Extract from Document Lcc01a with Regard to the Green Belt

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Extract from Document Lcc01a with Regard to the Green Belt Matter 4 / Issue 1 / Liverpool City Council Appendix 1: Extract from Document LCC01a with regard to the Green Belt. Question 51. Is there a Green Belt Review which assesses the qualities of the land at the Oglet which is proposed to be released from the Green Belt, and its contribution to the Green Belt? The City Council did not consider it necessary to undertake a city-wide Green Belt Review because of the opportunities to meet all of its objectively assessed needs for new residential and general employment development on non-Green Belt land elsewhere in the City. The obvious exception to this is the specific issue of the further expansion of Liverpool John Lennon Airport, which has grown considerably, to the economic and social benefit of the City Region, since the last time that the Green Belt was considered in a development plan context. The further expansion which has been shown to be necessary is locationally specific such that it can only rationally be accommodated at this particular location. Contribution of the Land to be released from the Green Belt An assessment of the land which is proposed to be removed from the Green Belt against each of the five purposes of the Green Belt as set out in national planning policy, is provided in Section 8 ‘Impact on Green Belt’ of Core Document 31.0 Liverpool John Lennon Airport: The Case for the Expansion. Paragraph 80 of the NPPF (2012) states that Green Belt serves five purposes: a) to check the unrestricted sprawl of large built-up areas; b) to prevent neighbouring towns merging into one another; c) to assist in safeguarding the countryside from encroachment; d) to preserve the setting and special character of historic towns; and e) to assist in urban regeneration, by encouraging the recycling of derelict and other urban land. The analysis in Section 8 shows that the land to be released comprises a narrow “limb” of land between the airport and the River Mersey (see Figure 8.1 of Liverpool John Lennon Airport: The Case for Expansion – Core Document 31.0). It does not contribute to preventing neighbouring towns merging into one another, it does not contribute towards the setting and special character of historic towns, and as there are no other potential land opportunities to accommodate the proposed expansion, the need for which arises from growth anticipated at the Airport, it will have no adverse impact on the objective of assisting urban regeneration. There is therefore no conflict with the second, fourth or fifth purposes of the Green Belt. With respect to the first and third purposes of the Green Belt (urban sprawl and encroachment into the countryside respectively), it also concludes that the land makes only a limited contribution to those objectives. The analysis also concludes that proposed change to the Green Belt boundary south of the airport would not have implications for the wider Green Belt in this part of Merseyside and it would create a logical and defensible boundary. The boundary would not need to be reviewed at the end of the plan period. The limited impact on the purposes of Green Belt as a result of the release of the Oglet land from the Green Belt under Policy EC7 must be taken into account in determining whether exceptional circumstances exist to justify the proposed amendment of the Green Belt boundary. This is 1 Matter 4 / Issue 1 / Liverpool City Council addressed in Part 3 ‘Exceptional Circumstances’ of the Case for the Expansion (Core Document 31.0) which concludes that the uniqueness of the need for and benefits of the planned expansion of LJLA, for which there is no alternative location within the LCR, comprise exceptional circumstances which justify the proposed release of land from the Green Belt. Other Qualities of the Land to be released from the Green Belt. Agricultural Land Classification Section 9 of the Case for the Expansion document (Core Document 31.0) provides summary analysis of the value of the land in agricultural terms. It refers to a study (Core Document 31.8) commissioned by the airport in 2005 to understand the potential impacts on agricultural resources (across the Master Plan area) that would occur should the Airport be expanded as anticipated within the Airport Master Plan (see Core Document CD22). The Agriculture Assessment Study, undertaken by Reading Agricultural Consultants (who have confirmed that the conclusions of their 2005 study remain valid in 2019), establishes that the land is currently mostly arable, dominated by cereals and oilseed rape with some permanent pasture. The land to the south of the Airport, around the Oglet, mainly supports a mixture of main crop carrots and potatoes, cereals and set-aside or rough grass. The study identifies that the land to be released from the Green Belt comprises land of