Acts 20:13-24

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Acts 20:13-24 a Grace Notes course The Acts of the Apostles an expositional study by Warren Doud Lesson 316: Acts 20:13-24 Grace Notes 1705 Aggie Lane, Austin, Texas 78757 Email: [email protected] ACTS, Lesson 316, Acts 20:13-24 Contents Acts 20:13-24 ............................................................................................................... 3 Acts 20:13,14 ................................................................................................................... 3 Acts 20:15 ........................................................................................................................ 3 Acts 20:16,17 ................................................................................................................... 4 Acts 20:18 ........................................................................................................................ 4 Acts 20:19 ........................................................................................................................ 4 Acts 20:20 ........................................................................................................................ 5 Acts 20:21 ........................................................................................................................ 5 Acts 20:22,23 ................................................................................................................... 5 Acts 20:24 ........................................................................................................................ 5 Grace ............................................................................................................................ 6 Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 6 Etymology: Bible Vocabulary Related to Grace ................................................................... 6 Common Grace ................................................................................................................11 Saving Grace ...................................................................................................................12 Living Grace .....................................................................................................................12 Surpassing Grace .............................................................................................................13 Distortions of Grace ..........................................................................................................13 Chios ........................................................................................................................... 17 Samos ......................................................................................................................... 18 Miletus ........................................................................................................................ 18 The Acts of the Apostles Page 3 ACTS 316, Acts 20:13-24 a Grace Notes study southern part of Lesbos and the mainland of Acts 20:13-24 1 Asia Minor. Acts 20:13,14 Acts 20:15 And we went before to ship, and sailed to Assos, there intending to take in Paul: for And we sailed from there, and came the he had so appointed, minding himself to go next day over against Chios; and the next afoot. day we arrived at Samos, and tarried at Trogyllium; and the next day we came to And when he met with us at Assos, we took Miletus. him in, and came to Mitylene. William Ramsay has an interesting remark Luke relates here that he and the other about this island hopping journey: companions of Paul shipped out as planned to “The ship evidently stopped every evening. sail to Assos, but that Paul had decided to go on The reason lies in the wind, which in the foot from Troas to Assos. Aegean during the summer generally blows Assos was about 20 miles from Troas, in the from the north, beginning at a very early province of Mysia, in western Asia Minor, a port hour in the morning; in the late afternoon it where travelers would sail south to the island dies away; at sunset there is a dead calm, of Lesbos, and its capital, Mitylene. Paul could and thereafter a gentle south wind arises readily walk that distance in one day. and blows during the night. The start would Commentators make a lot of guesses about why be made before sunrise; and it would be Paul decided to walk that day. Perhaps, they necessary for all passengers to go on board soon after midnight in order to be ready to say, some of the folks from Troas would walk a 2 ways with him, for fellowship and sail with the first breath from the north. conversations. Or perhaps Paul wanted a time They sailed past the island of Chios, that is, they alone with God, or just for some private sailed through a strait between Chios and the meditation. But it’s folly to try to fill in blanks in mainland, which would have provided a a historical narrative by inserting conjectures. sheltered route. They may have anchored Paul walked, and that’s all we know! somewhere to spend the night. Ships did not When they left Assos , Mitylene, the chief city of usually sail at night in this area of the Aegean Lesbos, came gradually into view. The beauty of Sea, which was cluttered with islands. The next the capital of Sappho's island was celebrated by day they sailed on to Samos. the architects, poets, and philosophers of Rome. TOPIC: CHIOS Like other Greek cities, which were ennobled by old recollections, it was honored by the Romans we arrived at Samos, and tarried at with the privilege of freedom. Situated on the Trogyllium south eastern coast of the island, it would afford a good shelter from the north westerly winds, The island of Samos was a “free city” in the whether the vessel entered the harbor or lay at province of Asia. Trogyllium lay on the anchor in the open roadstead. It seems likely mainland opposite Samos; perhaps Trogyllium that the reason why they lay here for the night was used as the night’s halting-place. was, because it was the time of dark moon, and Trogyllium was on a promontory which jutted they would wish for daylight to accomplish out into the Aegean, a few miles southwest of safely the intricate navigation between the 1 Conybeare and Howson, Chapter 20 2 William R. Ramsay, St. Paul the Traveler, p. 293. The Acts of the Apostles Page 4 ACTS 316, Acts 20:13-24 a Grace Notes study Ephesus. Paul stayed overnight here, but then The captain of the ship presumably had decided sailed on to Miletus instead of walking to to stay in the harbor of Miletus for a few days to Ephesus. The passage by ship from Trogyllium load and unload cargo. During those days of to Miletus would have brought the party to the waiting, Paul was able to meet with the elders port in no more than half a day. from Ephesus and, perhaps in a worship service, to give his farewell address. TOPIC: SAMOS Acts 20:18 TOPIC: MILETUS And when they were come to him, he said Acts 20:16,17 unto them, You know, from the first day For Paul had determined to sail by that I came into Asia, after what manner I Ephesus, because he would not spend the have been with you at all seasons, time in Asia: for he hasted, if it were Paul recalls, in this first part of his speech, how possible for him, to be at Jerusalem the day he first came from Corinth (Acts 18:19), taught of Pentecost. in the local synagogue, went to Jerusalem, and returned to Ephesus. When he came back to And from Miletus he sent to Ephesus, and Ephesus, he taught for nearly three years. In no called the elders of the church. other place had he preached the gospel for as Paul could have walked to Ephesus from long a period. Trogyllium, but he stayed on the ship until it These church leaders knew that Paul had docked at Miletus. He knew that a visit to faithfully taught the word of the Lord to Jews Ephesus itself would delay him several days, at and Gentiles in the province of Asia (Acts least, whereas he could invite the Ephesian 19:10). They could testify that he had been in elders to Miletus to have a brief conference. He their midst as a true messenger of the gospel of was too late to make it to Jerusalem for Christ. Convinced of Paul’s mission, they were Passover, but he was determined to be there to witnesses of the truth of the message he celebrate Pentecost, particularly now that proclaimed. They had observed that Paul was Pentecost was so meaningful to Christians. completely devoted to serving his Lord. Here is how Paul filled the seven weeks Acts 20:19 between Passover and Pentecost: 1. He spent five days traveling between Serving the Lord with all humility of mind, Neapolis and Troas (20:6); and with many tears, and testings, which 2. He stayed a week in Troas (20:6); he befell me by the lying in wait of the Jews: took four days to travel from Troas to Paul served without arrogance, pride, and Miletus (20:13–16); without peremptorily dictating to believers, 3. He spent perhaps most of a week on the without lording it over God’s people as many voyage from Miletus to Tyre (21:1–3); did later who were so conscious of the powers of their offices. 4. He remained a week in Tyre (21:4); Paul always showed tenderheartedness and 5. and with stops in Caesarea, he needed great regard for the souls of people and his at least a week to travel to Jerusalem urgent desire for the salvation of sinners. (21:7–15). The Jews, very often, were hardened against his According to the record that Luke provides, ministrations, and believed not the Gospel Paul had some time
Recommended publications
  • Missing in Modern Bibles the Old Heresy Revived
    Missing in Modern Bibles The Old Heresy Revived AV Seminar Studies Jack Moorman Contents Introduction I Key Passages Missing 5 II Names of Christ Missing: The Old Heresy 10 III ADOPTIONISM: The Old Heresy Behind the Text of the Modern Versions 15 IV Further Significant Passages Missing 17 V Hell Missing 22 VI How Many Missing Words? 25 VII How Many Different Kinds of Variations? 26 VIII The Theory Behind the Shorter and Altered Text 27 IX Manuscript Evidence for the Traditional Text 35 X A Recent Counter Argument 41 XI The Huge Disparity Among the Few Modern Version Manuscripts 43 XII Key Epochs in the Preservation History Of the New Testament Text 43 XIII Antioch or Alexandria 48 XIV Timeless or Time-bound 49 XV. AV Or NIV English 52 XVI The Translators to the Reader 53 XVII Principles of Bible Preservation 60 XVIII Some Further Arguments Against Our Bible 65 XIX An Example of the Downward Course that Accompanies Criticism and Rejection of the Authorised Version 71 XX The Great Contrast 73 1 2 Introduction Would it make a difference if you knew that the New Testament of your Modern Bible did not have First and Second Peter? Yet if the total number of missing words were added up this is how much shorter the modern translations are than the King James Version. Is it a cause for concern if in over 175 instances the names of Christ are missing, or if the word “hell” is not found in the Old Testament, or if key doctrinal passages have been diminished? And, the biggest shock of all! Is it possible that the most basic and blatant of all early heresies concerning the Person of Christ has been given a new lease on life in the modern Bibles? That these things are so, with the reasons why, are set forth in the following pages.
    [Show full text]
  • The Apostle Paul
    The Apostle Paul 1 Manitoulin Youth Camp Paul-Teen Book Dear Camper, We are looking forward to another great year studying God’s word at Manitoulin Youth Camp this summer, God Willing. This year we are blessed to be studying the apostle Paul, we will be considering five important first principle topics and also will be dedicating one of our classes to a group oriented workshop where we will focus on putting the principles and lessons of Paul’s life into practice in our lives. Please remember that it is important to do a good job on your workbook and pre-camp assignments. Not only will this allow you to fully participate in all the many fun activities Manitoulin Youth Camp has to offer, but also will allow you to get a lot more out of the classes and take home lessons that will stick with you for a lifetime! In the event we can’t have Youth Camp this year all together up at Manitoulin due to the on- going health issue, we still recommend you complete the workbook to gain the spiritual benefits of getting to know better one of the most incredible characters in all the Bible, the apostle Paul. Note the next page where you will review your workbook with your counsellors at camp, God willing, to make sure it is complete. This workbook is divided into three sections: 1) Daily readings, memory verses and practical application principles 2) The Study of Paul workbook (thanks to Uncle Joe and Aunt Courtney Robinson) 3) First Principles workbook If you have questions about the teen program in general this year please send a note to Uncle Dan and Aunt Nicki Styles at [email protected].
    [Show full text]
  • Acts 20 Paul Travels Through Macedonia and Greece on the Way Back to Jerusalem
    Acts of the Apostles 19:21–22 and Acts 20 Paul travels through Macedonia and Greece on the way back to Jerusalem The one where Eutychus falls out of a window and Paul says goodbye to the Ephesians. Last week u In Ephesus, twelve men who had only known the Baptism of John were baptized and when Paul laid hands on them, they received the Holy Spirit. u Paul preached in the synagogue for 3 months then left to preach daily in the hall of Tyrannus. u Paul remained in Ephesus for 3 years. All of Asia heard the WORD! u Paul performed miracles in Ephesus. Even his washcloths or aprons would heal people if these items of Paul touched their skin. u 7 sons of the High Priest try to exorcize a demon by using the name of Jesus. They are beat up and driven out of the house naked by the demon! Last week u Seeing this, many who had practiced magic brought their books together and burned them in sight of all who were there. u Paul wrote the First Letter to the Corinthians at this time. u Paul sent Timothy and Erastus to Macedonia and then sends Titus to Corinth. u Silversmiths who made idols of Artemis begin a riot in Ephesus. They fear Paul’s teaching will hurt their livelihood and keep tourists away from the Temple of Artemis of Ephesus. u A town clerk was the voice of reason who calmed the crowd. Acts 19:21-22 u 21 When this was concluded, Paul made up his mind to travel through Macedonia and Achaia, and then to go on to Jerusalem, saying, “After I have been there, I must visit Rome also.” 22 Then he sent to Macedonia two of his assistants, Timothy and Erastus, while he himself stayed for a while in the province of Asia.
    [Show full text]
  • The Compulsion of the Spirit in the Farewell Speech of Paul in Acts 20
    The Compulsion of the Spirit in the Farewell Speech of Paul in Acts 20:17-38 to the Ephesian Leaders An Exegetical Study Grounded in the Apostle’s Pneumatology and Christology by Cletus Hull 1 This analysis of Acts 20:17-38 considered the historical, theological, and exegetical issues of Paul’s farewell speech to the Ephesian leaders. As his discourse became one of the most important in Acts, the conclusion of the paper discussed the practical ramifications for ministry. Subsequently, a major imperative of this study unveiled that the presence of the Holy Spirit remains crucial for effective pastoral ministry. Introduction Luke recorded three typical Pauline speeches in Acts: the synagogue sermon in Pisidian Antioch (13:16-41), the Areopagus speech in Athens (17:22-31), and his farewell address to the Ephesian elders (20:18-35). He received information for the first two discourses from Paul, his travel companion, but of these three, Luke personally heard the third (Acts 21:1). In Acts 20, Luke recorded a homily delivered by the apostle to believers and the only account of a public occasion embedded in a “we-passage” of Acts. There remain similarities between the Acts 20 speech and Paul’s letters as he addressed a Christian audience that typified the advice he shared in his epistles. Moreover, it offered the best prospect of direct comparison between the Paul of Acts and the Paul of the epistles. The structure of the speech conveyed motifs revealing Paul's theology. His farewell address to the elders on Miletus beach exposed a number of phrases presented in his correspondences.
