DOCSLIB.ORG

Judge in Hughes Casit Calls Witness a 'Liar'

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Judge in Hughes Casit Calls Witness a 'Liar' SFehron icle JAN 2 i= 1977 "When I first saw it, it was on the back bar (counter) of the Judge in Hughes Casit station," Dummar said. "A man drove in and started talking about `wouldn't it be nice if I were in it (the will).' I thought he was off his Calls Witness a 'Liar' rocker." Las Vegas Dummar said the mystery man showed up at his station about 10 District Judge Keith Hayes suddenly lashed out yesterday at witness a.m. that day. Melvin Dummar, calling him a "liar" and threatening to "have a piece of your hide" if he fails to tell the truth about his involvement with the so- "What did I think of Howard called "Mormon will" of Howard Hughes. Hughes dying? — I remember him saying that," Dummar said. "I also "Brother Dummar," said the, . remember him saying he had been judge, who is a Mormon, in a looking for me. traditional religious greeting to a fellow Mormon, "I want the truth., "I remember him saying `Wouldn't it be nice if a guy like me Where did it (the will) come from?" were in Howard Hughes' will." "A man brought it to the station," Dummar, a Utah gas sta- Dummar said he recalled tell- tion operator, responded. ing the man the story about picking up a disheveled old man in the "Do you know who wrote it?" Nevada desert, giving him a quart- the judge asked. "I do not," the witness replied. er and taking him to Las Vegas "Did you participate in its where the man identified himself preparation in any way?" as Hughes. "I did not." "I don't remember what he The judge's sudden admonition said," Dummar said. "I wasn't inter- followed Dummar's testimony that ested." he first saw an envelope containing Dummar said that after the Back Page Col. 1 man, whom he described as be- tween 40 and 50, neatly dressed and about 5-foot-10, left his station he noticed the envelope had been left near some of his schoolbooks. "I picked it up and read it and From Page 1 it has been a nightmare ever since," he said. the purported will—which be- queathed one-sixteenth of Hughes' Dummar recalled that the en- $2.5 billion fortune to Dummar—on velope containing the will was a counter of his station on the sealed originally. morning of April 27, 1976. "I will , make it my specific project to recommend you do pris- "I steamed it open," he said. "I Dummar said a man apparent- on time," the judge told Dummar. read the will. Then I put it back into ly left it there. "If you are convicted of perjury or some of my books. I opened it Hayes called to Dummar on the any other crime (in this courtroom), several times and sealed it back up witness stand, "Turn your chair you will go to the Nevada state so nobody would know it had been around and face me! prison. It's not a country club." opened. I put it back in my notebook." "You have been examined by Dummar testified in the morn- Harold Rhoden whom I consider to ing session that after finding the The 31-year-old gas station op- be a competent attorney. The ma- envelope containing the will, he erator from Willard, Utah, said it jority of your testimony is that "steamed" it open to read its was a couple of hours before his you're a liar. You have now contents and was startled to learn wife, Bonnie, came home. Then he launched into your third story. drove to Salt Lake City, about 40 "We are here seeking the that he had been cut in for a share miles away, and went to the visi- truth. Mr. Dummar, I think you are of Hughes' fortune. tor's center in the Mormon church complex. lying now. If I were to ask for a Hughes died on April 5 on an raise of hands in this room, you emergency medical flight from would be astonished at how many Dummar testified that he went people here think you are lying." Acapulco to Houston. to the 25th floor of the church Before Dummar testified, at- office building and asked to see The judge allowed Rhoden to torney Rhoden, who has probated Spencer W. Kimball, president of proceed with his examination of the will for executor Noah Dietrich, the Church, He was told Kimball Dummar, but only after further warned Dummar: was tied up and couldn't see him. chiding: "I'm going to nk you where "There are a few things that "I then went down the hall. I you got the will and the envelope. If asked where the restroom was. are valuable. Personal freedom is you lie, you will feel the wrath of valuable. Good health. Love and That's when I got to thinking I this court." respect of your family and your didn't want to do anything." own self-respect. I don't believe Dummar, whose thumbprint you. There is a saying that, Toth it was found on the envelope contain- Dummar said he placed the profit a man if he gains the whole ing the will, has been granted envelope that contained the will world and loses his soul?' immunity from arrest while testify- inside another envelope and "wrote ing here, but could be held in a note as best as I could remember "I'm not concerned about your contempt if he perjures himself. what the man had said to me. I put soul. I'm concerned about your Before the thumbprint was found it on a desk and left." hide. You better be concerned he had denied having had anything about your hide. I will make it my to do with the will. duty to have a piece of your hide." On April 27, church officials found the envelope and came to The judge then instructed the Las Vegas to file it with the court. attorney general's office to "prose- cute if he is proven to be lying." United Press MELVIN DUMMAR (RIGHT) AND LAWYER, ROGER DUTSON In Las Vegas court, before testimony on Hughes will .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Howard Hughes
    Howard Hughes Howard Hughes September 24, 1905 Born Houston, Texas, USA April 5, 1976 (aged 70) Died Houston, Texas, USA Chairman, Hughes Aircraft; Occupation industrialist; aviator; engineer; film producer Net worth US$12.8 bn (1958 Forbes 400) Ella Rice (1925-1929) Spouse Terry Moore (1949-1976) Jean Peters (1957-1971) For the Welsh murderer, see Howard Hughes (murderer). Howard Robard Hughes, Jr. (September 24, 1905 – April 5, 1976) was, in his time, an aviator, engineer, industrialist, film producer and director, a palgrave, a playboy, an eccentric, and one of the wealthiest people in the world. He is famous for setting multiple, world air-speed records, building the Hughes H-1 Racer and H-4 Hercules airplanes, producing the movies Hell's Angels and The Outlaw, owning and expanding TWA, his enormous intellect[1], and for his debilitating eccentric behavior in later life. Early years Hughes was born in Houston, Texas, on 24 September or 24 December 1905. Hughes claimed his birthday was Christmas Eve, although some biographers debate his exact birth date, (according to NNDB.com, it was most likely "the more mundane date of September 24"[2] ). His parents were Allene Stone Gano Hughes (a descendant of Catherine of Valois, Dowager Queen of England, by second husband Owen Tudor) [3][4] and Howard R. Hughes, Sr., who patented the tri-cone roller bit, which 1 allowed rotary drilling for oil in previously inaccessible places. Howard R. Hughes, Sr. founded Hughes Tool Company in 1909 to commercialize this invention. Hughes grew up under the strong influence of his mother, who was obsessed with protecting her son from all germs and diseases.
    [Show full text]
  • Fall 2000.Indd
    CENTER E FO H R T L FALL 2000 A N N O THE LAY OF THE LAND I D THE CENTER FOR LAND USE INTERPRETATION NEWSLETTER T U A S T E RE INTERP “In the field of Interpretation, whether of the National Park System or other institutions, the activity is not instruction so much as what we may call provocation. It is true that the visi- tors to these preserves frequently desire straight information, which may be called instruction, and a good interpreter will always be able to teach when called upon. But the purpose of ➣ Interpretation is to stimulate the reader or hearer toward a desire to widen his horizon of interests and knowledge, and to gain an understanding of the greater truths that lie behind any statements of fact.” -From Interpreting our Heritage: Principles and Practices for Visitor Services, by Freeman Tilden FORMATIONS OF ERASURE CLUI OPENS INTERPRETIVE SITE IN DESERT EARTHWORKS AND ENTROPY SHOW LAUNCHES NEW CLUI LA EXHIBIT SPACE DESERT RESEARCH STATION IN HINKLEY, CALIFORNIA The Desert Research Station opened to the public in November, 2000, and is currently open The Formations of Erasure: Earthworks and Entropy exhibit and Land Art Database terminal to visitors during the weekends. at CLUI, Los Angeles. CLUI photo THE DESERT RESEARCH STATION, in the desert near Barstow, California, THE NEW EXHIBIT SPACE at the renovated CLUI Los Angeles location was once a thriving educational nature station for biologists and local opened in September with the exhibit Formations of Erasure: Earthworks school groups. In recent years, however, it was abandoned and vandal- and Entropy.
    [Show full text]
  • Press Release HHC Acquisition of Occidental Assets 2019-12-30
    THE HOWARD HUGHES CORPORATION® ACQUIRES APPROXIMATELY 1.4 MILLION SQUARE FEET OF PREMIUM OFFICE SPACE AND ADDITIONAL LAND FOR COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT IN THE WOODLANDS® FROM OCCIDENTAL Acquisition Also Includes 63-Acre Campus in the West Houston Energy Corridor THE WOODLANDS, TX (December 30, 2019) – The Howard Hughes Corporation® (NYSE:HHC) announced today the acquisition of two Class AAA office towers, warehouse space and developable land in The Woodlands®, Texas, from Occidental (NYSE: OXY), providing The Howard Hughes Corporation with highly sought-after, premium office space that will enable The Howard Hughes Corporation to meet ongoing demand in the market. The acquisition increases The Howard Hughes Corporation’s office portfolio within the award-winning master planned community (MPC) by approximately 50%, and reinforces The Howard Hughes Corporation’s standing as the community’s steward and largest stakeholder. The $565 million transaction also includes the acquisition of Occidental’s Century Park campus in the West Houston Energy Corridor—a 63-acre, 1.3-million-square-foot campus with 17 office buildings— which The Howard Hughes Corporation will immediately remarket, in line with its recently announced commitment to sell non-core properties and to focus resources into the growth of its core business of MPCs. In The Woodlands, The Howard Hughes Corporation's acquisition includes the two Class AAA towers rebranded as The Woodlands Towers at The Waterway, which total approximately 1.4 million square feet of office space, and a 125,000-square-foot warehouse. The acquisition also includes 9.3 acres of prime, developable land located in The Woodlands Town Center® bordering The Woodlands Waterway® and fronting Interstate 45 North, providing the opportunity for meaningful future commercial development in the heart of The Woodlands.
    [Show full text]
  • Reading Comprehension
    READING COMPREHENSION 4 Howard Hughes, The Aviator Read the text about the life of the billionaire Howard Hughes. • Then choose the correct answer (A, B, C or D) for questions 1–7. • Write your answers in the spaces provided. • The rst one (0) has been done for you. Howard Hughes, The Aviator by Jennifer Rosenberg Howard Hughes’ Childhood Though he grew up in a wealthy household, Howard Hughes Jr. had diffi culty focusing on school and changed schools often. Rather than sitting in a classroom, Hughes preferred to learn by tinkering with mechanical things. For instance, when his mother forbade him from having a motorcycle, he built one by building a motor and adding it to his bicycle. Hughes was a loner in his youth; with one notable exception, Hughes never really had any friends. Tragedy and Wealth When Hughes was just 16-years old, his doting mother passed away. And then not even two years later, his father also suddenly died. Howard Hughes received 75% of his father’s million-dollar estate; the other 25% went to relatives. Hughes immediately disagreed with his relatives over the running of Hughes Tool Company but being only 18-years old, Hughes could not do anything about it because he would not legally be considered an adult until age 21. Frustrated but determined, Hughes went to court and got a judge to grant him legal adulthood. He then bought out his relatives’ shares of the company. At age 19, Hughes became full owner of the company and also got married (to Ella Rice).
    [Show full text]
  • The Woodlands Bridgeland Summerlin Columbia
    Discover the HHC Investment Opportunity FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS Statements made in this presentation that are not historical facts, including statements accompanied by words such as “anticipate,” “believe,” “estimate,” “expect,” “forecast,” “intend,” “likely,” “may,” “plan,” “project,” “realize,” “should,” “transform,” “would,” and other statements of similar expression and other words of similar expression, are forward- looking statements within the meaning of Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933, as amended, and Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. These statements are based on management’s expectations, estimates, assumptions and projections as of the date of this presentation and are not guarantees of future performance. Actual results may differ materially from those expressed or implied in these statements. Factors that could cause actual results to differ materially are set forth as risk factors in our most recent Annual Report on Form 10-K filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. In this presentation, forward-looking statements include, but are not limited to, expectations about the performance of our Master Planned Communities segment and other current income producing properties and future liquidity, development opportunities, development spending and management plans. We caution you not to place undue reliance on the forward-looking statements contained in this presentation and do not undertake any obligation to publicly update or revise any forward-looking statements to reflect future events,
    [Show full text]
  • Premier Retail Shopping Center | Nec Green Valley Parkway & 215 Beltway
    PEBBLE MARKETPLACE PREMIER RETAIL SHOPPING CENTER | NEC GREEN VALLEY PARKWAY & 215 BELTWAY 3960 Howard Hughes Parkway Suite 150 SCOT MARKER JULIE DORNAK Las Vegas, NV 89169 +1 702 836 3782 +1 702 836 3770 T +1 702 735 5700 [email protected] [email protected] www.colliers.com/lasvegas FOR LEASE > LAS VEGAS E WAY PAIUTE GOLF RESORT PAIUT 93 PEBBLE MARKETPLACE 15 95 APEX INDUSTRIAL PARK KYLE CANYON RD KYLE SPRING SILVERSTONE IRON CANYON MOUNTAIN MOUNTAIN 157 GATEWAY RANCH RANCH PROPERTY HIGHLIGHTS GRAND ETONT DR IVE SEVERENCE LANE ALIANTE 15 PROVIDENCE ELKHORNROA D 215 93 N TENAYA WAY TENAYA N S ELKHORN L L AM DEER SPRINGS WAY 95 OSS B SPRINGS E B R L OA V D D W CENTENNIAL PARKWAY LAS VEGAS MOTOR SPEEDWAY 604 N N JONES N P 215 EL DORADO RO ECOS N DECAT N BLVD • Anchored by Smith’s Food & Drug, Wendy’s, Wells Fargo A D BLVD UR W ANN ROAD ANN ROAD N D U S C I RAN A M SHADOW PAINTED DESERT M M LOS I GO DRIVE N O UNION PACIFIC RR O WASHBURN RD N CREEK A PRADOS S L N 5TH STREET ST Bank, and Bank of America N RANCHO REET O R NELLIS AFB W LONE MOUNTAIN ROAD T DEL NORTE E RANCHO 15 ALTA MIRA CRAIG ROAD 573 C L I F F W ALEXANDER R OAD 93 S H N RAINBOW BLVD N RAINBOW BUFFALO DRIVE BUFFALO A D O W NORTH VD S D R AS BL M I 599 G V ART E • Join Starbuck’s, Rubios, Pizza Hut, The Cracked Egg, E DURANGO LAS VEGAS V AS I N L L N W CHEYENNE AVENUE HILLS U TH 574 ER K SUN CITY LAS VEGAS ING JR BLV DESERT SUNRISE Brooklyn Bagel, Jamba Juice, Subway, China Tango and HIGHLAND PALM NORTH LAS VEGAS E Evans Ave SHORES VISTA FALLS VALLEY AIRPORT D
    [Show full text]
  • Summerlin Brochure
    10845 Griffith Peak Drive Suite 160 Las Vegas, NV 89135 BE PART OF SOMETHING BEAUTIFUL SUMMERLIN.COM 7.2020 SOME PLACES JUST Feel like Home It’s all right here. From the simple to the spectacular. From the silence of daybreak to the roar of the crowd. From the glow of The Strip to the awe of Red Rock Canyon. From quiet neighborhoods to buzzing blocks of fashion, dining, sports and entertainment. No matter where you turn, Summerlin presents inspiration in every direction, beckoning you to be part of something beautiful. Reverence Summerlin is 22,500 acres of master-planned perfection just waiting for life’s most beautiful moments. More than 150 miles of trails are carved into this desert oasis, meandering through hundreds of parks and More Planned the most diverse and stunning Perfection selection of homes in the city. for Years to Come. HIKE. BIKE. RUN. EXPLORE. GATHER. APPLAUD. PLAY. BREATHE. Vistas Pool SOME PLACES LET YOU Live out Loud. This is life lived out loud. Outside the box. Outside the lines, defined only by the outstanding backdrop of stunning Red Rock Canyon. With 300+ days of constant sunshine each year, life in Summerlin is as bold, beautiful and brilliant as it gets. Cottonwood Canyon Red Rock Loop SHOP. WORK. EAT. DRINK. Be. Fashionistas, foodies and fun seekers all gather on the bustling city blocks of Downtown Summerlin®, where residences, shops, sports, restaurants, bars and entertainment come together. When this stylish area is fully developed, the 400-acre walkable urban core will be home to even more excitement, as well as retail, office and luxe, high- density, urban-style residences.
    [Show full text]
  • Protected Landmark Designation Report
    CITY OF HOUSTON Archaeological & Historical Commission Planning and Development Department PROTECTED LANDMARK DESIGNATION REPORT LANDMARK NAME: The Angelo and Lillian Minella House AGENDA ITEM: IV OWNER: Ben Koush HPO FILE NO.: 06PL20 APPLICANT: Ben Koush DATE ACCEPTED: Feb-13-06 LOCATION: 6328 Brookside Drive – Simms Woods Addition HAHC HEARING DATE: Feb-23-06 30-DAY HEARING NOTICE: N/A PC HEARING: Mar-02-06 SITE INFORMATION Lot 12, Block 6, Simms Woods Addition, City of Houston, Harris County, Texas. The site includes a historic one-story, concrete block residence and concrete block garage. TYPE OF APPROVAL REQUESTED: Protected Landmark Designation for residence and garage. HISTORY AND SIGNIFICANCE SUMMARY The Minella House is a significant example of modern, residential architecture as it evolved in mid- twentieth century Houston. It is significant because of its unusual all masonry construction, contemporary design by Houston architect, Allen R. Williams, Jr. It is an example of the Century Built Homes, variations on a standark design, of which the Minella House seemed to be most fully resolved. Its owners, Angelo and Lillian Minella, owned and operated a plumbing supply company in the East End for decades. HISTORY AND SIGNIFICANCE Lillian and Angelo Minella were originally from the Boston area. Minella worked as a plumber at 366-374 Washington Street in the 1930s in the Brighton Center, Massachusetts commercial area, which had a large Italian-American population.i As late as 1942 Angelo and Lillian were listed in the Essex County City Directory as living on Stanwood Avenue in Gloucester, Massachusetts.ii The Minellas probably left for Texas shortly thereafter.
    [Show full text]
  • U.S Got Communication Data Off Sunken Soviet Submarine
    GLOMAR, From Al the submerged boats and the naval bases on land. The Washington Post has reported The United States long ago that the Glomar Explorer retrieved at switched to a satellite system, which least two torpedoes with nuclear war- involves submarines .coming up to heads, giving intelligence experts a within 20 feet of the surface and com- rare glimpse of how the Soviets make municating via satellites able to nuclear weapons. pierce the first 20 feet of ocean water The New York Times has said the with a powerful radio beam. The Sovi- Glomar recovered the forward third ets are understood to have moved to of the • submarine, falling to retrieve such a system within the last six any nuclear warheads or the coveted months. code machines that would enable U.S. intelligence experts to unscramble al- most 10 years worth of secret Soviet • messages. Last week, The Times repeated this U.S Got Communication Data version of its story, quoting two broth- ers, Wayne FL and Billy C. Collier, who were Involved in the construction Off Sunken Soviet Submarine and operation of the Glomar Explorer ..,„1 7 7t° but were not aboard the ship during / By Thomas O'Toole Union. This might mean that the the recovery operation 750 miles Washinston Post Eltat Writer United States is no longer able to un- northwest of the Hawaiian island of When the Central, Intelligence derstand the chatter between subma- Oahu. Agency recovered a section of a Time magazine said three weeks rines at sea and their home pods. sunken Soviet submarine in 1974, it "It was a real bonanza," one .source ago that the salvage operation suc- retrieved a detailed description of ceeded in recovering the code ina- close to the CIA said.
    [Show full text]
  • Flying Boat “Spruce Goose”
    ASME International Howard Hughes’ Flying Boat “Spruce Goose” Historic Mechanical Engineering Landmark July 20, 2002 Evergreen Aviation Museum The Captain Michael King Smith Educational Institute In July 1942, the world was at war. America had just lost 800,000 tons of her supply ships to German U-boats. Henry Kaiser, famed industrialist and builder of “Liberty” ships, proposed a fleet of flying The fuselage under construction transports to safely move troops and Adhering to the government mandate not to use materials critical to the war effort (such as steel and aluminum), the Hughes team materiel across the Atlantic. Kaiser constructed the Flying Boat out of wood. Testing new concepts for large-scale hulls and approached Howard Hughes with his control surfaces, plus the incorporation of complex power boost systems, delayed the construction process. idea. Together they formed the Hughes In mid 1944, Henry Kaiser withdrew from the project, and Hughes renamed the seaplane H-4, Kaiser Corporation and obtained an representing his aircraft company’s fourth design. After the war’s end in 1945 criticism of the project mounted. The Flying Boat prototype $18,000,000 government contract to had exceeded the government’s funding allowance and the U.S. Senate formed an construct three flying boats. investigation committee to probe alleged misappropriation of funds. Hughes invested $7,000,000 of his own into the project to keep it going. Hughes and his team of skilled engineers Meanwhile, the Hughes team assembled the Flying Boat in the Long Beach dry dock. Wishing to vindicate himself after a being designed a single hull flying boat interrogated by the Senate committee in Washington, D.C., Hughes returned to capable of carrying 750 troops.
    [Show full text]
  • U.S. Department of Justice Federal Bureau of Investigation Washington
    U.S. Department of Justice Federal Bureau of Investigation Washington, D.C. 20535 June 22, 2021 MR. JOHN GREENEWALD JR. SUITE 1203 27305 WEST LIVE OAK ROAD CASTAIC, CA 91384-4520 FOIPA Request No.: 1432458-000 Subject: DUMMAR, MELVIN Dear Mr. Greenewald: The enclosed documents were reviewed under the Freedom of Information/Privacy Acts (FOIPA), Title 5, United States Code, Section 552/552a. Below you will find check boxes under the appropriate statute headings which indicate the types of exemptions asserted to protect information which is exempt from disclosure. The appropriate exemptions are noted on the enclosed pages next to redacted information. In addition, a deleted page information sheet was inserted to indicate where pages were withheld entirely and identify which exemptions were applied. The checked exemption boxes used to withhold information are further explained in the enclosed Explanation of Exemptions. Section 552 Section 552a (b)(1) (b)(7)(A) (d)(5) (b)(2) (b)(7)(B) (j)(2) (b)(3) (b)(7)(C) (k)(1) (b)(7)(D) (k)(2) (b)(7)(E) (k)(3) (b)(7)(F) (k)(4) (b)(4) (b)(8) (k)(5) (b)(5) (b)(9) (k)(6) (b)(6) (k)(7) 11 pages were reviewed and 11 pages are being released. Please see the paragraphs below for relevant information specific to your request as well as the enclosed FBI FOIPA Addendum for standard responses applicable to all requests. Document(s) were located which originated with, or contained information concerning, other Government Agency (ies) [OGA]. This information has been referred to the OGA(s) for review and direct response to you.
    [Show full text]
  • The Deseret News
    The Deseret News SALT LAKE CITY 15C Nostrums in the Newsroom Raised Sights and Raised Expectations at the DeseretNews By Paul Swenson Nineteen Hundred and Seventy-Six was not a dull year for the 127-year-old Deseret News. Melvin Dummar, a Box Elder County service station operator, was named, along with The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, as a major beneficiary in a purported Howard Hughes will. Idaho's Teton Dam burst, leaving hundreds homeless in the path of the flood. Rep. Allan Howe was arrested and convicted of soliciting sex in Salt Lake City. Theodore Bundy, a University of Utah law student and former aide to the Governor of Washington, was found guilty of attempted kidnapping. In addition, the newspaper's "Pinpoint" investigative team capped its second year of existence with a Sigma Delta Chi award for the year's best piece of investigative print journalism in Utah, a documented indictment of misspent Salt Lake County funds. And then there was Gary Gilmore. Before his execution, Jan. 17, 1977, Gilmore and the press were locked in a painful embrace that neither party could—or would—quit. The manipulative Gilmore engineered the newsflow on front pages worldwide with a degree of control he had never been able to apply to his own life. It was an irresistable news story: a brutal killer who wanted to die, and in the process challenged the hypocrisy behind a death sentence that seemed tortuously slow to culminate. Never mind that Gilmore was the first person likely to be executed in the United States in nine years and that the future of capital punishment in America perhaps hung in the balance.
    [Show full text]