1 SHAWN HAGERTY, Bar No. 182435 [email protected] 2 BEST BEST & KRIEGER LLP 655 West Broadway, 15th Floor 3 San Diego, 92101 Tel: 619.525.1300; Fax: 619.233.6118 4 Attorneys for Defendant and Cross-Complainant 5 CITY OF SAN BUENAVENTURA

6 DANIEL COOPER, Bar No. 153576 [email protected] 7 COOPER & LEWAND-MARTIN, INC. 1004 O’Reilly Avenue 8 San Francisco, California 94129 Tel: 415.360.2962 9 Attorneys for Petitioner and Plaintiff 10 SANTA BARBARA CHANNELKEEPER

11 ROBERT N. KWONG, Bar No. 121839 DENNIS O. LA ROCHELLE, Bar No. 71599 12 ARNOLD LAROCHELLE MATHEWS VANCONAS & ZIRBEL, LLP 300 Esplanade Dr Ste 2100 13 Oxnard, CA 93036 Tel: 805.988.9886 14 DAVID B. COSGROVE, Bar No. 115564 15 JEFFREY M. ODERMAN, Bar No. 63765 DOUGLAS J. DENNINGTON, Bar No. 173447 16 JEREMY N. JUNGREIS, Bar No. 256417 RUTAN & TUCKER, LLP 17 611 Anton Boulevard, Suite 1400 Costa Mesa, CA 92626-1931 18 Tel: 714.641.5100 Fax: 714.546.9035

19 Attorneys for Cross-Defendant 20 CASITAS MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT

21 22 23 24 25

26 27 28

82470.00018\32488672.1 - 2 - Jt. Status Conf. State.

1 JOINT STATUS CONFERENCE STATEMENT 2 3 Pursuant to Court order at the Status Conference on November 1, 2019 (“11/1/19 4 Conference”), Defendant and Cross-Complainant City of San Buenaventura (“City”), Plaintiff 5 Santa Barbara Channelkeeper (“Channelkeeper”), Cross-Defendant Casitas Municipal Water 6 District (“Casitas”), and Cross-Defendants who signed below submit this Joint Status Conference 7 Statement (“Statement”). City sent drafts of this Statement to all counsel on November 8, 14, and 8 18, 2019. In addition, counsel exchanged e-mails regarding the Statement. 9 10 1. THIRD AMENDED CROSS-COMPLAINT 11 12 A. PARTIES AND SERVICE 13 14 As counsel for City informed the Court at the 11/1/19 Conference, City proposes to file a

15 Third Amended Cross-Complaint (“3rd Am. Cross-Complaint”). The 3rd Am. Cross-Complaint 16 will add parties who may have riparian rights to the and its tributaries, and will 17 provide notice of the adjudication to persons who own property overlying one of the four 18 groundwater basins in the Ventura River Watershed.

19 The 3rd Am. Cross-Complaint individually names as parties each of the property owners 20 that own land adjacent to the Ventura River and its tributaries in the caption and in the body of

21 the pleading. The owners of approximately 500 parcels are named as parties because they own 22 land outside of one of the four groundwater basins, but adjacent to the Ventura River and its 23 tributaries (“Riparian Landowners”). The owners of an additional approximately 1,250 parcels 24 are named as parties because they own land overlying one of the four groundwater basins and 25 adjacent to the Ventura River and its tributaries (“Riparian and Overlying Landowners”). City

26 will personally serve the Riparian Landowners and Riparian and Overlying Landowners with the 27 3rd Am. Cross-Complaint and standard form Summons except it will provide 60 days to respond 28 to the 3rd Am. Cross-Complaint.

82470.00018\32488672.1 - 3 - Jt. Status Conf. State.

1 City proposes to allow the Riparian Landowners and Riparian and Overlying Landowners

2 60 days to respond to be consistent with the 60 days provided by the Cross-Defendants named in 3 the Second Amended Cross-Complaint pursuant to the Order Granting Respondent and Cross- 4 Complainant City of San Buenaventura’s Application for Extension of Time, issued by the San 5 Francisco Superior Court and filed November 15, 2018, and to allow these new Cross-Defendants 6 time to attend the public meetings described below that will answer questions about this lawsuit 7 before they must respond to the pleading. 8 The property owners only overlying one of the four basins (“Overlying Landowners”) are 9 not named individually, but instead, are referenced generically. 3rd Am. Cross-Complaint, p. 29, 10 caption; p. 62, ¶ 95. As explained at the Status Conference, the City believes the Overlying 11 Landowners are not automatically parties to the case under the Streamlined Groundwater 12 Adjudication Statutes. Instead, under California Civil Procedure Code section 836(a)(1)(A) 13 (emphasis added), the notice to property owners states in part: “you may become a party to this 14 lawsuit by filing an answer to the lawsuit on or before the deadline specified in this notice.” In

15 other words, an Overlying Landowner only becomes a cross-defendant if he or she answers the 3d 16 Am. Cross-Complaint. City will serve the Notice and Form Answer on the Overlying 17 Landowners pursuant to California Civil Procedure Code section 836. 18 19 B. PRAYER FOR RELIEF 20

21 Pursuant to the Court’s instruction, City revised the prayer for relief to specifically 22 identify the relief it seeks against the Riparian Landowners, Riparian and Overlying Landowners, 23 and Overlying Landowners who do not appear in the lawsuit. 3rd Am. Cross-Complaint, p. 74, 24 ¶¶ 4 - 5. A copy of the proposed 3rd Am. Cross-Complaint and the [Proposed] Order Granting 25 Leave to File the Third Amended Cross-Complaint are attached as Exs. A and B, respectively.

26 27 28

82470.00018\32488672.1 - 4 - Jt. Status Conf. State.

1 2. NOTICE TO COURT

2 3 The Senior Court administrator provided counsel for City with an Excel spreadsheet that 4 lists information for: (1) the Riparian Landowners and Riparian and Overlying Landowners; and 5 (2) the Overlying landowners. Copies of page 1 of the: (1) the Riparian Landowners and Riparian 6 and Overlying Landowners spreadsheet, and (2) the Overlying Landowners spreadsheet are 7 attached as Exs. C and D, respectively. 8 9 3. MOTION FOR APPROVAL 10 11 At the 11/1/19 Conference, the Court provided direction regarding City’s Motion for 12 Approval of the Notice of Commencement of Groundwater Basin and Watershed Adjudication 13 and Form Answer (“Motion for Approval”). The revised Notice of Commencement of 14 Groundwater Basin and Watershed Adjudication (“Notice of Adjudication”): (1) more

15 specifically advises the Overlying Landowners of the potentially adverse consequences if they do 16 not appear in the lawsuit; (2) initial capitalizes the term “Form Answer”; (3) first describes 17 electronic service and then describes filing Form Answers and other pleadings; (4) explains that 18 the Courthouse where pleadings are filed is different than the Courthouse where the case will be 19 heard; and (5) provides links to the Judicial Council form and File & ServeXpress form for 20 indigent parties to seek a fee waiver.

21 The Notice also changes the dates of the meetings and adds a third meeting. The meetings 22 described in item (6) above will be open to all potential parties and their counsel. The meetings 23 will be conducted by City, and shall take place on: 24 ______, February ___, 2019, 6:00 p.m. - 8:00 p.m. 25 Matilija Junior High School, Auditorium 26 703 El Paseo Road Ojai, CA 93023 27

28

82470.00018\32488672.1 - 5 - Jt. Status Conf. State.

1 Wednesday, February 12, 2019, 6:00 p.m. - 8:00 p.m. Bell Arts Factory, Community Room 2 432 N. Ventura Ave 3 Ventura, CA 93001

4 Thursday, February 13, 2019, 6:00 p.m. - 8:00 p.m. Oak View Community Center, Kunkle Room 5 18 Valley Road Oak View, CA 93022 6 7 City expects the Ojai meeting to take place of February 4 or 6 and hopes to confirm this at 8 the Status Conference. Also pursuant to the 11/1/19 Conference, the Form Answer is revised to 9 have Overlying Landowners: (1) state his or her name and address on caption page; and (2) state 10 his or her parcel number in the body of the form. 11 The [Proposed] Order Granting Motion to Approve excuses City from including the 3rd 12 Am. Cross-Complaint when it mail-serves the Notice and Form Answer. As the Court noted at 13 the 11/1/19 Conference, California Civil Procedure Code Section 836(a)(1)(A)(iii) anticipates the 14 underlying pleading is not served with the Notice because the Notice must state contact 15 information for plaintiff’s attorney “from whom the complaint may be obtained. . . .” However, 16 Section 836(d)(1)(B) contradicts the Notice because it requires plaintiff to serve “the notice, 17 complaint, and form answer to all holders of fee title. . . .” 18 As with other changes it made to the Notice, City requests the Court exercise its authority 19 under Section 836(i) to change this procedure: “The court may authorize any other procedures it 20 finds appropriate and necessary to provide notice. . . .” As the Court noted, the 3rd Am. Cross- 21 Complaint is a very technical document that is unlikely to assist the property owner. On the other 22 hand, it may confuse the owner since the Notice explains where he or she can obtain the pleading, 23 but the service package includes the pleading. 24 Copies of the revised English Notice of Adjudication, revised Spanish Notice of 25 Adjudication, revised Form Answer and revised Order Granting City’s Motion for Approval are 26 attached as Exhibits E, F, G and H, respectively. 27 28

82470.00018\32488672.1 - 6 - Jt. Status Conf. State.

1 4. NEUTRAL WEBSITE

2 3 City will establish and maintain during the pendency of litigation a neutral website 4 containing pleadings, reports, notices, party information contemplated by the Order for Stay, 5 signed August 23, 2019, and discovery if the stay is lifted. Parties who have appeared in the case 6 shall have access to file and review information on the website. City proposes the following 7 address for the website: venturariverwatershedadjudication.com. City proposes to use the 8 following vendor to host and maintain the website: JND Legal Administration, 1-800-207-7160, 9 and www.jndla.com . 10 11 5. INTERVENTION 12 13 Respondent State Water Resources Control Board (“SWRCB”) and the California 14 Department of Fish and Wildlife (“Department”) filed separate Motions to Intervene. City does

15 not oppose the Motions. 16 17 6. SETTLEMENT 18 19 The consumptive users who are in settlement discussions would like to update the Court 20 on the high level legal concepts supporting a proposed physical solution, and the technical basis

21 for that physical solution. These parties propose doing so in January 2020. 22 The SWRCB and CDFW have not been a party to these conversations, but are open to 23 hearing the proposals. CDFW looks forward to hearing from the consumptive users how the 24 results of CDFW’s forthcoming flow study will be incorporated into their conceptual framework. 25

26 27 28

82470.00018\32488672.1 - 7 - Jt. Status Conf. State.

1 November/2019 FERGUSON CASE ORR PATTERSON LLP

2 3 By: NEAL MAGUIRE 4 Attorneys for Cross-Defendant RANCHO MATILIJA MUTUAL WATER 5 COMPANY

6 November , 2019 BROWNSTEIN HYATT FARBER SCHRECK LLP 7

8 By: 9 SCOTT SLATER BRADLEY HERREMA 10 CHRISTOPHER GUILLEN Attorneys for Cross-Defendant WOOD- 11 CLAEYSSENS FOUNDATION

12 November , 2019 ARNOLD LAROCHELLE MATHEWS VANCONAS & ZIRBEL, LLP 13

14 By: is ROBERT N. KWONG Attorneys for Cross-Defendant CASITAS 16 MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT

17 November , 2019 RUTAN &TUCKER, LLP 1K 1) By: 20 DAVID B. COSGROVE JEFFREY M. ODERMAN 21 DOUGLAS J. DENNINGTON JEREMY N. JUNGREIS 22 Attorneys for Cross-Defendant CASITAS MiJNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT 23

24

2.5

26 ~7 I

?K

82470.0001832488672.1 - 9 - Jt. Status Conf. State.

EXHIBIT A 1 GENE TANAKA, Bar No. 101423 Exempt From Filing Fees Pursuant to [email protected] Cal. Gov’t Code § 6103 2 SARAH CHRISTOPHER FOLEY, Bar No. 277223 [email protected] 3 DAKOTAH BENJAMIN, Bar No. 316446 [email protected] 4 BEST BEST & KRIEGER LLP 2001 N. Main Street, Suite 390 5 Walnut Creek, California 94596 Tel.: 925.977.3300; Fax: 925.977.1870 6 SHAWN HAGERTY, Bar No. 182435 7 [email protected] BEST BEST & KRIEGER LLP 8 655 West Broadway, 15th Floor San Diego, California 92101 9 Tel.: 619.525.1300; Fax: 619.233.6118 10 Attorneys for Respondent and Cross-Complainant CITY OF SAN BUENAVENTURA 11

12 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 13 COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES 14 SANTA BARBARA CHANNELKEEPER, Case No. 19STCP01176 15 a California non-profit corporation, Judge: Honorable William F. Highberger 16 Petitioner, Deemed Verified Pursuant to Cal. Civ. Proc. 17 v. Code § 446 18 STATE WATER RESOURCES RESPONDENT AND CROSS- CONTROL BOARD, a California State COMPLAINANT CITY OF SAN 19 Agency; BUENAVENTURA’S THIRD AMENDED CITY OF SAN BUENAVENTURA, a CROSS-COMPLAINT FOR: 20 California municipal corporation, incorrectly named as CITY OF 1. VIOLATION OF REASONABLE USE; 21 BUENAVENTURA, 2. VIOLATION OF PUBLIC TRUST; 3. DECLARATORY RELIEF - PUEBLO 22 Respondents. AND/OR TREATY WATER RIGHTS; 4. DECLARATORY RELIEF - 23 PRESCRIPTIVE WATER RIGHTS; CITY OF SAN BUENAVENTURA, a 5. DECLARATORY RELIEF - 24 California municipal corporation, APPROPRIATIVE WATER RIGHTS; 6. COMPREHENSIVE ADJUDICATION; 25 Cross-Complainant 7. DECLARATORY RELIEF - MUNICIPAL PRIORITY; 26 v. 8. DECLARATORY RELIEF - HUMAN RIGHT TO WATER; and 27 DUNCAN ABBOTT; 9. DECLARATORY RELIEF AGR BREEDING, INC.; 28 [continued on next page] - 1 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 ASQUITH FAMILY LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, LTD.; TROY BECKER; BENTLEY FAMILY 2 LIMITED PARTNERSHIP; ROBIN BERNHOFT; DEWAYNE BOCCALI; JANET 3 BOULTON; MICHAEL BOULTON; DWAYNE BOWER; BURGESS RANCH; MICHAEL 4 CALDWELL; CASITAS MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT; CASITAS MUTUAL WATER 5 COMPANY; CHARLES CHO; JOE CLARK; KEVIN CLARK; LISA CLARK; REBECCA 6 COLLINS; THOMAS COLLINS; MICHAEL CROMER; ROBERT C. DAVIS, JR.; LINDA 7 EPSTEIN; ESSICK FARM MANAGEMENT COMPANY, LLC; ETCHART RANCH; JAMES 8 FINCH; FLYING H RANCH, INC.; ERNEST FORD; WAYNE FRANCIS; FRIEND’S 9 RANCHES, INC.; JOHN GALASKA; RICHARD GILLELAND; JURGEN GRAMCKOW and 10 GERALDINE GRAMCKOW, individually as Trustees of the J&G Trust; GRIDLEY ROAD 11 WATER GROUP; STEPHANIE GUSTAFSON; LAWRENCE HARTMANN; HERMITAGE 12 MUTUAL WATER COMPANY; DOROTHY HOLMES; STEPHEN HUYLER; CHERYL 13 JENSEN; BRETT KANTROWITZ; DENISE KANTROWITZ; JERRY KENTON; OLE 14 KONIG; KROTONA INSTITUTE OF THEOSOPHY; TIM KROUT; BETINA LA PLANTE; 15 LUTHERAN CHURCH OF THE HOLY CROSS OF OJAI; SCOTT LUTTENBERG; JEFFREY 16 LUTTRULL; MEINERS OAKS WATER DISTRICT; FREDRICK MENNINGER; 17 MARGARET MENNINGER; STEPHEN MITCHELL; BILL MOSES; NORTH FORK 18 SPRINGS MUTUAL WATER COMPANY; OJAI WATER CONSERVATION DISTRICT; 19 OLD CREEK ROAD MUTUAL WATER COMPANY; RANCHO DE CIELO MUTUAL 20 WATER COMPANY; RANCHO MATILIJA MUTUAL WATER COMPANY; SHLOMO RAZ;

21 SYLVIA RAZ; RINCON WATER AND ROAD WORKS; CHARLES RUDD; WILLIAM 22 RUSIN; MARK SALEH; SENIOR CANYON MUTUAL WATER COMPANY; SIETE 23 ROBLES MUTUAL WATER COMPANY; SISAR MUTUAL WATER COMPANY; SOULE 24 PARK GOLF COURSE, LTD.; ST. JOSEPH'S ASSOCIATES OF OJAI, CALIFORNIA, INC.; 25 ANDREW STASSE; GEORGE S. STUART; JOHN TAFT; TELOS, LLC; THACHER CREEK 26 CITRUS, LLC, a California Corporation; THE THACHER SCHOOL; TICO MUTUAL WATER 27 COMPANY; VICTOR TIMAR; TOPA TOPA RANCH COMPANY, LLC; LOU TOMESETTA; 28 JOHN TOWN; TRUDIE TOWN; ERNESTO VEGA; VENTURA COUNTY WATERSHED - 2 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 PROTECTION DISTRICT; VENTURA RIVER WATER DISTRICT; WOOD-CLAEYSSENS 2 FOUNDATION; CALVIN ZARA [collectively, “Original Cross-Defendants”]; 3 4 1970 RANCH ROAD, LLC; 625 N. VENTURES AVENUE, LLC; ABRAHAM MUNOZ; 5 AHDE and GANEA LAHTI, individually; ALAN and CAROL JAMES, individually; 6 ALESSANDRO LOBBA and MARY E. JACKSON, individually as Trustees of the LOOBA- 7 JACKSON FAMILY Trust; ALEXANDER and MARIA DORAN, individually; ALFREDO and 8 MONTELLE BELLO, individually; ALVIN and CLAUDIA CUNNINGHAM, individually; 9 AMERICAN RETIREMENT FUND, INC.; AMY MATTISON, Trustee of the Amy K. Mattison 10 Trust; ANATOLY and MARGARITA KOZUSHIN, individually; ANDREA LEIGH JENSEN, 11 Trustee of the Jensen Trust; ANDREW and JANE HOLGUIN, individually; ANDREW D. 12 WEST and PATRICIA G. WEST, individually as Trustees of the West Family Revocable Trust; 13 ANGIE MARI GANASEI and CHRISTOPHER PAUL DANCH, individually as Trustees of the 14 Genasei-Danch Family Trust; ANNE LOMBARD and FRANK HANSON, individually; 15 ARMANDO and SENDI SANCHEZ, individually; ARTHUR TIMOTHY and MAURYA 16 KATHLEEN FOY, individually; ASHLEN and IVY AQUILA, individually; AUBREY 17 BALKIND; AUBURN OAK BUILDERS, INC.; BARRY and ANGELA ROSS, individually; 18 BEHROOZ JADIDOLLAHI; BENJAMIN and STACEY VAIL, individually; BERKLEY and 19 SUZANNE BAKER, individually; BETTINA CHANDLER, Trustee of the Bettina Chandler 20 Trust; BLANCHE CHAPLER; BRADFORD and CHERYL BOYD, individually; BRENT and

21 SHANNA MUTH, individually; BRIAN and IRENE MCCONVILLE, individually; BRIAN and 22 JOAN ARCHER, individually; BRIAN and SHARON SMITH, individually; BRIAN S. 23 STAFFORD and JANICE M. THOMAS, individually as Trustees of the Stafford Thomas Family 24 Trust Est., March 22, 2019; BRIAN SKAGGS, Trustee of the Skaggs Trust; BRIGITTE 25 LOVELL, Trustee of the Lovell Living Trust; BRUCE ABBOTT and KATHLEEN QUINLAN, 26 individually; BRUCE and DIXIE GLADSTONE, individually; BRYAN WHITLEY; BRYCE 27 and KRISTA BELGUM, individually; CARL and BARBARA ENSON, individually; CARMEN 28 CHAVEZ and GUADALUPE PATINO, individually; CAROL NICHOLSON; CAROL ANN - 3 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 TENNANT, Trustee of the Carol McDonnell Family Trust; CARRIE MURPHY and MICHAEL 2 E. TEMPLIN, individually as Trustees of the Templin-Murphy 2016 Living Trust; CARTIN 3 FAMILY, LLC; CATHERINE E. LEE, Trustee of the Catherine E. Lee Trust; CHAD 4 WESCOTT and HEATHER CUSHNIE WESCOTT, individually; CHARLINE L. RICH and 5 RICHARD GIBSON JR., individually; CHARLES E. STARBUCK, Trustee of the Charles E. 6 Starbuck Trust; CHARLES P. WATLING, Trustee of the First Charles P. Watling Family Trust; 7 CHRISTOPHER and TINA ABE, individually; CHRISTOPHER HART; CHRISTOPHER 8 MOORE and MARY MOORE, individually as Trustees of the Christopher Moore and Mary 9 Moore Trust; CINDY PROSE; CLAIR and STACEY HARDING, individually; CLAUDIA 10 ZENOBIA LINARTE, Trustee of the Olga Trust; CLAUDIO and MAGDALENA LANDEROS, 11 individually; COMMUNITY MEMORIAL HEALTH SYSTEM; CONNIE S. MORGAN, 12 Trustee of the Connie S Morgan Trust; CONSERVATION ENDOWMENT FUND; 13 CONSTANCE and JUSTIN CAMPBELL, individually; CORINNE ANNE FRAUND; CRAIG 14 and ANA ZWIRN, individually; CURTIS and ORY NAMES, individually; CYNTHIA LEE, 15 Trustee of the Cynthia Lee Family Trust; D & J CAMPBELL BEST, LLC; DAN NEWMAN; 16 DAN STUART, Trustee of the Dana Stuart Trust; DAN WISEMAN; DANA and DAWN 17 CENICEROS, individually; DANIEL and AMY YANEZ, individually; DANIEL and NANCY 18 MCLAREN, individually; DANIEL and ROSALIND GRIMM, individually; DANNY 19 BROADHURST; DARREN and LISA LISLE, individually; DAVID FRIEND and ANGELA 20 MARIE FRIEND, individually; DAVID and LINDA SMITH, individually; DAVID and PATTI

21 WICKLUND, individually; DAVID CHASE and ANNE FITZGERALD, individually; DAVID 22 E. SISSUM, JR. and DIANA E. SISSUM, individually as Trustees of the Sissum Trust; DAVID 23 FLICK and EMMA FLICK, individually; DAWN and MARK GOLDEN, individually; DB 24 PROPERTIES, LLC; DEL CIELO, LLC; DENNIS and SUSAN RYDER, individually; DENNIS 25 BROWN; DENNIS WOOD and MARGARET VIGIL WOOD, individually; DIANE RUTH 26 WHITE, Trustee of the Diane Ruth White Living Trust; DIVE DEEP, LLC; DONALD and 27 WENDY GIVENS, individually; DONALD CAMPBELL; DONNA and JAMES KLEEBURG, 28 individually; DOROTHY HOLMES, Trustee of the Holmes Trust; DOROTHY LANQUIST; - 4 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 DOUGLAS FREEMAN and MIRANDA MARGETTS, individually; DZ SPE, LLC; EARL G. 2 HOLDER, Trustee of the Holder Survivors Trust; EDWARD and GERALDINE LEE, 3 individually; EDWARD C. LEICHT and JACQUELINE M. LEICHT, individually as Trustees of 4 the Leicht Family 2013 Revocable Trust; ELEANOR SMALL; ELENA DHYANSKY, Trustee of 5 the Elena Dhyansky Trust; ELIZABETH KEENEN; ELTON PEDERSEN and ALMA 6 CLAYTON PEDERSEN, individually; ERIC and JODI PERDUE, individually; ERIC and MING 7 JUN NAKAMURA, individually; ERIC and TRISHA JOHNSON, individually; ERIC 8 LAWRENCE BERNTHAL, SPECIAL Trustee of the Boss and Venice Trust; ERIC LEWIS and 9 BOBBI RODERICK LEWIS, individually; ERIK and TIRICA EADS, individually; EUGENE 10 and CHARLOTTE ELERDING, individually; EVELYN FRAMENT; FORTUNE BUILDERS, 11 INC.; FRANK ROBERT WALKER JR. and CARRIE ELLEN WALKER, individually as Co- 12 Trustees of the Walker Jr. Living Trust; FREDERICK and LORI PONCE, individually; GALEN 13 and MARIA DAVID, individually; GARY HIRSCHKRON, Trustee of the Gary Hirschkron 14 Revocable Trust; GARY L. WOLFE, SUCCESSOR Trustee of the Carolyn M. Tastad Revocable 15 Trust; GARY and TERRI MCCASKILL, individually as Trustees of the Mccaskill Family Trust; 16 GARY SPEEDS and LISA R. KIRBY, individually as Trustees of the Gary Speeds and Lisa 17 Kirby Family Trust; GELB ENTERPRISES; GEORGE and PAMELA ZELLER, individually; 18 GEORGE and ROXANNE PELT, individually; GEORGE HERNANDEZ; GEORGE 19 LAWHEAD, Trustee of the George and Carole Lawhead Revocable Trust; GIRL SCOUTS OF 20 CALIFORNIA'S CENTRAL COAST; GLENN and LORI AHLBERG, individually; GORDON

