Allerdale Borough Council Development Panel 2/2013/0494
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Allerdale Borough Council Development Panel 2/2013/0494 Reference No: 2/2013/0494 Received: 21 June 2013 Proposed Single wind turbine with maximum height to blade tip of 74m and Development: associated access track and electrical infrastructure Lo cation: Tarn Bank Winscales Workington Applicant: Mr Steven Palmer Drawing Numbers: Figure 2 - Detailed Location Plan Figure 3 - Site Layout Plan Figure 4 - Site Layout Plan Figure 5 - Wind Turbine Elevations Figure 6 - Typical Wind Turbine Foundation Figure 7 - Typical Access Track Construction Section Figure 8A - Block Plan A Figure 8B - Block Plan B Extended Phase 1 Habitat Survey Report SK/PR0073/D02. 8283-04-N-009 - Noise Assessment Policies: Allerdale Local Pla n, Adopted 1999 (Saved) Policy EN10 - Restoration, after uses cease Policy EN14 - Safeguarding Water Environment Policy EN19 - Landscape Protection Policy EN25 - Protecting the open countryside Policy EN32 - Protecting wildlife protected by law Policy EN35 - Creation of new wildlife habitats Policy EN5 - Pollution Control Policy EN6 - Location of potentially polluting development Policy EN9 - Contaminated/Derelict Land National Planning Policy Framework March 2012 (NPPF) Achieving sustainable development – paragraph 14 Chapter 10. Meeting the challenge of climate change, flooding and coastal change – paragraph 98 Chapter 11. Conserving and enhancing the natural environment Ministerial statement A ministerial statement by the Rt Hon Eric Pickles MP was issued on 6/6/2013. The statement regards the planning reforms to make the planning process more accessible to communities giving local people the opportunity to influence decisions that affect their lives. The statement makes specific and direct reference to on shore turbine development and the view that decisions are not always reflecting the locally-led planning system. It is stated that action is required to deliver the balance expected within the NPPF and to ensure that protecting the local environment is properly considered alongside the broader issues of protecting the global environment. In this respect new planning guidance sets out clearly that.. 1. The need for renewable energy does not automatically override environmental protections and the planning concerns of local communities. 2. Decisions should take into account the cumulative impact of wind turbines and properly reflect the increasing impact upon a) the landscape b) local amenity as the number of turbines in the area increases 3. Local topography should be a factor in assessing whether wind turbines have a damaging impact upon the landscape (i.e. recognise that the impact on predominantly flat landscapes can be as great or greater than on hilly or mountainous ones) 4. Great care should be taken to ensure heritage assets are conserved in a manner appropriate to their significance, including the impact of proposals on views important to their setting This statement and guidance is a material planning consideration and should be taken into account in assessing this application along with further detailed guidance published on 30 July 2013. Planning Practice Guidance for Renewable and Low Carbon Energy 30 July 2013 Cumbria Wind Energy Supplementary Planning Document July 2007 Relevant Planning 2/1997/0902 (11 turbines implemented) History: 2/2006/1321 (7 turbines implemented) 2/2013/0082 (Hunday Farm) Representations: Winscales Parish – No objections Great Clifton Parish Council – Objection (non-specific) Highway Authority – No objection subject to Construction Traffic Management Plan Environmental Protection – No objection subject to standard conditions. Coal Authority – No objections Natural England – No objections County Archaeologist – No objection NATS – Objection withdrawn following agreement for radar mitigation. Carlisle Airport (Stobart Air) – No objection Ministry of Defence – No objection CAA – No objection with standing advice referring to Ministry of Defence Arqiva – No objection Force – Objection regarding landscape and visual impact. The application has been advertised on site and adjoining landowners have been notified. One letter of objection and five letters of support have been received. Report Introduction The proposed site is on land adjacent to Tarn Bank, Winscales; the application seeks planning consent for the construction of a single wind turbine up to 74 metres in height to blade tip. The proposed development comprises the construction and operation of a single 80kW three bladed wind turbine on a 50 metre mast with a 48 metre rotor diameter. The turbine will add to the existing wind farm of 18 similar turbines and connected to the existing electrical infrastructure. Of note is a tandem application 2/2013/0495 for