DOCSLIB.ORG

Sexuality Education: an Overview for Independent Schools October 2017

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Sexuality Education: an Overview for Independent Schools October 2017 Sexuality Education: An Overview for Independent Schools October 2017 Miguel G. Marshall Sara Silverio Marques Justine Ang Fonte Amy Patel National Association of Independent Schools 1 Contents About the Authors ...................................................................................................... 3 Acknowledgements .................................................................................................... 4 Disclaimer .................................................................................................................. 5 Introduction ............................................................................................................... 6 What May Be the Role of Independent Schools? ............................................................ 9 Consider Some of the Background ....................................................................................... 11 Consider Some Key Terms ................................................................................................... 13 Consider Some of the Controversy ....................................................................................... 15 Consider Some Options ...................................................................................................... 16 What Has Been the Dialogue on Sexuality Education? .................................................. 17 What Is Sexuality Education? ..................................................................................... 20 Abstinence-Only Sexuality Education .................................................................................. 23 Abstinence-Plus Sexuality Education ................................................................................... 24 Comprehensive Sexuality Education .................................................................................... 25 Effective Practice ................................................................................................................ 27 Ensuring Developmental Appropriateness..................................................................................... 28 Developmentally Responsive Educational Strategies Assessment Tool ......................................... 29 What Are the Goals and Intended Outcomes of Sexuality Education? ............................ 34 Comprehensive Sexuality Education .................................................................................... 34 Abstinence Sexuality Education .......................................................................................... 38 Risks and Potential Negative Effects of Sexuality Education Programs .................................. 38 Conclusion ............................................................................................................... 39 Implementation: Potential Considerations for Independent Schools ............................. 40 References ............................................................................................................... 43 Resources ................................................................................................................. 51 National Association of Independent Schools 2 About the Authors Miguel G. Marshall is the former interim executive director of the Independent School Health Association (ISHA) and the foremost subject-matter expert on “school health in independent schools.” With 15 years of experience working with youth in a variety of settings, including independent schools, Marshall has taught, educated, collaborated, presented, researched, and published on topics and initiatives that advance schools’ commitments to the “whole child.” His research led to a proposal of the first NAIS Principles of Good Practice for School Health in Independent Schools. Marshall most recently served on the NAIS-TABS Task Force for Educator Sexual Misconduct. He led the development of the first national survey of student health, wellbeing, and grit in independent schools, keynoted the first Independent School Health Conference, and served as a member of the planning committees for the Independent School Health and Wellness Summit and the Northeast Independent Schools Mindfulness Conference. Marshall earned his Master of Arts and Doctor of Education degrees in health education from Columbia University. Sara Silverio Marques has more than 15 years of experience in youth development, including designing, implementing, and evaluating innovative ways to improve the health of young people in the United States and abroad. Her current work focuses on the health and developmental implications of early-life adversity on children as the director of strategic initiatives at the Center for Youth Wellness in San Francisco. Prior to this role, Silverio Marques was a research scientist and Ford Foundation fellow at the Public Health Institute’s Center for Research on Adolescent Health and Development, where she focused on adolescent sexual health and rights, web-based sexuality education, and the use of research to inform policy and program development. She earned her Doctor of Public Health degree from the University of California, Berkeley where her studies concentrated on the conceptualization and practice of developmentally appropriate sexuality education. Silverio Marques also holds a Master of Public Health from George Washington University. Justine Ang Fonte is a sexuality educator and social justice activist working in both public and private schools. Her work as a teacher began in middle school mathematics, which gave her the groundwork