DOCSLIB.ORG

C:\Nbwin\Rene\Finalt~1\Th8f62

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
C:\Nbwin\Rene\Finalt~1\Th8f62 Re-Placing the Galilean Jesus: Local Geography, Mark, Miracle, and the Quest for Jesus of Capernaum by Rene Alexander Baergen A Thesis submitted to the Faculty of St. Michael’s University College and the Biblical Department of the Toronto School of Theology. In partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Theology awarded by the University of St. Michael’s College. © Copyright by Rene Alexander Baergen 2013 Re-Placing the Galilean Jesus: Local Geography, Mark, Miracle, and the Quest for Jesus of Capernaum Rene Alexander Baergen Doctor of Philosophy in Theology University of St. Michael’s College 2013 ABSTRACT In a discourse notorious for disagreement, the extent to which scholars agree on placing the historical Jesus in and around Capernaum is remarkable: it is his centre (E. P. Sanders; G. Theissen), hub (J. Reed), and headquarters (R. Horsley), emblematic of his kingdom (J. D. Crossan) and constitutive of his career (S. Freyne). Nonetheless, reconstructions of Jesus routinely privilege other sorts of place (especially religious, political and cultural) at the expense of local geography. In other words, the historiographical conviction that Capernaum and environs matter for an historical description of Jesus has yet to be translated methodologically, or made to ‘count’ exegetically, in such a way as to occasion a reading strategy correspondingly sensitive to geographical place. My project is an attempt to address this lacuna. On the basis of G. Theissen’s attempt to prioritize for purposes of the historical enterprise those texts in the Synoptic tradition which bear the mark of local perspective ( Lokalkolorit), I suggest that we select similarly for the purpose of an historical description of Jesus those traditions which are ‘marked’ first, by the place names and, also, by the local perspective of Capernaum and environs, otherwise known as the Lake Region of Galilee, which is where scholarship has been wont to locate the man. Such a geographical criterion indicates a set of data clustered in Mark 4:35-8:26 as the most logical textual site at which to begin a closer analysis, or to dig deeper, if and when we take seriously the historiographical wager that Jesus’ local place ii matters. It is true that much of this material can be explained, subsequently, in the name of the Evangelist “Mark.” But it is also true that this explanation only goes so far vis-à-vis the local memory of Jesus as regional holy man and local thaumaturge of the Valley, possessed of the dunamis to manage single-handedly the various, locally experienced contingencies of life lived precisely there. Another, more exacting explanation is required, which I supply, by way of conclusion, in the name of the historical Jesus of Capernaum. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................... 1 CHAPTER ONE: DE-CIPHERING CAPERNAUM: CAPERNAUM AND THE TRADITION OF THE GALILEAN JESUS .............................. 19 In Capernaum .................................................................................................... 24 In the Lake Region .................................................................................................... 42 In the Name of the Border .................................................................................................... 45 CHAPTER TWO: DEFINITE PLACE: THE LAKE REGION OF GALILEE .................................................... 55 Definite Place ............................................................................ 57 A Definite Place Called the Lake Region ............................................................................ 60 Farming ............................................................................ 63 Fishing and Ferrying ............................................................................ 69 Definitely Placed ............................................................................ 77 CHAPTER THREE: TEXT IN PLACE, PART I: A PRELIMINARY DATABASE .............................................. 82 Three Promising Starts (In the Name of Gerd Theissen) ..................................................... 85 A Reading Strategy (In the Name of Local Place) ..................................................... 