20110314-NEWS--0001-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/11/2011 6:02 PM Page 1
®
www.crainsdetroit.com Vol. 27, No. 11 MARCH 14 – 20, 2011 $2 a copy; $59 a year
©Entire contents copyright 2011 by Crain Communications Inc. All rights reserved
Page 3 Moroun ad blitz, big names ‘Music can try to turn tide on bridge Snyder tax break be that bridge’ for business: 60% Calley: Focus is on SHIFTING THE BURDEN What’s a Pontiac dealer to Sphinx seeks to expand Under Gov. Rick Snyder’s plan, business taxes do? ‘Shift gears’ for Buick equity, job growth would contribute less to the state’s general and School Aid fund revenue, and individual income global reach with BY AMY LANE taxes would contribute more: Amid Mideast turmoil, rising CAPITOL CORRESPONDENT Currently FY 2013 diversity conference Business tax: 11% Business tax: 4.3% oil prices, Japan earthquake LANSING — Gov. Rick Snyder’s tax reform proposal would slice business-tax contribu- latest challenge to suppliers BY SHERRI WELCH tions to state revenue and shift the burden CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS largely to increases in individual income tax- Other: Other: es. 58% 54.7% Inside The Sphinx Organization plans to estab- Under Snyder’s plan, Michigan’s main busi- lish an international conference on in- ness tax would generate 4.3 percent of the creasing diversity in classical music state’s general fund and School Aid Fund rev- If Icahn sells Federal-Mogul Individual income Individual income while showcasing its musicians. enue — a major shift from the nearly 11 per- tax: 31% tax: 41% cent that the current Michigan Business Tax stake, private equity firms “SphinxFest” Source: Crain’s research, Public Sector Consultants Inc. supplies. could show interest, Page 8 IDEA: DETROIT would take place in The net business-tax revenue in fiscal 2013 England over a is even lower — 1.6 percent of general fund 2013, when changes are fully phased in, equat- Speaking: Sphinx and school aid revenue — if tax-credit payouts ing to a 60.8 percent tax cut. founder among week’s time, bring- are factored in, according to a recent analysis Beyond that, the state would pay out Crain’s List innovators addressing ing together key $500 million in previously granted tax credits conference, Page 4 arts, education and by Gary Olson, a senior fellow at Public Sector Consultants Inc. that year, further reducing business-tax con- Michigan’s largest diversity leaders But increasing, from 31 percent to 41 per- tributions to the general and School Aid funds from the country to discuss best prac- cent, would be the amount of state revenue to a net $292.7 million, or an 85.5 percent drop employers, Page 18 tices and to hear performances from generated from individual income taxes. from the current MBT. By comparison, general fund and School Sphinx musicians. Snyder’s plan would drop business-tax rev- enue from $2 billion to $792.7 million in fiscal This Just In Plans for the conference, which See Tax, Page 26 Sphinx seeks corporate funding to sup- port, are part of an international ex- Chinese company plans pansion of Sphinx’s mission to expansion in Canton Twp. See Sphinx, Page 28 Bing team’s turnover questioned A major Chinese automo- tive parts manufacturer is Sphinx expanding a technical center in Southeast Michigan — the founder Departures put power in fewer hands first step of its plan to form Aaron rector of planning and development; Janet An- alliances with U.S. suppliers. Dworkin BY NANCY KAFFER CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS derson, deputy budget director; and the entire The China Auto Parts & Ac- Office of Targeted Business Development. cessories Corp., a group of Al Fields joined Detroit Mayor Dave Bing’s And three veterans of the Kilpatrick admin- suppliers with $30 billion in executive team in January 2010. A veteran of istration — Chief Communications Officer annual sales, is expanding a former Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick’s adminis- Karen Dumas, Chief of Staff Shannon Holmes and Canton Township technical tration who also has private CFO Norm White — continue to center that it shares with sector experience, Fields said climb the organizational chart. Tempo International Group Ltd., he was recruited by Bing and So many departures have a Chinese maker of chassis other top city officials. People come left power in the mayor’s office components. Fifteen months later, he was “ concentrated in the hands of a The Canton facility al- and go. What’s gone. few C-level employees and ready has 100 engineers, and Fields is one of 46 employ- group executives, a lineup that CAPAC is hiring an addition- interesting is that ees, 31 of them managers, di- critics of the administration al 100. The company has rectors, deputy directors or say lacks the experience to spent $10 million on the facil- it’s all in the first group executives, who have guide the state’s largest city. ity and expects to spend left the mayor’s office in the To some, it signals instability more as operations expand. 22 months. past 22 months. in the mayor’s office. “We want to use this as a ” Most of the 46 were asked to Sheila Cockrel, “There’s always been a lot of See This Just In, Page 2 resign or their appointments Former City Council member movement on and off the 11th MIKE MOURADIAN were revoked; a handful re- floor,” said Sheila Cockrel, tired or were cut as departments were elimi- who served 16 years as a Detroit City Council nated. member and is now an adjunct professor at Bing defends his personnel choices as Wayne State University’s Irvin D. Reid Honors housekeeping, clearing out unsuccessful lega- College and owner of Crossroads Consulting. cy appointees from past administrations. “People come and go. What’s interesting is But many of the 46 were hires made by Bing, that it’s all in the first 22 months.” including Fields; former Bing Group CEO Kirk Cockrel said the churn shows that Bing is Lewis, who served as Bing’s chief government prepared to be decisive when it’s time to make
NEWSPAPER and corporate affairs officer; Charlie Beckham, chief administrative officer; Warren Palmer, di- See Turnover, Page 27 20110314-NEWS--0002-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/11/2011 5:31 PM Page 1
Page 2 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 14, 2011
der’s proposed 2012 budget, said cent of the program’s 1.8 million Initiative promoting Lake St. DMC parent lays off staff THIS JUST IN MEDC President and CEO recipients who are in Medicaid’s Clair as a tourism attraction and Michael Finney. fee-for-service program, among economic development asset. Last week, the Detroit Medical ■ From Page 1 Local participants include other things. Gerard Santoro, senior planner Center’s new corporate parent, George Jackson, president and — Jay Greene in the department, becomes the Vanguard Health Systems Inc., laid platform to (work with) all the CEO of the Detroit Economic county program manager of land off 21 employees at its Nashville other R&D centers in Detroit,” Growth Corp., and Maureen Dono- 3 leave Colliers, start new firm and water resources. headquarters — one side-effect of said CAPAC President Chen Kan- hue Krauss, director of the Oakland Santoro’s duties will include the acquisition of DMC, said Van- guard officials. gren, following a speech to busi- County Department of Economic De- Three commercial real estate coordinating with the nonprofit The layoffs represent about 10 ness executives here. velopment and Community Affairs. brokers have left Colliers Interna- Lake St. Clair Tourism Initiative percent of corporate staff. Beijing-based CAPAC, which is Stephen Cassin, executive director tional to form their own firm. launched in 2009, the Macomb The company said the job cuts primarily an aftermarket suppli- of the Macomb County Planning and Greg Kloiber, Al Leszczynski and County Water Quality Board and were part of a decision to shift er, generates annual sales of Economic Development Department, David Stechly have formed TG Cor- other agencies on improving wa- $80 million in the U.S., a relative- joins the group this week. porate Real Estate Advisors with a various management duties to ter quality and the economic de- some of the 26 hospitals it owns in ly small portion of its global The council was organized ear- new office in Livonia. All three velopment potential of the lake five states. Departments included sales. Chen said he wants to sell lier this year and will be an ongo- are owners, and Kloiber is man- and Clinton River. supply chain, marketing, strate- more components in North ing advisory panel to the MEDC aging partner. He will also seek funding for The three brokers were able to gy, program management opera- America, and he also hopes to on coordinating economic devel- debris removal from the river. opment programs. bring with them four major tions and clinical operations. form partnerships with U.S. sup- Hackel said the program manag- — Chad Halcom clients that have provided rough- A Vanguard spokesman said pliers to sell parts in China. er will promote and market the ly 85 percent of their revenue in regional Vanguard offices could CAPAC also has linked up with lake and river, as well as court recent years, Leszczynski said. hire people to fill the void, but Di- Leuliette Partners, a Birmingham- Agencies lobby against businesses ranging from canoe ana Marx Prosi, vice president of based investment group that has The move follows several other departures at Colliers. Last year, rentals and liveries to hotels or marketing for the DMC, said it been working with Tempo Inter- mental health budget cuts Randy Thomas left to revive his marina casinos. didn’t need to do so. national. The Michigan Association of Com- former business, InSite Commer- Hackel estimates a cleanup of Part of the deal that sold DMC — Crain News Service munity Mental Health Boards has cial Group. Cam McCausland recent- the entire river would cost $1 mil- to Vanguard has promises not to signed an agreement with the ly left the position of managing lion to $1.5 million and could be close any of DMC’s eight hospi- Group advises MEDC Michigan Association of Health director to head up brokerage complete by late next year if the tals. But there was no pledge to Plans to lobby against expected services at Plante Moran Cresa in county finds the funding. protect local jobs. An informal group of 15 area mental health budget cuts this Southfield. — Chad Halcom — Jay Greene economic development officials year and expand managed care — Daniel Duggan expects to advise the Michigan opportunities. Economic Development Corp. by Gov. Rick Snyder’s 2012 budget CORRECTIONS late April on how to appropriate a proposal calls for a 3 percent cut, Hackel planner to promote Ⅲ A Page 1 story about the Detroit Lions in the March 7 issue should state budget allotment for busi- or $8.5 million, of community benefits of Lake St. Clair have named William Clay Ford Sr. instead of his son as the team’s buyer ness attraction and retention. mental health services for non- in 1964. The group expects to meet to- Medicaid clients, the fourth Macomb County Executive Ⅲ A story on Page 16 of the March 7 issue incorrectly stated Hella Elec- Mark Hackel day in Lansing to begin develop- straight year of reductions. has assigned a senior tronics Corp’s 2010 revenue as $3.5 billion. The correct figure was 3.5 bil- ing a process for companies to The associations said they will planner in the county Planning lion euros, or $4.3 billion. It also incorrectly stated how many radar- seek funds allocated to business lobby to expand Medicaid man- and Economic Development De- based sensors Hella has sold worldwide. The correct number is 1.2 development in Gov. Rick Sny- aged care enrollment to 40 per- partment to lead a Blue Economy million.
-(:;05;,95,;4(2,:*/,30»:*/030-(:;,9 *H[JO\ZPM`V\JHU
With Comcast Business Class, we get Internet that’s as reliable as I was for 26 seasons, and up to 10 times faster than DSL and T1. We have great phone service, tons of TV options and our own dedicated local account team that provides support 24/7. Now we’re not a small business, we’re a fast business.
Chris Chelios, Hockey Legend )\ZPULZZ*VTJHZ[JVT & Small Business Owner
Restrictions apply. Not available in all areas. Speed comparison between Comcast Business Class Preferred 16 Mbps Internet service and standard 1.5 Mbps DSL and T1 service (downloads only). Actual speeds vary and are not guaranteed. Call for details. Comcast © 2011. All rights reserved.