21 and PATRICIA BLACK, individually; GRALAR, LLC; GRAYDON and HELEN HARRAH, 22 individually; GREGORY and MICHELE HAMMED, individually; GREGORY CAVETTE; 23 GREGORY GRANT and MARY KING, individually; HANS and ANNIKA GRUENN, 24 individually; HENDRIKA MARIA VON HECHT; HENRY and GENEVA OLIVA, individually; 25 HENRY and LESLIE SOHM, individually; HOWARD and IRENE HOOS, individually; HUGH 26 and LINDSAY THOMSON, individually; INTELL VENTURA, LLC; IRMA TRACY; JACKIE 27 M. SPRINGER, Trustee of the Jackie M. and Lanie Jo Springer Trust; JAMES and ANDREA 28 PENDLETON, individually; JAMES and GAYLE DAVID, individually; JAMES and STACI - 5 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 VALENCIA, individually; JAMES and SUE MILLS, individually; JAMES and TRISHA 2 PROUD, individually; JAMES and ZELDA CARR, individually; JAMES PECK; JAMES I. PIO, 3 Trustee of the James I. Pio Trust; JAN M. HIESTER, Trustee of the Jan M. Hiester 2014 Living 4 Trust; JANE E. HANCHETT, Trustee of the Hanchett Family Trust; JANE SPILLER, Trustee of 5 the Jane Spiller Trust; JANET LEWIS, Trustee of the Janet T. Lewis Family Trust; JANET 6 PECK, Trustee of the Janet Lee Peck Living Trust; JEANNETTE CURTIS; JEFFREY E. 7 FRANK, Trustee of the Frank Trust; JEFFREY TUBBS and LYNN DUBOWY DURAN, 8 individually; JENNIE SCOTT, Trustee of the Jennie Scott Family Trust; JENNIFER WARE and 9 JAMIE SELBY, individually; JEREMY AUGUST and ICOLE MARIE FERRO, individually; 10 JESSE WADSWORTH and SUSAN HYNDS, individually; JESUS CORNEJO and IDANIA 11 YUDITH CORNEJO, individually; JOAN KENTON, Trustee of the Joan Kenton Living Trust; 12 JOANNA POPE; JODY CALLEGARI; JOEL HERNANDEZ; JOHANNA COLLINS; JOHN 13 and LISA DILLARD, individually; JOHN and MARI ALLEN, individually; JOHN and NANCY 14 BEVANS, individually; JOHN and NILA VENTRESS, individually; JOHN EDWARD and 15 EVONNE LOUISE VACCA, individually; JOHN GUTIERREZ; JOHN MAZZOLA and APRIL 16 GOLDEN, individually; JOHN TAFT CORPORATION; JON HANSON; JONATHAN and 17 JACQUELINE PARKER, individually; JONATHAN and JULIE TEICHERT, individually; 18 JOSE JUAREZ and ANA VALENCIA, individually; JOSE VALADEZ and NORMA 19 HERNANDEZ, individually; JOSEPH PALMOUTSOS as Trustee of the Joseph Constantinos 20 Palmoutsos Living Trust; JOSEPH POLITO, Trustee of the Joseph R Polito 1989 Trust;

21 JOSHUA ANTELMAN; JOYCE FRENETTE; JUAN ESPINOZA and TRAVIS COKER, 22 individually; JUANA and HENRY MURILLO; individually; JUNE M. SPAR, Trustee of the 23 June M. Spar Living Trust; JUSTIN and RACHAEL JAYNE, individually; KAREN 24 MENDOZA, Trustee of the Vork Family Trust; KATHERINE PATTON and VIRGINIA 25 MCCONNELL, individually; KATHLEEN TURNER and ELIZABETH RENN, individually; 26 KAY BURNS; KEN COLLIN; KENNETH and MARIA BAKER, individually; KENNETH S. 27 COLLINS, Trustee of the Frank R. Walker, Jr. Trust; KENT and PATRICIA HARDLEY, 28 individually; KEVIN K. COX and MARY C. COX, individually as Trustees of the Cox Family - 6 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Trust; KIM JIRKA, Trustee of the Kim Jirka Trust; KONSTANTIN DEMIDOV; KYLE 2 BROWN; LANCE and DONELLE WOLESLAGLE, individually; LARRY and CECILIA 3 HICKOK, LARRY HUBENTHAL, individually and as Trustee of the Larry Hubenthal Living 4 Trust; individually; LASZLO and SHARON BIHARI, individually; LASZLO ENGELMAN, 5 Trustee of the Engeman Family Trust; LAUGHING DOG RANCH, LLC; LAVERNE M. 6 BROWNING; LAWRENCE and RACHEL CLEVENSON, individually; LEON and CECELIA 7 CARTER, individually; LEONARD FISCHER; LORENZO GAMA and YLDA CISNERO, 8 individually; LORETTA MAY WILLIAMS, aka LORETTA MAY BLACKBURN, Trustee of 9 the Loretta May Williams Revocable Living Trust; LUCILLE JANE CONFORTI and 10 RANDALL NORMAN KIRK, individually as Co-Trustees of the "Lucille Jane Conforti Trust"; 11 LYNN and ANN HENNE, individually; LYNN GOTCH and LINDA OLIVER, individually; 12 MANUEL and SANDY GARCIA, individually; MARILYN WALLACE, Trustee of the 13 MARILYN Wallace Separate Property Trust; MARIO AGUIRRE and PATRICE VERNAND, 14 individually; MARK and MEGAN STEFFY, individually; MARK ANTHONY and KIM MARIE 15 CRANE, individually; MARK ROBBINS, Trustee of the MARK ROBBINS Trust; MARK 16 THOMPSON; MARTIN and DARIAN O'BRIEN, individually; MARTIN and LINDA 17 GRAMCKOW, individually; MARTIN GRAMCKOW, Trustee of the Monika G. Huss 18 Irrevocable Trust, Trustee of the Karin W. Gramckow Irrevocable Trust, Trustee of the Kurt J. 19 Gramckow Irrevocable Trust; MARVEL PIERCE; MARYANN HEPP HILL, Trustee of the Hill 20 Family Trust; MARY BERGEN, Trustee of the Rosemary Hall Bergen Trust; MARY

21 MORRISON; MARY WALKART and WILLIAM HASTINGS, individually; MATILIJA 22 CANYON ALLIANCE; MATTHEW and CLAUDIA WILSON, individually; MATTHEW 23 ARREOLA; MATTHEW BOWE; MATTHEW DWYER and COLLEEN WALKER, 24 individually; MATTHEW LARREW and JORDANA KABAN, individually; MATTHEW 25 SIMON and AMANDA VINO, individually; MICHAEL and CAROL DAVIS, individually; 26 MICHAEL and CINDY BOEHM, individually; MICHAEL and HANNALORE GRESSER, 27 individually; MICHAEL and KATHY OGDEN, individually; MICHAEL and KIM REGAN, 28 individually; MICHAEL and MARIE MCTAVISH, individually; MICHAEL and PATRICIA - 7 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 MCWEENEY, individually; MICHAEL COGGINS JR. and CYNTHIA COGGINS, individually; 2 MICHAEL GREYNALD, Trustee of the Greynald Family Trust; MICHAEL L. ROCKHOLD, 3 Trustee of the Michael Rockhold Trust; MICHAEL TELLO; MICHELE WILLIS and 4 JOHANNA COLLINS, individually; MIGUEL A. MAYORGA, Trustee of the Edward R. 5 Mayorga Living Trust; MITCHAEL and RUBEENA BREESE, individually; MITCHELL and 6 ANA YOUNT, individually; MITCHELL and JOY DALBEY, individually; MITCHELL and 7 LISA MYERS, individually; NANCY MOORE, Trustee of the Nancy Anne Moore Separate 8 Property Trust; NIKOLAS and JULIA KRANKL, individually; OFFSHORE CRANE, INC.; 9 OFFSHORE CRANE and SERVICE COMPANY, INC.; OFFSHORE FACILITIES; OJAI 10 VALLEY CONSERVANCY; ORVILLE and MARION HERNVALL, individually; ORVILLE 11 and PAMELA HIBDON, individually; OSWALDO and NORMA RUIZ, individually; PACIFIC 12 TELEPHONE AND TELEGRAPH COMPANY; PAMELA WOOD; PATRIC and MARGARET 13 PEAKE, individually; PATRICIA and EDWARD LANSBERG, individually; PATRICIA 14 CUENOT; PATRICK and CATHY PAGNUSAT, individually; PAUL and ANGELA BOOTH, 15 individually; PAUL and ASHLEY RAMSEY, individually; PAUL and MARIA LOZANO, 16 individually; PAUL and MARTHA MEDLAR, individually; PAUL and OPAL SKAGGS, 17 individually; PETER and KELLI FREIBERG, individually; PETER and ROBIN SHEDLOSKY, 18 individually; PETER BROOKS and CARLA BROOKS, individually and as Trustees of the 19 Escoda Brooks Family Trust; PETER CAMBIER, Trustee of the Peter and Marilyn Cambier 20 Trust; PETER SCHEY, LLC; PEUVLIN VONG; PHILIP and DELIA SMITH, individually;

21 PHILIP FERRANTE JR. and NICOLE AVERSA-FERRANTE, individually; PHILIPPE 22 ROUSSEAU and KIMBERLY SHOBE, individually; PHYLLIS COURTNEY; RAFAEL 23 HERNANDEZ; RAMONA L. ANDREW, Trustee of the Ramona L. Andrews Trust; RANCHO 24 ARNAZ, LLC; RANCHO CASITAS, LLC; RANCHO SUENO, LLC; RAY and CAROLINA 25 GUILLEN, individually; RAYMOND and ANNETTE WEST, individually; RICHARD and 26 LAURA MANCILLA, individually; RICHARD and ALEXANDRA DUBEAU, individually; 27 RICHARD and CYNTHIA ROBINETT, individually; RICHARD BOLTON; RICHARD 28 MATHIEU and CLAUDIA HERRERA MATHIEU, individually; RICHARD MICHAEL and - 8 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 MARGARET KENNY, individually; RICHARD WILES and PEGGY CAREY, individually; 2 ROBERT ALAN and STACEY JEAN BOYD, individually; ROBERT and CAROLYN 3 JARBOE, individually; ROBERT and JUDITH CLARK, individually; ROBERT and NICKEY 4 GREGORY, individually; ROBERT and PATRICIA MCFALL, individually; ROBERT and 5 SUSAN BENNITT, individually; ROBERT and ANNA J. AURIC, individually as Trustees of 6 the Auric Revocable Trust of 1999; ROBERT LEVIN and LISA SOLINAS, individually; 7 ROBERT MARK and LORRAINE MELISA LOVATO, individually; ROBERT OCONNOR; 8 ROBERT PETRIN and BEATE SCHICKERLING, individually; ROBERT L. STONE, Trustee 9 of the Robert L. Stone Revocable Living Trust; ROBERT S. YOUNG, Trustee of the Young 10 Trust; RONALD and JANIS CALKINS, individually; RONALD KAPLAN and CYNTHIA 11 DANIELS, individually; RUDOLPH and CAROL SALDAMANDO, individually; RUSSELL 12 JAMES HALL, Trustee of the Russell James Hall Family Trust; SAM and DEBBIE TUCKER, 13 individually; SCOTT ALAN and EVA PRINCE WEISS, individually; SCOTT and AKI 14 FRESHMAN, individually; SCOTT and BERNADETTE KING, individually; SCOTT and 15 SARAH MCKAY, individually; SCOTT GREGORY EROCKSON and HANNAH BETH 16 GUZIK, individually; SCOTT R. JOHNSON and MARGARET BATES, individually; SERAFIN 17 CALDERON and BLANCA ORTIZ; individually; SHANE and AMY WATKINS, individually; 18 SHANE NASH; SHARON and BRUCE SPENCER, individually; SHARON BROWN, Trustee 19 of the Sharon Brown Living Trust; SHAUN and DAISY GARMAN, individually; SHIRLEY M. 20 PALMER, Trustee of the Shirley Palmer Revocable Trust; SKYNEST, LLC; SOCIETE

21 D’INVESTISSEMENT IMMOBILIERS ET FINANCIERS FRANCO-ALLEMAND, a French 22 corporation; STANLEY STEPHEN ROSLANSKY and LINDA ROSLANSKY, individually as 23 Trustees of the Roslansky Family Trust; STEPHEN and CARIN KALLY, individually; 24 STEPHEN and CINDY BARRACK, individually; STEPHEN CARR and DEBRA GILL, 25 individually; STEPHEN M. JOHNSON, Trustee of the Stephen M. Johnson Living Trust; 26 STEPHEN SANFORD; STEPHEN ZANE FRASER; STUART and NANCY RUPP, 27 individually; SUDARSHAN GAUTAM; SUSAN GARY; SUSAN M. RALPH, Trustee of the 28 Ralph Trust; SUSAN YARNELL; SUSHMA GUJRAL; SUZANNE RHODES, Trustee of the - 9 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Bateman-Rhodes Family Trust; TAMARRA BARBEY; TANE CHARLES ARNOLD, 2 individually, and as Trustee of the Tane C. Arnold 2006 Living Trust; TEEN CHALLENGE OF 3 , INC; TERRA CROWLEY; TERRANCE O'CONNOR and 4 KATHY FRANKLIN, individually; TERRIE LONGO; THE BAPTISTE FOUNDATION; THE 5 OJAI VALLEY LAND CONSERVANCY; THEODORE and JUDY LUCAS, individually; 6 THEODORE and NORMA SCHNEIDER, individually; THEODORE and TRACY MANDRYK, 7 individually; THEODORE and PEARL MALOS, individually and as Trustees of the Malos 8 Family Trust; THOMAS and CHRISTINE REED, individually; THOMAS and NIKKI YOUNG, 9 individually; TIMOTHY and NICOLE BECKETT, individually; TOBIAS and TANIA 10 PARKER, individually; TODD HENARD and KIBHI MARIE HENARD, individually; 11 TROPICO, LLC; VICTOR and SHERYL SANCHEZ, individually; VICTORIA and JOHN 12 JUNKIN, individually; VIDA VIDA, Trustee of the VIDA FAMILY Trust; VIJAY and NEETA 13 PATEL, individually; VIRGINIA I. WILLIAMSON, individually and as Trustee of Trust of 14 Virginia I. Williamson; VIRGINIA TREVINO; WALID A. ALAWAR, Trustee of the Walid A. 15 Alawar Living Trust; WARREN HEATH; WILLIAM and CHERYL MEADE, individually; 16 WILLIAM and HELEN PECK, individually; WILLIAM and IRENE SNIVELY, individually; 17 WILLIAM and KIMBRA CARNAGHE, individually; WILLIAM and PAULA STEVENS, 18 individually; WILLIAM LOUGHBORO; WILLIAM STARR; YONG YI; YVETTE MARIE and 19 DANIEL JOSEPH SINOHUI, individually; ZACHARY and DIANE TOTTEN, individually 20 [collectively, “Riparian Landowners”];

21 22 1300 SHIPPEE LANE, LLC; 3584 CALLE MORENO, LLC; AARON and ANGELA 23 HOEKSTRA, individually; ABEL and LOURDES CARRANZA, individually; ACSLAYTON, 24 LLC; ADAM CASEY and BRITTANY CHISUM, individually; ADAM DISTL, JR. and 25 BARBARA B. DISTL, individually as Trustees of the Adam Distl, Jr. And Barbara B. Distl 1998 26 Revocable Trust; ADRIAN OGDEN; AERA ENERGY, LLC; AJR INVESTMENT 27 PARTNERSHIP, LP; ALAN and DEBORAH SHARON, individually; ALAN and LESLIE 28 CONNELL, individually; ALAN and MARY KIRBY, individually; ALAN and SUSAN ECKER, - 10 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 individually; ALAN WALBRIDGE and DOROTHY FAY WALBRIDGE, individually; 2 ALBERTO and ADRIANA MONTANO, individually; ALBERTO and HILDA ZAMORA, 3 individually; ALBINE HOPCUS and ALVA LYDIA HOPCUS, individually as Trustees of the 4 Al and Alva Trust; ALFONSO and ALEJANDRA LIMON, individually; ALLAN and JANIS 5 PARKHURST, individually; ALLAN and KATHARINE PARIGIAN, individually; ALLAN and 6 MARY DOANE, individually; ALLEN VAIL; ALVARO and ELVA RUIZ, individually; 7 ALVIN and CLAUDIA CUNNINGHAM, individually; ANA CROSS, Trustee of the ANA 8 CROSS FAMILY Trust; ANDRE KEUNZLI and FABRIENNE KEUNZLI-MONARD, 9 individually; ANDREW and MELISSA MACCALLA, individually; ANDREW and REBECCA 10 CHANDLER, individually; ANDREW and SHARON ENGEL, individually; ANGELA JAYNE 11 GARDNER and JOHN PERCIVAL MAWSON, individually as Trustees of the Pleasant Avenue 12 Living Trust; ANITA J. DIAZ; ANN H. DONLON, Trustee of the Ann H. Donlon Revocable 13 Trust; ANNA ARCHER; ANNA KIRKWOOD; ANNE and DANIEL GOLDSTEIN, 14 individually; ANSON B. THACHER and ANNE F. THACHER, individually as Trustees of the 15 A. and A. Thacher Living Trust; ANTHONY BECCHIO and DENISE HEIMO, individually; 16 ANTHONY MASIEL; ANTONIO ESPINO and MARIA TORRES, individually; ARNE 17 ANSELM and MICHELLE VELDERRAIN, individually; ARNE ANSELM, Trustee of the 18 Velderrain M. Trust; ASHLEY and VICTORIA EDWARDS, individually; BALDEMAR 19 ALCANTAR and MICAELA ORTIZ ALCANTAR, individually; BARBARA A. 20 FITZGERALD, Trustee of the Fitzgerald 1994 Trust; BARBARA BONSIGNORI; BARBARA

21 CHEN LOWENTHA, Trustee of the 2017 Barbara Kay Chen Lowenthal Revocable Trust; 22 BARBARA HALL, Trustee of the Barbara Hall Living Trust; BARNARD PROPERTIES, LLC; 23 BART KENNEDY; BARTON KENNEDY; BERNARD MARTIN; BETH E. LINDLEY; 24 BETTYANN SESSING; BIG BLACK DOG, LLC; BLAZE BUONPANE; BRADLEY and 25 ANDREA ROE, individually; BRADLEY and IVELOU PANTOSKEY, individually; 26 BRANDON and TRESSA KAHLER, individually; BRANDON and KELSIE SCHNEIDER, 27 individually and as Trustees of the Brandon Schneider and Kelsie Simms-Schneider Family 28 Trust; BREAL and KAREN ROWE, individually; BRENDAN RICHARD and CHRISTA LEE - 11 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 DAWN FREEMAN, individually; BRENT and PAMELA LAMO, individually; BRETT and 2 LYNN WILSON, individually; BRETT CUNNINGHAM; BRETT NICHOLSON and NAN 3 DAVIS, individually; BRIAN and CYNTHIA MCDANIEL, individually; BRIAN and ERIN 4 EDWARDS, individually; BRIAN and JEAN HARRISON, individually; BRIAN and MARIE 5 HAASE, individually; BRIAN and SIOBHAN CALVIN, individually; BRIAN A. SCHAFFELS; 6 BRIAN OSBORNE and KIRSTEN HINRICHS, individually; BRITTANY and ALAN 7 FLETCHER, individually; BRUCE and LESLIE BOUCHE, individually; BRUCE and 8 VIRGINIA HIBBERD, individually; BRUCE C. BROCKMAN and BRIDGET TSAO- 9 BROCKMAN, individually as Trustees of the Tsao Brockman Family Trust; BRYAN and 10 NICOLE CRAWFORD, individually; BULMARO and ALFONSA PENA, individually; BYRON 11 and JENNIFER GREENE, individually; BYRON RADER and MYRA TOTH, individually; CAL 12 B. LAND CO., LLC; CALATLANTIC GROUP INC.; CAMP RAMAH IN CALIFORNIA INC.; 13 CARL and JUDITH BELL, individually; CARL and LEIGH HYNDMAN, individually; CARL 14 GADDIS and ANNA HICKS, individually; CARLA DENNIS, Trustee of the Carla D. Dennis 15 Trust; CARLA MELSON and CARLA J. MELSON, individually as Trustees of the Carla J. 16 Melson Revocable Living Trust; CARMEN and CAROLINA MURILLO, individually; CAROL 17 MARQUEZ-OLSON, Trustee of the Carol Marquez-Olson Trust; CAROL VESECKY, Trustee 18 of the Carol B. Vesecky Revocable Living Trust; CAROLINE TURNER, Trustee of the Turner 19 Survivors Trust; CAROLYN BOWMAN, Trustee of the Carolyn Bowman 2008 Trust; 20 CAROLYN HUISH; CARYN MOLINELLI; CATHERINE LANCASTER; CATHERINE

21 SELLMAN; CATHERINE SMITH, Trustee of the Catherine L. Smith Revocable Trust; CESAR 22 and DAVIENNE GUERRA, individually; CESAR JIMENEZ and AURA MINERA, 23 individually; CHAARENNE TORRIS and RAYMOND BRADLEY, individually; SOUTHERN 24 CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF SEVENTH DAY ADVENTISTS; CHAD CARPER; CHAD 25 RESS and STEPHANIE WASHBURN, individually; CHAD VICK, Trustee of the Chad C. Vick 26 Trust; CHARLENE VAN DEUSEN; CHARLES and DEANA SHERRY, individually; 27 CHARLES and JO BENNETT, individually; CHARLES G. BARNETT, SUCCESSOR Trustee 28 of the "Barnett Family Exemption Equivalent Trust"; CHARLES L. HOFF and KATHLEEN D. - 12 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 HOFF, Co-Trustees of the Hoff Revocable Trust; CHARLES MONN and ELENA HALE, 2 individually; CHARLES R. RUDD and LOLA L. RUDD, Trustees Under the Charles R. Rudd 3 and Lola L. Rudd Trust; CHRISTIE MATTULL, Trustee of the Christie Lynn Mattull Trust; 4 CHRISTINE and DONALD BOWEN, individually; CHRISTINE GOLDEN; CHRISTOPHER 5 and ANNA RHODA, individually; CHRISTOPHER and GILLIAN BORGESON, individually; 6 CHRISTOPHER and SHELAGH DUKE, individually; CHRISTOPHER CORSONES, Trustee of 7 the Christopher Corsones Living Trust; CHRISTOPHER MCGUIRE; CHRISTOPHER 8 SEWELL; CHRISTOPHER WEINER and DAMIAN BOURGUET, individually; CINDY 9 BURKHART, Trustee of the Cindy Burkhart Living Trust; CITY OF OJAI; CLAUDIA FARR, 10 Trustee of the Sam S. Farr And Claudia S. Farr Trust; CLAUDIA WUNDERLICH, Trustee of the 11 Claudia A Wunderlich Trust; CLEMENTINE TURNER, Trustee of the Clementine Turner 12 Living Trust; CODY GREEN; CODY STEVENS; CONNIE ANAISE; CONNIE and MARK 13 CLINE, individually as Trustee of the Mark Terry Cline Family Trust; CONSTANCE EATON; 14 CORY and NICHOLAS WINGATE, individually; COUNTY OF VENTURA; CRAIG and 15 STEPHANIE GARDNER, individually; CRAIG YOUNG and DANIEL POLING, individually; 16 CULBERT FAMILY PARTNERSHIP; CURTIS and CHRISTINA TOLMIE, individually; 17 CYNTHIA ELLIS and PAMELA THOMAS, individually; DAJ PROPERTIES, LLC; DAMIAN 18 and LORIE VOS, individually; DAMON and ANNE BRINK, individually; DANIEL and 19 ADAYA WALSH, individually; DANIEL and DEBORAH HOYT, individually; DANIEL and 20 ELIZABETH GEORGE, individually; DANIEL and ELIZABETH MCLAUGHLIN,