both Grade 2 (Very Good) and Grade 3a (Good to Moderate) within the Agricultural Land Classification (See Core Document 31.8 section 2). Paragraph 112 of the NPPF (2012) advises that “Local planning authorities should take into account the economic and other benefits of the best and most versatile agricultural land. Where significant development of agricultural land is demonstrated to be necessary, local planning authorities should seek to use areas of poorer quality land in preference to that of a higher quality”. The City Council has concluded that since the expansion of LJLA that has been shown to be necessary can only occur in this location there is no option to locate it on lower grade land. The very significant economic and social benefits for the City Region of the planned expansion of LJLA far outweigh the economic and other value of agricultural use of the land. The Sustainability Appraisal of the draft Local Plan also concludes that Policy EC7 would have a “negligible” impact on soil resources (see CD8 Table 5.5 page 54). Visual Quality of the Land to be Released from the Green Belt. Section 9 of CD 31.0 The Case for the Expansion also considers the Landscape Quality and Character of the land identified in the Airport’s Master Plan (CD 22) for expansion south of the existing runway. It confirms that existing views of the buildings and structures associated with LJLA are available from many locations in the vicinity. Visual sensitivity from the north of LJLA is low due to the low visual quality in this area. Where appropriate existing boundary mounding and fencing would be upgraded with increased planting alongside Hale Road. The layout, massing, scale and roofscape of buildings within LJLA would be dealt with at planning application stage and is appropriately addressed by other policies in the Local Plan including: • UD4 Inclusive Design • UD5 New Buildings • HD1 Heritage Assets • GI5 Protection of Biodiversity and Geodiversity 1 Matter 4 / Issue 1 / Liverpool City Council • R9 Solar Panels To the south of the runway, the visual agricultural character of the land to be released would be changed by the introduction of new buildings. There will be a landscape impact from a development of this scale. The assessment in Section 9 of The Case for Expansion (Core Document 31.0) considers that by retaining features where possible and through screening and planting, this impact can be mitigated. Neither the City Council nor LJLA have done nor is it considered necessary to do detailed landscape assessments at this stage. Policy EC7 and other Local Plan policies are considered to give suitable protection and development management guidance to ensure that this analysis occurs. In particular careful consideration during detailed design would ensure that where possible, existing landscape features are retained. Subject to these measures, which would be addressed at planning application stage, no significant impacts are envisaged on the shore and the adjacent cliffs. Key residual impacts would be minimised through extensive mitigation planting and earth works to screen and enclose development to the southern boundary as part of the planned coastal reserve. A similar approach was successful in delivery of the existing Speke Garston Coastal Reserve to the west of the Airport and its success provides a high degree of comfort that this would safeguard the visual amenity and accessibility of the Mersey Way coastal path. It is the City Council’s view that the proposed expansion at LJLA undertaken in accordance with Policy EC7 including robust assessment, design and where necessary, mitigation similar to that already implemented on land to the west, will not lead to significant adverse impacts upon the landscape quality or character of the surrounding area. Suitable landscaping and planting will inform proposals as they progress. Biodiversity Qualities of the Land to be Released In addition to consideration of potential impacts on the special interest of the Mersey Estuary, an Extended Phase 1 Habitat Survey of the land to be released from the Green Belt was undertaken in 2018 (by Atmos Ecology – see Core Document 31.6). While the survey is not yet as comprehensive as will be required to be prepared in support of a detailed planning application, it’s conclusions on the available evidence are that the habitats on site are predominantly comprise actively farmed arable fields of limited ecological value. It is acknowledged that the arable fields will have the potential to support a number of protected species and that parts of the site are included within local wildlife sites as shown on the Local Plan Policies Map. As such it is agreed that surveys will need to be undertaken to understand the potential impacts that any specific development could have on the species, in order to avoid effects in the design process, and/or to inform appropriate mitigation and/or compensation and enhancement measures.
