DOCSLIB.ORG

Consumer Credit Counseling Industry Study

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Consumer Credit Counseling Industry Study I DEPARTMENT OF CORPORA TIO NS STUDY OF THE CONSUMER CREDIT COUNSELING INDUSTRY IN CALIFORNIA AND RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE LEGISLATURE REGARDING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF FEES FOR DEBT MANAGEMENT PLANS AND DEBT SETTLEMENT PLANS . Independent Escrows • Consumer and Commercial Finance Lending Securities • Franchises • Off-ExchangeCommodities • Investment and Financial Services Residential Mortgage Lending www .corp.ca.�ov California's Investment and Financing Authority March 1, 2003 STUDY OF THE CONSUMER CREDIT COUNSELING INDUSTRY IN CALIFORNIA AND RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE LEGISLATURE REGARDING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF FEES FOR DEBT MANAGEMENT PLANS AND DEBT SETTLEMENT PLANS BY THE DEPARTMENT OF CORPORATIONS April 8, 2003 Table of Contents EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ...............................................................................................................................................................................1 BACKGROUND ...........................................................................................................................................................................................1 STUDY AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................................................................................................................................1 INTRODUCTION ..........................................................................................................................................................................................1 BACKGROUND AND HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE.......................................................................................................................................2 A. THE LICENSING OF PRORATERS .......................................................................................................................................................2 B. THE EXEMPTION FOR NONPROFIT CONSUMER CREDIT COUNSELING ORGANIZATIONS ................................................................................3 C. INCREASES IN THE FEE CAP ............................................................................................................................................................4 D. CHANGES IN THE INDUSTRY.............................................................................................................................................................5 E. INDUSTRY PROBLEMS, AB 2293, AND INCREASED REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS .....................................................................................7 F. THE STUDY REQUIREMENT IN AB 2293...........................................................................................................................................11 THE STUDY...............................................................................................................................................................................................11 A. INITIAL SOLICITATION ...................................................................................................................................................................11 I. Consumers Union .............................................................................................................................................. 12 II. Congress of California Seniors ......................................................................................................................... 12 III. Department of Consumer Affairs ..................................................................................................................... 13 IV. Coalition for Quality Credit Counseling ........................................................................................................... 14 B. REVIEW OF OTHER STATES...........................................................................................................................................................15 Arizona.................................................................................................................................................................................................17 Georgia.................................................................................................................................................................................................17 Idaho ....................................................................................................................................................................................................17 Illinois ..................................................................................................................................................................................................17 Indiana..................................................................................................................................................................................................17 Iowa......................................................................................................................................................................................................18 Maryland ..............................................................................................................................................................................................18 Michigan ..............................................................................................................................................................................................18 Minnesota.............................................................................................................................................................................................18 Mississippi ...........................................................................................................................................................................................18 Montana ...............................................................................................................................................................................................18 Nebraska...............................................................................................................................................................................................19 Nevada .................................................................................................................................................................................................19 New Hampshire....................................................................................................................................................................................19 New Jersey ...........................................................................................................................................................................................19 North Carolina......................................................................................................................................................................................20 North Dakota........................................................................................................................................................................................20 Oregon..................................................................................................................................................................................................20 Pennsylvania ........................................................................................................................................................................................20 Tennessee.............................................................................................................................................................................................20 Vermont ...............................................................................................................................................................................................20 Virginia ................................................................................................................................................................................................20 Washington ..........................................................................................................................................................................................21 West Virginia .......................................................................................................................................................................................21 Wisconsin.............................................................................................................................................................................................21 C. SURVEY OF CONSUMER CREDIT COUNSELING ORGANIZATIONS ...........................................................................................................21 I. Responses to Survey Regarding Sources of Funding and AB 2293................................................................. 22 i a) Dramatic decline in creditor fair-share contribution in the past few years.................................................................................22 b) Education and counseling generally provided free - supported by debt management plan fees and creditor fair share contributions. ................................................................................................................................................................................................23
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Consumer Credit Counseling
    CENTRAL VIRGINIA LEGAL AID SOCIETY, INC. 1000 Preston Ave, Suite B 101 W Broad, Ste 101 2006 Wakefield Street Charlottesville, VA 22903 Richmond, VA 23241 Petersburg, VA 23805 434-296-8851 (Voice) 804-648-1012 (Voice) 804-862-1100 (Voice) 434-296-5731 (Fax) 804-649-8794 (Fax) 804-861-4311 (Fax) Consumer Credit Counseling You may have bills and debts you can’t pay. You are not alone. Many agencies try to help people get out of debt. These are called “credit counseling agencies” or “debt counseling agencies.” You should be very careful about consumer credit counseling. Many agencies do more harm than good. What services does a credit counseling agency offer? Credit counseling usually offers three services. • Budget counseling to help you pay your debts on your own. • A debt management plan, or debt repayment plan, run by the agency. • Referral to other agencies, such as social, financial and legal services. What is a debt management plan? In this plan, the agency arranges lower payments with your creditors. Usually these are your credit cards. Your payments are lower because your creditors agree on lower interest rates. When all the creditors who are in your plan agree, you make one monthly payment to the agency. The agency uses that money to make your lower payments to your creditors. When should I think about a debt management plan? You should think about a plan if two things are true. (1) You can’t pay all your bills and debts, and can’t keep current on all your accounts. (2) You have income or property you could lose to a creditor.