21 individually; DANIEL and JANE KELLY, individually; DANIEL and LYDIA RUARK, 22 individually; DANIEL and RALPH FAIRBANKS, individually; DANIEL and TOMICA MORA, 23 individually; DANIEL and YOKO MCSWEENEY, individually; DANIEL CHRYNKO; 24 DANIEL CRANE; DANIEL H. I. and WILLIAM D. MOSES JR., individually as Trustees of the 25 William D. Moses, Jr. Separate Trust No. 1; DANIEL HULTGEN, Trustee of the Hultgen Living 26 Trust; DANNY HAAR and MARISKA DE FEITER, individually; DARRELL RALSTON, 27 Trustee of the Darrell Anthony Ralston 2009 Revocable Trust; DAVE and KATHLEEN 28 TARRATS, individually; DAVID and BEVERLY FULTON, individually; DAVID and CAROL - 13 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 CINTRON, individually; DAVID and DEBORAH TODD, individually; DAVID and DONNA 2 BERGER, individually; DAVID and ELIZABETH SILVA, individually; DAVID and 3 FERESCHTA SINCLAIR, individually; DAVID and KAREN BRUBAKER, individually; 4 DAVID and KATHLEEN OSTBY, individually; DAVID and LAURA MEISCH, individually; 5 DAVID and LAURIE MAHAN, individually; DAVID and MEGHAN SANDOVAL, 6 individually; DAVID and MINDY BENEZRA, individually; DAVID and PEGGY 7 STANWOOD, individually; DAVID and SANDRA MURILLO, individually; DAVID and 8 SHANNON RICHARD, individually; DAVID and SHARRON SPARKS, individually; DAVID 9 and STEPHANIE BERGER, individually; DAVID and TONI JOHNSON, individually; DAVID 10 COREY and JEAN SCHOLES, individually; DAVID E. PRESSEY and AGNES E. PRESSEY, 11 individually as Trustees of the David E. And Agnes E. Pressey Family Trust; DAVID KILLE and 12 SHANNON FREW, individually; DAVID L. GARBER and CYNTHIA GARBER, individually 13 as Trustees of the Garber Trust; DAVID ORBACH and EVA ARAUJO, individually; DAVID 14 STANLEY and MONICA BEDNAR STANLEY, individually; DAWN and BARCLAY HOPE, 15 individually; DE and JACQUE PISCIOTTA, individually; DEAN and GLORIA VADNAIS, 16 individually; DEAN and LORINDA STRONG, individually; DEANNA GONZALES, 17 individually; DEIRDRE LYNDS, individually; DELAVAN C. GARST and SHARON D. 18 GARST, individually as Trustees of the Delavan and Sharon Garst Family Trust; DELL and 19 ANNE MERCER, individually; DELORES and JERRY BERLIN, individually; DENISE 20 WIZMAN, as Trustee of the Denise Wizman Revocable Trust; DENNIS and CHERYL JACOBS,

21 individually; DENNIS and NADINE CORTE, individually; DEREK MEEK; DEVON and 22 JILLIANN COLLINGE, individually; DIANA ENGLE, Trustee of the Diana L Engle Revocable 23 Trust; DIANA PERON, Trustee of the Diana C Peron Living Trust; DIANA SYVERTSON, 24 Trustee of the Diana Syvertson Living Trust; DIANA TRENT, Trustee of the Diana Trent Living 25 Trust; DIANE and WILLIAM CLEGG, individually; DIANNE MCCOURTNEY, Trustee of the 26 Dianne Louise McCourtney Trust; DOLORES KEITH; DOMINIC HABIBI; DONALD and 27 CLARA TENPENNY, individually; DONALD BROSNAC and TWILA CARLSEN, 28 individually; DONALD DAVIS; DONALD G. and SUSAN B. DAVIS, individually as Trustees - 14 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 of the Donald G. And Susan B. Davis Revocable Family Trust of 1997; DONIS MONTOYA JR. 2 and TERESITA MONTOYA, individually; DONNA DEITCH, Trustee of the DONNA E. 3 DEITCH Trust; DONNA EPSTEIN, Trustee of the Epstein Survivors' Trust, Trustee of the 4 Epstein Marital Trust, and Trustee of the Epstein Bypass Trust; DOROTHY and JAMES 5 KEHOE, individually; DORTHEA KECK; DOUGLAS and ANN PARENT, individually; 6 DOUGLAS and CLAUDIA WEBBER, individually; DOUGLAS and ELISABETH VERNAND, 7 individually; DOUGLAS and KATHLEEN LEIGHTON, individually; DOUGLAS and MOIRA 8 VOLPI, individually; DOUGLAS DRAPER; DOUGLAS WASSON, Trustee of the Wasson 9 Trust; DUSTIN BEILKE; ED and LINDA COLBY, individually; EDSON TAFT, Trustee of the 10 Edson B. Taft Revocable Trust; EDWARD and DEBORAH GUERRA, individually; EDWARD 11 and LAURA SAVALA, individually; EDWARD and NANCY DENNIS, individually; 12 EDWARD and NANCY NECKER, individually; EDWARD and ROBERTA WALSH, 13 individually; EDWARD DUNN and JUDITH SHELBY DUNN, individually; EDWARD 14 PRESSEY; EDWIN NORRIS PROCTER, Trustee of the "E. Norris Procter Living Trust"; 15 EILAM BYLE, Trustee of the Eilam Byle Living Trust; EILEEN STERLING, Trustee of the 16 Eileen M. Sterling Revocable Trust; EILEEN WALKER; EL SERENO 1225, LLC; ELAIENE 17 KEELEY, Trustee of the Elaiene Keeley Trust; ELAINE FERGUSON; ELI and JESSICA 18 NEIDERHISER; ELIA ALDAPA; ELIZABETH BAUER, Trustee of the Elizabeth A Bauer 19 Trust; ELLEN LEOPOLD; ELMER and JOAN SWIFT; EMILY BENSON and LISA MARTEL, 20 individually; EMILY CLAY and MATTHEW GOODMAN, individually; ERBAY and VELDA

21 GARCIA, individually; ERIC and ARLENE SCHWERDTFEGER, individually; ERIC and 22 JOLENE HARRINGTON, individually; ERIC BUSH and CRAIG YOUNG, individually; ERIC 23 DILKS, Trustee of the Eric M. Dilks 2004 Revocable Trust; ERIC GOODE; ERIC MOORE; 24 ERIC ROSENBERG; ERNEST and DOROTHY NICHOLS, individually; ERNEST 25 THORNSBERRY, Trustee of the Ernest Thornsberry Revocable Trust; ESPERANZA and 26 SANDRA GUERRERO, individually; EUGENIJUS VALIULIS, Trustee of the Eugenijus 27 Valiulis Revocable Living Trust; EUSEBIO and LORI NAVARRO, individually; EVELYN 28 BARAN, Trustee of the Evelyn F Baran Personal Residence Trust; EZEQUIEL and AMBER - 15 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 MONARREZ, individually; FELIX and DELMY GARCIA, individually; FERNANDO 2 PORRAS; FEROZ and MONA ZAIDI, individually; FINCH FARMS, LLC; MEREWETHER 3 JUDSON, LLC; FLOYD and CHARLENE FITZGERALD, individually; FLOYD EUGENE 4 WIANCKO and HIROKO WIANCKO, Trustees of the Wiancko Family Trust; FOREST HOME, 5 INC.; FORTUNE REAL ESTATE 888, LLC; FRANCIS and SHAUNA LONGSTAFF, 6 individually; FRANCISCO and ANGELICA VALLES, individually; FRANK and LILA 7 SHELTREN, individually; FRANK C. URIAS and EVANGELINE S. URIAS, individually as 8 Trustees of the Urias Family Trust; FRANK CHAROLLA; FRANK EDWARD SHELTREN, 9 JR., aka FRANK E. SHELTREN and RITA CHERYL SHELTREM, individually as Trustees of 10 the Sheltren Family Trust; FRED and CARINE FISHER, individually; FRED and DONNA 11 STEVENS, individually; FRED KRAMER and MICHAELA WATKINS, individually; 12 FREDERIC DEVAULT; FREDERICK and LAURA FULMER, individually; FREDERICK 13 SLOMAN and NORDI HINTZE, individually; FREDRICK and ROXANNE BAKER, 14 individually; FUTURE MHPS, LLC; GABRIEL and MARGARITA MENDOZA, individually; 15 GALE and BERNABE GAONA JR., individually; GARY and CHARI PETROWSKI, 16 individually; GARY and COLLEEN FRY, individually; GARY and JOLENE CLARKE, 17 individually; GARY and JUDITH STEVER, individually; GARY and PATRICIA TUCKER, 18 individually; GARY and TERESA DOWNARD, individually; GENE and PATTY SAITO, 19 individually; GENNEVA MASCHLER and RICHARD YACIUK, individually; GEOFFREY and 20 PAULA CLARKE, individually; GEOFFREY BROWN and STEPHANIE GIBSON,

21 individually; GEORGE and LINDA BOSTON, individually; GEORGE and LYNN MALONE, 22 individually; GEORGE and MARGARET MELTON, individually; GEORGE and SIGRID 23 BRESSLER, individually; GEORGE STUART; GERALD and DARLENE CARLSON, 24 individually; GERARD LINSMEIER; GERBEN and JILL HOEKSMA, individually; GINO 25 LYNCH; GLENN MYERS, Trustee of the Glenn C. Myers Family Trust; GORDON and TERRY 26 HANUSEK, individually; GORDON GIBBONS, Trustee of the Gordon R. Gibbons Living Trust; 27 GRANT KEMP; GREG and JULIE TEBO, individually; GREGG and ROSIE DIERICKX, 28 individually; GREGG OLSON, Trustee of the Gregg W. Olson Revocable Trust; GREGORY and - 16 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 KAORI GOLDEN, individually; GREGORY and MARTHA LEPINE, individually; GREGORY 2 and SARAH DELVECCHIO, individually; GREGORY and SUSAN GILBERT, individually; 3 GREGORY and SUSAN IGNACIO, individually; GREGORY and SUZANNE COMBS; 4 GREGORY HERAS and ROZANNE BONAVITO, individually; GREGORY JOHNSON; 5 GREGORY N. PIMSTONE and LAURYN B. HARRIS, individually as Trustees of the Pimstone 6 Family Trust; GRIFFIN and NICOLE WILLIAMSON, individually; GUDAZ, LLC; GUY and 7 SHERI FLASCH, individually; GUY BRATTON; H and BEVERLY LEARD, individually; 8 HACIENDA LADERA, LLC; HANK and ALANA GARCIA, individually; HANS and EILEEN 9 VAN KOPPEN, individually; HARALD WAGNER; HARLAN KOSSOW; HARRISON HILL 10 and LAUREN WILSON, individually; HARRY and MARILYN LEHR, individually; HARRY 11 JOE; HAYDEN and RAQUEL WHITE, individually; HECTOR and ROCIO TORRES, 12 individually; HEIDI C. KURTZ, Trustee of the Gunild Walsh Seadrift Qprt FBO Heidi C. Kurtz; 13 HELIBERTA VALENCIA; HELP OF OJAI, INC.; HENRY and MOIRA TARMY, individually; 14 HERMANN and GAY THOMSEN, individually; H. H. LEARD and BEVERLY LEARD, 15 individually as Trustees of the Leard Family Trust; HICKEY BROS LAND CO. INC.; HOLLY 16 BASSUK; HOWARD and RUTH MILLER, individually; HOWARD ALTMAN, Trustee of the 17 Gerta Maritz Trust; HOYT TAROLA; IAN and CAROL ATKINSON, individually; IGNACIO 18 and ROSE VEGA, individually; IMELDA MARES, Trustee of the Imelda Mares Trust; 19 INDUSTRIAL VENTURA; INTEGRITAS OJAI, LLC; IRMA CRUZ; IRSHAD and LINDA 20 HAQUE, individually; ISIDRO SANCHEZ; J INVESTMENTS; J MCGLINCHEY; JACK and

21 MARIE KENTON, individually; JACK and SIMONE PATTERSON, individually; JACK and 22 VERNA TURBYVILLE, individually; JACOB and ANJA ZIMMERMAN, individually; 23 JACQUELINE DORFMAN, Trustee of the Jacqueline Dorfman Revocable Living Trust; 24 JACQUELINE URBAND; JAKOB and MARIANNE VOS, individually; JAMES and ALISA 25 VARNEY, individually; JAMES and DANIELA CASEY, individually; JAMES and DORI 26 SANDEFER, individually; JAMES and JANET LECROY, individually; JAMES and LAURA 27 FERNANDEZ, individually; JAMES and MARYETTA SANDERS, individually; JAMES and 28 PENNY HARVEY, individually; JAMES and RANDI CATLETT, individually; JAMES and - 17 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 WENDY OSHER, individually; JAMES DATA; JAMES FINLEY, Trustee of the James And M. 2 Reen Finley Family Trust; JAMES FINCH, Trustee of the Finch Family Trust; JAMES J. FINCH 3 and LORRAINE HOLVE FINCH, individually as Trustees of the James J. Finch and Loraine 4 Holve Finch Living Trust; JAMES PAUL FINCH; JAMES KIRK and JACELYN HAYES, 5 individually; JAMES SELMAN, Trustee of the JAMES C. SELMAN REVOCABLE INTER 6 VIVOS Trust; JAMES W. COULTAS and MARGARET COULTAS, Trustees of the James A. 7 And Margaret H. Coultas Intervivos Trust; TERRY COULTAS WILSON; JAMES W. 8 COULTAS Trustee of the Coultas Living Trust; JAN and PRISCILLA GRANADE, individually; 9 JANE MCCORD, Trustee of the Jane Ann Mccord Living Trust; JANET MCGINNIS, Trustee of 10 the Janet Karen Mcginnis Trust; JANICE and JESSE HILLESTAD, individually; JANICE 11 HALL, Trustee of the HALL Trust; JANIS LONG NICHOLAS and JESS E. LONG, individually 12 as Co-Trustees of the Long Family Trust; JASON and JENE LOOMIS, individually; JASON and 13 KATHRYN HEADLEY, individually; JASON and LANA SPEAR, individually; JASON 14 LOOMIS; JASPER and JESSICA JONES, individually; JAYNE PENDERGAST, Trustee of the 15 2014 Jayne E Pendergast Trust; JEFF and CHEREE SIMONS, individually; JEFF and DESIREE 16 WILBY, individually; JEFF MABRY; JEFFERIE SKAGGS and TIMOTHY BUNCE, 17 individually; JEFFREY and DENISE HELM, individually; JEFFREY and DONNA MEYER, 18 individually; JEFFREY and HOLLY LIEBER, individually; JEFFREY JENSON; JEFFREY 19 KENTON, Trustee of the Jeffrey T. Kenton 2004 Revocable Living Trust; JEFFREY S. BACON, 20 Trustee of the Villa Nero Trust; JEFFREY WEINSTEIN; JEFFRY and FIONA POUGHER,

21 individually; JENNIFER KISTLER, Trustee of the Jennifer L Kistler Trust; JEREMY and 22 BRITTANIA RENNIE, individually; JERI LEONARD; JEROME H. HITTLEMAN and LYNNE 23 M. GOLDFARB, Trustees of the Jerome H. Hittleman And Lynne M. Goldfarb Revocable 2016 24 Trust; JERRY DEAN MINER and GERALDINE ANN MINER, Trustees of the Miner Trust; 25 JESS EARL LONG; JESSIE STRICCHIOLA and ROSEMARY GARRISON, individually as 26 Trustees of the Phoenix Revocable Trust; JESUS and MARIA RAMOS, individually; JILL 27 OLIVARES, Trustee of the Jill Ann Olivares Revocable Living Trust; JIMMY and THERESA 28 RAMIREZ, individually; JLB RANCHO VISTA, LLC; JOAN GEDDES and JOHN SALUPPO, - 18 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 individually; JOAN ROBLES; JOANN BENSON, Trustee of the Joann Alva Benson Revocable 2 Living Trust; JOANNE BARNES, Trustee of the Barnes Family Trust; JOEL FOX and 3 JENNIFER DAY, individually; JOEL VUYLSTEKE, Trustee of the Country Club Trust; 4 JOHANNA RAE LONG; JOHN and A. ELROD, individually; JOHN and ALITEA 5 MARUSZEWSKI, individually; JOHN and CRYSTAL PEAKES, individually; JOHN and 6 JANIS NICHOLAS, individually; JOHN and LUCILLE ELROD, individually; JOHN and 7 MONICA HARTMANN, individually; JOHN and NORMA CURTIS, individually; JOHN and 8 PARRIS COLLINS, individually; JOHN and PATRICIA ESSICK, individually; JOHN and 9 TONYA PERALTA, individually; JOHN and VICTORIA BORTOLUSSI, individually; JOHN 10 BATTEL, Trustee of the John J Battel Living Trust; JOHN BROOMFIELD, Trustee of the John 11 Nicholas Broomfield Trust; JOHN F. JOHNSTON and KATHERINE M. JOHNSTON, 12 individually as Trustees of the John Fraser Johnston Family Trust; JOHN HAIGH; JOHN 13 KERTIS; JOHN MUTLOW; JOHN PACE, Trustee of the John Brice Pace Family Trust; JOHN 14 RICHARDSON; JOHN VINEYARD; JOHN WARNER and JENNIFER DUNN, individually; 15 JOHN WILLINGHAM; JOHN WINSPEAR; JOHN YOUNG; JONATHAN WONG and JAN 16 KOMURA, individually; JOSE and IMELDA HURTADO, individually; JOSE and LISA 17 MENDEZ, individually; JOSE ARREOLA JR. and PAOLA CARRENO, individually; JOSE 18 OLVERA and ALMA VALENCIANO, individually; JOSEPH and DRENDA PLEDGER, 19 individually; JOSEPH LYNN and ELVIRA LILLY BARTHELEMY, individually and Trustees 20 of the Joseph Lynn Barthelemy and Elvira Lilly Barthelemy 2002 Family Trust; JOSEPH and

21 KATHLEEN LASALLE, individually; JOSEPH and MICHELLE HARWELL, individually; 22 JOSEPH and NINA NEULIGHT, individually; JOSEPH and SHIRLEY GHOLSON, 23 individually; JOSEPH LAM; JOSEPH RANDALL, Trustee of the Joseph Darden Randall 24 Revocable Trust; JOSEPH RESEIGH; JOSEPH TOOKER; JOSHUA and JENNIFER 25 GOLDSTEIN, individually; JOSHUA MOREAU; JOYCE and FRANK PATOTA, individually; 26 JUAN and GLORIA ESTRADA, individually; JUAN and MARIA MARTINEZ, individually; 27 JUDITH REICHMAN and HAROLD BROWN, individually; JULIANNE BLOOMER and 28 PHILIP RABE, individually; JULIE CENTENO; JULIO LUNA and DEBBIE LUN, individually; - 19 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 JUNE SEARS, Trustee of the June Katherine Sears Living Trust; JUPETO PROPERTIES, LLC; 2 KAC LLC; KAREN L. HANSON and LAWRENCE S. HANSON, Trustees of the Hanson L.S. 3 Revocable Living Trust; KAREN PHIPPS, Trustee of the Phipps Family Trust; KARIN DRON, 4 Trustee of the Boyd S. Dron and Karin K. Dron Joint Living Trust; KARIN L. JAMES, Trustee 5 of the James Family Trust; KARL and BEVERLEY MALLETTE, individually; KATHARINE 6 and JOHN BROESAMLE, individually; KATHLEEN and ADAM MORRISON, individually; 7 KATHLEEN and THOMAS GERMAN, individually; KATHLEEN BACHELOR; KATHLEEN 8 NOLAN, Trustee of the Kathleen Ann Nolan Revocable 2006 Family Trust; KATHRYN 9 BARTHOLOMEW, Trustee of the Kathryn Oconnor Bartholomew Living Trust; KATHY 10 ALDERMAN; KATZ PINCETL ORCHARD, LLC; KAY DORNBUSCH, Trustee of the 11 Dornbusch Family Living Trust; KEITH and ANAHID JEWETT, individually; KEITH and 12 ROBIN LAWSON, individually; KEITH and VICTORIA NIGHTINGALE, individually; 13 KELLEY and JOHN DYER IV, individually; KELVIN DODD and DEBORAH GOMEZ, 14 individually; KENETT NIESSEN; KENNETH and ANNE BOYDSTON, individually; 15 KENNETH and BRENDA WHITTEKER, individually; KENNETH and CAROL FERGESON, 16 individually; KENNETH and ELIZABETH GRUBER, individually; KENNETH and LAURA 17 BROWN, individually; KENNETH and MICHAEL BALLARD, individually; KENNETH and 18 SARAH VAN DYKE, individually; KENNETH MORGAN; KENNETH VADNAIS; KERN 19 COUNTY; KEVIN and ASLI RUF, individually; KEVIN and JENNIFER WHITE, individually; 20 KEVIN and JOANNE OLSLAND, individually; KEVIN and JODI DUNN, individually;

21 KHALED A. AL-AWAR and SHERYL L. AL-AWAR, individually as Trustees of the K. and S. 22 Al-Awar Family Trust; KIKI LYON, Trustee of the Kiki Lyon Living Trust; KIM HANNA, 23 Trustee of the Hanna Family Trust; KRISTAN ALTIMUS; KURT and DAYNA 24 ROGGENSTROH, individually; KURT and LUISA NEHER, individually; KURT PATRICK 25 ZIERHUT and STEPHANIE LEE ZIERHUT, Co-Trustees of the Living Trust of Kurt Patrick 26 Zierhut and Stephanie Lee Zierhut; LANSPRING, LP; LARRY and JOYCE HEATH, 27 individually; LARRY DAVIS; LARRY HUBENTHAL, Trustee of the Larry Hubenthal Living 28 Trust; LARRY NEFF, Trustee of the Larry Neff Trust; LAS ENCINAS MOBILE HOME PARK; - 20 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 LAURA B. PECK and ANDREW D. VILES, individually as Trustees of the William L. and 2 LAURA B. PECK Trust - Marital Trust; LAURA GREEN, Trustee of the Green Survivors Trust; 3 LAURIE JOHNSON, Trustee of the Laurie A. Johnson Living Trust; LAURIE SMITH; 4 LAWRENCE and SHARON MCMILLAN, individually; LAWRENCE I and PATRICIA A. 5 HARTMANN, individually as Trustees of the Larry and Pat Hartmann Family Trust; LEE and 6 JANET CASSEL, individually; LEE FITZGERALD, Trustee of the Lee I Fitzgerald 2007 7 Revocable Living Trust; LEE LEBECK; LEE ROSENBAUM, Trustee of the Chief Cornerstone 8 Trust; LEON and CAROLINE PAHLE, individually; LEONARD PETITT and KAY ROLFE, 9 individually; LESLEE and TERRY GUSTAFSON, individually; LESLIE MCCLEARY; 10 LESTER L. and LINDA L. BARBEE, individually as Trustees of the Lester L. Barbee and Linda 11 L. Barbee Joint Revocable Living Trust; LIANA HARP and NATHAN JONES, individually; 12 LILIAN RUVALCABA; LINDA CHAPMAN, Trustee Linda of the Jean Chapman Living Trust; 13 LINDA GRIFFIN; LINDA MCLAUGHLIN, Trustee of the Linda Landrieu McLaughlin Living 14 Trust; LINDA OLIVER, Trustee of the Linda A Oliver 2005 Revocable Living Trust; LIPKA 15 RICHARD, Trustee of the Lorraine Trust; LISA LOPEZ and BRIAN MERRILL, individually; 16 LISA SMITH and NATHANIEL COX, individually; LLOYD SMITH; LOGAN and MISTY 17 HAGEGE, individually; LOGAN and TIFFANY GOULD, individually; LOIS STONE 18 ERBURU, as Trustee of the Surviving Spouse's Trust Created in the Robert and Lois Erburu 19 Living Trust; LON and MARGARETA KIRKGAARD, individually; LONGHORN LANE, LLC; 20 LORENE CLEARY; LORI SCHLOREDT; LOU and BARTON MATTHEWS, individually;

21 LOUIS and IRENE GUTIERREZ, individually; LOUIS PRICE; LOUISE and GARY CULVER, 22 individually; LOUISE KONSTANZER, Trustee of the Ron and Louise Konstanzer Family Trust; 23 LOUISE TINDLE, SOLE Trustee of the "Bypass Trust" Created Under The Tindle Trust; LUIS 24 HERRERA and KIMBERLY OYAMA, individually; LUPE MILNER, Trustee of the Lupe 25 Milner Family Trust; LYDIA JIMENEZ; LYLE and CECILIA HALLBLOM, individually; 26 LYNDON HEBENSTREIT; LYNN COLEMAN; LYNN PIKE, Trustee of the Lynn 2016 Trust; 27 LYSIANE WALLIS; M. SNYDER; MALCOLM and BRENDA KNIGHT, individually; 28 MALCOLM and KELLEY MCDOWELL, individually; MANDY MACALUSO, Trustee of the - 21 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Living Trust of Mandy Macaluso; MANUEL ALMEIDA and KEVIN BAGLEY, individually; 2 MARCUS and AMY HUEPPE, individually; MARCUS and EVA KETTLES, individually; 3 MARGARET M. ALDRICH, Trustee of the Russell F. Aldrich and Margaret M. Aldrich 4 “Decedent’s Trust,” and Trustee of the Russell F. Aldrich and Margaret M. Aldrich Living Trust; 5 MARGO KELLY, Trustee of the Kelly Trust; MARIA BLASCO; MARIA COLLINS; MARIE 6 W. WALLACE, Trustee of the Marie Weismiller Wallace Separate Property Trust; MARIKA 7 ZOLL; MARILYN SWEENEY, Trustee of the Marilyn Sweeney Revocable Living Trust; 8 MARIO and SHAWN REYES, individually; MARION and BETTY EARNEST, individually; 9 MARK and COLLEEN RUSIN, individually; MARK and CONNIE CLINE, individually; 10 MARK and HELEN MOSKOVITZ, individually; MARK and MARCIA ALBERTSEN, 11 individually; MARK BELLINI; MARK W. ETCHART, Trustee of the Mark W. Etchart Separate 12 Property Trust, and Trustee of the Michel A. Etchart Separate Property Trust; MARSHA 13 MACDONALD; MARSHALL and DINA MURPHY, individually; MARTHA FAST, Trustee of 14 the Martha L Fast Living Trust; MARTHA LALIBERTE; MARTHA MORAN; MARTIN and 15 BARBARA POPS, individually; MARTIN and NATALIE EHRLICH, individually; MARTIN 16 and PATRICIA HENDERSON, individually; MARY and THOMAS SNOW, individually; 17 MARY DOWNER, Trustee of the Arthur and Mary Downer Family Trust; MARY L. VOMUND, 18 Trustee of the Mary L. Vomund 1987 Trust; MARY THOMAS, Trustee of the Thomas Survivors 19 Trust; MARY WINGATE, Trustee of the Mary Louise Wingate Trust; MATTAWA and ROND 20 LARUE CLEMENTS, individually; MATTHEW and JUDY FARMER, individually;

