What Comes After LIBOR?

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

What Comes After LIBOR? What Comes After LIBOR? Annual Premier Client Kathie Brandt, Partner, Thompson Hine LLP Summit Today’s Objectives • Understanding the LIBOR problem and how we got here • Discussing transition challenges • Planning for the future • Staying awake for the entire presentation Annual Premier Client Summit 2 Understanding the LIBOR Problem & How We Got Here • Setting the context • History of LIBOR Annual Premier Client Summit Understanding the LIBOR Problem & How We Got Here • What is LIBOR and how is it derived? – London Interbank Offered Rate – how much would a bank believe they would have to pay another bank to borrow unsecured funds on the London interbank funding market (remember “match funding”?) – First appeared in 1970s; gained traction in 1980s when “prime rate” reached 21.50% – LIBOR rates now published every day in five currencies (USD, British pound sterling, euro, Japanese yen and Swiss franc) and for seven different interest periods ranging from overnight to one year Annual Premier Client Summit Understanding the LIBOR Problem & How We Got Here • History of LIBOR – Scandal • Financial crisis in 2008 resulted in investigations of LIBOR and financial institutions • Collusion (not with Russia this time) • 20 major banks subjects of criminal and civil investigations, billions of dollars of fines and penalties assessed and jail time Annual Premier Client Summit Understanding the LIBOR Problem & How We Got Here • History of LIBOR (cont.) – Announcement by Financial Conduct Authority • 2017: FCA’s CEO questions sustainability of LIBOR as a benchmark • FCA announces that after 2021 it will no longer compel panel banks to submit rates to enable the calculation of LIBOR • Y2K or “black swan” event? Annual Premier Client Summit Understanding the LIBOR Problem & How We Got Here • History of LIBOR (cont.) – Why is LIBOR going away an issue? • $200 trillion in outstanding transactions reference USD LIBOR (95% derivatives, 5% commercial and consumer loans) • Current daily transaction volume underlying LIBOR is around $500 million, based on “expert” judgments instead of actual transaction data Annual Premier Client Summit Understanding the LIBOR Problem & How We Got Here Asset Classes Affected1 Annual Premier Client Summit Understanding the LIBOR Problem & How We Got Here • LIBOR is not the only rate going away – EURIBOR – EONIA (Euro Overnight Index Average) – TOIS (Tomorrow/Next Overnight Indexed Swaps) – TIBOR (Tokyo Interbank Offered Rate) – CORRA (Canadian Overnight Repo Rate Average) – BUT, so far, CDOR (Canadian Dollar Offer Rate) is safe Annual Premier Client Summit Understanding the LIBOR Problem & How We Got Here • Actions to date – Regulatory bodies worldwide have been setting up working groups to come up with risk free, alternative reference rates (RFRs) – US – Federal Reserve convenes the Alternative Reference Rates Committee (ARRC) • Public/private working group • 27 firms and 10 government agencies • Mission: identify best practices for alternative reference rates, develop an adoption plan, and create an implementation plan with metrics of success and a timeline • October 2017 – ARRC announces Paced Transition Plan, which established a process and timeline • ARRC establishes SOFR (Secured Overnight Financing Rate) as US alternative to LIBOR Annual Premier Client Summit Understanding the LIBOR Problem & How We Got Here Other Relevant IBOR Replacement Rate Replacement SONIA GBP LIBOR Rates (Sterling Overnight Index Average) SARON CHF LIBOR (Swiss Average Rate Overnight) TONAR JPY LIBOR (Tokyo Overnight Average Rate) ESTER (Euro Short-Term Rate) Euro LIBOR/EURIBOR GS Pooling Deferred Rate RepoFunds Rate Annual Premier Client Summit Transition Challenges • Global coordination required – Different products and currencies – Derivatives linked to loan facilities • LIBOR is forward looking term rate • Proposed RFRs for different currencies calculated on different basis from each other (ex. SONIA vs SOFR) • Proposed RFRs likely to come online at different times • LIBOR factors in a credit risk and proposed RFRs do not Annual Premier Client Summit Transition Challenges • Template documentation cannot be prepared until an alternate rate gains market acceptance • Fallback provisions in existing documents meant to cover short-term disruptions in LIBOR, not discontinuation • Obtaining requisite consent for amendments to existing documentation (significant time and cost implications) • Significant changes to infrastructure and systems of market participants will be required • Transition may result in accounting