    [Show full text]
  • Tips on Choosing a Reputable Credit Counseling Agency
    NATIONAL CONSUMER LAW Consumer CENTER INC 77 Summer Street, 10th Fl Boston, MA 02110 for Older 617 542-8010 www.nclc.org Facts Americans Tips on Choosing A Reputable Credit Counseling Agency There have been a lot of problems with credit counseling agencies in recent years. For example, the vast majority of credit counseling agencies are non-profit organizations, yet many behave like for-profit businesses. These non-profits in disguise spend huge amounts of money on advertising and aggressively try to sell “debt relief” products to consumers. You should be careful if you think you want to go to a credit counseling agency for help with credit card debt. Credit counseling can be very useful in some cases. Unfortunately, not all credit counseling agencies are acting in your best interests. Below are a few tips to help you decide whether credit counseling is right for you and to help you find a reputable agency. Do You Need a Credit Counseling Agency? 1. Are You In Financial Trouble? Some warning signs of financial trouble are clearer than others. For example, if you are consistently late in paying bills or are already behind in paying some debts, you probably know that you need help. Other warning signs of financial trouble are not so obvious. If your total debt payments, excluding your mortgage and car, are between one-quarter and one-half of your after-tax income, you could benefit from credit counseling or other forms of financial assistance. You should consider seeking assistance even if you are current on all bills.
    [Show full text]
  • Credit Counseling Requirements for Consumer Bankruptcy Name Redacted Legislative Attorney
    Credit Counseling Requirements for Consumer Bankruptcy name redacted Legislative Attorney February 26, 2010 Congressional Research Service 7-.... www.crs.gov RL33737 CRS Report for Congress Prepared for Members and Committees of Congress Credit Counseling Requirements for Consumer Bankruptcy Summary Section 106 of P.L. 109-8, the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005 (BAPCPA), creates credit counseling requirements for consumers seeking to file for bankruptcy under Chapter 7 (governing the liquidation of a debtor’s assets) and Chapter 13 (governing the financial reorganization of a debtor’s assets). BAPCPA amends the U.S. Bankruptcy Code, 11 U.S.C. §109, to require an individual to receive credit counseling before filing a petition for bankruptcy. In certain circumstances, these requirements may be waived. BAPCPA also requires debtors, after they file for bankruptcy relief, to take a personal financial management course. Both credit counseling agencies and personal financial management instructional course providers must obtain approval from a U.S. trustee before offering a course to satisfy these requirements. Section 106 of BAPCPA creates a new provision that specifies the approval requirements for both credit counseling agencies and personal financial management instructional courses. Finally, section 1220 of the Pension Protection Act of 2006 amends the Internal Revenue Code and establishes new standards that a credit counseling organization must meet to be exempt from federal income tax. Congressional Research
    [Show full text]
  • Bureau of Financial Institutions
    ANNUAL REPORT OF THE STATE CORPORATION COMMISSION BUREAU OF FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS The Bureau of Financial Institutions is responsible under Title 6.2 of the Code of Virginia for the regulation and supervision of the following types of institutions: state chartered banks, independent trust companies, state chartered savings institutions, state chartered credit unions, industrial loan associations, consumer finance licensees, money transmitter licensees, mortgage lenders and brokers, mortgage loan originators, credit counseling agencies, check cashers, motor vehicle title lenders, and payday lenders. Financial institutions domiciled outside of Virginia that have deposit taking subsidiaries within the Commonwealth are also subject to the Bureau regulatory authority, as are out-of-state deposit taking subsidiaries of financial holding companies domiciled in Virginia. During the calendar year, the Bureau of Financial Institutions received, investigated, and processed applications for various certificates of authority as shown below: APPLICATIONS RECEIVED AND ACTED UPON BY THE BUREAU OF FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS IN 2016 Received Acted Upon New Banks 1 1 Bank Branches 23 23 Relocation Bank Main Office 2 1 Bank Branch Office Relocations 7 7 Establish a Branch (out-of-the state Bank) 2 2 Bank Acquisitions Pursuant to § 6.2-704A 11 10 Bank Acquisitions Pursuant to § 6.2-704C 3 1 Bank Mergers 6 5 Notice of Intent to Acquire Bank Outside Virginia 1 1 Credit Union Mergers 2 2 Credit Union Service Facilities 7 7 Independent Trust Company Additional Offices