21 MATTHEW and KIMBERLY HULTGEN, individually; MAX REED; MAXIMIANO and 22 NORMA ORTIZ, individually; J. MCGLIINCHEY; MCNELL CREEK RANCH, A GENERAL 23 PARTNERSHIP; MCNELL PROPERTIES, LLC; MELESIO RAMIREZ; MELISSA VAN 24 SICLEN; MERL and KIM MELSTRAND, individually; MICHAEL and ALLISON SEDLAK, 25 individually; MICHAEL and ANNELL LA BARGE, individually; MICHAEL and BARBARA 26 MCCARTHY, individually; MICHAEL and BERNARD CLARK, individually; MICHAEL and 27 CAROL JACKSON, individually; MICHAEL and DIANNA FARRAR, individually; MICHAEL 28 and HEIDI BRADBURY, individually; MICHAEL and KIMBERLY ROBERTSON, - 22 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 individually; MICHAEL and NANCY KRUMPSCHMIDT, individually; MICHAEL and 2 SHARON WILLIAMS, individually; MICHAEL and SONJA BARRETT, individually; 3 MICHAEL and TERRI IMWALLE, individually; MICHAEL CHAMBLISS; MICHAEL 4 HOOVER, Trustee of the Michael Hoover Living Trust; MICHAEL KELLEY; MICHAEL L. 5 DELAMOREand DEBORAH FINLEY-DELAMORE, individually as Trustees of the Delamore 6 Finley Family Trust; MICHAEL LOMBARDO, Trustee of the Michael Lombardo Living Trust; 7 MICHAEL MARIETTA, individually and as Trustee of the Marietta Separate Property Trust; 8 MICHAEL PRENTICE; MICHAEL PURDY, Trustee of the Purdy Family Revocable Trust; 9 MICHAEL SALEH, Trustee of the Saleh and Lea Saleh 1984 Family Trust; MICHAEL T. 10 MARSHALL and LISA SKYHEART MARSHALL, individually as Trustees of the Marshall 11 Living Trust; MICKY FROELICH; MIGUEL and ELVIA RAMIREZ, individually; MIGUEL 12 ESTRADA; MURELLE STEVENS, Trustee of the Stevens Family Trust; NANCY FERRELL, 13 Trustee of the Nancy A. Ferrell Family Trust; NANCY GRAHAM; NANCY JACKSON, Trustee 14 of the Nancy J. Jackson Living Trust; NATALIA MOORE, Trustee of the Moore Family Trust; 15 NATHAN ALLEN; NATHANIEL and SUZETTE O’GRADY, individually; NATHANIEL 16 TRAUDT and KAREN TRAUDT, individually and as Trustees of the Traudt Family Trust; NEIL 17 and PATRICIA FRIEDRICHSEN, individually; NEIL KREITMAN, Trustee of the Neil 18 Kreitman Living Trust; NICK and MORNA TAMINICH, individually; NICK DAILY; NINA 19 MENCONI; NYE RANCH, LLC; OAK HAVEN, LLC; OAK VIEW SANITARY DISTRICT; 20 KRISHNAMURTI FOUNDATION OF AMERICA; OILFIELD SERVICE and TRUCK CO.;

21 OILFIELD SERVICE and TRUCK, INC.; OJAI ASSEMBLY OF GOD, INC., DBA OJAI’S 22 CHURCH OF THE LIVING CHRIST, INC.; OJAI HOME, LLC; OJAI UNIFIED SCHOOL 23 DISTRICT; OJAI VALLEY ATHLETIC CLUB; OJAI VALLEY LAND CONSERVANCY; 24 OJAI-JACKMAN, LLC; OLE BEHRENDTSEN; OLGA and TRENT JONES, individually; 25 ORIN JR. and KAREN CHAPPELL, individually; ORVILLE HERNVALL, Trustee of Hervnall 26 Orville and Marion Orville Trust; OSCAR and MARY KAAS, individually; OSCAR ACOSTA, 27 Trustee of the Acosta Trust; OST TRUCKS and CRANES; OVIS, LLC; PAMELA GRAU, 28 Trustee of the Pamela Grau Living Trust; PAMELA MELONE, Trustee of the Pamela M. Melone - 23 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Living Trust; PATRICIA BOAN and ALINA HOFFMAN, individually; PATRICIA BOAN and 2 JOHN HOFFMAN, individually; PATRICIA MARSHALL, Trustee of the Patricia Ann Marshall 3 Trust; PATRICIA MCPHERSON; PATRICIA MCGANN; PATRICIA UNRUHE and 4 ANDREW JARVIS, individually; PATRICK HENDERSON and JESSICA MAHARRY, 5 Trustees of the Maharry Henderson Family Trust; PATRICK TUMAMAIT; PAUL and ALDINE 6 HENNIGAN, individually; PAUL and JANET BAILEY, individually; PAUL and JUNE CLEM, 7 individually; PAUL and KIM ROBIE, individually; PAUL and MAELYN EBERT, individually; 8 PAUL and SALLY CENTENO, individually; PAUL FONTEYN, individually; PAUL 9 HOLAHAN and JULIE GRIST, individually; PAUL LEPIANE and BO BENGTSON, 10 individually; PAULA BROWN, Trustee of the Paula Jean Brown Trust; PAULA LASITER; 11 PAULA MCCULLOUGH, Trustee of the Paula J. McCullough Living Trust; PAULINE 12 MERCADO, Trustee of the Pauline Mercado Revocable Trust; PEDRO CISNEROS; PEDRO 13 TEPESANO; PER and INGE CHRISTIANSEN, individually; PERRY FAMILY, LLC; PETER 14 and LINDA DAPRIX, individually; PETER and NORMA DWORKIS, individually; PETER 15 DUFAU; PETER PASSELL; PETER STRAUSS and RACHEL TICOTIN, individually; 16 PETROCHEM DEVELOPMENT I, LLC; PHILIP and DARYLYN LONG, individually; PHILIP 17 and MARY PIERPONT, individually; PHILIP and ROBERT PIERPONT, individually; 18 PHILIPPE and BETSY CALAND, Trustees of the Philippe M. and Betsy C. Trust; 19 PREPARATORY VILLANOVA; QUINT MORRIS; RACHEL KONDOR and BRIAN SEGEE, 20 individually; RAFAEL and MAGDALENA VILLALPANDO, individually; RAFFI J.

21 MESROBIAN and MYRNA R. MESROBIAN, individually as Trustees of the Mesrobian Family 22 Trust; RAINER BUSCHMANN and JOHN JOHNSTON, individually; RALPH and LYNNE 23 LUNDY, individually; RAMAA MOSLEY; RANDAL R. O'CONNOR, SUCCESSOR Trustee of 24 the Red Clay Trust, and successor Trustee of the Le Cedre Trust; RANJIT SEVAPRAKASAM; 25 RAY HALL, Trustee-in-Trust of the 30 Acre Trust; RAYMOND and ESTHER KARDLY, 26 individually; RAYMOND and EVA LYONS, individually; RAYMOND MAGEE and LINDA 27 TAYLOR, individually; RDK LAND, LLC; REBECCA ADAMS; RED MOUNTAIN LAND 28 and FARMING, LLC; REEVES ORCHARD, LLC; REFUGIO GOMEZ; REX and HEIDI - 24 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 LANNING, individually; REYNOLDS FLEMING; RICARDO GONZALEZ; RICHARD and 2 BILLIE SUMNER, individually; RICHARD and EMILY CARGILL, individually; RICHARD 3 and KATHERINE GODFREY, individually; RICHARD and LEE HARPER, individually; 4 RICHARD and MARILYN KALLAS;, individually RICHARD and NANCY FRANCIS, 5 individually; RICHARD and TERESA TURNER, individually; RICHARD DODSON, Trustee of 6 the Richard E. Dodson 2010 Revocable Trust; RICHARD FRANCIS; RICHARD FREY and 7 WENDY APPLEBY, individually; RICHARD and EMMA KLINE, individually; RICHARD 8 LOWEN; RICHARD MAGANA; RICHARD MCGRATH, Trustee of the Richard K McGrath 9 Living Trust; RICHARD SOJKA; RJPR LTD. PARTNERSHIP; ROBERT and ANAMARIA 10 SCHMID, individually; ROBERT and ANTOINETTE TIVY, individually; ROBERT and 11 DIANA PETROPULOS, individually; ROBERT and DIANNE STONE, individually; ROBERT 12 and DOMINQUE DANIELS, individually; ROBERT and DORA BALITZER, individually; 13 ROBERT and EMILY MARTIN, individually; ROBERT and GAEA CANNADAY, 14 individually; ROBERT and GERALDINE HUNSAKER, individually; ROBERT and 15 JACQUELINE MCDANIEL, individually; ROBERT and JANICE HASTIE, individually; 16 ROBERT and MARILYN SALAS, individually; ROBERT and MAUREEN YOUNG, 17 individually; ROBERT and SHEILA GHEN, individually; ROBERT and SONIA RODARTE, 18 individually; ROBERT and TAUNDRA RODDICK, individually; ROBERT and ANNA J. 19 AURIC, individually as Trustees of the Auric Anna J. Family Trust; ROBERT CALDER DAVIS, 20 JR., Trustee of the Robert Davis Surviving Spouse's Trust, Trustee of the Davis Family Bypass

21 Trust and Trustee of the Davis Family Trust; ROBERT DEKKERS; ROBERT ERICKSON and 22 RONALD WILSON, individually; ROBERT GRASMERE; ROBERT POLIDORI and 23 BRITTANY SANDERS, individually; ROBERTO and MARIA ALONSO, individually; 24 ROCKY MANN; RODERICK and JOYCE GREENE, individually; ROGER and SUSAN 25 DICKENS, individually; ROGER BURKE; ROGER HALEY; Trustee of the Roger and Christina 26 Haley Survivors Trust; ROGER WALKER; ROGERS-COOPER MEMORIAL FOUNDATION; 27 RONALD and BETTE BLUHM, individually; RONALD and JULIA BRUNS, individually; 28 RONALD BLOOD and LINDA JORDAN, individually; RONALD E. NOVAK and LINDA L. - 25 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 LEWIS, individually as Trustees of the Novak Family Trust; RONALD K. FREELAND and 2 DOREEN FREELAND, individually as Trustees or their successors in interest of the Freeland 3 Trust and any amendment; RONALD L.R. HILL and DEBI R. HILL, Trustees of the R&D Hill 4 Family Trust; RONALD VOGT; ROSEMARIE SINGER; ROSEMARY PAYNE, Trustee of the 5 Rosemary Payne Trust; ROSS ANDERSON; ROWLAND A. HILL II and BRENDA M. HILL, 6 individually as Trustees of the Trust dated November 1, 2002; ROY HICKS, Trustee of the Roy 7 and Jacquelyn Hicks Family Trust; RUBEN and MARISA MARTINEZ, individually; RUBEN 8 CHAVEZ; RUBEN MAGANA and JANETTE LUPERCIO, individually; RUDY BAEZ; 9 RUSSEL and LAURA ALFORD, individually; RUSSELL and GOLDEN WILEY, individually; 10 RUSSELL WALDROP, Trustee of the Russell B. Waldrop Living Trust; RYAN and LAUREN 11 NICHOLS, individually; SABINO and NICKI PEREZ, individually; SABRINA VENSKUS, 12 Trustee of the Sabrina Venskus Living Trust; SALLY CRAIN; SALVATORE SCARPATO; 13 SAMUEL and JOANNA SCHINDEL, individually; SAMUEL EATON; SANTA ANA RANCH, 14 INC.; SARAH YOUNG; SAUNIE KREWSON; SCOTT and BRITTANY DENTON, 15 individually; SCOTT and CAROL RASMUSSEN, individually; SCOTT and KEELA ALLISON, 16 individually; SCOTT and MARIA HERTZOG, individually; SCOTT and MICHELE SUPAN; 17 SCOTT CHASSE, Trustee of the Scott Chasse Revocable Living Trust; SCOTT FORSYTH and 18 JOY FEDELE, individually; SCOTT LUNDY, Trustee of the Scott Lundy Trust; SCOTT 19 LUTTENBERGER and NATASHA WILCOX, individually; SCOTTIE MONICAL; SEAN and 20 LESLIE BENNETT, individually; SERAFIN and MARTHA FLORES, individually; SEVAN

21 GERARD; SHAHRAM SHAHROKHFAR and DINA NAVA, individually; SHANKS 22 INVESTMENT GROUP, LLC; SHAWN FULBRIGHT, Trustee of the Shawn Fulbright 2014 23 Revocable Trust; SHAWN REED; SHELL OIL CO.; SHERRICE and JOHN WEECES, 24 individually; SHERRIE DAILY; SHERYL SHUSHAN; SHIPPEE, LLC; SHULL BONSALL, 25 JR., Trustee of the SHULL BONSALL FAMILY Trust; EVANGELINE BONSALL SMITH, a 26 married woman; SIDNEY and JAYNE RICE, individually; STEVEN P. SMITH and LYNN 27 DAVIS-SMITH, individually as Trustees of the Smith Revocable Living Trust; SOUTHERN 28 CALIFORNIA EDISON CO.; SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATED INVESTORS, LTD.; - 26 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 SPENCER and BAILEY HILL, individually; SRPS, LP; STACY CADENASSO; STANLEY and 2 THERESA WYATT, individually; STANLEY and W HUBBELL, individually; STATE OF 3 CALIFORNIA, DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION; STEFAN KOZAK and ANA 4 LOPES, individually; STEPHANIE and CHERYL BEAS, individually; STEPHEN MATZKIN, 5 Trustee of the Stephen Matzkin Trust; STEPHEN TURNER, Trustee of the Stephen R. Turner 6 Living Trust; STEVEN and BRENT KANALY, individually; STEVEN and CHRISTINE 7 VAUGHAN, individually; STEVEN and KA RAPHOLZ, individually; STEVEN and KAREN 8 ERICKSON, individually; STEVEN and KRISSELL DUTTER, individually; STEVEN ELLIOT 9 EDELSON, Trustee of the Los Angeles Entertainment Trust; SUMEET BHATIA and MICHAEL 10 MCDONALD, individually; SUMPURAN KHALSA, Trustee of the Sumpuran S. Khalsa Living 11 Trust; SURIA and JOHN GOTTESMAN, individually; SUSAN BEE, Trustee of the John and 12 Susan Bee Family Trust; SUSAN CONLEY, Trustee of the William and Susan Conley Family 13 Trust; SUSAN DILLER, Trustee of the Susan J Diller Trust; SUSAN GARAND; SUSAN 14 GRUBER, individually and as Trustee of the Susan Gruber Living Trust; SUSAN MCCORD- 15 NEUFELD; SUSAN MOLL; SUSAN WEBSTER; SUZANNE HARVEY, individually and as 16 Trustee of the Suzanne G. Harvey Revocable Trust; T BONE HOLDINGS, LLC; TANYA 17 SMITH and MICHAEL MONTANO, individually; TANYA STARCEVICH; TED ROBINSON, 18 Trustee of the Robinson Family Trust; TELOS DEVELOPMENT OJAI, LLC; TERRY 19 WILSON, Trustee of the Terry Coultas Wilson Living Trust; THE OJAI RENTAL, LLC; THE 20 ROMAN CATHOLIC ARCHBISHOP OF LOS ANGELES, a sole corporation; THEODOR and

21 LORE EXNER, individually; THERESA STARK; THOMAS and CYNTHIA CARVER, 22 individually; THOMAS and NANETTE BENBROOK, individually; THOMAS and JADONA 23 COLLER HARPER, individually; THOMAS JACKSON; THOMAS TAMPLIN and 24 MICHELLE WELLS, individually; THOMAS WALBRIDGE, Trustee of the Thomas C 25 Walbridge Trust; THREE OAKS, LLC; THREE SISTERS ORCHARD, LP; TIMOTHY and 26 CHERYL AUSTIN, individually; TIMOTHY and KATHLEEN MCHUGH, individually; 27 TIMOTHY and KATHRYN MORAN, individually; TIMOTHY and LINDA TURNER, 28 individually; TIMOTHY and MARY WILLIAMSON, individually; TIMOTHY JONES; TODD - 27 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 and CHRISTINA MCGINLEY, individually; TODD RYAN and JESSICA CLICK, individually; 2 TODD TULLETT, Trustee of the Todd Tullett Revocable Living Trust; TOM and NANCY 3 ROLAND, individually; TONY and HEATHER CARLOS, individually; TRACEY and 4 MELANIE BOULTON, individually; TRENT and KRIS GRECO, individually; TYLER and 5 MARIA BARRELL, individually; TYLER LABINE and CARRIE RUSCHEINSKY, 6 individually; ULDINE and FABIEN CASTEL, individually; URIEL and CHIEKO LOPEZ, 7 individually; US NATURAL RESOURCES, INC.; VALLEY OAK CHARTER; VANLAW 8 INVESTMENT CORP.; VENTURA LAND Trust; VENTURA UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT; 9 VICENTE GUZMAN; VICKI DAW; VICKI L. HOLLINGSWORTH, Trustee of the 10 Hollingsworth Trust; VIRGINIA M. MCCARTHY, Trustee of the Virginia M. McCarthy Living 11 Trust; VIRGINIA SIEGFRIED, Trustee of the Virginia A. Siegfried Revocable Trust; VIVIAN 12 ARBER; VIVIENNE MOODY; WALTER and EVELYN GOLIS, individually; WALTER and 13 LINDA BOYSIEWICK, individually; WALTER MCGOWAN, individually and as Trustee of the 14 Walter Robert McGowan 1995 Trust; WANDA and MENIFORD CANTERBERRY, 15 individually; WATERMARK CARP II LLC; WAYNE TATE and JANICE PRIEBE-TATE, 16 individually as Trustees of the Tate Trust, as community property; WEISS INVESTMENT 17 PROPERTIES; WENDY and DAVID CHURCHILL, individually; WERNER and ELVA 18 FISCHER, individually; WESLEY SCOTT and KASEY PERINS, individually; WEST CRAG 19 GLEN SMITH, successor Trustee of the Melissa Irene Elizabeth Smith Irrevocable Special Needs 20 Trust - 1993; WILLI and STEFANIE U. COELER, individually and as Trustees of the W. and S.

21 Coeler Living Trust; WILLIAM and CYNTHIA ANDERSON, individually; WILLIAM and 22 JACQUELINE BOCH, individually; WILLIAM and LORRAINE WALSH, individually; 23 WILLIAM and MELINDA WELCH, individually; WILLIAM and SUSAN LUTHER, 24 individually; WILLIAM B. HART, JR., Trustee of the Constance Eaton Personal Residence 25 Trust; WILLIAM BAILEY, Trustee of the William F. Bailey Living Trust; WILLIAM 26 BROTHERS, Trustee of the William C. Brothers Living Trust; WILLIAM ERICKSON; 27 WILLIAM F. NEWTON and CHARLOTTE R. NEWTON, individually as Trustees of the 28 NEWTON FAMILY Trust; WILLIAM GILBRETH, Trustee of the William J. Gilbreth Trust; - 28 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 WILLIAM HAWKSWORTH; WILLIAM LOWES; WILLIAM L. REYNOLDS; WILLIAM 2 WHITE, Trustee of the William C. White Trust; WILLIAM WHORF; WILMETTA DAVIS; 3 WINFRIED and CAROL BOERSCH, individually; WYNN JOHNSON and LISA AYALA 4 JOHNSON, individually; YAN and ALILI COMMENT, individually; YARROW and 5 CAROLINE CHENEY, individually; YITZHAK and SMADAR ORLANS, individually; YVON 6 and MALINDA CHOUINARD, individually; ZOBEIDA OLSON [collectively “Riparian and 7 Overlying Landowners”]; 8 9 ALL PERSONS WHO OWN AN INTEREST IN LAND OVERLYING THE VENTURA 10 RIVER WATERSHED’S GROUNDWATER BASINS AND CLAIM AN INTEREST TO 11 PUMP, EXTRACT OR STORE GROUNDWATER FROM, UNDER OR ON THAT LAND 12 [collectively “Interested Persons”] 13 14 and ROES 1-1,000, 15 collectively, Cross-Defendants. 16 17 18 19 20

21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 - 29 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 THIRD AMENDED CROSS-COMPLAINT 2 3 Cross-Complainant City of San Buenaventura (“City”) alleges as follows: 4 5 INTRODUCTION 6 7 1. This Cross-Complaint seeks a judicial determination of rights to all water within 8 the Ventura River Watershed (“Watershed”), including a comprehensive adjudication of the 9 waters of the Ventura River and the groundwater basins located within the Watershed and their 10 interconnected surface waters and for the imposition of a physical solution. An adjudication is 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 necessary to protect and conserve the limited water supply that is vital to the public health, safety,

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 and welfare of all persons and entities that depend upon waters from the Watershed and to ensure O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 the reasonable use, pursuant to Article X, section 2 of the California Constitution, of the waters in F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 the Watershed. For these reasons, City files this Cross-Complaint to promote the general public A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 welfare in the Watershed; protect City’s rights to pump and divert water and provide water to the N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 public; protect from a loss of the public’s water supply; prevent degradation of the quality of the 17 public water supply; and avoid higher water costs to the public. 18 19 PARTIES 20

21 2. City is a charter city and municipal corporation of the State of California and 22 located in the County of Ventura (“Ventura County”). The City operates wells and diversions 23 which extract surface and/or subsurface water from the Ventura River and receives water 24 deliveries from . 25 Original Cross-Defendants 26 3. Cross-Defendant Duncan Abbott (“Abbott”) is an individual. City is informed and 27 believes that Abbott operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface and/or subsurface 28 water from Coyote Creek. - 30 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 4. Cross-Defendant AGR Breeding, Inc. (“AGR”) is a California corporation 2 organized and existing under the laws of the State of Colorado and doing business in Ventura 3 County. City is informed and believes that AGR operates wells and/or diversions which extract 4 surface and/or subsurface water from San Antonio Creek. 5 5. Cross-Defendant Asquith Family Limited Partnership, Ltd. (“Asquith Family”) is 6 a California Corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and 7 doing business in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that Asquith Family operates 8 well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin. 9 6. Cross-Defendant Troy Becker (“Becker”) is an individual. City is informed and 10 believes that Becker operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 Basin.

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 7. Cross-Defendant Bentley Family Limited Partnership (“Bentley”) is a California O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 corporation registered in Delaware and does business in Ventura County. City is informed and F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 believes that Bentley operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 Basin. N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 8. Cross-Defendant Robin Bernhotf (“Bernhoft”) is an individual. City is informed 17 and believes that Bernhoft operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley 18 Groundwater Basin. 19 9. Cross-Defendant Dwayne Boccali (“Boccali”) is an individual. City is informed 20 and believes that Bernhoft operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley

21 Groundwater Basin. 22 10. Cross-Defendant Janet Boulton (“J. Boulton”) is an individual. City is informed 23 and believes that J. Boulton operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley 24 Groundwater Basin. 25 11. Cross-Defendant Michael Boulton (“M. Boulton”) is an individual. City is 26 informed and believes that M. Boulton operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley 27 Groundwater Basin. 28 - 31 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 12. Cross-Defendant Dwayne Bower (“Bower”) is an individual. City is informed and 2 believes that Bower operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 3 Basin. 4 13. Cross-Defendant Burgess Ranch (“Burgess”) is a California corporation organized 5 and existing under the laws of the State of Colorado and doing business in Ventura County. City 6 is informed and believes that Burgess operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley 7 Groundwater Basin. nera 14. Cross-Defendant Michael Caldwell (“Caldwell”) is an individual. City is informed l and believes that Caldwell operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface and/or welf subsurface water from the Upper Ventura River. 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 are 15. Cross-Defendant Casitas Municipal Water District (“Casitas”) is a California

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S of special district organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and located in O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R the Ventura County. City is informed and believes that Casitas obtains water from Lake Casitas F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A citiz which contains natural flows from Coyote and Santa Ana Creeks and Ventura River diversions A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B ens, transported to the lake via the 5.4-mile Robles Canal from the Robles Diversion and Fish Passage N 0 L 0 2 A W inha Facility. City is informed and believes that in 2017, Casitas acquired Golden State Water bita Company (“Golden State”), a California corporation previously organized and existing under the nts, laws of the State of California and doing business in Ventura County. Golden State was a public and utility regulated by the California Public Utilities Commission. City is informed and believes that cust Golden State operated and that Casitas now operates wells that extract water from the Ojai Valley

ome Groundwater Basin, affecting outflows from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin to a tributary of rs the Ventura River. wi 16. Cross-Defendant Casitas Mutual Water Company (“CMWC”) is a California corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and doing business as a mutual water company in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that CMWC operates wells that extract water from the Upper Ventura River Groundwater Basin, affecting outflows from that basin to Watershed.