H1AP-211V1-A11 20110314-NEWS--0003-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/11/2011 5:38 PM Page 1
March 14, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 3 Can Moroun’s big guns win draw? Health Care Extra
year-old bridge despite opposition from Ad blitz, big names circle wagons against rival Canada, also has hired former Clinton administration consultant and Fox News BY BILL SHEA Grosse Pointe trucking industrialist commentator Dick Morris and bought CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Manuel “Matty” Moroun, who bought airtime on Fox News for commercials the Ambassador Bridge in 1977, has critical of the proposed bridge. What might be a last-ditch effort by the spent an estimated $400,000 via his Detroit Moroun says the new bridge is un- Ambassador Bridge’s owner to sway International Bridge Co. on a statewide needed because border traffic remains at public and political television campaign urging viewers to pre-2000 levels and is unfair government opinion against a pro- PAN SAGA call lawmakers to protest the new com- competition that would bankrupt his posed government- S peting span, dubbed by Gov. Rick Snyder span. He claims to have a legal monopoly owned Detroit River Details: Costs, the New International Trade Crossing. Legis- on Detroit’s border corridor. Giving physicians a stake crossing is being background and lation for that bridge is expected to be in- Moroun’s 30-second television spot greeted with mixed re- big names, troduced soon in Lansing. warns that the bridge “will lose money in services, Page 19 Moroun Page 29 views. Moroun, who is seeking to twin his 81- See Moroun, Page 29
Company index These organizations appear in this week’s Crain’s Challenges Detroit Business: American Axle & Manufacturing ...... 25 New brand, new life Amway Corp...... 9 Angle Advisors ...... 8 hit suppliers BorgWarner ...... 25 Dealer loses Pontiac, Cascade Engineering ...... 16 Cellasto ...... 3 sells buyers on Buick Center for Michigan ...... 15 in waves Delphi ...... 25 BY MIKE COLIAS Denso ...... 25 Detroit International Bridge Co...... 3 CRAIN NEWS SERVICE Oil prices, quake Federal-Mogul ...... 8 In 2005, Sam Slaughter’s Farm- Foley Lardner ...... 20 ington Hills dealership sold exact- test their strength Forest Hills Foods ...... 13 ly zero Buicks. Last year, he sold Gilmore Collection ...... 12 687, more than any other store in Grand Valley State ...... 12 BY DAVID BARKHOLZ the country. Henry Ford Health System ...... 19 AND DUSTIN WALSH A shrine in his showroom tells Henry Ford Medical Group ...... 21 part of the story behind the num- CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Henry Ford Vattikuti Urology Institute ...... 27 bers. A “1926-2010” sign hangs After one of the biggest two- Hydra Professionals ...... 8 above a gleaming 1966 Pontiac week jumps in gasoline prices on IHS Automotive ...... 25 GTO, paying homage to the now- record, it remains to be seen Meijer ...... 9 defunct brand that represented whether the economy, and the more than half of Slaughter’s Metro Health Hospital ...... 10 auto supply chain, is resilient business just 18 months ago. Mich. Dept. of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth . . 17 enough to handle more tremors. Slaughter successfully an- Michigan Institute of Urology ...... 27 Last week’s earthquake in Japan, swered vexing questions faced by Mosaic Youth Theatre ...... 28 political volatility in the Middle hundreds of dealers in recent Nexteer Inc...... 14 East and a prediction for further up- years: How do you replace rev- Pennant Health Alliance ...... 10 ward gas price climbs are just some enue lost after the amputation of a Providence Hospital ...... 19 of the factors that could affect earn- key franchise? How do you transi- Public Sector Consultants ...... 1 ings outlooks. tion to a new brand from the one Right Place ...... 16 Surging oil prices are expected your customer base has favored? Rockford Development Group ...... 9 to cut 2011 profits of auto suppli- For Slaughter, 48, the answer ers, which are largely unable to Royal Technologies ...... 16 required a quick two-step. He pass along short-term increases in Sellers Buick-GMC ...... 3 spent the brutal downturn of 2009 the prices of raw materials. St. John Cardiovascular Co-Management ...... 19 milking Pontiac for much-needed Of 119 suppliers responding last St. John Hospital, Medical Center ...... 19 cash flow. At the same time, he week to a survey conducted by St. John Macomb-Oakland Hospital ...... 19 overhauled his store and re- Crain’s sister publication Automo- St. John Providence Health System ...... 19 trained his staff to sell Buick, tive News, 87 percent said the oil St. Joseph Mercy Health System ...... 27 which is attracting more upscale price spike will dampen their 2011 Steelcase ...... 9 buyers amid a product resur- profits. Most respondents said the The Sphinx Organization ...... 1 gence. hit would be 10 percent or less. Tri County Urologists ...... 27 “We tried our best to gracefully A silver lining, so far, is that get out of the Pontiac business Trinity Health ...... 10 only 14 percent of respondents said while also ramping up this whole TRW Automotive ...... 25 they have seen cuts in automak- premium idea,” said Slaughter, GLENN TRIEST University of Michigan Health System ...... 10 ers’ production plans as a result of dealer principal of Sellers Buick- Urological Surgeons ...... 27 higher oil prices. GMC. “We completely shifted Via Design ...... 10 We were able to move (Buicks) because Suppliers also say they have gears.” Visteon ...... 25 “ made progress over the past four Slaughter had low expectations Wello ...... 4 we kept a lot of those Pontiac customers years in reducing their sales re- when he acquired the Buick fran- William Beaumont Hospitals ...... 19 liance on truck and SUV plat- chise in 2006. By 2009, Buick rep- and picked up new ones, like Saturn. Windquest Group ...... 16 forms, which are most vulnerable resented just 10 percent of his ” Wolverine World Wide ...... 9 to oil shocks. overall volume. Pontiac was 55 Sam Slaughter, Sellers Buick-GMC With recent prices near $105 per percent and GMC 35 percent. barrel, the oil run-up will take In April 2009, then-General Mo- to finance ongoing construction. GM employee-discount market. about 5 percent to 10 percent out of tors Corp. said it would pull the So while Pontiac dealers across “It was either a good guess or this year’s profits, said Dave plug on Pontiac. Slaughter real- the country were scrambling to dumb luck, but we just said, ‘Let’s Grimes, business director for the Department index ized he would need to embrace purge their lots of unsold new make something out of this,’ ” Cellasto parts unit of German Buick, a brand long derided as a Pontiacs, Slaughter was snapping said Paul Phalen, Sellers’ sales BANKRUPTCIES ...... 4 chemical giant BASF. grandparent’s car. But he could up 500 units through dealer trades manager. CALENDAR ...... 24 not get enough Buick inventory in the second half of 2009. He had CAREERWORKS ...... 23 See Suppliers, Page 25 to generate the cash flow needed the benefit of being in a strong See Dealer, Page 27 CLASSIFIED ADS ...... 24 KEITH CRAIN...... 6 Bring ideas with you Getting to work OPINION ...... 6 Crain's and Advertising Age are hosting the Career information can be found THIS WEEK @ PEOPLE ...... 23 Idea: Detroit conference March 23. Register at Crain's CareerWorks, WWW.CRAINSDETROIT.COM at crainsdetroit.com/crainsevents. crainsdetroit.com/careerworks. RUMBLINGS ...... 30 WEEK ON THE WEB ...... 30 20110314-NEWS--0004-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/11/2011 2:52 PM Page 1
Page 4 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 14, 2011
THE MILLER LAW FIRM Idea: Detroit conference to hear a professional corporation from WaterWheel entrepreneur
BY SHAWN WRIGHT Idea: Detroit, modeled after Ad SPECIAL TO CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS IDEA: DETROIT Age’s Idea conference held for the past five years in Manhattan, will Ⅲ What: Innovation-focused Cynthia Koenig, a University of conference sponsored by Crain’s feature 14 speakers, each talking Michigan MBA student, had an idea Detroit Business and Advertising about a specific product, innova- to help people in underprivileged Age. tion or trend. countries transport water more Ⅲ When: March 23 “Whatever small thing you can Our firm specializes in litigation: easily. Ⅲ Where: Taubman Center, do, just do it,” Koenig said. “When I From that College for Creative Studies started, I didn’t intend to launch a • Complex Commercial and Business thought, Koenig Ⅲ Registration: business in another country. I • Shareholder and Partnership created Ann Ar- crainsdetroit.com/events thought I’d raise funds and just con- • Automotive Supplier bor-based Wello, tribute to water projects interna- an award-win- tionally. (But) I knew it was impor- • Class Actions er. The conference is sponsored by ning social ven- Crain’s Detroit Business and its sis- tant. … It’s bigger than I thought it • Employment ture that manu- ter publication, Advertising Age. would be.” • Family Law and Probate Litigation factures and “There’s so much attention paid To help fund the project, Koenig, (248) 841-2200 distributes the to the negatives of Detroit. … Fay, and Mueller pitched Wello 950 West University Drive, Suite 300 WaterWheel. That’s what makes news,” Koenig last spring, finishing second in the millerlawpc.com Rochester, Michigan 48307 Koenig The Water- said. “But there are so many posi- 2010 Princeton Entrepreneur Net- Wheel — a 20- tive things to talk about. This is an work Pitch and winning the Dow gallon drum that can be pushed opportunity to highlight that Sustainability Challenge Grant. like a baby stroller and transports something’s going on, and a great The three also earned the Social four to five times the amount of opportunity to be optimistic about Impact Award at the 2010 Michi- water possible using traditional the future of Detroit — it’s not all gan Business Challenge. methods of collection, such as car- despair.” Koenig, who will graduate this rying a 5-gallon bucket on the head In addition to Koenig, Idea: De- year from UM, hopes attendees of — was designed for people who troit will feature social entrepre- the Idea conference will come live where safe drinking water is neurs such as Veronika Scott, a away with the feeling that they can not readily available. College for Creative Studies student take initiative because “even a Koenig, who had help from fel- who designed a coat for the home- small thing can have a huge, posi- low students Colm Fay and less that doubles as a sleeping tive impact on the world.” Christopher Mueller, said one of bag/shelter, using products from In addition to the speakers, the most inspiring experiences she two Michigan companies — Tyvek Crain’s will showcase the next had during the early stages before from Midland-based Dow Corning crop of innovative entrepreneurs creating Wello and the Water- Corp. and fleece from Dearborn- during its Big Ideas contest, to be Wheel was listening to a presenta- based Carhartt Inc. highlighted during the conference. tion by David Bornstein, author of Other speakers include David In tandem with Idea: Detroit, the How to Change the World: Social Morrow, founder of Warren-based Big Ideas competition asked en- Entrepreneurs and the Power of sporting goods firm Warrior Sports trants to submit their best ideas in New Ideas. Inc.; Eric Ryan, a Grosse Pointe na- the categories of arts and culture, Bornstein’s book profiles men tive and co-founder of Method Prod- entrepreneurship, education, en- and women from around the world ucts Inc., maker of eco-friendly vironment and bringing people to who have found innovative solu- household and personal care prod- live in Detroit. tions to a wide variety of social ucts; and Aaron Dworkin, founder Entrants submitted statements and economic problems. of Sphinx, the classical music com- about a problem, issue or opportu- “It was really eye-opening,” petition devoted to placing minori- nity and how they would address it Koenig said. “I didn’t know any- ty musicians in top orchestras (See with a solution, product or service. one was doing this. … The phrase story, Page 1). Submissions included lists of who ‘social entrepreneur’ was only be- Also speaking at the conference would contribute and how the ing talked about within the last will be Josh Linkner, founder of goals could be realized. couple of years.” ePrize and fund manager for Quick- Finalists will present their ideas Koenig will share her experi- en Loans Inc. founder and Chair- at the conference, at the College for ences and thoughts on being a man Dan Gilbert’s venture capital Creative Studies’ A. Alfred Taub- young social entrepreneur at the fund Detroit Venture Partners, aimed man Center for Design in Detroit. first-ever Idea: Detroit conference at seeding early startups in digital For more information, visit March 23, where she will be a speak- technology and digital marketing. www.crainsdetroit.com/2011ideas.
BANKRUPTCIES Is Your Business Aware of The following businesses filed for Chapter 7 or 11 protection in U.S. Changes to Michigan’s Bankruptcy Court in Detroit March 4- 10. Under Chapter 11, a company files for reorganization, Chapter 7 involves Unclaimed Property Law? liquidation. MH&A Real Estate Inc., 418 W. Tor- rington Drive, Canton Township, vol- untary Chapter 7. Assets: $0; liabili- ties: $309,175. Get Informed ! Patros Inc., 18540 Frazho Road, Ro- seville, voluntary Chapter 11. Assets and liabilities not available. New date for reporting unclaimed Internet Medical Billing LLC, 691 N. property is July 1 (changed from Squirrel Road, Suite 108, Auburn Hills, involuntary Chapter 7. Assets November 1) and liabilities not available. Dormancy Period for most properties Investor’s Network Fund LLC, 390 En- now 3 years terprise, Suite 100, Bloomfield Hills, voluntary Chapter 7. Assets: $1.9 mil- 25% penalty may be levied … plus lion; liabilities: $2.4 million. interest One Stop LLC, 37490 Dequindre Road, Sterling Heights, voluntary Chapter More information, including free filing software is at 11. Assets and liabilities not avail- www.michigan.gov/unclaimedproperty able. — Shawn Wright DBpageAD.qxp 1/5/2011 9:19 AM Page 1
SOME BANKS WANT YOUR FEES. WE’D RATHER HAVE YOUR BUSINESS. HUNTINGTON FREE BUSINESS CHECKING
Finding the right checking account for a small business can be a challenge. You can opt for free checking and be treated like an afterthought, or pay a premium for services you don’t use. Then there’s Huntington. All the services you need with award-winning customer support – that’s what our Free Business Checking offers. It’s what you’d expect from the #1 SBA lender. See what we can do for you by visiting huntington.com/bizchecking or calling 1-800-480-2001.