another turbine of the same specification 400 metres to the south west extending the same group of existing turbines. This is subject to a separate report for Members’ consideration. The turbine will add to the existing wind farm and continue the diversification of the farm business providing electricity to the National Grid via the feed-in-tariff. Tarn Bank has an educational access agreement in place through the Higher level Stewardship Scheme and the income stream from the turbine will continue to fund this scheme and facilitate educational access and contribute to the funding of a part time job to coordinate such visits or provide supporting resources. Site and Surroundings The proposed site comprises agricultural land with farmstead and associated buildings within a broader agricultural area. The field is near adjacent to the A595. There are a variety of scattered residential properties in the immediate area within 600 metres. The nearest dwelling is Capel How 571 metres to the east of the proposal. The residential suburb of Stainburn 1.8km to the north west is noted separated by the A66 bypass. The small settlement of Hunday is 800 metres south of the existing windfarm and a greater distance of 1.4km from the proposal. In most case the proposal is further away from residential properties than the existing turbines. The proposed turbine siting is adjacent to the existing turbines within 175 metres that make up the existing Winscales windfarm. These were approved as two separate groups near adjacent to each other under refs 2/1997/0902 (11 turbines 63.5 metres total height) and 2/2006/1321 (7 turbines 81 metres total height). Policy Considerations As core principles, the National Planning Policy Framework includes the requirement to take account of the different roles and character of different areas, recognising the intrinsic character and beauty of the countryside and encourage the use of renewable resources. The NPPF states that the delivery of low carbon energy and associated infrastructure is central to the economic social and environmental dimensions of sustainable development. In determining planning applications, LPA’s should: • not require applicants for energy development to demonstrate the overall need for renewable or low carbon energy and also recognise that even small-scale projects provide a valuable contribution to cutting greenhouse gas emissions; and • approve the application if its impacts are (or can be made) acceptable. This positive approach to renewables is underpinned by the Climate Change Act and binding legal targets to reduce carbon emissions. Policy EN25 of the Allerdale Local Plan restricts development within the open countryside to that which is ‘essential’ to meet a local need. However, the weight to be given to this policy now depends on compatibility with the NPPF which specifies approval of such applications if its impacts are (or can be made) acceptable. In assessing the merits of the proposed development it is necessary to balance the economic, social and environmental benefits of the proposed renewable energy development with any adverse environmental impact of the proposed turbines, taking into account the advice provided in the recent Ministerial Statement and subsequent guidance (see earlier in the report). Of particular note are extracts from the Planning practice guidance and low carbon energy 30 July 2013 which state: ‘Para 2 advises “Government planning practice guidance can be a material consideration in planning decisions and should generally be followed unless there are clear reasons not to.” Para 3 states “..Planning has an important role in the delivery of new renewable and low carbon energy infrastructure in locations where the local environmental impact is acceptable. “ Para 8 includes “..but in considering locations, local planning authorities will need to ensure they take into account the requirements of the technology (see paragraphs 12-13) and, critically, the potential impacts on the local environment, including from cumulative impacts (see paragraphs 43-44). The views of local communities likely to be affected should be listened to. “ Par 11 specifies “..The expectation should always be that an application should only be approved if the impact is (or can be made) acceptable. “ Para 15 refers to “ In shaping local criteria for inclusion in Local Plans and considering planning applications in the meantime, it is important to be clear that: - the need for renewable or low carbon energy does not automatically override environmental protections -cumulative impacts require particular attention, especially the increasing impact that wind turbines and large scale solar farms can have on landscape and local amenity as the number of turbines and solar arrays in an area increases -local topography is an important factor