to understand the administrative structures in school systems. She experienced first-hand the negative impact that insufficient health care and access had on her math students’ learning. She received her Master of Education in teaching from the University of Hawai`i and Master of Public Health from Columbia University with a specialization in sexuality. She is currently the director of health and wellness at The Dalton School (NYC), teaching health to the student, parent, and faculty communities. She also works as a consultant and speaker to schools and universities on feminist-based health education across the United States. Amy Patel is the Medical Director at Phillips Academy (MA). A graduate of Tufts University and the University of Vermont College of Medicine, she went on to complete a combined residency program in internal medicine and pediatrics. She has worked in a variety of settings as a physician, medical director, and health IT startup cofounder prior to joining the Phillips Academy community in 2012. She is a member of the Sports Medicine Advisory Council for the New England Prep School Athletic Council and co-director of the Independent School Health Association. Patel’s professional interests are rooted in the belief that adolescence to early adulthood is a crucial time in a person’s life for developing lifelong healthy habits, and she believes that everyone deserves access to quality health care and evidence-based, inclusive health education. National Association of Independent Schools 3 Acknowledgements The authors would like to acknowledge and thank Debra Wilson, NAIS’s general counsel, whose foresight, input, reflectivity, collaboration, experience, and emphasis on proactively healthy schools initiated this work and enabled its publication. The authors would also like to thank Bridget Janicki, NAIS’ editor, for her stylistic contributions, editing, and thoughtful review of this document. National Association of Independent Schools 4 Disclaimer This document (the “Document”) is authored by Miguel G. Marshall, Sara Silverio Marques, Justine Ang Fonte, and Amy Patel (the “Authors”) in their collective capacity. Opinions expressed in the Document are the Authors’ own and do not reflect the view of the National Association of Independent Schools, Independent School Health Association, Center for Youth Wellness (Public Health Institute, UC Berkeley), The Dalton School, Phillips Academy or any employee, student, parent, or volunteer thereof. The document and research does not reflect an academic-level, formal, documented, or systematized review of the literature on any topic. All peer-reviewed literature cited in this document was retrieved from Columbia University Libraries and, therefore, may be limited to the holdings of those libraries. Although the final publication of the Document reflects a collaborative endeavor, the references supporting information in the Document may reflect biases of the author who selected those references and that author’s interpretation of those references. Although the Document cites publications and peer-reviewed, academic literature, it does not represent a comprehensive review of research or literature on any topic(s) and it undoubtedly excludes reference to resources that may be helpful to readers. Additionally, the contents of the Document, such as text, graphics, images, and other material contained herein are for informational purposes only and do not constitute medical and/or legal advice; the Document is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical, psychological, legal, insurance, or risk-management advice. Finally, information contained in the Document does not address teaching to students with intellectual disabilities. Further, because there is a dearth of academic literature pertaining to independent schools, it is important to note that research gathered for the Document is mostly reflective of studies completed within and implementations
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Complexities of Sex Education in Utah
    1 The Complexities of Sex Education in Utah Grace Sponaugle Occidental College, Urban & Environmental Policy Professor Cha, Professor Matsuoka, & Professor Shamasunder April 8, 2019 Sponaugle 2 Abstract Utah has a state-wide policy of abstinence education. Abstinence education programs have been proven to be ineffective at delaying the initiation of sex and changing sexual risk behaviors (Santelli et al., 2017), correlating with high rates of teen pregnancies and STIs ​ ​ ((Stanger-Hall & Hall, 2011)(McCammon, 2017)). Limiting the standards by which sex ​ ​ education programs are deemed “effective” to disease and pregnancy prevention, neglects the holistic view of sexual health as defined by the CDC. Therefore, in an attempt to understand the broader implications that sex education has had on youth in Utah, this study examined, through a survey and interviews, the social, cultural, and educational influences that youth in Utah attributed to their sex education. Additionally, this study analyzed how these influences have played a role in the youth’s self perception of their sexual knowledge and sexual health. This research revealed that abstinence education is inherently limited, calling for Utah to expand its sex education framework beyond abstinence education and embrace a comprehensive model for sex education. Sponaugle 3 Acknowledgements First, I would like to thank Professor Cha, Professor Matsuoka, and Professor Shamasunder for their help and guidance not only on the completion of my thesis, but also throughout my journey at Occidental College. Additionally, I would like to thank everyone that participated in the survey and interviews. None of this would have be possible without your support and interest in my project.