Huntington Free Business Checking is limited to 200 transactions and $5,000 in-branch cash deposits per month, then excess transaction and cash deposit transaction fees apply. A “transaction” is any combination of checks paid, deposit tickets, deposited checks and ACH credits and debits. Award claim based on 2009 Business Banking Study. All excellence award selections were based on studies conducted by Greenwich Associates, a leading worldwide strategic consulting and research firm specializing in fi nancial services. Huntington is the #1 SBA 7(a) lender in the region made up of Indiana, Kentucky, Ohio, Michigan, West Virginia and Western PA. Source: U.S. SBA from October 1, 2007, through November 30, 2010. Member FDIC. B® and Huntington® are federally registered service marks of Huntington Bancshares Incorporated. Huntington.® Welcome.TM is a service mark of Huntington Bancshares Incorporated. ©2011 Huntington Bancshares Incorporated. 20110314-NEWS--0006,0007-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/11/2011 5:32 PM Page 1
Page 6 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 14, 2011 OPINION Michigan biz eager to get in the game ichigan isn’t coming back because it never went away — it just sat on the sidelines for a while. M So said Brian Campbell, the seasoned mergers- and-acquisitions dealmaker and operations whiz who, with his wife Mary Campbell, shared the Lifetime Achievement award from Crain’s and the Association for Corporate Growth at the fourth annual M&A Awards program. The room of nearly 350 bankers, accountants, investment bankers and investors listened to the Campbells recap their careers that started in Southeast Michigan about 30 years ago when Brian Campbell took a job at Masco Corp. At the time, he said, there were just two or three profession- al advisers and investment banking offices in Detroit. The suc- cess of the auto industry just didn’t create the infrastructure for supporting growth of the companies in the tiers below it. Today, that picture is dramatically different, with a dozen venture capital firms doing business in Michigan and a hand- ful of private equity investors looking for deals. Today’s infra- structure, Campbell said, can help companies grow to become acquisition targets — or to become acquirers themselves. In any case, the growth creates wealth for owners and investors along the way. In fact, Campbell cautioned attendees to refrain from count- ing Michigan out of the competitive business arena. After all, TALK ON THE WEB fellow Ann Arborite Gov. Rick Snyder is a former venture capi- talist who understands what it takes to make companies grow. From www.crainsdetroit.com Re: DSO labor talks Reader responses to stories and Re: Cobo to get $221M upgrade To both sides: If you don’t get blogs that appeared on Crain’s I have attended many events at Bing’s inner circle seems smaller over it and get on with it soon, Web site. Comments may be Cobo over the years and will con- there will be nothing left to fight over. edited for length and clarity. tinue to do so. This is great news. Turnover at the top can be a good thing or a bad thing — or Grant Writer 4 Good James Goss sometimes something in between. Re: Beck, Detroit and Hiroshima If you put lipstick on a pig, it still Detroit Mayor Dave Bing seems content with the churn that Re: Thinking about banning Facebook? is a pig. We’re all thin-skinned. I guess JAK has produced departures of 31 higher-level managers within Banning social media seems to half-truths hit too close to home. Spectacular vision and design — the city of Detroit in the past 22 months. (See story, Page 1.) be more of an old-school approach John Galt a great move ahead for our entire re- He has company. in business. It should be all about Chicago, New York and Los An- the output of those employees, not gion. Across the street in the RenCen headquarters of General geles can’t pay their bills either. whether they take a five-minute K. Alessandro Motors Co., CFO Chris Liddell departed last week, capping a Hilco Industrial break to check Facebook. Empower The sprawl argument is a sopho- string of top-level changes that have been common at the com- the employees by trusting them, and moric one at best. Sprawl is mainly Re: Keith Crain on public broadcasting pany as it reinvents itself. measure their results. the result of the population’s desire Can’t disagree more with Keith Bing has a tough job in creating a new culture in City Hall JaredDetroit to spread from congestion, not the Crain. Sorry, but access to educa- that prizes integrity — as well as accountability and perfor- government’s encouragement to do so. tional television without ads is impor- mance. The churn suggests he has no problem making a tough Re: Detroit Water Department Dave M tant to the well-being of our kids. And call and letting a top aide go. It appears no one was protecting not everyone can afford cable. Re: State should welcome immigrants Anne Osmer But it also seems as though his circle of closest aides is get- the interests of the suburban users of the system who will now be Ms. Fassia misses the point com- Public TV has quality shows in a ting smaller. That can make for a tight, functioning machine. asked to pay for 30-plus years of pletely in her (Other Voices) arti- steady lineup that you can’t al- Or it can insulate the mayor from input that never makes it needed repairs. How high must rates cle. Arizona and other states like ways find on cable networks, and past the gatekeepers. be raised to complete the work Michigan are not anti-immigrant. it can be accessed without cable. I It’s a delicate balance. needed within six months? They are anti-illegal immigrant. Bloomfielder Supplier geek See Talk, Page 7 KEITH CRAIN: What happened to democracy in the U.S.?
All over this country, anarchy hard to see him or her Before that, Democ- to see what the voters do in the times when politicians don’t do seems to be jostling for position replaced in the next rats controlled the next election. what you want them to do. There against the rule of law. Peaceful election. White House and both But what’s happened in Wash- are many laws that are passed that assembly is one thing; everyone In fact, there are houses and seemed to ington is tame compared to what’s you don’t want passed. But that’s certainly deserves free speech, those who would tell be able to pass just been going on in many state capi- no reason for unlawful assembly but it seems to be getting out of you that is exactly about any bill the par- tols. I don’t think we expected it. or speech that borders on insurrec- hand. what happened on a na- ty in power was inter- And it may be happening in Michi- tion. I know plenty of folks aren’t tional stage last year ested in passing. A lot gan, too. Let the politicians do their job. If happy in some of the state legisla- when enough Republi- of voters weren’t hap- The voters have voted. If you you disagree, your job is to work to tures around the country, but the cans were elected to py with what they saw want to protest, OK, but do it get them un-elected for their next folks in the capitols have been control the U.S. House happening, so the elec- without looking to the entire term. duly elected. I always thought if of Representatives, tion last fall changed world like you are on the verge of Don’t threaten the legislative you don’t like what an elected offi- ending Democratic the balance of power. a riot. process. It is simply not democrat- cial is doing in office, you work control of both House and Senate. Obviously it will be interesting In a democracy, there are many ic. 20110314-NEWS--0006,0007-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/11/2011 2:26 PM Page 2
March 14, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 7 OTHER VOICES: Economy demands economic education
Education is the silver fessional development of riculum. The State Board of Edu- der NCLB. Only improved access The crystal ball is clear: While bullet, and economic edu- the classroom teacher is cation approved and implementa- to academically-based, content-ori- young people are 50 percent of our cation is the crystal ball. one of the key variables in tion has begun with the new K-12 ented professional development population, they are 100 percent of It is critical to prepare a determining what stu- Grade Level and Course Content for teachers in economics, entre- our future. The future involve- young populace that un- dents learn. Expectations and new high school preneurship and personal econom- ment and leadership of Michigan derstands and appreciates Research confirms that graduation requirements, includ- ics can raise Michigan’s level of lies in our students’ understand- the private-market eco- teacher content knowledge ing one-half credit in economics. the quality of economics teaching. ing of economic education to lead nomic system. They must is vital to student learning. In 2008, then-Gov. Jennifer As the silver bullet of Michi- the new state economy into the acknowledge the critical Teacher preparation at Granholm signed legislation per- gan’s transformation, education is 21st century. role of entrepreneurship both the pre-service and in- mitting school districts to grant going to need the role, relevance David Dieterle is president and and small business in gen- service level remains the math credit for a personal finance and rigor necessary for a state in chief academic officer of the Novi- erating employment op- David Dieterle most important device for course. Nationally, the No Child economic transition. Michigan based Michigan Council on Eco- portunities. improving a student’s knowledge of Left Behind legislation, though un- teachers must have access to quali- nomic Education, an alliance to Michigan’s future is dependent economics, entrepreneurship and der debate, has a defined Highly ty academically-based content in promote and advocate for quality on our young people’s apprecia- personal economics. Qualified qualification for class- economics, entrepreneurship and economics, entrepreneurship and tion for the possibilities of the vi- Michigan has set in motion the room teachers. Many Michigan personal economics. Only then personal economics. For more infor- tal role Michigan can play in the evolution of Michigan education to economics teachers currently do will the needs of our citizens and mation, call (248) 596-9560 or visit ever-expanding global economy. If a knowledge-based statewide cur- not qualify to teach economics un- future leaders be met. www.mceeonline.org. our education system can prepare Michigan’s students for this fu- ture, Michigan will emerge ad- mired and desired for its business creation and a leadership role in a vibrant national and global eco- “HealthPlus takes care of my employees nomic community. Michigan education’s most criti- cal variable is the classroom so I can take care of business. That’s a teacher. When John Milton Grego- ry wrote the Seven Laws of Teach- ing, he identified the vital role of big Plus.” the classroom teacher with his first and foremost law. Paraphras- ing, teachers cannot teach what they do not know. This law is still as relevant in 2011 as it was in 1884 when he wrote it. Content-specific and standards-based curriculum- focused teacher education and pro-
TALK CONTINUED ■ From Page 6 support PBS and will continue to do so. Your column came off pretty one-sided and selfish. J/B Heitman
Re: Detroit recovering, Bing says Agreed, “The city must be more business-friendly.” The same can also be said for many other communi- ties in our region. Mark Cory
Re: Snyder’s budget I love the idea of “shared sacri- fice.” The working poor sacrifice the earned income credit. Retirees on fixed income sacrifice by hav- ing their pensions taxed. State workers will sacrifice through union-busting provisions. And the wealthy will sacrifice ... hmmm. … I guess in Snyder’s world, everyone sacrifices in his own special way. AllanR
While I agree with Gov. Snyder HealthPlus goes above and beyond for employers. that we need to be the best not the cheapest, how does that jibe with the cuts to the universities? džƚĞŶƐŝǀĞƐƚĂƚĞǁŝĚĞĂŶĚŶĂƟŽŶĂůƉƌŽǀŝĚĞƌŶĞƚǁŽƌŬƐ billm Worldwide emergency coverage Re: Film industry to rally against cuts WĞƌƐŽŶĂůĂƩĞŶƟŽŶďLJĂĚĞĚŝĐĂƚĞĚƵƐƚŽŵĞƌ^ĞƌǀŝĐĞƚĞĂŵ How about working out a payback to the credits based on gross film re- ĂƐLJƚƌĂŶƐŝƟŽŶĨƌŽŵŽƚŚĞƌŚĞĂůƚŚƉůĂŶƐ ceipts? A win-win. Dirt Dog Customizable HMO, PPO and self-funded health plans These incentives are creating jobs and economic activity that would To enroll, contact your independent agent or call: otherwise pass us by. Flint, MI 1-800-530-9071 The film incentives are virtually www.healthplus.org worthless. That is why no other state is as dumb as Michigan to make them so high. HealthPlus HMO is a product of HealthPlus of Michigan, Inc. HealthPlus PPO is a product of HealthPlus Insurance Company. © 2011 HealthPlus of Michigan LCS 20110314-NEWS--0008-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/11/2011 2:24 PM Page 1
Page 8 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 14, 2011 A sale of Icahn’s Federal-Mogul stake would be juicy to PE firms
