PSA/DNA Full LOA PSA/DNA Pre-Certified Not Reviewed The Jack Smalling Collection Debut Year Player Hall of Fame Item Grade 1871 Doug Allison Letter Cap Anson HOF Letter 7 Al Reach Letter Deacon White HOF Cut 8 Nicholas Young Letter 1872 Jack Remsen Letter 1874 Billy Barnie Letter Tommy Bond Cut Morgan Bulkeley HOF Cut 9 Jack Chapman Letter 1875 Fred Goldsmith Cut 1876 Foghorn Bradley Cut 1877 Jack Gleason Cut 1878 Phil Powers Letter 1879 Hick Carpenter Cut Barney Gilligan Cut Jack Glasscock Index Horace Phillips Letter 1880 Frank Bancroft Letter Ned Hanlon HOF Letter 7 Arlie Latham Index Mickey Welch HOF Index 9 Art Whitney Cut 1882 Bill Gleason Cut Jake Seymour Letter Ren Wylie Cut 1883 Cal Broughton Cut Bob Emslie Cut John Humphries Cut Joe Mulvey Letter Jim Mutrie Cut Walter Prince Cut Dupee Shaw Cut Billy Sunday Index 1884 Ed Andrews Letter Al Atkinson Index Charley Bassett Letter Frank Foreman Index Joe Gunson Cut John Kirby Letter Tom Lynch Cut Al Maul Cut Abner Powell Index Gus Schmeltz Letter Phenomenal Smith Cut Chief Zimmer Cut 1885 John Tener Cut 1886 Dan Dugdale Letter Connie Mack HOF Index Joe Murphy Cut Wilbert Robinson HOF Cut 8 Billy Shindle Cut Mike Smith Cut Farmer Vaughn Letter 1887 Jocko Fields Cut Joseph Herr Cut Jack O'Connor Cut Frank Scheibeck Cut George Tebeau Letter Gus Weyhing Cut 1888 Hugh Duffy HOF Index Frank Dwyer Cut Dummy Hoy Index Mike Kilroy Cut Phil Knell Cut Bob Leadley Letter Pete McShannic Cut Scott Stratton Letter 1889 George Bausewine Index Jack Doyle Index Jesse Duryea Cut Hank Gastright Letter Jimmy McAleer Cut Sadie McMahon Index 1890 Bob Allen Cut Sumner Bowman Cut Billy Clingman Check Tommy Corcoran Index Patsy Donovan Index Robert Gibson Cut Billy Gumbert Cut George Hemming Cut John Leighton Cut Ezra Lincoln Cut Bobby Lowe Index Kid Nichols HOF Index George Stallings Cut Jake Virtue Cut Cy Young HOF Index 10 1891 Ted Breitenstein Cut Buster Burrell Cut Bill Clymer Cut Charlie Cushman Letter Bill Dahlen Index Tommy Dowd Cut Buck Freeman Cut Clark Griffith HOF Index Hughie Jennings HOF Letter Jack Leiper Cut 1892 Bert Abbey Cut Frank Bird Cut Lew Camp Cut Pink Hawley Letter John Hollison Cut Will Thompson Cut 1893 Boileryard Clarke Cut Frank Donnelly Cut Bill Lange Cut Ed McFarland Cut Joe Sugden Cut 1894 Jimmy Callahan Cut Fred Clarke HOF Index Mike Grady Letter Kid Mohler Cut Kip Selbach Index Jesse Tannehill Cut Fred Tenney Index Bobby Wallace HOF Index Huyler Westervelt Cut 1895 Frank Bowerman Index Jimmy Collins HOF Index 9 Joe Connor Cut Harry Davis Cut Gussie Gannon Cut Bill Hoffer Cut George Hogriever Cut John McCloskey Cut Carlton Molesworth Cut Al Orth Cut Walter Thornton Cut Deke White Letter 1896 Lou Criger Cut Klondike Douglass Cut Chick Fraser Cut Dale Gear Cut Phil Geier Index Fielder Jones Letter Nap Lajoie HOF Index Harley Payne Cut Sammy Strang Letter 1897 Ed Abbaticchio Index Bob Becker Cut Roger Bresnahan HOF Index 7 Win Clark Cut Jack Dunn Letter John Grimes Cut Dick Harley Index Dick Harley Index Charlie Hickman Cut Frank Huelsman Cut Jim Jones Cut Tom Leahy Cut Jimmy Sheckard Cut Joe Stanley Cut Honus Wagner HOF Index 1898 Nick Altrock Index Kitty Bransfield Cut Jimmy Burke Cut