Research Paper
GEOSPHERE Evolution of the Jura-Cretaceous North American Cordilleran margin: Insights from detrital-zircon U-Pb and Hf isotopes of GEOSPHERE; v. 13, no. 6 sedimentary units of the North Cascades Range, Washington doi:10.1130/GES01501.1 Kirsten B. Sauer1, Stacia M. Gordon1, Robert B. Miller2, Jeffrey D. Vervoort3, and Christopher M. Fisher3 12 figures; 3 tables; 1 supplemental file 1Department of Geological Sciences, University of Nevada, Reno, 1664 N. Virginia Street, Reno, Nevada 89557, USA 2Department of Geology, San Jose State University, One Washington Square, San Jose, California 95192-0102, USA 3School of the Environment, Washington State University, P.O. Box 642812, Pullman, Washington 99164-2812, USA CORRESPONDENCE: kirsten.b.sauer@gmail.com
CITATION: Sauer, K.B., Gordon, S.M., Miller, R.B., ABSTRACT sedimentary basins (e.g., Saleeby and Busby-Spera, 1992; Dickinson, 2004). Vervoort, J.D., and Fisher, C.M., 2017, Evolution of the Jura-Cretaceous North American Cordilleran The U-Pb age spectra of detrital zircons from western North American Cordi margin: Insights from detrital-zircon U-Pb and Hf The U-Pb age and Hf-isotope composition of detrital zircons from Jurassic lleran sedimentary rocks have been used to help understand episodic high-flux isotopes of sedimentary units of the North Cas- to Upper Cretaceous sedimentary rocks adjacent to the southern North Cas- magmatism (Paterson and Ducea, 2015), the timing at which sediment sources cades Range, Washington: Geosphere, v. 13, no. 6, p. 2094–2118, doi:10.1130/GES01501.1. cades–Coast Plutonic Complex continental magmatic arc document shifting were uplifted and when basins subsided (e.g., DeGraaff-Surpless et al., 2003; provenance, the tectonic evolution of the arc system, and translation along Laskowski et al., 2013; Surpless et al., 2014), paleogeography, and terrane Received 20 January 2017 the continental margin. Systematic changes in the detrital-zircon data pro- mobility (e.g., Gehrels et al., 1995; Housen and Beck, 1999; Barbeau et al., Revision received 12 June 2017 vide insight that the western margin of North America evolved from: marginal 2005). Hafnium-isotope analyses of detrital zircons are used as an additional Accepted 25 July 2017 basins adjacent to continent-fringing oceanic arcs (ca. 160–140 Ma); forearc fingerprint of sedimentary provenance (e.g., Gehrels and Pecha, 2014; Surpless Published online 2 October 2017 basins adjacent to mid-Cretaceous (ca. 120–90 Ma) Andean-type continental et al., 2014; Holland et al., 2015) by comparing to zircon Hf-isotope compo- arcs; and addition of a cratonic source to forearc and accretionary wedge units sitions of potential source rocks (e.g., Goodge and Vervoort, 2006; Gaschnig to Cordilleran arc systems in the mid-Late Cretaceous (ca. 85 Ma). Jurassic et al., 2011; Lackey et al., 2012; Shaw et al., 2014). Methow terrane, Nooksack Formation, and western mélange belt units domi- Controversy surrounds the Late Cretaceous tectonic history of northwest- nantly contain detrital zircons derived from accreted oceanic terranes, whereas ern North America, with many studies suggesting significant terrane transla- Lower Cretaceous strata from the same units have age peaks that correspond tion for parts of the Insular and Intermontane superterranes and the plutonic to known pulses of magmatism in Cordilleran continental magmatic arc sys- rocks of the Coast Plutonic Complex–North Cascades range that separate the tems. The age peaks and Hf-isotope signature of the Jurassic and Lower Cre- two superterranes (e.g., Monger et al., 1982; Cowan et al., 1997) (Fig. 1). Early taceous strata are comparable to multiple sources exposed along the margin. paleomagnetic studies of the Cretaceous plutonic and sedimentary rocks In contrast, the Upper Cretaceous western mélange belt has distinct Precam- suggested that the Insular superterrane and Coast Plutonic Complex–North brian zircon populations and unradiogenic Late Cretaceous zircons that are Cascades formed ~2500–3000 km to the south relative to the North American more similar to southwestern than northwestern Laurentian sources. Statisti- craton and were translated to the north between ca. 90–55 Ma (the “Baja-BC” cal comparisons confirm provenance similarities between rocks of the North hypothesis; Beck et al., 1981; Umhoefer, 1987; Ague and Brandon, 1996; Enkin Cascades and those 700–2000 km to the south and, thus, support margin- et al., 2001). More recent paleomagnetic studies interpret moderate (~1600– parallel translation from as far as the latitude of southern California. 2000 km) translation of these same rocks from reconstructions based on a combination of corrections to the paleomagnetic data and known fault offsets (Kim and Kodama, 2004; Krijgsman and Tauxe, 2006; Umhoefer and Blakey, INTRODUCTION 2006; Rusmore et al., 2013). Conversely, evidence from measured lateral off- sets on faults as well as stratigraphic correlations between similar packages Sedimentary basins associated with ancient arc systems arguably yield a of rocks indicate significantly less (<1000 km) northward translation (Price and more detailed history of arc evolution compared to arc volcanic components, Carmichael, 1986; Monger, 1997; Wyld et al., 2006). In comparison, paleomag- which are typically not preserved, or the plutonic rocks, which are variably netic signatures of rocks in the Intermontane superterrane, located to the east eroded and exposed (Gehrels, 2014). Jurassic to Eocene convergence along the of the Coast Plutonic Complex–North Cascades arc, suggest they originated For permission to copy, contact Copyright western margin of the North American continent resulted in the accretion of ~1100 km to the south of their current position relative to the North American Permissions, GSA, or [email protected]. multiple oceanic-arc terranes, intrusion of arc plutons, and formation of large craton (Irving et al., 1995; Symons et al., 2005).
© 2017 Geological Society of America
GEOSPHERE | Volume 13 | Number 6 Sauer et al. | Evolution of the North American Cordilleran margin Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/13/6/2094/3990859/2094.pdf 2094 by guest on 26 September 2021 Research Paper
Chugach- The North Cascades range is located at the southern end of the “Baja-BC” Prince William Terrane block and the Jurassic to Eocene Coast Plutonic Complex–North Cascades AK continental magmatic arc, which stretches from Alaska to Washington (Fig. 1). Accretionary The crystalline core of the North Cascades arc system is juxtaposed with co- Complexes eval sedimentary units and Paleozoic and Mesozoic tectonostratigraphic ter- Jurassic to Eocene forearc/backarc basins ranes by major dextral strike-slip structures, the Ross Lake fault zone to the Jurassic to Eocene east and the Straight Creek fault to the west (Misch, 1966; Monger, 1986; Miller YK magmatic arc North American and Bowring, 1990; Umhoefer and Miller, 1996; Gordon et al., 2010). The sedi- passive margin mentary units and terranes, from west to east, are grouped into: (1) the west- BC Inter Insular superterrane ern mélange belt (WMB), representative of accretionary-wedge material that
montane Intermontane is outboard of the arc; (2) the northwest Cascades thrust system (NWCS) and Insula superterrane its footwall sedimentary rocks, presently in a forearc position to the arc; and Paleozoic-Jurassic arc r terranes (3) the Methow terrane, which was formed as a forearc basin but was jux- ST Cordilleran taposed with the eastern, inboard boundary of the North Cascades core by foreland the Late Cretaceous (Miller, 1994) (Fig. 2). These packages of rocks are fault- Sevier thrust belt bounded, and all include sediment that was deposited before and during the Coast Undifferentiated interval when proposed terrane translation was occurring (ca. 90–55 Ma) (e.g., Plutonic Pacific Complex Misch, 1966; Brandon et al., 1988; Hurlow, 1993; Tabor, 1994; Umhoefer, 2003; QU plate Brown and Gehrels, 2007; Brown, 2012). Thus, the sedimentary rocks surround- Figure 1. Generalized geologic map of western North America highlighting the ing the North Cascades core likely contain valuable information about their WR major tectonic elements of the Cordilleran provenance, which may provide insight into terrane-translation hypotheses. Nanaimo arc system and the sedimentary units ad NWCS Methow This study uses U-Pb and Hf-isotope analyses of detrital zircons from accre- jacent to the different arc belts (modified CANADA tionary-wedge and forearc-basin deposits inboard and outboard of the North from Yonkee and Weil, 2015). BM—Blue U.S.A. Mountains; FB—Foothills Belt; HB—Horn WMB Belt Cascades crystalline core to interpret the Jurassic–Late Cretaceous tectonic North brook Basin; KM—Klamath Mountains; Cascades Supergroup history surrounding the arc (Fig. 2). The new zircon analyses presented here QU—Quesnellia; NWCS—Northwest Cas Juan de WA Lehmhi are used to evaluate potential source terranes for these sediments and are cades thrust system; SAFZ—San Andreas Fuca plate subbasin fault zone; ST—Stikine terrane; WMB— Cenozoic compared to previous detrital-zircon and Hf-isotope studies of the western cover western mélange belt; WR—Wrangellia. MT BM Cordillera to evaluate terrane translation. Idaho Batholith HB KM OR ID GEOLOGIC SETTING CA NV WY The western margin of the North American continent experienced multi- UT North UST FB ple episodes of accretion of oceanic-arc terranes, batholith emplacement, and American THR Franciscan Great sedimentation in large basins during Jurassic to Eocene convergence (e.g., Complex passive margin Saleeby and Busby-Spera, 1992; Dickinson, 2008). Voluminous magmatism Valley SEVIER is represented by the Peninsular Ranges batholith (e.g., Silver and Chappell, Colorado Sierra 1988; Busby, 2004; Morton et al., 2014), Sierra Nevada batholith (e.g., Bateman, Nevada AZ Plateau PACIFIC Salinian Block 1992; Coleman and Glazner, 1997; Cecil et al., 2012), Idaho batholith (e.g., Hynd- OCEAN Mojave man, 1983; Gaschnig et al., 2009), and plutons that form the Coast Plutonic SAFZ Desert Yavapai-Mazatzal basement Complex–North Cascades range (e.g., Barker and Arth, 1984; Gehrels et al., 2009; Miller et al., 2009) (Fig. 1). Coeval Jurassic–Eocene sedimentary units
Bisbee basin deposited during arc activity are preserved along the present-day North Amer- U.S.A. ican margin. Accretionary complexes, such as the Franciscan Complex (Hamil- N Peninsular Ranges MEXICO ton, 1969; Blake et al., 1988; Ernst, 2011), western mélange belt (Jett and Heller, 500 km 1988; Tabor et al., 1993, 2003), and Chugach–Prince William terrane (Plafker et al., 1994; Kusky et al., 1997; Cowan, 2003) were assembled near the sub-
GEOSPHERE | Volume 13 | Number 6 Sauer et al. | Evolution of the North American Cordilleran margin Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/13/6/2094/3990859/2094.pdf 2095 by guest on 26 September 2021 Research Paper
NC-667
Nanaimo CANADA NC-666 Group 49°N U.S.A. Nooksack-1 BR Okanogan CN CH Range P A NK HF a BP s Northern a Ross Lak y t Figure 2. Simplified geologic map of EA subterrane e n EA northwestern Washington and southern A F ′ a British Columbia showing Jurassic to Paleo e fault MT u SK13-20 l NWCS CH t cene sedimentary basins adjacent to the North Cascades continental magmatic arc z one SK13-06 Straight Creek fa and where samples were collected (black SAN JUAN EA boxes for this study; white boxes from pre ISLANDS HH SK13-05 DDMFZ SK13-01 vious work [see text]). Lines A–A′ and B–B′ EM Southern represent the location of cross sections Chuckanut subterrane shown in Figure 4. BR—Bridge River Hoza Formation NORTH CASCADES meen; BP—Bell Pass mélange; CH—Chilli WMB CRYSTALLINE wack Group; CN—Chuckanut Formation; ult B Nanaimo Group B ′ DDMFZ—Darrington–Devil’s Mountain
15-28AF zon CORE fault zone; EA—Easton Suite; EM—eastern Helena-Haystack 14-39S mélange belt; HF—Hozameen fault; HH— e Helena Haystack mélange; IO—Ingalls Nooksack 13-35J 48°N Formation WMB-1 Ophiolite; WMB—western mélange belt; MT—Methow terrane; NK—Nooksack NWCS Formation; NWCS—Northwest Cascades Cenozoic 08-45J thrust system. Compiled from Brown and Accretionary Cover wedge Gehrels (2007), Miller et al. (2009), and Seattle DeGraaff-Surpless et al. (2003). Methow Crystalline rocks N (undifferentiated) Cenozoic crystalline IO rocks 122º 25 km
122°W 120°W
duction trench of the active Mesozoic arcs (Fig. 1). Sediment also accumulated the suture zone between the allochthonous Paleozoic and Mesozoic rocks that in forearc basins, including the Great Valley sequence (Dickinson, 1995), the make up the Wrangellia and Alexander terranes of the Insular superterrane and Hornbrook Formation (Nilsen, 1984), the Methow terrane (Tennyson and Cole, the Quesnel, Cache Creek, and Stikinia terranes within the Intermontane super- 1978), and the Nanaimo Group (Mustard et al., 1995), and in backarc basins, terrane (Fig. 1; e.g., Monger et al., 1982, 1994). such as the McCoy-Bisbee basin (Barth et al., 2004) and the Gravina belt (Craw- ford et al., 1987) (Fig. 1). Detrital zircons from these sediments reveal distinct Sedimentary Units Adjacent to the North Cascades “detrital-zircon facies,” which relate changes in detrital-zircon age character- istics to evolving tectonic setting (LaMaskin, 2012). For example, pre-Middle The Methow terrane (Barksdale, 1975), the northwest Cascades thrust sys- Jurassic rocks have Precambrian detrital zircons with a transcontinental (Ap- tem (Misch, 1966; Brandon et al., 1988; Brown and Gehrels, 2007), the western palachian orogeny) age signature, whereas younger (Jurassic to Cretaceous) mélange belt (Frizzell et al., 1987; Tabor et al., 1993), and the Nanaimo Group rocks have dominantly Mesozoic detrital zircons that reflect the development mainly contain volcanic and plutonic sedimentary detritus (Jett and Heller, of an Andean-type continental margin (LaMaskin, 2012). 1988; Mustard, 1994; DeGraaff-Surpless et al., 2003; Brown and Gehrels, 2007; Plutonic and metamorphic rocks of the Coast Plutonic Complex–North Cas- Brown, 2012; Surpless et al., 2014). The NWCS and WMB were amalgamated cades Range stretch ~1800 km from northern Washington to Alaska and are with the Insular superterrane by the Late Cretaceous (Misch, 1966; Brown, the result of subduction-related plutonism and the development of an Andean- 1987; Brandon et al., 1988), whereas the Methow terrane lies between the plu- type arc from ca. 160–48 Ma (Gehrels et al., 2009). Plutons of this arc intruded tonic rocks of the Coast Plutonic Complex–North Cascades and Intermontane
GEOSPHERE | Volume 13 | Number 6 Sauer et al. | Evolution of the North American Cordilleran margin Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/13/6/2094/3990859/2094.pdf 2096 by guest on 26 September 2021 Research Paper