92 Exegetical Implications (In the Name of Mark) ..................................................... 95 CHAPTER FOUR: TEXT IN PLACE, PART II: A CRITICAL DATABASE .................................................... 113 Mk 4:35-41, Stilling a Storm ......................................... 122 Mk 5:1-20, The Gerasene Demoniac ......................................... 125 Mk 5:21-43, Jairus’ Daughter and the Hemorrhaging Woman ......................................... 130 Mk 6:34-44, Feeding the 5,000 ......................................... 132 Mk 6:45-52, Walking on Water ......................................... 135 Mk 6:53-56, In and Around Gennesaret ......................................... 139 Mk 7:24-30, The Syrophoenician Woman ......................................... 143 Mk 7:31-37, A Deaf-Mute Man ......................................... 146 Mk 8:1-10, Feeding the 4,000 ......................................... 149 Mk 8:22-26, A Blind Man in Bethsaida ......................................... 152 iv CHAPTER FIVE: JESUS IN PLACE ..................................................................................................... 159 Miracle Stories, In So Many Words ............................................................................. 163 Miracle Stories, In the Idiom of the Valley ............................................................................. 177 Miracle Stories, In the Name of Jesus ............................................................................. 195 Jesus of Capernaum ............................................................................. 211 CONCLUSION ..................................................................................................... 218 APPENDIX ONE ..................................................................................................... 237 BIBLIOGRAPHY ..................................................................................................... 242 v Introduction To live is to live locally . Edward Casey (2009 [1993], 321) I. This was originally to be a thesis on the parables of Jesus. I had been struck by the unanimity with which Jesus scholars of all ideological persuasions identified the geographical place of the historical Jesus under the guise of “the Valley,” 1 “the Lake Region,” 2 the “border region” of Galilee, 3 or otherwise in the name of Capernam and environs.4 I wondered whether the concrete detail implied in this datum might redirect the discourse of the quest from the sort of theological investment which has always hovered round it to the material realities of a life lived, sometime and (especially) somewhere, which has always been at least the stated goal of the quest. I decided to explore the effect, for an historical description of Jesus, of paying closer attention to those textual memories marked by the local place where Jesus scholars otherwise put the man. The parables seemed a natural place to begin. Admittedly, the impression that the parables would be the site at which to encounter the textual imprint of Jesus’ local place is one inspired by the likes of C.H. Dodd (1936) and Joachim Jeremias (1972). Dodd’s famous turn of phrase (1936, 21) that the parables represent “probably a more complete picture of petit-bourgeois and peasant life than we possess for any other province of the Roman Empire except Egypt,” continues to resonate, as does Jeremias’ suggestion (1972, 11) that the parables sit near the historical bedrock of the tradition. Following Dodd and Jeremias, the parables are regularly surveyed for remains of Jesus’ social and cultural ------------------------------------ 1 Eric Meyers (1976; 1979; 1985) and Sean Freyne (1980a). 2 Sean Freyne (2004). 3 Jonathan Reed (2000; 2007) and Mark Chancey (2002; 2005). 4 For instance, Jürgen Becker (1998), Maurice Casey (2010), James Charlesworth (2008), Bruce Chilton (2000), John Dominic Crossan (1991; 2001), James Dunn (2003), David Flusser (1997), Paula Fredriksen (1999), Robert Funk (1998), Richard Horlsey (2003), Craig Keener (2009), John Meier (1994), E.P. Sanders (1985; 1993a), Jens Schröter (2006a) and Gerd Theissen (1998). 1 2 context. 