From Neoliberalism to Neo-Developmentalism? the Political Economy of Post-Crisis Argentina, 2002-2007

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

From Neoliberalism to Neo-Developmentalism? the Political Economy of Post-Crisis Argentina, 2002-2007 1 FROM NEOLIBERALISM TO NEO-DEVELOPMENTALISM? THE POLITICAL ECONOMY OF POST-CRISIS ARGENTINA, 2002-2007 A Dissertation Submitted for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Sheffield Hilal Gezmis Department of Politics Faculty of Social Sciences March 2015 2 Contents ABSTRACT ..................................................................................................................................... 4 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .................................................................................................................. 5 Abbreviations ................................................................................................................................ 6 List of Tables ................................................................................................................................. 9 CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................... 11 1.1. Problematizing the Approaches to the New Left ........................................................................ 12 1.2. Towards a “New” Approach to Neo-developmentalism ............................................................. 16 1.3. Argument and Contributions of the thesis ................................................................................. 19 1.3.1. Financial Regulation............................................................................................................. 23 1.3.2. Trade Policy ........................................................................................................................ 24 1.3.3. Investment Policy ................................................................................................................ 24 1.3.4. Labour Policy ...................................................................................................................... 25 1.4. Research Methods ...................................................................................................................... 26 1.4.1. Case Study Selection ........................................................................................................... 26 1.4.2. Limitations and Difficulties .................................................................................................. 29 1.5. An Outline of the Thesis: ............................................................................................................ 29 CHAPTER 2. CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK: TOWARDS A “NEW” APPROACH TO NEO-DEVELOPMENTALISM .................................................................................................................................................. 33 2.1 From Developmentalism to Neoliberalism in Latin America ....................................................... 34 2.2. Approaches to the New Left ....................................................................................................... 43 2.3. Compatibility of Neoliberalism and Developmentalism ............................................................. 64 2.4. Conclusion .................................................................................................................................. 69 CHAPTER 3. A BACKGROUND TO THE ARGENTINE POLITICAL ECONOMY: FROM ISI TO THE FINANCIAL CRISIS OF 2001-2002 ................................................................................................................... 70 3.1. Beginnings of ISI: The First Phase of ISI under Peronism (1946-1955) ....................................... 70 3.2. Argentina`s Neoliberal Transformation ...................................................................................... 77 3.3. Lessons from the Financial Crisis of 2001/2002 ......................................................................... 85 3.4. Conclusion .................................................................................................................................. 88 CHAPTER 4. FINANCIAL POLICY RESPONSES BETWEEN 2002 AND 2007 ............................................. 90 4.1. Convertibility Plan and Financial Deregulation in Argentina (1989-2001) .................................. 91 4.2. Post-crisis Financial Regulation Policies (2002-2007) ................................................................. 98 4.2.1. Foreign Exchange Intervention .......................................................................................... 100 4.2.2. Acting as a Lender of Last Resort ....................................................................................... 104 4.2.3. Debt Management ............................................................................................................ 107 4.2.4. Constraints of Financial Policy ........................................................................................... 109 3 4.3. Conclusion ................................................................................................................................ 114 CHAPTER 5. TRADE POLICY RESPONSES BETWEEN 2002 AND 2007 ................................................. 116 5.1. Trade Policy and Neoliberal Transformation in Argentina (1989-2001) ................................... 116 5.2. Trade Policy Responses (2002-2007) ........................................................................................ 127 5.2.1. Trade Barriers .................................................................................................................... 