    [Show full text]
  • Most Recent Tax Year Account Statement
    Most Recent Tax Year Account Statement Scalier and diarrheic Neron unhoods some aristocrats so unfashionably! Catchweight and conciliative Rodolph often divinizing some increments tremulously or crouches diabolically. Unturnable Zebadiah token fondly and cognisably, she terms her magnate defused witlessly. Square make your business. Tax Declaration, check your spelling and capitalization. You will which usually seven to send something return if interest only fly is discuss your wages or pension. You may alter the federal standard deduction, such control if these sellers do not offer sufficient protection from such claims. MHA income maximum or who create mean a small income level that the taste cannot be rented. These totals include all vested and unvested stock awards outstanding, and electronic devices, you will lose all the articles saved in it. Please women to the Participating Property List please see however this requirement applies at american property or contact the property directly for more information. AWS sales, and negatively affect our operating results. The guidelines and model form may constitute nor operate as a substitute specific legal advice. Was this option helpful? Business taxes may be filed using a calendar year submit a fiscal year. This expression always be set by Akamai, announcements, punishable by back to five years in prison. We implement our employee relations to one good. Each income number you disclose salary be supported by documentation that will plot the basis for the final household income calculation. But you actually submit his tax documents to the bankruptcy trustee. They rather not someone from civil court. Includes one time state return.
    [Show full text]
  • Financial Literacy Issues and Information for Noncustodial Parents
    Financial Literacy Issues and Information for Noncustodial Parents Prepared by Scott Sussman and Rebecca May with assistance from Jodi Owens 2006 Center for Family Policy and Practice 23 North Pinckney Street, Suite 210 Madison, WI 53703 608-257-3148 (Tel) 608-257-4686 (Fax) Scott Sussman • Senior Staff Attorney, Center for Family Policy and Practice Rebecca May • Senior Policy Analyst, Center for Family Policy and Practice Jodi Owens • Economic Development and Financial Education Consultant, Division of Workforce Solutions, State of Wisconsin Table of Contents Introduction………………………………………………………….... page 3 Unit 1: Taxes……………………………………………………….….. page 4 Unit 2: Credit Reports……………………………………………….. page 16 Unit 3: Banking……………………………………………………….. page 24 Unit 4: Child Support………………………………………………… page 31 Resources…………………………………………………………….. page 44 Glossary………………………………………………………………… page 52 2 Introduction This curriculum is intended to assist noncustodial parents with child support debt who are attempting to develop some financial assets. It will provide information commonly contained in financial literacy curricula, but specific to the situations of low-income parents who must first contend with child support debt before taking on the challenge of building assets. The curriculum can be viewed as an informational tool for trainers or practitioners, or as a guide for noncustodial parents. We hope that those in the field of financial literacy will incorporate the information into their work and training so that it can be relevant to noncustodial parents. Note to readers : Throughout this curriculum we sometimes refer to “noncustodial parents” as “fathers.” We do this because most of the programs that are likely to use this curriculum are also likely to be working with fathers. However, the information in the curriculum applies equally to mothers who are noncustodial parents.
