Brieing Paper 01/2014

Deep Sea Mining: Environmental, Legal and Technical Challenges for Developing Countries Sensitization Seminar 7, Mexico, 2013

Sensizaon seminars are organized by the Internaonal Seabed Authority (ISA) in partnership with the hosng country and experts from various scienfic and legal instuons associated with the 1982 UN Convenon on the Law of the Sea (the Convenon). In November 10‐11, 2013, a sensizaon seminar entled “Deep Sea Mining Opportunies for Mexico on Internaonal Waters”, was carried out in Mexico City and organized by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the ISA. This was the seventh in a series of seminars convened by the Authority, and the second to be held in Lan America. Previous seminars were held in Indonesia, Brazil, Nigeria, Spain, Jamaica and three in New York in 2012, 2013 and 2014.

In his opening address, the Secretary of the Mexican Foreign Affairs Ministry, Dr. José Meade, stated that sustainable deep sea mining acvity should include clear legal framework, sustainable technology and the parcipaon of the private and public sector under strong governance. Dr. Meade added that the exploitaon of such resources must be done with respect for the environment in a raonal and sustainable manner. Dr. Idelfonso Guajardo Villareal, Secretary‐General of the Ministry of Economy of Mexico, in his statement, declared that from 2014‐ 2050 the world’s demand for minerals will be the highest yet observed. He menoned that the Clarion‐ Clipperton Zone (CCZ), which extends from Mexico to Hawaii, could account for more than 27 million metric tons of mineral resources, such as, nickel (Ni), cobalt (Co), manganese (Mn) and copper (Cu). Figure 1: (Top L‐R): Mr. J. Rebolledo, Mining Consorum The Secretary‐General of ISA, Mr. Nii A. Odunton Group of Mexico; Dr. José Narro Robles, President of (Figure 1), also addressed the seminar corroborang Universidad Autonoma de Mexico; Mr. Nii. A. Odunton, the fact that such reserves exist, but that they should Secretary‐General, ISA; Dr. José A. Meade Kuribreña, be exploited under the rules and regulaons of the Secretary of the Mexican Foreign Affairs Ministry; and Dr. Ildefonso Guajardo Villarreal, Secretary of Economy of ISA to ensure that undeveloped countries would have Mexico. (Boom) Seminar Parcipants. fair parcipaon of these natural resources that are the common heritage of mankind. In the same line of thought, Dr. José Narro Robles, President of REGULATORY REGIME FOR DEEP SEA Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México (UNAM), MINING IN THE AREA echoed the statement made by Mr. Meade, by offering its academic plaorm (scienfic and The legal and administrave framework under which technological capabilies of Mexico) to the Mexican the ISA relates to member States and contractors was authories and the private sector to work towards a presented by the Deputy to the Secretary General, Mr. sound programme of exploraon and exploitaon of Michael Lodge. deep sea habitats. Page 2 for explora bodies: regulatory massive scope expected. the number member Law been the The Mulsow. the ecological Environmental deposits explained implementa Con about with Head valuable limits a polymetallic these role States men for exploita the the Mr. assessments. the structure #seas) www.gc.noaa.gov/gcil_mari and In The RESOURCES: DEEP represents blue Figure

his er

the extended

Area CCZ historical parallel ISA con

Galo UN environmental

the

of of

represents coastal

nental

all

received of

oned presenta

of ins

of 200.4

3: of

(Figure

CLCS the

Law

was

ISA,

Division

the Commission (Figure

O

SEA of polymetallic

con

The on nental environmental the and States. for

Carrera, America. on

He and

ffi the tu

The applica

func

frameworks

Sea new

that

advances of

and ce

applica presented

Jamaica;

Shelf

in

and cobalt millions areas Area

nodules, UNCLOS

explained

cobalt limits on

evolu

nental ons.

func

di

3). the NATURAL

total and

of the rela (DOALOS)

Monitoring,

2) shelf

applica ff

on, a ons

prospec for of in

Resources is erent This (CLCS)

total of

ons EEZ and Sea

around MINERALS

Mr. ‐

that the the

shaded

of ‐ aspect enriched

ons he area Ocean

on rich as

on CLCS, shelf ons

km on

for sulphides. Interna

and in massive to and con

area

(ITLOS),

the

by

Luigi

explained well

extended

acquisi of to the

roles exist

of

a

of

2

the technologies

data the ons in crusts. member for ,

of

considerable

presented

ng

67 the

are the

the (h its

ISA

the in

described ISA licences

of

A

the nental

will

importance

high

Dr. as CLCS.