5 Why not as well for traces of Jesus’ local geography? What more likely site, in other words, at which to encounter the textual remains of Capernaum and environs and, by extension, the textual traces of the historical person Jesus? The more I immersed myself in what historians have said about Jesus’ definite place, however, the less I found myself engaging the parables tradition. To be sure, the parables are very clearly germane to life in general in the Roman East; for this reason, they are obviously of interest to the student of the historical Jesus. But for this same reason they do not speak nearly as incisively to the particular possibilities and limitations of a life lived in particular, “by the sea,” in Capernaum and environs. In other words: what makes the parables interesting as a statement of political economy germane to life as it was experienced on the eastern frontier of the early Roman Empire also makes them difficult as evidence particular to Capernaum and environs and to life, or a life, lived precisely there (and not simply
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Trade and Commerce at Sepphoris, Israel
    Illinois Wesleyan University Digital Commons @ IWU Honors Projects Sociology and Anthropology 1998 Trade and Commerce at Sepphoris, Israel Sarah VanSickle '98 Illinois Wesleyan University Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.iwu.edu/socanth_honproj Part of the Anthropology Commons Recommended Citation VanSickle '98, Sarah, "Trade and Commerce at Sepphoris, Israel" (1998). Honors Projects. 19. https://digitalcommons.iwu.edu/socanth_honproj/19 This Article is protected by copyright and/or related rights. It has been brought to you by Digital Commons @ IWU with permission from the rights-holder(s). You are free to use this material in any way that is permitted by the copyright and related rights legislation that applies to your use. For other uses you need to obtain permission from the rights-holder(s) directly, unless additional rights are indicated by a Creative Commons license in the record and/ or on the work itself. This material has been accepted for inclusion by Faculty at Illinois Wesleyan University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. ©Copyright is owned by the author of this document. Trade and Commerce At Sepphoris, Israel Sarah VanSickle 1998 Honors Research Dr. Dennis E. Groh, Advisor I Introduction Trade patterns in the Near East are the subject of conflicting interpretations. Researchers debate whether Galilean cities utilized trade routes along the Sea of Galilee and the Mediterranean or were self-sufficient, with little access to trade. An analysis of material culture found at specific sites can most efficiently determine the extent of trade in the region. If commerce is extensive, a significant assemblage of foreign goods will be found; an overwhelming majority of provincial artifacts will suggest minimal trade.
    [Show full text]
  • The Field School Survey Marginals (N=77) Sepphoris/Shikhin, Israel January 2016 James Riley Strange and Penny Long Marler Numbe
    The Field School Survey Marginals (N=77) Sepphoris/Shikhin, Israel January 2016 James Riley Strange and Penny Long Marler Number of cases per item in parentheses; percentages by response category; means for numeric write-ins; top 3 text responses on repeated write-ins; “check all that apply” do not sum to 100 because respondents could choose multiple options 1. During what season (or seasons) did you participate in Sepphoris/Shikhin excavations? (check all that apply) (77) 2009 12.4 2010 14.6 2011 7.6 2012 16.7 2013 22.0 2014 44.8 2015 34.2 2. Have you ever participated in other dig experiences? (77) No 75.8 Yes 24.2 3. If yes, how many other dig seasons at other sites? (write in number) (19) Mean=8 4. If yes, where were your other dig experiences? (sites by country e.g. Bethsaida, Israel) (write in) (19) Top 3: U.S. (10.7); Susita-Hipos Israel, Tel Kasish Israel (7.7); Yodefat Israel et al. (7.7) 5. What was your role during your time(s) at the Sepphoris/Shikhin excavation? (check all that apply) (77) Undergraduate student 51.6 Graduate student 10.3 Volunteer 22.1 Staff 15.1 6. Did you receive academic credit for your participation on the dig? (77) No 48.4 Yes 51.6 7. What leadership role, if any, did you hold during the Sepphoris/Shikhin excavations? (check all that apply) (77) No official leadership role 63.2 Assistant Area Supervisor 13.2 Area Supervisor 17.8 Other staff position 17.7 8.