- 32 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 17. Cross-Defendant Charles Cho (“Cho”) is an individual. City is informed and 2 believes that Cho operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin. 3 18. Cross-Defendant Joe Clark (“J. Clark”) is an individual. City is informed and 4 believes that J. Clark operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 5 Basin. 6 19. Cross-Defendant Kevin Clark (“K. Clark”) is an individual. City is informed and 7 believes that K. Clark operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 8 Basin. 9 20. Cross-Defendant Lisa Clark (“L. Clark”) is an individual. City is informed and 10 believes that L. Clark operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 Basin.

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 21. Cross-Defendant Rebecca Collins (“R. Collins”) is an individual. City is informed O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 and believes that R. Collins operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 Groundwater Basin. A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 22. Cross-Defendant Thomas Collins (“T. Collins”) is an individual. City is informed N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 and believes that T. Collins operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley 17 Groundwater Basin. 18 23. Cross-Defendant Michael Cromer (“Cromer”) is an individual. City is informed 19 and believes that Cromer operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface and/or subsurface 20 water from San Antonio Creek.

21 24. Cross-Defendant Robert C. Davis, Jr. (“Davis”) is an individual. City is informed 22 and believes that Davis operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 23 Basin. 24 25. Cross-Defendant Linda Epstein (“Epstein”) is an individual. City is informed and 25 believes that Epstein operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 26 Basin. 27 26. Cross-Defendant Essick Farm Management Company, LLC (“Essick”) is a 28 California corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and doing - 33 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 business in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that Essick operates well(s) which 2 extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin. 3 27. Cross-Defendant Etchart Ranch (“Etchart”) is located in Ventura County. City is 4 informed and believes that Etchart operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface and/or 5 subsurface water from the Upper Ventura River. 6 28. Cross-Defendant James Finch (“Finch”) is an individual. City is informed and 7 believes that Finch operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface and/or subsurface water 8 from the Lower Ventura River. 9 29. Cross-Defendant Flying H Ranch, Inc. (“Flying”) is a California corporation 10 organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and doing business in Ventura 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 County. City is informed and believes that Flying operates wells and/or diversions which extract

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 surface and/or subsurface water from San Antonio Creek. O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 30. Cross-Defendant Ernest Ford (“Ford”) is an individual. City is informed and F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 believes that Ford operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface and/or subsurface water A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 from the Upper Ventura River. N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 31. Cross-Defendant Wayne Francis (“Francis”) is an individual. City is informed and 17 believes that Francis operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 18 Basin. 19 32. Cross-Defendant Friend’s Ranches, Inc. (“Friend’s”) is a California corporation 20 organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and doing business in Ventura

21 County. City is informed and believes that Friend’s operates wells and/or diversions which 22 extract surface and/or subsurface water from San Antonio Creek and the Upper Ventura River. 23 33. Cross-Defendant John Galaska (“Galaska”) is an individual. City is informed and 24 believes that Galaska operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 25 Basin. 26 34. Cross-Defendant Richard Gilleland (“Gilleland”) is an individual. City is 27 informed and believes that Gilleland operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface 28 and/or subsurface water from San Antonio Creek. - 34 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 35. Cross-Defendant Jurgen Gramckow (“Gramckow”) is an individual. City is 2 informed and believes that Gramckow operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface 3 and/or subsurface water from Coyote Creek. 4 36. Cross-Defendant Gridley Road Water Group (“Gridley”) is a California 5 corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and doing business as 6 a mutual water company in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that Gridley operates 7 wells that extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin, affecting outflows from that 8 basin to Watershed. 9 37. Cross-Defendant Stephanie Gustafson (“Gustafson”) is an individual. City is 10 informed and believes that Gustafson operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 Groundwater Basin.

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 38. Cross-Defendant Lawrence Hartmann (“Hartmann”) is an individual. City is O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 informed and believes that Hartmann operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 Groundwater Basin. A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 39. Cross-Defendant Hermitage Mutual Water Company (“Hermitage”) is a California N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and doing business as 17 a mutual water company in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that Hermitage 18 operates wells that extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin, affecting outflows 19 from that basin to Watershed. 20 40. Cross-Defendant Dorothy Holmes (“Holmes”) is an individual. City is informed

21 and believes that Holmes operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface and/or 22 subsurface water from North Fork . 23 41. Cross-Defendant Stephen Huyler (“Huyler”) is an individual. City is informed and 24 believes that Huyler operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 25 Basin. 26 42. Cross-Defendants Jurgen Gramckow and Geraldine Gramckow are Trustees of the 27 J&G Trust (“Gramckows”). City is informed and believes that Gramckows operate wells and/or 28 diversions which extract surface and/or subsurface water from the Upper Ventura River - 35 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Groundwater Basin. City is informed and believes that Gramckows are owners of or are 2 beneficial interest holders in real property located within the Ventura River Watershed, and they 3 claim riparian rights to divert and/or extract surface and/or subsurface water from the Ventura 4 River and/or its tributaries, whether or not they have exercised such riparian rights. 5 43. Cross-Defendant Cheryl Jensen (“Jensen”) is an individual. City is informed and 6 believes that Jensen operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 7 Basin. 8 44. Cross-Defendant Brett Kantrowitz (“B. Kantrowitz”) is an individual. City is 9 informed and believes that B. Kantrowitz operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai 10 Valley Groundwater Basin. 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 45. Cross-Defendant Denise Kantrowitz (“D. Kantrowitz”)is an individual. City is

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 informed and believes that D. Kantrowitz operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 Valley Groundwater Basin. F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 46. Cross-Defendant Jerry Kenton (“Kenton”) is an individual. City is informed and A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 believes that Kenton operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface and/or subsurface N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 water from North Fork Matilija Creek. 17 47. Cross-Defendant Ole Konig (“Konig”) is an individual. City is informed and 18 believes that Konig operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface and/or subsurface 19 water from San Antonio Creek. 20 48. Cross-Defendant Krotona Institute of Theosophy (“Krotona”) is a 501(c)(3)

21 California non-profit corporation located in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that 22 Krotona claims water rights to surface water and/or groundwater in the Ventura River Watershed. 23 49. Cross-Defendant Tim Krout (“Krout”) is an individual. City is informed and 24 believes that Krout operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin. 25 50. Cross-Defendant Betina La Plante (“La Plante”)is an individual. City is informed 26 and believes that La Plante operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley 27 Groundwater Basin. 28 - 36 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 51. Cross-Defendant Lutheran Church of the Holy Cross of Ojai (“Lutheran Church”) 2 is a California Non-profit Corporation. City is informed and believes that Lutheran Church 3 operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface and/or subsurface water from San Antonio 4 Creek. 5 52. Cross-Defendant Scott Luttenberg (“Luttenberg”) is an individual. City is 6 informed and believes that Luttenberg operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley 7 Groundwater Basin. 8 53. Cross-Defendant Jeffrey Luttrull (“Luttrull”) is an individual. City is informed 9 and believes that Luttrull operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 10 Basin. 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 54. Cross-Defendant Meiners Oaks Water District (“Meiners Oaks”) is a California

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 special district organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and located in O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 Ventura County. City is informed and believes that Meiners Oaks operates wells that extract F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 surface and/or subsurface water from the Ventura River and/or Watershed. A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 55. Cross-Defendant Fredrick Menninger (“F. Menninger”) is an individual. City is N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 informed and believes that F. Menninger operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai 17 Valley Groundwater Basin. 18 56. Cross-Defendant Margaret Menninger (“M. Menninger”) is an individual. City is 19 informed and believes that M. Menninger operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai 20 Valley Groundwater Basin.

21 57. Cross-Defendant Stephen Mitchell (“Mitchell”) is an individual. City is informed 22 and believes that Mitchell operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 23 Basin. 24 58. Cross-Defendant Bill Moses (“Moses”) is an individual. City is informed and 25 believes that Moses operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 26 Basin. 27 59. Cross-Defendant North Fork Springs Mutual Water Company (“North Fork 28 Springs”) is a California corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of - 37 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 California and doing business as a mutual water company in Ventura County. City is informed 2 and believes that North Fork Springs operates wells that extract water from the Upper Ventura 3 River Groundwater Basin, affecting outflows from that basin to Watershed. 4 60. Cross-Defendant Ojai Water Conservation District (“Ojai WCD”) is a California 5 special district organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and located in 6 Ventura County. City is informed and believes that Ojai WCD operates wells and/or diversions 7 which extract surface and/or subsurface water from San Antonio Creek. 8 61. Cross-Defendant Old Creek Road Mutual Water Company (“Old Creek Road”) is 9 a California corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and 10 doing business as a mutual water company in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 Old Creek Road obtains water from Casitas, which obtains water from Lake Casitas which

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 contains water diverted from the Ventura River. O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 62. Cross-Defendant Rancho de Cielo Mutual Water Company (“Rancho de Cielo”) is F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 a California corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 doing business as a mutual water company in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 Rancho de Cielo obtains water from Casitas, which obtains water from Lake Casitas which 17 contains water diverted from the Ventura River. 18 63. Cross-Defendant Rancho Matilija Mutual Water Company (“Rancho Matilija”) is 19 a California corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and 20 doing business as a mutual water company in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that

21 Rancho Matilija operates wells that extract surface and/or subsurface water from the Ventura 22 River and/or Watershed. 23 64. Cross-Defendant Shlomo Raz is an individual. City is informed and believes that 24 Shlomo Raz operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin. 25 65. Cross-Defendant Sylvia Raz is an individual. City is informed and believes that 26 Sylvia Raz operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin. 27 66. Cross-Defendant Rincon Water and Road Works (“Rincon”) is a California 28 corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and doing business in - 38 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Ventura County. City is informed and believes that Rincon claims water rights to surface water 2 and/or groundwater in the Ventura River Watershed. 3 67. Cross-Defendant Charles Rudd (“Rudd”) is an individual. City is informed and 4 believes that Rudd operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface and/or subsurface water 5 from San Antonio Creek. 6 68. Cross-Defendant William Rusin (“Rusin”) is an individual. City is informed and 7 believes that Rusin operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface and/or subsurface 8 water from San Antonio Creek. 9 69. Defendant Mark Saleh (“Saleh”) is an individual. City is informed and believes 10 that Saleh operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin. 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 70. Cross-Defendant Senior Canyon Mutual Water Company (“Senior Canyon”) is a

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 California corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and doing O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 business as a mutual water company in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 Senior Canyon operates wells that extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin, A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 affecting outflows from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin to a tributary of the Ventura River. N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 71. Cross-Defendant Siete Robles Mutual Water Company (“Siete Robles”) is a 17 California corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and doing 18 business as a mutual water company in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that Siete 19 Robles operates wells that extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin, affecting 20 outflows from that basin to Watershed.

21 72. Cross-Defendant Sisar Mutual Water Company (“Sisar”) is a California 22 corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and doing business as 23 a mutual water company in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that Sisar operates 24 wells that extract water from the Upper Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin, affecting outflows from 25 that basin to Watershed. 26 73. Cross-Defendant Soule Park Golf Course, Ltd. (“Soule Park”) is a California 27 corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and doing business in 28 - 39 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Ventura County. City is informed and believes that Soule Park operates well(s) which extract 2 water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin. 3 74. Cross-Defendant St Joseph’s Associates of Ojai, California, Inc. (“St. Joseph’s”) is 4 a California corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and 5 doing business in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that St. Joseph’s operates wells 6 and/or diversions which extract surface and/or subsurface water from San Antonio Creek. 7 75. Cross-Defendant Andrew Stasse (“Stasse”) is an individual. City is informed and 8 believes that Stasse operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 9 Basin. 10 76. Cross-Defendant George S. Stuart (“Stuart”) is an individual. City is informed and 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 believes that Stuart operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin.

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 77. Cross-Defendant John Taft (“Taft”) is an individual. City is informed and believes O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 that Taft operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface and/or subsurface water from F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 Coyote Creek. A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 78. Cross-Defendant Telos, LLC (“Telos”) is a California Corporation organized and N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 existing under the laws of the State of California and doing business in Ventura County. City is 17 informed and believes that Telos operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley 18 Groundwater Basin. 19 79. Cross-Defendant Thacher Creek Citrus, LLC (“Thacher Creek”) is a California 20 corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and doing business in

21 Ventura County. City is informed and believes that Thacher Creek operates wells and/or 22 diversions which extract surface and/or subsurface water from San Antonio Creek. 23 80. Cross-Defendant The Thacher School (“Thacher School”) is a California non- 24 profit organization organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and doing 25 business in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that Thacher School operates well(s) 26 which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin. 27 81. Cross-Defendant Tico Mutual Water Company (“Tico”) is a California corporation 28 organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and doing business as a mutual - 40 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 water company in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that Tico operates wells that 2 extract water from the Upper Ventura River Groundwater Basin, affecting outflows from that 3 basin to Watershed. 4 82. Cross-Defendant Victor Timar (“Timar”) is an individual. City is informed and 5 believes that Timar operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 6 Basin. 7 83. Cross-Defendant Topa Topa Ranch Company, LLC (“Topa”) is a California 8 corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and doing business in 9 Ventura County. City is informed and believes that Topa operates wells and/or diversions which 10 extract surface and/or subsurface water from San Antonio Creek. 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 84. Cross-Defendant Lou Tomesetta (“Tomesetta”) is an individual. City is informed

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 and believes that Tomesetta operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 Groundwater Basin. F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 85. Cross-Defendant John Town (“J. Town”) is an individual. City is informed and A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 believes that J. Town operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 Basin. 17 86. Cross-Defendant Trudie Town (“T. Town”) is an individual. City is informed and 18 believes that T. Town operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater 19 Basin. 20 87. Cross-Defendant Ernesto Vega (“Vega”) is an individual. City is informed and

21 believes that Vega operates well(s) which extract water from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin. 22 88. Cross-Defendant Ventura County Watershed Protection District (“VCWPD”) is a 23 California special district organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and 24 located in Ventura County. City is informed and believes that VCWPD operates wells and/or 25 diversions which extract surface and/or subsurface water from San Antonio Creek. 26 89. Cross-Defendant the Ventura River Water District (“VRWD”) is a California 27 special district organized and existing under the laws of the State of California and located in 28 - 41 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Ventura County. City is informed and believes that VRWD operates wells that extract surface 2 and/or subsurface water from the Ventura River and/or Watershed. 3 90. Cross-Defendant Wood-Claeyssens Foundation (“Foundation”) is a 501(c)(3) 4 charitable foundation registered in Delaware that owns the Taylor Ranch property and does 5 business in Ventura County. Foundation operates wells, extracts groundwater, and has operated a 6 surface diversion that extracts surface and/or subsurface water from the Ventura River and/or 7 Watershed. 8 91. Cross-Defendant Calvin Zara (“Zara”) is an individual. City is informed and 9 believes that Zara operates wells and/or diversions which extract surface and/or subsurface water 10 from Matilija Creek. 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 Riparian Landowners

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 92. City is informed and believes that the following Cross-Defendants (“Riparian O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 Landowners”) are owners of or are beneficial interest holders in real property located within the F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 Ventura River Watershed, and they claim riparian rights to divert and/or extract surface and/or A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 subsurface water from the Ventura River and/or its tributaries, whether or not they have exercised N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 such riparian rights: 17 Trust; 18 1970 Ranch Road, LLC; Andrew and Jane Holguin, individually; 625 N. Ventures Avenue, LLC; 19 Andrew D. West and Patricia G. West, Abraham Munoz; individually as Trustees of the West Family 20 Ahde and Ganea Lahti, individually; Revocable Trust; Alan and Carol James, individually; Angie Mari Ganasei and Christopher Paul 21 Alessandro Lobba and Mary E. Jackson, Danch, individually as Trustees of the individually as Trustees of the Looba- Genasei-Danch Family Trust; 22 Jackson Family Trust; Anne Lombard and Frank Hanson, Alexander and Maria Doran, individually; 23 individually; Alfredo and Montelle Bello, individually; Armando and Sendi Sanchez, individually; 24 Alvin and Claudia Cunningham, Arthur Timothy and Maurya Kathleen Foy, individually; individually; 25 American Retirement Fund, Inc.; Ashlen and Ivy Aquila, individually; Amy Mattison, Trustee of the Amy K. Aubrey Balkind; 26 Mattison Trust; Auburn Oak Builders, Inc.; Anatoly and Margarita Kozushin, 27 Barry and Angela Ross, individually; individually; Behrooz Jadidollahi; 28 Andrea Leigh Jensen, Trustee of the Jensen Benjamin and Stacey Vail, individually; - 42 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Berkley and Suzanne Baker, individually; Trust; Bettina Chandler, Trustee of the Bettina Claudio and Magdalena Landeros, 2 Chandler Trust; individually; 3 Blanche Chapler; Community Memorial Health System; Bradford and Cheryl Boyd, individually; Connie S. Morgan, Trustee of the Connie S. 4 Brent and Shanna Muth, individually; Morgan Trust; Brian and Irene McConville, individually; Conservation Endowment Fund; 5 Brian and Joan Archer, individually; Constance and Justin Campbell, Brian and Sharon Smith, individually; individually; 6 Brian S. Stafford and Janice M. Thomas, Corinne Anne Fraund; 7 individually as Trustees of the Stafford Craig and Ana Zwirn, individually; Thomas Family Trust; Curtis and Ory Names, individually; 8 Brian Skaggs, Trustee of the Skaggs Trust; Cynthia Lee, Trustee of the Cynthia Lee Brigitte Lovell, Trustee of the Lovell Living Family Trust; 9 Trust; D & J Campbell Best, LLC; Bruce Abbott and Kathleen Quinlan, Dan Newman; 10 individually; Dan Stuart, Trustee of the Dana Stuart Trust; 6 9 0 5 9

4 Bruce and Dixie Gladstone, individually; Dan Wiseman; 3

9 11

P

L E A L Bryan Whitley; Dana and Dawn Ceniceros, individually; T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Bryce and Krista Belgum, individually; Daniel and Amy Yanez, individually; O

, G O S T F E I I E E Carl and Barbara Enson, individually; Daniel and Nancy Mclaren, individually; L R E C A I K R 13 F C Carmen Chavez and Guadalupe Patino, Daniel and Rosalind Grimm, individually;

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N individually; Danny Broadhurst; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L Carol Nicholson; Darren and Lisa Lisle, individually; C

T

. S T N

E U Carol Ann Tennant, Trustee of the Carol David Friend and Angela Marie Friend, 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A McDonnell Family Trust; individually; W 16 Carrie Murphy and Michael E. Templin, David and Linda Smith, individually; individually as Trustees of the Templin- David and Patti Wicklund, individually; 17 Murphy 2016 Living Trust; David Chase and Anne Fitzgerald, Cartin Family, LLC; individually; 18 Catherine E. Lee, Trustee of the Catherine E. David E. Sissum, Jr. and Diana E. Sissum, 19 Lee Trust; individually as Trustees of the Sissum Trust; Chad Westcott and Heather Cushnie David Flick and Emma Flick, individually; 20 Wescott, individually; Dawn and Mark Golden, individually; Charles E. Starbuck, Trustee of the Charles DB Properties, LLC; 21 E. Starbuck Trust; Del Cielo, LLC; 22 Charles P. Watling, Trustee of the First Dennis and Susan Ryder, individually; Charles P. Watling Family Trust; Dennis Brown; 23 Charline L. Rich and Richard Gibson Jr., Dennis Wood and Margaret Vigil Wood, individually; individually; 24 Christopher and Tina Abe, individually; Diane Ruth White, Trustee of the Diane Christopher Hart; Ruth White Living Trust; 25 Christopher Moore and Mary Moore, Dive Deep, LLC; 26 individually as Trustees of the Christopher Donald and Wendy Givens, individually; Moore and Mary Moore Trust; Donald Campbell; 27 Cindy Prose; Donna and James Kleeburg, individually; Clair and Stacey Harding, individually; Dorothy Holmes, Trustee of the Holmes 28 Claudia Zenobia Linarte, Trustee of the Olga Trust; - 43 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Dorothy Lanquist; Glenn and Lori Ahlberg, individually; Douglas Freeman and Miranda Gordon and Patricia Black, individually; 2 MargettGunild Seadrifts, individually; Gralar, LLC; 3 DZ SPE, LLC; Graydon and Helen Harrah, Individually; Earl G. Holder, Trustee of the Holder Gregory and Michele Hammed, individually; 4 Survivors Trust; Gregory Cavette; Edward and Geraldine Lee, individually; Gregory Grant and Mary King, individually; 5 Edward C. Leicht and Jacqueline M. Leicht, Hans and Annika Gruenn, individually; individually as Trustees of the Leicht Family Hendrika Maria Von Hecht; 6 2013 Revocable Trust; Henry and Geneva Oliva, individually; 7 Eleanor Small; Henry and Leslie Sohm, individually; Elena Dhyansky, Trustee of the Elena Howard and Irene Hoos, individually; 8 Dhyansky Trust; Hugh and Lindsay Thomson, individually; Elizabeth Keenen; Intell Ventura, LLC; 9 Elton Pedersen and Alma Clayton Pedersen, Irma Tracy; individually; Jackie M. Springer, Trustee to the Jackie M. 10 Eric and Jodi Perdue, individually; and Lanie Jo Springer Trust; 6 9 0 5 9

4 Eric and Ming Jun Nakamura, individually; James and Andrea Pendleton, individually; 3

9 11

P

L E A L Eric and Trisha Johnson, individually; James and Gayle David, individually; T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Eric Lawrence Bernthal, Special Trustee of James and Staci Valencia, individually; O

, G O S T F E I I E E the Boss and Venice Trust; James and Sue Mills, individually; L R E C A I K R 13 F C Eric Lewis and Bobbi Roderick Lewis, James and Trisha Proud, individually;

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N individually; James and Zelda Carr, individually; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L Erik and Tirica Eads, individually; James Peck; C

T

. S T N

E U Eugene and Charlotte Elerding, individually; James I. Pio, Trustee of the James I. Pio 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A Evelyn Frament; Trust; W 16 Fortune Builders, Inc.; Jan M. Hiester, Trustee of the Jan M. Hiester Frank Robert Walker Jr. and Carrie Ellen 2014 Living Trust; 17 Walker, individually as Co-Trustees of the Jane E. Hanchett, Trustee of the Hanchett Walker Jr. Living Trust; Family Trust; 18 Frederick and Lori Ponce, individually; Jane Spiller, Trustee of the Jane Spiller 19 Galen and Maria David, individually; Trust; Gary Hirschkron, Trustee of the Gary Janet Lewis, Trustee of the Janet T. Lewis 20 Hirschkron Revocable Trust; Family Trust; Gary L. Wolfe, Successor Trustee of the Janet Peck, Trustee of the Janet Lee Peck 21 Carolyn M. Tastad Revocable Trust; Living Trust; 22 Gary and Terri McCaskill, individually as Jeannette Curtis; Trustees of the McCaskill Family Trust; Jeffrey E. Frank, Trustee of The Frank Trust; 23 Gary Speeds and Lisa R. Kirby, individually Jeffrey Tubbs and Lynn Dubowy Duran, as Trustees of the Gary Speeds and Lisa individually; 24 Kirby Family Trust; Jennie Scott, Trustee of the Jennie Scott Gelb Enterprises; Family Trust; 25 George and Pamela Zeller, individually; Jennifer Ware and Jamie Selby, individually; 26 George and Roxanne Pelt, individually; Jeremy August and Icole Marie Ferro, George Hernandez; Individually; 27 George Lawhead, Trustee of the George and Jesse Wadsworth and Susan Hynds, Carole Lawhead Revocable Trust; individually; 28 Girl Scouts Of California's Central Coast; Jesus Cornejo and Idania Yudith Cornejo, - 44 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 individually; Kenneth S. Collins, Trustee of the Frank R. Joan Kenton, Trustee of The Joan Kenton Walker, Jr. Trust; 2 Living Trust; Kent and Patricia Hardley, individually; 3 Joanna Pope; Kevin K. Cox and Mary C. Cox, individually Jody Callegari; as Trustees of the Cox Family Trust; 4 Joel Hernandez; Kim Jirka, Trustee of the Kim Jirka Trust; Johanna Collins; Konstantin Demidov; 5 John and Lisa Dillard, individually; Kyle Brown; John and Mari Allen, individually; Lance and Donelle Woleslagle, individually; 6 John and Nancy Bevans, individually; Larry and Cecilia Hickok, individually; 7 John and Nila Ventress, individually; Larry Hubenthal, individually and as Trustee John Edward and Evonne Louise Vacca, of the Larry Hubenthal Living Trust; 8 individually; Laszlo and Sharon Bihari, individually; John Gutierrez; Laszlo Engelman, Trustee of the Engeman 9 John Mazzola and April Golden, Family Trust individually; Laughing Dog Ranch, LLC; 10 John Taft Corporation; Laverne M. Browning; 6 9 0 5 9