superterrane (Monger et al., 1982). All of these units are separated from the Methow Terrane exhumed crystalline core of the arc by major dextral strike-slip faults––the Straight Creek fault to the west and the Ross Lake fault zone to the east (Fig. 2; The Methow terrane contains a thick sequence of Jurassic to Cretaceous Misch, 1966; Miller and Bowring, 1990; Miller, 1994; Umhoefer and Miller, 1996; sedimentary and lesser volcanic rocks deposited on Triassic oceanic basalts. Baldwin et al., 1997; Gordon et al., 2010). Each unit is discussed in detail below The terrane is located to the east of the crystalline core and is bounded by the and summarized in Table 1. Ross Lake and Hozameen fault zones to the west and the Pasayten fault to
TAB E 1. SEDIMENTAR UNITS ADJACENT TO THE NORTH CASCADES Unit nomenclature Description
Metho terrane Northern subterrane Spider Peak Formation Early Tr iassic ophiolitic greenstone and chert. adner Group Boston Bar Formation Early to Middle Jurassic marine argillite, siltstone, lithic sandstone, minor conglomerate. De dney Creek Formation Middle to ate Jurassic marine coarse grained sandstone, conglomerate, siltstone, pyroclastic rocks, volcanic flo s. Southern subterrane Ne by Group Middle Jurassic –Early Cretaceous base not e posed marine sedimentary rocks including black argillite, volcanic sandstone, tuff, and breccia. Cretaceous overlap assemblage Jackass Mountain Group Early Cretaceous pro imal marine and deltaic medium- to coarse-grained arkosic and volcaniclastic sandstone. Pasayten Group Mid- to ate Cretaceous shallo marine and fluvial chert, lithic, and arkosic sandstones, conglomerates, and lesser andesitic volcanic flo s. Goat Wall Unit ate Cretaceous non-marine volcanics and volcaniclastic sandstones Foot all and nappes of the north est Cascades thrust system Footwall (autochthon) Wrangellia Paleozoic and Tr iassic composite terrane consisting of oceanic flood basalts and marine sedimentary rocks. Wells Creek volcanic member Early Jurassic dacite, volcanic breccia, and tuff ith small amounts of interbedded argillite; oceanic-arc provenance. Nooksack Formation ate Jurassic–Early Cretaceous marine island-arc deposits of volcaniclastic sandstone and argillite. Components of the NWCS§§ ello Aster Comple Early to mid-Paleozoic allochthonous terrane composed of gneisses and plutonic rocks. Bell Pass m lange ate Jurassic to Early Cretaceous heterogeneous assemblage of rocks including metagabbro, metatonalite, silicic gneiss, amphibolite gneiss, uartzite, schist, and ultramafic rocks. Easton metamorphic suite ate Jurassic to Early Cretaceous greenschist, amphibolite, ultramafics, and phyllite i.e., Darrington Phyllite ummi Formation ate Jurassic ocean floor and trench deposits consisting of volcanic- and chert-rich gray acke turbidites. Constitution Formation ate Jurassic trench deposits of volcanic-rich sandstone and siltstone ith interlayered chert and oceanic basalt. Fidalgo Comple ate Jurassic arc-related ophiolitic rocks ith volcanic-lithic gray acke deposited on top. Overlap between Wrangellia and NWCS Nanaimo Group Cretaceous to Paleogene marine and non-marine foreland basin sandstone and conglomerate. Accretionary edge: estern m lange belt Western m lange belt Cretaceous –Paleogene accretionary edge containing blocks of sandstone, Jurassic gabbro-tonalite, and lesser limestone and chert in an argillite matri . Note: Only describes units mentioned in the te t. NWCS North est Cascades thrust system. Ray 1990 . Mahoney 1993 . Mahoney et al. 2002 . Tennyson and Cole 1978 ; DeGraaff-Surpless et al. 2003 ; Haugerud et al. 1996 . Monger and Journeay 1994 . Misch 1966 , Tabor et al. 2003 . Tabor et al. 2002 ; Bro n and Gehrels 2007 . Mustard et al. 1995 . Tabor et al. 2002 ; Bro n 2012 .
GEOSPHERE | Volume 13 | Number 6 Sauer et al. | Evolution of the North American Cordilleran margin Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/13/6/2094/3990859/2094.pdf 2097 by guest on 26 September 2021 Research Paper
the east (Fig. 2). The Methow terrane is interpreted to have been deposited in a Formation (Coates, 1974; Mahoney, 1993). The lowest unit of the southern sub- forearc basin (Coates, 1974; Barksdale, 1975), but it reached its current inboard terrane is the Jurassic Newby Group, which includes the lower Newby Group position with respect to the North Cascades by ca. 92 Ma, when it was intruded (Twisp Formation) and the upper Newby Group (Barksdale, 1975; McGroder by the Black Peak pluton (Miller, 1994; Shea et al., 2016). The Triassic–Jurassic et al., 1990). The base of the Newby Group is not exposed. The Newby and base of the Methow terrane is divided into northern and southern subterranes Ladner Groups consist of volcanic-lithic, marine sandstones and black shales, (Fig. 3; McGroder, 1988). Oceanic basalt of the Lower Triassic Spider Peak For- and lesser volcanic rocks (Coates, 1974; Barksdale, 1975; O’Brien, 1986; Tabor mation is the basement in the northern subterrane (Ray, 1986, 1990). The Lower et al., 1989). The Thunder Lake sequence contains sandstone and shale that to Middle Jurassic Ladner Group is unconformable on the Spider Peak For- were disconformably deposited on the Ladner Group in the northern subter- mation and includes the Boston Bar Formation and overlying Dewdney Creek rane (Coates, 1974). The Hauterivian to Albian Jackass Mountain Group overlaps both subter- ranes, and the correlative early to middle Albian Harts Pass Formation is pres- ent in the southern subterrane (Coates, 1974; McGroder et al., 1990). The Jack- ass Mountain Group is dominantly composed of marine and marine-marginal Goat Wall unit feldspathic sandstone (Barksdale, 1975; DeGraaff-Surpless et al., 2003). The at e Harts Pass Formation is composed of east-derived sandstone and siltstone Virginian Ridge Winthrop (Tennyson and Cole, 1978). The Middle to Upper Cretaceous Pasayten Group Formation Formation lies above the Jackass Mountain Group and Harts Pass Formation and includes Grou p
Pasayten SK13-01 the westerly-derived, marginal-marine, Cenomanian(?) to Turonian Virginian Ridge Formation (black shale and chert-pebble conglomerate) that interfingers Jackass Mtn Cretaceous with the easterly-derived, non-marine Albian to Turonian Winthrop Formation Harts Pass Group (undivided) Frm (arkosic sandstone) (Tennyson and Cole, 1978; Kiessling and Mahoney, 1997;
Earl yL DeGraaff-Surpless et al., 2003). The Turonian to Coniacian Goat Wall unit is stratigraphically above the Pasayten Group and includes volcaniclastic sedi- mentary rocks and andesites (Haugerud et al., 1996; Enkin et al., 2002). upper Newby Thunder Lake seq. A number of studies have focused on the Cretaceous Winthrop and Harts
p Group Pass Formations, including paleocurrent, sandstone petrography, paleomag- Figure 3. Schematic diagram of the Dewdney at e stratigraphy exposed in the northern SK13-06 Creek netic, detrital zircon, and paleofloral investigations (Fig. 3; Coates, 1974; Garver, and southern Methow subterranes. Formation lower Newby 1992; Garver and Brandon, 1994; Kiessling and Mahoney, 1997; DeGraaff- Gray fill indicates an unconformity, NC-667 Group Surpless et al., 2003; Miller et al., 2006; Surpless et al., 2014). DeGraaff-Surpless and yellow stars designate the approx Newby Grou imate location of analyzed samples. (Twisp NC-666 et al. (2003) and Surpless et al. (2014) interpret that the Jackass Mountain and Modified after Haugerud et al. (1996) iddle Formation) Pasayten Groups were derived from proximal sources located to the east of the and Surpless et al. (2014). Jurassi c Base not exposed basin based on detrital-zircon peaks of ca. 160–150 and 120–110 Ma with very Ladner Group Boston Bar Formation minimal (<1%) input from inboard cratonic or recycled sedimentary sources. Possible sources of these zircons include the eastern belt of the Coast Plutonic Complex and/or the Okanogan Range, a ca. 120–110 Ma plutonic complex lo- Earl yL cated to the east (Surpless et al., 2014). In comparison to the Cretaceous strata, there have been no detrital-zircon analyses of the Jurassic Methow strata. Fossil evidence suggests Lower to Middle Jurassic ages for the Ladner Group (Coates, 1974; Mahoney, 1993). Lat eM Moreover, a plutonic clast from the Dewdney Creek Formation yields a U-Pb multi-grain isotope dilution-thermal ionization mass spectrometry (ID-TIMS)
riassic zircon age of ca. 235 Ma; the clast is interpreted to be derived from the Quesnel Middle
T ? terrane to the east of the Methow terrane (O’Brien et al., 1992). From the south- Spider Peak ern Methow subterrane, the Twisp Formation is intruded by the ca. 142 Ma
Early Formation Alder Creek stock, indicating that the Formation is older than earliest Creta- Southern Methow Northern Methow ceous (U-Pb isotope dilution–thermal ionization mass spectrometry zircon; subterrane subterrane Mahoney et al., 2002).