    [Show full text]
  • CV James Riley Strange 2019-10-17
    James Riley Strange Department of Religion, Howard College of Arts and Sciences Samford University 800 Lakeshore Drive Birmingham, AlaBama 35229 (205) 726-4543; [email protected] www.samford.edu/religion http://www.samford.edu/arts-and-sciences/excavations-at-shikhin/ Personal Married to Laura Strange; one child, Sarah Smythe Pugliese Current Position Charles Jackson Granade and Elizabeth Donald Granade Professor in New Testament (tenure, April 2013), Howard College of Arts and Sciences, Samford University. Education Ph.D. New Testament and Formative Christianity, Emory University, August 2007. Dissertation: “The Moral World of James”; advisor: Luke Timothy Johnson M.A. Religious Studies, Formative Judaism and Christianity, University of South Florida, December 1999. Thesis: “The Emergence of the Christian Basilica in the Fourth Century”; advisor: JacoB Neusner M.Div., emphasis in pastoral care, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, December 1991. B.A. Classics, Furman University, June 1985. Areas of Research Archaeology of Palestine from the Hellenistic to ByZantine Periods The New Testament and Early Christianity in their Greco-Roman and Judaic Environments Academic Honors and OrganiZations Charles Jackson Granade and ElizaBeth Donald Granade Chair in New Testament, Howard College of Arts and Sciences, Samford University, 13 September 2017. Dean’s Award for Research, Howard College of Arts and Sciences, Samford University, 5 May 2015. Theta Kappa Alpha, Alpha Iota Epsilon Chapter, Samford University, 15 April 2008. Emory University Graduate Fellowship, 2000–2004. Phi Kappa Phi, Chapter 126, University of South Florida, 21 March 1999. “High Honors,” USF Comprehensive Examinations for Master of Arts, 1999. Phi Sigma Iota, Furman University, 1984. Eta Sigma Phi, Furman University, 1983.
    [Show full text]
  • An Early Byzantine-Period Burial Cave at Kabul
    ‘Atiqot 66, 2011 AN EA RLY BYZ ANTINE-PE RIOD BURIAL CAVE AT KabL U FA NNY VITTO A burial cave was excavated at Kabul in the None of the burial troughs was covered with western Galilee (map ref. NIG 2205/7524, OIG slabs; as no slabs were found in the debris, the 1705/2524) following its chance discovery troughs were probably not originally sealed. during the digging of a cistern (Fig. 1; Vitto 1974).1 All the finds—glass vessels, DESCRIPTION OF THE CAVE (Plan 1) jewelry and a coin—are datable to the second half of the fourth–early fifth centuries CE, with Entrance to the cave is in the southern wall the exception of a scarab, attributed to the New of Chamber A through a rectangular opening Kingdom, which had obviously been reused as (0.65 m wide, 0.8 m high), sealed by a limestone part of a necklace. slab (0.65 × 0.75 m, 0.25 m thick), and followed The cave was excavated through a breach by a narrow passage (0.65–0.75 m wide, 1 m made in the ceiling at the time of its discovery long, 1.05 m high). A hewn step (0.25 m high) (Fig. 2) and its entrance could not be exposed descends from the entrance to the level of the from the exterior for lack of time. Some earth shelves of Chamber A (Fig. 3). Chamber A and rocks had penetrated the central chamber is rectangular (3.55–4.00 × 4.45–4.65 m, 1.85 and a few of the burial troughs.
    [Show full text]
  • Preface to Volume 2
    Preface to Volume 2 No literary work takes places without a context. The three decades that span 1980–2010 wit- nessed three series of publications that provide the backdrop for this two-volume project. These publications took place in the fields of New Testament studies, Jewish studies, and Gali- lean studies. The first of these developments was the ongoing quest of the historical Jesus. The current quest has manifested itself in three movements: the Jesus Seminar, the Context Group, and the Third Quest. Although they operate under different assumptions and use different methodolo- gies, participants in these three groups have one thing in common. Few of them—there are exceptions—betray any knowledge of the archaeology of Galilee. We offer the current volume to the Jesus quest as a collection of data that scholars can easily access and use in their research. The second development was the advances in the study of early Judaism that occurred during these decades. First, a new collection of Pseudepigrapha was offered in the mid-1980s. Second, all of the remaining Qumran Scrolls were released in the early 1990s. Third, the trans- lations of much of the rabbinic literature by Jacob Neusner and his students and colleagues, published intermittently during these three decades, have made the monumental Jewish mate- rials much more available to the English-speaking general public. Although these publication events have allowed greater access to the Jewish literature and have sparked renewed interest in Jewish Studies, the material culture of Jewish sites has remained largely unknown. The third development that has led to this project is the rise of the Galileans, both the historians and the archaeologists.
