Montana State University Research Paper
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
DESIGNING AND ASSESSING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF DENIL FISHWAYS USING HYDRAULIC MODELING-BASED APPROACHES by Nolan Chalmers Platt A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science in Civil Engineering MONTANA STATE UNIVERSITY Bozeman, Montana April 2019 ©COPYRIGHT by Nolan Platt 2019 All Rights Reserved ii DEDICATION To Megan and the 404, much love to the community. To Alan and Joan, for valuing education and making it all possible. To Ben, this project would not be what it was without him. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. INTRODUCTION ...........................................................................................................1 2. LITERATURE REVIEW ................................................................................................4 The Big Hole and Grayling ..............................................................................................4 Hydraulic Modeling Applied to Fish Passage .................................................................7 3. MODELING UPSTREAM ARCTIC GRAYLING PASSAGE THROUGH DENIL FISHWAYS IN THE BIG HOLE VALLEY, MONTANA .............................13 Contributions of Authors and Co-Authors.....................................................................13 Manuscript Information .................................................................................................14 Introduction ....................................................................................................................15 Methods..........................................................................................................................21 Study Area and S ites ..............................................................................................21 Data Collection ......................................................................................................24 Hydraulic Modeling ...............................................................................................29 Passage Index Application .....................................................................................32 Results ............................................................................................................................35 Hydraulic Models...................................................................................................35 Operating Condition...............................................................................................37 Passage Windows...................................................................................................37 Disc uss io n ......................................................................................................................40 Known Passage Conditions....................................................................................40 Unknown Passage Conditions................................................................................41 Biological Consideration .......................................................................................42 Hydraulic Models...................................................................................................47 Model Application .................................................................................................49 Acknowledgements .......................................................................................................51 Disclosure Statement .....................................................................................................52 Funding ..........................................................................................................................52 References .....................................................................................................................52 Appendix .......................................................................................................................59 4. HYDRAULIC DESIGN OF DENIL FISHWAYS AT PIN-AND-PLANK IRRIGATION DIVERSIONS: A TECHNICAL REPORT ..........................................81 Contributions of Authors and Co-Authors.....................................................................81 Manuscript Information .................................................................................................82 Summary ........................................................................................................................83 iv TABLE OF CONTENTS CONTINUED Design Scenario .............................................................................................................87 Step 1: Define Design Criteria .......................................................................................88 Step 2: Collect Pertinent Data ........................................................................................94 Step 3: Construct Hydraulic Model ...............................................................................99 Step 4: Determine Downstream Invert Elevation ........................................................102 Step 5: Check Minimum-Slope Depth Requirements..................................................103 Step 6: Determine Upstream Invert Elevation .............................................................105 Step 7: Final Design C heck..........................................................................................107 Fishway Operation and Maintenance...........................................................................107 Definitions and Abbreviations .....................................................................................108 Disclaimer ....................................................................................................................109 References ....................................................................................................................110 Appendices...................................................................................................................112 Appendix 1 ...........................................................................................................112 Hydraulic Design Process Example: Steel Creek Diversion .......................112 Hydraulic Design Process Example: Big Hole River Diversion .................116 Appendix 2 ...........................................................................................................122 Appendix 3 ...........................................................................................................123 5. CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................124 REFERENCES CITED....................................................................................................126 v LIST OF TABLES Tab le Page 3.1 Passage index ..................................................................................................34 3.2 Hydraulic model calibration results ................................................................36 3.3 Passage windows ............................................................................................38 4.1 Design criteria .................................................................................................89 vi LIST OF FIGURES Figure Page 3.1 Study area map................................................................................................22 3.2 Swa mp Creek site photo .................................................................................24 3.3 Plan view site schematic .................................................................................26 3.4 Graphical representation of passage condition of Site 28, 2018.....................39 4.1 Design process flow chart ...............................................................................86 4.2 Denil schematics .............................................................................................92 4.3 Site schematic .................................................................................................97 4.4 Step 4 visual summary ..................................................................................103 vii ABSTRACT Man-made, instream structures can pose barriers to fish movement. Fish move about river systems to reach habitats associated with various stages of their life histories. If access to required habitat is blocked, it can cause detrimental effects to fish populations. Removing barriers to fish movement is often socio-economically infeasible so fishways are used to promote fish passage around barriers. Denil fishways consist of a chute for water to flow through and baffles to slow water velocities; they are a relatively cheap solution for promoting upstream fish passage over low-head barriers. The Big Hole River basin is home to the last fluvia l population of Arctic Grayling in the continental United States. Per an agreement between landowners and several government organizations, Denil fishways were installed at irrigation diversions in the Big Hole Valley to provide fish volitional routes to navigate irrigation diversions. Eleven Denil fishways at irrigation diversions were evaluated for their effectiveness at passing grayling by using hydraulic modeling techniques coupled with biologic data. Hydrologic data was applied to hydraulic models to estimate water surface elevations about the Denils over time. A passage index was developed which inferred passage efficiency of the fishway based on depths at the upstream and downstream