Assessing the Role of Social Capital in the Community Development

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Assessing the Role of Social Capital in the Community Development ASSESSING THE ROLE OF SOCIAL CAPITAL IN THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FIELD: A MULTI-LEVEL ANALYSIS by HYOUNG YONG KIM (Under the Direction of Kevin L. DeWeaver) ABSTRACT A multi-level and dimensional approach to social capital is applied for this study. This approach is particularly suitable for addressing the conceptual issues of social capital because it is a differentiated phenomenon that varies in its levels and components. The present study is thus the first empirical test of the three competing models of social capital that can be applied to the field of community development. In a multi-level framework, 1) the effect of individual- level social capital (bonding, bridging, and linking) on community development action is tested (network dynamic model), 2) it is examined whether neighborhood-level social cohesion has an independent effect on residents’ community development action (collective efficacy model), and 3) cross-level interaction tests the hypothesis that neighborhood-level social cohesion accounts for the way in which individual-level social capital are related to community development action (synergy model). In addition, the mediation and moderation models specify the associations. The empirical model of the study is thus designed to increase the explanatory power of each of social capital construct, using hierarchical linear and nonlinear models. The results generally support the network dynamic and collective efficacy hypotheses, concluding that both individual-level social capital and neighborhood-level social cohesion are significant predictors of the outcome, but there are substantial differences in the magnitude of the effect. Specifically, bridging and linking types of social capital produce stronger effects on residents’ community development action than any other variables, and the effect of neighborhood-level social cohesion is small and partially mediated by individual-level bonding capital. Also, neighborhood-level social cohesion does not explain the extent to which individual-level social capital exerts influence on its outcome. The research findings imply several lessons for social work. The key features of social capital are social relationships accruing to individuals rather than communities. While bonding networks have beneficial effects on the organization of the poor, strategies that extend the boundary of networks and cultivate institutional involvement are more critical to creating opportunities of resource mobilization. Given the findings of this study, the author suggests some ways of promoting community development through investment in social capital. In particular, social workers’ awareness of bridging and linking capital is very important to the success of their intervention. Social workers thus need to take a leadership role in efforts to expand diverse social connections. INDEX WORDS: Social capital, Social cohesion, Bonding capital, Bridging capital, Linking capital, Community development action, Network dynamic, Collective efficacy, Synergy. ASSESSING THE ROLE OF SOCIAL CAPITAL IN THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FIELD: A MULTI-LEVEL ANALYSIS by HYOUNG YONG KIM B.A., Yonsei University, 1995 M.A., Yonsei University, 2000 M.A., University of Georgia, 2005 A Dissertation Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of The University of Georgia in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY ATHENS, GEORGIA 2006 © 2006 HYOUNG YONG KIM All Rights Reserved ASSESSING THE ROLE OF SOCIAL CAPITAL IN THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FIELD: A MULTI-LEVEL ANALYSIS by HYOUNG YONG KIM Major Professor: Kevin L. DeWeaver Committee: Thomas P. Holland Kristina Jaskyte Electronic Version Approved: Maureen Grasso Dean of the Graduate School The University of Georgia Dec 2006 iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to deliver the best appreciation to Dr. Kevin DeWeaver, my committee chair and academic mentor, for having believed in my potential as a researcher. His expert knowledge and guidance were the foundation for my doctoral research and his encouragement and patience were the impetus for completing this dissertation. I know that my gratitude to him is beyond my words of appreciation, but hope that his efforts will be rewarded as we continue to develop our relationship of trust. Likewise, I wish to thank Dr. Thomas Holland, for his academic advice and support for this very conceptual research, and Dr. Kristina Jaskyte, especially for her incredible contribution to the refinement of the study variables. Insightful comments and assistance offered by the dissertation committee shall be remembered for many years. My gratitude goes as well to the School of Social Work and the Graduate School for providing me with financial support to dedicate my doctoral study throughout the whole years in UGA. My sincere thanks go to my Korean friends for their wonderful support and love. I would like to express my special thanks to Dongsoo Kim and his family. They shared with my family every step of studying and living in Athens, and willingly helped us in times of challenge. Without them, things would be a lot different. I wish to express my gratitude to Sunghae Kim and Sangwoo Han for their academic friendship. Even though we’d been together in a very few years, we practiced a number of ideas together that were the best memory of my learning. I thank my fellow school members who constantly gave me encouragement. To Sung Hyun Yoon, Minhong Lee, Sunyung Yoo, and Byungduck Kang, I will not forget what you have shared with me. I also thank Sangyeon Lee for prayers and opportunities for spiritual growth. To v Gyeongsoo Kang, Jongsuk Choi, Hyunju Lee, and Kunkyu Kim. Obviously, I would be very lonely without our friendship. To my father and mother, thank you for all the support and understanding during the years in the U.S. From the very depths of my heart, I wish you know my gratitude to you for giving me hope, wisdom, strength, and passion. All achievement must be credited to them. To my brother and sister and their families, thank you for believing me even when I was too distracted to nurture our relationships. Finally, but more important, my gratitude to my wife is boundless. I feel so blessed to have HyeRyeong and cannot thank her enough for all that she has done for me. To my daughter, Lynnette, you made me appreciate my life so much more. I love you. vi TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS...................................................................................................... iiv LIST OF