DOCSLIB.ORG

Let's Talk About Sexual Assault

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Let's Talk About Sexual Assault Let’s Talk About Sexual Assault A Feminist Exploration of the Relationship Between Legal and Experiential Discourses Dana Phillips A Thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate Studies in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Laws Graduate Program in Law Osgoode Hall Law School York University Toronto, Ontario November 2015 © Dana Phillips 2015 Abstract This thesis challenges the tendency within feminist legal thought to imagine a sharp division between law and lived experience, and specifically between feminist methods that engage legal discourse and those that invoke grassroots narratives grounded in experience. In order to better elucidate the relationship between legal and experiential discourses, the author compares recent legal discourse on sexual assault—focusing on two Supreme Court of Canada decisions—with women’s own accounts of sexual violence, as presented in mainstream news media in the wake of the 2014 Jian Ghomeshi story. The findings, examined through the lens of feminist scholarship, support a view of legal and experiential discourses on sexual violence as deeply intertwined and mutually constitutive. While law shapes accounts of firsthand experience, experiential accounts also hold the potential to shape, or “reform,” the law. This understanding suggests a different vision of the nature and process of law reform. ii Acknowledgements Like any project of its kind, this thesis builds upon the work and insight of many others, to whom I am deeply indebted. I am particularly grateful to those who engaged directly with this project as it developed. My deepest thanks go out to my supervisor, Professor Benjamin Berger, for his unfailing support and encouragement, and his unique ability to help me articulate my own ideas. Our many conversations were not only crucial to my progress, but enjoyable and edifying in their own right. A wealth of gratitude is due to Professor Sonia Lawrence, for her time, expertise, and thoughtfulness in offering feedback on my work. Our interactions always pushed me to see the issues I was addressing in new ways, and from different perspectives. I also wish to thank Professor Amanda Glasbeek for her kind words and thought-provoking questions at my defence, as well as Professor Ruth Buchanan for an excellent introduction to the craft of research, and helpful guidance in developing my project proposal. Finally, I am thankful to the Graduate Program in Law at Osgoode Hall and to the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council for supporting me in this endeavor. iii Table of Contents Abstract ................................................................................................................................................... ii Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................................ iii Table of Contents ................................................................................................................................ iv CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................... 1 A Note About Terminology ......................................................................................................................................... 5 Feminist Critiques of Law Reform ........................................................................................................................... 8 Alternative Foundations ........................................................................................................................................... 15 The Discursive Construction of Experience ...................................................................................................... 22 My Claim ........................................................................................................................................................................... 30 Overview and Summary of Chapters ................................................................................................................... 32 CHAPTER TWO: THE LEGAL DISCOURSE .................................................................................... 35 INTRODUCTION: Law and Experience ................................................................................................... 35 PART I: Overview of Reforms ................................................................................................................... 39 Actus Reus ....................................................................................................................................................................... 41 Mens Rea .......................................................................................................................................................................... 46 Evidentiary Issues ........................................................................................................................................................ 49 Summary of Reforms .................................................................................................................................................. 52 PART II: Ewanchuk and JA ......................................................................................................................... 53 A. The Cases .................................................................................................................................................... 54 R v Ewanchuk: Subjective Consent and Rape Myths ..................................................................................... 54 R v JA: Advance Consent ............................................................................................................................................ 57 B. Law and Experience in Ewanchuk and JA ........................................................................................ 60 Meta-Discourse: Law’s Self-Image ........................................................................................................................ 61 Discourse: Power Struggles and the Shifting Meaning of Consent ......................................................... 69 Chapter Summary ........................................................................................................................................ 76 CHAPTER THREE: THE SURVIVOR MEDIA DISCOURSE .......................................................... 78 Part I: The Ghomeshi Story ....................................................................................................................... 81 Part II: The Survivor Discourse ............................................................................................................... 85 Consciousness-raising ................................................................................................................................................ 87 “Why Didn’t You Call the Police?”: Survivors and the Justice System ................................................... 89 Alternatives to Law: Justice through Storytelling ........................................................................................ 101 “What Happened to me?”: Constructions of Sexual Violence .................................................................. 113 Chapter Summary ...................................................................................................................................... 