    [Show full text]
  • The Memory of the Temple in Palestinian Rabbinic Literature Nathan Still Schumer Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Require
    The Memory of the Temple in Palestinian Rabbinic Literature Nathan Still Schumer Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY 2017 © 2017 Nathan Schumer All rights reserved ABSTRACT The Memory of the Temple in Palestinian Rabbinic Literature Nathan Schumer This dissertation concerns the memory of the Jerusalem Temple in rabbinic literature, arguing that different groups of rabbis continued to remember and recall the Temple after its destruction in 70 CE for a series of changing memorial purposes. This dissertation concerns two discrete questions about the role of the Temple in rabbinic literature: why did the rabbis remember the Temple in their various texts after its destruction in 70 CE and why were they often so accurate in their memories of the Temple and people that lived in the Second Temple period? Previous scholarship on this question has primarily argued that rabbinic memories of the Temple were a means to create rabbinic authority. This explanation does not account rabbinic literature’s accuracy concerning the Temple and the figures of the Second Temple period. My argument is that the project of rabbinic memory of the Temple is far more complex, and I argue that each rabbinic collection has its own particular set of memorial purposes, which motivated its commemoration of the Temple. Indeed, the very object of commemoration shifts between different rabbinic collections, which shows the malleability of rabbinic accounts of the Second Temple period. For this dissertation, I draw on the methodology of social memory, looking at how the past was updated and changed to fit the present.
    [Show full text]
  • ASOR Annual Meeting
    November 15–18 | Boston, Massachusetts Welcome to ASOR’s 2017 Annual Meeting 2–6 History of ASOR 7 Program-at-a-Glance 12–15 Members’ Meeting Agenda 15 Business Meetings and Special Events 16–17 Academic Program 20–52 Projects on Parade Poster Session 52–53 Contents Digital Archaeology Demo Showcase Posters 54–55 of 2017 Sponsors and Exhibitors 56–61 2016 Honors and Awards 65 Looking Ahead to the 2018 Annual Meeting 66 Honorific and Memorial Gifts 67 Fiscal Year 2017 Honor Roll 68–69 Table Table ASOR’s Legacy Circle 70 2017 ACOR Jordanian Travel Scholarship Recipients 70 2017 Fellowship Recipients 71 ASOR Board of Trustees 72 ASOR Committees 73–75 Institutional Members 76 Overseas Centers 77 ASOR Staff 78 BASOR Recommendation Form 79 Paper Abstracts 82–187 Projects on Parade Poster Abstracts 188–194 Digital Archaeology Demo Showcase Poster Abstracts 195–201 Index of Sessions 202–204 Index of Presenters 205–211 Wifi Information 212 Hotel Information and Floor Plans 213–215 Meeting Highlights 216 Cover photo by Selma Omerefendic ISBN 978-0-89757-107-4 ASOR PROGRAM GUIDE 2017 | 1 American Schools of Oriental Research | 2017 Annual Meeting Welcome from ASOR President, Susan Ackerman Welcome to ASOR’s 2017 Annual Meeting, which promises to be ASOR’s biggest ever. Already back in February, we received a record number of paper proposals, and the Programs Committee has worked overtime to put the best of these proposals together into the richest and fullest set of sessions we have ever been able to offer—covering all the major regions of the Near East and wider Mediterranean from earliest times through the Islamic period.
