Acknowledgments
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Acknowledgments World Resources 2002–2004 is the result of a unique partner- Fundación RIDES, Chile ship between the United Nations Environment Programme Fundación Terram, Chile (UNEP), the United Nations Development Programme Indonesian Center for Environmental Law (ICEL) (UNDP), The World Bank, and the World Resources Institute King Prajadhipok’s Institute (KPI), Thailand (WRI). It is the only instance where UN agencies, a multilat- NGO-Coordinating Committee on Development (NGO-COD), eral financial institution, and an NGO work together to deter- Thailand mine the content, conclusions, and recommendations of a Ohio Citizen Action, USA major environmental report. Presencia Ciudadana, Mexico Silicon Valley Toxics Coalition (SVTC), USA INSTITUTIONS Society for Participatory Research in Asia (PRIA), India For our tenth edition in the World Resources series, the World Sustainable Development Institute, Hungary Resources staff gives special thanks to the Metanoia Fund, Thailand Environment Institute the Netherlands Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Swedish Uganda Wildlife Society International Development Cooperation Agency (SIDA), and World Resources Institute, USA the Earth Charter Initiative for their generous support. The Ford Motor Company, The David and Lucile Packard Founda- INDIVIDUALS tion, SIDA, UNDP, UNEP, the V. Kann Rasmussen Founda- Many individuals contributed to the development of this tion, The World Bank, and WRI also provided additional sup- report by providing expert advice, data, or careful review of port for EarthTrends, the companion website to the World manuscripts. While final responsibility for the contents rests Resources series, which offers environmental data, indica- with the World Resources staff, the report reflects valuable tors, and information on-line. contributions from all of the following individuals and organi- zations. In particular, special thanks go to Mirjam Schomaker We are particularly grateful to the Access Initiative, a global (consultant) of UNEP, Kirk Hamilton of the World Bank, and coalition of civil society groups. In 2000, the Access Initiative Jake Werksman of UNDP, who coordinated the input of many partners set out to measure the public’s ability to participate experts throughout their organizations including: in decisions about the environment. Their findings became a key part of this report. UNEP Adnan Amin, Meryem Amar-Samnotra, Charles Arden- THE ACCESS INITIATIVE PARTNERS Clarke, Marion Cheatle, Munyaradzi Chenje, Dan Claasen, Advocates Coalition for Development and Environment Gerry Cunningham, Arthur Dahl, Volodymyr Demkine, Hal- (ACODE), Uganda ifa Drammeh, Eric Falt, Hiremagalur Gopalan, Tessa Gov- Agricultural Cooperative Development International (ACDI), erse, Michael Graber, Sherry Heileman, John Hilborn, Anja Uganda Jaenz, Cornis Lugt, Timo Maukonen, Elizabeth Migongo- Austral Center for Environmental Law, Chile Bake, Patrick M’mayi, Masa Nagai, Werner Obermeyer, Neil Centro de Investigación y Planificación del Medio Ambiente Pratt, Naomi Poulton, Daniel Puig, Anisur Rahman, Denis (CIPMA), Chile Ruysschaert, Nelson Sabogal, Vijay Samnotra, Megumi Seki, Centro Mexicano de Derechos Ambientales (CEMDA), Mexico Rajendra Shende, David Smith, Eric Usher, Isabelle Vander- Comunicación y Educación Ambiental, Mexico beck, Marceil Yeater Corporación PARTICIPA, Chile Cultural Ecológica, Mexico UNDP Ecological Institute for Sustainable Development (Miskolc), Ali Farzin, Sergio Feld, Linda Ghanime, Pascal Girot, Hos- Hungary sein Jafari Giv, Peter Hazlewood, John Hough, Selim Jahan, Environmental Justice Networking Forum (EJNF), South Mehdi Kamyab, Arun Kashyap, Charles McNeill, Joseph Africa Opio Odongo, Usha Rao, Nadine Smith Environmental Law and Management Clinic of Technikon Pretoria, South Africa THE WORLD BANK Environmental Law Institute (ELI), USA Kristalina Georgieva, Magda Lovei, Saeed Ordoubadi, Environmental Management and Law Association (EMLA), Stefano Pagiola, Gunars Platais Hungary Environmental Partnership for Central Europe (ÖKOTÁRS), Special thanks go to Allen Hammond who graciously stepped in Hungary as acting Editor-in-Chief to guide the Report to final publication. 