DOCSLIB.ORG

Download Download

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Download Download Yesterday’s Tomorrows: Past Visions of Future Financial Markets By Robert I. Webb Prof. Robert I. Webb is the Paul Tudor Jones II Research Professor at the McIntire School of Commerce at the University of Virginia in Charlottesville, Virginia, USA. Introduction It is easy to imagine that the present - yesterday’s to observe some of the changes in financial markets; first as tomorrow - was always the future expected in the past. Yet, a student of finance, and later with service: at a regulator; what we now accept as the normal state of affairs - the at an exchange; as a trader; in academia. I will draw upon present - was not the only possible outcome that could some of my recollections and personal experiences in the have come to pass nor was it often the most commonly discussion that follows. expected one. What is now considered “inevitable” – Most readers have always lived in a world where when viewed from the vantage point of 20/20 hindsight - exchange traded derivatives on financial assets existed. was often not immediately embraced or accepted. Many readers have always lived in a world where interest In order to understand where we are going it is important rate swaps and other over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives to understand where we have been and how we got there. were important. Many readers have always lived in a world I want to discuss some past visions of the future of financial where exchange traded derivatives on energy, in general, markets, in general, and derivative markets, in particular, and crude oil, in particular, existed and were important. as seen by academics, practitioners and policymakers at Some readers have always lived in a world where large various points in time. There are few advantages of age Asian financial and commodity futures markets existed and but one of them is the opportunity to witness changes were important in the global price discovery process. Yet, and remember the contemporary context in which they this was not always the case. occurred. I have been fortunate to have had a catbird seat Yesterday’s Tomorrow: 1972 2012 marked the 40th anniversary of the development of ICE) in New York. Leo Melamed argued that the reason the first successful financial futures contracts. On May 16, why the IMM-traded FX futures were successful was timing 1972—trading on foreign exchange or FX futures began on - the Bretton Woods Agreement and its system of fixed the International Monetary Market (IMM) in Chicago. The exchange rates had collapsed.2 IMM was established as an independent exchange and later became a division of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange Yesterday’s Tomorrow: 1973 (CME). FX futures arose in part because small speculators It has been 41 years since the introduction of exchange had a difficult time trying to put short speculative FX positions traded equity options. On April 26, 1973, options trading on with the large banks that dominated the market.1 in 16 listed stocks began on the Chicago Board Options To be sure, FX futures had been introduced earlier but Exchange (CBOE). According to the CBOE, 911 option failed. The first FX futures contracts were introduced on April contracts traded on opening day. Only call options were 23, 1970 on the International Commercial Exchange (not to allowed to trade. Today, exchange traded equity options be confused with the present Intercontinental Exchange or are an integral part of financial markets. 02 Yesterday’s Tomorrows: Past Visions of Future Financial Markets What did the future look like in the past? Specifically, what Interestingly, in the mid 1980’s Merton Miller (1986) argued did it look like for exchange traded equity options? There that the development of financial futures rather than were a number of worries. One worry was that speculators exchange traded equity options was the most important would eschew trading in the cash stock market in favor financial innovation of the previous 20 years. The essence of trading equity options. That is, a successful options of Merton Miller’s argument is that the development of market would cause trading volume on the stock market financial futures preceded the development of exchange to dwindle as people traded options instead of stocks. The traded equity options and that the success of FX futures fundamental premise behind this fear - that option prices contracts stimulated the development of futures contracts would be volatile while equity prices were stagnant reveals on numerous other financial instruments. a fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of options. It is tempting to believe that all currently successful Another fear at the time was that if trading in put options financial futures were an immediate success. However, were permitted it would push down stock prices. This fear they were not always immediately embraced. For instance, was powerful enough to cause the Securities and Exchange the Chicago Board of Trade introduced Treasury bond Commission (SEC) to