Recommended publications
  • Aigburth Grange
    AigbuLiverpoorthl Grange A beautiful collection of 2, 3 & 4 bedroom homes Homes you’ll love inside out GOING OUT SHOPPING Liverpool offers an unrivalled range of Liverpool is nothing short of a shoppers’ entertainment for a great night out. Film paradise, with a huge range of shops and buffs can choose between the state of the stores. Visit the £1bn Liverpool One art iMax at Liverpool One and the art complex, with its flagship stores, and don’t house movies of FACT, while theatre goers miss the high street styles of Church Street, will be spoiled for choice with the Empire, the quirky independents of Bold Street or Everyman and Playhouse theatres to choose the designer labels of the Cavern Walks. from, along with the major concerts and You’ll also find a good selection of local shops SPORT & LEISURE shows of the Echo Arena. close to the development, including a Tesco The city is famous for its sports, with a Liverpool also has a vibrant nightlife, with a Metro store just a few minutes walk away. choice of Premier League football action, huge range of restaurants and bars to choose Aintree and Haydock racecourses and a from, with something for every taste and Championship golf course. There’s also an Everything budget. Closer to home, you’ll find a good excellent selection of challenging golf courses selection of restaurants along Aigburth Road circling the city. and Lark Lane. For more relaxed leisure time, take a stroll in one along the Mersey at Otterspool Promenade, or enjoy all that Sefton Park has to offer, just across the road from the development, including the famous Palm House.
    [Show full text]
  • Guide to Liverpool Waterfront
    Guide to Liverpool Waterfront “Three Graces” – Together the Royal Liver Building, Cunard Building and the Port of Liverpool Building make up the Mersey’s ‘Three Graces’ and are at the architectural centre of Liverpool’s iconic waterfront. A massive engineering project has recently extended the canal in front of these three buildings, adding beautifully landscaped seating areas and viewpoints along the canal and the river. Museum of Liverpool – this brand new museum, opened in 2011 is a magnificent addition to Liverpool’s waterfront. Celebrating the origins and heritage of the city, it features collections from National Museums Liverpool that have never been seen before. Otterspool Promenade – The construction of Otterspool Promenade (1950) provided both a new amenity for Liverpool and an open space dividend from the disposal of Mersey Tunnel spoil and household waste; a project repeated three decades later to reclaim the future International Garden Festival site. A favourite with kite fliers this often overlooked wide open space is perfect for views of the river and picnics Antony Gormley’s “Another Place” - These spectacular sculptures by Antony Gormley are on Crosby beach, about 10 minutes out of Liverpool. Another Place consists of 100 cast-iron, life-size figures spread out along three kilometres of the foreshore, stretching almost one kilometre out to sea. The Another Place figures - each one weighing 650 kilos - are made from casts of the artist's own body standing on the beach, all of them looking out to sea, staring at the horizon in silent expectation. Mersey Ferry - There's no better way to experience Liverpool and Merseyside than from the deck of the world famous Mersey Ferry listening to the commentary.
    [Show full text]
  • First Steps Enterprise Limited & Fazakerley, Croxteth, Stoneycroft
    First Steps Enterprise Limited & Fazakerley, Croxteth, Stoneycroft & Knotty Ash Children’s Centre Job Title: Activities Worker Number: 2 positions Pay: £9 per hour/16 hours per week Initially fixed term until 31st March 2020 Aims of Post • To support and deliver family & child activities (such as Rhyme Time, Stay and Play, Messy Play, Baby massage, baby weighing, physical activity sessions, Early Years Workshops, Early Support and others), which provide childcare, education, health and family support • To work as part of the centre team to deliver high quality early years services for children and families Responsible to: • Day-to-day – Centre Manager • Employer – First Steps Enterprise Managing Director Responsible for: N/a Main Responsibilities • To work as part of the children’s centre team to deliver family & child activities and creches, which provide childcare, education, health and family support • To fully support the delivery within the Early Years Foundation Stage framework and be able to deliver continuous provision • To maintain appropriate records and evaluation of sessions promoting EYFS development. • To assist in the setting up and clearing of rooms for activities, including preparing snack and creating and updating wall displays. • To work as part of the centre team to ensure a welcoming and friendly environment for children and families at all times. • To support communication and language development for children in the centre’s reach area which may require further intervention. • To provide regular feedback to parents
    [Show full text]
  • LIVERPOOL INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES March 2018
