Ngaruroro, Tutaekuri, Karamu River and Ahuriri Estuary Catchments State and Trends of River Water Quality and Ecology
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
Ngaruroro, Tutaekuri, Karamu River and Ahuriri Estuary Catchments State and Trends of River Water Quality and Ecology July 2016 HBRC Report No. RM16-08 4787 Environmental Science - Water Quality and Ecology Ngaruroro, Tutaekuri, Karamu River and Ahuriri Estuary Catchments State and Trends of River Water Quality and Ecology July 2016 HBRC Report No. RM 16-08. Plan Number 4787. Prepared By: Dr Sandy Haidekker Dr Adam Uytendaal Dr Andy Hicks Oliver Wade Heli Wade Vicki Lyon Anna Madarasz-Smith Reviewed By: Stephen Swabey – Manager – Environmental Science Approved By: Iain Maxwell – Group Manager – Resource Management Signed: . Contents Executive summary ....................................................................................................................... 9 1 Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 13 1.1 TANK Catchment Descriptions and Land Use Overview ................................................... 13 1.2 Description of the Ngaruroro River Catchment ................................................................ 15 1.3 Description of the Tutaekuri River Catchment ................................................................. 19 1.4 Description of the Karamu Stream Catchment ................................................................. 24 1.5 Description of the Ahuriri Catchment ............................................................................... 30 1.6 Recreational usage and water quality in the TANK catchments ....................................... 32 1.7 SOE Water Quality Data and Analysis ............................................................................... 32 2 Water Quality in the Ngaruroro and Tutaekuri River Catchments: Long-term SOE data ........ 37 2.1 Nutrients ........................................................................................................................... 37 2.2 Nitrate-nitrogen toxicity ................................................................................................... 49 2.3 Water Clarity – Black disc and turbidity ............................................................................ 52 2.4 Bacteriological water quality – E. coli ............................................................................... 58 2.5 Dissolved oxygen ............................................................................................................... 61 2.6 Temperature ..................................................................................................................... 70 2.7 Biological indicators .......................................................................................................... 73 2.8 Assessment against the NOF NPS-FM (2014) attribute bands ......................................... 81 2.9 Compliance with HBRC Regional Resource Management Plan 2006 surface water quality Environmental Guidelines ................................................................................................. 84 2.10 Land use intensification in the upper Tutaekuri catchment – potential impacts on the Mangatutu Stream and the Mangaone River ................................................................... 87 2.11 Summary and conclusion for the Ngaruroro and Tutaekuri River catchments ................ 88 3 Water Quality of the Karamu Stream and Ahuriri Estuary Catchments: Long-term SOE data 89 3.1 Nutrients ........................................................................................................................... 89 3.2 Toxicity: nitrate-nitrogen and ammoniacal-nitrogen ..................................................... 100 3.3 Water Clarity – Black disc and turbidity .......................................................................... 103 3.4 Bacteriological water quality – E. coli ............................................................................. 107 3.5 Dissolved oxygen ............................................................................................................. 110 3.6 Temperature ................................................................................................................... 116 3.7 Biological indicators ........................................................................................................ 118 3.8 Karamu targeted study – life-supporting capacity ......................................................... 124 Ngaruroro, Tutaekuri, Karamu River and Ahuriri Estuary Catchments 3 3.9 Stormwater ..................................................................................................................... 124 3.10 Assessment against the NOF NPS-FM (2014) attribute bands ....................................... 