prohibit trading in put options for futures on August 22, 1977. The 30-year U.S. Treasury bond almost an additional 4 years. Thanks to this decision, put- futures market traded around 4,000 contracts a day until call parity in U.S. exchange traded equity options remained early October 1979 when the Federal Reserve switched to a theoretical concept during those four years. targeting the quantity of money rather than interest rates. It is easy to imagine that exchange traded options began The ensuing volatility in interest rates that resulted from with the trading of equity options on the CBOE. However, this central bank policy shift created a need for investors it is important to note that exchange traded options did to manage interest rate risk exposure or face the risk of not begin with exchange traded equity options. Indeed, large avoidable losses. Essentially, volatile financial markets options on futures (“privileges”) were once common on U.S. penalized those who failed to avoid risk by not hedging. commodity futures markets as Miller (1986) notes. However In this sense, government and central bank policy played trading in “privileges” (futures options) was prohibited and an important role in making financial futures successful by then re-allowed in the U.S. in the 1980s. It is also important to exacerbating financial market volatility. recall that the Chicago Board of Trade (CBOT) created the CBOE.3 Put differently, the idea of exchange traded equity Yesterday’s Tomorrow: 1981 options originated at a futures exchange in Chicago. It has been 33 years since the first interest rate swap was Given that the first successful financial futures contracts transacted in 1981 between the World Bank and IBM. This also originated in Chicago, there is also an important lesson financial market took off quickly. In contrast, Eurodollar about the nature of financial innovations—namely, they futures took longer to become successful even though they don’t always originate in financial capitals. allow one to replicate interest rate swap positions. However, 2013 also marked the 40th anniversary of the publication the need by swap dealers to hedge their net interest rate of the seminal article on option pricing by Fisher Black and swap exposure helped make the Eurodollar futures market Myron Scholes. This article is often rightly credited with both incredibly successful. It also stimulated active trading in stimulating academic research and igniting the subsequent deferred contract months--so much so that Eurodollar explosion in derivatives trading. futures trading extended 10 years out into the future. The Black-Scholes article is also every Editor’s nightmare. It was rejected by many journals before it was finally Yesterday’s Tomorrow: 1980s accepted at the Journal of Political Economy. The The New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) created the seminal article by Fisher Black and Myron Scholes played New York Futures Exchange (NYFE or “Knife”) in 1980 in a crucial role in stimulating the use, and study, of options. In an attempt to bring the financial futures business to New a testament to the power of the wisdom of (trading) York. The introduction of stock index futures in 1982 pitted crowds, later studies showed that competitive markets the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, which traded futures reached similar prices even before the Black Scholes contracts based on the S&P 500 stock index against the model was developed. For example, Moore and Juh NYFE, which traded futures contracts based on a New (2006) report evidence that Johannesburg Stock Exchange York Stock Exchange index. Both started to trade at the traded “warrant prices were surprisingly accurate” during same time in April 1982. It was not immediately clear which 1909-1922. exchange would dominate stock index futures trading. APPLIED FINANCE LETTERS | Volume 03 - ISSUE 01 | 2014 03 To be sure, the NYFE failed to attract much trading volume At the time, futures exchanges viewed energy as the to its Treasury bond futures contract where it competed last great-untapped commodity market. Both the Chicago against the Chicago Board of Trade but that was an Board of Trade and the Chicago Mercantile Exchange established market.4 Both markets traded futures in pits sought to wrest control of the energy futures markets from using open outcry. Ultimately, Chicago won the battle and the NYMEX. They failed. Just as the NYSE’s NYFE fought dominated financial futures trading in the U.S. Incidentally, a losing battle to wrest control of financial futures from Chicago would likely also have dominated U.S. equity the Chicago markets, the Chicago futures exchanges options trading were it not for a SEC desire to regulate fought a losing battle to wrest control of the energy futures multiple option exchanges. The SEC ensured the existence markets from New York. Why did the NYMEX –an exchange of multiple options exchanges by dividing potential stocks whose most important futures contract less than a decade for listed options among multiple exchanges rather than earlier was Maine potatoes--succeed and the far larger letting the Chicago Board Options Exchange dominate the CBOT and CME fail? Was it a lack of resources? No, both nascent market.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Story of Leo Melamed and the Birth of Modern Finance
