Distribution of Rational Points on Algebraic Varieties
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Distribution of rational points on algebraic varieties by Sho Tanimoto A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Mathematics New York University May 2012 Professor Yuri Tschinkel To my wife, Mei. iii Acknowledgements First and foremost it is my pleasure to thank my advisor Yuri Tschinkel for his pa- tience and guidance throughout my Ph.D.. He has influenced my development from an ordinary math student to a professional researcher in mathematics. I learned from him, his patience, work ethic, creativity, and broad outlook in mathematics, and these have shaped me as a professional mathematician. I would also like to thank my second advisor Fedor Bogomolov. His passion, intuition, creativity, and the view of mathematics have inspired me in my research. His generosity has supported my study and life, and without it, I would not have completed this dissertation. I would like to thank Sylvain Cappell for his warmest support which he has given me since I was a first year student at Courant. Brendan Hassett is a great inspiration for my research, and I also benefited from conversations and discus- sions with Benjamin Bakker, David Harvey, Sonal Jain, Ilya Karzhemanov, Brian Lehmann, and Tony Varilly. Many thanks to my fellow students in our algebraic geometry and number theory group, Michael Burr, Edgar Costa, Lukas Koehler, Fedor Soloviev, Jordan Thomas, and Pankaj Vishe, for their insights, questions, help, and friendship. In particular, Michael and Jordan helped me to improve the exposition of this thesis, and Lukas did a fantastic job to activate our algebraic geometry seminar. I would also like to thank friends with whom I shared time as a graduate student at Courant, especially Andrea, Chaitu, Dingyu, Felix, Hantaek, Ivan, Jong Ho, Jungwoon, Kela, Nengli, Shoshana, and Sukbin. I owe a special debt of gratitude to Tamar Arnon for her warmest support throughout my Ph.D.. Going back to Japan, I would like to thank my teachers at my college, Takao iv Fujita, Shihoko Ishii, and Nobushige Kurokawa for their support and encourage- ment. I learned a great deal of algebraic geometry from my advisor Takao Fujita when I was an undergraduate student at Tokyo Institute of Technology. Ryoichi Aoki, my physics teacher at my high school, is one who let me consider a career path in academia. He always kept his door open for me, and he shared time with me to discuss my questions in physics. Finally, I thank my family: my parents, Shin and Mariko, my brother Ryo, and our lovely cats, Chao and Mie have supported me via skype for the last five years and provided me an ideal atmosphere when I was in Japan. And my wife Mei, for me, she is everything. She has supported and encouraged me all the time with her love via skype, phone, and shipments, and without her support, I could not have achieved any accomplishment which today I have. I thank her with all my love, and I wish the best luck for our continuing journey. v Abstract We study the asymptotic formulas for the number of rational points of bounded height on equivariant compactifications of solvable linear algebraic groups over a number field, and we introduce the notion of balanced line bundles. In the first part, we discuss Height zeta functions of equivariant compactifica- tions of solvable linear algebraic groups and show that the main term of a Height zeta function coincides with the prediction of Manin's conjecture by using geomet- ric integration techniques developed by Chambert-Loir and Tschinkel. Then we study Height zeta functions of equivariant compactifications of the ax + b-group and prove Manin's conjecture under some mild geometric conditions. In the second part, we introduce the notion of balanced line bundles and give a systematic study of this notion in terms of birational geometry. We identify balanced big line bundles for many cases, e.g., del Pezzo surfaces, Fano 3-folds of Picard rank one, flag varieties, toric varieties, and equivariant compactifications of homogeneous spaces. The last result has important arithmetic applications in [CLT02] and [GTBT11]. vi Contents Dedication . iii Acknowledgements . iv Abstract . vi Introduction . 1 I Height zeta functions 8 1 Height functions 9 1.1 Metrics and Heights . 9 1.2 Measures . 16 2 Manin's conjecture and Height zeta functions 22 2.1 Manin's conjecture . 23 2.2 Height zeta functions . 30 3 Height zeta functions of equivariant compactifications of semi- direct products of algebraic groups 37 3.1 Geometry of equivariant compactifications . 38 3.2 The main terms of Height zeta functions of equivariant compactifi- cations of solvable algebraic groups . 46 vii 3.3 Height zeta functions of equivariant compactifications of the ax + b- group . 64 II Balanced line bundles 99 4 Balanced line bundles 100 4.1 Generalities . 