Polarization Transfer Dynamics in Multi-Spin Systems Using the DREAM Scheme
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Research Collection Doctoral Thesis Polarization transfer dynamics in multi-spin systems using the DREAM scheme Author(s): Westfeld, Thomas Publication Date: 2010 Permanent Link: https://doi.org/10.3929/ethz-a-006410379 Rights / License: In Copyright - Non-Commercial Use Permitted This page was generated automatically upon download from the ETH Zurich Research Collection. For more information please consult the Terms of use. ETH Library DISS. ETH NO. 19196 Polarization Transfer Dynamics in Multi-Spin Systems Using the DREAM Scheme A dissertation submitted to ETH ZÜRICH for the degree of Doctor of Sciences presented by THOMAS WESTFELD born September 9, 1979 citizen of the Federal Republic of Germany accepted on the recommendation of Prof. Dr. Beat H. Meier, examiner Prof. Dr. Roland Riek, co-examiner 2010 Meiner Mutter nanos gigantium humeris insidentes Bernardus Carnotensis Contents Abbreviations ix Abstract xi Zusammenfassung xiii 1. General Introduction 1 1.1. Quantum-mechanical Framework of NMR . ............. 1 1.1.1. Hamiltonians in NMR . ..................... 1 1.1.2. Describing the Outcome of an NMR Experiment ......... 5 1.1.3. Average-Hamiltonian Theory . ................. 6 1.1.4. Spherical-Tensor Representations and Rotations ......... 7 1.1.5. Magic-Angle Spinning . ..................... 9 1.1.6. Adiabatic Fast-Passage . ..................... 13 1.2. NMR on Biomolecules . ......................... 15 1.2.1. Liquid-State NMR . ......................... 15 1.2.2. Solid-State NMR . ......................... 17 1.3. The Assignment Problem . ......................... 21 I. Solid-State NMR Studies of the Prion Protein HET-s (156-289) 25 2. Introduction To Prion Proteins and Amyloids 27 2.1. Discovery of Prions . ............................. 27 2.2. Replication of Prions and Amyloid Fiber Formation . ......... 28 2.3. Amyloid diseases . ............................. 30 2.4. Fungal Prions ................................. 31 v vi Contents 2.5. The HET-s Prion . ............................. 32 2.5.1. Biological Background . ..................... 32 2.5.2. Solid-state NMR Studies on HET-s(218–289) . ......... 33 2.5.3. The HET-s(156–289) Prion . ..................... 34 3. Experimental 37 3.1. Bacterial Strains . ............................. 37 3.2. Protein Expression and Purification..................... 37 3.2.1. Transformation of pET24-HET-s(156–289) Vector ......... 37 3.2.2. Expression of U-13C,15N HET-s (156-289) ............. 37 3.2.3. Expression of HET-s(156–289) Using Auto-Induction . 38 3.2.4. Cell Work-Up and Lysis . ..................... 38 3.2.5. Purification.............................. 39 3.2.6. SDS–PAGE . ............................. 39 3.2.7. Fibrilization and Sample Preparation . ............. 39 3.2.8. Preparation of Low Temperature Samples ............. 40 3.3. Electron Microscopy ............................. 40 3.4. NMR Experiments . ............................. 40 3.4.1. Solid-State NMR Experiments . ................. 40 3.4.2. Data Processing and Data Analysis ................. 43 4. Results 45 4.1. Expression of HET-s(156–289) . ..................... 45 4.1.1. Expression of U-13C,15N HET-s (156-289) ............. 45 4.1.2. Expression of HET-s(156–289) Using Auto-induction . 45 4.1.3. Refolding and Fibrilization of HET-s(156–289) . ......... 47 4.2. Solid-State NMR studies . ......................... 47 4.2.1. Comparing HET-s(218–289) and HET-s(156–289) ......... 47 4.2.2. Chemical Shift Mapping . ..................... 56 4.2.3. Low-Temperature Measurements . ................. 56 4.2.4. Using non Dipolar-Based Experiments . ............. 62 5. Discussion 67 5.1. Solid-state NMR Spectra of HET-s(156–289) . ............. 67 5.2. J-BasedSpectra................................ 69 Contents vii 6. Conclusion 71 II. The DREAM Experiment in Multi-Spin Systems 73 7. Introduction to the DREAM Experiment 75 7.1. Theoretical Description . ......................... 76 7.1.1. The HORROR Experiment . ..................... 76 7.1.2. From HORROR to DREAM ..................... 80 7.1.3. DREAM in Multi-Spin Systems . ................. 83 7.2. Simulation Strategies ............................. 85 7.3. DREAMing Away . ............................. 87 8. Experimental 91 8.1. Simulation of DREAM Transfer . ..................... 91 8.1.1. Simulating the Mixing Using Time-Slicing . ......... 92 8.1.2. Simulating the Mixing Using Floquet Theory . ......... 92 8.2. Experimental DREAM Spectra . ..................... 93 8.2.1. DREAM Spectra of Single Amino Acids . ............. 93 8.2.2. DREAM Spectra of Ubiquitin . ................. 94 8.2.3. Data Evaluation . ......................... 94 9. Results 97 9.1. Simulation Strategies ............................. 