128 5.2.2. Argentina-MERCOSUR Trade Relations ............................................................................. 140 5.2.3. Multilateral and Preferential Negotiations ........................................................................ 148 5.2.4. Argentina-China Trade Relations: ...................................................................................... 151 5.3. Conclusion ................................................................................................................................ 153 CHAPTER 6. INVESTMENT POLICY RESPONSES BETWEEN 2002 AND 2007 ....................................... 156 6.1. Investment Policy and Neoliberalism in Argentina (1989-2001) .............................................. 156 6. 2. Investment Policy Responses (2002-2007) .............................................................................. 162 6.2.1. Regulation in Strategic Industries ...................................................................................... 163 6.2.2. Industrial Incentives and Capital controls .......................................................................... 169 6.3. Conclusion ................................................................................................................................ 175 CHAPTER 7. LABOUR POLICY RESPONSES BETWEEN 2002 AND 2007 .............................................. 177 7.1. Neoliberalism and Labour policy in Argentina (1989-2001) ..................................................... 177 7.2. Labour Policy Responses (2002-2007) ................................................................................. 183 7.2. 1. Employment Creation ....................................................................................................... 184 7.2.3. Re-regulation of Labour Markets ....................................................................................... 190 7.2.4. Constraints of Labour Policies ........................................................................................... 194 7.3. Conclusion ................................................................................................................................ 202 CHAPTER 8. CONCLUSION .......................................................................................................... 204 8.1. Problematizing the approaches to the New Left: Towards a “New” approach to Neo- developmentalism ........................................................................................................................... 205 8.2. Understanding the Financial Crisis of 2001-2002 ..................................................................... 211 8.3. From Neoliberalism to Neo-developmentalism in Argentina (2002-2007) .............................. 214 8.4. Moving the Debate Forward .................................................................................................... 224 8.5. Conclusions............................................................................................................................... 225 BIBLIOGRAPHY .......................................................................................................................... 227 Newspaper clippings ....................................................................................................................... 256 Websites .......................................................................................................................................... 264 Appendix List of Interviewees ..................................................................................................... 266 4 ABSTRACT In this thesis, I explore the policy responses to the financial crisis of 2001/2002 in Argentina and its implications for the Argentine political economy between 2002 and 2007. Precisely, I examine the extent and nature of the shift from neoliberalism to neo- developmentalism in Argentina between 2002 and 2007. Scholars who observed the rise of the New Left governments in Latin America argued
Recommended publications
  • Latin America Economic Outlook
    Latin America Economic Outlook August 2014 Contents The world and the region: 1 The outlook for the region remains positive Country outlooks: Argentina 2 Challenging scenario in the short-term Brazil 3 Weak economic activity Chile 4 Low growth Colombia 5 On the right track Ecuador 6 Favorable projections Mexico 7 Recovering economy Peru 8 Unrealized potential for growth Venezuela 9 Structural imbalances unaddressed 10 Macroeconomic variables The world and the region The outlook for the region remains positive 1 2 3 Nearly six years removed from the worst Although global markets generally, and of the subprime crisis, the U.S. economy emerging markets in particular, have thus 4 appears to be slowly returning to normal. far been dependent on the steps that the The economy is growing, employment Fed has taken, recent international fears 5 is up (the unemployment rate is falling), concerning adjustments to its monetary people are spending more, and companies policy are perhaps overblown. A change to 6 are doing their part in terms of investing in the policy would be a natural consequence physical and human capital. of an economy that, after the disruptions 7 of 2008, is resuming development under 8 Even if there is a long road ahead before a more normal conditions. And globally, a return to pre-crisis levels, the ground gained return to relative normalcy by the world’s 9 is plainly evident. And so it is no surprise largest economy can never be bad news. that the Federal Reserve is continuing with On the contrary, both the developed world 10 its plan to cut back on special monetary and emerging economies should benefit stimulus.