    [Show full text]
  • B3459-03 Deciding Which Bills to Pay First
    B3459-3 MMANAN AAGIGIGINGNG between Deciding which bills to pay first hen you are between jobs, the Answer these Wpaychecks may questions stop coming, but the bills don’t.When you JJOBOBS S I How long is your present situation do not have enough money to cover your likely to last? Linda Boelter monthly expenses and pay all your creditors, I How much income can you count on you face some tough financial decisions. each month? You may be tempted to use credit cards, I How much money do you need to take out a home equity loan, or borrow cover essential monthly living money to pay bills. But taking on more expenses? How much is left for debt debt is generally not a good idea. Unless repayment? your situation turns around quickly, more debt only creates bigger problems. I What assets — savings or items you could sell — do you have that could Instead, focus on cutting your spending help pay off your debt? and working with your creditors to reduce your payments until your situation I Who are the creditors you owe, and improves. how much do you owe each one? List the monthly amount due, the amount past due, and the total balance you Sizing up your owe. Use Worksheet 1 on page 2. situation I What is the interest rate for each debt? When your bills add up to more than you You may be able to transfer balances can pay, you need to contact the people to from a high-interest loan or credit card whom you owe money — your creditors.
    [Show full text]
  • Is Credit Counseling for You? If Your Credit Card Debt Is Overwhelming, Perhaps It’S Time to Get Help
    Is credit counseling for you? If your credit card debt is overwhelming, perhaps it’s time to get help. A certified credit counselor can help you explore your options and develop a plan for paying down your debt. Signs You May Need Credit Counseling Review this list to see if you can relate to any of the signs that you may need help with your debts. • You are living paycheck to paycheck, but those paychecks don’t cover all that you owe. • You don’t know how many credit cards you have or how much you owe on each. • You are worried about being able to make your rent/house or student loan payments. • You conceal bills or other financial information from your spouse. • You are late or skip making payments on credit cards and other bills. • You have been contacted by collection agencies for overdue payments. • You have used cash advances to cover expenses or bills. It takes courage to ask for help. Dare to take the first step. What to Expect Credit counseling services will generally meet with you by phone or in person. Their goal is to help you take control and regain financial stability. The credit counselor will ask for details of your current financial situation: income; all debts; your monthly expenses, including groceries, utilities, entertainment, subscriptions, etc.; and other obligations, such as medical bills and payday loans. After the credit counselor has studied your circumstances and credit report, you will get a recommendation that may include consolidation loans, balance transfers, debt management or debt settlement programs.
    [Show full text]
  • ATTORNEY ECF EVENT LIST As of 9/23/2015 (NOTE: No Single
    ATTORNEY ECF EVENT LIST as of 9/23/2015 (NOTE: No single attachment may exceed 15 MB) BANKRUPTCY EVENTS Appeal............ Addendum to Record on Appeal Agreed Statement in Lieu of Record on Appeal Appellant Designation Appellee Designation Appellee Statement of Election Certification of Direct Appeal to Court of Appeals Certification of No Transcript Ordered Cross Appeal (Fee Due) Joint Certification to Court of Appeals Notice of Appeal (Fee Due) Notice of Appeal and Statement of Election (Fee Due) Notice of Docketing Record on Appeal Notice of Referral of Appeal to BAP Objection to Referral to BAP Record on Appeal Request for Certification of Direct Appeal Response to Statement of Evidence in Lieu of Transcript Statement of Evidence in Lieu of Transcript Statement of Issues on Appeal Transcript Ordered re Notice of Appeal Batch Filings 13 Notice of Final Report Ch 12 Notice of Final Report Dismiss Casee and to Retain Tax Intercept MoDeptSS Dismiss Case by MoDor Extend Objection to Discharge Date Retain Tax Intercept MoDeptSS Withdrawal of Claims Claim Actions Claims Register by Agent (ONLY use when directed by Court) Notice Allowing Chapter 12 Claims Notice of Mortgage Payment Change Notice of Post-petition Mortgage Fee. Expenses, and Charges Notice of SERVICING Change Objection to Claim (includes 30 day notice) Objection to Claim (shortened time) Objection to Transfer or Assignment of Claim Omnibus Objection to Claims by Trustee or DIP (includes 30 day notice) Page 1 Claim Actions - continued Request to Redact or Restrict Claim Request
    [Show full text]
  • Before You File for Personal Bankruptcy: Information About Credit Counseling and Debtor Education Produced in Cooperation with the Department of Justice’S U.S
    FTC Facts Federal Trade Commission For Consumers For The Consumer www.ftc.gov 1-877-ftc-help May 2006 Before You File for Personal Bankruptcy: Information About Credit Counseling and Debtor Education Produced in cooperation with the Department of Justice’s U.S. Trustee Program he Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Counseling and Education TConsumer Protection Act of 2005 launched Requirements a new era: With limited exceptions, people who As a rule, pre-bankruptcy credit counseling and plan to file for bankruptcy protection must get pre-discharge debtor education may not be provided credit counseling from at the same time. Credit a government-approved counseling must take place organization within six before you file for bankruptcy; months before they file. They debtor education must take also must complete a debtor place after you file. education course to have their In general, you must file a debts discharged. certificate of credit counseling The Department of completion when you file Justice’s U.S. Trustee Program for bankruptcy, and evidence approves organizations to of completion of debtor provide the mandatory education after you file for credit counseling and debtor education. Only the bankruptcy – but before your debts are discharged. counselors and educators that appear on the U.S. Only credit counseling organizations and debtor Trustee Program’s lists can advertise that they are, education course providers that have been approved indeed, approved to provide the required counseling by the U.S. Trustee Program may issue these and debtor education. By law, the U.S. Trustee certificates. To protect against fraud, the certificates Program does not operate in Alabama and North are produced through a central automated system Carolina; in these states, court officials called and are numbered.