GEOSPHERE | Volume 13 | Number 6 Sauer et al. | Evolution of the North American Cordilleran margin Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/13/6/2094/3990859/2094.pdf 2098 by guest on 26 September 2021 Research Paper
Northwest Cascades Thrust System thought to be autochthonous, and the clastic rocks are potentially fan deposits of a volcanic arc associated with Wrangellia (Sondergaard, 1979; Brown and The NWCS is a fault-bounded nappe stack located to the northeast of the Gehrels, 2007). The Nooksack Formation was deposited by ca. 114 Ma based Darrington–Devil’s Mountain fault zone and to the west of the Straight Creek on the youngest population of detrital zircons in a sandstone near the top of fault (Fig. 2). The nappes of the NWCS consist of Paleozoic to Mesozoic oceanic the section (Brown and Gehrels, 2007). Fossil ages are mostly between ca. and island-arc assemblages, with a large component of Jurassic–Early Cre- 155–130 Ma (Tabor et al., 2003). taceous immature, oceanic clastic strata that have experienced multiple epi- The emplacement of the NWCS nappes on the Nooksack Formation oc- sodes of accretion and subduction-zone metamorphism (Brandon et al., 1988; curred after deposition of the sandstone within the Bell Pass mélange and, Brown and Gehrels, 2007). thus, has been loosely bracketed to ca. 114–59 Ma (Tabor, 1994; Brown and Sedimentary components of the nappes, including the Lummi Formation, Gehrels, 2007). However, the majority of thrusting is generally interpreted to Constitution Formation, Easton Metamorphic Suite, and the Fidalgo Com- have occurred by the beginning of the Late Cretaceous (Misch, 1966; Brandon plex dominantly have unimodal detrital-zircon populations between ca. 160– et al., 1988; McGroder, 1991). 140 Ma that are interpreted to be arc-derived and close to their depositional ages (ca. 150–135 Ma; Brown and Gehrels, 2007). The Bell Pass mélange con- sists of an oceanic chert, basalt, argillite, and graywacke matrix with blocks of Nanaimo Group the same lithologies as well as large tectonic blocks of the Twin Sisters Dunite, Baker Lake Blueschist, and Yellow Aster Complex (Brown, 1987; Tabor et al., The Nanaimo Group is an Upper Cretaceous overlap sequence consisting 2003). The latter complex is also found as tectonic lenses within the Bell Pass of dominantly marine and non-marine clastic sediments that were deposited mélange and includes Paleozoic and Neoproterozoic feldspathic and calc-sili unconformably on Wrangellia to the west and the Coast Plutonic Complex to cate gneisses with lesser ultramafite (Misch, 1966). A sandstone of the Bell the east, and the sequence is in fault contact with the NWCS (Mustard, 1994) Pass mélange contains both arc-related Mesozoic detrital zircons and Precam- (Figs. 1 and 2). Portions of the NWCS and Nanaimo Group share a similar brian zircons that may have been derived from the Yellow Aster Complex or provenance based on the presence of similar quartz arenite clasts in both units North American passive margin rocks (Brown and Gehrels, 2007). In compar- (Garver, 1988) and cobbles probably derived from the Yellow Aster Complex in ison, Yellow Aster Complex paragneisses are characterized by Paleozoic and the Nanaimo Group (Brown, 2012). The Nanaimo Group sediments deposited Precambrian detrital zircons and were likely derived from the passive margin before the early Campanian (ca. 80–72 Ma) are characterized by a Mesozoic or outboard terranes of the North American Cordillera (Brown and Gehrels, detrital-zircon signature, whereas younger Nanaimo units have a mix of Juras- 2007) or northeastern Laurentian sources (Schermer et al., 2015). sic to Cretaceous arc-related ages as well as Proterozoic dates (Mustard et al., The Nooksack Formation is exposed in the footwall of the nappe stack 2006; Mahoney et al., 2014; Matthews et al., 2017). The appearance of Protero- (Fig. 4) and is a thick sequence of slaty to phyllitic, marine sandstones and zoic zircons in the latest Cretaceous strata has been linked to uplift and erosion argillites (Misch, 1966; Tabor et al., 2003). The ca. 180–175 Ma (J.M. Mattin- of potential sources in the Belt Supergroup region to the east (Mustard et al., son reported in Franklin, 1985) Wells Creek Volcanic Member is found at the 2006; Mahoney et al., 2014) or in the Mojave terrane in southwestern Laurentia base of the unit (Misch, 1966; Tabor et al., 2003). The Nooksack Formation is (Matthews et al., 2017).
NC northwest Cascades thrust system SK13-20 BP core NA SJI nappes CN SCFZ Figure 4. Schematic cross section of the Northwest Cascades (NC) BP EA EA NK CH thrust system (simplified from Brandon et al. [1988] and Brown and CH Gehrels [2007]) and western mélange belt (simplified fromTabor WR ? (Footwall) et al. [2003]) showing the units that are contained within individ ual nappes. Approximate sample locations are designated by the A A′ yellow stars. BP—Bell Pass mélange; CH—Chilliwack Group; CN— DDMFZ EA Chuckanut Formation; DDMFZ—Darrington–Devil’s Mountain fault WMB
SCFZ zone; EA—Easton Metamorphic Suite; EMB—eastern mélange belt; Depositional contact HH—Helena Haystack mélange; NA—Nanaimo Group; NK—Nook Fault contact ? 14-39S 13-35J HH EA CH sack Formation; SCFZ—Straight Creek fault zone; SJI—San Juan Inferred contact EMB Islands; WMB—western mélange belt; WR—Wrangellia.