    [Show full text]
  • Interventionism in the Era of Globalization
    Pratical theory 9 Stanisław Kowalczyk, Roman Sobiecki Interventionism in the era of globalization Interventionism is a system of influ- entities, weakening of their competitive- ence of a nation state or an integration ness, which consequently can translate group on the economy as a whole or on into deterioration of the macroeconomic separate sectors, whose role is to allevi- situation in the long run. A manifesta- ate contradictions between the micro- tion of unreliability of interventionism and macroeconomic objectives. can also be the temptation to overuse the tools of interventionism to achieve strictly The tools used for this purpose are of political, party or electoral goals. There- economic, legal and administrative na- fore, the trick is to find the right relations ture (Sobiecki, 2015). More specifically between interventionism and the market – economic and legal, as well as admin- activity. istrative and legal, and sometimes persua- The beginnings of interventionism sive. Thus, interventionism is not an oc- date back to ancient times, when Athens casional and accidental influence of a state was fully supplied with the goods of for- through its institutions, but an ordered eign origin, which was the reason for the system subordinated to the achievement collapse of the domestic production. This of specified objectives. situation forced the introduction of duties Interventionism is necessary to achieve on imported goods to protect its own pro- reasonableness on a macroeconomic scale duction. It can, therefore, be concluded and to alleviate contradictions with the that it was a little taste of interventionism, approach to the reasonableness from the so it is as old as the institution of the state.
    [Show full text]
  • Which Developmentalism
    1 Which developmentalism? A Keynesian-Institutionalist proposal Fernando Ferrari Filho Professor of Economics at Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul and Researcher at National Council for Scientific and Technological Development, Brazil. [email protected] Pedro Cezar Dutra Fonseca Professor of Economics at Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul and Researcher at National Council for Scientific and Technological Development, Brazil. [email protected] Abstract: Academic discussion of Brazil’s economic growth is currently framed in terms of export-led growth and wage-led growth, identified, respectively, with the new- developmentalism and the social-developmentalism approaches. This article presents a Keynesian-Institutionalist proposal to the Brazilian economy based on a wage-led regime without neglecting the long run balance of payment on current account requirement to ensure macroeconomic stability in the Brazilian economy. Keywords: New-developmentalism, social-developmentalism, Keynesian- Institutionalist, wage-led, profit-led and export-led growths. JEL Codes: B, B5. 1 Introduction While priority was given to monetary stability during the 1980s and 1990s, economic growth has gradually been finding its way back to both theoretical economic debate and economic policy discussions in Brazil since the 2000s. This has been due partly, on the one hand, to the election of various governments critical of neoliberalism in Latin America and, on the other hand, to the 2007-2008 financial crisis, which restored interventionism to the agenda,
    [Show full text]
  • Developmentalism, Modernity, and Dependency Theory in Latin America
    Developmentalism, Modernity, and Dependency Theory in Latin America Ramón Grosfoguel The Latin American dependentistas produced a knowledge that criticized the Eurocentric assumptions of the cepalistas,includingtheorthodoxMarxistandtheNorthAmericanmodern- ization theories. The dependentista school critique of stagism and develop- mentalism was an important intervention that transformed the imaginary of intellectual debates in many parts of the world. However, I will argue that many dependentistas were still caught in the developmentalism, and in some cases even the stagism, that they were trying to overcome. Moreover, although the dependentistas’ critique of stagism was important in denying the “denial of coevalness” that Johannes Fabian (1983) describes as central to Eurocentric constructions of “otherness,” some dependentistas replaced it with new forms of denial of coevalness. The first part of this article dis- cusses developmentalist ideology and what I call “feudalmania” as part of the longue durée of modernity in Latin America. The second part discusses the dependentistas’ developmentalism. The third part is a critical discussion of Fernando Henrique Cardoso’s version of dependency theory. Finally, the fourth part discusses the dependentistas’ concept of culture. Developmentalist Ideology and Feudalmania as Part of the Ideology of Modernity in Latin America There is a tendency to present the post-1945 development debates in Latin America as unprecedented. In order to distinguish continuity from dis- continuity, we must place the 1945–90 development debates in the context of the longue durée of Latin American history. The 1945–90 development Nepantla: Views from South 1:2 Copyright 2000 by Duke University Press 347 348 Nepantla debates in Latin America, although seemingly radical, in fact form part of the longue durée of the geoculture of modernity that has dominated the modern world-system since the French Revolution in the late eighteenth century.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 2: What Went Wrong in Argentina