Limits

Santosuosso

the and ff

were dark for

for

submissions crusts of ins

the

to me.html

light p:// airs

Authority’s

granted

contracts onal

world. as

sulphide biodiversity

Germany; United

decrease Sandor

on each

To understand

extended seas

well work limits tu blue.

the

States and

shelf

brown

of of

Tribunal date, given and

the

onal

of the

the is for

as

He

Light to the

of

of

of had

at

in

could are Figure 2014).

four

s

2: There ll

applica Nineteen

apply

are

for.

few ons

contracts

reserved pending

have

areas approval

been

at

the

issued and

CCZ

three

across

that

new

developing

three

applica

oceans.

ons countries

There (ISA

A B C A: Polymetallic Nodules (2000); B: Massive Sulphides (2010) C: Cobalt‐Rich Crusts (2012) Page

3 Both acvies are important crusts not only provided Ni, Cu, Co, SUPPLY AND DEMAND and are cornerstones for Mn and iron (Fe) but also many rare devising environmental impact earth minerals, such as tellurium (Te) While land‐based mining is driven by assessment (EIA) of future which is important in photovoltaic cell demand and scarcity of the resources, exploitaon acvies in the producon. Dr. Hein stated that deep sea mining is driven by supply Area for polymetallic nodules, “finding enough Te is the largest and demand. Caitlyn Antrim’s enriched cobalt crust and barrier to mul‐terawa use of presentaon provided an extensive massive polymetallic cadmium (Cd)‐Te electricity analysis of the supply and demand of sulphides. generaon. It is widely regarded as the major minerals known to exist in the deep sea habitat. She pointed out Deep sea mining involves the the lowest cost photovoltaic that four major factors influenced prospecng and exploraon of technology with the greatest exploitaon of minerals in the Area: deep sea habitat to classify the potenal.” Dr. Hein concluded that quality, technology, regulatory regime resources in terms of there were several challenges that and commodity markets. She stated feasibility (cost‐producon). needed to be met, such as accurate that crical mineral security (Table 1) Dr. Jim Hein, of United States ageing methods for crusts, definion was a very relevant topic to look in Geological Survey (USGS), of processes that increase the relaon to deep sea mining. In examined cobalt‐rich crust presence of planum (Pt), and rare parcular, with rare earth elements deposits. He said deep sea earth elements in the crust formaon, (REEs) mainly produced by one mining was a complex process and technological innovaon to country (China) and used in many new that required sustained and remotely assess the nature of the technological advances worldwide, strong investments in crust, (e.g. thickness). He noted that future demands were expected to be technology, metallurgic and metallurgic process innovaon would high. environmental assessments. also be desired. The orogeny of cobalt‐rich Table 1. Comparave analysis of some mineral commodies (C. Antrim, 2013)

Fracon of US Consumpon Net Import Major World Ore US imports in 1 million Reliance* Producers Sources tons of deep sea minerals

Nickel 47% Russia, Canada Russia, Canada, 10.1% Australia, Norway

Copper 35% Chile, USA Chile, Canada, Peru 0.6%

Cobalt 75% DR Congo, Zambia China, Norway, 36.9% Russia, Canada

Zinc Metal: 77% China, Peru, Canada, Peru, 19% Ore: 0% Australia Mexico

Manganese 100% Gabon, Australia Gabon, South Africa, 35.8% Australia, China

REE 100% China China 10%

*Import reliance counts secondary recovery (recycling) as domesc producon

ij It was clear that deep sea minerals are world‐class List of Participants resources of minerals crical to worldwide MEXICO development and for the industrialisaon of Dr. José Antonio Meade Kuribreña, Secretario, Secretaría de undeveloped countries with compeon between land‐ Relaciones Exteriores, based nickel laterite and porphyry copper caused by Dr. Ildefonso Guajardo Villarreal, Secretario, Secretaria de declining grade and accessibility of the laer. Economía Dr. José Narro Robles, Rector, Universidad Autónoma Nacional DEEP SEA HABITAT AT HIGH SEAS: A H.E. Ambassador Gerardo Lozano, Permanent Representave of Mexico to the Authority 4