TABLES......................................................................................................................x LIST OF FIGURES .................................................................................................................xii CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION........................................................................................................1 Why Social Capital Matters .......................................................................................4 General Controversies in Research on Social Capital .................................................7 A Multilevel and Dimensional Approach to Social Capital.......................................12 Research Questions..................................................................................................14 Significance of the Study .........................................................................................16 Organization of the Study ........................................................................................18 2. LITERATURE REVIEW: BACKGROUND OF SOCIAL CAPITAL RESEARCH ...20 Social Capital Theory ..............................................................................................20 Social Capital as Individual Advantage – James Coleman ...................................21 Social Capital as Power Relation – Pierre Bourdieu ............................................23 Social Capital as a Collective Asset – Robert Putnam..........................................27 Comparisons of Three Perspectives.....................................................................30 Conceptualization of Social Capital .........................................................................33 Definition of Social Capital.................................................................................34 vii Forms of Social Capital.......................................................................................35 Social Cohesion ..................................................................................................37 Measurement Issues............................................................................................38 Empirical Research on Social Capital and Community Development.......................43 Economic Development ......................................................................................43 Political Development.........................................................................................47 Cultural Development .........................................................................................49 Neighborhood Context and Social Capital...........................................................51 3. CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK................................................................................56 Community Development Field ...............................................................................57 The Goals of the Community Development Field................................................59 Community Development
Recommended publications
  • Building Bridges Building Power
    Developments in Institution-Based Community Organizing www.interfaithfunders.org www.interfaithfunders.org Table of Contents BuildingBuilding Bridges,Bridges, BuildingBuilding Power:Power: DevelopmentsDevelopments inin Institution-BasedInstitution-Based CommunityCommunity OrganizingOrganizing Executive Summary ....................................................................................................................................................................................... State of the Field Report ..................................................................................................................................................................................1 CONTEXT AND KEY FINDINGS RESEARCH DESIGN OVERVIEW OF THE FIELD: The State of the Field in 1999 and 2011 Governing and Leading IBCOs: Board members, leaders, organizers, and directors Organizing Money What is Community Organizing? .........................................................................................................................................................................3 ORGANIZING AND RELIGION ..............................................................................................................................................................................9 Religious Composition of the Field Religious Diversity among IBCOs The Effects of Religious Diversity on Organizing Activities Religious Practices of IBCOs and Their Directors ORGANIZING AND RACE ...................................................................................................................................................................................13
    [Show full text]
  • African Socialism in Tanzania: Lessons of a Community Development Strategy for Rural Transformation in Developing Countries
    ISSN 2039-2117 (online) Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences Vol 6 No 4 S2 ISSN 2039-9340 (print) MCSER Publishing, Rome-Italy July 2015 African Socialism in Tanzania: Lessons of a Community Development Strategy for Rural Transformation in Developing Countries Dr. Apuega R. Arikawei Dept of Educational Foundations, Niger Delta University, Wilberforce Island, Bayelsa State Email: arikawei@gmail.com Doi:10.5901/mjss.2015.v6n4s2p540 Abstract In a bid to formulate an appropriate development strategy to curb the quagmire of the underdevelopment crisis of the continent, African leaders adopted various policy options to extricate her economies from the dominance of colonial hegemony. In Tanzania, the philosophy of African socialism was initiated at post-colonial independence to consolidate not only the true spirit of African brother-hood but also to achieve self-reliance which is the basic principle of community development. This paper examined the practices of African socialism as a nexus toward the actualization of self-reliance and rural development. It adopted the exploratory research and relied on the conceptual framework methodology to establish the relationship between the philosophy of African socialism and community development. This was done with a view to unravel the lessons that could be drawn by any society that desired to achieve community development under the context of the African experience. Keywords: African Socialism, Ujaama, Strategy, Transformation, Agriculture, Education, Community Development. 1. Introduction Across the globe, every nation tries to forge a process of attaining some forms of development to enhance better standard of living for its citizenry. The quest for development however polarized nations to advantaged and disadvantaged position.