    [Show full text]
  • Values Education and Teachers' Work: a Quality Teaching Perspective
    VALUES EDUCATION AND TEACHERS’ WORK: A QUALITY TEACHING PERSPECTIVE ©Professor Terence Lovat The University of Newcastle NSW 2308 AUSTRALIA [email protected] Keynote Address at the National Values Education Forum, Australian Government Department of Education Science and Training, National Museum, Canberra, May 2005 **Nb. A version of this paper will appear in New Horizons in Education, volume 112 (2005) 2 VALUES EDUCATION AND TEACHERS’ WORK: A QUALITY TEACHING PERSPECTIVE Abstract In order for values education to become part and parcel of mainstream schooling, the closest possible links need to be found between it and the world of teachers and schools. Teaching has undergone a revolution over the past decade or so. Updated research into the role of the teacher has uncovered the true potential of the teacher (and, through the teachers, the school) to make a difference. Much of this research insight is captured in the notion of ‘Quality Teaching’, a perspective that speaks of intellectual depth, inter-relational capacity and self-reflection as being among the factors that characterize the kind of learning that makes a difference. There are important synergies between these perspectives and those of values education. Making these links has potential to release the true power of values education and to elevate it to a mainstream issue for all schools. The address will explore these links and demonstrate how other frameworks and resources available to teachers can be incorporated into a comprehensive and powerful values education for all schools. Introduction In order for Values Education to become part and parcel of mainstream schooling, especially in public systems, the closest possible links need to be found between it and the world of teachers and schools.
    [Show full text]
  • Dangerous Inhib Template
    Dangerous Inhibitions: How America Is Letting AIDS Become An Epidemic Of The Young By Chris Collins monograph series occasional paper #3 February 1997 M A R K E T I N G HIV P R E V E N T I O N • Harvard AIDS Institute • CAPS Center for AIDS Prevention Studies University of California San Francisco Chris Collins is an AIDS policy analyst at the Center for AIDS Prevention Studies (CAPS), University of California, San Francisco 74 New Montgomery Street, Suite 600 San Francisco, CA 94105 Phone: 415/597-9100 This monograph was produced as part of the Marketing HIV Prevention project, a collaborative project between the Center for AIDS Prevention Studies at the University of California, San Francisco (Thomas J. Coates, PhD, Director) and the Harvard AIDS Institute (Richard Marlink, MD, Executive Director). We would like to thank SmithKline Beecham Consumer Health Care, makers of OraSure, for its unrestricted grant in support of the Marketing HIV Prevention project. We would also like to acknowledge the support of the Office of AIDS, National Institute of Mental Health, National Institutes of Health, for its ongoing support of the Center for AIDS Prevention Studies under grant number MH42459. The author would like to thank Thomas Coates and Mario Cooper for their significant contributions to this report. I am also indebted to several colleagues who reviewed earlier drafts of the paper, including: Paula Brewer, James Colgrove, Peggy Dolcini, Kevin Filocamo, Katherine Haynes-Sanstad, Lisa Heft, Susan Kegeles, Clark Moore, Ric Marlink, Maureen Michaels, James Riggs, Mark Steitz, Jeff Stryker, and Steve Wakefield.
    [Show full text]
  • The Conceptions of Literacy of New Graduate Instructors Teaching Composition
    THE CONCEPTIONS OF LITERACY OF NEW GRADUATE INSTRUCTORS TEACHING COMPOSITION A Dissertation Submitted to the Temple University Graduate Board In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY by Meaghan H. Brewer May 2013 Examining Committee Members: Dr. Eli Goldblatt, Advisory Chair, Department of English Dr. Michael Smith, Department of Teaching and Learning Dr. Steve Newman, Department of English Dr. Jessica Restaino, External Member, Montclair State University ii © Copyright 2013 by Meaghan H. Brewer All Rights Reserved iii ABSTRACT This study explores the variety of understandings of literacy, or conceptions of literacy, that exist among graduate instructors in the fields of English literature, rhetoric and composition, and creative writing in their first semester of teaching and what the implications are for having these conceptions, particularly with regard to their teaching. I collected two kinds of data from seven participants who were enrolled in a fall 2010 composition practicum at a large, public university in the Northeast. The data I elicited included interviews of participants in which they examine their own writing, an assignment ranking activity, observations of participants as they teach composition, and field notes I collected from the Practicum course meetings. I also collected artifacts from their work in the Practicum course and their teaching, including two drafts of a literacy autobiography that they wrote for the practicum and marked-up student paper drafts from the composition course they were teaching. Following the work of Michael W. Smith and Dorothy Strickland, I parsed the data by content units. Using Peter Goggin’s categories for defining literacy from Professing Literacy in Composition Studies, I coded data using the qualitative data management system Atlas.ti according to seven conceptions: literacy for personal growth, literacy for personal growth, social/critical literacy, critical activist literacy, cultural literacy, functionalist literacy, and instrumental literacy.