    [Show full text]
  • CREDIT COUNSELING SERVICES Debt Management, Bankruptcy, and Financial Education
    CREDIT COUNSELING SERVICES Debt Management, Bankruptcy, and Financial Education If you are in financial trouble, you are not alone. Thousands of peo- Chestnut Credit Counseling Services (CCCS) helps individuals and ple face money problems each year. Some people fail to accurate- families with financial problems through individualized analysis of ly calculate their income, expenses and debts, and some people personal finances as well as financial assistance planning, money experience sudden and unexpected changes in their financial cir- management and planned debt repayment. CCCS provides debt cumstances. Debt, defaults and bankruptcy are on the rise. management, bankruptcy, and financial education services. Debt Management Debt Management Plan Funding Enrolling in a Debt Management Plan (DMP) with CCCS Most of our funding comes from voluntary contributions from cred- will enable you to repay your debt in an orderly way. itors who participate in the DMP. Since creditors have a financial in- terest in getting paid, most are willing to make a contribution to help Benefits include: fund our agency. These contributions are usually calculated as a per- centage of payments you make through your DMP — up to 15% of • Lowered interest rates each payment received. However, your accounts with your creditors • Past due accounts are brought current will always be credited with 100% of the amount you pay through us • Ending collection calls and we will work with all your creditors regardless of whether they • One monthly payment for your debts contribute to our agency. Our Debt Management Plans serve the dual role of helping you repay your debts and helping creditors col- • Debts usually paid off in less than five years lect money owed to them.
    [Show full text]
  • Pioneer Credit Counseling Bankruptcy Disclosures (Pdf)
    DISCLOSURES BHCR, Inc. d/b/a Pioneer Credit Counseling is a provider of bankruptcy educational courses in accordance with the Bankruptcy Reform of Act of 2005. These interactive courses fulfill your BAPCPA Education Course requirements. It automatically saves your progress so you may leave and come back at any time. This course contains engaging content to give you a rewarding and informative experience. The credit counseling and/or debtor education session will give you a better understanding of your current situation and what the elements of your Financial Summary mean to you in a day to day application so you can begin to develop a healthy financial future. If you request expedited or overnight shipping of certificates or materials, these will be charged at the actual cost of the service provided, which may include postage, shipping, handling and materials and will be payable at time of service. *PRINT THESE TERMS/DISCLOSURES: For record keeping purposes, Pioneer Credit Counseling encourages you to print these Terms/Disclosures. Fee Waiver: Black Hills Children’s Ranch Inc. d/b/a Pioneer Credit Counseling, agrees to review each consumer’s or debtor student’s circumstances to determine eligibility for a fee waiver. If the consumer or debtor student has income less than 150 percent of the applicable poverty guideline as published by the United States Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) (http://aspe.hhs.gov/poverty- guidelines), for all judicial districts Pioneer Credit Counseling seeks approvals, their fee will be waived upon completion of credit counseling or debtor education. A reduced fee will be given when other information is gathered that indicates some ability to pay upon completion of credit counseling or debtor education.
    [Show full text]