    [Show full text]
  • Sense of Community, Neighboring, and Social Capital As Predictors of Local Political Participation in China
    Am J Community Psychol (2010) 45:259–271 DOI 10.1007/s10464-010-9312-2 ORIGINAL PAPER Sense of Community, Neighboring, and Social Capital as Predictors of Local Political Participation in China Qingwen Xu • Douglas D. Perkins • Julian Chun-Chung Chow Published online: 14 March 2010 Ó Society for Community Research and Action 2010 Abstract This study examines the state of sense of notions of trust, reciprocity or membership, may lead to the community, neighboring behavior, and social capital in the development of local democracy. People’s Republic of China, and explores their ability to predict local political participation, in the form of voting in Keywords China Á Citizen participation Á elections for Urban Resident/Rural Villager Committees. Sense of community Á Neighboring Á Social capital Á Using a nationally representative survey, rural, older and Community cognition Á Chinese general social survey married residents and those with a primary or high school education and higher perceived socio-economic status are more likely to participate. In rural areas, men are more Introduction likely than women to vote. For urban residents, knowing one’s neighbors is more important whereas in rural areas, China is the most populous country in the world, and is neighboring behavior is more important, but both predict becoming the dominant nation economically and politically voting. Social capital does not generally predict Chinese in Asia. In the last two decades, China’s economic and people’s local political participation. Western definitions of welfare reforms and their social and cultural impact on social capital derived from theories about networking, communities, on community-based services, and on bonding and bridging ties may be too culturally individu- opportunities for local community participation have gen- alistic for China, whose collectivist society and agrarian erated significant interest among scholars and nongovern- kinship networks predate Communism.
    [Show full text]
  • The Role of Cooperatives in Community Development: the Case of the Motloulela Farming Cooperative
    The role of cooperatives in community development: The case of the Motloulela Farming Cooperative by Molebo Pretty Mohlala Thesis presented in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree Masters in Public Administration in the faculty of Management Science at Stellenbosch University Supervisor: Prof Firoz Khan March 2020 Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za Declaration By submitting this thesis electronically, I declare that the entirety of the work contained therein is my own, original work, that I am the sole author thereof (safe to the extent explicitly otherwise stated), that reproduction and publication thereof by Stellenbosch University will not infringe any third party rights and that I have not previously in its entirety or in part submitted it for obtaining any qualification. M.P Mohlala Date: March 2020 Copyright © 2020 Stellenbosch University All rights reserved i Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za Abstract Most rural communities in South Africa struggle with poverty, unemployment and social collapse. To address these difficulties, many residents work collectively in cooperatives, united in the belief that they can achieve more than when working individually. Cooperatives represent a resilient, vibrant and viable economic alternative in bringing people together to work towards a common goal and meeting their shared needs through cooperation. However, while most of the cooperatives in South Africa are largely weak or failing, there remain a few strong and vibrant cooperatives able to provide an economic boost to their communities. This study adopted a qualitative approach and utilised case-study research design to conduct qualitative research into the role of the Motloulela Farming Cooperative (MFC) (Limpopo) in community development.