284 W ORLD RESOURCES 2002–2004 World Resources staff also gratefully acknowledges the guid- national), Jesse Ribot (WRI), Frances Seymour (WRI), ance of Anthony Janetos (WRI) in project planning and Dan Barbara Wyckoff-Baird (Aspen Institute) Tunstall (WRI) in overseeing the review process. CHAPTER 6 DRIVING BUSINESS ACCOUNTABILITY Contributors and reviewers: Shakeb Afsah (International PART I Resources Group), Rick Bunch (WRI), Cary Coglianese (Har- vard University), Julie Gorte (Calvert Group), Chris Herlug- son (BP-Amoco), Jacky Higgins (HSBC), David Hillyard CHAPTER 1 ENVIRONMENTAL GOVERNANCE: WHOSE VOICE? (Earthwatch), Fran Irwin (WRI), William Kramer (WRI), WHOSE CHOICE? Steve Lippman (Trillium Asset Management), Nick Maybury Contributors and reviewers: Nikolai Denisov (UNEP/GRID- (HSBC), Elena Petkova (WRI), Janet Ranganathan (WRI), Arendal), Sofie Flensborg (UN Economic Commission for Don Reed (Ecos Corporation), David Wheeler (World Bank) Europe), Allen Hammond (WRI), Norbert Henninger (WRI), Somrudee Nicro (Thailand Environment Institute), CHAPTER 7 INTERNATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL GOVERNANCE Gustavo Alanis Ortega (Centro Mexicano de Derecho Ambi- Contributors and reviewers: Linda Shaffer Bollert (WRI), ental), Elena Petkova (WRI), Jesse Ribot (WRI), Alejandra Duncan Brack (RIIA), Anne Marie DeRose (WRI), Charles Di Serrano P. (Centro Mexicano de Derecho Ambiental), Leva (World Bank), Navroz Dubash (WRI), Lindsey Fransen Frances Seymour (WRI), Peter Veit (WRI), Jeremy Wates (WRI), Mairi Dupar Gore (WRI), Allen Hammond (WRI), (UN Economic Commission for Europe) Fredrich Karhl (WRI), Tony La Viña (WRI), Crescie Maurer (WRI), Frances Seymour (WRI) CHAPTER 2 ENVIRONMENTAL GOVERNANCE TODAY Contributors and reviewers: Frank Ahern (Terrevista Earth CHAPTER 8 A WORLD OF DECISIONS: CASE STUDIES Imaging), Linda Shaffer Bollert (WRI), Carl Bruch (Environ- Contributors and reviewers: Bharti Bhavsar (SEWA), Melissa mental Law Institute), Dirk Bryant (WRI), Andrew Buchman Boness (WRI), George Branch (University of Cape Town), (WRI), Jean-Gael Collomb (WRI), Gayle Coolidge (WRI), Mauricio Castro (Secretaría General del Sistema de la Inte- Hamid R. Davoodi (IMF), Linda Delgado (WRI), Katie Fro- gracíon Centroamericana), Angela Cassar (Environmental hardt (African Wildlife Foundation), Allen Hammond Law Institute), Elsa Chang (Advocacy Institute), Rick (WRI), Massimo Mastruzzi (World Bank Institute), Emily Clugston (Center for Respect of Life and Environment, and Matthews (WRI), Crescie Maurer (WRI), Erin McAlister Earth Charter), Malcolm Douglas, Geoff Evans (Mineral Pol- (WRI), Becky Milton (WRI), Susan Minnemeyer (WRI), Judy icy Institute), Ali Farzin (UNDP), Polly Ghazi, Gwendolyn Oglethorpe (WWF-US), Elena Petkova (WRI), Jesse Ribot Hallsmith, Graeme Hancock (Department of Mining, PNG), (WRI), James Shambaugh, Frances Seymour (WRI), Peter Ben Hardwick (Slater & Gordon Lawyers), Jean Harris Veit (WRI) (Ezemvelo KwaZulu-Natal Wildlife), Maria Hauck (Univer- sity of Cape Town), Aditi Kapoor (Alternative Futures), Stu- CHAPTER 3 PUBLIC PARTICIPATION AND ACCESS art Kirsch (University of Michigan), Harvey Locke, Emily Contributors and reviewers: The Access Initiative, Tom Matthews (WRI), Kenton Miller (WRI), Marta Miranda Beierle (Resources for the Future), John Coyle (WRI), (WRI), Mohit Mukherjee (Earth Charter International Secre- Gretchen Hoff (WRI), Bill LaRocque (WRI), Elena Petkova tariat), Reema Nanavaty (SEWA), Steven C. Rockefeller (WRI), Lina Maria Ibarra Ruiz (WRI) (Middlebury College), Phil Shearman, John E. Strongman (The World Bank), Asghar Tahmasebi, Anil Prabhakar Tam- CHAPTER 4 AWAKENING CIVIL SOCIETY bay (BAIF Development Research Foundation), Patricia Contributors and reviewers: Richard Andrews (University of Townsend, Peter Veit (WRI), Mirian Vilela (Earth Charter North Carolina), L. David Brown (Harvard University), Secretariat), Peter Wilshusen (Bucknell University of Grant Curtis (ADB), Robert Dobias (ADB), Alan Fowler Pennslyvania), David Wissink (OK Tedi Mining Limited) (INTRAC), Marlies Glasius (Global Civil Society 2001), William Moody (Rockefeller Brothers Foundation), Tomas CHAPTER 9 TOWARD A BETTER BALANCE R˚uˇziˇcka (EPCE), Tamás Scsaurszki (C.S. Mott Foundation), Contributors and reviewers: Navroz Dubash (WRI), Mairi Robert Sinclair (consultant) Dupar Gore (WRI), Gretchen Hoff (WRI), Tony La Viña (WRI), Allen Hammond (WRI), Elena Petkova (WRI), Jesse CHAPTER 5 DECENTRALIZATION: A LOCAL VOICE Ribot (WRI), Frances Seymour (WRI) Contributors and reviewers: Jon Anderson (USAID), Krister Par Andersson (Indiana University), Richard Andrews (Uni- versity of North Carolina), Nate Badenoch (WRI), Navroz Dubash (WRI), Mairi Dupar Gore (WRI), Fredrich Kahrl (WRI), Anne M. Larson (CIFOR), Jamie Pittock (WWF Inter- 285 Acknowledgments PART II Forests, Grasslands, and Drylands Reviewers and contributors: Nigel Dudley (Equilibrium), Peter Gilruth (Raytheon), Suzie Greenhalgh (WRI), Peter DATA TABLES Holmgren (FAO), Alexander Korotkov (UNECE), Emily Institutions and Governance Matthews (WRI) Reviewers and contributors: David Banisar (Privacy Interna- tional), Maryam Niamir-Fuller (UNDP), Norbert Henninger Freshwater Resources (WRI), Frances Irwin (WRI), Tundu Lissu (WRI), Crescen- Reviewers and contributors: Lauretta Burke (WRI), Åse Elias- cia Maurer (WRI), Elena Petkova (WRI), Frances