    MAN OF THE FUTURES The Story of Leo Melamed and the Birth of Modern Finance LEO MELAMED harriman house ltd 3 Viceroy Court Bedford Road Petersfield Hampshire GU32 3LJ GREAT BRITAIN Tel: +44 (0)1730 233870 Email: [email protected] Website: harriman.house First published in 2021. Copyright © Leo Melamed The right of Leo Melamed to be identified as the Author has been asserted in accordance with the Copyright, Design and Patents Act 1988. Hardcover ISBN: 978-0-85719-748-1 eBook ISBN: 978-0-85719-749-8 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A CIP catalogue record for this book can be obtained from the British Library. All rights reserved; no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise without the prior written permission of the Publisher. This book may not be lent, resold, hired out or otherwise disposed of by way of trade in any form of binding or cover other than that in which it is published without the prior written consent of the Publisher. Whilst every efort has been made to ensure that information in this book is accurate, no liability can be accepted for any loss incurred in any way whatsoever by any person relying solely on the information contained herein. No responsibility for loss occasioned to any person or corporate body acting or refraining to act as a result of reading material in this book can be accepted by the Publisher, by the Author, or by the employers of the Author.
    [Show full text]
  • Alternative Investment Analyst Review the Resiliency of the U.S
    Alternative Image Here Investment Analyst Review PERSPECTIVES The Resiliency of the U.S. Futures Industry Hilary Till Q1 2014, Volume 2, Issue 4 Chartered Alternative Investment Analyst Association® RESEARCH REVIEW Research Review CAIAPerspectivesCAIA Member Member Contribution Contribution The Resiliency of the U.S. Futures Industry Hilary Till Principal, Premia Risk Consultancy, Inc. 59 Alternative Investment Analyst Review The Resiliency of the U.S. Futures Industry RESEARCH REVIEW 1. Introduction In a pattern that would repeat itself, the Chicago Board of Financial professionals are well-aware that the ongoing Trade’s founding was the “result of evolution, not intent implementation of the Dodd-Frank Act could cause or design,” noted Stassen (1982), who explained, “The changes to market structure, including the structure Chicago Board of Trade was created by businessmen of the futures markets. Should market participants as a commercial exchange for businessmen – grain be concerned? The short answer is not necessarily, merchants – who needed some order in a world of chaos, given that the history of U.S. futures trading is one of and some relief from a hostile judicial system which responding to constant adversity through dynamic only reluctantly enforced businessmen’s bargains… innovation. [T]he courts in Illinois, as in most states, adhered to old English precedent, which places damages for expected 2. How and Why U.S. Futures Trading Began profits on a par with usury.” The story of U.S. futures markets has largely been one of innovation flowing from Chicago, with additional In spite of their illustrious history, grain merchants in innovations taking place elsewhere.
    [Show full text]
  • TRUE SISTERS: the Book Is a Translation from the Pioneers of a New Jewish Identity, 1843-1914
    Look to the rock from which you were hewn Vol. 37, No. 1, Winter 2013 Revised from earlier print edition chicago jewish historical societ y chicago jewish history Talks, Tours, Art Exhibitions, Movies, Mah Jongg—Let’s Go! Ellen Weinberg Dreyfus has Save the Date! been the rabbi of B’nai Yehuda Beth Sholom in Leo Melamed Speaks Homewood, Illinois, since the congregation was on “Financial Markets founded in 1998 with the merger of Temple B’nai in Chicago and Jews” Yehuda and Congregation Beth Sholom. Sunday, May 19 Rabbi Dreyfus is past The CJHS open meeting on Sunday, May 19 will be president of the Central held at Emanuel Congregation, 5959 North Sheridan Conference of American Road, Chicago. The program begins at 2:00 p.m. Rabbis, the organization of Continued on page 14 nearly 2,000 Reform rabbis in North America and around the world. She is past president of the Chicago Board of Rabbis, the first woman to hold this office. Save the Date! Rabbi Ellen Dreyfus Speaks on “Women in the Rabbinate –Chicago” Sunday, April 14 The next open meeting of the Chicago Jewish Historical Society will be held on Sunday, April 14, 2:00 p.m., at Temple Beth Israel, 3601 West Dempster Street, Skokie. The featured lecture by Rabbi Dreyfus will be preceded by a brief ceremony. Four young playwrights —students or recent graduates of Chicago universities and colleges—will receive the Society’s Emerging Talent Awards for their one-act plays that received staged readings at the Chicago History Museum in connection with the “Shalom Chicago” exhibition.