COMMON HERITAGE OF MANKIND Dr. Jose Luis Vallarta, Faculty of Law, UNAM and former Permanent Representave of Mexico to the Authority The Director of the Instuto de Ciencias Marinas y Page Dr. Elva Escobar, ISA LTC Member, General Director, Instute of Limnológicas de UNAM, Dr. Elva Escobar put in Marine Science and Limnology, Universidad Autónoma Nacional perspecve the complexity and fragility, (Figure 4) of de Mexico (UNAM) the deep sea from the ecological aspect as well as from Dr. Katy Juarez, Instute of Biotechnology, UNAM Mr. Enrique Cabrero, Director General, Consejo Nacional de Ciencia the logisc challenges. Dr. Escobar stated in her y Tecnología presentaon, that any kind of deep sea mining Mr. Rebolledo, Mining Consorum Group of Mexico iniave, must be done responsibly and as a joint effort Mr. Max Diener, Legal Consultant of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs among sciensts, miners and the public governance of of Mexico member States such as Mexico. She pointed out that Mr. Hector Bausta, General Director of Port Lazaro Cardenas, Ministry of Transport and Communicaon the deep sea provided both non‐living natural ARGENTINA resources and living resources. Dr. Katy Juarez of Ms. Frida Armas, Coordinator, Naonal Commission on the Outer Limits of the Connental Shelf, Bueno Aires CANADA Mr. Galo Carrera, UN Commission on the Limits of the Connental Shelf, Associate Professor to the Marine Affairs Program, Dalhousie University UNITED STATES Dr. James Hein, U.S. Geological Survey Ms. Caitlyn Antrim, Execuve Director, Rule of Law Commiee for the Oceans Environmental Security Mr. Luigi Santosuosso, United Naons, Office of Legal Affairs, Division for Ocean Affairs and the Law of the Sea, New York ISA Mr. Nii A. Odunton, Secretary‐General Mr. M. Lodge, Deputy to the Secretary‐General Dr. Sandor Mulsow, Head, OREM

Figure 4: Hydrothermal vent from the Pacific Rise form a Acknowledgements natural reserved Area. (Dr. E. Escobar, ICML‐UNAM) This workshop would have not been possible without UNAM also pointed out that one of the emerging areas the commitment of the Government of Mexico. The from deep sea habitats was bioprospecng. She said host country and their organizers, in parcular Lic that there were several iniaves to prospect the Asencio Herrera and his team provided all the oceans for genomic noveles and named two projects ‐ necessary logiscs to make this sensizaon seminar a the Sorcerer II and the Tara Oceans cruises that were success. The Authority also thanks Caitlyn Antrim, systemacally sampling for bacteria and sequencing on James Hein, Elva Escobar, Katy Juarez, Galo Carrera and a world wide scale from the ocean. Luigi Santosuosso for their contribuon.

The Internaonal Seabed Authority is an autonomous internaonal organizaon established under the 1982 United Naons Convenon on the Law of the Sea and the 1994 Agreement relang to the Implementaon of Part XI of the United Naons Convenon on the Law of the Sea. The Authority is the organizaon through which States Pares to the Convenon shall, in accordance with the regime for the seabed and ocean floor and subsoil thereof beyond the limits of naonal jurisdicon (the Area) established in Part XI and the Agreement, organize and control acvies in the Area, parcularly with a view to administering the resources of the Area.

Internaonal Seabed Authority, 14‐20 Port Royal Street Kingston, Jamaica Tel: +1 876 922‐9105 | Fax: +1 876 922‐0195 Website: www.isa.org.jm