    [Show full text]
  • From Promise to Proof Promise From
    POWER TO DECIDE HIGHLIGHTS OF POP PARTNERSHIPS CULTURE From Promise to Proof HOW THE MEDIA HAS HELPED REDUCE TEEN AND UNPLANNED PREGNANCY TABLE OF CONTENTS ABOUT US ...................................................................................................4 WHY IT MATTERS .......................................................................................5 SPOTLIGHT ON KEY PARTNERSHIPS ...........................................................7 FREEFORM ..................................................................................................8 COSMOPOLITAN ......................................................................................12 TLC ..............................................................................................................16 SNAPSHOTS OF KEY MEDIA PARTNERSHIPS ...........................................21 SEX EDUCATION ..................................................................................... 22 BLACK-ISH ............................................................................................... 23 ANDI MACK .............................................................................................. 24 MTV ........................................................................................................... 26 AP BIO ....................................................................................................... 28 BUZZFEED—BC ....................................................................................... 29 HULU ........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Approved Continuing Education Courses
    Approved Continuing Education Courses # of Date Activity Name Organizer Credit Type Credits Oncology Association of October 1, Mind Body Approaches Naturopathic 1 Category A 2018 in Oncology Physicians (OncANP) Integrative Fibromyalgia Series: Integrative Canadian Approaches to October 4 – College of Fibromyalgia and November Naturopathic 9 Category A Myalgic 29, 2018 Medicine Encephalomyelitis (CCNM) (Chronic Fatigue Syndrome) Canadian October 9, College of 2018 – Integrative Pediatrics Naturopathic 9 Category A January 29, Series Medicine 2019 (CCNM) Integrative Acupuncture Health October Certificate Program – Leadership and 12-15, 26 Category A Advanced Practice Learning 2018 Module 2 Network Canadian October 12, Advanced Naturopathic College of 2018 – Oncology – Supporting Category A – 3 Naturopathic 27 January 25, the Patient with Cancer Pharmacology Medicine 2019 (3-Part Series) (CCNM) Treating Pain Ontario Intelligently: Patient Association of October 17, Perspective, Clinical Category A – 0.5 Naturopathic 1.5 2018 Experiences, and a Pharmacology Doctors Review of the (OAND) Literature 1 | P a g e Approved Continuing Education Courses Functional and October 20, Category A – 12 Personalized Hormone LP3 Network 3.5 2018 Pharmacology Restoration Therapy Nutritional October 20, Advances in Women’s Fundamentals Category A – 0.5 5.5 2018 Health for Health Pharmacology (NFH) Inc. Ontario Palliative Care: A Association of Category A – 0.5 October 24, Naturopathic Approach Naturopathic 1.25 IVIT, 0.25 2018 to Improving Quality of Doctors
    [Show full text]
  • History of Sex Education Table of Contents
    History of Sex Education Table of contents Introduction 5 The social hygiene movement 9 Schools and character-building organizations 13 The influence of WWI 17 Moving beyond disease prevention 19 Family life education 21 The sexual revolution and culture wars 25 Controversies erupt 29 The culture wars 33 AIDS changes the debate 37 The fight between abstinence-only and comprehensive sexuality education 39 The rise of the abstinence-only movement 43 Abstinence-only programs face criticism 49 Evidence-based programs and beyond 51 The fight continues 55 Looking forward: Sex ed as a vehicle for social change 59 2 3 Introduction Sex education in the United States has great potential to educate both individuals and society. It can give us knowledge about our bodies; debunk harmful stereotypes about sex, race, and gender; provide opportunities for us to think critically about our own values and relationships; and empower us to stand up for our rights and the rights of others to pleasure, bodily autonomy, and consent. This was not, however, what sex education was initially designed to do. Too often, over the past 100 years of American history, it has been used to do just the opposite. 4 5 Those who originally pushed the importance of SIECUS believes, however, that sex education— educating the public about sexuality did so out if done properly—has the power to serve as a of a fear that their comfortable, white, middle vehicle for social change. Understanding the class way of living was being threatened by the history of sex education in this country, the loosening of sexual morals.