    2 What Went Wrong in Argentina Several factors contributed to the remarkable deterioration of Argentina from an apparent paragon of economic reform and stabilization in 1997–98 to the tragedy now unfolding in that economy. If Argentina had a more flexible economic system, especially in its labor markets, its econ- omy would have been more able to adapt to the rigors of the Con- vertibility Plan; unemployment would have been lower; growth would have been stronger; fiscal deficits would have been smaller; and interest rates would have been lower because creditors would have had more confidence in the capacity of the Argentine government to service its obligations. Moreover, if the US dollar had not been so strong in recent years, Argentina would have had a more competitive exchange rate vis-à-vis its important European trading partners, contributing both to somewhat better growth and a better balance of payments. If Argentina had not suf- fered the external shock from the collapse of Brazil’s crawling-peg ex- change rate policy, one of the important causes of Argentina’s recession during the period 1999–2001 would have been removed; and this would have had favorable consequences in several important dimensions. Or if Argentina had decided in 1997 or 1998 that the Convertibility Plan had fulfilled its purpose and the time had come to shift to a more flexible regime for exchange rate and monetary policy, it might have been better able to manage the difficulties of 1999–2001. In sum, if things had broken more in Argentina’s favor, this surely would have helped to preserve the success and avoid the tragedy of Argentina’s stabilization efforts.
    [Show full text]
  • Elusive Development by Marshall Wolfe
    Elusive Development by Marshall Wolfe . »JLL»/ United Nations United Nations Research Institute Economic Commission for for Social Development Latin America Printed by S'*! Hungary, 1981 Statistical Publishing House Contents Acknowledgments ........................................... P reface ............................................................... in CHAPTER ONE: Why Elusive Development? 1 CHAPTER TWO: The Quest for a Unified Approach 11 Background of the unified approach project of UNRISD and ECLA — Methodology and institutional constraints - Differing approaches that emerged and their underlying supposition — The changing international market for propositions on development during and since the unified approach project - The place of the unified approach project in the inter­ national rethinking of development - Lessons for the future and needs for international research. CHAPTER THREE: Development Images, Agents and Choices............................. 55 Images of development - Concepts, values and criteria for styles of develop­ ment — A digression on the practical - Choices aiming at an acceptable and viable style of development. CHAPTER FOUR: Approaches to Development: Who is Approaching what? 75 Development under question: The feasibility of national choice between alternative styles — The setting within which developmental choices present themselves — Policy approaches to the challenge of “unified”, “original”, or “human-oriented” styles of development. CHAPTER FIVE: Social and Political Structures and Development Policy
    [Show full text]
  • Underestimating Savings and Investment in an Open Economy
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Research Papers in Economics WP-2007-015 Data and Definitions: Underestimating Savings and Investment in an Open Economy Ashima Goyal Indira Gandhi Institute of Development Research, Mumbai October 2007 Data and Definitions: Underestimating Savings and Investment in an Open Economy1 Ashima Goyal Indira Gandhi Institute of Development Research (IGIDR) General Arun Kumar Vaidya Marg Goregaon (E), Mumbai- 400065, INDIA Email: [email protected] Abstract This note clarifies definitions and derives from first principles the relationship between investment, domestic and foreign savings in order to show that there is underestimation of investment and foreign savings given conceptual macroeconomic definitions and Indian practice. Indian national accounts report and use gross domestic savings but the measure of capital inflows used with it is the one appropriate for gross national savings. The degree of underestimation is shown using recent data and implications drawn from the errors. Key words: gross domestic and national savings, capital formation, national accounts JEL Code(s): E21, E22, F36, O47 1 The author thanks Atul Sarma and Raghbendra Jha for comments and T.S.Ananthi for help with the tables. 2 Data and definitions: Underestimating Savings and Investment in an Open Economy Ashima Goyal The Indian statistical and measurement system set up was advanced for its time and place. Experts nurtured it carefully. But innovation was required to cut through complexities due to underdevelopment and to lack of data for the large unorganized sectors. Approximations are particularly marked in the estimation of savings and investment and where the open economy impinges on the two.