B B′ not to scale
GEOSPHERE | Volume 13 | Number 6 Sauer et al. | Evolution of the North American Cordilleran margin Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/13/6/2094/3990859/2094.pdf 2099 by guest on 26 September 2021 Research Paper
Western Mélange Belt nated significant distances (~1600–2000 km) to the south and were adjacent to the southern Sierra Nevada in the Late Cretaceous (Kim and Kodama, 2004; The WMB is an accretionary complex separated from the NWCS by the Krijgsman and Tauxe, 2006). Furthermore, the presence of Archean detrital zir- Darrington-Devil’s Mountain fault zone (Fig. 2). The accretionary wedge was as- cons (older than ca. 2.5 Ga) in the Nanaimo Group has been used to argue for sembled by ca. 59 Ma, when the nonmarine Chuckanut Formation was depos- (Housen and Beck, 1999) and against (Mahoney et al., 1999) translation. ited on top of the WMB (Eddy et al., 2015). The WMB is dominantly composed In contrast, others emphasize that the known displacements on large of a weakly metamorphosed argillite and graywacke matrix that hosts blocks strike-slip faults in the region are much too small for the necessary translation of marble, metagabbro, sandstone, metadiabase, and chert (Tabor et al., 1989, indicated by the paleomagnetic data (e.g., Monger and Price, 1996). Recon- 1993). The sandstones of the WMB are divided into three petrofacies: arkosic, structions that rely on known fault offsets can account for ~700 km of dis- lithic, and chert-rich (Jett and Heller, 1988). Based on lithologic similarities, the placement for rocks of the Insular superterrane in northwestern Washington WMB has been compared to the Franciscan Complex (Jett and Heller, 1988) (e.g., Wyld et al., 2006). The reconstructions of Wyld et al. (2006) place the WMB and the Methow terrane (Garver, 1988). Detrital zircons have been analyzed and Nanaimo Basin at the latitude of the Klamath Mountains and northern from three arkosic sandstones and two lithic sandstones of the WMB; our U-Pb Sierra Nevada and the Methow terrane to the north of the Hornbrook-Ochoco results from two WMB samples were previously reported in Dragovich et al. basins at ca. 100 Ma. This more moderate ~700 km displacement is consistent (2014) and Dragovich et al. (2015). Maximum depositional ages (MDA) are re- with lithologic and detrital-zircon data that suggest various components of the calculated here for the detrital-zircon data reported in Dragovich et al. (2014), NWCS nappes formed at the latitude of the Klamath Mountains (Brown, 1987; Dragovich et al. (2015), and Dragovich et al. (2016) using the youngest three Brandon et al., 1988; Brown and Gehrels, 2007; MacDonald et al., 2008). These analyses that overlap at 2-sigma uncertainty to be consistent with this and hypotheses of paleogeography and magnitude of terrane translation can be other studies. The arkoses have dates from and MDAs of: (1) ca. 230 to 87 Ma further evaluated, and potentially refined, with U-Pb and Hf-isotope investi- and ca. 89 Ma (08-45J; Dragovich et al., 2009); (2) ca. 2.3 Ga to 84 Ma and gations of detrital zircon from samples from the Methow terrane, NWCS, and ca. 87 Ma (WMB-1; Brown, 2012); and (3) ca. 2.1 Ga to 69 Ma and ca. 72 Ma WMB. These data are the first Hf-isotope characterization of the WMB, NWCS, (13-35J; our data reported in Dragovich et al., 2014), respectively. One lithic and the Jurassic strata of the Methow terrane. Comparison of the Cascades sample has a unimodal age population centered at ca. 167 Ma and an MDA of U-Pb and Hf data are used to assess possible sedimentary sources, and the ca. 152 Ma (15-28AF; Dragovich et al., 2016). The second lithic sandstone yields relationship of these sedimentary units to each other, and to basins located at dates between ca. 2.1 Ga and 107 Ma with an MDA of ca. 109 Ma (14-39S; our different latitudes in the present-day North American Cordillera. data reported in Dragovich et al., 2015). The Jurassic to Cretaceous detrital zir- cons from all samples are interpreted to be derived from arc-related sources, METHODS whereas Precambrian zircons in the arkoses with Late Cretaceous MDAs indi- cate a combination of arc and inboard sources (Dragovich et al., 2009; Drago Samples were collected for detrital-zircon U-Pb and Hf-isotope analyses vich et al., 2016; Brown, 2012). from: (1) arkosic sandstones from the Winthrop Formation (SK13-01), Twisp Formation (SK13-06), and the Virginian Ridge Formation (SK13-05) and vol- Paleogeographic Reconstructions caniclastic sandstones from the Boston Bar Formation (NC-666), and Dewd- ney Creek Formation (NC-667) of the Ladner Group, all of which are from Previous investigations of the Methow terrane, NWCS, and accretionary the Methow terrane; (2) a fine-grained, arkosic sandstone (SK13-20) from the wedge units that border the North Cascades range have resulted in differing Nooksack Formation of the NWCS; and (3) an arkosic sandstone (13-35J) and a ideas of where these rocks originated. Paleomagnetic and faunal data from fine-grained lithic sandstone (14-39S) from the WMB (Fig. 2 and Table 2). the Methow terrane and Nanaimo Group suggest that these sediments may Zircon separation was performed at the University of Nevada, Reno, using have undergone large-scale translation (~2500–3000 km), i.e., the “Baja-BC standard crushing, magnetic, and heavy liquid (methylene iodide) density- hypothesis,” between ca. 90–50 Ma (Beck, 1976; Irving et al., 1985; Umhoefer, separation procedures. Grains were mounted in 1-inch epoxy rounds, which 1987; Ward et al., 1997; Miller et al., 2006). Paleomagnetic (Enkin et al., 2002), were polished to expose the approximate center of the zircon crystals. Cathodo- paleofloral (Miller et al., 2006), and zircon fission-track (Garver and Brandon, luminescence (CL) images of zircons were acquired using either a FEI Quanta 1994) results suggest that the Methow terrane formed at least 2000 km to the 400f scanning electron microscope (SEM) at the University of California–Santa south, potentially as a forearc basin to the Peninsular Ranges batholith of Barbara or a JEOL JSM-7100FT SEM at the University of Nevada, Reno. These southern California and Mexico, and reached its current latitude between 48°N images were used to guide the U-Pb and Hf-isotope analyses, ensuring that and 52°N by ca. 55 Ma (Garver and Brandon, 1994; Enkin et al., 2002). More spots were placed within discrete growth zones whenever possible (Fig. 5H). recent paleomagnetic data from the Nanaimo basin that have been corrected Both U-Pb and Hf isotopes were measured by laser-ablation, multi for depositional flattening of magnetic inclinations suggest the strata origi- collector, inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA-MC-ICPMS).