    [Show full text]
  • ABQ Free Press, June 1, 2016
    VOL III, Issue 11, June 1 – June 14, 2016 Albuquerque’s Award-winning Alternative Newspaper The Cost Of APD’s Drug Stings P AGE 10 An Interview What Our Readers with Think of the Grant-Lee Candidates P AGE 15 Phillips P AGE 27 Monahan: Trump Slimes Susana P AGE 7 Iggy Pop Talks Rehab and Politics PAGE 20 2 • June 1 – June 14, 2016 • ABQ FREE PRESS ABQ FREE PRESS • June 1 – June 14, 2016 • 3 nEwS www.freeabq.com EditoR’S A&E Pick Editor: [email protected] Arts: [email protected] ABQ Free Press Pulp News News: [email protected] On Twitter: @FreeABQ COMPILED BY ABQ FREE PRESS STAFF On Facebook: facebook.com/abqfreepress A&E: Three to See will no longer count against the reporter, Jonathan Lowe, told police Deadly landscape Editor 140-character limit in tweets, he just had to go. An onlooker wit- [Page 21] Forty years after the end of the Dan Vukelich according to The New York Times. nessed the event. Goodyear, Ariz., Vietnam war, unexploded bombs (505) 345-4080. Ext. 800 #film #BloodOrange #IggyPop police said Lowe was arrested on remain a threat — so much so Space junk “suspicion of public defecation.” Associate Editor, News Samantha Anne Carrillo reviews that grade-schoolers are taught The man Lowe was covering was Dennis Domrzalski how to identify them and how to Approximately 23,000 man-made ob- British thriller ‘Blood Orange’ InstructIon & FacIlItatIon traInIng charged with killing his 6-year-old (505) 306-3260 ce avoid being blown up. Among jects are orbiting the Earth, but only 1,300 of them are satellites.
    [Show full text]
  • Community Action Toolkit
    COMMUNITY ACTION TOOLKIT a guide to advancing sex education in your community About SIECUS SIECUS believes sexuality—due to its intrinsic value as well as its importance to individual and collective health—is worthy of our utmost attention, public discourse, thoughtful instruction, and societal respect. For the past 54 years, SIECUS has made strides in ensuring young people’s positive and healthy sexual development through several different strategies thereby promoting and increasing lifelong health and well-being. To continue to gain ground on fulfilling this mission, we stand for: ● a nationwide commitment to comprehensive sexuality education in schools; ● more and better trained teachers delivering this education; ● stronger policies that support both comprehensive sexuality education and sexual and reproductive health, rights, and justice; and ● a public that is better informed about sexual and reproductive health and rights issues. Fulfilling the above objectives, in context and over time, will enable us to realize our vision of a sexually healthy world where individuals: ● Appreciate their own bodies. ● Interact with all genders in respectful and appropriate ways. ● Affirm their own sexual orientation and respect the sexual orientations of others. ● Develop and maintain meaningful relationships. ● Make informed and autonomous choices about family planning options. ● Develop and practice effective critical-thinking and decision-making skills. ● Express their sexuality in ways that are congruent with their values. ● Practice health-promoting behaviors, such as scheduling regular physical exams, using contraception effectively, avoiding contracting or transmitting STIs, and communicating effectively with partners about their needs, wants, and desires. ● Enjoy and express their sexuality throughout the duration of their lifetime.