and tax issues • Hedging could be less effective if transition of underlying obligation to an alternative rate does not occur at the same time as the related hedge Annual Premier Client Summit Transition Challenges SOFR (Secured Overnight Financing Rate) • How calculated – Measures the cost of borrowing cash overnight collateralized by US Treasury securities – Has been published since April 2018 – Fed publishes SOFR on its website each day at approximately 8:00 a.m. Annual Premier Client Summit Transition Challenges SOFR (Secured Overnight Financing Rate) • Issues/comparisons to LIBOR – Overnight rate (to begin) – Over $700 billion of daily trades – New and not well understood – Not easily manipulated – Secured – Not in contracts broadly yet – Risk-free rate – Liquid and deep – Will not widen in periods of credit stress Annual Premier Client Summit Transition Challenges SOFR (Secured Overnight Financing Rate) • Comparison to LIBOR – SOFR should be lower, but spread differential isn’t stable • Four components to loan fallback language – Trigger – Reference rate – Spread adjustment – Amendment process Annual Premier Client Summit Transition Challenges • Two approaches proposed by ARRC Amendment “Hard-Wired” Approach Approach • Pros and cons • Market data – what are lenders and borrowers doing now? Annual Premier Client Summit Future Planning • What should be done in existing facility agreements? Review agreements to check: – Fallbacks that apply if the relevant IBOR ceases to exist Annual Premier Client Summit Future Planning • Procedure for amending agreement to change the interest rate provisions – Level of lender consent required? – Consents of other creditors required (intercreditor agreements)? – What are the trigger events for the determination of a replacement rate? – Who selects the replacement rate? – Any safeguards on selecting the replacement rate (prevailing market convention, rate widely accepted in relevant loan market)? – Are all necessary changes included in fallback language (adjustment of margins if appropriate)? • Having completed review – should you amend now? Annual Premier Client Summit Future Planning • What should be done in new facility agreements? Consider the following: Does an adjustment How to make it as easy as spread need to be added What are (should be) possible to transition to a to the replacement rate to the triggers for applying new rate even if the new make it economically the new rate? rate is not yet specified? comparable to LIBOR being replaced? What is the prevailing What are appropriate market convention in What is the prevailing fallbacks for the documentation regarding replacement rate(s)? replacement rate? transitioning to a new rate? Annual Premier Client Summit Q&A • Questions? • Anyone still awake? Annual Premier Client Summit What Comes After LIBOR? Annual Premier Client Kathie Brandt, Partner, Thompson Hine LLP Summit.
Recommended publications
  • The Search for a Libor Replacement
    THE INTERNATIONAL DEBT CAPITAL MARKETS HANDBOOK 2020 23rd Edition The Great Transition: The search for a libor replacement by Esohe Denise Odaro, International Finance Corporation No one knew it at the time, but in 1969 Minos Zombanakis was soon to make history. That winter, the Greek financier had convened a group of banks in Manufacturers Hanover's newly minted London office. His intention? To formalise the first syndicated loan of its kind to fund an US$80m loan to Iran. Given the immense scale of the loan at that time, Zombanakis aimed to reduce lender risk and increase appetite among candidate banks by apportioning the credit across several lenders, thereby generating a syndicated loan. 38 At the time, interest rates in the UK were 8% and rising, so instruments and asset classes. From the early 1980s most banks were reluctant to lend at a fixed rate for an onwards, The British Bankers' Association (BBA) extended duration. Consequently, Zombanakis devised a administered the LIBOR rate-setting process. By 2005, the system whereby the borrower – in this case, Iran – could be BBA would survey a panel of 16 banks daily, and LIBOR was charged a variable interest rate. He proposed that the calculated using only the average of the median eight pricing should be based on the syndicate's weighted quotes. The BBA produced 150 LIBOR benchmarks in 10 average cost of funding plus a spread for a predetermined currencies with 15 maturities (overnight to 12 months). period. To achieve this, the banks in the lending syndicate Historically, only a few voiced apprehensions about the would report their funding costs before the loan's "rolling structural weaknesses of the LIBOR setting process.
