Engagement with the Visual Arts Increases Mindfulness
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Tennessee at Chattanooga UTC Scholar Student Research, Creative Works, and Honors Theses Publications 5-2017 Engagement with the visual arts increases mindfulness Lydia G. Fogo University of Tennessee at Chattanooga, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://scholar.utc.edu/honors-theses Part of the Art and Design Commons Recommended Citation Fogo, Lydia G., "Engagement with the visual arts increases mindfulness" (2017). Honors Theses. This Theses is brought to you for free and open access by the Student Research, Creative Works, and Publications at UTC Scholar. It has been accepted for inclusion in Honors Theses by an authorized administrator of UTC Scholar. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Engagement with the Visual Arts Increases Mindfulness Lydia Grace Fogo Departmental Honors Thesis The University of Tennessee at Chattanooga Department of Art Examination Date: April 3rd, 2017 ________________________ ________________________ Dr. Gavin Townsend Dr. Jordan Amirkhani Professor of Art History Assistant Professor of Art History Thesis Director Department Examiner ________________________ Dr. Christopher J. L. Cunningham UC Foundation Associate Professor of Psychology Department Examiner 1 Contents Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 3 What is Mindfulness? ..................................................................................................................... 5 Historical and Modern Definitions of Mindfulness .................................................................... 5 Examples of Mindfulness and Mindfulness Practices .............................................................. 10 Misconceptions About Mindfulness ......................................................................................... 12 History of Mindfulness ............................................................................................................. 15 Mindfulness in Psychology ................................................................................................... 15 Mindfulness in Art ................................................................................................................ 16 Research on Mindfulness and Art ................................................................................................. 21 Decreased Negative Affect ....................................................................................................... 21 Attention and Memory .............................................................................................................. 25 Self-Knowledge, Self-Regulation, and Emotional Regulation ................................................. 29 Concluding Remarks on Mindfulness ....................................................................................... 33 Art and Mindfulness ..................................................................................................................... 34 Study Report ............................................................................................................................. 35 Participants ............................................................................................................................ 35 Materials and Measures ........................................................................................................ 35 Procedure .............................................................................................................................. 37 Results ................................................................................................................................... 39 Discussion ............................................................................................................................. 43 Ways Engagement with the Visual Arts Increases Mindfulness .................................................. 44 A Focus on the Present Moment ............................................................................................... 45 Flow State ............................................................................................................................. 47 2 An Artistically Mindful Mindset .............................................................................................. 50 Mindfulness Expanded.......................................................................................................... 51 Art Expanded ........................................................................................................................ 52 An Artistically Mindful Mindset .......................................................................................... 53 Discussion ..................................................................................................................................... 62 The Limited Context of Art ...................................................................................................... 62 Art Therapy ........................................................................................................................... 62 Art and Mindfulness in Schools ............................................................................................ 64 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................... 65 Bibliography ................................................................................................................................. 67 Appendix A ................................................................................................................................... 75 Appendix B ................................................................................................................................... 89 3 Introduction For many cultures throughout the ages, art has been synonymous with healing and has held a key role in many ancient spiritual and religious healing rituals.1 Traditionally, art has also been held as a hallowed and fundamental part of society and culture. However, the role of art is changing. Today the value of art-making is in increasingly under scrutiny and often dubbed an unnecessary and unimportant luxury. Art is being slowly removed from school curricula and faces defunding. While art has never been more available, still too often art is quarantined in the isolated halls of museums and available only to the select few who have the luxury to go out of their way to be involved with the arts. As art’s role in contemporary society is increasingly questioned, another topic has enjoyed a surge in popularity: mindfulness. Contemporary psychology has seen a substantial increase in the study of mindfulness—in 2012 alone over 500 scientific articles on mindfulness were published, more than the total number of articles published about mindfulness from 1980 to 2000.2 A large body of research indicate significant correlations between increased mindfulness and many positive psychological and physiological outcomes. These benefits suggest that mindfulness is a valuable tool for increasing general well-being and psychological health, and implies that mindfulness is likely to remain a popular subject of research in the near future. Although both mindfulness and art have been proven to have a variety of positive outcomes, little research has explored the possible relationship between the visual arts and mindfulness. This is surprising given that the benefits of mindfulness and engagement with the 1 Mindfulness and the Arts Therapies: Theory and Practice. Jessica Kingsley Publishers, 2014: 12. 2 Edo Shonin, William Van Gordon, and Mark Griffiths, “Mindfulness-Based Interventions: Towards Mindful Clinical Integration," [In English]. Frontiers in Psychology 4, no. 194 (2013): 1. 4 visual arts are very similar. Furthermore, the activities of mindfulness and art-making share several similarities, such as increased engagement with the present moment and regulation of attention. Given this gap in research, I propose that engagement with the visual arts, through viewing but especially through creation, provides opportunities to cultivate mindfulness. Thus, interacting with art may result in many of the same psychological and physiological benefits of mindfulness. In this paper, I seek to demonstrate that interactions with art likely have more benefits than research has currently proven, that these benefits can be helpful for a wide population, and that engagement with any form of visual art likely results in many of the same benefits of mindfulness. This paper first introduces the procedure for a study that was conducted to test the hypothesis that engagement with the visual arts increases mindfulness. Next, chapter one explores historical and modern understandings of mindfulness, provides examples of mindfulness, gives insight into misconceptions about mindfulness, and offers a brief history of the way the fields of psychology and art have incorporated mindfulness practices. Chapter two then examines several main benefits of mindfulness and engagement with the visual arts. In chapter three the methods, procedure, results from an experiment which was conducted as a part of this thesis are discussed. Qualitative and quantitative data gathered from this experiment will be included as examples throughout the paper after this point. Chapter four then examines why