BY DUSTIN WALSH Lazard Ltd. to work toward the stone antifreeze, Fram filters and CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS process. Autolite spark plugs. Icahn pulled Federal-Mogul out Late last year, Rank acquired Carl Icahn’s possible sale of his of bankruptcy in 2008 and owns 75.7 Evansville, Ind.-based UCI Interna- majority stake in Southfield-based percent of the company. Federal- tional Inc. for $605 million. UCI was Federal-Mogul Corp. (NASDAQ: Mogul shares were trading Thurs- previously controlled by another FDML) could day afternoon at $24.01, making the private equity firm, New York- come at the right company worth approximately $2.4 based The Carlyle Group. time to garner billion. Icahn’s stake is worth ap- Federal-Mogul could play well in interest from proximately $1.8 billion. the portfolio of New York-based major private eq- Federal-Mogul’s business units Blackstone Group LP — which also uity firms, ac- are diverse, which makes the stake controls Livonia-based safety tech- cording to local particularly attractive to private nology supplier TRW Automotive Inc. experts. equity firms, said William Wildern, The Carlyle Group represents an- Last week, CEO of Farmington Hills-based other potential buyer, as acquiring Reuters reported business advisory firm Hydra Profes- Federal-Mogul could boost its auto- that billionaire sionals LLC. motive portfolio, which includes Icahn New York in- “A company like Federal-Mogul Howell-based Diversified Machine Inc. vestor Icahn may sell his control- really invites the possibility of a and Plymouth-based Metaldyne LLC. ling stake in the supplier of brake major play involving a single pri- However, Carlyle has been focus- pads, pistons, spark plugs and wind- vate equity firm,” he said. ing its acquisitions over the past 12 shield wipers and has hired New Federal-Mogul has 26 registered months in Europe and Asia, most York-based financial advisory firm trademarked brands — including recently acquiring Japanese bear- Wagner brakes, ANCO wiper ings parts maker Tsubaki Nakashima blades and Champion spark plugs Co. for approximately $854 million, — each likely worth something on Dow Jones reported. the market, Wildern said. Other private equity firms on the “There’s a lot of flexibility with short list for Federal-Mogul are: Federal-Mogul and a PE (private eq- Bethesda, Md.-based American Capi- uity) firm can come in and start tal Ltd., New York-based Kohlberg shaving off parts and acquire other Kravis Roberts & Co. LP and Toronto- parts to solidify the core business.” based Onex Corp. Federal-Mogul’s automotive af- The $1.8 billion price tag puts termarket business would likely re- most automotive suppliers out of main the core, as private equity the running for the majority stake, continues its plunge into that mar- Wildern said. ket. The automotive aftermarket is “A supplier would have to have a $300 billion industry and roughly nearly $2 billion in capital and most 250 private equity firms have in- just don’t,” he said. “Private equity vested $5 billion in the industry has deeper pockets and more flexi- during the past five years, he said. bility.” Billionaire mogul Graeme Hart’s Federal-Mogul’s $2.8 billion in New Zealand-based The Rank Group debt likely will keep other automo- is a potential buyer, said Kevin tive suppliers, still recovering from Marsh, partner at Birmingham- the recent industry collapse, away based financial advisory firm Angle from the deal, Wildern said. Advisors LLC. Federal-Mogul declined to com- “The Rank Group is making a big ment on the reports, calling it “spec- push in aftermarket in the U.S., and ulation and rumor.” a possible Federal-Mogul sale has to Icahn purchased unsecured Fed- be on their radar,” he said. eral-Mogul bonds before it exited In January, Rank acquired Mor- bankruptcy in 2007 and later ristown, N.J.-based Honeywell Inter- swapped them for equity as part of national Inc.’s consumer products the company’s reorganization. group in a cash deal valued at $950 Dustin Walsh: (313) 446-6042, million. The group consists of Pre- [email protected]
PLATFORM INVESTMENT CRITERIA TRANSACTION TYPES
Revenues Up to $300 million Buyouts Buy & Build EBITDA $5 million or more Recapitalizations Growth Initiatives Equity per Deal $10 - $70 million Family Successions Corporate Spin-offs
www.huroncapital.com 500 Griswold Street, Suite 2700 I Detroit, Michigan 48226 I Tel: 313.962.5800 4 King Street West, Suite 1300 I Toronto, Ontario M5H 1B6 I Tel: 416.234.0313 20110314-NEWS--0009,0010,0011-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/10/2011 4:21 PM Page 1
March 14, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 9
PUBLISHER’S NOTEBOOK
GRID70 in CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS Grand Rapids Mary Kramer Young talent reshapes cities The headline read, “Poll: Majority of Michiganders say Detroit is key to state’s success.” Know and tell NATHAN SKID/CDB But when you looked closely at the results of the Detroit Free Press/WXYZ-Channel 7 statewide poll, released March 6, only 32 percent said Detroit’s success is Companies find safe place to share secrets for mutual benefits essential to Michigan’s. An additional 40 percent described it as BY MATTHEW GRYCZAN “important but not essential.” CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS Still, when you add up the results, more than 70 percent of RAND RAPIDS — In a Michiganders are saying “Detroit building punctuated with matters.” G spires that rise like excla- Even with a population under mation points, a team 900,000, Detroit is still the state’s plotting the future of largest city, and its reputation Amway Corp. discussed influences the reputation of the confidential research whole state. about the demograph- Detroit has huge challenges: ics of its Southeast — short for poverty, illiteracy, crime and Asian customers — Grand staggering budget and financial Rapids In- issues, like pension liabilities for all within listening workers and retirees. range of Steelcase Inc. novation & Design But like a lot of Michigan, its future researchers. will depend on shaping a new mind- A month earlier at and the set to produce new and better results. the site, dubbed GRID70, Steelcase build- I’m lucky to have lived and worked in shared trade secrets with Wolverine ing’s ad- five Michigan communities. I grew World Wide Inc. on how to dress of 70 Ionia up in Grand Rapids, graduated from control odors from ce- St. — may become a template. Grand Valley State University and ments used in their prod- Mike Maier, president of Rock- had a journalism career that included ucts — a problem common ford Development Group LLC, which stops in Grand Rapids, Kalamazoo, to footwear and office fur- owns and manages the GRID70 Jackson and Ann Arbor before niture manufacturing. building, says his company is landing in Detroit 21 years ago. This week, researchers considering launching the con- And in both Grand Rapids and from all three companies and cept in fast-growing markets such Detroit, you find young Meijer Inc. will convene to as Austin, Texas. entrepreneurs who are intent on But it’s not the building that building businesses and lives on share sensi- their terms. They are reshaping the tive data — makes GRID70 unique, Maier says. Cherry Hill neighborhood in Grand what they It’s the commitment by executives Rapids as much as they are know about to bring a new culture of corporate Corktown and Midtown in Detroit. Generation Y — collaboration to West Michigan. There’s much talk about “keeping in hopes that GRid70 is an outgrowth of dis- talent” in Michigan and building our they come away cussions by several members of future. But do policymakers really with fresh out- What’s Next, a committee of about listen to younger adults? looks on how to 30 corporate leaders who want to Phil Cooley, co-owner of the popular serve customers strengthen the area’s economy. Corktown restaurant Slows Bar BQ, in their early 30s last week was quoted in USA Today and younger — about investing $100,000 in a the so-called echo Breaking old habits 30,000-square-foot building he “I don’t care who you are — hoped to use for artists’ studios. By boomers. contrast, it would be tough to find GRID70 isn’t a when you are with one company, even 300 square feet in New York drop point for corporate espi- you can get stuck in the same pat- for that price. onage; it’s a pileup of “happy acci- tern of thinking,” says Seth Starn- When Crain’s held a contest last dents” where four — soon to be er, manager of business innova- year to develop an advertising five — of the largest tions consulting at Amway and a campaign to attract young talent, the employers in Michi- leader of the team studying South- low cost of living was one of the key gan have dis- east Asian demographics. “What themes for many entries. patched some of GRID70 allows you to do is to in- In that same USA Today article, their brightest teract with others who might Margarita Barry, founder of the I Am employees to have very different points of view Young Detroit website, talked about share confidential — because of the way their busi- the appeal of the edgy side of information freely ness works, because of the cus- Detroit, the kind of feeling you’re in tomers they serve, because of the a frontier and can try anything. in the hopes of finding true inno- vation. products they sell.” On March 23, Cooley, Barry and other social entrepreneurs from If the grand experiment comes See GRID70, Page 10 Detroit will be featured at IDEA: off as many think it will, GRID70 Detroit, a daylong event co- sponsored by Crain’s Detroit Amway Corp.’s Seth Starner, amid Business and its sister publication brainstorming ideas on sticky notes, Advertising Age. says GRID70 exposes its tenants to Cooley and Barry have counterparts different points of view. in Grand Rapids, too. Maybe next year we’ll take IDEA statewide. Mary Kramer is publisher of Crain’s VIDEO Detroit Business. You can write her at [email protected] Collaboration: Starner on the culture of GRID70, crainsdetroit.com/video NATHAN SKID/CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS 20110314-NEWS--0010-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/10/2011 4:41 PM Page 1
Page 10 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 14, 2011 CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS GRID70: Business tenants share secrets for mutual benefits ■ From Page 9 There shouldn’t be a lack of fresh Pennant’s website says it has an- president of growth initiatives at fore it draws solid conclusions. Participants write down ideas, viewpoints. The soon-to-be five ten- nual revenue of about $3.6 billion Steelcase and a point person on the then stick them under general cat- ants on three floors of the building and serves 3.8 million residents in project. egories to build a mosaic of under- in downtown Grand Rapids range 43 Michigan counties. Trinity and “The collaborative space not Collaboration takes time standing the problem. from a superstore retailer to a Pennant Health will be leasing only gives you a place to work as While GRID70 was announced “You need to be able to see health care provider network. about 6,000 square feet in GRid70. teams, but it also creates those op- about a year ago, participants say what’s in my head,” Starner says, The tenant with the largest portunities for happy accidents — the design hub is really about 6 “and the best way to do that is for space, Wolverine, posted revenue maybe strike up a conversation on months old, with the collaborative me to put it up on a board. I want last year of about $1.25 billion as Open-door policy an issue or come away with a dif- culture starting to jell only in Jan- to walk with this idea down to the one of the world’s leading manu- While the doors will be closed to ferent thought. uary. It was then that Starner in- third floor and ask someone, ‘What facturers and marketers of brand- the public Friday for the half-day “Just like companies that are on vited Steelcase researchers to join do you think?’ ed footwear and apparel. symposium on Gen Y, they will be the manufacturing side of things his Amway team analyzing data “Now, is what we are doing di- Steelcase is the world’s largest open wide to anyone on the three try to never leave capacity idle, we about Southeast Asian consumers. rectly related to a project that manufacturer of modular office floors of the want to use office space to its high- Amway hopes to distill a report Steelcase is doing? No. furniture, with 13,000 employees building, whose est capacity.” that details new socioeconomic “Do they (Steelcase researchers) and revenue last year of about offices are de- Because of the different space markets in Southeast Asia with walk away with added perspective $2.3 billion. signed to foster each tenant leases — Steelcase has high potential for direct selling, to the way they’re doing their job Rounding out the group are Ada- chance meetings about 1,200 square feet, while using guideposts such as size of and add value to the company? Ab- based Amway, subsidiary of $9.2 of people brim- Wolverine World Wide occupies the opportunity, how the corpora- solutely.” billion Alticor Inc. and a worldwide ming with ideas. about 10 times that square footage tion might approach the market leader in direct selling, with more On the fourth on an entire floor — Rockford De- and options for growth. than 3 million independent busi- floor, spacious velopment splits the cost of the “We use the collaborative space Wising up to Gen Y ness owners in more than 80 coun- rooms aptly common area. Half is shared a lot for sense-making — taking The Amway project led to anoth- tries and territories; and Walker- Maier named The Fo- equally among the tenants, while qualitative and quantitative data er collaboration: the Gen Y sympo- based Meijer, which employs about rum and SkunkWorks reinforce half is prorated by the percentage and synthesizing it into something sium put together by Starner and 60,000 full- and part-time workers at the sharing of ideas. Maier says a of total space each tenant occupies. understandable,” Starner says. Steelcase senior design researcher 195 supercenter and other format little more than 20 percent of the Steelcase has four full-time em- The two Steelcase researchers Melanie Redman. stores in five states. Industry ob- 28,000 square feet leased by the five ployees assigned to GRID70, but as attending Amway sessions Starn- “Steelcase has done a tremen- servers pegged Meijer’s annual corporations is common space, many as 15 may use it as a work er has held on his project carry all dous amount of research on Gen Y, sales at $14.2 billion last year. and the interior design by Via De- space one or two days a week. the rights and privileges of an and we are coming at it from two On April 1, add to that mix Novi- sign Inc. in Grand Rapids encour- “We’ve had days when there are Amway employee when it comes to totally different perspectives with based Trinity Health and Pennant ages mingling. more than 50 people down there for challenging assumptions, offering different needs,” says Amway’s Health Alliance, a health care “What GRID70’s business model Steelcase meetings,” Malnor says. opinions and critiquing data. Starner. “When you boil it down, provider network sponsored by has allowed each company to do is Preliminary estimates on how At one such session two weeks we really are talking about the Metro Health Hospital in Wyoming, to take a much smaller space than well space is used in GRid70 are ago, the room looked as if dyna- same people. It’s a way to chal- Mich., and the University of Michi- maybe they would have leased on promising, Malnor says, but Steel- mite had blasted scores of brightly gan Health System in Ann Arbor. their own,” says John Malnor, vice case wants to collect more data be- colored sticky notes to the walls. See Next Page
Within each of us is the ability to inspire others. Discover To expand horizons. To lead. the leader At Northwood University, we know leadership is a quality that isn’t simply taught, it’s instilled. in you. It requires a faculty who are role models. Men and women who are successful entrepreneurs and executives – who have directed the course of companies in many industries. It demands a relevant curriculum that goes beyond textbook learning with real-world case studies, group projects, and small interactive classes that teach you how to motivate others. You have what it takes to be a leader. Get your MBA at Northwood University.