    [Show full text]
  • Interbank Offered Rates (Ibors) and Alternative Reference Rates (Arrs)
    VERSION: 24 SEPTEMBER 2020 Interbank Offered Rates (IBORs) and Alternative Reference Rates (ARRs) The following table has been compiled on the basis of publicly available information. Whilst reasonable care has been taken to ensure that the information in the table is accurate as at the date that the table was last revised, no warranty or representation is given as to the information in the table. The information in the table is a summary, is not exhaustive and is subject to change. Key Multiple-rate approach (IBOR + RFR) Moving to RFR only IBOR only Basis on Development of Expected/ Expected fall which forward-looking likely fall- back rate to IBOR is Expected ARR? back rate to the ARR (if 3 Expected being Date from date by the IBOR2 applicable) discontinu continued which which ation date (if Alternative ARR will replaceme for IBOR applicable Reference be nt of IBOR Currency IBOR (if any) )1 Rate published is needed ARS BAIBAR TBC TBC TBC TBC TBC TBC TBC (Argentina) 1 Information in this column is taken from Financial Stability Board “Reforming major interest rate benchmarks” progress reports and other publicly available English language sources. 2 This column sets out current expectations based on publicly available information but in many cases no formal decisions have been taken or announcements made. This column will be revisited and revised following publication of the ISDA 2020 IBOR Fallbacks Protocol. References in this column to a rate being “Adjusted” are to such rate with adjustments being made (i) to reflect the fact that the applicable ARR may be an overnight rate while the IBOR rate will be a term rate and (ii) to add a spread.
    [Show full text]
  • LIBOR Transition - Frequently Asked Questions
    LIBOR Transition - Frequently Asked Questions Published: 9 January 2019 This document is a summary of the questions submitted during or following the webinar on LIBOR transition recorded on 6 December 2018 and which can be accessed at: https://www.treasurers.org/webinars/LIBORtransition In addition to the responses below, ‘What you need to know about LIBOR transition’ produced by the Working Group on Sterling Risk-Free Reference Rates; The Treasurer’s Checklist and materials on https://www.treasurers.org/liborreform are helpful resources. 1. Selection of Risk Free Rates by currency > What does SONIA stand for? > Is LIBOR cessation only for GBP? > Has a USD LIBOR alternative been selected yet? This announcement impacts all 5 LIBOR currencies: USD, GBP, JPY, EUR, CHF. Other countries are also considering changing their term benchmarks for similar reasons (e.g. BBSW in Australia). The alternative RFR (near Risk Free Rates) benchmarks that have been identified are: US: SOFR Secured Overnight Funding Rate EURO: ESTER European Short-Term Euro Rate Japan: TONAR Tokyo Overnight Average Rate Switzerland: SARON Swiss Average Rate Overnight UK: SONIA Sterling Overnight Index Average > When is the SOFR reference rate expected to be ready? > You mentioned H2-19 for the UK, what is the expected timeframe for the US SOFR benchmark? The ARRC (US working group)’s timetable and key milestones are here: https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/Microsites/arrc/files/2018/ARRC-Progress-Timeline-Oct- 30.pdf More details and historic data are available at https://apps.newyorkfed.org/markets/autorates/sofr. > What does ESTER relate to? i.e. what currencies would this apply to? It relates to EUR denominated transactions.
    [Show full text]
  • Libor's Long Goodbye
    LIBOR’S LONG GOODBYE Readiness for LIBOR transition TRANSACTIONAL POWERHOUSE 1 CASE0155238_Report_Print Ready.indd 1 21/07/2020 12:06:23 Introduction As has been noted in a continuous drumbeat of warnings from major global, regional and local regulatory bodies, LIBOR is expected to go away at the end of 2021, when the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has announced it will withdraw support for the rate. This deadline was first announced This report also includes a matrix written, in each case that mature in a speech by Andrew Bailey, chief showing an assessment of readiness after 2021. The official sector executive of the FCA, in July 2017. for transition by currency and product of regulators and central banks Since more than half of the roughly type. As we’ve noted previously, continues to stress the need to four-and-a-half-year-period that that LIBOR transition is at different develop robust alternative reference speech gave until the deadline has stages of progress in different rates and robust contractual fallbacks now elapsed, it is perhaps fitting to jurisdictions and with respect to in the event that LIBOR were to consider how far markets have come different financial products. cease or become unrepresentative in LIBOR transition, and how much of underlying financial reality, and to further they need to go. LIBOR transition remains a transition to such alternative rates. fundamental issue confronting Despite the uncertainty that exists, the This report assesses the state of financial markets. To date, transition FCA has stated firmly that the end-2021 readiness for transition from LIBOR has been slower than regulators deadline remains in effect, a statement (and other interbank offered rates would like, and considerable it reiterated on 25 March 2020 in (IBORs)) to alternative interest rates uncertainty still exists (and may response to the Covid-19 pandemic.