    [Show full text]
  • The Globalization of Stock Index Futures
    Northwestern Journal of International Law & Business Volume 15 Issue 2 Winter Winter 1994 The Globalization of Stock Index Futures: A Summary of the Market and Regulatory Developments in Stock Index Futures and the Regulatory Hurdles which Exist for Foreign Stock Index Futures in the United States William J. Brodsky Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/njilb Part of the Banking and Finance Commons Recommended Citation William J. Brodsky, The Globalization of Stock Index Futures: A Summary of the Market and Regulatory Developments in Stock Index Futures and the Regulatory Hurdles which Exist for Foreign Stock Index Futures in the United States, 15 Nw. J. Int'l L. & Bus. 248 (1994-1995) This Article is brought to you for free and open access by Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Northwestern Journal of International Law & Business by an authorized administrator of Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. ARTICLES The Globalization of Stock Index Futures: A Summary of the Market and Regulatory Developments in Stock Index Futures and the Regulatory Hurdles Which Exist for Foreign Stock Index Futures in the United States William J. Brodsky* TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION .......................................... 249 II. DEFINITION OF STOCK INDEX FUTURES ................. 250 III. DEVELOPMENT OF STOCK INDEX FUTURES .............. 250 A. Indexation and the Equity Markets ................. 252 IV. USES OF STOCK INDEX FUTURES ........................ 253 V. GLOBALIZATION OF STOCK INDEX FUTUES ............ 256 A. Globalizaion in the 1990s ........................... 257 * William J. Brodsky, President and CEO, Chicago Mercantile Exchange, J.D. 1968, Syra- cuse University, A.B.
    [Show full text]
  • Mchanizing the Merc: the Chicago Mercantile Exchange and The
    Edinburgh Research Explorer Mechanizing the Merc Citation for published version: MacKenzie, D 2015, 'Mechanizing the Merc: The Chicago Mercantile Exchange and the Rise of High- Frequency Trading', Technology and culture, vol. 56, no. 3, pp. 646. https://doi.org/10.1353/tech.2015.0102 Digital Object Identifier (DOI): 10.1353/tech.2015.0102 Link: Link to publication record in Edinburgh Research Explorer Document Version: Peer reviewed version Published In: Technology and culture General rights Copyright for the publications made accessible via the Edinburgh Research Explorer is retained by the author(s) and / or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing these publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. Take down policy The University of Edinburgh has made every reasonable effort to ensure that Edinburgh Research Explorer content complies with UK legislation. If you believe that the public display of this file breaches copyright please contact [email protected] providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Download date: 30. Sep. 2021 Mechanizing the Merc: The Chicago Mercantile Exchange and the Rise of High-Frequency Trading Donald MacKenzie Abstract This article investigates one important strand in the evolution of today’s high- frequency trading or HFT (the fast, automated trading of large numbers of financial securities). That strand is the history of the automation of trading on what has become the world’s most prominent futures exchange, the Chicago Mercantile Exchange or Merc. The process of the automation of the Merc was episodic, often driven by responses to perceived external threats, and involved both “local” politics and transnational considerations.
    [Show full text]