    LIVERPOOL INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES March 2018 Liverpool has an exciting future with £14 billion worth of investment in the pipeline. Come and join in. Liverpool – world renowned waterfront city – is currently attracting more investment happening than at any previous time in its history. Development activity is running at over £1 billion each year, in a city that has a worldwide reputation for excellence. We’re building a city with aspirations to become the most business-friendly location in the UK. We are excelling in key industries such as digital and creative. We have one of the UK’s most significant clusters of bio-sciences and a growing logistics industry located right next to the country’s newest deep water freight container terminal. We have a leisure and culture offer that not only draws in visitors from our own region but also nationally and from all over the globe. With a pipeline of £14 billion worth of schemes, there are several opportunities for investors to become involved, and for future end users to influence the type of buildings they want. This brief guide highlights some of the major schemes being led by Liverpool City Council that are happening right now or are planned, and for which investors are being sought. For more information about these and other opportunities we can help you with, please visit our website www.regeneratingliverpool.com Opportunities – Schemes seeking partners Liverpool Waters Ten Streets LOCATION: Liverpool waterfront, LOCATION: Kirkdale, North Liverpool Liverpool City Centre TOTAL SITE AREA:
    [Show full text]
  • Liverpool District Local Integrated Risk Management Plan 2010/2011
    APPENDIX B (CFO/057/10) Liverpool District Local Integrated Risk Management Plan 2010/2011 Contents 1. Foreword 2. Our Purpose, Aims and Core Values 3. Introduction 4. Liverpool’s Story of Place 5. Our Plans to Reduce Risk and to Address Local Priorities in Liverpool • Liverpool Community Gyms • Liverpool East Community Garden • Street Based Teams • Liverpool South Speke Community Gardens • Neighbourhood Firefighters • TAG Rugby • Healthy Watch • Generic Action Point - Fitness and Health • Generic Action Point – Corporate Social Responsibility • Generic Action Point - Carbon Footprint • Generic Action Point – Equality and Diversity 6. Conclusion 7. Appendix A Merseyside Fire & Rescue Service Local Performance Indicators. 8. Appendix B Liverpool Local Area Priority National Indicators 9. Appendix C Merseyside Fire & Rescue Service Liverpool District Management Structure. Contact Information Liverpool Management Team Position Name Email Contact District Manager Dave Mottram [email protected] 0151 296 4714 District Manager Richard Davis [email protected] 0151 296 4622 NM East Kevin Johnson NM South Ken Ross NM SouthCentral Sara Lawton NM North+City Paul Murphy NM Alt Valley Kevin Firth Liverpool 1st Rob Taylor Liverpool Fire Stations Station Address Contact 10 – Kirkdale Studholme Street, Liverpool, L20 8EQ 0151 296 5375 11 – City Centre St Anne Street, Liverpool, L3 3DS 0151 296 6250 12 – Low Hill West Derby Road, Liverpool, L6 2AE 0151 296 5415 13 – Allerton Mather Avenue, Allerton, Liverpool, L18 6HE 0151 296
    [Show full text]
  • Liverpool Historic Settlement Study
    Liverpool Historic Settlement Study Merseyside Historic Characterisation Project December 2011 Merseyside Historic Characterisation Project Museum of Liverpool Pier Head Liverpool L3 1DG © Trustees of National Museums Liverpool and English Heritage 2011 Contents Introduction to Historic Settlement Study..................................................................1 Aigburth....................................................................................................................4 Allerton.....................................................................................................................7 Anfield.................................................................................................................... 10 Broadgreen ............................................................................................................ 12 Childwall................................................................................................................. 14 Clubmoor ............................................................................................................... 16 Croxteth Park ......................................................................................................... 18 Dovecot.................................................................................................................. 20 Everton................................................................................................................... 22 Fairfield .................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 102 Bus Time Schedule & Line Route