    [Show full text]
  • Dorcas/Tabitha
    / Dorcas Tabitha Dorcas (Tabitha) is the only woman in the bible referred to as a disciple. The way the first verse is written implies there may have been other female disciples in Joppa too, who are not mentioned by name. Her name Tabitha means Gazelle – indicating perhaps that she is a woman of grace, energy, beauty, and quick movements. Like Paul, she has both Greek & Jewish names – Greek = Dorcas, Jewish = Tabitha. The name Tabitha was also popular among slaves – like Lydia there is the possibility that she was a freewoman. She is raised from the dead after Peter prays for her. There are some similarities with other stories where people are risen from the dead: • Elijah raising Zarephath’s son’s widow (1 Kings 17:17-24) • Elisha’s raising of Shunammite woman’s son (2 Kings 4:18-37) • Jesus raising Nain’s son (Luke 7:11-17) • Jairus’s daughter Talitha (Luke 8:41-42 & 49-56, Mark 5:35-43) – similar name! Coincidence? • Lazarus (John 11:1-44, Eutychus (Acts 20:9-12). Tabitha is much loved and respected. Uses her sewing skills and financial resources for good. She is clearly generous and kind, has made clothes for widows and they all mourn her when she dies. Her story converts many people into believing. Care of widows was a long- held way of demonstrating God’s righteousness and justice. Tabitha’s status may imply she was leading the church in Joppa. The widows in the story are not passive but engaged. They are neither silent nor insignificant, but rather of key importance.
    [Show full text]
  • The Bible in the Church, Part 1 the Book of Acts, Part 48 | Acts 20:1 – 24 | David Platt, MBC Interim Teaching Pastor & President of the IMB
    The Bible in the Church, part 1 The Book of Acts, part 48 | Acts 20:1 – 24 | David Platt, MBC Interim Teaching Pastor & President of the IMB Acts 2:41 “So those who received his word were baptized, and there were added that day about three thousand souls.” Acts 4:4 “But many of those who had heard the word believed, and the number of the men came to about five thousand.” Acts 4:29 “And now, Lord, look upon their threats and grant to your servants to continue to speak your word with all boldness . .” Acts 4:31 “And when they had prayed, the place in which they were gathered together was shaken, and they were all filled with the Holy Spirit and continued to speak the word of God with boldness.” Acts 6:2 – 4 “And the twelve summoned the full number of the disciples and said, ‘It is not right that we should give up preaching the word of God to serve tables. Therefore, brothers, pick out from among you seven men of good repute, full of the Spirit and of wisdom, whom we will appoint to this duty. But we will devote ourselves to prayer and to the ministry of the word.’” Acts 6:7 “And the word of God continued to increase, and the number of the disciples multiplied greatly in Jerusalem, and a great many of the priests became obedient to the faith.” Acts 8:4 “Now those who were scattered went about preaching the word.” Acts 8:14 “Now when the apostles at Jerusalem heard that Samaria had received the word of God, they sent to them Peter and John .
    [Show full text]
  • In the Midst of the Storm” Acts 27:1–44 Previous Message Summary: Paul, Still B
    b. How many people were aboard the ship and how many made it ashore? See Acts 27:37, 44. Small Group Questions 4. In Acts 27:3, the ship travels up the coast to Sidon “The Church Afire:”In the Midst of the Storm” where Julius frees Paul to go to his friends to provide Acts 27:1–44 for his needs. Previous Message Summary: Paul, still being held a. From verses 1-3 and 43, what do you know about captive by Governor Festus, had the opportunity to speak Julius? before King Agrippa and Bernice. Governor Festus was trying to come up with some reasonable charges against b. Why do you think a Roman soldier responsible for Paul. Paul gave us a great example of the different parts his prisoner’s captivity would let Paul go freely to of a testimony. his friends? We learned that: c. If you were the centurion, would you let your a. God is in the “story changing” business. prisoner have so much freedom? b. We need to carefully think through how to tell our story. c. We need to pray that God uses our story to help spread d. Can you share a time when you trusted someone His story. with a big responsibility? Did it pay off or were you disappointed? As you begin, you may want to read this passage in its entirety. 5. Paul warned the crew that the ship was headed for disaster if the voyage continued. Julius chose to listen Introduction to the ship’s pilot and owner.