122 CHAPTER FOUR: CONCLUSION .................................................................................................... 124 Feminist Conceptions of Law Reform .................................................................................................. 124 Survivor Narratives as Law Reform ..................................................................................................... 129 Reinforcing New Legal Norms .............................................................................................................................. 130 Transforming Legal Meanings .............................................................................................................................. 135 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................................... 140 References ........................................................................................................................................... 143 iv CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION The recent allegations against former CBC radio host Jian Ghomeshi catalyzed an exceptional moment of public discourse on sexual assault in Canada. Following public revelations from several women who described being attacked by Ghomeshi, many others were compelled to come forward with accounts of sexual assault in their own lives. A tide of survivor1 narratives soon flooded Canadian public and social media with messages about the prevalence of sexual assault, the challenges of seeking redress through the criminal justice system, and the importance of “breaking the silence.” The emerging stories affirmed concerns expressed by feminist lawyers and legal scholars about the persistence of gendered sexual violence in the wake of feminist-influenced criminal law reforms. They also aligned with feminist methods that cast doubt on legal solutions to sexual violence and emphasize the narration of personal experience as a tool for critical
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Abstract in This Paper, I Undertake the Case Study of the Jian Ghomeshi
    Abstract In this paper, I undertake the case study of the Jian Ghomeshi trial to understand how the criminal justice system responds to the problem of sexual violence against women. Specifically, I mobilize two criminological perspectives – conflict and feminist – to make sense of the trial and verdict. Drawing from the work of Richard Quinney, I argue that Ghomeshi’s social status enabled him to avoid discipline by his employer, the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, in the wake of sexual harassment complaints and to hire a highly regarded lawyer. This case clearly illustrates that the criminal justice system is designed to preserve the status quo and favours the wealthy and powerful. In this particular instance the trial re-victimized the female complainants, putting their actions on trial instead of Ghomeshi’s. Feminist theorists have critiqued the adversarial nature of the criminal justice system and the tendency for sexual assault cases to be reduced to a simple ‘he said/she said’ trial of believability. I argue that in order to restore fairness and equity to the criminal justice process a more empathetic framework must be employed which takes into account the existing power differential between men and women in society. 2 He Said She Said: Conflict and Feminism in the Ghomeshi Trial Sexual assault refers to “all incidents of unwanted sexual activity, including sexual attacks and sexual touching” and in Canada females account for 92% of sexual assault victims (Brennan & Taylor-Butts, 2008; Statistics Canada, 2008). There are two major issues regarding sexual assault against women that must be recognized: its prevalence – it affects as many as 1 in 3 women – and that it is a highly underreported crime, with approximately 8% of sexual assaults reported to police (Benoit, Shumka, Phillips, Kennedy, & Belle-Isle, 2015; Statistics Canada, 2008).
    [Show full text]
  • Karissasovdithesis2016.Pdf (628.2Kb)
    Running head: ASKING FOR IT 1 Asking For It: The Sexualized Violence of Jian Ghomeshi as Depicted by Four Traditional Journalistic Media Sources Karissa L. Sovdi Running head: ASKING FOR IT 2 Table of Contents Abstract .......................................................................................................................................... 4 Acknowledgements ....................................................................................................................... 4 Introduction ................................................................................................................................... 5 Literature Review ......................................................................................................................... 7 Activist Scholarship Regarding Rape Culture ..................................................................................... 8 Media and Language ............................................................................................................................ 11 Methods ........................................................................................................................................ 15 Data Acquisition ................................................................................................................................... 16 CBC data. ........................................................................................................................................... 17 Dailies data. .......................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Examining Expressions of Belief in the Jian Ghomeshi Case
    Examining Expressions of Belief in the Jian Ghomeshi Case by Vickie Richard A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Department of Psychology University of Alberta © Vickie Richard, 2018 ii Abstract In late October 2014, accusations of sexual assault levelled against Jian Ghomeshi dominated the Canadian news cycle. This case offers an opportunity to examine the public’s struggle to determine whether to believe Ghomeshi’s alleged victims, to make sense of how that belief matters, and ask what responses these beliefs demand. This project is a narrative study of expressions of belief in the Ghomeshi scandal. In this project, I use a multi-step approach to explore what it meant for participants to say they believed or did not believe Ghomeshi or his alleged victims. In order to first characterize the context in which those comments were made, in Chapter 1 I sketch a broad timeline of events that make up the Ghomeshi scandal using news articles and publicly available online media. In Chapter 2, I detail a discursive analysis of Ghomeshi’s Facebook post which publicly triggered the scandal. In Chapter 3, I provide a thematic analysis of the responses to the Facebook post made by commenters on the same platform. Finally, in Chapter 4 I present a discursive psychological analysis of what the expressions of belief in these responses might mean, an analysis I augmented with a discussion of Charles Taylor’s strong evaluations. I conclude with a discussion of this work. Keywords: Jian Ghomeshi, sexual assault, discursive psychology, Charles Taylor, Facebook iii Dedication Pour Maman et Papa, qui m’ont toujours encouragé de poursuivre mes élans, même quand ils m’emmènent en Alberta.