    [Show full text]
  • Trends, Issues and Challenges in Teaching Values Education
    “Education without values, as useful as it is, seems rather to make man a more clever devil.” – CS Lewis Values are what a person considers to be important in his life and one’s values set the direction for which he/she lives. Values education, in the words of one of our experts in Values Education is “the development of a person committed to building a free, democratic, peaceful, and progressive nation.” (1) self actualization, people imbued with a sense of human dignity; (2) a sense of responsibility for community and environment, self- discipline; (3) productivity, contributory to the economic security and development of the family and nation; (4) a deep sense of nationalism, commitment to the progress of the nation and to global solidarity; and (5) an abiding faith in God and spirituality. (1) be oriented towards the whole learner; (2) consider the unique role of the family in personal development and integration into society and the nation; and (3) recognize and emphasize the role of teachers who themselves must possess a proper sense of values and respect for the person of the student. These are beautiful words, goals and aspirations. They are worth aspiring for. Let us look at them for a moment.,. (1986-1993) A glance at our newspapers today speak a lot of what we are now as a society. This is confirmed by what we hear on radio news as well as what we see and hear on our television sets. Perhaps some of us here in this audience are victims of unsavory experiences caused by so-called lawless elements or even educated people both from public and private schools.
    [Show full text]
  • Learned in Sex Ed
    Western Oregon University Digital Commons@WOU Honors Senior Theses/Projects Student Scholarship Summer 2020 Devising A Show From the Ground Up: Things We (never) Learned in Sex Ed Lindsay R. Spear Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.wou.edu/honors_theses Devising A Show From the Ground Up: Things We (never) Learned in Sex Ed By Lindsay R Spear An Honors Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for Graduation from the Western Oregon University Honors Program Dr. Kent Neely, Thesis Advisor Dr. Gavin Keulks, Honors Program Director September 2020 Acknowledgements To Gavin Keulks, thank you for not giving up on me. A lot of people would have. But thank you for always reaching out and kicking me in the butt when I needed it. You are the reason I was able to finish my thesis. Thank you from the bottom of my heart. To Michael Phillips, thank you. You taught me not only how to devise a show, but you made it a point to teach me how to support myself as I write and tour shows in the future. You showed me the best spots to hang posters, the tedium of applying, and the importance of reaching out to fellow artists, among so much more. I am happy to call you not just my director or professor, but my friend as well. To Phoebe Thomspson, thank you for being my creative partner, and for hearing all my songs and ideas before rehearsals when I was too scared to show it to Michael. You were so patient and taught me so much during our process.
    [Show full text]
  • Values Education in American Public Schools
    VALUES EDUCATION IN AMERICAN PUBLIC SCHOOLS: AN OVERVIEW WITH IMPLICATIONS FOR THE FUTURE by DOUGLAS STEPHENS ESKEW (Under the Direction of Jo Blase) ABSTRACT In the history of the American public school, teachers have consistently played a major role in the transmission of values and that function continues today. Yet there is a great deal of conflict in the arena of values education over the question : Which values are to be taught? Following the traditional Rankean historicist method of historical research, this study features a detailed examination of the history of values education in the United States as well as the philosophy of those involved in selecting the values to be taught. The focus is upon the differing views between those of a more conservative paradigm who consider themselves traditionalists and those with a more liberal paradigm who consider themselves multiculturalists. Included is an overview of current policies and practices and a presentation of values education principles and practices across the nation that have potential to unite Americans of all perspectives. INDEX WORDS: Character Education, Civic Education, Traditionalism, Multiculturalism, Higher Law, Natural Rights, Rule of Law, Democratic Values, Relativism, Absolutes, Race, Sexuality VALUES EDUCATION IN AMERICAN PUBLIC SCHOOLS: AN OVERVIEW WITH IMPLICATIONS FOR THE FUTURE by DOUGLAS STEPHENS ESKEW B.A., Augusta College, 1977 M.Ed. University of Georgia, 1980 A Dissertation Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of the University of Georgia In Partial Fulfillment
    [Show full text]