    [Show full text]
  • APAC IBOR Transition Benchmarking Study
    R E P O R T APAC IBOR Transition Benchmarking Study. July 2020 Banking & Finance. 0 0 sia-partners.com 0 0 Content 6 • Executive summary 8 • Summary of APAC IBOR transitions 9 • APAC IBOR deep dives 10 Hong Kong 11 Singapore 13 Japan 15 Australia 16 New Zealand 17 Thailand 18 Philippines 19 Indonesia 20 Malaysia 21 South Korea 22 • Benchmarking study findings 23 • Planning the next 12 months 24 • How Sia Partners can help 0 0 Editorial team. Maximilien Bouchet Domitille Mozat Ernest Yuen Nikhilesh Pagrut Joyce Chan 0 0 Foreword. Financial benchmarks play a significant role in the global financial system. They are referenced in a multitude of financial contracts, from derivatives and securities to consumer and business loans. Many interest rate benchmarks such as the London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR) are calculated based on submissions from a panel of banks. However, since the global financial crisis in 2008, there was a notable decline in the liquidity of the unsecured money markets combined with incidents of benchmark manipulation. In July 2013, IOSCO Principles for Financial Benchmarks have been published to improve their robustness and integrity. One year later, the Financial Stability Board Official Sector Steering Group released a report titled “Reforming Major Interest Rate Benchmarks”, recommending relevant authorities and market participants to develop and adopt appropriate alternative reference rates (ARRs), including risk- free rates (RFRs). In July 2017, the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), announced that by the end of 2021 the FCA would no longer compel panel banks to submit quotes for LIBOR. And in March 2020, in response to the Covid-19 outbreak, the FCA stressed that the assumption of an end of the LIBOR publication after 2021 has not changed.
    [Show full text]
  • SIFMA Insights: SOFR Primer
    Executive Summary SIFMA Insights: Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR) Primer The transition away from LIBOR July 2019 SIFMA Insights Page | 1 Executive Summary Contents Executive Summary ................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 The Transition Away from LIBOR ............................................................................................................................................................... 6 What is LIBOR? .......................................................................................................................................................................................... 6 Why Is LIBOR Important?........................................................................................................................................................................... 8 Why Transition to New Reference Rates, Away from LIBOR? ................................................................................................................... 9 Who Is Impacted by the Transition? ........................................................................................................................................................... 9 US Transition Plan ................................................................................................................................................................................... 11 Establishing the ARRC ............................................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • LIBOR Transition
    JUNE 2021 LIBOR Transition AT A GLANCE WHAT IS LIBOR? Following guidance from the Financial Stability Board (FSB), regulatory led public/private working groups Interbank Offered Rates (IBORs), commonly referred were established to identify and promote adoption to as the London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR), are of robust alternate risk free rates (ARFRs) that were systemically important interest rate benchmarks, aimed based on substantial underlying transactions to at providing an indication of the average rates at which replace the various LIBOR currency rates. Most RFRs banks can obtain unsecured funding from each other were created as a response to the end of LIBOR; while in various currencies. Various regulatory authorities SONIA, which was historically referenced on overnight have announced their support for a reduced reliance on transactions, was reformed. IBORs, with cessation dates starting at the end of 2021, detailed in Figure 1. LIBOR has often been used in the industry as an interest rate benchmark rate for various LIBOR VERSUS RFR financial products ranging from capital markets to lending products including mortgages. LIBOR RFR In addition to LIBOR cessation, other benchmarks Term Term rate An overnight rate such as EONIA (Euro Overnight Index Average) will be benchmark e.g. (with no existing ceasing publication on 3 January 2022 and there are 3M, 6M, 1Y term structure)1 a number of other benchmarks that reference LIBOR in their calculations, which will be reformed, including View Forward-looking Backward-looking SOR (Singapore Dollar Offer Rate) and THBFIX (Thai Baht Fix). Secured? Unsecured Some based on a secured overnight rate, others WHAT ARE RISK FREE RATES (RFRS)? unsecured RFRs are interest rate benchmarks that seek to Credit Risk Embedded credit Near to risk free, measure the overnight cost of borrowing cash by risk component as there is no bank banks, underpinned by actual transactions.