MBA NORTHWOOD UNIVERSITY
800.MBA.9000 / 800.622.9000 www.northwood.edu
“What I learned from the DeVos program is how to take real life problems and find good solutions that meet the business objectives and our customers’ needs. Because of my DeVos experience I am able to contribute a lot more than just the legal perspective.” Lynn Krauss, Associate General Counsel, Dow Corning Corporation 20110314-NEWS--0009,0010,0011-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/10/2011 4:22 PM Page 3
March 14, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 11 CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS
From Previous Page contend that there often is more laborative culture like GRID70. up to the discretion of those who classes in September. Accreditation lenge your assumptions and learn common ground between compa- “You can’t collaborate without collaborate. by the organization means that something about how you are us- nies than first meets the eye. trust,” Starner says. “There is a “I feel really fortunate to be courses offered in Grand Rapids ing the data that you have.” “Talk about a different perspec- confidentiality agreement between working with these companies, be- will be identical to those offered at Steelcase likewise sees value in tive with Meijer — I know nothing all four companies, but in practical cause each has such a high level of IIT’s Chicago home campus for pur- joint efforts. “We want to solve about the food business,” Starner terms, I know everyone here at my integrity,” he says. “It’s been one of poses of granting degrees. problems more quickly — ones you says. “Understanding of how retail sessions is going to be discreet with the great joys so far with GRID70.” Malnor says GRID70 has given wouldn’t have solved with your works and how they operate on such the information. They are here for Besides serving as a center for the community a rallying point. own blinders on,” says Malnor. very small profit margins — how do insight, not to walk off with another sharing ideas, GRID70 is expected “One broadly held sentiment is The companies may even con- they do that, how do they make a company’s ideas.” to house a new master of design that West Michigan has changed a duct some research jointly and profitable company out of that?” Malnor breaks the proprietary methods program offered in West lot in the past 15 years, and maybe share the cost, he says. Says Steelcase’s Malnor: “Like nature of the discussions into two Michigan by the Illinois Institute of we haven’t done as good a job as That spirit of cooperation was us, Meijer has a big global supply categories: patents and trade se- Technology’s Institute of Design. we could in showing those changes the basis of meetings a few weeks chain. And on some levels, we are crets, and plans that are confiden- Starner says the program recent- — or taking advantage of those ago where Steel- all product-based companies that tial until they become a reality. ly received accreditation from the changes ourselves. So when we case and are also experience-based.” Patents pending or trade secrets North Central Association Commission bring new people in downtown and Wolverine mate- come under strict rules that are of- on Accreditation and School Improve- then we show them GRID70, it’s rial experts ten crafted case by case, he says. ment’s Office of Postsecondary Edu- pretty compelling.” started to share It goes bust without trust Confidential information such as cation — a necessary milestone for Matthew Gryczan: (616) 916-8158, best practices in There’s a key element to any col- the launch of a venture is left more the program as it gears up to offer [email protected] fastening mate- rials with ce- ments and sewing, says Robert Koenen, Koenen vice president and general manager of Wolver- ine’s Cat Footwear division. “You get so many great ideas that are outside of your own path, things really start to bubble up,” Koenen says. “We are now planning more frequent meetings.” He credits GRID70 with helping to break down walls and foster new creativity within Wolverine. About six months ago, the compa- ny moved more than 35 designers serving 11 brands of footwear from its Rockford headquarters to the third floor of GRID70. Wolverine licenses the Harley- Davidson name for a line of lifestyle footwear. “When the design groups were located in Rockford, we did not bump into each other or even know the designers in the other groups,” Koenen says. That all changed when the Cat brand — licensed from Caterpillar Inc. — lost a designer in London. Through conversations and friend- ships formed at GRID70, the divi- sion learned that a designer in the Harley group could try the work. The result: a new line of sandals launching in spring 2012 with a “whole fresh attitude, looking at Cat from the outside in,” Koenen says. “It was fantastic because she brought exactly what we needed.” And Meijer makes 4 Meijer looks forward to joining the three other tenants when it completes its first-floor renovation, which will include kitchens for test- ing its private-label foods and other products. Thirteen employees will be assigned to the space when it’s completed in late March or early April, says Frank Guglielmi, Meijer director of public relations. Guglielmi says Meijer will use the space to develop products, packaging, presentation and more, possibly even hosting test panels working on new items. “(CEO) Hank Meijer and (Presi- dent) Mark Murray were immedi- ately interested because innovation is a key driver in the company,” Guglielmi says of GRID70. “The mind-set of Meijer from the top down is to take chances.” It remains to be seen how much interaction Meijer and Pennant Health will have with the three oth- er tenants, particularly because their customers are based in the Midwest while Steelcase, Amway and Wolverine serve customers globally. But Starner and Malnor 20110314-NEWS--0012,0013-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/10/2011 4:18 PM Page 1
Page 12 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 14, 2011 CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS Dialing for dollars: Test runs hint at biz need for apps
BY MATTHEW GRYCZAN whether, for food retailers, phone today already would rather use serving West Michigan. CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS apps become as necessary to doing their smart phones to check on to- In addition to basics such as business as having websites. day’s blue plate special or find menus, hours of operation and lo- GRAND RAPIDS — Over the Apps are programs with signifi- which grocery aisle has the bread cations, the Gilmore app will link next few months, West Michigan cant computing power that are crumbs than ask a waiter or store to the Foursquare app so a user will become a testing ground for stored on cell phones. What makes associate. can find friends and invite them to how consumers use smart phones apps attractive to smart-phone socialize. to order meals at restaurants, owners is their ease of use — the While that feature may seem like share news about specials at a gro- fewer clicks or touches to get infor- An appetite for apps overkill in a small restaurant on a cery store or navigate through a mation, the better. In April, The Gilmore Collection slow night, it takes on new signifi- Meijer Inc. supercenter. With an estimated 500 million Corp. in Grand Rapids expects to cance when someone wants to find While hundreds of thousands of smart phones in use worldwide to- unveil a free app for Apple’s friends visiting a 70,000-square-foot, Engelsma Dowdy applications and games are avail- day and that number expected to iPhone that will enable users to four-story building that houses tion’s B.O.B. restaurant last week in able now for smart phones, what quadruple by 2015, experts say an call up information on any of com- eight restaurants, bars and night- celebration of Fat Tuesday. makes the Grand Rapids experi- app is going to be in just about pany’s 25 restaurants, nightclubs clubs packed with people — which The Gilmore Collection, estab- ence worth watching is to see everyone’s future. Plenty of people and catering and banquet centers was the case at The Gilmore Collec- lished in 1976, has restaurants in metro Grand Rapids, Grand Haven and Redstone, Colo., and employs about 600 full- and part-time work- ers. “Gilmore’s got great restau- rants,” says Jonathan Engelsma, an associate professor researching mo- bile technology at Grand Valley State University who oversaw graduate students who cre- ated the app. “So if my wife and I were going out and we wanted to pick a nice restau- rant, I probably The Gilmore run the Gilmore app Collection’s before I’d run Ur- iPhone app banspoon or Open Table because they can give you too much information.” Says Matt Dowdy, creative direc- tor at The Gilmore Collection: “If you want to adapt to a society that is turning to the Web to advertise, then you accept that people are ac- cessing the Web on their mobile phones and market accordingly.” Dowdy draws a strong distinc- tion between using a phone app and calling up a restaurant’s web- site on a smart phone. A phone app provides less information but in- teracts much easier than the Web, such as automatically calling a restaurant to make a reservation. “You can’t just take what’s on your regular Web page and copy that to the app,” Dowdy says. “There’s just too much data.” Engelsma says some research indicates a company can lose 10 percent of its audience using a computer or smart phone with every click or interaction the user is required to make. Because an app doesn’t use a Web browser, it requires many fewer steps in searches. Dowdy concedes that The Gilmore Collection probably wouldn’t have paid to create a phone app because of development costs. But it sees value in learning more about its customers’ dining experiences — particularly how they use Foursquare. So when GVSU offered to develop the app for free as a research tool, the com- pany jumped at the chance. If the experiment is successful, the company may pay to have apps written for the Android and Black- Berry smart phones, he says. What’s the latest in aisle 7? Giving customers up-to-the- minute information on food spe- cials is key to a free app for Android See Next Page 20110314-NEWS--0012,0013-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/10/2011 4:19 PM Page 2
March 14, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 13
CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS Advertisement Why is “Placemaking” picture-perfect for Michigan’s economy?
Neighborhoods, cities, regions and states across America are taking notice of how important “place” is in the economic development equation. Michigan is no exception.
To revitalize Michigan we must examine our state through a new lens, taking into account the types of places where New Economy workers,
MATT GRYCZAN/CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS entrepreneurs and businesses want to locate, invest and expand. President Jeffrey VandenBerge says Forest Hills Foods Inc. hopes to boost This approach is commonly described as a “sense of place” or just business and learn more about customers through an app for Android phones. “placemaking.” It’s a simple concept really, based on a single principle – talented and young people settle in places that offer the amenities, social From Previous Page “We are finding there are people who would prefer to use their and professional networks, resources and opportunities to support thriving phones being launched this month smart phones to find something in lifestyles. Michigan can attract and retain talent-based workers by focusing by Forest Hills Foods Inc., an old-line the store rather than ask someone, on how best to utilize our regional communities’ unique placemaking assets supermarket serving southeastern just like there are people who love such as squares, plazas, parks, streets, green spaces and waterfronts. Grand Rapids. The 50,000-square- the self-scan checkers, and there foot supermarket and fuel station, are people who refuse to use Our job begins by working together to build and maintain quality places in established in 1959, employs about them,” says Frank Guglielmi, Mei- each region of Michigan that will reinvent our state for the 21st century. 250 full- and part-time workers. jer’s director of public relations. Like The Gilmore Collection, “Basically, we Don’t just take our word for it. Forest Hills Foods used free devel- want to serve Ask Cynthia Kay, founder of a high-definition media production and opment work from GVSU to tap every type of into how its customers use social customer, and communications consulting company. networks, says company President we want to make Jeffrey VandenBerge. One of the the shopping ex- Kay’s six-person firm’s clients include multinationals like Herman Miller, primary uses of the app will be to perience as easy Amway Global, Siemens Industry, Novartis, Wiley Publishing, as well as inform smart-phone users about as possible.” educational institutions like Michigan State University, Grand Valley State daily specials, which they can Meijer is now University and Hope College. share with family and friends via enhancing the e-mails, text messages, Twitter Find-It app, Guglielmi and Facebook. launched last “In a sense, it’s trying to encour- August, to “add more functionality age your customer into becoming and increase the number of applic- an advocate for your business,” able stores,” Guglielmi says. “We VandenBerge says. “We should plan to eventually have a level of then be able to track which of functionality that will work with- those conduits are being used and in all Meijer stores.” get a sense of how the consumers Meijer, based in Walker near talk with each other.” Grand Rapids, operates in five She could have opened her state-of-the-art shop anywhere. All of that information becomes states, with its 195 stores ranging Kay chose Grand Rapids because of her belief that a vibrant community is valuable as Forest Hills Foods and from supercenters to smaller-format vital to success – not just to her corporate bottom line but to the quality of life other retailers begin to experi- stores of about 100,000 square feet. her family, employees and neighbors proudly enjoy. ment with digital direct-to-con- Engelsma says the Find-It app sumer channels in addition to tra- appears to have been well-received “Our downtown is a place where people want to be,” she says. ditional methods of advertising by consumers, with complaints “You’ll find students, young professionals, entrepreneurs and corporate types through print fliers. largely centering on the fact that it It may be possible for Forest isn’t available yet in many stores. out and about networking and socializing, in cafes, restaurants and parks. Hills Foods to use its app to sup- “One Meijer store probably has We get to rub shoulders, rub ideas together, and the magic that results is port buy-local initiatives by allow- more than 10,000 items in it, and good for business. ing shoppers to scan bar codes and there’s a lot of flux with seasonal learn more about the suppliers be- items moving in and out,” he says. “And the arts scene in Grand Rapids is a big part of it all. From museums to hind the items. “How are you going to keep a data- Art Prize, it’s an energizing environment where things can and do happen. The app already helps users find base up to date with that many prod- When you’re a part of a community like this, you want to become a part of it items in the store. And Vanden- ucts changing? That’s got to be an and give back – that’s why we donate our services to many nonprofits. Berge hopes, through the app’s incredibly hard problem to solve.” use, to cull information about how If another digital shopping ini- It’s part of the cycle that brings people and ideas together.” items are displayed — as long as it tiative by Meijer is any gauge, doesn’t get too heavily used. Find-It may have widespread use. The Small Business Association of Michigan (SBAM) and the Michigan State “We are a service business, and Meijer’s mPerks program Housing Development Authority (MSHDA) share Cynthia Kay’s belief: part of our business model is to launched in September for digital Placemaking matters. have people on the floor to answer coupon clipping that can be used at questions,” he says. “However, all the chain’s stores. It is averaging Together, we are helping Michigan’s state and local governments eliminate there are certain people who don’t about 5,000 new users a week, with barriers to placemaking, leverage private investment, promote diverse want to interact with other people, a current total of about 175,000 par- housing choices and mixed-use development, spur alternative or maybe heavy users of the ticipants, Guglielmi says. transportation, embrace cultural activities and cultivate green spaces. phones. So it will be interesting to A user creates an account with a see how much the map function re- mobile phone number, then clips The best thinking about successful communities and regions ally gets used.” coupons digitally. During check- out at a Meijer store, the shopper points to one conclusion. Creating vibrant, attractive public inputs the mobile phone number, spaces is not just a winning economic strategy. Meijer’s app finds food, your car and the coupons are automatically That same dichotomy — digital deducted from the bill. Placemaking is picture-perfect for Michigan’s return to prosperity. age vs. traditional shopper — is “My contention is that retailers making itself apparent at five Mei- need to build experiences that are jer stores in metropolitan Grand specific to their venues and give SMALL BUSINESS Rapids that are test locations for users just what they want while AssociationA of MICHIGAN the corporation’s Find-It app for they’re in their stores,” Engelsma Focusing the power of small business. Apple and Android devices. Shop- says. “Having an app specifically pers can use the free app to find for your business appears to do products in the stores, provide in- just that.” To learn more about Michigan placemaking, go to: michigan.gov/mshda formation on sale items and even Matt Gryczan: (616) 916-8158, find where they parked. [email protected] 20110314-NEWS--0014-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/10/2011 4:17 PM Page 1
Page 14 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 14, 2011 CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS
• The largest health care focused CEO’s determination, law firm in the nation. • Over 40 years in the health law business. new owners give Saginaw • More than 150 attorneys serving health care clients. • Representing over 500 health care auto supplier a future organizations nationwide.