    102 bus time schedule & line map 102 Fazakerley - Broadgreen View In Website Mode The 102 bus line (Fazakerley - Broadgreen) has 3 routes. For regular weekdays, their operation hours are: (1) Broadgreen: 5:05 PM - 11:05 PM (2) Fazakerley: 7:00 AM - 11:35 PM (3) Woolfall Heath: 7:05 AM - 4:05 PM Use the Moovit App to ƒnd the closest 102 bus station near you and ƒnd out when is the next 102 bus arriving. Direction: Broadgreen 102 bus Time Schedule 54 stops Broadgreen Route Timetable: VIEW LINE SCHEDULE Sunday 7:06 AM - 11:05 PM Monday 5:05 PM - 11:05 PM Sefton Road, Fazakerley Tuesday 5:05 PM - 11:05 PM Lower Lane, Fazakerley Wednesday 5:05 PM - 11:05 PM Aintree Hospital, Fazakerley Thursday 5:05 PM - 11:05 PM Police Station, Gillmoss Friday 5:05 PM - 11:05 PM Long Lane, Walton Saturday 5:05 PM - 11:05 PM East Lancashire Road, Norris Green West Derby Cemetery, Norris Green 102 bus Info Oakgate Close, Dog And Gun Direction: Broadgreen Stops: 54 Trip Duration: 27 min Worrow Road, Dog And Gun Line Summary: Sefton Road, Fazakerley, Lower Oakgate Close, Liverpool Lane, Fazakerley, Aintree Hospital, Fazakerley, Police Station, Gillmoss, Long Lane, Walton, East Waterstone Close, Dog And Gun Lancashire Road, Norris Green, West Derby Porchƒeld Close, Liverpool Cemetery, Norris Green, Oakgate Close, Dog And Gun, Worrow Road, Dog And Gun, Waterstone Close, Mansion Drive, Croxteth Dog And Gun, Mansion Drive, Croxteth, Stonedale Crescent, Croxteth, Stonedale Cresent, Croxteth, Stonedale Crescent, Croxteth Stonebridge Lane, Croxteth, Stonebridge Lane,
    [Show full text]
  • Liverpool District Local Integrated Risk Management Plan 2011/2012
    Liverpool District Local Integrated Risk Management Plan 2011/2012 2 Contents 1. Foreword 2. Our Purpose, Aims and Core Values 3. Introduction 4. Liverpool’s Story of Place 5. Our Plans to Reduce Risk and to Address Local Priorities in Liverpool 6. Conclusion 7. Appendix C Merseyside Fire & Rescue Service Liverpool District Management Structure. 3 Contact Information Liverpool Management Team Position Name Email Contact District Manager Allan Harris [email protected] 0151 296 4711 District Manager Richard Davis [email protected] 0151 296 4622 NM East/Alt Valley Kevin Johnson [email protected] 07837476441 NM South Mark Thomas [email protected] 07801273137 NM South Central Sara Lawton [email protected] 07837475768 NM North+ City Paul Hitchin [email protected] 07970566857 Liverpool 1st Rob Taylor [email protected] 07837655539 District Manager Allan Harris [email protected] 0151 296 4711 Liverpool Fire Stations Station Address Contact 10 – Kirkdale Studholme Street, Liverpool, L20 8EQ 0151 296 5375 11 – City Centre St Anne Street, Liverpool, L3 3DS 0151 296 6250 12 – Kensington Beech Street, Liverpool, L7 0EU 0151 296 5415 13 – Allerton Mather Avenue, Allerton, Liverpool, L18 6HE 0151 296 5865 14 – Speke/Garston Cartwright’s Farm Road, Speke, Liverpool, L24 1UY 0151 296 6750 15 – Toxteth High Park Street, Liverpool, L8 8DX 0151 296 5835 16 – Old Swan 628 Queens Drive, Old Swan, Liverpool, L13 5UD 0151 296 5725 17 – Belle Vale Childwall Valley Road, Belle Vale, Liverpool, L25 2PY 0151 296 6600 18 – Aintree Longmoor Lane, Aintree, Liverpool, L9 0EN 0151 296 5695 19 – Croxteth Storrington Avenue, Croxteth, Liverpool, L11 9AP 0151 296 5595 Stations Overlapping Into Liverpool Station Address Contact 40 – Huyton Huyton Lane, Huyton, Liverpool, L36 7XG 0151 296 5445 42 - Kirkby Webster Drive, Kirkby, L32 8SJ 0151 296 5505 4 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Network Profile Croxteth & Norris Green November 2019
    Network Profile Croxteth & Norris Green November 2019 1 | Page READER INFORMATION Title Network Profile – Croxteth & Norris Green Team Liverpool CCG Business Intelligence Team; Liverpool City Council Intelligence & Data Analytics Team Author(s) Sophie Kelly, AnnMarie Daley, Danielle Wilson, Karen Jones Contributor(s) Liverpool City Council Social Services Analysis Team; Liverpool Community Health Analysis Team Reviewer(s) Network Clinical Leads; Locality Clinical Leads; Liverpol CCG Primary Care Team; Liverpool CCG Business Intelligence Team: Liverpool City Council Public Health Team; Mersey Care Community Health Intelligence and Public Health Teams Circulated to Network Clinical and Managerial Leads; Liverpool GP Bulletin; Liverpool CCG employees including Primary Care Team and Programme Managers; Adult Social Services (LCC); Public Health (LCC); Mersey Care, Provider Alliance Version 1.0 Status Final Date of release November 2019 Review date Annual update Purpose The packs are intended for Primary Care Networks to use to understand the needs of the populations they serve. They will support networks in understanding health inequalities that may exist for their population and subsequently how they may want to configure services around patients. Description This series of reports contains Population Segmentation intelligence about each of the 14 Primary Care Network Units in Liverpool. The information benchmarks each network against its peers so they can understand the relative need, management and service utilisation of people in their area. The pack contains information on wider determinants of health, health, social care and community services. Reference JSNA Documents The Joint Strategic Needs Assessment (JSNA) identifies the key issues affecting the health and wellbeing of local people, both now and in the future.