4 Jon Hanson; Lawrence and Rachel Clevenson, 3

9 11

P

L E A L Jonathan and Jacqueline Parker, individually; T I

I N R U F E R S 12 individually; Leon and Cecelia Carter, individually; O

, G O S T F E I I E E Jonathan and Julie Teichert, individually; Leonard Fischer; L R E C A I K R 13 F C Jose Juarez and Ana Valencia, individually; Lorenzo Gama and Ylda Cisnero,

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N Jose Valadez and Norma Hernandez, individually; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L individually; Loretta May Williams, aka Loretta May C

T

. S T N

E U Joseph Palmoutsos as Trustee of the Joseph Blackburn, Trustee of the Loretta May 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A Constantinos Palmoutsos Living Trust; Williams Revocable Living Trust; W 16 Joseph Polito, Trustee of the Joseph R Polito Lucille Jane Conforti and Randall Norman 1989 Trust; Kirk, individually as Co-Trustees of the 17 Joshua Antelman; "Lucille Jane Conforti Trust"; Joyce Frenette; Lynn and Ann Henne, individually; 18 Juan Espinoza and Travis Coker, Lynn Gotch and Linda Oliver, individually; 19 individually; Manuel and Sandy Garcia, individually; Juana and Henry Murillo; individually; Marilyn Wallace, Trustee of the Marilyn 20 June M. Spar, Trustee of the June M. Spar Wallace Separate Property Trust; Living Trust; Mario Aguirre and Patrice Vernand, 21 Jurgen Gramckow and Geraldine individually; 22 Gramckow, individually as Trustees of the Mark and Megan Steffy, individually; J&G Trust; Mark Anthony and Kim Marie Crane, 23 Justin and Rachael Jayne, individually; individually; Karen Mendoza, Trustee of the Vork Family Mark Robbins, Trustee of the Mark Robbins 24 Trust; Trust; Katherine Patton and Virginia Mcconnell, Mark Thompson; 25 individually; Martin and Darian O'brien, individually; 26 Kathleen Turner and Elizabeth Renn, Martin and Linda Gramckow, individually; individually; Martin Gramckow, Trustee of the Monika G. 27 Kay Burns; Huss Irrevocable Trust, Trustee of the Karin Ken Collin; W. Gramckow Irrevocable Trust, Trustee of 28 Kenneth and Maria Baker, individually; the Kurt J. Gramckow Irrevocable Trust; - 45 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Marvel Pierce; Ojai Valley Conservancy; MaryAnn Hepp Hill, Trustee of the Hill Orville and Marion Hernvall, individually; 2 Family Trust; Orville and Pamela Hibdon, individually; 3 Mary Bergen, Trustee of the Rosemary Hall Oswaldo and Norma Ruiz, individually; Bergen Trust; Pacific Telephone and Telegraph Company; 4 Mary Morrison; Pamela Wood; Mary Walkart and William Hastings, Patric and Margaret Peake, individually; 5 individually; Patricia and Edward Lansberg, individually; Matilija Canyon Alliance; Patricia Cuenot; 6 Matthew and Claudia Wilson, individually; Patrick and Cathy Pagnusat, individually; 7 Matthew Arreola; Paul and Angela Booth, individually; Matthew Bowe; Paul and Ashley Ramsey, individually; 8 Matthew Dwyer and Colleen Walker, Paul and Maria Lozano, individually; individually; Paul and Martha Medlar, individually; 9 Matthew Larrew and Jordana Kaban, Paul and Opal Skaggs, individually; individually; Peter and Kelli Freiberg, individually; 10 Matthew Simon and Amanda Vino, Peter and Robin Shedlosky, individually; 6 9 0 5 9

4 individually; Peter Brooks and Carla Brooks, individually 3

9 11

P

L E A L Michael and Carol Davis, individually; and as Trustees of the Escoda Brooks Family T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Michael and Cindy Boehm, individually; Trust; O

, G O S T F E I I E E Michael and Hannalore Gresser, Peter Cambier, Trustee of the Peter and L R E C A I K R 13 F C individually; Marilyn Cambier Trust;

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N Michael and Kathy Ogden, individually; Peter Schey, LLC; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L Michael and Kim Regan, individually; Peuvlin Vong; C

T

. S T N

E U Michael and Marie Mctavish, individually; Philip and Delia Smith, individually; 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A Michael and Patricia Mcweeney, Philip Ferrante Jr. and Nicole Aversa- W 16 individually; Ferrante, individually; Michael Coggins Jr. and Cynthia Coggins, Philippe Rousseau and Kimberly Shobe, 17 individually; individually; Michael Greynald, Trustee of the Greynald Phyllis Courtney; 18 Family Trust; Rafael Hernandez; 19 Michael L. Rockhold, Trustee of the Michael Ramona L. Andrew, Trustee of the Ramona Rockhold Trust; L. Andrews Trust; 20 Michael Tello; Rancho Arnaz, LLC; Michele Willis and Johanna Collins, Rancho Casitas, LLC; 21 individually; Rancho Sueno, LLC; 22 Miguel A. Mayorga, Trustee of the Edward Ray and Carolina Guillen, individually; R. Mayorga Living Trust; Raymond and Annette West, individually; 23 Mitchael and Rubeena Breese, individually; Richard and Laura Mancilla, individually; Mitchell and Ana Yount, individually; Richard and Alexandra Dubeau, 24 Mitchell and Joy Dalbey, individually; individually; Mitchell and Lisa Myers, individually; Richard and Cynthia Robinett, individually; 25 Nancy Moore, Trustee of the Nancy Anne Richard Bolton; 26 Moore Separate Property Trust; Richard Mathieu and Claudia Herrera Nikolas and Julia Krankl, individually; Mathieu, individually; 27 Offshore Crane, Inc.; Richard Michael and Margaret Kenny, Offshore Crane and Service Company, Inc.; individually; 28 Offshore Facilities; Richard Wiles and Peggy Carey, - 46 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 individually; Skynest, LLC; Robert Alan and Stacey Jean Boyd, Societe d’Investissement Immobiliers et 2 individually; Financiers Franco-Allemand, a French 3 Robert and Carolyn Jarboe, individually; corporation; Robert and Judith Clark, individually; Stanley Stephen Roslansky and Linda 4 Robert and Nickey Gregory, individually; Roslansky, individually as Trustees of the Robert and Patricia Mcfall, individually; Roslansky Family Trust; 5 Robert and Susan Bennitt, individually; Stephen and Carin Kally, individually; Robert and Anna J. Auric, individually as Stephen and Cindy Barrack, individually; 6 Trustees of the Auric Revocable Trust of Stephen Carr and Debra Gill, individually; 7 1999; Stephen M. Johnson, Trustee of the Stephen Robert Levin and Lisa Solinas, individually; M. Johnson Living Trust; 8 Robert Mark and Lorraine Melisa Lovato, Stephen Sanford; individually; Stephen Zane Fraser; 9 Robert OConnor; Stuart and Nancy Rupp, individually; Robert Petrin and Beate Schickerling, Sudarshan Gautam; 10 individually; Susan Gary; 6 9 0 5 9

4 Robert L. Stone, Trustee of the Robert L. Susan M. Ralph, Trustee of the Ralph Trust; 3

9 11

P

L E A L Stone Revocable Living Trust; Susan Yarnell; T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Robert S. Young, Trustee of the Young Sushma Gujral; O

, G O S T F E I I E E Trust; Suzanne Rhodes, Trustee of the Bateman- L R E C A I K R 13 F C Ronald and Janis Calkins, individually; Rhodes Family Trust;

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N Ronald Kaplan and Cynthia Daniels, T. Snyder; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L individually; Tamarra Barbey; C

T

. S T N

E U Rudolph and Carol Saldamando, Tane Charles Arnold, individually and as 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A individually; Trustee of the Tane C. Arnold 2006 Living W 16 Russell James Hall, Trustee of the Russell Trust James Hall Family Trust; Teen Challenge of Southern California, Inc.; 17 Sam and Debbie Tucker, individually; Terra Crowley; Scott Alan and Eva Prince Weiss, Terrance O'Connor and Kathy Franklin, 18 individually; individually; 19 Scott and Aki Freshman, individually; Terrie Longo; Scott and Bernadette King, individually; The Baptiste Foundation; 20 Scott and Sarah Mckay, individually; The Ojai Valley Land Conservancy; Scott Gregory Erockson and Hannah Beth Theodore and Judy Lucas, individually; 21 Guzik, individually; Theodore and Norma Schneider, 22 Scott R. Johnson and Margaret Bates, individually; individually; Theodore and Tracy Mandryk, individually; 23 Serafin Calderon and Blanca Ortiz; Theodore Willis Malos, Jr. and Pearl B. individually; Malos, individually and as Trustees of the 24 Shane and Amy Watkins, individually; Malos Family Trust,; Shane Nash; Thomas and Christine Reed, individually; 25 Sharon and Bruce Spencer, individually; Thomas and Nikki Young, individually; 26 Sharon Brown, Trustee of the Sharon Brown Timothy and Nicole Beckett, individually; Living Trust; Tobias and Tania Parker, individually; 27 Shaun and Daisy Garman, individually; Todd Henard and Kibhi Marie Henard, Shirley M. Palmer, Trustee of the Shirley individually; 28 Palmer Revocable Trust; Tropico, LLC; - 47 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Victor and Sheryl Sanchez, individually; William and Helen Peck, individually; Victoria and John Junkin, individually; William and Irene Snively, individually; 2 Vida Vida, Trustee of the Vida Family Trust; William and Kimbra Carnaghe, individually; 3 Vijay and Neeta Patel, individually; William and Paula Stevens, individually; Virginia I. Williamson, individually and as William Loughboro; 4 Trustee of Trust of Virginia I. Williamson; William Starr; Virginia Trevino; Yong Yi; 5 Walid A. Alawar, Trustee of the Walid A. Yvette Marie and Daniel Joseph Sinohui, Alawar Living Trust; individually; 6 Warren Heath; Zachary and Diane Totten, individually 7 William and Cheryl Meade, individually;

8 Riparian and Overlying Landowners 9 93. City is informed and believes that the following Cross-Defendants (“Riparian and 10 Overlying Landowners”) are owners of or are beneficial interest holders in real property located 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11

P

L within the Ventura River Watershed and overlying one or more of Watershed’s Groundwater E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 O

, G O Basins (Upper Ventura River Groundwater Basin; Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin; Lower S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 F C

T & , F Ventura River Groundwater Basin; and Upper Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin), and they claim

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 A R B

M riparian rights to divert and/or extract surface and/or subsurface water from the Ventura River L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 N 0

L and/or its tributaries, whether or not they have exercised such riparian rights, and/or they claim 0 2 A W 16 overlying rights to extract groundwater from one or more of the Watershed’s Groundwater 17 Basins, whether or not they have exercised such overlying rights: 18 19 1300 Shippee Lane, LLC; Alan and Susan Ecker, individually; 3584 Calle Moreno, LLC; Alan Walbridge and Dorothy Fay 20 Aaron and Angela Hoekstra, individually; Walbridge, individually; Abel and Lourdes Carranza, individually; Alberto and Adriana Montano, individually; 21 Acslayton, LLC; Alberto and Hilda Zamora, individually; 22 Adam Casey and Brittany Chisum, Albine Hopcus and Alva Lydia Hopcus, individually; individually as Trustees of the Al and Alva 23 Adam Distl, Jr. and Barbara B. Distl, Trust; individually as Trustees of the Adam Distl, Alfonso and Alejandra Limon, individually; 24 Jr. and Barbara B. Distl 1998 Revocable Allan and Janis Parkhurst, individually; Trust; Allan and Katharine Parigian, individually; 25 Adrian Ogden; Allan and Mary Doane, individually; 26 Aera Energy, LLC; Allen Vail; Ajr Investment Partnership, LP; Alvaro and Elva Ruiz, individually; 27 Alan and Deborah Sharon, individually; Alvin and Claudia Cunningham, Alan and Leslie Connell, individually; individually; 28 Alan and Mary Kirby, individually; - 48 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Ana Cross, Trustee of the Ana Cross Family Bradley and Ivelou Pantoskey, individually; Trust; Brand and Tressa Kahler, individually; 2 Andre Keunzli and Fabrienne Keunzli- Brandon and Kelsie Schneider, individually 3 Monard, individually; and as Trustees of the Brandon Schneider Andrew and Melissa Maccalla, individually; and Kelsie Simms-Schneider Family Trust; 4 Andrew and Rebecca Chandler, individually; Breal and Karen Rowe, individually; Andrew and Sharon Engel, individually; Brendan Richard and Christa Lee Dawn 5 Angela Jayne Gardner and John Percival Freeman, individually; Mawson, individually as Trustees of the Brent and Pamela Lamo, individually; 6 Pleasant Avenue Living Trust; Brett and Lynn Wilson, individually; 7 Anita J. Diaz; Brett Cunningham; Ann H. Donlon, Trustee of the Ann H. Brett Nicholson and Nan Davis, 8 Donlon Revocable Trust; individually; Anna Archer; Brian and Cynthia McDaniel, individually; 9 Anna Kirkwood; Brian and Erin Edwards, individually; Anne and Daniel Goldstein, individually; Brian and Jean Harrison, individually; 10 Anson B. Thacher and Anne F. Thacher, Brian and Marie Haase, individually; 6 9 0 5 9

4 individually as Trustees of the A. and A. Brian and Siobhan Calvin, individually; 3

9 11

P

L E A L Thacher Living Trust; Brian A. Schaffels; T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Anthony Becchio and Denise Heimo, Brian Osborne and Kirsten Hinrichs, O

, G O S T F E I I E E individually; individually; L R E C A I K R 13 F C Anthony Masiel; Brittany and Alan Fletcher, individually;

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N Antonio Espino and Maria Torres, Bruce and Leslie Bouche, individually; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L individually; Bruce and Virginia Hibberd, individually; C

T

. S T N

E U Arne Anselm and Michelle Velderrain, Bruce C. Brockman and Bridget Tsao- 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A individually; Brockman, individually as Trustees of the W 16 Arne Anselm, Trustee of the Velderrain M. Tsao Brockman Family Trust; Trust; Bryan and Nicole Crawford, individually; 17 Ashley and Victoria Edwards, individually; Bulmaro and Alfonsa Pena, individually; Baldemar Alcantar and Micaela Ortiz Byron and Jennifer Greene, individually; 18 Alcantar, individually; Byron Rader and Myra Toth, individually; 19 Barbara A. Fitzgerald, Trustee of the Cal B. Land Co., LLC; Fitzgerald 1994 Trust; Calatlantic Group Inc.; 20 Barbara Bonsignori; Camp Ramah in California Inc.; Barbara Chen Lowentha, Trustee of the 2017 Carl and Judith Bell, individually; 21 Barbara Kay Chen Lowenthal Revocable Carl and Leigh Hyndman, individually; 22 Trust; Carl Gaddis and Anna Hicks, individually; Barbara Hall, Trustee of the Barbara Hall Carla Dennis, Trustee of the Carla D. Dennis 23 Living Trust; Trust; Barnard Properties, LLC; Carla Melson and Carla J. Melson, 24 Bart Kennedy; individually as Trustees of the Carla J. Barton Kennedy; Melson Revocable Living Trust; 25 Bernard Martin; Carmen and Carolina Murillo, individually; 26 Beth E. Lindley; Carol Marquez-Olson, Trustee of the Carol Bettyann Sessing; Marquez-Olson Trust; 27 Big Black Dog, LLC; Carol Vesecky, Trustee of the Carol B. Blaze Buonpane; Vesecky Revocable Living Trust; 28 Bradley and Andrea Roe, individually; - 49 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Caroline Turner, Trustee of the Turner Cindy Burkhart, Trustee of the Cindy Survivors Trust; Burkhart Living Trust; 2 Carolyn Bowman, Trustee of the Carolyn City of Ojai; 3 Bowman 2008 Trust; Claudia Farr, Trustee of the Sam S. Farr and Carolyn Huish; Claudia S. Farr Trust; 4 Caryn Molinelli; Claudia Wunderlich, Trustee of the Claudia Catherine Lancaster; A Wunderlich Trust; 5 Catherine Sellman; Clementine Turner, Trustee of the Catherine Smith, Trustee of the Catherine L. Clementine Turner Living Trust; 6 Smith Revocable Trust; Cody Green; 7 Cesar and Davienne Guerra, individually; Cody Stevens; Cesar Jimenez and Aura Minera, Connie Anaise; 8 individually; Connie and Mark Cline, Trustee of the Mark Chaarenne Torris and Raymond Bradley, Terry Cline Family Trust; 9 individually; Constance Eaton; Southern California Association of Seventh Cory and Nicholas Wingate, individually; 10 Day Adventists; County of Ventura; 6 9 0 5 9

4 Chad Carper; Craig and Stephanie Gardner, individually; 3

9 11

P

L E A L Chad Ress and Stephanie Washburn, Craig Young and Daniel Poling, T I

I N R U F E R S 12 individually; individually; O

, G O S T F E I I E E Chad Vick, Trustee of the Chad C. Vick Culbert Family Partnership; L R E C A I K R 13 F C Trust; Curtis and Christina Tolmie, individually;

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N Charlene Van Deusen; Cynthia Ellis and Pamela Thomas, I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L Charles and Deana Sherry, individually; individually; C

T

. S T N

E U Charles and Jo Bennett, individually; Daj Properties, LLC; 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A Charles G. Barnett, Successor Trustee of the Damian and Lorie Vos, individually; W 16 "Barnett Family Exemption Equivalent Damon and Anne Brink, individually; Trust"; Daniel and Adaya Walsh, individually; 17 Charles L. Hoff and Kathleen D. Hoff, Co- Daniel and Deborah Hoyt, individually; Trustees of the Hoff Revocable Trust; Daniel and Elizabeth George, individually; 18 Charles Monn and Elena Hale, individually; Daniel and Elizabeth Mclaughlin, 19 Charles R. Rudd and Lola L. Rudd, Trustees individually; under the Charles R. Rudd and Lola L. Rudd Daniel and Jane Kelly, individually; 20 Trust; Daniel and Lydia Ruark, individually; Christie Mattull, Trustee of the Christie Daniel and Ralph Fairbanks, individually; 21 Lynn Mattull Trust; Daniel and Tomica Mora, individually; 22 Christine and Donald Bowen, individually; Daniel and Yoko Mcsweeney, individually; Christine Golden; Daniel Chrynko; 23 Christopher and Anna Rhoda, individually; Daniel Crane; Christopher and Gillian Borgeson, Daniel H. I. and William D. Moses Jr., 24 individually; individually as Trustees of the William D. Christopher and Shelagh Duke, individually; Moses, Jr. Separate Trust No. 1; 25 Christopher Corsones, Trustee of the Daniel Hultgen, Trustee of the Hultgen 26 Christopher Corsones Living Trust; Living Trust; Christopher McGuire; Danny Haar and Mariska De Feiter, 27 Christopher Sewell; individually; Christopher Weiner and Damian Bourguet, Darrell Ralston, Trustee of the Darrell 28 individually; Anthony Ralston 2009 Revocable Trust; - 50 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Dave and Kathleen Tarrats, individually; Diana Peron, Trustee of the Diana C Peron David and Beverly Fulton, individually; Living Trust; 2 David and Carol Cintron, individually; Diana Syvertson, Trustee of the Diana 3 David and Deborah Todd, individually; Syvertson Living Trust; David and Donna Berger, individually; Diana Trent, Trustee of the Diana Trent 4 David and Elizabeth Silva, individually; Living Trust; David and Fereschta Sinclair, individually; Diane and William Clegg, individually; 5 David and Karen Brubaker, individually; Dianne Mccourtney, Trustee of the Dianne David and Kathleen Ostby, individually; Louise Mccourtney Trust; 6 David and Laura Meisch, individually; Dolores Keith; 7 David and Laurie Mahan, individually; Dominic Habibi; David and Meghan Sandoval, individually; Donald and Clara Tenpenny, individually; 8 David and Mindy Benezra, individually; Donald Brosnac and Twila Carlsen, David and Peggy Stanwood, individually; individually; 9 David and Sandra Murillo, individually; Donald Davis; David and Shannon Richard, individually; Donald G. and Susan B. Davis, individually 10 David and Sharron Sparks, individually; as Trustees of the Donald G. and Susan B. 6 9 0 5 9

4 David and Stephanie Berger, individually; Davis Revocable Family Trust of 1997; 3

9 11

P

L E A L David and Toni Johnson, individually; Donis Montoya Jr. and Teresita Montoya, T I

I N R U F E R S 12 David Corey and Jean Scholes, individually; individually; O

, G O S T F E I I E E David E. Pressey and Agnes E. Pressey, Donna Deitch, Trustee of the Donna E. L R E C A I K R 13 F C individually as Trustees of the David E. and Deitch Trust;

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N Agnes E. Pressey Family Trust; Donna Epstein, Trustee of the Epstein I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L David Kille and Shannon Frew, individually; Survivors' Trust, Trustee of the Epstein C

T

. S T N

E U David L. Garber and Cynthia Garber, Marital Trust, and Trustee of the Epstein 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A individually as Trustees of the Garber Trust; Bypass Trust; W 16 David Orbach and Eva Araujo, individually; Dorothy and James Kehoe, individually; David Stanley and Monica Bednar Stanley, Dorthea Keck; 17 individually; Douglas and Ann Parent, individually; Dawn and Barclay Hope, individually; Douglas and Claudia Webber, individually; 18 De and Jacque Pisciotta, individually; Douglas and Elisabeth Vernand, 19 Dean and Gloria Vadnais, individually; individually; Dean and Lorinda Strong, individually; Douglas and Kathleen Leighton, 20 Deanna Gonzales, individually; individually; Deirdre Lynds, individually; Douglas and Moira Volpi, individually; 21 Delavan C. Garst and Sharon D. Garst, Douglas Draper; 22 individually as Trustees of the Delavan and Douglas Wasson, Trustee of the Wasson Sharon Garst Family Trust; Trust; 23 Dell and Anne Mercer, individually; Dustin Beilke; Delores and Jerry Berlin, individually; Ed and Linda Colby, individually; 24 Denise Wizman, as Trustee of the Denise Edson Taft, Trustee of the Edson B. Taft Wizman Revocable Trust; Revocable Trust; 25 Dennis and Cheryl Jacobs, individually; Edward and Deborah Guerra, individually; 26 Dennis and Nadine Corte, individually; Edward and Laura Savala, individually; Derek Meek; Edward and Nancy Dennis, individually; 27 Devon and Jilliann Collinge, individually; Edward and Nancy Necker, individually; Diana Engle, Trustee of the Diana L Engle Edward and Roberta Walsh, individually; 28 Revocable Trust; - 51 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Edward Dunn and Judith Shelby Dunn, Floyd and Charlene Fitzgerald, individually; individually; Floyd Eugene Wiancko and Hiroko 2 Edward Pressey; Wiancko, Trustees of the Wiancko Family 3 Edwin Norris Procter, Trustee of the "E. Trust; Norris Procter Living Trust"; Forest Home, Inc.; 4 Eilam Byle, Trustee of the Eilam Byle Fortune Real Estate 888, LLC; Living Trust; Francis and Shauna Longstaff, individually; 5 Eileen Sterling, Trustee of the Eileen M. Francisco and Angelica Valles, individually; Sterling Revocable Trust; Frank and Lila Sheltren, individually; 6 Eileen Walker; Frank C. Urias and Evangeline S. Urias, 7 El Sereno 1225, LLC; individually as Trustees of the Urias Family Elaiene Keeley, Trustee of the Elaiene Trust; 8 Keeley Trust; Frank Charolla; Elaine Ferguson; Frank Edward Sheltren, Jr., aka Frank E. 9 Eli and Jessica Neiderhiser; Sheltren and Rita Cheryl Sheltrem, Elia Aldapa; individually as Trustees of the Sheltren 10 Elizabeth Bauer, Trustee of the Elizabeth A Family Trust; 6 9 0 5 9

4 Bauer Trust; Fred and Carine Fisher, individually; 3

9 11

P

L E A L Ellen Leopold; Fred and Donna Stevens, individually; T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Elmer and Joan Swift; Fred Kramer and Michaela Watkins, O

, G O S T F E I I E E Emily Benson and Lisa Martel, individually; individually; L R E C A I K R 13 F C Emily Clay and Matthew Goodman, Frederic Devault;

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N individually; Frederick and Laura Fulmer, individually; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L Erbay and Velda Garcia, individually; Frederick Sloman and Nordi Hintze, C

