and garage Wendens Ambo Essex 1 Waterbutt Row UTT/15/3016/LB Replace timber cladding to exterior walls of rear Appeal Allowed N/A Cambridge Road extension, replace windows to side and rear of 19.10.2016 Quendon property, replace side access door and replace 2 no. interior doors in rear extension.

Barn At Charlflo UTT/15/1971/PAP3 Prior notification of proposed change of use of Appeal Allowed N/A Farm Q agricultural building to dwelling 12.07.2016 Pepples Lane Wimbish Saffron Walden

Snow Hill Nursery UTT/15/3599/FUL Demolition of existing buildings and structures, Appeal Allowed N/A Dunmow Road erection of no. 2 dwellings with detached 02.08.2016 Great Easton garages Essex CM6 2DR

Land Adj Three UTT/15/3467/FUL Erection of 1 no. two bedroom dwelling with Appeal Allowed N/A Horse Shoes associated access 16.08.2016 Bannister Green Felsted Essex CM6 3ND

Land At Cedar UTT/15/3231/FUL Erection of one dwelling Appeal Dismissed N/A House 13.10.2016 Broad Green Chrishall Essex SG8 8QR Land Rear Of Hill UTT/15/0623/FUL Proposed change of use from haulage yard to Appeal Dismissed N/A Top Yard gypsy site for 5 no. pitches with toilet block 13.09.2016 Mill Road Henham Bishops Stortford

Woodbine Cottage UTT/15/3462/HHF Proposed demolition of existing double garage Appeal Dismissed N/A Church Lane and erection of replacement outbuilding/garage. 31.08.2016 White Roding Essex CM6 1RN Margaret’s Cottage UTT/16/0069/HHF Proposed two storey side extension. Appeal Allowed Park Road 03.08.2016 Little Easton Essex CM6 2

Land Adj Orchard UTT/15/3747/OP Outline application, with all matters reserved Appeal Allowed N/A House except for access, for 1 no. dwelling with 23.09.2016 Walden Road garage and new access for existing property Ashdon Saffron Walden Essex CB10 2HJ Land Adj Orchard UTT/15/3747/OP Outline application, with all matters reserved Appeal Allowed N/A House except for access, for 1 no. dwelling with 23.09.2016 Walden Road garage and new access for existing property Ashdon Saffron Walden Essex CB10 2HJ

Midden UTT/15/3512/FUL New dwelling, garage, drive and vehicular Appeal Dismissed N/A Top Road crossover Wimbish Essex CB10 2XJ

Land Adjacent UTT/16/0331/FUL 1 no. new dwelling and cartlodge together with Appeal Dismissed N/A Sargents Lane new access 01.11.2016 Walden Road Hadstock Essex CB21 4PA

Barn At Grange UTT/15/2966/PAP3 Prior notification of change of use of agricultural Appeal Dismissed N/A Farm Q building to 3 no. dwellings 18.10.2016 Sparrows Lane Hatfield Heath Bishops Stortford Hertfordshire CM22 7AU

The Old Chalk Pit UTT/15/3481/FUL Erection of 1 no,dwelling and garage and Appeal Dismissed N/A Walden Road change of use to C3. 27.10.2016 Great Chesterford Essex

First Floor UTT/16/0791/AV Retention of fascia sign at 1st floor level Appeal Dismissed N/A 27 High Street 13.09.2016 Dunmow CM6 1AB

Dabbs House UTT/16/0790/FUL Demolition of garage and erection of 1 no. Appeal Allowed N/A London Road dwelling and alterations to access 31.10.2016 Great Chesterford Essex CB10 1NY Rickling House UTT/15/3702/HHF Retrospective planning permission for the Appeal Allowed N/A Cambridge Road erection of a galvanised steel palisade fence to 02.08.2016 Quendon the boundary perimeter. Essex CB11 3XJ

Land South Of 1 UTT/15/1859/FUL Erection of 8 no. residential units and 4 no. low Appeal Dismissed N/A Carters Hill cost residential units with associated parking 06.10.2016 Manuden and landscaping Hertfordshire

Highcroft UTT/16/0536/FUL Demolition of stable block, and erection of one Appeal Allowed N/A Keeres Green dwelling 16.08.2016 Aythorpe Roding Essex CM6 1PQ