    [Show full text]
  • Aos/Asor/Sbl/Csbr 2008 Annual
    AOS/ASOR/SBL/CSBR Saturday Morning, February 16, 2008 2008 ANNUAL MEETING PROGRAM 8:00-11:00 Registration Weber Center, Lobby Friday Evening, February 15, 2008 8:00-9:00 Coffee, compliments of book publishers 4:00-8:00 Registration – Weber Center, Lobby Room 308 Dinner – local restaurants 8:00-6:00 Publisher Book Displays Room 308 Session 1 SBL Plenary Session: 7:00-8:30 The Body, Healing, and Medicine Session 2A ASOR: Art, Archaeology, and Ethnicity I Chair: Mark Whitters, Eastern Michigan University 9:00-12:00 Room 104 Chair: Wayne Pitard, University of Illinois Room 309 7:00-7:30 John Scarborough, U of Wisconsin, Madison Greco-Roman Medicine: Research and Conclusions, 9:00-9:30 Ralph K. Hawkins, Bethel College 1960-2000 Gilgal or Gilgalim? Fortified Encampments in the Israelite Settlement 7:30-8:00 JoAnn Scurlock, Elmhurst College A Body of Medicine: Recent Developments in the History 9:30-10:00 David A. Fiensy, Kentucky Christian University of Assyro-Babylonian Medicine Exploited or Egalitarian? The Debate between Archaeologists and Sociologists over Galilee in the Late 8:00-8:30 Hector Avalos, Iowa State University Second Temple Period Health Care and Biblical Studies: New Vistas on Embodiment 10:00-10:30 Coffee Break 8:30-9:30 Reception 10:30-11:00 Jeffrey Szuchman, Oriental Institute, University of Weber Center, Lobby Chicago Identifying Arameans along the Upper Tigris Hosted by the School of Theology and Pastoral Ministry of Olivet Nazarene University and the SBL, Midwest 11:00-11:30 Jeff Hudon, Horn Archaeological Museum Region
    [Show full text]
  • Paper Abstracts
    PAPER ABSTRACTS Plenary Address Eric H. Cline (The George Washington University), “Dirt, Digging, Dreams, and Drama: Why Presenting Proper Archaeology to the Public is Crucial for the Future of Our Field” We seem to have forgotten that previous generations of Near Eastern archaeologists knew full well the need to bring their work before the eyes of the general public; think especially of V. Gordon Childe, Sir Leonard Woolley, Gertrude Bell, James Henry Breasted, Yigael Yadin, Dame Kathleen Kenyon, and a whole host of others who lectured widely and wrote prolifically. Breasted even created a movie on the exploits of the Oriental Institute, which debuted at Carnegie Hall and then played around the country in the 1930s. The public was hungry for accurate information back then and is still hungry for it today. And yet, with a few exceptions, we have lost sight of this, sacrificed to the goal of achieving tenure and other perceived institutional norms, and have left it to others to tell our stories for us, not always to our satisfaction. I believe that it is time for us all— not just a few, but as many as possible—to once again begin telling our own stories about our findings and presenting our archaeological work in ways that make it relevant, interesting, and engaging to a broader audience. We need to deliver our findings and our thoughts about the ancient world in a way that will not only attract but excite our audiences. Our livelihoods, and the future of the field, depend upon it, for this is true not only for our lectures and writings for the general public but also in our classrooms.
    [Show full text]
  • Excavating Israel Syllabus A2019
    Pamela Mullins Reaves, Ph.D. Assistant Professor of Religion [email protected] Armstrong 121 – 719.389.6615 / 919.270.0534 RE 200 / CL 222 / HY 200 – Excavating Israel: The Archaeology of Ancient Judaism and Christianity Summer 2019, Block A (May 24 – June 24) This course centers on student participation in archaeological excavations at Shikhin, an ancient Jewish village in the Galilee region of Israel. Through this field experience, students will gain training in essential methods and theories of archaeology as well as insights into the history, culture, politics and economics of the region during the Hellenistic and Roman periods. With an understanding of these contexts, students will examine the related histories of early Judaism, the ministry of Jesus, and Christian origins. In addition to their experience in the field, students will learn through assigned readings, regular evening lectures, excursions to other significant historical sites in the region, and a final weekend exploring Jerusalem. The course will be especially attentive to the benefits and challenges of correlating ancient literary sources, including biblical narratives, with the archaeological record. LEARNING OUTCOMES Through this course, students will gain: § A solid understanding of the history and culture of Judaism in the Hellenistic and Roman periods, including an awareness of the impacts of political shifts and conflicts. § Perspectives on understanding Jesus’ historical ministry that are grounded in studies of the society and culture of the Galilee region; a related awareness of the origins of Christianity within first-century CE Judaism. § Familiarity with the geography of Roman Galilee, including architecture, trade networks, the intersection of urban and village communities, and related cultural cross currents.