    [Show full text]
  • Women's Ministries Devotionals
    WOMEN’S MINISTRIES DEVOTIONALS A Follower of Jesus Vonda Rodeheaver Scripture: Acts 9: 1-2, 36 Tabitha was from Joppa, a Jewish Mediterranean coastal town with Greek cultural influence. Her Hebrew name was Tabitha, but she was known by her Greek-speaking friends as Dorcas. (Often Jews living in areas of strong Greek cultural influence spoke not only Aramaic but also Greek.) Tabitha was a devout Hebrew believer living in a Hellenized town. She was zealous for God. She was well known and was referred to as a “disciple” of Jesus. She would have been considered as a member of “the Way”, people who believed that Jesus had been resurrected from the dead and that therefore Jesus was the Messiah, the Son of God. Tabitha, or Dorcas as her friends called her, always went about doing good and helping the poor. Saul, another devout Hebrew, was born in Tarsus of Cilicia, a town under the influence of Roman rule and culture. Young Saul was brought to Jerusalem where he was trained to follow the Old Testament Law and the religious customs of his ancestors. He excelled under the teaching of a leading rabbi named Gamaliel and he was quite zealous for God. At one level Tabitha and Saul hold much in common. They both had been raised to be devout Jews even though born into contexts of strong gentile influence. Yet there is a key difference between Saul and Tabitha at this point in the story. Saul was zealous to keep the Jewish laws but refused to believe that Jesus was the Messiah, the Son of God.
    [Show full text]
  • Lesson Booklet
    WITNESSES TO CHRIST Studies in the Acts of the Apostles But ye shall receive power, after that the Holy Ghost is come upon you: and ye shall be witnesses unto me both in Jerusalem, and in all Judaea, and in Samaria, and unto the uttermost part of the earth. Acts 1:8 Trinity Bible Church Sunday School Spring, 2004 Table of Contents Introduction ................................................................3 Schedule ..................................................................4 Scripture Memorization: Verses from the Acts of the Apostles . 5 Hymn Memorization: “The Head that Once was Crowned with Thorns” . 7 Lesson 1: You Shall be Witnesses ............................................8 Acts 1 2: The Day of Pentecost .............................................9 Acts 2 3: The Blessing of Jesus ............................................10 Acts 3:1-4:4 4: Great Power, Great Grace, Great Fear . 11 Acts 4:5-5:11 5: A Work of God .................................................12 Acts 5:12-6:15 6: Resisting the Holy Spirit...........................................13 Acts 7 7: Preaching Christ Everywhere .......................................14 Acts 8 8: Christ's Chosen Vessel............................................15 Acts 9 9: God Shows No Partiality ..........................................16 Acts 10 10: Who Can Withstand God? .........................................17 Acts 11:1-12:25 11: The Appointment of God..........................................18 Acts 13 12: The Opened Door of Faith ........................................19
    [Show full text]
  • Sermon Notes​May 12, 2019 Focus ​Good Shepherd Sunday with A
    Sermon Notes May 12, 2019 ​ Focus Good Shepherd Sunday with a focus on Acts 9 (Tabitha / Dorcas) ​ Lectionary Readings http://www.lectionarypage.net/YearC_RCL/Easter/CEaster4_RCL.html ​ I am not going to focus on “Jesus the good shepherd” in preaching so much as I’m going to invite us to be good shepherds. Tabitha /Dorcas was a good shepherd both ​ ​ before she died and after she was raised in Acts chapter 9. Her resurrection story is an important evolution of Jesus’ role as shepherd. Resurrection and new life help us to be a shepherd. Sidenote I offer you a couple of links to some striking Good Shepherd art. ​ ● Asian artists Asian art of the Good Shepherd. ​ ​ ● Global artists Global art of the Good Shepherd ​ Resurrection stories beyond Jesus’s resurrection (Tabitha is one of them) ● Widow of Nain’s son (Luke 7:11-17). Jesus raised this young man literally in ​ the middle of his funeral procession. The text says it’s her only son and she’s a widow. Jesus’ fame spreads widely because of this act of power and care. It might’ve spread too widely because his approach is much more private with Jairus’ daughter ● Jairus’ daughter (Luke 8:49-56). Jesus raised the synagogue leader’s ​ daughter in the presence of the parents, Peter, James, and John in a separate room. Then, Jesus does this curious thing by insisting no one says anything. Maybe he just wants people to own the power of God themselves instead of offloading it all the time onto him? ● Tabitha (Tabitha is Aramaic.