DAVID SEDGWICK turned Saginaw Steering Gear — CRAIN NEWS SERVICE now named Nexteer — to GM in 2009. Padlocked plants and windswept The toughest part of the reorga- parking lots are common sights in nization occurred last June, when Michigan’s industrial landscape. Nexteer’s hourly workers rejected Bob Remenar, CEO of Nexteer a five-year wage freeze, with a $12- Inc., was deter- an-hour starting wage, down from mined to avoid $14. In 2003, Delphi’s starting wage IF IT’S HEALTH CARE that fate for his was about $28 per hour, excluding company, which benefits. Twelve dollars an hour is makes steering below the federal poverty level for systems in Sagi- a family of five. WE WILL BE THERE. naw. The proposed $12-an-hour con- Remenar tract originally offered individual For a comprehensive resource on reform-related stuck with Gen- health care coverage for new hires, regulatory developments visit hallrender.com/hcr. eral Motors but no family medical plan. After Remenar Corp.’s former Nexteer restored family coverage, in-house steer- the workers accepted the deal. ing-gear supplier through the Matt Beaver, vice president of bankruptcy of parent Delphi Corp.; UAW Local 699, says Remenar has through Delphi’s showdown with kept the union well-informed about the United Auto Workers union that company operations. Remenar cut starting wages by about half; holds meetings every other week and through the bankruptcy of with local UAW leaders and quar- GM, Nexteer’s main customer. terly meetings with members. 201 West Big Beaver Road | Suite 1200 | Troy, MI 48084 | 248.740.7505 www.hallrender.com Now, with a new Chinese owner, “Bob works with the UAW,” fresh capital and hot products, Nex- Beaver said. “I think highly of teer is back. Last year, GM sold him. I feel that he cares.” Nexteer to Pacific Century Motors, a A month after Local 699 ratified Chinese investment group with a the contract, GM sold Nexteer to long-term strategy. Pacific Century Motors, a joint Last year, Nexteer generated venture between Tempo Internation- sales of $2 billion, up from $1.6 bil- al, a Chinese maker of chassis lion in 2009, and Remenar expects parts, and Beijing’s municipal gov- sales to rise 10 percent in 2011. An- ernment. In November, Tempo other sign of health: Nexteer has dropped out of the joint venture. won contracts to supply electric While Nexteer boasted good power steering systems to an management, products and a com- unidentified Chinese automaker mitted workforce, the company’s and to French automaker PSA/Peu- Chinese investors deserve credit geot-Citroen. for taking the long view. When the Remenar has run Nexteer since deal was announced last July, Pa- 2002, when it was still known as cific Century Motors made three the Saginaw Steering Gear divi- promises: It would retain Nex- sion of Delphi, GM’s former in- teer’s current management, honor GRAND VALLEY STATE UNIVERSITY’S house supplier. When Delphi en- its union contracts and maintain tered bankruptcy in 2005, Remenar its headquarters in Saginaw. knew he couldn’t count on GM to The UAW’s Beaver and Remenar keep his factories busy. And a both say Pacific Century has kept post-bankruptcy Delphi planned to its word. The new owners have leave slow-growth product seg- kept a low profile in Saginaw, and ments such as steering systems. Remenar has focused on adding Ten days after Delphi filed for business. He is naturally upbeat, INITIAL PUBLIC bankruptcy protection on Oct. 8, and the role seems to suit him. 2005, Remenar asked for a meeting And he believes he has the right with Delphi’s leadership. product: electric power steering. He told his bosses that Delphi In contrast to hydraulic steering had too many mouths to feed, and units, which are always draining then he made his pitch: Instead of power from the engine off a drive OFFERING. being on the wind-down path, why belt, electric power steering con- don’t you give me a chance to save sumes energy only when the vehi- Saginaw Steering? cle is actually turning. Delphi President Rodney O’Neal Last year, electric power steer- agreed. ing generated 30 percent of Nex- After Delphi announced plans to teer’s total revenue, up from just 4 sell Saginaw Steering Gear in 2006, percent in 2002. Remenar expects Find your next hire through the GVSU the painful turnaround work be- it to generate 60 percent of Nex- gan. The company had good prod- Full-Time Integrated M.B.A. (FIMBA) Program. teer’s revenue by 2015. ucts and global operations, but With a slimmed-down organiza- costs were too high. tion, new owners with deep pock- Working with U.S. Bankruptcy ets and a product he believes in, Court and his Delphi bosses, Re- Remenar has the upbeat mien of a menar closed four plants — in salesman who has finally been un- Spain, Italy, France and Alabama. leashed. Our new accelerated M.B.A. program is available to business graduates with Saginaw Steering Gear also laid off “This company has gone through fewer than three years of experience. You can help groom these future leaders a third of its salaried workforce a lot of uncertainty over the last five and keep more talent in West Michigan by participating in our fellowship and handed off its pension obliga- years,” he said. “We started with a program. To learn more, visit www.gvsu.edu/grad/fimba or call 616.331.7400. tions to the federal Pension Benefit troubled business, and we trans- Guaranty Corp. formed it. We survived.” Still seeking a buyer, Delphi re- From Automotive News 20110314-NEWS--0015-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/10/2011 4:16 PM Page 1
March 14, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 15 CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS ‘We tried to keep it real’ SPREAD Budget-balancing game not for faint of heart
BY SHAWN WRIGHT SPECIAL TO CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS YOUR THE TOP TARGETS If you think these Since Gov. Rick Snyder un- Want to take a crack at balancing “ veiled his proposed budget last Michigan’s budget? Visit thecenterformichigan.net/you- are easy month, many around the state balance-the-state-budget to try it. have spoken out on everything Here are the five most popular choices, from the proposed cuts to higher strategies players of the online education to the elimination of al- game have used: you WINGS most all tax credits and the dis- 1. Raise the beer tax to 6 cents mantling of the film incentive pro- per bottle from 2 cents, and the should gram. Everyone, it seems, has an wine tax to 3 cents a liter from a opinion. penny. play the This is one reason that the Cen- 2. Extend the sales tax to personal ter for Michigan in Ann Arbor cre- services, which lowers all sales game. ated “You Balance the State Bud- taxes to 5.5 percent from 6 ” get,” an online game that percent but taxes many new Jeff Williams, launched Feb. 24. services, including home and car Public Sector Consultants repairs and maintenance, cable The idea came from John Be- and satellite TV, legal services and that, even today, when the words bow, executive live entertainment. director of the ‘billion’ and ‘trillion’ are in our vo- 3. Adopt Gov. Rick Snyder’s plan center, a non- for concessions from state cabulary, we don’t know what it profit think workers, which amounts to $3,200 really means until you have to find tank, and Jeff per worker in lower wages or higher ways to cut something.” Williams, CEO benefit co-pays. That’s an average Said Bebow: “If you play this of Public Sector cut of about 3.8 percent per budget game, you’re going to be Consultants, a worker. faced with tough decisions. It’s not nonpartisan 4. Adopt Snyder’s plan to cut a picnic to be a legislator; it gets think tank in funding by 15 percent for 15 state- gut-wrenching when deciding to Lansing. funded universities, which is likely make these cuts for real.” Bebow to result in tuition increases. To help de- He also suggested that family 5. Across-the-board cuts in state sign the game, Williams tapped a members play the game together. emich.edu couple of computer programmers departments, meaning a 10 percent reduction in general “I did it with my wife,” Bebow who have done work for Public government expenses. said. “We reached different con- Sector Consultants. clusions on what to cut.” The inspiration came from dif- Not everyone who has played enough that everyone in Michigan ferent sources, Bebow and the game is pleased with the op- Williams said, with the primary will feel it,” Williams said. “If you tions given, which is evident by being an online game The New think these are easy choices, you some of the comments left at the York Times launched last Novem- should play the game. You can’t bottom of the game’s Web page. ber that dealt with federal budget get to $2 billion in one cut.” cuts. Participants are asked to click Some people wrote that the list of “We took ideas from Gov. Sny- categories where they can choose choices should have included a der’s budget and House and Senate cuts or tax increases. As they graduated income tax or further fiscal agencies,” Williams said. choose, a blue bar at the top of the examination of all current busi- “We tried to keep it real and very screen shows how close they are to ness tax credits, besides cutting current as well.” a balanced budget. the Michigan Business Tax. The first choice participants Participants can choose from Options to retain or cut the film must make is whether to cut busi- more than a dozen options in sev- incentive also weren’t available. ness taxes by $1.2 billion, as pro- eral categories: education, prison “With a project like this, you’re posed in Snyder’s plan. Depending and police, welfare and health never going to make everyone hap- on their choice, the budget cutters care, and public workforce. py,” Bebow said. “We put out rea- will begin with a $1.4 billion or “I’ve taken it a lot of times, dur- soned and documentable choices. $2.6 billion hole. ing the testing phase and after,” We wanted the game to be accessi- “The size of the hole is big Williams said. “What struck me is ble to everyone. This is probably going to be disappointing if you’re a budget wonk.” As of March 4, more than 6,000 Exceptional Leadership. people have played the role of leg- islator. Of those who played, near- Delivered. ly 62 percent balanced the budget. Nearly 49 percent chose to cut the Michigan Business Tax, and al- most 79 percent relied on some sort of new tax or tax increase. The number of participants has surprised Williams and Be- Michigan’s bow. “We would’ve been happy with a Premier few hundred participants over Retained three weeks,” Bebow said. “You never know with this stuff. I think Executive it shows the high level of interest and how much people care about Search Firm this issue.” The game is scheduled to re- main on the Center for Michigan website for at least a couple more weeks, Williams said. “We’re looking to possibly con- LLC tinue to update and relaunch the International Executive Search game as more budget issues come along,” he said. “We’re open to the Tel: +1.248.645.1551 • www.huntergroup.com idea of maintaining it until the budget is signed.” 20110314-NEWS--0016-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/10/2011 4:16 PM Page 1
Page 16 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 14, 2011 CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS Plastics firm recognized for ‘green’ products, practices
BY PAT SHELLENBARGER In February, Cascade, head- stores in California, and it plans to SPECIAL TO CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS quartered near Grand Rapids in expand its retail offerings of sus- Cascade Township, became the tainable products through a new di- GRAND RAPIDS — Maybe he state’s first certified “B Corpora- vision called Cascade for the Home. could make more money by concen- tion” — the “B” stands for benefit. Cascade is a leader among many trating on profits alone and ignor- That recognition was bestowed by West Michigan companies that fol- ing his company’s environmental B Lab, a Pennsylvania nonprofit low sustainable business practices, and social responsibilities, Cascade dedicated to using the power of said Birgit Klohs, CEO of the Right Engineering President and CEO Fred business to solve social and envi- Place, the Grand Rapids area’s eco- Keller conceded. ronmental problems. nomic development agency. In part- But the bottom line is not his Cascade, which began as a man- nership with the U.S. Environmental bottom line. ufacturer of plastic-injected parts Protection Agency, the Right Place “Our purpose is to make a posi- for the automotive and office fur- founded the West Michigan Green tive impact on society and the en- niture industries, is the largest of Suppliers Network to help businesses vironment and be financially suc- the 380 corpora- become more sustainable. Another cessful,” Keller said. “If you’re tions so far rec- organization, the West Michigan Sus- going to be around, you have to be ognized with the tainable Business Forum, also encour- financially successful. B certification. ages companies to become more en- “For me personally, I don’t know Keller, 66, vironmentally responsible. if I could run a business if I didn’t founded Cascade Being lean and green makes enjoy what it’s doing in the world.” Engineering in sense not only environmentally 1973 with six em- but also financially, Klohs said. “If ployees and a you take waste out of the system, goal of building a you’re not taking it to the landfill, company that and you’re saving on energy.” Keller treats its em- Royal Technologies, a Cascade ployees well. competitor based in Hudsonville, The business has grown to more southwest of Grand Rapids, sends than 1,000 employees in 14 sites little to the landfill, recycles oil worldwide. While continuing to and uses energy-efficient lighting, supply plastic parts to the auto and said Ed Bos, who heads the compa- office furniture industries, Cas- ny’s sustainability program. Simplifying cade has expanded to 15 business “Some people think when you go units in manufacturing and mar- green, it costs more money,” he keting — reflecting Keller’s leader- said. “That isn’t necessarily true.” ship in environmentally friendly He credited Keller and Cascade the World of Healthcare business practices such as using with leading a green revolution in recycled plastics in new products. manufacturing. In 2007, Cascade began making a “I think it’s very admirable that plastic filter filled with sand to pu- they are taking the lead and spend- rify water in developing countries. ing efforts on being green,” Bos said. Last year it launched a global safe- That leadership extends to civic water initiative with the Windquest commitments. Keller chairs the In an increasingly complex world, Wolverine Solutions Group (WSG) can make life a whole Group, a Grand Rapids-based pri- W.K. Kellogg Foundation board and vate investment fund. So far, more was named to the U.S. Commerce De- lot easier. With a variety of technology-driven marketing communications products and services all than 1,000 of Cascade’s HydrAid partment’s Manufacturing Council under one roof, it’s time to make WSG your single source supplier, freeingyou up to spend more time on bio-sand filters have been deliv- in 2004. He also is among 50 CEOs what really matters—your core business. ered to cholera-stricken Haiti. who formed Talent 2025, an effort to For years, Cascade has manu- attract and retain creative employ- factured plastic trash carts on ees in West Michigan. In the fall of For over 30 years, WSG has grown to become a One Touch Partner by providing creative, printing wheels. Last year, Jo-Anne 2002, Keller began teaching a class andproduction services to our Healthcare clients—as well as clients in many other industries. We Perkins, general manager of Cas- in sustainable business practices at are proud of our reputation of providing all our clients with innovative products, fueled by cutting cade’s Cart Solutions division, Cornell University, his alma mater. suggested the company begin “I didn’t have this epiphany,” he edge technologies coupled with WSG’s unrivaled dedication to customer service. molding pink trash carts and do- said. “I didn’t wake up one morn- nating $5 for each one sold to the ing and say, ‘I want to make sus- WSG offers our Healthcare clients the following products and services: American Cancer Society’s breast tainable products.’ We didn’t have cancer awareness program. a word for it back then.” Other Services: “It was an easy ‘yes’ when she Being sustainable is not easy, • • Statement Processing-Patient Billing Statements, Direct Marketing came and said, ‘I’d like to do this,’ ” Keller said. • EOB’s/EOPB’s, Check Printing and Processing Web Solutions said Keller, whose first wife died of “Closing a plant and firing some- breast cancer in 1988. body, those are easy decisions,” he • • Creative Services On line Electronic Payment and Billing Systems Cascade uses about 12 million said. But figuring out how to mini- • • Patient-Friendly Billing Statement Creation and Production Web Based Fulfillment pounds of recycled plastic each mize a company’s impact on the en- • • Enrollment Benefit Kit Assembly and Distribution Online Print Solutions year, Keller said, and he hopes to in- vironment while making a profit? • crease that. The company recently That’s when creativity starts. • SPD Booklet Printing and Mailing Presorting • developed a process for painting That’s when it’s interesting.” • Open Enrollment Personalized Forms/Kit Production and Digital Printing plastic parts in the mold to reduce As a private company — Keller • Distribution List Acquisition the release of volatile organic com- and his family hold nearly all the pounds into the atmosphere. shares — Cascade does not release • Personalized targeted health care direct mail and other Three years ago, the company financial figures. But he said that marketing services added a line: small wind turbines “after a little setback in 2009,” Cas- for homes, communities and busi- cade’s growth rebounded last year nesses. Cascade manufactures the by 17 percent with revenue of a lit- Contact us today to discover how WSG can optimize your business turbine rotors and assembles them tle more than $250 million. The to generators built by Swift Wind company is on track for another 17 processes. [email protected], 313-871-2620 Turbine. Through a new division, percent increase this year, he said. Cascade Renewable Energy, formed Whether he could make more 1601 Clay Street, Detroit, MI 48211 • www.wolverinemail.com last July, the company sells wind money by focusing only on the bot- turbines and solar panels made by tom line is not something he companies in Oregon and China. thinks about, Keller said. Last year, Cascade began selling “I don’t have an ambition to die wind turbines through 21 Lowe’s with the most toys.” 20110314-NEWS--0017-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/10/2011 4:15 PM Page 1
March 14, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 17 CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS Manufacturing leads state job growth
BY AMY LANE eas such as fabricated-metal manu- 15,000 jobs from January 2010. CAPITOL CORRESPONDENT facturing and machinery manufac- Michigan’s unemployment rate turing, said Jim Rhein, a labor mar- in January was 10.7 percent, down LANSING — In small but en- ket analyst for the department. from December’s 11.1 percent rate couraging steps, some hard-hit Furniture manufacturing, and the lowest monthly jobless Do the sectors of Michigan’s economy are which had been showing declines, rate for the state since the 10.6 per- adding jobs. “seems to be holding its own” and cent rate in December 2008. The manu- is up slightly, he said. Compared with a year ago, the CRAIN’S LIST facturing Another area reporting gains is state’s January rate was down 3 per- Michigan’s largest sector led construction. That sector added centage points, from 13.7 percent. Right Thing employers, Page 18 overall gains 6,000 jobs in January but began But only about half that decline in Michigan showing minor increases in the is due to job growth, Rhein said. In payrolls in January, adding 20,000 last quarter of 2010. addition, fewer unemployed peo- jobs and continuing growth that Over the year, Michigan payroll ple are searching for jobs, which occurred throughout 2010, accord- jobs grew by 69,000, or 1.8 percent. contributed the remainder of the Ethos Week ing to the latest data from the Manufacturing posted the largest over-the-year change in the unem- Michigan Department of Energy, La- increase, adding 36,000 jobs, fol- ployment rate. bor & Economic Growth. lowed by professional and busi- “So it’s a good-news, bad-news March 14 -18 Although many of the manufac- ness services with 19,000 new jobs. situation,” Rhein said. “This big turing gains were auto-related, “a Education and health services drop is not all due to just employ- good portion of the over-the-year added 15,000 jobs. ment gains, unfortunately.” cob.emich.edu growth has actually been outside of Employment loss was concen- Amy Lane: (517) 371-5355, transportation equipment,” in ar- trated in government, which shed [email protected]
BRIEFLY SBAM scorecard: State strong lowed by tourism and recreation Rapids chamber since January (14 percent), shipping (8 percent), 2004, managing operations that in- in R&D, weak in business growth agriculture (8 percent), science and clude a 27 employees and an annual First, the good news: Michigan is engineering (2 percent), utilities budget of more than $3 million. holding steady when it comes to fos- (1 percent) and mining (1 percent). At the Quad Cities chamber, tering an entrepreneurial climate, The Michigan Sea Grant is part which has joint offices in Moline, according to the latest Small Busi- of the National Oceanic and Atmos- Ill., and Davenport, Iowa, Baker WJR’s Paul W. Smith pheric Administration-National Sea heads an organization that has ness Association of Michigan Entre- EMU’s David Mielke preneurial Scorecard. Grant network of more than 30 uni- 1,800 member businesses, 34 em- And now the bad news: That versity-based programs. ployees and a $4.6 million budget. means Michigan is close to the bot- — Shawn Wright Baker assumes his new post tom in some key metrics, com- April 4, and Englehart said she pared with the rest of the country. Plastics firm gets tax break, will remain at the chamber The state’s strengths are in the through mid-April. She said she quality of its research and develop- to spend $53 million, add jobs has not yet made plans for her next ment capabilities, said Graham professional steps. The state is providing tax incen- — Amy Lane Toft, president of Florida-based tives to Bad Axe-based Gemini Group Growth Economics Inc. and a techni- Inc. to renovate, upgrade and ex- cal consultant to SBAM on the pand in Huron County. Gemini, Snyder to speak at Grand Rapids scorecard. All figures are from 2009. whose holdings include four plas- The state ranked 13th in univer- tics plants in Michigan, will invest chamber lunch April 11 sity spinoffs and ninth in private $53 million on machinery, physical Gov. Rick Snyder will speak lending to small businesses. The expansion and capital investments. about the role job providers play number of self-employed Michigan Company executives were not in revitalizing Michigan at a Grand residents has increased, which immediately available to discuss Rapids Area Chamber of Commerce Toft said is a good thing. But the how they plan to use the invest- luncheon April 11. state ranked 50th in small-busi- ment, but they noted the money will Chamber and community mem- ness payroll growth and general create up to 290 jobs. The state is bers are invited to attend the event, business growth, 45th in entrepre- providing $6.56 million in tax cred- which will take place from noon to neurial climate and 30th in entre- its, while local governments are 1:30 p.m. in the Ambassador Ball- Plan. Invest. Extend a legacy. preneurial vitality. considering incentive packages. room at the Amway Grand Plaza Hotel To see the scorecard online, vis- Gemini had considered moving in downtown Grand Rapids. For Find us at PMFA.com. it www.sbam.org and click on the operations out of Michigan, but more information or to register, vis- News section of the website. the financial support will help en- it www.grandrapids.org/govluncheon. — Nancy Kaffer sure continued growth, CFO T.L. — Shawn Wright Bushey said in a news release. Be- Report: 1.5 million jobs, $62B sides the new jobs, the tax credits UPCOMING BREAKFAST ROUNDTABLE: will retain 762 jobs across the Wisconsin firm plans to add up in wages linked to Great Lakes state, he said. The Michigan Eco- to 156 jobs in Owosso Twp. March 15 nomic Growth Authority last month More than 1.5 million U.S. jobs Reaching Financial Independence and Charitable Planning approved tax incentives for Gemi- Wausaukee Composites–Owosso are directly connected to the Great ni and 14 other companies. Inc., which makes composite com- Lakes, generating $62 billion in — Plastics News ponents for the construction, agri- wages annually, says an analysis by cultural equipment, medical, All roundtables will be held from 7:30-8:30 a.m. at 27400 Northwestern Hwy., Southfield, MI 48034. Michigan Sea Grant, a collaborative transportation and wind energy effort of the University of Michigan Grand Rapids chamber finds industries, is planning a major Visit roundtables.pmfa.com to register. Seating is limited. and Michigan State University. capital investment at its location The two-page economic analysis new leader on Illinois-Iowa border in Owosso Township. updates a more extensive Michigan The Grand Rapids Area Chamber of The Wausaukee, Wis.-based com- Sea Grant report issued in 2009. Commerce has tapped a chamber pany plans to spend up to $1.9 million That report focused on the state’s executive in Illinois and Iowa as to expand and renovate the plant. economic ties to the lakes. The up- its next leader. Rick Baker, 46, The project is expected to create up date provides figures for all eight president and COO of the Quad to 156 jobs on top of 132 existing jobs. states that border the Great Lakes. Cities Chamber of Commerce, will be- The company received a Michigan INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT I *TRUST SERVICES According to the report, Michi- come president and CEO of the Economic Development Corp. Michigan *INSURANCE SERVICES I *TAX PLANNING gan has the highest number of jobs Grand Rapids chamber. He’ll suc- Business Tax credit, valued at that depend on the lakes — 525,886. ceed Jeanne Englehart, who in Oc- $783,909 over five years. The town- ESTATE PLANNING I WEALTH MANAGEMENT Manufacturing was responsible for tober said she would step down. ship board also approved a request BUSINESS TRANSITION I PHILANTHROPIC PLANNING 66 percent of the Great Lakes-linked Englehart has been president and for a local property tax incentive. QHHGTGFVJTQWIJCHſNKCVGUQH2/(# jobs, according to the report, fol- CEO of the 3,000-member Grand — Shawn Wright 20110314-NEWS--0018-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/10/2011 3:06 PM Page 1
Page 18 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 14, 2011
CRAIN'S LIST: MICHIGAN'S LARGEST EMPLOYERS State’s largest Ranked by full-time employees January 2011 for-profit employers Company Michigan Worldwide Address employees employees 1. General Motors Rank Phone; website Top executive 2011/2010 2011/2010 Type of business 38,835 State of Michigan Richard Snyder 43,616 43,658 State government 2. Ford Motor 1. Cadillac Place; Detroit 48202 governor 48,029 48,074 38,000 (313) 456-4400; www.michigan.gov 3. Chrysler Group General Motors Co. Daniel Akerson 38,835 209,000 Automobile manufacturer 22,431 2. 300 Renaissance Center; Detroit 48265 chairman of the board 41,828 215,000 4. Detroit Medical (313) 556-5000; www.gm.com Center* Ford Motor Co. Alan Mulally 38,000 163,000 Automobile manufacturer 9,904 3. 1 American Road; Dearborn 48126 president and CEO NA 159,000 5. Johnson Controls (313) 322-3000; www.ford.com 9,300 U.S. government NA 30,915 B 2,113,980 B Federal government 6. Dow Chemical 4. 477 Michigan Ave.; Detroit 48226 27,696 1,917,515 5,918 (800) 688-9889 7. Comerica Bank University of Michigan Mary Sue Coleman 28,449 28,449 Public university and health system 5,812 5. Ann Arbor 48109 president 27,815 27,815 (734) 764-1817; www.umich.edu 8. Dow Corning 4,500 Trinity Health Joseph Swedish 23,145 44,920 Health care system 9. Spartan Stores 6. 27870 Cabot Drive; Novi 48377-2920 president and CEO 23,145 45,572 (248) 489-6000; www.trinity-health.org 4,102 10. Amway Chrysler Group LLC Sergio Marchionne 22,431 52,488 Automobile manufacturer 4,000 7. 1000 Chrysler Drive; Auburn Hills 48326 CEO 19,423 47,470 (248) 576-5741; www.chryslerllc.com 11. Herman Miller 3,700 Henry Ford Health System Nancy Schlichting 19,963 19,963 Health care system 12. TRW Automotive 8. 1 Ford Place; Detroit 48202 president and CEO 18,473 18,473 (800) 436-7936; www.henryford.com Holdings 3,360 U.S. Postal Service Jo Ann Feindt 19,068 NA Postal service 13. Steelcase 9. 1401 W. Fort St.; Detroit 48233-9998 vice president of area operations NA (313) 226-8607; www.usps.gov 3,276 14. Pfizer Spectrum Health Richard Breon 16,131 16,131 Health care system 3,000 10. 100 Michigan St. NE; Grand Rapids 49503 president and CEO 15,027 15,027 (866) 989-7999; www.spectrum-health.org 15. General Dynamics 2,920 Philip Incarnati 15,750 15,750 Integrated health care delivery system McLaren Health Care Corp. 16. Gentex 11. G-3235 Beecher Road; Flint 48532 president and CEO 15,000 15,000 (810) 342-1100; www.mclaren.org 2,874 17. Gordon Food Patricia Maryland 13,140 13,140 Health care system St. John Providence Health System Service 12. 