135 3.11 Compliance with HBRC Regional Resource Management Plan (2006) surface water quality Environmental Guidelines ................................................................................... 138 4 Recreational Water Quality in the TANK catchments ........................................................ 141 4.1 ANZECC guidelines .......................................................................................................... 142 4.2 Suitability for Recreation Grade...................................................................................... 143 4.3 Recreational Usage ......................................................................................................... 144 4.4 Faecal bacterial contamination ....................................................................................... 144 4.5 Shellfish Gathering .......................................................................................................... 146 References ................................................................................................................................ 147 Appendix A Summary statistics by flow in the Ngaruroro and Tutaekuri catchments ............. 152 Appendix B Summary statistics by flow in the Karamu and Ahuriri catchments ..................... 176 Appendix C Trend analysis results for water quality variables ............................................... 188 Appendix D Regional ranking tables for select water quality variables ................................... 198 Appendix E NPS-FW (2014) NOF attribute tables .................................................................. 209 Appendix F Summary of NOF bands for E.coli, Nitrate-nitrogen and Ammonia. ..................... 214 Appendix G MfE benthic cyanobacteria alert-level framework .............................................. 219 Tables Table 1-1: Catchment characteristics of the major Ngaruroro River catchment zones. 18 Table 1-2: Summary of relevant water quality guidelines for the TANK catchments. 35 Table 1-3: HBRC Regional Resource Management Plan (2006) water quality limits - “Environmental Guidelines – Surface Water Quality”. 36 Table 2-1: Trend analysis results for DIN and DRP for Ngaruroro and Tutaekuri catchment SOE monitoring sites 43 Table 2-2: Trend analysis results for DIN and DRP for SOE monitoring sites of the Ngaruroro and Tutaekuri catchments. 49 Table 2-3: Trend analysis results for Nitrate-nitrogen (NO3-N) for SOE monitoring sites of the Ngaruroro and Tutaekuri catchments. 52 Table 2-4: Trend analysis results for black disc clarity and turbidity for SOE monitoring sites of the Ngaruroro and Tutaekuri River. 58 Table 2-5: Trend analysis results for E. coli for SOE monitoring sites of the Ngaruroro and Tutaekuri catchments. 61 Table 2-6: Proposed temperature thresholds for discussion for the National Objectives Framework . 72 4 Ngaruroro, Tutaekuri, Karamu River and Ahuriri Estuary Catchments Table 2-7: Cox-Rutherford Index (CRI) at 6 sites in the Ngaruroro and Tutaekuri catchments. 72 Table 2-8: MCI quality classes as defined by Stark and Maxted (2007). 78 Table 2-9: NPS-FW (2014) NOF band summary for freshwater river attributes for Tutaekuri and Ngaruroro catchment monitoring sites for the period 2009 to 2013. 83 Table 2-10: Comparison of average measured dissolved oxygen, black disc, dissolved reactive phosphorus and ammoniacal-nitrogen levels with HBRC RRMP 2006 Environmental Guideline levels. 85 Table 2-11: Comparison of measured DO, BD clarity and DRP values with HBRC RRMP 2006 Environmental Guideline levels. 86 Table 3-1: Trend analysis results for DIN and DRP for SOE monitoring sites of the Karamu Stream and Ahuriri Estuary catchment. 94 Table 3-2: Trend analysis results for DIN and DRP for SOE monitoring sites of the Karamu Stream and Ahuriri Estuary catchment. 99 Table 3-3: Trend analysis results for nitrate-nitrogen (NO3-N) for SOE monitoring sites of the Karamu Stream and Ahuriri Estuary. 103 Table 3-4: Trend analysis for black disc clarity and turbidity in the Karamu Stream and Ahuriri Estuary (see Appendix E for full results). 107 Table 3-5: Trend analysis results for E. coli for SOE monitoring sites in the Karamu Stream and Ahuriri Estuary (full results in Appendix E). 110 Table 3-6: Results from 24-hour continuous DO measurements during a warm summer period.114 Table 3-7: Proposed temperature thresholds for discussion for the National Objectives Framework. 117 Table 3-8: Cox-Rutherford Index (CRI) at 4 sites in the Karamu catchment. 117 Table 3-9: MCI and MCI-sb quality classes as defined by Stark and Maxted (2007). 121 Table 3-10: Sources of stormwater derived contaminants that may affect values associated with the Karamu and Ahuriri receiving environments. 126 Table 3-11: