Yannarie Solar Salt East Coast of Exmouth Gulf

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Yannarie Solar Salt East Coast of Exmouth Gulf Yannarie Solar Salt East Coast of Exmouth Gulf Straits Salt Pty Ltd Report and recommendations of the Environmental Protection Authority Environmental Protection Authority Perth, Western Australia Report 1295 July 2008 Environmental Impact Assessment Process Timelines Date Progress stages Time (weeks) 28/5/04 Level of Assessment set (following any appeals upheld) - 4/12/06 Proponent Document Released for Public Comment 131 12/3/07 Public Comment Period Closed 14 23/1/08 Proponent response to the issues raised 45 25/2/08 Proponent release of modified proposal and supplementary 5 reports. 24/3/08 Public Comment Period Closed 4 7/5/08 Final Proponent response to the issues raised 6 23/7/08 EPA report to the Minister for the Environment 11 Report Released: 23/07/08 Appeals Close: 6/08/08 ISSN 1836-0483 (Print) ISSN 1836-0491 (Online) Assessment No. 1521 Summary and recommendations Straits Salt proposes to construct and operate a 4.2 million tonne per annum solar salt farm on the east coast of Exmouth Gulf. This report provides the Environmental Protection Authority’s (EPA’s) advice and recommendations to the Minister for the Environment on the environmental factors relevant to the proposal. Section 44 of the Environmental Protection Act 1986 requires the EPA to report to the Minister for the Environment on the environmental factors relevant to the proposal and on the conditions and procedures to which the proposal should be subject, if implemented. In addition, the EPA may make recommendations as it sees fit. The EPA is also required to have regard for the principles set out in section 4A of the Environmental Protection Act 1986. Relevant environmental factors and principles The EPA decided that the following environmental factors relevant to the proposal required detailed evaluation in the report: (a) Conservation status and policy framework; (b) Mangrove and algal mat communities – changes to relative sea level; (c) Marine productivity - nutrient input; (d) Biota and water quality - salinity and bitterns management; (e) Water quality – acid and heavy metal release; (f) Marine fauna - vessel operations; and (g) Habitat loss. There were a number of other factors which were relevant to the proposal, but the EPA is of the view that the information set out in Appendix 3 provides sufficient evaluation. The following principles were considered by the EPA in relation to the proposal: (a) The principle of conservation of biological diversity and ecological integrity; (b) The precautionary principle; (c) The principle of intergenerational equity; and (d) The principle of minimisation of waste. Conclusion Having considered the proponent’s Environmental Review and Management Programme report and supplementary information, public and government agency submissions, separate expert advice and the proponent’s response to submissions, the EPA has concluded that the proposed solar salt farm is located in an area that presents unacceptably high risks of environmental harm to wetland values and unacceptable levels of uncertainty in relation to long term management of bitterns. i The whole of the east coast of Exmouth Gulf, including all of the salt flats and in- shore waters, are listed as a wetland of national importance in A Directory of Important Wetlands in Australia (ANCA, 1993). The EPA considers that it is environmentally unacceptable to locate a 17,765 hectare salt field within a wetland of national importance. While the salt farm is proposed to be largely located on an area of apparently bare salt flats, these flats form an integral part of the wetland ecosystem and land unit supporting the algal mats and mangroves which underpin the productivity of the wetland and Exmouth Gulf. Disturbance on the salt flats could have serious and irreversible adverse impacts on the algal mats and mangroves. The EPA recognises wetlands that are listed in A Directory of Important Wetlands in Australia as ‘critical assets’ (EPA, 2006) representing the most important environmental assets in the State and requiring the highest level of protection. The status of the site as a critical environmental asset, together with the extent of predicted impacts, the high degree of residual uncertainty and the unacceptably high risks posed by the proposal have lead the EPA to conclude that the proposal is environmentally unacceptable. The key areas where significant impacts or risks of impacts have been identified are: • Loss of biodiversity and wetland values in a listed wetland of national importance; • Significant loss and fragmentation of benthic primary producer habitat and associated ecosystem services as a result of salt pond levee walls blocking the distributional adjustments of algal mat and mangrove communities in response to sea level rise. • Potential loss of regionally significant mangroves and algal mats caused by the mobilisation of hypersaline groundwater; • A high level of uncertainty in relation to the proponent’s ability to manage the ongoing production of over 1 million cubic metres per annum of bitterns C, which is toxic to marine biota and therefore likely to degrade wetland and biodiversity values should bitterns discharge occur either accidentally or be required to maintain salt farm production in the long term; • Potentially significant and damaging changes to nutrient availability and delivery to coastal waters, affecting productivity in Exmouth Gulf; and • Potential release of acid and heavy metals to coastal wetland environments during dredging operations and from stored acid sulphate sediments following excavation. The proponent has not been able to demonstrate to the EPA that the environmental values of the area could be maintained with a high degree of certainty, nor that the risks to those values would be acceptably low in the long term. Based on this assessment, the EPA does not believe that the proposal could be made environmentally acceptable and recommends that the proposal should not be permitted to proceed. Accordingly, the EPA has not recommended any conditions as it does not consider that the current proposal could be implemented in an environmentally acceptable manner. ii Other advice The EPA makes the following recommendation in relation to the potential for future expansion of the proposed salt field. Should the Minister for the Environment consider the current proposal acceptable and issue a Statement permitting its construction, there is a likelihood that the proponent may wish to expand the proposed 4.2 million tonne per annum (Mtpa) of salts proposal to produce up to ten Mtpa of salts in the future. The EPA considers the known impacts and residual uncertainties associated with the assessed 4.2 Mtpa proposal to be unacceptably high. Many of these impacts and risks are directly related to the size of the development footprint, the proportional length of coastline affected and the quantities of materials and natural resources consumed. An expanded salt field beyond four Mtpa would therefore be expected to have further unacceptable cumulative impacts. Recommendations The EPA submits the following recommendations to the Minister for the Environment: 1. That the Minister considers the report on the relevant environmental factors and principles that the EPA considered relevant to the proposal, as set out in Section 3; 2. That the Minister notes that the EPA considers that a 17,765 hectare salt field should not be located within a wetland of national significance that is a critical environmental asset; 3. That the Minister notes that the EPA has concluded that the proposal cannot meet the EPA’s environmental objectives and is considered environmentally unacceptable, particularly with regard to the risk of impacts to biodiversity values and ecosystem functionality within a listed wetland of national significance, regionally significant mangrove communities, and water quality within an area recommended for ‘maximum’ water quality protection; 4. That the Minister notes that the EPA has not included in this Report conditions and procedures to which the proposal should be subject, if implemented, because the EPA holds the view that the proposal should not be implemented; 5. That the Minister not issue a statement that the proposal may be implemented; and 6. That the Minister notes the EPA’s other advice presented in Section 4 in relation to the potential for future expansion, if consideration is given to approving the construction of the solar salt farm which is the subject of this assessment report. iii Contents Page Summary and recommendations.................................................................................i 1. Introduction and background.............................................................................1 2. The proposal.........................................................................................................2 3. Relevant environmental factors and principles ................................................6 3.1 Conservation status and policy framework................................................9 3.2 Mangrove and algal mat communities - changes to relative sea level.....14 3.3 marine productivity - nutrient input.........................................................21 3.4 Biota and water quality - salinity and bitterns management....................29 3.4.1 Discharge of contained brines and bitterns...................................30 3.4.2 Long term bitterns management ....................................................37 3.4.3 Salt production and transport........................................................41
Recommended publications
  • The Cyclone As Trope of Apocalypse and Place in Queensland Literature
    ResearchOnline@JCU This file is part of the following work: Spicer, Chrystopher J. (2018) The cyclone written into our place: the cyclone as trope of apocalypse and place in Queensland literature. PhD Thesis, James Cook University. Access to this file is available from: https://doi.org/10.25903/7pjw%2D9y76 Copyright © 2018 Chrystopher J. Spicer. The author has certified to JCU that they have made a reasonable effort to gain permission and acknowledge the owners of any third party copyright material included in this document. If you believe that this is not the case, please email [email protected] The Cyclone Written Into Our Place The cyclone as trope of apocalypse and place in Queensland literature Thesis submitted by Chrystopher J Spicer M.A. July, 2018 For the degree of Doctor of Philosophy College of Arts, Society and Education James Cook University ii Acknowledgements of the Contribution of Others I would like to thank a number of people for their help and encouragement during this research project. Firstly, I would like to thank my wife Marcella whose constant belief that I could accomplish this project, while she was learning to live with her own personal trauma at the same time, encouraged me to persevere with this thesis project when the tide of my own faith would ebb. I could not have come this far without her faith in me and her determination to journey with me on this path. I would also like to thank my supervisors, Professors Stephen Torre and Richard Landsdown, for their valuable support, constructive criticism and suggestions during the course of our work together.
    [Show full text]
  • Developing Impact-Based Thresholds for Coastal Inundation from Tide Gauge Observations
    CSIRO PUBLISHING Journal of Southern Hemisphere Earth Systems Science, 2019, 69, 252–272 https://doi.org/10.1071/ES19024 Developing impact-based thresholds for coastal inundation from tide gauge observations Ben S. HagueA,B,C, Bradley F. MurphyA, David A. JonesA and Andy J. TaylorA ABureau of Meteorology, GPO Box 1289, Melbourne, Vic. 3001, Australia. BSchool of Earth, Atmosphere and Environment, Monash University, Clayton, Vic., Australia. CCorresponding author. Email: [email protected] Abstract. This study presents the first assessment of the observed frequency of the impacts of high sea levels at locations along Australia’s northern coastline. We used a new methodology to systematically define impact-based thresholds for coastal tide gauges, utilising reports of coastal inundation from diverse sources. This method permitted a holistic consideration of impact-producing relative sea-level extremes without attributing physical causes. Impact-based thresh- olds may also provide a basis for the development of meaningful coastal flood warnings, forecasts and monitoring in the future. These services will become increasingly important as sea-level rise continues.The frequency of high sea-level events leading to coastal flooding increased at all 21 locations where impact-based thresholds were defined. Although we did not undertake a formal attribution, this increase was consistent with the well-documented rise in global sea levels. Notably, tide gauges from the south coast of Queensland showed that frequent coastal inundation was already occurring. At Brisbane and the Sunshine Coast, impact-based thresholds were being exceeded on average 21.6 and 24.3 h per year respectively. In the case of Brisbane, the number of hours of inundation annually has increased fourfold since 1977.
    [Show full text]
  • Western Australia Cyclone Preparedness Guide
    Is your property ready? Western Australia Cyclone Preparedness Guide Cyclone Preparedness Guide This Guide has been prepared for WA property owners to provide information on tropical cyclones and their effect on buildings. It provides recommendations about things you can do before the cyclone season to minimise damage to your property from severe winds and rain during a cyclone. The key to preparing your property is regular inspection and continued maintenance. The checklists at the back of this Guide will help you identify any potential problems with your property and ensure that it is kept in good condition. Seek advice from a building professional to address any issues if required. TABLE OF CONTENTS WHAT IS A CYCLONE? ............................................................................................................................... 3 What are the Characteristics of a Cyclone? .............................................................................................. 3 Strong winds and rain ............................................................................................................................ 3 Storm surge and storm tide ................................................................................................................... 3 WHEN AND WHERE DO CYCLONES OCCUR? ......................................................................................... 4 Wind Loading Regions .............................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Tropical Cyclone Vance 18 – 24 March 1999
    Tropical Cyclone Vance 18 – 24 March 1999 Perth Tropical Cyclone Warning Centre Bureau of Meteorology A. Summary Severe tropical cyclone Vance was one of the strongest cyclones ever to affect mainland Australia. After developing off Darwin on 17-18 March, Vance gradually intensified as it tracked to the west southwest then to the south before crossing the coast near Exmouth on 22 March as a category 5 system. Vance caused severe structural damage to about 10 per cent of buildings in the town though many more experienced less obvious damage due to intrusion of rainwater. A high storm tide caused coastal erosion and damage between Exmouth and Onslow - the estimated peak storm surge west of Onslow was estimated at over 5 m. In addition to damage in the far west Pilbara, water and power supplies throughout the Gascoyne and Goldfields were disrupted and many homesteads sustained wind or flooding damage. The main rail and road links to the eastern states were cut. B. Meteorological Description As the circulation associated with tropical cyclone Elaine moved slowly west, another low within the monsoon trough, which persisted over the north coast of Australia near Darwin for several days, moved into the Timor Sea. The low- level circulation, favourably situated beneath the upper ridge in a region of weak wind shear quickly intensified to cyclone intensity. Vance moved quite steadily west-southwest at first, then towards the southwest during 20-21 March. It intensified steadily and was declared a severe Category 3 cyclone late on 19 March. It was further upgraded to a Category 5 overnight on 20 March.
    [Show full text]
  • When Disaster Strikes … How Communities Cope and Adapt: a Social Capital Perspective
    In: Social Capital: Theory, Measurement and Outcomes ISBN: 978-1-62417-822-1 Editor: C. Douglas Johnson © 2013 Nova Science Publishers, Inc. No part of this digital document may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted commercially in any form or by any means. The publisher has taken reasonable care in the preparation of this digital document, but makes no expressed or implied warranty of any kind and assumes no responsibility for any errors or omissions. No liability is assumed for incidental or consequential damages in connection with or arising out of information contained herein. This digital document is sold with the clear understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering legal, medical or any other professional services. Chapter 6 WHEN DISASTER STRIKES … HOW COMMUNITIES COPE AND ADAPT: A SOCIAL CAPITAL PERSPECTIVE Lisa J. Wood, Bryan J. Boruff and Helen M. Smith The University of Western Australia, Crawley, WA, Australia ABSTRACT Human beings have had to co-exist with natural disasters and environmental calamity since the dawn of time, and our vulnerability to disasters is potentially increased in the 21st century as we contend with exponential population growth and the volatilities of climate change. When a disaster strikes, a community has no choice but to respond and cope with the event. But why is it that some communities cope and adapt better than others in the face of adversity? Underlying a well-integrated, resilient community is social capital, which can play an important role in enabling communities to work together to recover from a disaster. Social capital also provides a useful framework for assessing a community’s mechanisms for preventing or preparing for disasters before they occur.
    [Show full text]
  • The Age Natural Disaster Posters
    The Age Natural Disaster Posters Wild Weather Student Activities Wild Weather 1. Search for an image on the Internet showing damage caused by either cyclone Yasi or cyclone Tracy and insert it in your work. Using this image, complete the Thinking Routine: See—Think— Wonder using the table below. What do you see? What do you think about? What does it make you wonder? 2. World faces growing wild weather threat a. How many people have lost their lives from weather and climate-related events in the last 60 years? b. What is the NatCatService? c. What does the NatCatService show over the past 30 years? d. What is the IDMC? e. Create a line graph to show the number of people forced from their homes because of sudden, natural disasters. f. According to experts why are these disasters getting worse? g. As human impact on the environment grows, what effect will this have on the weather? h. Between 1991 and 2005 which regions of the world were most affected by natural disasters? i. Historically, what has been the worst of Australia’s natural disasters? 3. Go to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Global_tropical_cyclone_tracks-edit2.jpg and copy the world map of tropical cyclones into your work. Use the PQE approach to describe the spatial distribution of world tropical cyclones. This is as follows: a. P – describe the general pattern shown on the map. b. Q – use appropriate examples and statistics to quantify the pattern. c. E – identifying any exceptions to the general pattern. 4. Some of the worst Question starts a.
    [Show full text]
  • The Effects of Tropical Cyclone Vance on Exmouth
    The effects of tropical cyclone Vance on Exmouth Introduction for a category 5 cyclone in Region D is Cyclone Vance hit Exmouth on the morning by Greg Reardon (Cyclone Testing Station, James Cook University, Townsville), ‘Significant roof and structural damage. of Monday 22nd March, 1999. Exmouth is a Geoff Boughton (Curtin University of Dangerous airborne debris’, that is, the small coastal township some 1250 km north Technology, Perth), David Henderson and tabulated description for a category 4 event of Perth, and almost at the tip of Northwest John Ginger (Cyclone Testing Station, JCU) in Region C. Cape in Western Australia. It is located on Cyclone Vance the west side of the Exmouth Gulf and has a maximum gust speed expressed in both Vance formed in the Timor Sea and was population of just under 3000. It was kilometres per hour (km/h) and metres per established in the early 1960s as the service declared a Category 1 cyclone by the Bureau second (m/s). of Meteorology on 18 March. It headed west centre for the Australian–United States The damage potential listed in Tab le 1 for Communication Station. Now its main then southwest as it intensified rapidly to each category of cyclone has been based on become a Category 5 by 21 March. The fol- industry is tourism. likely performance of buildings in cyclone The township extends over an area of lowing day it was travelling almost due south Region C, as defined in the wind loading as it entered Exmouth Gulf. The Bureau’s about 4 km long by 2 km wide, and is about code.
    [Show full text]
  • Damage Investigation of Buildings at Minjilang, Cape Don and Smith Point in NT Following Cyclone Ingrid
    CYCLONE TESTING STATION Damage investigation of buildings at Minjilang, Cape Don and Smith Point in NT following Cyclone Ingrid Report: TR50 September, 2005 Cyclone Testing Station School of Engineering James Cook University Queensland, 4811 Phone: 07 4 781 4340 Fax: 07 477 5 11 84 CYCLONE TESTING STATION SCHOOL of ENGINEERING JAMES COOK UNIVERSITY TECHNICAL REPORT NO. 50 Damage investigation of buildings at Minjilang, Cape Don and Smith Point in NT following Cyclone Ingrid By David Henderson and Cam Leitch September 2005 © James Cook Cyclone Testing Station Henderson, David, 1967 - . Damage investigation of buildings at Minjilang, Cape Don and Smith Point in NT following Cyclone Ingrid Bibliography. ISBN 0 86443 748 X ISSN 0158 - 8338 1. Cyclone Ingrid 2005 2. Buildings – Natural disaster effects. 3. Cyclones – Northern Territory - 2005 I. Leitch, Campbell, 1954 - . II. James Cook University. Cyclone Testing Station. III. Title. (Series : Technical Report (James Cook University. Cyclone Testing Station); no. 50). 624.1772 Contents 1. Summary .......................................................................................................................... 4 2. Acknowledgements .......................................................................................................... 4 3. Cyclone Ingrid.................................................................................................................. 5 4. Minjilang .........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • This Is a Sample File Demonstrating the Style for ICWE14 Papers
    1 Insurance loss drivers and mitigation for Australian housing in severe wind events Daniel J. Smith1, David J. Henderson1, John D. Ginger1 1Cyclone Testing Station, College of Science, Technology, and Engineering, James Cook University, Townsville, Australia email: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] ABSTRACT: Damage investigations conducted by the Cyclone Testing Station (CTS) following severe wind events have typically shown that Australian homes built prior to the mid-1980s do not offer the same level of performance and protection during severe wind events as homes constructed to contemporary building standards. A direct relationship between observed damage modes and societal cost is needed to inform cost-benefit analysis of retrofit mitigation solutions. Policy data from one insurer in the North Queensland region of Australia during Cyclone Yasi (2011) were analyzed to identify correlations between claim value, typical damage modes, and construction age. Preliminary results suggest that ancillary damages (i.e. fabric shade coverings, roofing vents, wind-borne debris impacts on wall cladding, etc.) contribute significantly to overall loss for all ages of housing construction. In addition, the frequency of severe structural and water ingress damages is shown to be higher for legacy housing in a region subjected to wind speeds below design level. Structural retrofitting details exist for some forms of legacy housing in Australia but the utility of these details is limited. Hence, the issues of retrofitting legacy Australian housing, including practicality, economy, etc. must also be analyzed. A recently conducted survey of building industry representatives in Australia indicates that the utility of current retrofitting guidelines is inhibited by cost and facultative status.
    [Show full text]
  • Housing Damage in Windstorms and Mitigation for Australia
    Housing damage in windstorms and mitigation for Australia John Ginger a, David Henderson a, Mark Edwards b and John Holmes c aCyclone Testing Station, School of Engineering & Physical Sciences, James Cook University Townsville, Queensland, Australia bGeoScience Australia, Canberra, ACT, Australia cJDH Consulting, Melbourne, Australia ABSTRACT: Windstorms cause most of the damage to housing in Australia. Population growth is exposing more people and buildings to risks from these wind hazards. Houses and components are currently designed and built to standards aligned with the Building Code of Australia. Regulatory measures including building inspections are meant to ensure acceptable quality of construction. Inspections and post windstorm damage surveys have consistently shown that contemporary houses (post 1980) perform better than older houses (pre 1980) in cyclone and non cyclone areas. However, errors in design and construction found during recent surveys, reduce the resilience of contemporary housing. Geoscience Australia is developing a software tool for assessing the vulnerability of housing, using empirical models, expert opinion, and engineering methods. These models could be used to assess vulnerability of a range of house types and also recommend adaptation measure to account for increases in the intensity of windstorms in Australia. KEYWORDS: Cyclone, Windstorm, Vulnerability, Housing, Standards, Codes, Damage 1 INTRODUCTION Windstorms are recognized as the natural hazard that causes most of the damage to buildings in Australia [1]. In addition to economic losses, these events also inflict a social cost on the community. Population growth is exposing more people and buildings to risks from these wind hazards. This risk is dependent on the frequency and intensity of windstorms, the number of buildings exposed and their vulnerability.
    [Show full text]
  • Air Quality Impact Assessment.Pdf
    Perdaman Urea Project Cardno (WA) Pty Ltd Air Quality Impact Assessment Final | Revision 7 16 March 2020 Air Quality Impact Assessment Perdaman Urea Project Project No: IW213400 Document Title: Air Quality Impact Assessment Document No.: Final Revision: Revision 7 Date: 16 March 2020 Client Name: Cardno (WA) Pty Ltd Project Manager: Lisa Boulden Author: Matthew Pickett, Maria Murphy & Andrew Boyd File Name: Perdaman-AQ-Assessment-Rev7_issued Jacobs Group (Australia) Pty Limited ABN 37 001 024 095 Level 6, 30 Flinders Street Adelaide SA 5000 Australia T +61 8 8113 5400 F +61 8 8113 5440 www.jacobs.com © Copyright 2020 Jacobs Group (Australia) Pty Limited. The concepts and information contained in this document are the property of Jacobs. Use or copying of this document in whole or in part without the written permission of Jacobs constitutes an infringement of copyright. Limitation: This document has been prepared on behalf of, and for the exclusive use of Jacobs’ client, and is subject to, and issued in accordance with, the provisions of the contract between Jacobs and the client. Jacobs accepts no liability or responsibility whatsoever for, or in respect of, any use of, or reliance upon, this document by any third party. Document history and status Revision Date Description By Review Approved A 12 Aug 2019 Preliminary draft M Pickett, M Murphy, A Boyd S Lakmaker, L Boulden L Boulden B 6 Sep 2019 Draft report M Pickett, M Murphy, A Boyd S Lakmaker, L Boulden D Malins 0 26 Sep 2019 Draft report M Pickett, M Murphy, A Boyd L Boulden D Malins
    [Show full text]
  • ABSTRACTS in Alphabetical Order by Presenting Author
    ABSTRACTS in alphabetical order by presenting author 6-9 July 2004 Index of Authors and Abstracts (in alphabetical order by presenter) Allen, Simon Commercial platforms for marine science – Why re-invent the wheel? 13 Allen, Tim Finding a voice for Nemo – Opportunities for AMSA engagement in marine policy and public awareness 13 Ambo Rappe, Rohani & Maria J Schreider Possible consequences of fragmentation of seagrass bed on mobile epifauna 14 Anantharaman, Mohan Oil pollution regulations and oily water separator design to meet these requirements 14 Arendt, Michael D Data…Not just another bad, four-letter word when you have the right tools to manage it! 15 Awruch, CA, S Frusher & J Stevens Conventional and acoustic tagging studies on the draughtboard shark (Cephaloscyllium laticeps) in a scientific reserve in Tasmania 15 Baird, ME, PG Timko, JH Middleton & IM Suthers Biological response to wind forcing in the EAC 16 Bani, Ali, Natalie Moltschaniwskyj & Alan Jordan (Poster) Necessity of temporal and spatial management in recreational fisheries, sand flathead case 16 Bannister, Raymond, Christopher Battershill & Rocky de Nys Feeding biology of the tropical sponge Coscinoderma sp. on the Great Barrier Reef (GBR) 17 Barnes, Julia, Rhys Hauler & Chris Carter The effect of differing dietary protein:energy ratios on feed intake and growth of Atlantic salmon (Salmo Salar) at elevated temperature 17 Barnes, Peter Examination of processes affecting the distribution of the sponge, Suberites sp. in NSW coastal lakes 18 Bax, Nic & Piers Dunstan Evaluating
    [Show full text]