    [Show full text]
  • The Jerusalem "Apostolic Decree" in Acts 15:1-35
    The Jerusalem "apostolic decree" in Acts 15:1-35 Author: Patrick Ogbonyomi Alemayo Persistent link: http://hdl.handle.net/2345/bc-ir:108451 This work is posted on eScholarship@BC, Boston College University Libraries. Boston College Electronic Thesis or Dissertation, 2019 Copyright is held by the author, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise noted. THE JERUSALEM “APOSTOLIC DECREE” IN ACTS 15:1-35 By Rev. Patrick Ogbonyomi ALEMAYO, C.S.Sp. A Thesis submitted to Boston College in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the Award of the Licentiate in Sacred Theology (S.T.L.) Degree, Boston College School of Theology and Ministry, Brighton, MA, U.S.A. April 30, 2019 Primary Co-Mentor: Professor Christopher R. Matthews Co-Mentor: Rev. Professor Thomas D. Stegman, S.J. DEDICATION This work is dedicated to Very Rev. Fr. Dr. Ayodele Ayeni, C.S.Sp. Provincial Superior Congregation of the Holy Spirit Province of Nigeria North-West Abuja, Nigeria with Fraternal Love and Gratitude 2 ABSTRACT The strict historical reading of the Jerusalem Council in Acts 15:1-35 is a problematic in scholarship. This raises the question of the purpose of the Jerusalem “Apostolic Decree” in Luke’s narrative of the Jerusalem Council. This study argues that Luke’s purpose of the Decree in Acts (15:20, 29; [also found in 21:25]) is not for a pure historical evolution of the Christian mission from Jerusalem to the Gentile world, but refers to a theological and social etiology, founded on divine choice, the Mosaic law, and the prophets, that Luke promulgates as four prohibitions, which have practical values for Luke’s community in creating the conditions necessary for enabling the table-fellowship between Jewish Christians and Gentile Christians.
    [Show full text]
  • The Lukan Periplus of Paul's Third Journey with A
    Acta Theologica 2016 36(1): 229‑254 DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.4314/actat.v36i1.13 ISSN 2309‑9089 © UV/UFS <http://www.ufs.ac.za/ActaTheologica> M. Wilson THE LUKAN PERIPLUS OF PAUL’S THIRD JOURNEY WITH A TEXTUAL CONUNDRUM IN ACTS 20:15 ABSTRACT This article discusses a pericope in Acts 20:6–21:8 recounting the sea portion of Paul’s third journey. Its genre resembles the periplus, and generic features are discussed as well as parallels with other periploi. Paul’s periplus in the Aegean and Mediterranean Seas is presented within a fixed calendar in the Jewish year, and the itinerary’s specifics are detailed. A textual conundrum in Acts 20:15 is discussed as it relates to an anchorage opposite Chios. A lexical discussion of ἄντικρυς Χίου is presented, and possible translations are reviewed. The article presents a new hypothesis that the Ionian city of Erythrae was the place of the ship’s landing. It closes with a brief history of Erythrae’s significance in the Greco-Roman world and why a stop there by Paul’s coasting vessel was likely during this part of the journey. 1. INTRODUCTION This article discusses a pericope in the Acts of the Apostles that recounts the sea portion of Paul’s third journey.1 It first argues that the traditional author Luke2 cast the account in a genre well known to his audience – the 1 I wish to thank Dr. Linford Stutzman and Dr. Dan Davis, both scholars who have sailed the Aegean waters described in this article, for their helpful comments on an earlier draft.
    [Show full text]