    [Show full text]
  • Strategic Green and Open Spaces Review Board
    Strategic Green and Open Spaces Review Board Final Report 2016 A city becomes magnificent when the spaces between the buildings equal the architecture they frame Contents Mayoral Preface .................................................................................................................................................................. 6 Chair’s Note ........................................................................................................................................................................ 8 1. The Strategic Green and Open Spaces Review Board ............................................................................................... 9 Board Members .................................................................................................................................................................................. 9 2. Overview and Introduction .......................................................................................................................................... 13 Background and Context ................................................................................................................................................................. 13 Time of Austerity .............................................................................................................................................................................. 13 The Review ......................................................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Lancashire Countryside Directory for People with Disabilities
    Lancashire Countryside Directory for People with Disabilities Second edition Whatever your needs, access to and enjoyment of the countryside is rewarding, healthy and great fun. This directory can help you find out what opportunities are available to you in your area. Get yourself outdoors and enjoy all the benefits that come with it… Foreword written by: Bill Oddie OBE This directory was designed for people with a disability, though the information included will be useful to everyone. Lancashire’s countryside has much to offer; from the gritstone fells of the Forest of Bowland to the sand dunes of the Sefton Coast. There are some great opportunities to view wildlife too, including red squirrels and marsh harriers. It is more than worth taking that first step and getting yourself involved in your local countryside, regardless of your abilities. For people interested in wildlife and conservation there is much that can be done from home or a local accessible area. Whatever your chosen form of countryside recreation, whether it’s joining a group, doing voluntary work, or getting yourself out into the countryside on your own, we hope you will get as much out of it as we do. There is still some way to go before we have a properly accessible countryside. By contacting Open Country or another of the organisations listed here, you can help us to encourage better access for all in the future. This Second Edition published Summer 2019 Copyright © Open Country 2019 There are some things that some disabilities make “ more difficult. The countryside and wildlife should not be among them.
    [Show full text]
  • Enquiries To: Information Team Our Ref: FOI 678107 Request-563551
    Enquiries to: Information Team Our Ref: FOI 678107 [email protected] Dear Ms Mullen Freedom of Information Request 678107 Thank you for your recent request received 22 March 2019. Your request was actioned under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 in which you requested the following information – In numerous Council meetings/media reports etc, Mayor Anderson has stated that he has created '67 acres of new green space'......he made it very clear that this was NOT refurbished green space or 'Meanwhile' green space....but permanent new green space [1] Please clearly indicate the location of each of these new green spaces [2] Please indicate when each one was created and the acreage of each one Response: Liverpool City Council would advise that a detailed report on this matter was submitted to the then Neighbourhood Services Select Committee at its meeting of 24 February 2015. A copy of the report and accompanying appendices is attached with this letter. We would advise that this report was and remains fully in the public domain and in accordance with the application of Section 21 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA), that this can be reasonably accessed via the following weblink – http://councillors.liverpool.gov.uk/ieListDocuments.aspx?CId=1432&MId=14489 The sites included in the report were incredibly diverse and as such were the result of a mix of different circumstances; there are some sites which were highlighted as development space in previous regeneration activity and were still deemed to be potential development sites. In this circumstance the improvement was described as a meanwhile use and a temporary improvement until such time the site was developed.
    [Show full text]