T

. S T N

E U Eric and Arlene Schwerdtfeger, individually; individually; 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A Eric and Jolene Harrington, individually; Fredrick and Roxanne Baker, individually; W 16 Eric Bush and Craig Young, individually; Future Mhps, LLC; Eric Dilks, Trustee of the Eric M. Dilks 2004 Gabriel and Margarita Mendoza, 17 Revocable Trust; individually; Eric Goode; Gale and Bernabe Gaona Jr., individually; 18 Eric Moore; Gary and Chari Petrowski, individually; 19 Eric Rosenberg; Gary and Colleen Fry, individually; Ernest and Dorothy Nichols, individually; Gary and Jolene Clarke, individually; 20 Ernest Thornsberry, Trustee of the Ernest Gary and Judith Stever, individually; Thornsberry Revocable Trust; Gary and Patricia Tucker, individually; 21 Esperanza and Sandra Guerrero, Gary and Teresa Downard, individually; 22 individually; Gene and Patty Saito, individually; Eugenijus Valiulis, Trustee of the Eugenijus Genneva Maschler and Richard Yaciuk, 23 Valiulis Revocable Living Trust; individually; Eusebio and Lori Navarro, individually; Geoffrey and Paula Clarke, individually; 24 Evelyn Baran, Trustee of the Evelyn F Baran Geoffrey Brown and Stephanie Gibson, Personal Residence Trust; individually; 25 Ezequiel and Amber Monarrez, individually; George and Linda Boston, individually; 26 Felix and Delmy Garcia, individually; George and Lynn Malone, individually; Fernando Porras; George and Margaret Melton, individually; 27 Feroz and Mona Zaidi, individually; George and Sigrid Bressler, individually; Finch Farms, LLC; George Stuart; 28 Merewether Judson, LLC; Gerald and Darlene Carlson, individually; - 52 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Gerard Linsmeier; H. H. Leard and Beverly Leard, individually Gerben and Jill Hoeksma, individually; as Trustees to the Leard Family Trust 2 Gino Lynch; Hickey Bros Land Co. Inc.; 3 Glenn Myers, Trustee of the Glenn C. Myers Holly Bassuk; Family Trust; Howard and Ruth Miller, individually; 4 Gordon and Terry Hanusek, individually; Howard Altman, Trustee of the Gerta Maritz Gordon Gibbons, Trustee of the Gordon R. Trust; 5 Gibbons Living Trust; Hoyt Tarola; Grant Kemp; Ian and Carol Atkinson, individually; 6 Greg and Julie Tebo, individually; Ignacio and Rose Vega, individually; 7 Gregg and Rosie Dierickx, individually; Imelda Mares, Trustee of the Imelda Mares Gregg Olson, Trustee of the Gregg W. Olson Trust; 8 Revocable Trust; Industrial Ventura; Gregory and Kaori Golden, individually; Integritas Ojai, LLC; 9 Gregory and Martha Lepine, individually; Irma Cruz; Gregory and Sarah Delvecchio, individually; Irshad and Linda Haque, individually; 10 Gregory and Susan Gilbert, individually; Isidro Sanchez; 6 9 0 5 9

4 Gregory and Susan Ignacio, individually; J Investments; 3

9 11

P

L E A L Gregory and Suzanne Combs; J McGlinchey; T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Gregory Heras and Rozanne Bonavito, Jack and Marie Kenton, individually; O

, G O S T F E I I E E individually; Jack and Simone Patterson, individually; L R E C A I K R 13 F C Gregory Johnson; Jack and Verna Turbyville, individually;

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N Gregory N. Pimstone and Lauryn B. Harris, Jacob and Anja Zimmerman, individually; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L individually as Trustees of the Pimstone Jacqueline Dorfman, Trustee of the C

T

. S T N

E U Family Trust; Jacqueline Dorfman Revocable Living Trust; 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A Griffin and Nicole Williamson, individually; Jacqueline Urband; W 16 Gudaz, LLC; Jakob and Marianne Vos, individually; Guy and Sheri Flasch, individually; James and Alisa Varney, individually; 17 Guy Bratton; James and Daniela Casey, individually; H and Beverly Leard, individually; James and Dori Sandefer, individually; 18 Hacienda Ladera, LLC; James and Janet Lecroy, individually; 19 Hank and Alana Garcia, individually; James and Laura Fernandez, individually; Hans and Eileen Van Koppen, individually; James and Maryetta Sanders, individually; 20 Harald Wagner; James and Penny Harvey, individually; Harlan Kossow; James and Randi Catlett, individually; 21 Harrison Hill and Lauren Wilson, James and Wendy Osher, individually; 22 individually; James Data; Harry and Marilyn Lehr, individually; James Finley, Trustee of the James and M. 23 Harry Joe; Reen Finley Family Trust; Hayden and Raquel White, individually; James Finch, Trustee of the Finch Family 24 Heidi C. Kurtz, Trustee of the Gunild Walsh Trust; Seadrift Qprt FBO Heidi C. Kurtz; James J. Finch and Lorraine Holve Finch, 25 Hector and Rocio Torres, individually; individually as Trustees of the James J. 26 Heliberta Valencia; Finch and Loraine Holve Finch Living Trust; Help of Ojai, Inc.; James Paul Finch; 27 Henry and Moira Tarmy, individually; James Kirk and Jacelyn Hayes, individually; Hermann and Gay Thomsen, individually; James Selman, Trustee of the James C. 28 Selman Revocable Inter Vivos Trust; - 53 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 James W. Coultas and Margaret Coultas, Jess Earl Long; Trustees of the James A. and Margaret H. Jessie Stricchiola and Rosemary Garrison, 2 Coultas Intervivos Trust; individually as Trustees of the Phoenix 3 Terry Coultas Wilson; Revocable Trust; James W. Coultas, Trustee of the Coultas Jesus and Maria Ramos, individually; 4 Living Trust; Jill Olivares, Trustee of the Jill Ann Olivares Jan and Priscilla Granade, individually; Revocable Living Trust; 5 Jane Mccord, Trustee of the Jane Ann Jimmy and Theresa Ramirez, individually; Mccord Living Trust; JLB Rancho Vista, LLC; 6 Janet Mcginnis, Trustee of the Janet Karen Joan Geddes and John Saluppo, individually; 7 Mcginnis Trust; Joan Robles; Janice and Jesse Hillestad, individually; Joann Benson, Trustee of the Joann Alva 8 Janice Hall, Trustee of the Hall Trust; Benson Revocable Living Trust; Janis Long Nicholas and Jess E. Long, Joanne Barnes, Trustee of the Barnes Family 9 individually as Co-Trustees of the Long Trust; Family Trust; Joel Fox and Jennifer Day, individually; 10 Jason and Jene Loomis, individually; Joel Vuylsteke, Trustee of the Country Club 6 9 0 5 9

4 Jason and Kathryn Headley, individually; Trust; 3

9 11

P

L E A L Jason and Lana Spear, individually; Johanna Rae Long; T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Jason Loomis; John and A. Elrod, individually; O

, G O S T F E I I E E Jasper and Jessica Jones, individually; John and Alitea Maruszewski, individually; L R E C A I K R 13 F C Jayne Pendergast, Trustee of the 2014 Jayne John and Crystal Peakes, individually;

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N E Pendergast Trust; John and Janis Nicholas, individually; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L Jeff and Cheree Simons, individually; John and Lucille Elrod, individually; C

T

. S T N

E U Jeff and Desiree Wilby, individually; John and Monica Hartmann, individually; 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A Jeff Mabry; John and Norma Curtis, individually; W 16 Jefferie Skaggs and Timothy Bunce, John and Parris Collins, individually; individually; John and Patricia Essick, individually; 17 Jeffrey and Denise Helm, individually; John and Tonya Peralta, individually; Jeffrey and Donna Meyer, individually; John and Victoria Bortolussi, individually; 18 Jeffrey and Holly Lieber, individually; John Battel, Trustee of the John J Battel 19 Jeffrey Jenson; Living Trust; Jeffrey Kenton, Trustee of the Jeffrey T. John Broomfield, Trustee of the John 20 Kenton 2004 Revocable Living Trust; Nicholas Broomfield Trust; Jeffrey S. Bacon, Trustee of the Villa Nero John F. Johnston and Katherine M. Johnston, 21 Trust; individually as Trustees of the John Fraser 22 Jeffrey Weinstein; Johnston Family Trust; Jeffry and Fiona Pougher, individually; John Haigh; 23 Jennifer Kistler, Trustee of the Jennifer L John Kertis; Kistler Trust; John Mutlow; 24 Jeremy and Brittania Rennie, individually; John Pace, Trustee of the John Brice Pace Jeri Leonard; Family Trust; 25 Jerome H. Hittleman and Lynne M. John Richardson; 26 Goldfarb, Trustees of the Jerome H. John Vineyard; Hittleman and Lynne M. Goldfarb John Warner and Jennifer Dunn, 27 Revocable 2016 Trust; individually; Jerry Dean Miner and Geraldine Ann Miner, John Willingham; 28 Trustees of the Miner Trust; John Winspear; - 54 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 John Young; Katharine and John Broesamle, individually; Jonathan Wong and Jan Komura, Kathleen and Adam Morrison, individually; 2 individually; Kathleen and Thomas German, individually; 3 Jose and Imelda Hurtado, individually; Kathleen Bachelor; Jose and Lisa Mendez, individually; Kathleen Nolan, Trustee of the Kathleen 4 Jose Arreola Jr. and Paola Carreno, Ann Nolan Revocable 2006 Family Trust; individually; Kathryn Bartholomew, Trustee of the 5 Jose Olvera and Alma Valenciano, Kathryn Oconnor Bartholomew Living individually; Trust; 6 Joseph and Drenda Pledger, individually; Kathy Alderman; 7 Joseph Lynn and Elvira Lilly Barthelemy, Katz Pincetl Orchard, LLC; individually and Trustees of the Joseph Lynn Kay Dornbusch, Trustee of the The 8 Barthelemy and Elvira Lilly Barthelemy Dornbusch Family Living Trust; 2002 Family Trust; Keith and Anahid Jewett, individually; 9 Joseph and Kathleen Lasalle, individually; Keith and Robin Lawson, individually; Joseph and Michelle Harwell, individually; Keith and Victoria Nightingale, individually; 10 Joseph and Nina Neulight, individually; Kelley and John Dyer IV, individually; 6 9 0 5 9

4 Joseph and Shirley Gholson, individually; Kelvin Dodd and Deborah Gomez, 3

9 11

P

L E A L Joseph Lam; individually; T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Joseph Randall, Trustee of the Joseph Kenett Niessen; O

, G O S T F E I I E E Darden Randall Revocable Trust; Kenneth and Anne Boydston, individually; L R E C A I K R 13 F C Joseph Reseigh; Kenneth and Brenda Whitteker, individually;

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N Joseph Tooker; Kenneth and Carol Fergeson, individually; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L Joshua and Jennifer Goldstein, individually; Kenneth and Elizabeth Gruber, individually; C

T

. S T N

E U Joshua Moreau; Kenneth and Laura Brown, individually; 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A Joyce and Frank Patota, individually; Kenneth and Michael Ballard, individually; W 16 Juan and Gloria Estrada, individually; Kenneth and Sarah Van Dyke, individually; Juan and Maria Martinez, individually; Kenneth Morgan; 17 Judith Reichman and Harold Brown, Kenneth Vadnais; individually; Kern County; 18 Julianne Bloomer and Philip Rabe, Kevin and Asli Ruf, individually; 19 individually; Kevin and Jennifer White, individually; Julie Centeno; Kevin and Joanne Olsland, individually; 20 Julio Luna and Debbie Lun, individually; Kevin and Jodi Dunn, individually; June Sears, Trustee of the June Katherine Khaled A. Al-Awar and Sheryl L. Al-Awar, 21 Sears Living Trust; individually as Trustees of the K. and S. Al- 22 Jupeto Properties, LLC; Awar Family Trust; Kac LLC; Kiki Lyon, Trustee of the Kiki Lyon Living 23 Karen L. Hanson and Lawrence S. Hanson, Trust; Trustees of the Hanson L.S. Revocable Kim Hanna, Trustee of the Hanna Family 24 Living Trust; Trust; Karen Phipps, Trustee of the Phipps Family Kristan Altimus; 25 Trust; Kurt and Dayna Roggenstroh, individually; 26 Karin Dron, Trustee of the Boyd S. Dron and Kurt and Luisa Neher, individually; Karin K. Dron Joint Living Trust; Kurt Patrick Zierhut and Stephanie Lee 27 Karin L. James, Trustee of the James Family Zierhut, Co-Trustees of the Living Trust of Trust; Kurt Patrick Zierhut and Stephanie Lee 28 Karl and Beverley Mallette, individually; Zierhut; - 55 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Lanspring, LP; Logan and Tiffany Gould, individually; Larry and Joyce Heath, individually; Lois Stone Erburu, as Trustee of the 2 Larry Davis; Surviving Spouse's Trust created in the 3 Larry Hubenthal, Trustee of the Larry Robert and Lois Erburu Living Trust; Hubenthal Living Trust; Lon and Margareta Kirkgaard, individually; 4 Larry Neff, Trustee of the Larry Neff Trust; Longhorn Lane, LLC; Las Encinas Mobile Home Park; Lorene Cleary; 5 Laura B. Peck and Andrew D. Viles, Lori Schloredt; individually as Trustees of the William L. Lou and Barton Matthews, individually; 6 and Laura B. Peck Trust - Marital Trust; Louis and Irene Gutierrez, individually; 7 Laura Green, Trustee of the Green Survivors Louis Price; Trust; Louise and Gary Culver, individually; 8 Laurie Johnson, Trustee of the Laurie A. Louise Konstanzer, Trustee of the Ron and Johnson Living Trust; Louise Konstanzer Family Trust; 9 Laurie Smith; Louise Tindle, Sole Trustee of the "Bypass Lawrence and Sharon McMillan, Trust" created under the Tindle Trust; 10 individually; Luis Herrera and Kimberly Oyama, 6 9 0 5 9

4 Lawrence I. and Patricia A. Hartmann, individually; 3

9 11

P

L E A L individually as Trustees of the Larry and Pat Lupe Milner, Trustee of the Lupe Milner T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Hartmann Family Trust; Family Trust; O

, G O S T F E I I E E Lee and Janet Cassel, individually; Lydia Jimenez; L R E C A I K R 13 F C Lee Fitzgerald, Trustee of the Lee I Lyle and Cecilia Hallblom, individually;

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N Fitzgerald 2007 Revocable Living Trust; Lyndon Hebenstreit; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L Lee Lebeck; Lynn Coleman; C

T

. S T N

E U Lee Rosenbaum, Trustee of the Chief Lynn Pike, Trustee of the Lynn 2016 Trust; 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A Cornerstone Trust; Lysiane Wallis; W 16 Leon and Caroline Pahle, individually; M. Snyder; Leonard Petitt and Kay Rolfe, individually; Malcolm and Brenda Knight, individually; 17 Leslee and Terry Gustafson, individually; Malcolm and Kelley McDowell, Leslie McCleary; individually; 18 Lester L. and Linda L. Barbee, individually Mandy Macaluso, Trustee of the Living 19 as Trustees of the Lester L. Barbee and Trust of Mandy Macaluso; Linda L. Barbee Joint Revocable Living Manuel Almeida and Kevin Bagley, 20 Trust; individually; Liana Harp and Nathan Jones, individually; Marcus and Amy Hueppe, individually; 21 Lilian Ruvalcaba; Marcus and Eva Kettles, individually; 22 Linda Chapman, Trustee Linda of the Jean Margaret M. Aldrich, Trustee of the Russell Chapman Living Trust; F. Aldrich and Margaret M. Aldrich 23 Linda Griffin; “Decedent’s Trust,” and Trustee of the Linda McLaughlin, Trustee of the Linda Russell F. Aldrich and Margaret M. Aldrich 24 Landrieu McLaughlin Living Trust; Living Trust; Linda Oliver, Trustee of the Linda A Oliver Margo Kelly, Trustee of the Kelly Trust; 25 2005 Revocable Living Trust; Maria Blasco; 26 Lipka Richard, Trustee of the Lorraine Trust; Maria Collins; Lisa Lopez and Brian Merrill, individually; Marie W. Wallace, Trustee of the Marie 27 Lisa Smith and Nathaniel Cox, individually; Weismiller Wallace Separate Property Trust; Lloyd Smith; Marika Zoll; 28 Logan and Misty Hagege, individually; - 56 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Marilyn Sweeney, Trustee of the Marilyn Michael and Bernard Clark, individually; Sweeney Revocable Living Trust; Michael and Carol Jackson, individually; 2 Mario and Shawn Reyes, individually; Michael and Dianna Farrar, individually; 3 Marion and Betty Earnest, individually; Michael and Heidi Bradbury, individually; Mark and Colleen Rusin, individually; Michael and Kimberly Robertson, 4 Mark and Connie Cline, individually; individually; Mark and Helen Moskovitz, individually; Michael and Nancy Krumpschmidt, 5 Mark and Marcia Albertsen, individually; individually; Mark Bellini; Michael and Sharon Williams, individually; 6 Mark W. Etchart, Trustee of the Mark W. Michael and Sonja Barrett, individually; 7 Etchart Separate Property Trust, and Trustee Michael and Terri Imwalle, individually; of the Michel A. Etchart Separate Property Michael Chambliss; 8 Trust; Michael Hoover, Trustee of the Michael Marsha MacDonald; Hoover Living Trust; 9 Marshall and Dina Murphy, individually; Michael Kelley; Martha Fast, Trustee of the Martha L Fast Michael L. Delamore and Deborah Finley- 10 Living Trust; Delamore, individually as Trustees of the 6 9 0 5 9

4 Martha Laliberte; Delamore Finley Family Trust; 3

9 11

P

L E A L Martha Moran; Michael Lombardo, Trustee of the Michael T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Martin and Barbara Pops, individually; Lombardo Living Trust; O

, G O S T F E I I E E Martin and Natalie Ehrlich, individually; Michael Marietta, individually and as L R E C A I K R 13 F C Martin and Patricia Henderson, individually; Trustee of the Marietta Separate Property

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N Mary and Thomas Snow, individually; Trust; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L Mary Downer, Trustee of the Arthur and Michael Prentice; C

T

. S T N

E U Mary Downer Family Trust; Michael Purdy, Trustee of the Purdy Family 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A Mary L. Vomund, Trustee of the Mary L. Revocable Trust; W 16 Vomund 1987 Trust; Michael Saleh, Trustee of the Saleh and Lea Mary Thomas, Trustee of The Thomas Saleh 1984 Family Trust; 17 Survivors Trust; Michael T. Marshall and Lisa Skyheart Mary Wingate, Trustee of the Mary Louise Marshall, individually as Trustees of the 18 Wingate Trust; Marshall Living Trust; 19 Mattawa and Rond Larue Clements, Micky Froelich; individually; Miguel and Elvia Ramirez, individually; 20 Matthew and Judy Farmer, individually; Miguel Estrada; Matthew and Kimberly Hultgen, Murelle Stevens, Trustee of the Stevens 21 individually; Family Trust; 22 Max Reed; Nancy Ferrell, Trustee of the Nancy A. Maximiano and Norma Ortiz, individually; Ferrell Family Trust; 23 J. McGliinchey; Nancy Graham; McNell Creek Ranch, a general partnership; Nancy Jackson, Trustee of the Nancy J. 24 McNell Properties, LLC; Jackson Living Trust; Melesio Ramirez; Natalia Moore, Trustee of the Moore Family 25 Melissa Van Siclen; Trust; 26 Merl and Kim Melstrand, individually; Nathan Allen; Michael and Allison Sedlak, individually; Nathaniel and Suzette O’Grady, 27 Michael and Annell La Barge, individually; individually; Michael and Barbara McCarthy, 28 individually; - 57 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Nathaniel Traudt and Karen Traudt, Patrick Tumamait; individually and as Trustees of the Traudt Paul and Aldine Hennigan, individually; 2 Family Trust; Paul and Janet Bailey, individually; 3 Neil and Patricia Friedrichsen, individually; Paul and June Clem, individually; Neil Kreitman, Trustee of the Neil Kreitman Paul and Kim Robie, individually; 4 Living Trust; Paul and Maelyn Ebert, individually; Nick and Morna Taminich, individually; Paul and Sally Centeno, individually; 5 Nick Daily; Paul Fonteyn, individually; Nina Menconi; Paul Holahan and Julie Grist, individually; 6 Nye Ranch, LLC; Paul Lepiane and Bo Bengtson, individually; 7 Oak Haven, LLC; Paula Brown, Trustee of the Paula Jean Oak View Sanitary District; Brown Trust; 8 Krishnamurti Foundation of America; Paula Lasiter; Oilfield Service and Truck Co.; Paula McCullough, Trustee of the Paula J. 9 Oilfield Service and Truck, Inc.; McCullough Living Trust; Ojai Assembly of God, Inc., dba Ojai’s Pauline Mercado, Trustee of the Pauline 10 Church of the Living Christ, Inc. Mercado Revocable Trust; 6 9 0 5 9

4 Ojai Home, LLC; Pedro Cisneros; 3

9 11

P

L E A L Ojai Unified School District; Pedro Tepesano; T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Ojai Valley Athletic Club; Per and Inge Christiansen, individually; O

, G O S T F E I I E E Ojai Valley Land Conservancy; Perry Family, LLC; L R E C A I K R 13 F C Ojai-Jackman, LLC; Peter and Linda Daprix, individually;

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N Ole Behrendtsen; Peter and Norma Dworkis, individually; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L Olga and Trent Jones, individually; Peter Dufau; C

T

. S T N

E U Orin Jr. and Karen Chappell, individually; Peter Passell; 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A Orville Hernvall, Trustee of Hervnall Orville Peter Strauss and Rachel Ticotin, W 16 and Marion Orville Trust; individually; Oscar and Mary Kaas, individually; Petrochem Development I, LLC; 17 Oscar Acosta, Trustee of the Acosta Trust; Philip and Darylyn Long, individually; OST Trucks and Cranes; Philip and Mary Pierpont, individually; 18 Ovis, LLC; Philip and Robert Pierpont, individually; 19 Pamela Grau, Trustee of the Pamela Grau Philippe and Betsy Caland, Trustees of the Living Trust; Philippe M. and Betsy C. Trust; 20 Pamela Melone, Trustee of the Pamela M. Preparatory Villanova; Melone Living Trust; Quint Morris; 21 Patricia Boan and Alina Hoffman, Rachel Kondor and Brian Segee, 22 individually; individually; Patricia Boan and John Hoffman, Rafael and Magdalena Villalpando, 23 individually; individually; Patricia Marshall, Trustee of the Patricia Raffi J. Mesrobian and Myrna R. Mesrobian, 24 Ann Marshall Trust; individually as Trustees of the Mesrobian Patricia McPherson; Family Trust; 25 Patricia McGann; Rainer Buschmann and John Johnston, 26 Patricia Unruhe and Andrew Jarvis, individually; individually; Ralph and Lynne Lundy, individually; 27 Patrick Henderson and Jessica Maharry, Ramaa Mosley; Trustees of the Maharry Henderson Family 28 Trust; - 58 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Randal R. O'Connor, Successor Trustee of Robert and Jacqueline McDaniel, the Red Clay Trust, and Successor Trustee of individually; 2 the Le Cedre Trust; Robert and Janice Hastie, individually; 3 Ranjit Sevaprakasam; Robert and Marilyn Salas, individually; Ray Hall, Trustee-in-Trust of the 30 Acre Robert and Maureen Young, individually; 4 Trust; Robert and Sheila Ghen, individually; Raymond and Esther Kardly, individually; Robert and Sonia Rodarte, individually; 5 Raymond and Eva Lyons, individually; Robert and Taundra Roddick, individually; Raymond Magee and Linda Taylor, Robert and Anna J. Auric, individually as 6 individually; Trustees of the Auric Anna J. Family Trust; 7 RDK Land, LLC; Robert Calder Davis, Jr., Trustee of the Rebecca Adams; Robert Davis Surviving Spouse's Trust, 8 Red Mountain Land and Farming, LLC; Trustee of the Davis Family Bypass Trust Reeves Orchard, LLC; and Trustee of the Davis Family Trust; 9 Refugio Gomez; Robert Dekkers; Rex and Heidi Lanning, individually; Robert Erickson and Ronald Wilson, 10 Reynolds Fleming; individually; 6 9 0 5 9

4 Ricardo Gonzalez; Robert Grasmere; 3

9 11

P

L E A L Richard and Billie Sumner, individually; Robert Polidori and Brittany Sanders, T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Richard and Emily Cargill, individually; individually; O

, G O S T F E I I E E Richard and Katherine Godfrey, Roberto and Maria Alonso, individually; L R E C A I K R 13 F C individually; Rocky Mann;

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N Richard and Lee Harper, individually; Roderick and Joyce Greene, individually; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L Richard and Marilyn Kallas;, individually Roger and Susan Dickens, individually; C