    [Show full text]
  • Community Organizing Practices in Academia: a Model, and Stories of Partnerships Maria Avila, with Contributions from Alan Knoerr, Nik Orlando, and Celestina Castillo
    © Journal of Higher Education Outreach and Engagement, Volume 14, Number 2, p. 37, (2010) Community Organizing Practices in Academia: A Model, and Stories of Partnerships Maria Avila, with contributions from Alan Knoerr, Nik Orlando, and Celestina Castillo Introduction his article is based on my experience in developing a model of civic engagement at Occidental College that incorporates practices I learned as a community orga- Tnizer. Using a narrative approach, I share several stories: my own story; the story of a staff member at Occidental College’s Center for Community Based Learning, who was previously a commu- nity partner; the story of a community partner; and the story of a faculty member in Occidental’s Mathematics Department. These first-person stories illustrate the journeys that took each of us to a role in building long-term, reciprocal, academic-community part- nerships. These stories represent and reveal something I learned in community organizing: people are more likely to engage in long- term movements to create social change if they are in touch with their stories, their roots, and the reasons behind their desire to create change. Another way to refer to this is honoring our birth- rights, or the rights and responsibilities we were born with and that determine our role in society or in this world (Wolin, 1989, chapter 8). Although Occidental College has been the base for my develop- ment of this model, I have learned a great deal from my work with higher education colleagues and institutions in Mexico, Ireland, and the United States. The model of civic engagement we have developed at Occidental addresses an issue in higher education that I have observed and have heard described by several colleagues in the civic engagement field: the lack of reciprocity of interest, skills, and resources in creating long-term partnerships between academia and communities.
    [Show full text]
  • Community Development in Rural America: Sociological Issues in National Policy
    CORE Metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk Provided by eGrove (Univ. of Mississippi) Journal of Rural Social Sciences Volume 03 Issue 1 Southern Rural Sociology Volume 3, Article 10 Issue 1 (1985) December 2019 Community Development in Rural America: Sociological Issues in National Policy Kenneth P. Wilkinson Pennsylvania State University Follow this and additional works at: https://egrove.olemiss.edu/jrss Part of the Rural Sociology Commons Recommended Citation Wilkinson, Kenneth. 2019. "Community Development in Rural America: Sociological Issues in National Policy." Journal of Rural Social Sciences, 03(1): Article 10. Available At: https://egrove.olemiss.edu/jrss/ vol03/iss1/10 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Center for Population Studies at eGrove. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Rural Social Sciences by an authorized editor of eGrove. For more information, please contact egrove@olemiss.edu. Wilkinson: Community Development in Rural America: Sociological Issues in Na Wilkinson COMUDNITY DEVELOPMENT IN RURAL AMERICA: SOCIOIAGICAL ISSUES IN NATIONAL POLICY^ Kenneth P. Wilkinson Department of Agricultural Economics and Rural Sociology. Pennsylvania State University ABSTRACT Definitions of the concepts of rural, community, and development suggest problems for a policy of rural community development. An effective policy must address two barriers to development of community among residents of rural areas: 1) deficits in access to resources for meeting common needs and 2) severe inequalities in access to resources that are available. Rurality encourages community development when these barriers are low. The aim of policy should be to attack rural barriers while cultivating rural potentials for community development.
    [Show full text]
  • Society, Community, and Development: a Tale of Two Regions
    Michael Storper, Lena Lavinas and Alejandro Mercado- Célis Society, community, and development: a tale of two regions Book section Original citation: Originally published in Polenske, Karen, The economic geography of innovation. Cambridge, UK : Cambridge University Press, 2007, pp. 310-339. © 2007 Cambridge University Press This version available at: http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/4882/ Available in LSE Research Online: May 2008 LSE has developed LSE Research Online so that users may access research output of the School. Copyright © and Moral Rights for the papers on this site are retained by the individual authors and/or other copyright owners. Users may download and/or print one copy of any article(s) in LSE Research Online to facilitate their private study or for non-commercial research. You may not engage in further distribution of the material or use it for any profit-making activities or any commercial gain. You may freely distribute the URL (http://eprints.lse.ac.uk) of the LSE Research Online website. This document is the author’s submitted version of the book section. There may be differences between this version and the published version. You are advised to consult the publisher’s version if you wish to cite from it. 0 SOCIETY, COMMUNITY AND DEVELOPMENT:1 A Tale of Two Regions Michael Storper Lena Lavinas Alejandro Mercado Célis Storper: Institut d’Etudes Politiques de Paris and London School of Economics Lavinas : Institute of Economics, Federal University of Rio de Janeiro (lelavinas@aol.com) Mercado : Universidad Nacional Autónoma
    [Show full text]
  • Common Course Outline for SOCL
    Common Course Outline SOCL 101 Introduction to Sociology 3 Credits Community College of Baltimore County Description SOCL 101 – 3 credits – Introduction to Sociology examines social interactions and the use of sociological perspectives to explain the individual relationships , as well as interactions among the groups and societies that shape them. It covers basic concepts such as culture, socialization, social inequality, social power, deviance, social control, institutions, and global issues. 3 credits Prerequisites: ACLT 052 or ACLT 053 Overall Course Objectives Upon completion of this course students will be able to: 1. assess the sociological perspective and its development in studying human behavior; 2. compare and contrast the macro and micro sociological approaches in examining social structure and social interaction; 3. evaluate the importance of social institutions including marriage, family, the media, educational, political and economic structures in a diverse and global society; 4. evaluate major sociological theories by focusing on the main concepts, ideas and critical assessment of each theory from a historical, social and political context; 5. apply the sociological perspective when using technology to evaluate and validate information; 6. find, evaluate, use, and cite appropriate academic resources related to sociological topics; 7. apply the steps in the scientific research process, utilizing technology and appropriate academic resources, to analyze or design a sociological study; 8. examine the nature of culture, subcultures, social norms, ethnocentrism, and cultural relativism with a focus on diversity appreciation and ethical awareness; 9. describe the theories and processes of socialization on the development of the self and lifelong learning; 10. assess patterns of social interaction using the concepts: status, role, primary group, and secondary group; 11.
    [Show full text]
  • Community of Practice Design Guide
    CCoommmmuunniittyy ooff PPrraaccttiiccee DDeessiiggnn GGuuiiddee A Step-by-Step Guide for Designing & Cultivating Communities of Practice in Higher Education Acknowledgments Why Are Communities Important? This guide was developed based on the shared Today, organizations, workgroups, teams, and experiences of several organizations working together individuals must work together in new ways. Inter- in ways that embody the spirit of collaboration. These organizational collaboration is increasingly important. included the National Learning Infrastructure Initiative Communities of practice provide a new model for at EDUCAUSE (http://www.educause.edu/nlii) and a connecting people in the spirit of learning, knowledge community it sponsored, the Bridging VCOP; the sharing, and collaboration as well as individual, group, American Association for Higher Education. and organizational development. (http://www.aahe.org); and iCohere (http://www.icohere.com). We would also like to Communities of practice are important because they: specifically acknowledge the NLII VCOP Facilitators X Connect people who might not otherwise Team and four generations of NLII Fellows for their have the opportunity to interact, either as ongoing contribution to and successful demonstration frequently or at all. of many of the processes and tools presented in this guide. X Provide a shared context for people to communicate and share information, stories, and personal experiences in a way that builds understanding and insight. How to Use This Community Design Guide X Enable dialogue between people who come This guide provides a practical approach to creating together to explore new possibilities, solve challenging problems, and create new, communities of practice (CoPs) based on experiences mutually beneficial opportunities. working with corporations, nonprofits, associations, government organizations, and educational X Stimulate learning by serving as a vehicle for institutions.