GEOSPHERE | Volume 13 | Number 6 Sauer et al. | Evolution of the North American Cordilleran margin Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/13/6/2094/3990859/2094.pdf 2100 by guest on 26 September 2021 Research Paper
TABLE 2. SAMPLE LOCATIONS AND DESCRIPTIONS Location Major U-Pb zircon Maximum Sample No. of date peaks depositional age number UnitRock type UTM E UTM N zircons (Ma) (Ma)
Backarc (Methow terrane) SK13-01Pasayten Group Arkosic 701854 5361821162 115, 160105 ± 2 (Winthrop Formation) sandstone SK13-06 Newby Group Arkosic 709572 537030527155 152 ± 3 (Twisp Formation) sandstone NC-666 Ladner Group Volcaniclastic 641480 5454576100 170165 ± 4 (Boston Bar Formation) sandstone Forearc (northwest Cascades thrust system) SK13-20 Nooksack Fine-grained 595062 5389431114 155145 ± 3 Formation sandstone Accretionary wedge (western mélange belt) 13-35J Arkosic Arkosic 591595304985129 74, 90, 165, 72 ± 2 petrofacies sandstone 190, 1400, 1700 14-39S Lithic Lithic 582117 5308085145 110, 160, 180 109 ± 3 petrofacies sandstone
The zircon U-Th-Pb isotopes were measured first at the University of Califor- rates and Faraday-cup configurations for the mass spectrometer followed the nia–Santa Barbara using a Nu Instruments Plasma HR MC-ICP-MS coupled parameters described in Fisher et al. (2014b). Plesovice (176Hf/177Hf = 0.282482 ± with a 193 nm Photon Machines excimer laser. A spot size of ~15–24 µm was 12, Sláma et al., 2008) was used as the primary standard, and FC-1 (176Hf/177Hf = used with a laser fluence of 3–4 J/cm2, producing an ablation pit depth of ~6–10 0.282183 ± 12, Fisher et al., 2014a) and GJ-1 (176Hf/177Hf = 0.282000 ± 23, Morel µm (60–100 shots/analysis). Samples were bracketed every 6–8 analyses with et al., 2008) were used as the secondary standards. Measured 176Hf/177Hf val- the standards 91500 (1062.4 ± 0.4 Ma, primary standard; Wiedenbeck et al., ues for the secondary standards were 0.282180 ± 65 (n = 29) and 0.282010 ± 1995) and GJ1 (608.5 ± 0.4 Ma, secondary standard; Jackson et al., 2004). The 35 (n = 32), respectively. Hafnium-isotope ratios were normalized relative to average measured value for secondary standard GJ1 was 599 ± 11 (n = 105). 176Hf/177Hf = 0.282482 for Plesovice (Sláma et al., 2008). Data reduction and inter Data were reduced using Iolite v. 2.3 (Paton et al., 2010). Errors were calculated ference corrections followed the methods outlined in Fisher et al. (2011) and 176 177 using the reproducibility of the standards during each run but were a minimum Fisher et al. (2014b). For the calculation of εHf values and initial Hf/ Hf ratios, of 2% based on the long-term reproducibility of in-house standards. For dates we used the chondritic uniform reservoir (CHUR) Lu-Hf values of Bouvier et al. greater than 1.0 Ga, the 207Pb/206Pb age is reported, whereas the 206Pb/238U age (2008) and the 176Lu decay constant determination of Söderlund et al. (2004). is used for younger grains (cf. Gehrels et al., 2008). Data were filtered using The results are shown in Figure 6 and Supplemental Table S2 (see footnote 1). a 90% concordance filter for grains >ca. 400 Ma to eliminate dates that were highly affected by lead loss (cf. Gehrels, 2012). Maximum depositional ages U-Pb AND Hf-ISOTOPE RESULTS were estimated based on the youngest detrital-zircon age population that in- cluded at least five concordant, overlapping analyses (Dickinson andGehrels, Methow Terrane SUPPLEMENTARY DATA TABLE S2. DETRITAL ZIRCON Lu-Hf DATA Sample 176Hf/177Hfa 2 SEb176Lu/177Hf 2 SEb176Yb/177Hf 2 SEb178Hf/177Hf 2 SEb εHf(0)c 2 SE 176Hf/177Hf(i)d εHf(i)d 2 SE assigned agee 2 SE Total Hf (V)f correction (in εHf units)g
SK13-01: Winthrop Formation arkose sandstone SK13_01_2 0.282915 0.000020 0.000670.00004 0.018300.00100 1.467158 0.000027 4.60.7 0.282913 8.00.7 157321.8 678 2009). The U-Pb results are shown in kernel density estimate plots (Figs. 5A– SK13_01_4 0.282954 0.000022 0.002170.00014 0.066200.00500 1.467188 0.000028 6.00.8 0.282947 9.50.8 171425.6 2442 SK13_01_6 0.282927 0.000031 0.001160.00002 0.031880.00068 1.467166 0.000031 5.01.1 0.282924 8.41.1 155317.4 1180 SK13_01_7 0.282915 0.000029 0.001220.00005 0.036600.00110 1.467136 0.000037 4.61.0 0.2829118.1 1.0163 419.71351 SK13_01_80.2828960.0000280.00086 0.000020.02628 0.000561.4671870.0000273.9 1.00.2828946.2 1.0105 218.5969 SK13_01_90.2828940.0000230.00155 0.000130.04630 0.003501.4671730.0000283.8 0.80.2828897.2 0.8160 418.11709 1 SK13_01_100.2829960.0000240.00088 0.000010.02281 0.000471.4671770.0000247.5 0.80.282995 10.1 0.8122 319.1846 SK13_01_110.2828970.0000260.00070 0.000030.02100 0.001001.467127 0.000032 4.00.9 0.2828957.5 0.9161 416.9775 5H; Vermeesch, 2012) and in Supplemental Table S1. Detrital zircons from Jurassic to Lower Cretaceous rocks near the base of SK13_01_12 0.282904 0.000026 0.000990.00003 0.026700.00100 1.467159 0.000030 4.20.9 0.2829027.8 0.9165 416.5989 SK13_01_13 0.282863 0.000027 0.001020.00010 0.032200.00350 1.467164 0.000030 2.71.0 0.2828606.2 1.0159 416.91186 SK13_01_140.2828400.0000220.00078 0.000020.02487 0.000641.4671730.0000631.9 0.80.2828384.5 0.8119 317.1916 SK13_01_150.2829590.0000300.00199 0.000020.05160 0.001001.4671470.0000366.1 1.10.2829538.4 1.1113 319.51914 SK13_01_16 0.282896 0.000028 0.001270.00005 0.040400.00120 1.467149 0.000032 3.91.0 0.2828936.5 1.0122 317.71488 SK13_01_17 0.282875 0.000019 0.001080.00002 0.031600.00087 1.467132 0.000037 3.20.7 0.282871 6.40.7 151416.2 1167 SK13_01_18 0.282974 0.000019 0.001830.00008 0.049100.00190 1.467149 0.000026 6.70.7 0.28296910.10.7 160417.2 1819 Based on the U-Pb dates, representative zircons from significant age pop- the northern and southern subterranes of the Methow terrane have not been SK13_01_190.2829160.0000200.00119 0.000060.03540 0.002601.4671570.0000334.6 0.70.2829127.1 0.7116 316.51307 SK13_01_200.2828740.0000160.00099 0.000030.03235 0.000611.4671880.0000323.1 0.60.2828134.6 0.6163 416.51191 SK13_01_21 0.282894 0.000019 0.000390.00001 0.011020.00032 1.467183 0.000032 3.80.7 0.282870 6.30.7 147317.9 408 SK13_01_22 0.282927 0.000024 0.001380.00001 0.040100.00120 1.467149 0.000034 5.00.8 0.282842 5.30.8 150.0415.7 1482 ulations were subsequently analyzed for Hf isotopes at the Radiogenic Iso- previously characterized. Two volcaniclastic sandstones were collected from aHf isotope ratios were corrected for instrumental mass bias using 179Hf/177Hf = 0.7935. 