    [Show full text]
  • Life After Libor
    October 2019 TOPIC OF FOCUS: REGULATORY LIFE AFTER LIBOR On the Web: https://wam.gt/2BRKmQR LIBOR is one of the most important interest rates in the world, with fnancial products of about $200 trillion tied to its benchmark rate. But LIBOR is being phased out in 2021 and the transition to a new reference rate will be a major undertaking for fnancial institutions great and small. Here we provide a high-level overview of the situation based on the facts available today and provide guidance regarding the upcoming transition from and likely replacements to LIBOR. KEY TAKEAWAYS LIBOR is one of the world’s most widely used fnancial benchmarks for short-term interest rates and determines the rate for unsecured short-term borrowing between banks. LIBOR will be phased out at the end of 2021 and the transition to a new reference rate will be a major undertaking for many fnancial institutions. Due to the vast number of fnancial vehicles tied to LIBOR, it will be replaced by several diferent indices that will serve the same function going forward. Several working groups around the world have been researching their respective Thomas McMahon Product Specialist recommendations to replace LIBOR for their local markets. Western Asset is monitoring the situation closely, and providing this summary of the status of the LIBOR retirement to help investors and fnancial professionals best prepare for the transition ahead. © Western Asset Management Company, LLC 2019. This publication is the property of Western Asset Management Company and is intended for the sole use of its clients, consultants, and other intended recipients.
    [Show full text]
  • Yi Gang: the Development of Shibor As a Market Benchmark (Central
    Yi Gang: The development of Shibor as a market benchmark Speech by Mr Yi Gang, Deputy Governor of the People’s Bank of China, at the 2008 Shibor Work Conference, Beijing, 11 January 2008. * * * Thank you for your presence. Since its launch one year ago, Shibor has made remarkable progress. I’d like to share with you some of my observations. First, Shibor is for market participants. At the initial stage, central bank promotion is necessary. But Shibor, as a market benchmark, belongs to the market and all the market participants. All parties concerned including financial institutions, National Inter-bank Funding Center, National Association of Financial Market Institutional Investors shall have a full understanding of this, and actively play a role in the operations of Shibor as stakeholders. The success of Shibor relies on the joint efforts of all the stakeholders. Under the command economy, the central bank is the leader while commercial banks are followers. But from the current perspective of the central bank’s functions, the bipartite relationship varies on different occasions. In terms of monetary policies, the central bank, as the monetary authority, is the policy maker and regulator, while commercial banks are market participants and players. But in terms of market building, the relationship is not simply that of leader and followers, but of central bank and commercial banks in a market environment. This broad positioning and premise will have a direct bearing on how we behave. On the one hand, it requires the central bank to work as a service provider, a general designer and supervisor of the market.