100 4.2 Balanced line bundles . 112 5 Fano varieties 115 5.1 Del Pezzo surfaces . 115 5.2 Del Pezzo surface fibrations . 120 5.3 Fano threefolds . 122 6 Equivariant geometry 125 6.1 Generalized flag varieties . 125 6.2 Equivariant compactifications of homogeneous spaces . 129 6.3 Toric varieties . 137 Bibliography 146 viii Introduction One of the classical problems in mathematics is to study integral or rational solutions to Diophantine equations, i.e., integral or rational solutions to polynomial equations with integer coefficients. The most famous Diophantine equations are the Fermat equations : xn + yn = zn; where n is a positive integer. There are many traditional questions concerning Diophantine equations, which include: 1. (Existence) Do integral or rational solutions exist? 2. (Finiteness) If solutions exist, are there finitely or infinitely many? 3. (Distribution) If there are infinitely many solutions, how are they distributed? For example, one could determine their density in various topologies or asymptotic formulae for the counting functions of solutions with respect to appropriate size functions. 4. (Construction) Construct some or all solutions effectively. The solutions to each of these problems have lead to intensive and long studies, and they are still active areas in modern mathematics. Although there are many elementary and ad hoc approaches to these questions, modern research in this field focuses on intrinsic properties of Diophantine equations, e.g., their geometry. 1 Diophantine geometry Note that answers to the above questions are stable under changes of coordi- nates. Perhaps this is the first observation to support the philosophy that \Geom- etry determines Arithmetic", appearing in [HS00]. The subject which studies the phenomena realizing this philosophy is called Diophantine geometry, and is one of main topics in current mathematics. One of the most important invariants in Diophantine geometry is the canonical line bundle KX of a smooth projective variety X, and we believe that this geometric invariant roughly determines the behavior of the distribution of rational points, at least after taking a finite extension. To illustrate this idea, consider the case of curves: Let F be a number field and C a smooth projective curve defined over F . The behavior of the distribution of rational points is determined by one geometric invariant, the genus g of C: • When g = 0, −KC is ample and C(F ) is either empty or infinite; • When g = 1, KC is trivial and C(F ) is either empty or a finitely generated abelian group. C(F ) is infinite if and only if the Mordell-Weil rank, the rank of C(F ), is positive. • When g ≥ 2, KC is ample and C(F ) is finite. (Mordell-Faltings theorem) In particular, after taking a finite extension of F , C(F ) is infinite when −KX is ample or trivial. Based on this evidence, we believe in the following principle which is the most important guiding principle in Diophantine geometry: The positivity of the canonical line bundle (or the anticanonical line bundle) determines the distribution of rational points on X. 2 We hope that the principle applies to higher dimensional cases as well, and thus we consider the following classification of smooth projective varieties: n • (Fano-type): −KX is ample, e.g., P , del Pezzo surfaces, and Fano manifolds; • (Intermediate type): KX is trivial, e.g., abelian varieties and K3 surfaces; • (General type): KX is ample, e.g., projective manifolds of general type. My research interest lies in Fano and intermediate type varieties which are expected to have infinitely many rational points, at least after taking a finite extension. More precisely, I am interested in the distribution of rational points on these varieties. Distribution of rational points There are many problems involving the distribution of rational points on al- gebraic varieties, but here we would like to mention two problems: Let X be a smooth projective variety defined over a number field F . One can ask the following two questions: • (Potential density): Is X(F ) dense in the Zariski topology, possibly after taking a finite extension of F ? • (Asymptotic formulae): Let L = (L; k · k) be a big, adelically metrized line bundle on X and HL the associated height (see Definitions 4 and 6 in Subsection 1.1.2). What is the asymptotic formula of the counting function of rational points of bounded height? In other words, determine ◦ ◦ N(X ; L; B) := #fx 2 X (F ) j HL(x) 6 Bg ∼ ??? as B ! 1, for a suitable Zariski open subset X◦. 3 The answer to the potential density problem is believed to be affirmative for Fano and Intermediate type varieties. It is possible that X(F ) is empty due to the arithmetic obstructions, e.g., the Hasse principle and the Brauer-Manin obstruc- tions (see, for example, [Man86]). To focus on the effect of geometry, it is essential to allow one to take a finite extension.