Charlie Carr Cut Josh Clarke Cut Tom Connolly HOF Cut 9 Bill Dinneen Index Bill Donovan Cut Charlie Ebbets Letter Kid Elberfeld Index Elmer Flick HOF Index Dave Fultz Index John Ganzel Index Russ Hall Letter Jack Katoll Index Tommy Leach Index Sam Leever Index George Magoon Cut Ralph Miller Index Bill Shettsline Letter Harry Steinfeldt Cut Jack Taylor Letter Vic Willis HOF Index 9 Walt Woods Index 1899 Shad Barry Cut Ginger Beaumont Index Bill Bernhard Cut Bill Bradley Index Harry Colliflower Cut Bill Coughlin Index Sam Crawford HOF Index Mike Donlin Cut Tom Fleming Pass Charlie Frisbee Cut Noodles Hahn Index Jack Harper Letter Charlie Harris Cut Charlie Hemphill Cut Fred Hoey Cut Rudy Hulswitt Index Mike Kelley Index Otto Krueger Cut Red Owens Cut Freddy Parent Index Skel Roach Cut Jimmy Slagle Cut Billy Sullivan Index Roy Thomas Letter Jimmy Williams Index 1900 Mal Eason Index Louie Heilbroner Letter Tom Hughes Index Ban Johnson HOF Contract Johnny Kling Index Danny Murphy Index Dummy Taylor Index 1901 Harry Bay Index Jack Bracken Index Dick Braggins Cut Dave Brain Check Lew Carr Cut Charlie Case Index Wid Conroy Index Davey Crockett Cut Jim Delahanty Letter Frank Dupee Index Bill Friel Index Bill Friel Index Daff Gammons Cut Billy Gilbert Cut Harry Gleason Index Emil Haberer Cut Davy Jones Index Paddy Livingston Index Billy Maloney Index George McBride Index Gene McCann Cut Fred Mitchell Index Earl Moore Index Mike O'Neill Cut Roy Patterson Cut Fred Raymer Index George Rohe Cut Al Shaw Cut Danny Shay Cut Jack Slattery Cut Happy Townsend Index Terry Turner Index Jake Volz Contract Doc White Index 1902 Joe Adams Cut Bill Armour Letter Jake Atz Index Bob Blewett Cut Andy Coakley Index Red Dooin Cut Gus Dorner Check Lew Drill Index Wish Egan Index Johnny Evers HOF Index 9 Bob Ewing Index Ed Fisher Index Lee Fohl Index Jim Hackett Cut Jack Hendricks Cut George Hildebrand Index Tom Jones Cut Jack Lundbom Index Jack O'Neill Cut Andy Oyler Index Alex Pearson Index Bob Rhoads Index Lew Ritter Cut Ernie Ross Cut Nap Shea Cut Joe Tinker HOF Index 8 Rube Vickers Cut Heinie Wagner Cut Libe Washburn Cut Otto Williams Cut Gary Wilson Index 1903 Red Ames Cut Bill Bartley Index Ed Barrow HOF Cut Chief Bender HOF Index Elmer Bliss Cut Mordecai Brown HOF Index 8 Fred Carisch Index Pep Clark Letter Bert Daly Cut Lee DeMontreville Cut Jack Doscher Index Norwood Gibson Index Weldon Henley Check Solly Hofman Cut Dutch Jordan Index John Kalahan Cut Ed Killian Cut Hans Lobert Index Joe Martin Index Judge McCredie Cut Charlie Moran Cut Lew Moren Index Cy Morgan Cut George Moriarty Index Champ Osteen Index Jack Pfiester Index Ambrose Puttmann Cut Dutch Rudolph Index War Sanders Cut George Stone Cut Jesse Stovall Cut Pinky Swander Cut Jimmy Wiggs Cut Barney Wolfe Cut 1904 Fred Applegate Index Jimmy Archer Index Art Bader Cut Claude Berry Index Lou Bruce Index Ralph Caldwell Index Howie Camnitz Index Rip Cannell Check Orth Collins Cut Art Devlin Cut Tom Fisher Index Ernie Groth Cut Bob Hall Letter Bill Lauterborn Index Doc Marshall Index Harry McChesney Cut Moose McCormick Index Rabbit Nill Index Pete Noonan Index Kid O'Hara Letter Charley O'Leary Cut Fred Odwell Cut