176Hf/177Hf ratios were normalized relative to 176Hf/177Hf = 0.282482 for Plesovice (Slama et al., 2008; Fisher et al., 2014) and 176Hf/177Hf = 0.282160 for JMC-475 (Vervoort and Blichert-Toft, 1999). MunZirc-2 and MunZirc-4, a Yb-rich synthetic zircon (Fisher et al., 2011), were analyzed to assess the accuracy of the 176Yb and 176Lu interference correction in the unknowns. bUncertainties on Hf/Hf, Lu/Hf, and Yb/Hf isotope ratios are 2s standard error based on the population of measurements within an analysis. c 176 177 176 177 TheεHf values were calculated using CHUR values of Hf/ Hf = 0.282785 and Lu/ Hf = 0.0336 (Bouvier et al., 2008). d 176 177 176 -11 The initial Hf/ Hf and εHf values were calculated using the Lu decay constant (1.867*10 ) of Söderlund et al. (2004). e tope and Geochronology Laboratory (RIGL) at Washington State University. the basal clastic units of the northern subterrane (Ladner Group): one from Assigned age is based on the LA-ICP-MS U-Pb analysis of the same grain. fTotal volts of Hf isotope signal during analysis. g 176 177 176 176 Correction (in εHf units) applied to the Hf/ Hf ratio due to interference of Lu and Yb. Hafnium-isotope ratios were measured using a New Wave UP 213 Nd-YAG the Dewdney Creek Formation and the other from the Boston Bar Formation 1Supplemental Tables. Table S1: Detrital-zircon U-Pb (213 nm) laser ablation system paired with a ThermoFinnigan Neptune MC- (Fig. 3). The Dewdney Creek sample (NC-667) did not yield any zircon. Zircons data and Table S2: Detrital-zircon Lu-Hf data. Please ICPMS. A 40-µm spot was used for the Hf analyses and was placed directly on from the Boston Bar Formation sandstone (NC-666) are dominantly prismatic visit http://doi.org/10.1130/GES01501.S1 or the full- 2 text article on www.gsapubs.org to view the Supple- the smaller U-Pb ablation pit. The laser fluence was ~7 J/cm with a repetition to subrounded with oscillatory zoning (Fig. 5H). One zircon yields a ca. 97 Ma mental Tables. rate of 10 Hz, ablating a 30–40 µm deep pit. The mass spectrometer gas-flow date, whereas the rest range between ca. 226–152 Ma (n = 99), with a maxi-
GEOSPHERE | Volume 13 | Number 6 Sauer et al. | Evolution of the North American Cordilleran margin Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/13/6/2094/3990859/2094.pdf 2101 by guest on 26 September 2021 Research Paper
A 170 Ma NC-666: Boston Bar Formation n = 100 H CL images SK13-01 165 ± 4 Ma NC-666 SK13-06 7.1 ± 0.7 13.5 ± 1.0 116 ± 3 Ma 8.1 ± 0.7 155 Ma Ke B SK13-06: Twisp Formation 160 ± 4 Ma r n = 27 nel density estimate 12.9 ± 1.8 w terrane 159 ± 4 Ma 161 ± 4 Ma 173 ± 4 Ma 152 ± 3 Ma
Metho C 160 Ma SK13-01: Winthrop Formation SK13-20 14-39S n =162 13-35J Figure 5. Kernel density estimate plots for 13.1 ± 1.6 8.4 ± 0.8 186 ± 4 Ma this study’s detrital-zircon data (note the 115 Ma 164 ± 4 Ma change in scale for the x-axis at 500 Ma), 105 ± 2 Ma with the ages of the peaks and maximum depositional age and associated 2-sigma 155 Ma 166 ± 168 ± D SK13-20: Nooksack Formation 116 ± 3 Ma error labeled for samples: (A) Boston Bar 4 Ma 4 Ma 166 ± 4 Ma Formation NC-666; (B) Twisp Formation n =155 SK13-06; (C) Winthrop Formation SK13-01;
(D) Nooksack Formation SK13-20; (E) lithic NWCS petrofacies of the WMB 14-39S; (F) arkosic 145 ± 3 Ma petrofacies of the WMB 13-35J. The red E 160 Ma line indicates the maximum depositional 14-39S: lithic petrofacies 110 Ma age. (G) Cumulative-probability plot for 180 Ma n = 145 all samples. (H) Representative cathodo Scattered Paleozoic and Proterozoic dates luminescence images from each sample showing zircon texture, the laser abla 109 ± 3 Ma tion–inductively coupled plasma mass F 74 Ma spectrometry (LA-ICPMS) age, and the mélange belt 13-35J: arkosic petrofacies 1.38 Ga 90 Ma LA‑ICPMS Hf-isotope composition. The Hf n =129 spot (red) is 40 µm across and the U-Pb 1.68 Ga
este rn 165 Ma spot is 15 µm across. NWCS—Northwest 190 Ma
Cascades thrust system. W 72 ± 2 Ma G 0.8 13-35J 0.6 14-39S SK13-20 e Probability 0.4 SK13-01 SK13-06 0.2 NC-666
Cumulativ 0 // 050 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 U-Pb age (Ma)
mum depositional age (MDA) of 165 ± 4 Ma. The majority of the grains form The Twisp Formation represents the oldest clastic unit in the Newby Group a peak at ca. 170 Ma (n = 93) (Fig. 5A). Hafnium-isotope results from this ca. of the southern Methow subterrane (Fig. 3). An arkosic sandstone (SK13-06) 170 Ma population have a small range of compositions, from those charac- from this formation was relatively zircon poor, and only 27 zircons were ana
teristic of the depleted mantle with εHfi of +13.9 to slightly less radiogenic εHfi lyzed. The zircons are euhedral and have variable internal textures, from no
values of +9.6 (n = 22) (Fig. 6). One ca. 202 Ma grain has a lower εHfi of +4.6; the zoning to sector zoning and oscillatory zoning (Fig. 5H). The zircons have a ca. 97 Ma zircon was too small to analyze (<40 µm). narrow range of dates from ca. 159–150 Ma, defining a ca. 155 Ma peak and
GEOSPHERE | Volume 13 | Number 6 Sauer et al. | Evolution of the North American Cordilleran margin Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/13/6/2094/3990859/2094.pdf 2102 by guest on 26 September 2021 Research Paper
A All Hf data Analyses for grains < 300 Ma Analyses for grains > 300 Ma
10 DM
0
ε Hfi CHUR
Figure 6. Hafnium results for (A) all zircons Nooksack Formation Methow terrane from this study (note change in scale for –10 the x-axis at 300 Ma) and (B) zircons with SK13-20 (n = 14) SK13-01 (n = 19) ages <200 Ma from this study (n = num WMB SK13-06 (n = 10) ber of analyses for zircons <200 Ma), with colors for each sample corresponding 13-35J (n = 47) NC-666 (n = 22) –20 to Figure 5 and in order of older inferred 14-39S (n = 39) maximum depositional age (MDA) (red text) from left to right. In both figures, 100 200 300 1000 2000 3000 depleted mantle (DM) and chondritic uni U-Pb age (Ma) U-Pb age (Ma) form reservoir (CHUR) values are shown for reference (Vervoort and Blichert-Toft, 1999). In (A), typical 2-sigma errors are B Hf data for ages < 200 Ma smaller than each analysis point and are MDA typically ~± 1.0 epsilon unit, and in (B), the III. II. I. II. I. II. I. I. I. I. gray bars indicate the 2-sigma errors. In (B), the gray boxes correspond to key age pop ulations described in the text (I. Jurassic [190–180 Ma and 170–150 Ma], II. Mid-Cre 10 taceous [120–100 Ma], and III. Late Creta ceous [100–70 Ma]) and for the western mélange belt [WMB] samples. pf.—petro facies. 0 ε Hf i 72 ± 2 Ma
–10 105 ± 2 Ma 109 ± 3 Ma 145 ± 3 Ma 152 ± 3 Ma 165 ± 4 Ma 13-35J SK13-01 14-39S SK13-20 SK13-06 NC-666 arkosic pf. Winthrop Formation lithic pf. Nooksack Formation Twisp Formation Ladner Group (n = 26) (n = 27) –20 (n = 19) (n =14) (n = 10) (n = 22) WMB Methow WMB Nooksack Methow Methow 50 100 150 200 100 150 200 100 150 200 100 150 200 100 150 200 100 150 200 U-Pb age (Ma)
a 152 ± 3 Ma MDA (Fig. 5B). Initial εHf values form a tight cluster around near- dates show a small peak at ca. 115 Ma (n = 8) and a much larger peak at ca. depleted mantle values, from +14.0 to +12.6 (n = 10) (Fig. 6). 160 Ma (n = 101) (Fig. 5C). Zircons from both age peaks have a similar distribu-