    [Show full text]
  • Industrial and Commercial Bank of China Limited, Dubai (DIFC)
    OFFERING CIRCULAR INDUSTRIAL AND COMMERCIAL BANK OF CHINA LIMITED, ACTING THROUGH INDUSTRIAL AND COMMERCIAL BANK OF CHINA LIMITED, DUBAI (DIFC) BRANCH (a joint stock company incorporated in the People’s Republic of China with limited liability) US$8,000,000,000 Euro Medium Term Note Programme ____________________ Under this US$8,000,000,000 Euro Medium Term Note Programme (the Programme), Industrial and Commercial Bank of China Limited, acting through Industrial and Commercial Bank of China Limited, Dubai (DIFC) Branch (the Issuer), subject to compliance with all relevant laws, regulations and directives, may from time to time issue notes (the Notes) denominated in any currency agreed between it and the relevant Dealer (as defined below). Notes may be issued in bearer or registered form (respectively Bearer Notes and Registered Notes). The maximum aggregate nominal amount of all Notes from time to time outstanding under the Programme will not exceed US$8,000,000,000 (or its equivalent in other currencies calculated as described in the Programme Agreement described herein), subject to increase as described herein. The Notes may be issued on a continuing basis to one or more of the Dealers specified under “Overview of the Programme” and any additional Dealer appointed by the Issuer under the Programme from time to time (each a Dealer and together the Dealers), which appointment may be for a specific issue or on an ongoing basis. References in this Offering Circular to the relevant Dealer shall, in the case of an issue of Notes being (or intended to be) subscribed by more than one Dealer, be to all Dealers agreeing to subscribe such Notes.
    [Show full text]
  • IBOR Transition Update June 2021
    Issue 6 | June 2021 Die deutsche Übersetzung folgt dem englischen Text The Q2 2021 industry targets for LIBOR transition are rapidly approaching, Following Useful Resources the successful adoption of the 31st March 2021 targets, the market has now ceased Deutsche Bank IBOR initiation of new GBP LIBOR-linked loans, bonds, securitisations and linear Transition website derivatives* that expire after the end of 2021. Deutsche Bank IBOR videos: Q2 LIBOR transition targets - Introduction to LIBOR British pound transition — Cease initiation of new GBP LIBOR non-linear derivatives that expire after end- 2021*. - Challenges and Deutsche Bank’s approach — Cease initiation of new GBP LIBOR exchange-traded derivatives that expire after end-2021*. Industry newsletters — Progress active conversion of all legacy GBP LIBOR contracts expiring after end-2021 where viable. If not viable, then ensure robust fallbacks are adopted BoE RFR Newsletter – where possible. May 2021 NEW ARRC RFR Newsletter – *Except for risk management of existing positions (Sterling RFR WG Guidance). April/May 2021 NEW Swiss franc Get in Touch — Per FINMA guidelines all new Swiss franc contracts should use SARON-based benchmarks by 30th June 2021. Investment Bank, Corporate Bank and Capital Release Unit Japanese yen DWS — Cease issuance of new loans and bonds referencing JPY LIBOR that mature after the end of 2021. Private Bank U.S. dollar Social media — The Federal Reserve, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) and the Search Twitter and LinkedIn for Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) have encouraged banks to cease entering into new LIBOR contracts as soon as practicable, and in any event no #DeutscheBankIBORtranstion later than December 31, 2021, except under specific circumstances, (Read USD LIBOR usage exceptions) — The ARRC’s best practices are just that, and intended to support the Federal Reserve’s hard deadline of ceasing entering into new contracts that use USD LIBOR as a reference rate no later than 31st December 2021.
    [Show full text]
  • Our Preparation for the Reform of LIBOR Some Frequently Asked Questions
    Investment Professionals only Our preparation for the reform of LIBOR Some frequently asked questions March 2021 • Alternative rates have been identified to replace the London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR) and other IBORs as market standard benchmark interest rates as their publication comes to an end. • Sterling LIBOR is being replaced by SONIA, the Sterling Overnight Index Average. • M&G has a company-wide project team to orchestrate the transition from LIBOR and the other IBORs to the respective replacement rates. • Any effect on the value of your investments, at the time the change occurs, is expected to be minimal and we undertake not to introduce inferior terms to our clients as a consequence of this process. • You do not need to take any action. We will communicate to you any planned changes to objectives of funds you are invested in before they take effect. The value of investments will fluctuate, which will cause prices to fall as well as rise and you may not get back the original amount you invested. Where past performance is shown, please note that this is not a guide to future performance. GENERAL benchmark rates to be both administered by central banks and based on actual transactions in deep and liquid What is LIBOR and what is happening to it? markets. Introducing SONIA to replace LIBOR for sterling interest rates aims to achieve those objectives. LIBOR stands for the London Interbank Offered Rate and In the wake of the Global Financial Crisis over a decade is the interest rate (or more specifically, a family of ago, banks have been making less use of the interbank interest rates) at which banks lend to each other on a lending market.
    [Show full text]