    [Show full text]
  • Survivor Stories and the Law in the Jian Ghomeshi Media Discourse
    Osgoode Hall Law Journal Volume 54 Issue 4 Volume 54, Issue 4 (Summer 2017) Article 9 Creating Opportunities: A Vision for the Future 10-13-2017 Let’s Talk About Sexual Assault: Survivor Stories and the Law in the Jian Ghomeshi Media Discourse Dana Phillips Osgoode Hall Law School Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/ohlj Part of the Criminal Law Commons, and the Law and Gender Commons Article This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 4.0 License. Citation Information Phillips, Dana. "Let’s Talk About Sexual Assault: Survivor Stories and the Law in the Jian Ghomeshi Media Discourse." Osgoode Hall Law Journal 54.4 (2017) : 1133-1180. https://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/ohlj/vol54/iss4/9 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at Osgoode Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Osgoode Hall Law Journal by an authorized editor of Osgoode Digital Commons. Let’s Talk About Sexual Assault: Survivor Stories and the Law in the Jian Ghomeshi Media Discourse Abstract The recent allegations against former Canadian radio host Jian Ghomeshi catalyzed an exceptional moment of public discourse on sexual assault in Canada. Following public revelations from several women who described being attacked by Ghomeshi, many others came forward with accounts of sexual violence in their own lives. Affirmingeminist f critiques of sexual assault law reform, many survivors drew on their experiences to expose the criminal justice system’s ongoing flaws in processing sexual assault cases. While some held out hope for the criminal law’s role in addressing sexual violence, most rejected its individualizing and retributive aspects.
    [Show full text]
  • CONFLICT and FEMINISM in the GHOMESHI TRIAL He Said She Said
    Running head: HE SAID SHE SAID: CONFLICT AND FEMINISM IN THE GHOMESHI TRIAL He Said She Said: Conflict and Feminism in the Ghomeshi Trial Shannon Leach – 250748355 Sociology 4409G Dr. Liam Kennedy Kings University College April 5, 2017 HE SAID SHE SAID: CONFLICT AND FEMINISM IN THE GHOMESHI TRIAL 2 He Said She Said: Conflict and Feminism in the Ghomeshi Trial “Crime begins in the mind.” – (Quinney 2001) Sexual assault is a form of violence against the person. It is defined as, “a term used to refer to all incidents of unwanted sexual activity, including sexual attacks and sexual touching” with “females accounting for 92% of sexual assault victims in Canada” (Brennan and Taylor- Butts 2008; Statistics Canada 2008). There are two major issues regarding sexual assault against women that must be recognized: its prevalence, “affecting as many as 1 in 3 women in Canada”; and that it is a highly underreported crime, only “about 8% of sexual assaults were reported to police” (Benoit et al. 2015; Statistics Canada 2008). Feminist theorists have pointed to the adversarial nature of the criminal justice system, and the fact that many investigations, through lack of physical evidence, are reduced to a simple ‘he said/she said’ trial of believability. Through an examination of the recent and highly publicized Jian Ghomeshi trial, this paper will use conflict and feminist criminological perspectives to explore the challenges female sexual assault victims face while interacting with the criminal justice system. This essay will begin with a short case summary and an evaluation of its importance to the field of criminology.
    [Show full text]
  • Sydney Jacklin
    Imagining Law: Curated Narratives of Sexual Assault in The Ghomeshi Effect by Sydney Jacklin A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Legal Studies Carleton University Ottawa, Ontario © 2017 Sydney Jacklin Abstract This project explores how myths of law are aesthetically animated. I unpack narratives of sexual violence, trauma, and social transformation presented in the verbatim theatre performance of The Ghomeshi Effect. I suggest that while the producers of the play claim that the verbatim methods authentically tell experiences of sexual violence, their representation of these narratives reproduce broader myths of law as an ordered system of truth. Stories of sexual violence in this performance are not authentic representations, but an aesthetic platform through which the power of law is animated. i IMAGINING LAW Acknowledgements Special thank you to Professor Stacy Douglas for challenging me and pushing me to my limits. Your teaching is insightful and your work is inspiring. Thank you to my second reader, Professor Ummni Khan for dedicating so much time and patience helping me evolve this project. Thank you to Michelle and Cheryl for editing way too many drafts. To my closest friend, Jake. Thank you for providing me with a soundboard for ideas and those much-needed glasses of wine and cups of coffee. I am forever grateful for your companionship. To my partner, Josh. Thank you for your support, care, and kindness. You have taught me how to approach life thoughtfully and patiently. Finally, thank you to my mom, dad, and brother for constantly inspiring me to be creative and to do what I love.
    [Show full text]