Jesse Purnell Index Bugs Raymond Letter Frank Schulte Cut Bill Schwartz Letter George Stovall Cut Gabby Street Index Elmer Stricklett Index Deacon Van Buren Cut Ed Walsh HOF Index Hooks Wiltse Index 1905 Jap Barbeau Index Al Bridwell Index Andy Bruckmiller Index Hal Chase Index Charlie Chech Cut Eddie Cicotte Index Ty Cobb HOF Index 9 Frank Delahanty Index Jimmy Dygert Cut Gene Ford Index Bob Ganley Cut George Gibson Index John Godwin Cut Dick Harley Cut Joe Harris Cut Hub Hart Cut Frank Hershey Cut Homer Hillebrand Index Bill Hinchman Cut Del Howard Cut John Hummel Cut Ollie Johns Cut Nick Kahl Cut Ed Kinsella Index Bill Klem HOF Index Otto Knabe Index John Knight Index Punch Knoll Cut Lefty Leifield Index Bris Lord Index Offa Neal Cut Rube Oldring Index Big Jeff Pfeffer Index Ed Reulbach Index Branch Rickey HOF Index Stan Robison Cut Shag Shaughnessy Index Johnny Siegle Index Tubby Spencer Cut Allie Strobel Index Hughie Tate Cut Frosty Thomas Index Rip Vowinkel Index Hi West Index 1906 Babe Adams Index Dave Altizer Index Cy Barger Index Fred Beebe Index Joe Birmingham Index Sam Brown Letter Bill Carrigan Index Eddie Collins HOF Index Jack Coombs Index Ches Crist Cut Jerry Donovan Cut Bob Edmondson Index Bill Essick Index Billy Evans HOF Index Lou Fiene Index Art Fromme Index Ralph Glaze Index Clyde Goodwin Index Charlie Graham Index Leo Hafford Letter Charley Hall Letter Roy Hartzell Cut Gus Hetling Cut Irv Higginbotham Cut Ed Holly Index Ducky Holmes Index Tom Hughes Cut Harry Huston Index Frank Jude Letter Glenn Liebhardt Cut Pop Lloyd HOF Cut 8 Red Murray Index Harry Niles Cut Frank Oberlin Index Fred Payne Index Jack Rowan Index Jack Schulte Index Dave Shean Cut Oscar Stanage Cut Ira Thomas Index Tom Walsh Index Joe Ward Cut Roy Witherup Cut 1907 Chick Autry Index Neal Ball Index Frank Barberich Index Roy Beecher Cut Heinie Berger Cut Jake Boultes Cut Lew Brockett Cut Kid Butler Index Bobby Byrne Index Harry Coveleski Index Harry Curtis Index Rube Dessau Index Larry Doyle Index Roy Hitt Cut Walter Johnson HOF Index 8 Bobby Keefe Index Red Killefer Index Sam Lanford Index Nick Maddox Index Bill McGill Cut Bill McKechnie HOF Index Fred Merkle Index Clyde Milan Index Mike Mitchell Index Jess Orndorff Cut Dode Paskert Cut Nap Rucker Index Al Shaw Index Tris Speaker HOF Index Elmer Steele Cut Jim Stephens Index Ham Wade Cut George Whiteman Index Harry Wolter Index Heinie Zimmerman Index 1908 Home Run Baker HOF Index Orson Baldwin Cut Jack Barry Index Jack Bliss Index Donie Bush Index Vin Campbell Index Walter Carlisle Index Nick Carter Cut Eli Cates Cut Doc Crandall Cut Gavvy Cravath Index Birdie Cree Index Dode Criss Index Josh Devore Index Pat Donahue Index Jean Dubuc Index Joe Dunn Cut Ben Egan Index Jack Flater Index Jack Fox Letter Larry Gardner Index Jack Graney Index Buck Herzog Cut Dick Hoblitzell Index Harry Hoch Cut Burt Keeley Index Harry Krause Cut Abe Kruger Cut Grover Land Index Bill Mack Cut Frank Manush Index Rube Marquard HOF Index Jim McHale Cut Tommy McMillan Index Walter Morris Letter Walter Morris Index Andy O'Connor Index Patsy O'Rourke Letter Marty O'Toole Letter Harry Pattee Index George Perring Cut Clay Perry Cut Billy