    [Show full text]
  • The Political Economy of Argentina's Abandonment
    Going through the labyrinth: the political economy of Argentina’s abandonment of the gold standard (1929-1933) Pablo Gerchunoff and José Luis Machinea ABSTRACT This article is the short but crucial history of four years of transition in a monetary and exchange-rate regime that culminated in 1933 with the final abandonment of the gold standard in Argentina. That process involved decisions made at critical junctures at which the government authorities had little time to deliberate and against which they had no analytical arsenal, no technical certainties and few political convictions. The objective of this study is to analyse those “decisions” at seven milestone moments, from the external shock of 1929 to the submission to Congress of a bill for the creation of the central bank and a currency control regime characterized by multiple exchange rates. The new regime that this reordering of the Argentine economy implied would remain in place, in one form or another, for at least a quarter of a century. KEYWORDS Monetary policy, gold standard, economic history, Argentina JEL CLASSIFICATION E42, F4, N1 AUTHORS Pablo Gerchunoff is a professor at the Department of History, Torcuato Di Tella University, Buenos Aires, Argentina. [email protected] José Luis Machinea is a professor at the Department of Economics, Torcuato Di Tella University, Buenos Aires, Argentina. [email protected] 104 CEPAL REVIEW 117 • DECEMBER 2015 I Introduction This is not a comprehensive history of the 1930s —of and, if they are, they might well be convinced that the economic policy regarding State functions and the entrance is the exit: in other words, that the way out is production apparatus— or of the resulting structural to return to the gold standard.
    [Show full text]
  • Mill's "Very Simple Principle": Liberty, Utilitarianism And
    MILL'S "VERY SIMPLE PRINCIPLE": LIBERTY, UTILITARIANISM AND SOCIALISM MICHAEL GRENFELL submitted for degree of Ph.D. London School of Economics and Political Science UMI Number: U048607 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. Dissertation Publishing UMI U048607 Published by ProQuest LLC 2014. Copyright in the Dissertation held by the Author. Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 I H^S £ S F 6SI6 ABSTRACT OF THESIS MILL'S "VERY SIMPLE PRINCIPLE'*: LIBERTY. UTILITARIANISM AND SOCIALISM 1 The thesis aims to examine the political consequences of applying J.S. Mill's "very simple principle" of liberty in practice: whether the result would be free-market liberalism or socialism, and to what extent a society governed in accordance with the principle would be free. 2 Contrary to Mill's claims for the principle, it fails to provide a clear or coherent answer to this "practical question". This is largely because of three essential ambiguities in Mill's formulation of the principle, examined in turn in the three chapters of the thesis. 3 First, Mill is ambivalent about whether liberty is to be promoted for its intrinsic value, or because it is instrumental to the achievement of other objectives, principally the utilitarian objective of "general welfare".
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Political Shocks and Asset Prices Daniel Carnahan
    Political Shocks and Asset Prices Daniel Carnahan (Business Insider) Sebastian Saiegh (University of California San Diego) Abstract We estimate how asset prices respond to a range of political shocks, including changes in a country’s economic stewardship, national elections, coup d'états, wars, and terrorist attacks. Multiple instances of these events took place in Argentina between 1967 and 2020. Using an event study approach and over 13,000 daily prices from the Buenos Aires exchange, we find that stock-market volatility increases in the days immediately following unexpected, major policy- shifting events. These results hold irrespective of whether market returns are measured in nominal terms, in local consumption units, or in US dollars. Our analysis allows us to establish comparisons across different types of political shocks while avoiding the identification problems of multi-country event studies. The most significant increase in post-event risk is associated with irregular government turnovers (coup d'états, presidential death, resignations); approximately 100 percent on average, when returns are expressed in US dollars. Volatility also increases in the days immediately following a defeat in an international war, national elections and changes in the country’s economic stewardship. No changes in stock market volatility occur, however, after terrorist attacks or when the date of a new administration’s inauguration is publicly known and determined sufficiently far in advance. Word Count: 10,929 1 Introduction Investors concerned about non-commercial risks need to consider their exposure to political events that may affect the value of their assets. These political risks can originate in specific government actions, such as laws or regulations.