An arkosic sandstone was collected from the Upper Winthrop Formation tion of εHfi values from +10.1 to +4.5 (n = 19) (Fig. 6). within the mid to Upper Cretaceous Pasayten Group located stratigraphically above the Twisp Formation to complement the extensive detrital-zircon data Nooksack Formation set of DeGraaff-Surpless et al. (2003) and Surpless et al. (2014) (Fig. 3). This sandstone (SK13-01) has subhedral zircons with variable internal textures, A fine-grained arkosic sandstone from the Nooksack Formation (SK13‑20) ranging from oscillatory-zoned grains to unzoned grains (Fig. 5H). The zircons (Fig. 4) was collected stratigraphically below the sample from Brown and record dates from ca. 217–103 Ma (n = 162), with an MDA of 105 ± 2 Ma. Zircon Gehrels (2007) following their structural interpretation. The zircons from the
GEOSPHERE | Volume 13 | Number 6 Sauer et al. | Evolution of the North American Cordilleran margin Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/13/6/2094/3990859/2094.pdf 2103 by guest on 26 September 2021 Research Paper
sandstone are euhedral and dominantly display oscillatory zoning (Fig. 5). DISCUSSION Dates range from ca. 182–143 Ma (n = 114), with one outlier at ca. 92 Ma. The majority of the dates cluster at ca. 155 Ma (n = 84) and yield a MDA of 145 ± Detrital-Zircon Provenance
3 Ma (Fig. 5D). Initial εHf values of zircons from the ca. 155 Ma age population cluster between +13.0 and +6.7 (n = 14) (Fig. 6). The U-Pb age data from the Methow, Nooksack Formation, and WMB sam- ples form peaks centered in four main periods: pre-Triassic (>250 Ma), Juras- sic (ca. 190–180 and ca. 170–150 Ma), mid-Cretaceous (ca. 120–100 Ma), and Late Cretaceous (ca. 100–70 Ma). The sources for these ages have been doc- Western Mélange Belt umented throughout the North American Cordillera, and their characteristic ages and Hf-isotope signatures are summarized in Table 3. The provenance for Two samples of the western mélange belt were collected from two of the the major age peaks in each sample is discussed below. three petrofacies of Jett and Heller (1988) to characterize the clastic compo- nents of the accretionary wedge: a lithic sandstone of the lithic petrofacies (14-39S) and an arkosic sandstone of the arkosic petrofacies (13-35J). Our Jurassic Units U-Pb results from these samples were previously reported in Dragovich et al. (2014) and Dragovich et al. (2015), respectively, and are summarized here All Jurassic (ca. 165–145 Ma) samples from the Methow terrane (NC-666, with the CL images and new Hf-isotope results. Sample 14-39S is a lithic MDA = ca. 165 Ma; SK13-06, MDA = ca. 152 Ma) and Nooksack Formation sandstone composed of subangular to subrounded quartz, plagioclase, and (SK13-20, MDA = ca. 145 Ma) of this study are characterized by unimodal volcanic-lithic fragments (Dragovich et al., 2015). Zircons from the lithic sand- detrital-zircon age peaks (ca. 170–150 Ma). Hafnium isotopes from these zir-
stone (14-39S) are dominantly rounded and have a mix of unzoned-, sector-, cons yield near-depleted mantle compositions (εHfi of +14 to +9) (Fig. 6). The and oscillatory-internal textures (Fig. 5). The zircons range in age from ca. lithologies of these rocks also indicate marine environments with dominantly 2.12 Ga to 108 Ma (n = 145), with age peaks at ca. 110 Ma (n = 20), ca. 160 Ma volcanic sediment sources. These combined characteristics suggest that the (n = 63), and ca. 180 Ma (n = 15). The rest of the dates are scattered between zircons were likely associated with an accreted Jurassic oceanic arc. Potential ca. 2.12 Ga–217 Ma with minor peaks centered at ca. 305 Ma (n = 4) and sources are common throughout the Cordillera as Late Jurassic arc assem- 325 Ma (n = 3) (Fig. 5E), with a resulting MDA of 109 ± 3 Ma MDA. The ca. blages and ophiolites were accreted along the entire North American conti-
110 Ma peak has εHfi values between +11.2 and +6.7 (n = 8), whereas the domi nental margin; however, no Hf-isotope data are available from these sources
nant ca. 160 Ma peak has slightly higher εHfi values from +13.7 to +9.2, with for comparison (Table 3).
outliers at +0.0 and +4.5 (n = 10). The ca. 180 Ma peak has εHfi values from
+11.8 to +8.5 (n = 6), and late Paleozoic zircons (ca. 325–250 Ma) have εHfi between +9.5 and +13.0 (n = 6) (Fig. 6A). The zircons with dates at ca. 2.1 and Mid-Cretaceous Units
0.5 Ga are less radiogenic (εHfi of –2.5 to –4.8, n = 3), whereas zircons with
dates between 1.8 and 1.1 Ga have more radiogenic εHfi values that range Jurassic zircons in mid-Cretaceous units from the Methow (SK13-01, MDA = from +7.6 to +0.1 (n = 5) (Fig. 6B). ca. 105 Ma) and WMB (14-39S, MDA = ca. 109 Ma) of this study have distinctly
In comparison, the arkosic sandstone contains abundant detrital potassium less radiogenic Hf-isotope compositions (εHfi = +10.1 to +4.6 and εHfi = +13.3 feldspar and lesser muscovite and biotite (Dragovich et al., 2014). Zircons from to +0.0, respectively) than the Jurassic zircons from the basal Methow and the sandstone are slightly rounded, range from stubby to elongate, and are Nooksack strata described above (Fig. 6). These strata also contain Early Creta- oscillatory zoned to unzoned (Fig. 5). The zircons have dates that range from ceous (ca. 120–100 Ma) zircons that plot between depleted-mantle and CHUR ca. 2190–67 Ma (n = 129; MDA of 72 ± 2 Ma), with prominent Late Cretaceous values (Fig. 6). The less radiogenic Hf-isotope signature for ca. 120–100 Ma and peaks at ca. 74 (n = 18) and 90 Ma (n = 17), Proterozoic peaks at ca. 1.37 (n = 23) 160–140 Ma zircons likely resulted from interaction of juvenile melts with more and 1.68 Ga (n = 13), and minor peaks at ca. 165 (n = 6) and 190 Ma (n = 8) (Fig. evolved crustal materials, as observed in continental arc systems such as the
5F). The initial εHfi values of Late Cretaceous zircons range from +5.9 to –22.5 Peninsular Ranges batholith, Sierra Nevada batholith, and Coast Plutonic Com-
(n = 19) and are dominantly negative (n = 16). The εHfi for Jurassic to Early Cre- plex (e.g., Cecil et al., 2011; Lackey et al., 2012; Shaw et al., 2014) (Fig. 7A and taceous zircons are clustered between +10.4 and +8.4 (n = 3) and +0.9 and –0.8 Table 3). Thus, the sediment provenance for the Methow terrane must have (n = 2). For the Proterozoic peaks, zircons typically plot above or near CHUR switched from primarily an oceanic arc to a continental arc that incorporated with +11.3 to –0.4 (n = 12) values for the 1.37 Ga peak and +8.4 to –0.7 (n = 8) crustal material source during the Jurassic to the Cretaceous, respectively. for the 1.68 Ga peak, with a trend toward more positive values for younger The Jurassic and Cretaceous zircons from the WMB cover a larger range of
grains (Fig. 6B). εHfi values and include ca. 190–180 Ma and scattered Paleozoic and Proterozoic
GEOSPHERE | Volume 13 | Number 6 Sauer et al. | Evolution of the North American Cordilleran margin Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/13/6/2094/3990859/2094.pdf 2104 by guest on 26 September 2021 Research Paper
TAB E 3. SUMMAR OF DETRITA - IRCON SOURCES FOR MAIN AGE POPU ATIONS Age Age range Hf-isotope composition
population Potential sources Ma εHfi References