    [Show full text]
  • Kefar Shikhin
    GALILEE in the late second temple and mishnaic periods Volume 2 Te Archaeological Record from Cities, Towns, and Villages FM_Galilee II.indd 1 9/2/2015 6:54:14 PM FM_Galilee II.indd 2 9/2/2015 6:54:14 PM GALILEE in the late second temple and mishnaic periods Volume 2 Te Archaeological Record from Cities, Towns, and Villages David A. Fiensy and James Riley Strange Editors Fortress Press Minneapolis FM_Galilee II.indd 3 9/2/2015 6:54:14 PM GALILEE IN THE LATE SECOND TEMPLE AND MISHNAIC PERIODS Volume 2: Te Archaeological Record from Cities, Towns, and Villages David A. Fiensy and James Riley Strange, Editors Copyright © 2015 Fortress Press. All rights reserved. Except for brief quotations in critical articles and reviews, no part of this book may be reproduced in any manner without prior written permission from the publisher. Visit http://www.augsburgfortress.org/copyrights/contact.asp or write to Permissions, Augsburg Fortress, Box 1209, Minneapolis, MN 55440. Cover images, clockwise from upper left: Geometric mosaic at Tiberias, Sky View, used with permission of the New Tiberias Excavation Project. Aerial view of Kedesh, Sky View, used with permission of Tel Kedesh Excavations. Sarcophagus at Kedesh, photo courtesy James Riley Strange. Mikveh at H|uqoq, photo courtesy of Jim Haberman. Teater at Sepphoris, photo courtesy Douglas Oakman. Cover design: Laurie Ingram Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication data is available ISBN: 918-1-4514-6742-0 eISBN: 918-1-5064-0195-9 Te paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences—Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI Z329, 48-1984.
    [Show full text]
  • Jewish Priests and the Social History of Post-70 Palestine
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Carolina Digital Repository JEWISH PRIESTS AND THE SOCIAL HISTORY OF POST-70 PALESTINE Matthew J. Grey A dissertation submitted to the faculty of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill in partial fulfillment of requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Religious Studies. Chapel Hill 2011 Approved by: Jodi Magness Eric Meyers Joel Marcus Bart Ehrman Evyatar Marienberg ©2011 Matthew J. Grey ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ii ABSTRACT MATTHEW J. GREY: Jewish Priests and the Social History of Post-70 Palestine (Under the direction of Jodi Magness) For over a century, most scholars have claimed that the presence, activity, and influence of the Jewish priesthood sharply declined with the destruction of the Jerusalem temple in 70 C.E. According to the traditional narrative, priestly authority in the Jewish community was replaced by the leadership of rabbinic sages, whose legal expertise superseded the third-party mediation of the divine presence previously provided by hereditary priests. Priests may have retained an honorary status in post-70 Jewish society, but functional leadership belonged to the rabbis. As a result of this model, most literary and archaeological material relating to Judaism after 70 has been viewed through the lens of rabbinic literature, rulings, and interests. In this dissertation I challenge the traditional narrative by arguing that priests did not disappear from Jewish society or abrogate their claims to national leadership with the loss of the Jerusalem temple. Literary, epigraphic, and archaeological evidence indicates that many priestly circles survived the First Revolt, continued to identify themselves as priests, retained much of their status, and contributed to Jewish social, religious, and political dynamics in Palestine for several centuries after 70.
    [Show full text]