    [Show full text]
  • Human Services and Community Justice
    BACHELOR OF SCIENCE IN MAJOR HUMAN SERVICES AND COMMUNITY JUSTICE DEPARTMENT OF COUNSELING AND HUMAN SERVICES 524 West 59th Street, New York, NY 10019 ¢ New Building, 8.65.26 ¢ 212-393-6883 www.jjay.cuny.edu/department-counseling-human-services See all major requirements at: www.jjay.cuny.edu/human-services-and-community-justice-major-resources WHAT WILL YOU LEARN IN THIS MAJOR? The Human Services and Community Justice (HSCJ) major is designed to train students in the practice and theory of human services. Students in the major will progress through a series of required core courses, designed to prepare them to be self-reflective, competent and compas- sionate practitioners, change agents, advocates, and community lead- ers. Students will examine issues of social, racial, and economic injustice, and the challenges encountered by diverse and underserved populations in society. Through multidisciplinary coursework, students will develop a rich appreciation for diverse human systems and interventions, justice and advocacy, and policy and administration, promoting a “just” society. IN THIS MAJOR YOU WILL nnn FIRST COURSES IN THE MAJOR nnn Read journal articles and textbooks. CHS 150: Foundations of Human Services Understand human services values, attitudes and Counseling ethics and their appropriate application in practice to AFR 145: Introduction to Community Justice culture, ethnicity, race, class, gender, religion/spiritual- in Human Systems ity, ability, sexual orientation, and other expressions of AFR 227: Community Based Approaches diversity. to Justice Engage with diverse faculty and social and advocacy CHS 230: Culture, Direct Services & Community groups, examining the dynamics of power, values Practice and equity of public service, civic activism and CHS 235: Theories of Assessment and transformational organizational change.
    [Show full text]
  • Sense of Community in Adolescence
    Sense of community in adolescence Elvira Cicognani, Bruna Zani, Cinzia Albanesi Department of Sciences of Education “G.M.Bertin” University of Bologna e-mail: elvira.cicognani@unibo.it Abstract In adolescence, Sense of Community (SoC) grows thanks to positive experiences with peers and significant adults in different settings (e.g., neighbourhoods, schools) and contributes to the development of personal and social identity and to positive developmental outcomes. In order to study SoC during this developmental period, it is important to develop instruments that adequately capture adolescents’ feelings and experiences within the community. This paper describes the process of construction of an instrument to measure Sense of community among adolescents. A series of qualitative and quantitative studies lead to the identification of five dimensions of SoC, consistent with McMillan & Chavis (1986) model, that are relevant for this age group: sense of belonging, support and emotional connection with the community, support and emotional connection with peers, satisfaction of needs and opportunities for involvement, opportunities for influence. The scale, both in its complete (36 items) and short (20 items) version, demonstrated good psychometric properties, and positively correlates with perceived social support and well being. SoC referred to the hometown decreases across the adolescent years. Results of research conducted using this instrument indicated the important role of SoC in enhancing social participation during adolescence, and its contributing role in increasing social well being. Key words: Sense of community, measurement, adolescence, social participation Introduction In this context we will briefly illustrate the development of an instrument for measuring Sense of Belonging to a community where people feel community in adolescence and some lines of research connected, supported and influential has to do with a we conduced to investigate SoC in this “fundamental human phenomenon of collective developmental period.
    [Show full text]
  • What Is Social Capital?
    OECD Insights: Human Capital What is social capital? The concept of social capital became fashionable only relatively recently, but the term has been in use for almost a century while the ideas behind it go back further still. “Social capital” may first have appeared in a book published in 1916 in the United States that dis- cussed how neighbours could work together to oversee schools. Author Lyda Hanifan referred to social capital as “those tangible assets [that] count for most in the daily lives of people: namely goodwill, fellowship, sympathy, and social intercourse among the individuals and families who make up a social unit”. That gives some sense of what’s meant by social capital, although today it would be hard to come up with a single definition that sat- isfied everyone. For the sake of simplicity, however, we can think of social capital as the links, shared values and understandings in society that enable individuals and groups to trust each other and so work together. In recent years, the term entered the popular imagination with the publication in 2000 of Robert Putnam’s bestseller, Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. Putnam argued that while Americans have become wealthier their sense of commu- nity has withered. Cities and traditional suburbs have given way to “edge cities” and “exurbs” – vast, anonymous places where people sleep and work and do little else. As people spend more and more time in the office, commuting to work and watching TV alone, there’s less time for joining community groups and voluntary organ- isations, and socialising with neighbours, friends and even family.
    [Show full text]