28000 Dequindre Road; Warren 48092 president and CEO 12,995 12,995 (866) 501-3627; www.stjohnprovidence.org 2,510 18. Stryker William Beaumont Hospitals Gene Michalski 12,437 NA Health care system 2,310 13. 3711 W. 13 Mile Road; Royal Oak 48073 president and CEO 14,495 (248) 898-5000; www.beaumonthospitals.com 19. IAC Group 2,243 City of Detroit Dave Bing 11,396 C 11,396 C City government 14. 2 Woodward Ave. mayor 12,472 12,472 20. Auto-Owners Coleman A. Young Municipal Center; Detroit 48226 Insurance (313) 224-3700; www.ci.detroit.mi.us 2,112 Detroit Public Schools Robert Bobb 10,948 10,948 Public school system 21. Art Van Furniture 15. 3011 W. Grand Blvd. Fisher Building; Detroit 48202 emergency financial manager 13,039 13,039 (313) 873-3111; www.detroitk12.org 2,055 22. MotorCity Casino Michigan State University Lou Anna Simon 10,725 NA Public university 2,040 16. East Lansing 48824 president NA (517) 355-1855; www.msu.edu 23. Lacks Enterprises 2,000 Detroit Medical Center Michael Duggan 9,904 9,904 Health care system 23. Haworth 17. 3990 John R; Detroit 48201 president and CEO 11,882 11,882 (313) 745-1250; www.dmc.org 2,000 23. Kellogg Johnson Controls-automotive operations Beda Bolzenius 9,300 142,000 Automotive supplier, building control systems and 2,000** 18. 49200 Halyard Drive; Plymouth 48170 president, automotive experience NA 130,000 facilities management (734) 254-5000; www.johnsoncontrols.com *On Dec. 31, 2010, DMC was acquired by Vanguard DTE Energy Co. Gerard Anderson 9,289 9,845 Energy and energy-technology company Health Systems, a Nashville- 19. 1 Energy Plaza; Detroit 48226 president and CEO 9,577 10,292 based investor-owned (800) 477-4747; www.dteenergy.com hospital company. DMC is now owned and operated by Consumers Energy Co. John Russell 7,522 7,522 Electric and natural gas utility VHS of Michigan, a 20. 1 Energy Plaza; Jackson 49201-2276 president and CEO 7,755 7,755 Vanguard for-profit (517) 788-0550; www.consumersenergy.com subsidiary. **Crain’s estimate Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan/ Daniel Loepp 6,972 6,972 Health care insurer 21. Blue Care Network president and CEO 6,992 6,992 600 E. Lafayette Blvd.; Detroit 48226 Want more? (313) 225-9000; www.bcbsm.com Purchase the list of the Wayne State University Allan Gilmour 6,272 6,272 Public university 125 largest employers 22. 42 W. Warren; Detroit 48202 president 6,183 6,183 in Michigan, other (313) 577-3577; www.wayne.edu Crain’s lists or our Book of Lists in Excel Oakwood Healthcare Inc. Brian Connolly 5,935 5,935 Health care system format at 23. 1 Parklane Blvd., Suite 1000E; Dearborn 48126 president and CEO 5,837 5,837 crainsdetroit.com. (313) 253-6000; www.oakwood.org Click on “Lists/Resources” on Andrew Liveris 5,918 50,154 Chemical manufacturer Dow Chemical Co. the top navigation bar. 24. 2030 Dow Center ; Midland 48674 chairman and CEO 5,748 52,268 (989) 636-1000; www.dow.com If you’ve never used this feature before, Comerica Bank Thomas Ogden 5,812 9,383 Financial services provider you’ll be prompted to 25. 500 Woodward Ave.; Detroit 48226 Michigan market president 5,526 8,940 set up an account. (248) 371-5000; www.comerica.com Should your company be on this list? This list of Michigan employers encompasses companies with headquarters in the state. Companies with headquarters elsewhere are listed with the address and top executive of their main Michigan office. This is not a Contact our data editor complete list, but the most comprehensive available. Unless otherwise noted, information was provided by the companies. Number of full-time employees may include full-time equivalents. NA means not available. Anne Marks at B As of Oct. 1, 2010. [email protected] or C As of Feb. 9, 2011. (313) 446-0418. LIST RESEARCHED BY ANNE MARKS AND PATRICE BUSHART 20110314-NEWS--0019-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/10/2011 3:06 PM Page 1
March 14, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 19 Extra
People
Lisa Newman, M.D., MPH, a professor of surgery and director of the Breast Care Center at the University of All aboard Michigan Comprehensive Cancer Center, and Kenneth Jamerson, At St. John, co-management gives physicians stake in services M.D., a professor of Newman internal medicine and hypertension specialist at the BY JAY GREENE University of Michigan Cardiovascular CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Center, were among those listed by f there is one overriding theme in the Black Health magazine as the 25 Most Influential African-American Doctors in new five-year strategic plan under the Detroit area. I way at St. John Providence Health Sys- Newman’s research focuses on tem, it is working more closely with the disparities in breast cancer, including an 2,200 mostly private physicians on the aggressive type of the disease called Warren-based system’s six hospital triple negative breast cancer that occurs medical staffs to improve quality of care more frequently in African-American and expand business opportunities. women. Most hospital systems in metropoli- Jamerson is nationally known for tan Detroit, including William Beaumont research in treatment of hypertension. Hospitals and Henry Ford Health System He was selected to lead a study (See story, Page 21), are trying to work showing early aggressive treatment of more closely with their physicians as high blood pressure with combination health care reform begins to encourage medicines is more effective at inpatient and outpatient care coordina- preventing heart attacks and strokes. tion, reduction in hospital readmis- Deborah Whiting, sions and development of accountable- MSA, BSN, and Pam care organizations. Wong, B.A., MBA, But at the heart of St. John Provi- have joined the staff dence’s plan is the creation of separate of Greater Detroit operating companies — 50-50 owned by Area Health Council. physician investors and Whiting will serve the hospitals — to co-man- as vice president of age entire clinical service community health. In lines. this role, she will DAVID DALTON direct the While it’s not a new con- Tom LaLonde, M.D., chairman of St. John Cardiovascular Co-Management Co., and Diane Radloff, Whiting organization’s cept nationally, St. John president of St. John Hospital and Medical Center, represent co-management in the health system. collaborative efforts to improve the Providence is the only health status of Southeast Michigan. health system in Southeast Physicians stand to make money in Whiting has worked with the Detroit Michigan to co-manage an two ways. First, doctor investors will Health Department and Wayne County inpatient hospital clinical WHATISCO-MANAGEMENT? receive hourly rates based on fair mar- Health and Community Services. service — in this case, car- Under clinical services co-management, Wong will serve as director of diovascular care — in a a health system or hospital typically ket value for various management ser- membership relations, joint venture with a group owns the real estate and jointly vices, LaLonde said. They also receive communications, community of physicians. manages specific clinical services with incentive compensation based on sev- partnerships and fund development. The “The goal is to achieve doctors who practice there. en quality metrics, two efficiency met- With more than 30 years of public “ the highest quality and effi- Physicians buy shares in the new rics and one program development relations, marketing, communications goal is to ciency” with the co-man- company that total 50 percent metric. and external affairs expertise, Wong aged companies, said ownership. Hospitals own the other 50 “The incentive payments will have previously served as chief of staff for achieve Michael Wiemann, M.D., percent. three tiers, with the highest tier being Michigan’s superintendent of public president of Providence Hos- The service is co-managed through an as efficient as any hospital in the coun- instruction. the pital in Southfield. “We oversight board of equal numbers of try,” LaLonde said. “Doctors will be doctors and hospital officials. Efthemia Steele, clinical services need to be more tightly in- paid an hourly rate, like a consultant, coordinator for Meijer Inc., was named highest tegrated with the hospitals The physicians get fair-market pay, for time spent on committees and to op- usually hourly rates for operational and the Community Pharmacist of the Year and the doctors to achieve timize outcomes and incentives.” at the Michigan Pharmacists quality clinical management duties. They also this.” Ann Brandt, senior director with Association’s annual convention and are paid based on exceeding certain Health Care Appraisers in Delray Beach, Effective March 1, St. clinical performance measurements for exposition Feb. 25-27 at the Detroit and effi- Fla., said the consulting firm developed Marriott Renaissance Center. John Providence began op- various metrics. erating St. John Cardiovascu- a fair-market-value total payment Steele has been active in the ciency. amount for the St. John Providence American Diabetes Association, where ” lar Co-Management Co., said Madison Heights. Tom LaLonde, M.D., chair- Under co-management, each doctor physicians if they meet targets. she has hosted a number of expos, Michael “Based on the performance and tasks provided presentations and serves as man of the newly formed will purchase an unspecified amount of Wiemann, M.D., performed, we gave (St. John Provi- the current co-chair of the ADA Stomp company. shares in the company to total 50 per- Providence dence) a two-year opinion with an an- Out Diabetes committee. Hospital “Doctors want to do what cent ownership. The St. John hospitals is good for patients and will own an equal share. A board com- nual dollar amount that included base Laura Wagner, pay and incentives,” Brandt said. “(St. CEO of Bingham work with hospitals on a posed of equal numbers of doctors and John) can pay anything up to that Farms-based In- common goal,” said LaLonde, who also hospital administrators will jointly amount.” House Hospice and is chief of cardiology at St. John Hospital make operational decisions. Palliative Care, has and Medical Center, Detroit. “This is a If the company achieves its stated Doug Rich, vice president of strategy been appointed to great opportunity for us.” goals, improved quality could lead to a and business development, said St. the board of The company includes 44 cardiolo- lower mortality rate, fewer hospital-ac- John does not expect a return on in- directors of the gists and heart surgeons and two of St. quired infections and higher reimburse- vestment until the second year. Health Care John’s hospitals — St. John Hospital ment by government and private pay- In 2009, Grand Blanc Township-based Association of and St. John Macomb-Oakland Hospital, a ers. Increased efficiencies could lead to Michigan. two-campus facility in Warren and lower expenses and more patients. See Co-management, Page 20 Wagner 20110314-NEWS--0020-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/10/2011 3:05 PM Page 1
Page 20 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 14, 2011 Health Care Extra Co-management: Docs have stake in companies ■ From Page 19 Genesys Health System formed three co-management companies with about 60 physicians. Genesys and The goal is not to St. John Providence are sister hos- “ pital companies. Both are part of St. increase volume. It Louis-based Ascension Health, the largest Catholic system in the U.S. is to increase quality Now in its second year co-man- aging the three companies — cov- and reduce costs. ering cardiovascular, general ” surgery, and orthopedics-podiatry Chris Rossman, Foley Lardner and neurology — Genesys has ex- perienced positive financial, effi- back statutes and physician self- ciency, patient and physician sat- referral bans. isfaction and quality results, said “Generally, doctors can’t refer a interim CEO Betsy Aderholdt. patient to an entity where they For example, have a financial interest,” Ross- Genesys in- man said. creased first- Avoiding legal problems can be time surgical accomplished in several ways, in- case starts by 20 cluding setting up a written agree- percent, in- ment between the hospitals and creased rates of physicians, determining the com- history and pensation in advance and not ty- physical com- ing referrals to the financial incen- pletion by 10 tives, Rossman said. percent, in- “The goal is not to increase vol- Aderholdt creased conges- ume. It is to increase quality and tive heart failure core measures to reduce costs,” Rossman said. “A nearly 100 percent and reduced collateral goal is to attract high- coronary stents per angioplasty quality physicians to practice at procedure to 1.43 from 1.72, saving the hospital and possibly partici- hundreds of thousands of dollars. pate in the co-management compa- “We were in the 88 to 90 percent ny. This can lead to increased vol- level with the core measures, and ume, but it can’t be the goal.” now we are up to 99 and 100 per- LaLonde said it is easier for cent,” Aderholdt said. physicians at the University of Michi- Core quality measures are col- gan and Henry Ford Health System lected voluntarily from hospitals to work more closely with their by the Centers for Medicare and Med- health systems on quality projects icaid Services and are posted on the and share in financial incentives U.S. Department of Human Services because doctors in those systems Hospital Compare website, www. are mostly employees, as opposed hospitalcompare.hhs.gov. to independent private practition- CMS core measures include the ers. percentage of heart attack patients Brandt said many hospitals who receive an aspirin upon ar- have tried ways to improve quality rival in the emergency depart- and efficiency of their clinical ser- ment, whether an antibiotic is giv- vices by working closely with 6WDUW6DYLQJ en within an hour before surgery, physicians. whether discharge instructions “They can hire physicians to 7RGD\ZLWK(QHUJ\ are given to heart failure patients manage the service line, or take a and whether pneumonia patients co-management approach. There (IÀFLHQF\,QFHQWLYHV are given smoking cessation in- is not a one-size-fits-all (ap- structions before discharge. proach),” Brandt said. “There has From a financial standpoint, been a huge increase in employ- ITH COLDER TEMPERATURES, now is the Aderholdt said, the physicians ment arrangements. The key is to get the doctors motivated and time to start saving energy and saving earned back their original invest- W ment halfway into the first 18- working on the same page.” money by boosting the energy efficiency of your month contract, excluding hourly By late spring, St. John plans to natural gas heating system. consulting fees. When the first create four other co-managed com- contract ended last December, the panies in unspecified clinical ar- Incentives are available for: physicians earned a 2.5-to-1 return eas, Wiemann said. Two of the • &URNACE