    [Show full text]
  • The Need for State in the Economy- Epistemological Approach
    Annals of the University of Petroşani, Economics, 10(3), 2010, 291-300 291 THE NEED FOR STATE IN THE ECONOMY- EPISTEMOLOGICAL APPROACH ANCA-ŞTEFANIA SAVA * ABSTRACT: The aim of this paper is to discuss the need for state in the economy, in an epistemological viewpoint. It presents in a critical manner the ideas on the state of the mercantilism and physiocracy representatives, of the classical and Keynesian economists and of the so-called current „the new liberal orthodoxy”. It is noticed that the need for a minimal state, as a condition of proper functioning of the society, has been justified even by those who have criticized it (classical liberals), being recognized that a society can not be conceived anarchic and utopian. If during ’29-’33s, the philosophy of laisser-faire was replaced by the Keynesian doctrine, and ’70s have placed the welfare state in a crisis of legitimacy, starting from 2008 we can talk of a resurgence of the Keynesian paradigm, according to which government intervention is seen as a way to stimulate the economic recovery. KEY WORDS: Welfare-state; the minimal state; Keynesianism; macroeconomic policy; School of economic thought; classicism; monetarism JEL CLASSIFICATION: I38, H10, E12, E61, B10, B12, B52, E61 1. THE NEED FOR STATE INTERVENTION IN THE ECONOMY FROM THE MERCANTILISTS AND PHYSIOCRATS’ PERSPECTIVE Mercantilists were the first which made reference to the role of the state in the economy, paving the way for the assertion of physiocracy and classical liberalism doctrine. This particular school of thought specific for the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries has dominated the economic life in the theoretical and practical matter, until the mid-XVIII century.
    [Show full text]
  • Land Tenancy, Soybean, Actors and Transformations in the Pampas: a District Balance Hernán A
    Land tenancy, soybean, actors and transformations in the pampas: A district balance Hernán A. Urcola, Xavier Arnauld de Sartre, Iran Veiga, Julio Elverdín, Christophe Albaladejo To cite this version: Hernán A. Urcola, Xavier Arnauld de Sartre, Iran Veiga, Julio Elverdín, Christophe Albaladejo. Land tenancy, soybean, actors and transformations in the pampas: A district balance. Journal of Rural Studies, Elsevier, 2015, 39, pp.32-40. 10.1016/j.jrurstud.2015.03.001. halshs-01252579 HAL Id: halshs-01252579 https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-01252579 Submitted on 8 Jan 2016 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. Land tenancy, soybean, actors and transformations in the pampas: A district balance1 a b c a Hernán A. URCOLA , Xavier ARNAULD DE SARTRE , Iran VEIGA , Julio ELVERDIN , Christophe Albaladejod a. Instituto Nacional de Tecnología Agropecuaria (INTA), Laboratoire AGRITERRIS, Economía y Sociología Rural INTA, Ruta 226, Km 73,5 (7620) Balcarce, Buenos Aires, Argentina. Te: +54-2266-439105, int 221 Fax: +54-2266-439101 Email: [email protected] [email protected] b. UMR Société environnement territoire Centre national de la recherche scientifique / Université de Pau et des Pays de l’Adour Domaine universitaire BP 576 64012 Pau France Tel: (33) 559407262 Fax: (33) 559407255 Email: [email protected] c.
    [Show full text]