97 9.2. Transfer Efficiency Dependence on Carrier Position and RF Field . 99 9.3. Cross Peak Patterns in Protein Spectra . ................. 104 9.3.1. Experimental DREAM Spectra . ................. 104 9.3.2. Simulated DREAM Spectra ..................... 105 9.3.3. Comparing Simulated and Experimental DREAM Spectra . 105 10.Discussion 115 10.1. Simulation Strategies of DREAM Spectra ................. 115 10.2. Transfer Efficiency Dependence on Carrier Position and RF Field . 117 10.3. Cross Peak Patterns in Protein Spectra . ................. 120 viii Contents 11.Conclusion 123 12.Outlook 125 Bibliography 129 Acknowledgements 143 Curriculum Vitae 145 Publications 147 Abbreviations 1D One dimensional 2D Two dimensional APHH CP Adiabatic-passage Hartmann-Hahn cross-polarization AHT Average Hamiltonian theory BSE Bovine spongiform encephalopathy CJD Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease CP Cross-polarization CSA Chemical shift anisotropy DARR Dipolar assisted rotational resonance DNA Deoxyribonucleic acid DREAM Dipolar recoupling enhanced by amplitude modulation FT Fourier transform GFP Green fluorescent protein GSS Gerstmann-Sträussler syndrome HORROR Homonuclear rotary-resonance INEPT Insensitive nuclei enhanced by polarization transfer LAB Laboratory frame MAS Magic-angle spinning MiByte Mebibyte (1 Mebibyte = 10242 byte) MOL Molecular fixed frame MRI Magnetic resonance imaging NMR Nuclear magnetic resonance NOE Nuclear Overhauser effect λ = OD600 Optical density at wavelength 600 nm PAS Principle axis frame ppm Parts per million Prion Proteinaceous infectious particle ix x Contents RF Radio frequency RNA Ribonucleic acid ROT Rotor fixed frame SDS Sodium dodecyl sulfate STEM Scanning transmission electron microscopy TOBSY Through-bond spectroscopy TPPM Two pulse phase modulation WiW WURST–inverse–WURST WURST Wideband, uniform rate, and smooth truncation XiX x–inverse–x Abstract In this thesis two projects are presented which demonstrate the application of solid- state NMR on prion proteins and the characteristics of a polarization transfer method in the context of biomolecular NMR. Prion proteins are linked with a number of neurodegenerative diseases such as bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) in cattle or chronic wasting disease (CWD) in mule deer and elk. In humans known prion diseases are the Creutzfeldt-Jakob dis- ease, the Gerstmann-Sträussler syndrome and kuru. The protein is therefore trans- formed from a soluble state into an infectious prion state in which it aggregates to amyloid plaques which consist of protein fibrils. The prion protein HET-s studied in this work is from the filamentous fungus Po- dospora anserina. In this organism the prion is involved in the recognition of the com- patibility of other species before cell fusion. In this case the prion is not pathogenic, but has an important function for the fungus. Amyloids are not soluble and do not form crystals which make them inaccessible for standard protein structure determination techniques such as X-ray crystallogra- phy or liquid-state NMR. However solid-state NMR studies have been applied suc- cessfully to gain insight into the structure of prions. In the first project of this work a C-terminal fragment of HET-s from residue 156 to 289 is studied. This fragment can be divided into a prion forming domain from residue 218 to 289 and roughly the same number of residues which are located in the globular part of the protein from residue 156 to 217. It has been shown that the prion forming domain alone is able for form amyloid fibril which are infectious to the fungus but is not active with respect to its function to distinguish between compatible and non compatible cell fusion partners. In contrast the fragment studied here is in this respect biologically active. To characterize this fragment the protein was produced recombinantely by expres- sion in E.coli. The uniformly 13C and 15N labeled sample was then used to collect xi xii Abstract different 2D correlation spectra at ambient and low temperature. This data was com- pared to the analogous spectra of the prion forming domain alone. It was possible to show that the prion forming domain has the same structure in HET-s(156–289) and HET-s(218–289) . The additional residues are visible in the spectrum at positions in- dicating that they are in a random coil. There are also resonances observed which indicate that some residues are in an alpha-helical conformation. The weak signal in- tensity and the observed random-coil chemical shift indicate that the part belonging to the globular domain of HET-s(156–289) is structurally disordered. The second project of this thesis demonstrates how a method for reintroducing the dipolar coupling in solid-state NMR under Magic Angle Spinning (MAS) can be tailored to facilitate the analysis of protein spectra. MAS is averaging