T

. S T N

E U Richard and Nancy Francis, individually; Roger Burke; 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A Richard and Teresa Turner, individually; Roger Haley; Trustee of the Roger and W 16 Richard Dodson, Trustee of the Richard E. Christina Haley Survivors Trust; Dodson 2010 Revocable Trust; Roger Walker; 17 Richard Francis; Rogers-Cooper Memorial Foundation; Richard Frey and Wendy Appleby, Ronald and Bette Bluhm, individually; 18 individually; Ronald and Julia Bruns, individually; 19 Richard and Emma Kline, individually; Ronald Blood and Linda Jordan, Richard Lowen; individually; 20 Richard Magana; Ronald E. Novak and Linda L. Lewis, Richard Mcgrath, Trustee of the Richard K individually as Trustees of the Novak Family 21 McGrath Living Trust; Trust; 22 Richard Sojka; Ronald K. Freeland and Doreen Freeland, RJPR Ltd. Partnership; individually as Trustees or their successors 23 Robert and Anamaria Schmid, individually; in interest of the Freeland Trust and any Robert and Antoinette Tivy, individually; amendment; 24 Robert and Diana Petropulos, individually; Ronald L.R. Hill and Debi R. Hill, Trustees Robert and Dianne Stone, individually; of the R&D Hill Family Trust; 25 Robert and Dominque Daniels, individually; Ronald Vogt; 26 Robert and Dora Balitzer, individually; Rosemarie Singer; Robert and Emily Martin, individually; Rosemary Payne, Trustee of the Rosemary 27 Robert and Gaea Cannaday, individually; Payne Trust; Robert and Geraldine Hunsaker, Ross Anderson; 28 individually; - 59 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Rowland A. Hill II and Brenda M. Hill, Sherrice and John Weeces, individually; individually as Trustees of the Trust dated Sherrie Daily; 2 November 1, 2002; Sheryl Shushan; 3 Roy Hicks, Trustee of the Roy and Shippee, LLC; Jacquelyn Hicks Family Trust; Shull Bonsall, Jr., Trustee of the Shull 4 Ruben and Marisa Martinez, individually; Bonsall Family Trust; Ruben Chavez; Evangeline Bonsall Smith, a married 5 Ruben Magana and Janette Lupercio, woman; individually; Sidney and Jayne Rice, individually; 6 Rudy Baez; Steven P. Smith and Lynn Davis-Smith, 7 Russel and Laura Alford, individually; individually as Trustees of the Smith Russell and Golden Wiley, individually; Revocable Living Trust; 8 Russell Waldrop, Trustee of the Russell B. Southern California Edison Co.; Waldrop Living Trust; Southern California Associated Investors, 9 Ryan and Lauren Nichols, individually; Ltd.; Sabino and Nicki Perez, individually; Spencer and Bailey Hill, individually; 10 Sabrina Venskus, Trustee of the Sabrina SRPS, LP; 6 9 0 5 9

4 Venskus Living Trust; Stacy Cadenasso; 3

9 11

P

L E A L Sally Crain; Stanley and Theresa Wyatt, individually; T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Salvatore Scarpato; Stanley and W Hubbell, individually; O

, G O S T F E I I E E Samuel and Joanna Schindel, individually; State of California, Department of L R E C A I K R 13 F C Samuel Eaton; Transportation;

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N Santa Ana Ranch, Inc.; Stefan Kozak and Ana Lopes, individually; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L Sarah Young; Stephanie and Cheryl Beas, individually; C

T

. S T N

E U Saunie Krewson; Stephen Matzkin, Trustee of the Stephen 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A Scott and Brittany Denton, individually; Matzkin Trust; W 16 Scott and Carol Rasmussen, individually; Stephen Turner, Trustee of the Stephen R. Scott and Keela Allison, individually; Turner Living Trust; 17 Scott and Maria Hertzog, individually; Steven and Brent Kanaly, individually; Scott and Michele Supan; Steven and Christine Vaughan, individually; 18 Scott Chasse, Trustee of the Scott Chasse Steven and Ka Rapholz, individually; 19 Revocable Living Trust; Steven and Karen Erickson, individually; Scott Forsyth and Joy Fedele, individually; Steven and Krissell Dutter, individually; 20 Scott Lundy, Trustee of the Scott Lundy Steven Elliot Edelson, Trustee of the Los Trust; Angeles Entertainment Trust; 21 Scott Luttenberger and Natasha Wilcox, Sumeet Bhatia and Michael Mcdonald, 22 individually; individually; Scottie Monical; Sumpuran Khalsa, Trustee of the Sumpuran 23 Sean and Leslie Bennett, individually; S. Khalsa Living Trust; Serafin and Martha Flores, individually; Suria and John Gottesman, individually; 24 Sevan Gerard; Susan Bee, Trustee of the John and Susan Shahram Shahrokhfar and Dina Nava, Bee Family Trust; 25 individually; Susan Conley, Trustee of the William and 26 Shanks Investment Group, LLC; Susan Conley Family Trust; Shawn Fulbright, Trustee of the Shawn Susan Diller, Trustee of the Susan J Diller 27 Fulbright 2014 Revocable Trust; Trust; Shawn Reed; Susan Garand; 28 Shell Oil Co.; - 60 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 Susan Gruber, individually and as Trustee of Tyler Labine and Carrie Ruscheinsky, the Susan Gruber Living Trust; individually; 2 Susan McCord-Neufeld; Uldine and Fabien Castel, individually; 3 Susan Moll; Uriel and Chieko Lopez, individually; Susan Webster; US Natural Resources, Inc.; 4 Suzanne Harvey, individually and as Trustee Vanlaw Investment Corp.; of the Suzanne G. Harvey Revocable Trust; Ventura Land Trust; 5 T Bone Holdings, LLC; Ventura Unified School District; Tanya Smith and Michael Montano, Vicente Guzman; 6 individually; Vicki Daw; 7 Tanya Starcevich; Vicki L. Hollingsworth, Trustee of the Ted Robinson, Trustee of the Robinson Hollingsworth Trust; 8 Family Trust; Virginia M. McCarthy, Trustee of the Telos Development Ojai, LLC; Virginia M. McCarthy Living Trust; 9 Terry Wilson, Trustee of the Terry Coultas Virginia Siegfried, Trustee of the Virginia A. Wilson Living Trust; Siegfried Revocable Trust; 10 The Ojai Rental, LLC; Vivian Arber; 6 9 0 5 9

4 The Roman Catholic Archbishop of Los Vivienne Moody; 3

9 11

P

L E A L Angeles, a sole corporation; Walter and Evelyn Golis, individually; T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Theodor and Lore Exner, individually; Walter and Linda Boysiewick, individually; O

, G O S T F E I I E E Theresa Stark; Walter McGowan, Individually and as L R E C A I K R 13 F C Thomas and Cynthia Carver, individually; Trustee of the Walter Robert McGowan

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N Thomas and Nanette Benbrook, individually; 1995 Trust; I E W E

A 14 A R B

M L Thomas and Jadona Coller Harper, Wanda and Meniford Canterberry, C

T

. S T N

E U individually; individually; 1

B 15 N 0 L 0

2 A Thomas Jackson; Watermark Carp II LLC; W 16 Thomas Tamplin and Michelle Wells, Wayne Tate and Janice Priebe-Tate, individually; individually as Trustees of the Tate Trust, as 17 Thomas Walbridge, Trustee of the Thomas C community property; Walbridge Trust; Weiss Investment Properties; 18 Three Oaks, LLC; Wendy and David Churchill, individually; 19 Three Sisters Orchard, LP; Werner and Elva Fischer, individually; Timothy and Cheryl Austin, individually; Wesley Scott and Kasey Perins, individually; 20 Timothy and Kathleen McHugh, West Crag Glen Smith, Successor Trustee of individually; the Melissa Irene Elizabeth Smith 21 Timothy and Kathryn Moran, individually; Irrevocable Special Needs Trust - 1993; 22 Timothy and Linda Turner, individually; Willi and Stefanie U. Coeler, individually Timothy and Mary Williamson, individually; and as Trustees of the W. and S. Coeler 23 Timothy Jones; Living Trust; Todd and Christina McGinley, individually; William and Cynthia Anderson, individually; 24 Todd Ryan and Jessica Click, individually; William and Jacqueline Boch, individually; Todd Tullett, Trustee of the Todd Tullett William and Lorraine Walsh, individually; 25 Revocable Living Trust; William and Melinda Welch, individually; 26 Tom and Nancy Roland, individually; William and Susan Luther, individually; Tony and Heather Carlos, individually; William B. Hart, Jr., Trustee of the 27 Tracey and Melanie Boulton, individually; Constance Eaton Personal Residence Trust; Trent and Kris Greco, individually; William Bailey, Trustee of the William F. 28 Tyler and Maria Barrell, individually; Bailey Living Trust; - 61 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 William Brothers, Trustee of the William C. William White, Trustee of the William C. Brothers Living Trust; White Trust; 2 William Erickson; William Whorf; 3 William F. Newton and Charlotte R. Wilmetta Davis; Newton, individually as Trustees of the Winfried and Carol Boersch, individually; 4 Newton Family Trust; Wynn Johnson and Lisa Ayala Johnson, William Gilbreth, Trustee of the William J. individually; 5 Gilbreth Trust; Yan and Alili Comment, individually; William Hawksworth; Yarrow and Caroline Cheney, individually; 6 William Lowes; Yitzhak and Smadar Orlans, individually; 7 William L. Reynolds; Yvon and Malinda Chouinard, individually; Zobeida Olson 8 9 10 Overlying Landowners 6 9 0 5

9 94. Pursuant to California Civil Procedure Code section 836(d)(1)(A), City will serve 4 3

9 11

P

L E A L T I

I N R U

F the owners all real property overlying the Watershed’s Groundwater Basins (“Overlying E R S 12 O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C Landowners”) with this Third Amended Cross-Complaint and court-approved notice of A I K R 13 F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N

I adjudication and form answer. Pursuant to California Civil Procedure Code section 836(k), upon E W E

A 14 A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E

U receipt of the requisite notice, Overlying Landowners interested in this proceeding shall have the 1

B 15 N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 duty to appear in this action and become a party if they so choose. 17 18 Interested Persons 19 95. All Persons Who Own an Interest in Land Overlying the Ventura River 20 Watershed’s Groundwater Basins and Claim an Interest to Pump, Extract or Store Groundwater

21 From, Under or on That Land. 22 23 Roe Cross-Defendants 24 96. City is informed and believes that: 25 (a) Cross-Defendants Roes 1 through 50 operate wells and/or diversions which 26 extract surface and/or subsurface water from the Ventura River. 27 (b) Cross-Defendants Roes 51 through 100 operate wells and/or diversions 28 which extract surface and/or subsurface water from Matilija Creek. - 62 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 (c) Cross-Defendants Roes 101 through 150 operate wells and/or diversions 2 which extract surface and/or subsurface water from North Fork Matilija Creek. 3 (d) Cross-Defendants Roes 151 through 200 operate wells and/or diversions 4 which extract surface and/or subsurface water from San Antonio Creek. 5 (e) Cross-Defendants Roes 201 through 250 operate wells and/or diversions 6 which extract surface and/or subsurface water from Coyote Creek. 7 (f) Cross-Defendants Roes 251 through 300 operate wells and/or diversions 8 which extract surface and/or subsurface water from Cañada Larga Creek. 9 (g) Cross-Defendants Roes 301 through 350 operate wells and/or diversions 10 which extract surface and/or subsurface water from Santa Ana Creek. 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 (h) Cross-Defendants Roes 351 through 400 operate wells which extract water

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 from the Upper Ventura River Groundwater Basin. O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 (i) Cross-Defendants Roes 401 through 450 operate wells which extract water F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 from the Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin. A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 (j) Cross-Defendants Roes 451 through 500 operate wells which extract water N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 from the Lower Ventura River Groundwater Basin. 17 (k) Cross-Defendants Roes 501 through 550 operate wells which extract water 18 from the Upper Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin. 19 (l) Cross-Defendants Roes 551 through 1,000 are the owners, lessees, or other 20 persons or entities (i) holding or claiming to hold ownership or possessory interests in real

21 property within the boundaries of the Watershed; (ii) extracting water from the Watershed; (iii) 22 claiming some right, title, or interest to water located within the Watershed; or (iv) having or 23 asserting claims adverse to City’s rights and claims. 24 97. City is unaware of the true names and capacities of Cross-Defendants Roes 1 25 through 1,000. When the City becomes aware of their trues names and capacities, it will seek 26 leave of court to amend this Cross-Complaint accordingly. 27 28 - 63 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 BACKGROUND 2 3 98. The Watershed is located in western Ventura County, with a small section located 4 in eastern Santa Barbara County. The City is informed and believes that the Watershed is fan- 5 shaped and covers 226 square miles. 6 99. The Ventura River and its headwater tributary run through the center of the 7 Watershed along a 33.5 mile stretch from its headwaters in the to the Pacific 8 Ocean. 9 100. The Ventura River and its headwater tributary is fed by several major tributaries, 10 including Matilija Creek, North Fork Matilija Creek, San Antonio Creek, Cañada Larga Creek, 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 and Coyote Creek.

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 101. Lake Casitas is a man-made reservoir located in the Watershed primarily filled by O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 runoff from Coyote Creek and Santa Ana Creek and water diverted from the Ventura River. F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 102. The Ventura River consists of five distinct reaches starting upstream from the A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 Pacific Ocean: Reach 1 (Pacific Ocean to Ventura River Estuary), Reach 2 (Ventura River N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 Estuary to Foster Park), Reach 3 (Foster Park to the San Antonio Creek Confluence), Reach 4 17 (just above the Ventura River’s confluence with San Antonio Creek to below the Robles 18 Diversion Facility), and Reach 5 (Robles Diversion Facility to confluence of Matilija Creek and 19 North Folk Matilija Creek). 20 103. There are four significant groundwater basins in the Watershed:

21 (a) Upper Ventura River Groundwater Basin (DWR Bulletin 118, 22 Groundwater Basin Number 4-3.01); 23 (b) Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin (DWR’s Bulletin 118, Groundwater Basin 24 Number 4-2); 25 (c) Lower Ventura River Groundwater Basin (DWR’s Bulletin 118, 26 Groundwater Basin Number 4-3.02); and 27 (d) Upper Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin (DWR’s Bulletin 118 Groundwater 28 Basin Number 4-1) - 64 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 (collectively “Watershed’s Groundwater Basins”). There is a hydrological connection between 2 the Ventura River and its tributaries and the Watershed’s Groundwater Basins. Three maps of the 3 Watershed and the Watershed’s Groundwater Basins are attached as Exhibit A. 4 104. In its First Amended Complaint and Verified Petition for Writ of Mandate 5 (“Complaint”), Plaintiff Santa Barbara Channelkeeper (“Channelkeeper”) alleges that City’s use 6 of the Ventura River water harms the steelhead trout and its critical habitat and exceeds water 7 quality standards. Channelkeeper also alleges City’s use of water is unreasonable and violates the 8 public trust doctrine. Channelkeeper further alleges that City’s water rights are subordinate to 9 upstream riparian and overlying groundwater rights in the Ventura River Watershed. 10 105. City is informed and believes that Cross-Defendants’ use of water from the 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 Ventura River and the Watershed’s Groundwater Basins reduces the surface and/or subsurface

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 water flow of the Ventura River. O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 106. City is informed and believes and thereon alleges that there are conflicting claims F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 of rights to the Watershed and/or its water. A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 107. City is informed and believes and thereon alleges that it has pueblo, prescriptive, N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 and/or appropriative rights to water in the Watershed. City is a successor to the Mission San 17 Buenaventura pueblo water right, which gives it a priority to use sufficient water from the 18 Ventura River Watershed to meet its needs. It has utilized water from the Watershed for more 19 than five years prior to the filing of this Cross-Complaint. It has used the Watershed and/or its 20 water for reasonable and beneficial purposes; and it has done so under a claim of right in an

21 actual, open, notorious, exclusive, continuous, uninterrupted, hostile, adverse use and/or manner 22 for a period of time of at least five years before filing this Cross-Complaint. City holds pre-1914 23 appropriative water rights. 24 108. Upon information and belief, each Cross-Defendant claims a right to utilize water 25 and threatens to increase its taking of water without regard to the City’s rights. Cross- 26 Defendants’ pumping and/or diversions reduces Watershed groundwater tables and surface flows 27 and contributes to the deficiency of the Watershed water supply as a whole. 28 - 65 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 109. Cross-Defendants’ continued and increasing extraction and/or diversion of 2 Watershed waters has resulted in, and will result in a diminution, reduction, and impairment of 3 the Watershed’s water supply. 4 110. Cross-Defendants’ continued and increasing extraction and/or diversion of 5 Watershed waters has and will deprive the City of its rights to provide water for the public health, 6 welfare, and benefit. 7 8 9 FIRST CLAIM FOR RELIEF 10 (Cal. Const. art. X, § 2 - Against All Cross-Defendants) 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 111. City incorporates by reference the allegations of paragraphs 1 through 110. O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 112. Water resources in California must be put to reasonable and beneficial use, and F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 parties exercising a right to use water must engage in a reasonable method of use and reasonable A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 method of diversion. N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 113. City’s reasonable and beneficial use of water requires consideration of 17 Channelkeeper’s claims and Cross-Defendants’ uses and diversions of water from the Ventura 18 River or the Watershed’s Groundwater Basins. 19 114. City’s reasonable and beneficial use of water also requires consideration of all 20 other uses and users in the Watershed in the context of Statewide laws favoring domestic use of

21 water; conservation of water; service of safe, clean, affordable, and accessible water; and 22 protection of municipal water rights. 23 115. Based on those considerations, City’s use of water from the Ventura River 24 Watershed as compared to all other uses and users is reasonable and beneficial because: 25 (a) City’s water is used for domestic purposes. 26 (b) City encourages conservation of water by its users, does not waste water in 27 its operations, and only uses water for municipal purposes. 28 (c) City provides safe, clean, affordable, and accessible water. - 66 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 (d) City is exercising vested water rights. 2 116. City seeks a preliminary and permanent injunction reducing Cross-Defendants’ use 3 of surface and/or subsurface water and groundwater affecting the surface and/or subsurface flow 4 of the Ventura River to a level of reasonable and beneficial use and a level that protects public 5 trust resources after a consideration of all water uses and users in the Watershed pursuant the 6 Court of Appeal’s decision in Santa Barbara Channelkeeper v. City of San Buenaventura (2018) 7 19 Cal.App.5th 1176, 1192–1193. 8 9 SECOND CLAIM FOR RELIEF 10 (Public Trust Doctrine - Against All Cross-Defendants) 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 117. City incorporates by reference the allegations of paragraphs 1 through 110. O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 118. The public trust doctrine protects the environmental values of rivers and streams in F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 California for the benefit of the public, but is subject to parties reasonably exercising their water A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 rights. Additionally, public trust doctrine uses are limited by the doctrine of reasonable and N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 beneficial use. 17 119. Evaluating the City’s reasonable and beneficial use of water requires consideration 18 of all other uses and users in the Watershed. 19 120. Evaluating the City’s reasonable and beneficial use of water also requires 20 consideration of Water Code provisions and Statewide laws favoring domestic use of water;

21 conservation of water; service of safe, clean, affordable, and accessible water; and protection of 22 municipal water rights and the potential that non-flow related mitigation measures may 23 reasonably reduce the quantity of water required to protect the environment and public trust 24 resources. 25 121. Based on those considerations, City’s use of water from the Ventura River and 26 Lake Casitas is reasonable and beneficial because: 27 (a) City’s water is used for domestic purposes. 28 - 67 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 (b) City encourages conservation of water by its users, does not waste water in 2 its operations and only uses water for municipal purposes. 3 (c) City provides safe, clean, affordable and accessible water. 4 (d) City is exercising vested water rights. 5 122. City seeks a preliminary and permanent injunction reducing Cross-Defendants’ use 6 of surface and/or subsurface water and groundwater affecting the surface and/or subsurface flow 7 of the Ventura River to a level of reasonable and beneficial use and a level that protects public 8 trust resources after consideration of Channelkeeper’s claims. 9 10 THIRD CLAIM FOR RELIEF 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 (Declaratory Relief - Pueblo and/or Treaty Water Rights -

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 Against All Cross-Defendants) O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 123. City incorporates by reference the allegations of paragraphs 1 through 110. A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 124. The City, or a portion of it, is located within the boundaries of the former Mission N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 San Buenaventura. The designation of the Mission San Buenaventura and its subsequent 17 secularization led to the creation of a pueblo water right. The City is a successor to the pueblo 18 right which gives it a priority water right to use sufficient water from the Ventura River 19 Watershed to meet its needs. 20 125. City is located on land that used to be part of Mexico. While that land was part of

21 Mexico, a vested water right was established on it that was subsequently recognized by the 22 in the Treaty of Guadalupe-Hidalgo. City is a successor to the Mexican water right, 23 which has a priority over any right established under California law. 24 126. City contends that each Cross-Defendant’s rights to utilize water from the 25 Watershed are subordinate to City’s pueblo and/or treaty water rights and to the general welfare 26 of the citizens, inhabitants, and customers within City’s jurisdiction. 27 28 - 68 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 127. An actual controversy has arisen between City and Cross-Defendants, and each of 2 them. City alleges, on information and belief, that each Cross-Defendant disputes City’s 3 contentions, as described in the immediately preceding paragraph. 4 128. City seeks a judicial determination as to the correctness of its contentions and a 5 finding as to the priority and amount of water it and each Cross-Defendant are entitled to utilize 6 from the Watershed. 7 8 FOURTH CLAIM FOR RELIEF 9 (Declaratory Relief - Prescriptive Water Rights - 10 Against All Cross-Defendants) 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 129. City incorporates by reference the allegations of paragraphs 1 through 110. O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 130. The California Supreme Court has long recognized prescriptive water rights to F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 both surface and groundwater. City alleges that, for more than five years and before the date of A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 this Cross-Complaint, it has utilized water from the Watershed for reasonable and beneficial N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 purposes, and done so under a claim of right in an actual, open, notorious, exclusive, continuous, 17 hostile, and adverse manner. City further alleges that each Cross-Defendant had actual and/or 18 constructive notice of these activities, either of which is sufficient to establish City’s prescriptive 19 rights. 20 131. City contends that each Cross-Defendant’s rights to utilize water from the

21 Watershed are subordinate to City’s prescriptive rights and to the general welfare of the citizens, 22 inhabitants, and customers within City’s jurisdiction. 23 132. An actual controversy has arisen between City and Cross-Defendants, and each of 24 them. City alleges, on information and belief, that each Cross-Defendant disputes City’s 25 contentions, as described in the immediately preceding paragraph. 26 133. City seeks a judicial determination as to the correctness of its contentions and a 27 finding as to the priority and amount of water it and each Cross-Defendant are entitled to utilize 28 from the Watershed. - 69 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 FIFTH CLAIM FOR RELIEF 2 (Declaratory Relief - Appropriative Water Rights - 3 Against All Cross-Defendants) 4 5 134. City incorporates by reference the allegations of paragraphs 1 through 110. 6 135. City alleges that, alternatively or in addition to its prescriptive rights, it has priority 7 pre-1914 appropriative rights to utilize water from the Watershed based upon extensive historic 8 and beneficial use of local water in the Ventura River, including local water impounded and 9 collected in Lake Casitas. 10 136. An actual controversy has arisen between City and Cross-Defendants, and each of 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 them. City alleges, on information and belief, that all Cross-Defendants, and each of them, seek

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 to prevent City from exercising its priority pre-1914 appropriative rights to utilize water from the O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 Watershed. F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 137. City seeks a judicial determination of the rights of persons and/or entities with A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 overlying, appropriative, and prescriptive rights to utilize water from the Watershed. N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 17 SIXTH CLAIM FOR RELIEF 18 (Cal. Civ. Proc Code §§ 830-852 - Comprehensive Adjudication 19 and Physical Solution - Against All Cross-Defendants) 20

21 138. City incorporates by reference the allegations of paragraphs 1 through 110. 22 139. The physical solution doctrine imposes a duty on this Court to resolve competing 23 claims to water by cooperatively satisfying the reasonable and beneficial needs of each user while 24 protecting the substantial enjoyment of their prior rights. A physical solution can achieve this 25 result by: compelling non-flow related improvements for the protection of public trust resources 26 thereby preserving and protecting water supply for domestic use, the highest and best use, and for 27 irrigation use, the next highest and best use (Water Code section 106); augmenting the 28 Watershed’s water supply; and imposing other measures. The physical solution is a practical way - 70 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 of fulfilling the mandate of the California Constitution (article X, section 2) that the water 2 resources of the State be put to use to the fullest extent of which they are capable. 3 140. Further, the Code of Civil Procedure authorizes the comprehensive adjudication of 4 groundwater rights, including interconnected surface waters, and the imposition of physical 5 solution. Cal. Civ. Proc. Code §§ 830-852. 6 141. Accordingly, City seeks a physical solution among City and Cross-Defendants 7 regarding their respective uses of surface and/or subsurface water and groundwater affecting the 8 Ventura River. 9 10 SEVENTH CLAIM FOR RELIEF 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 (Declaratory Relief - Municipal Priority - Against All Cross-Defendants)

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 142. City incorporates by reference the allegations of paragraphs 1 through 110. F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 143. City has the right to utilize water from the Watershed to meet existing public water A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 needs and also to utilize increased amounts of water from the Watershed as necessary to meet N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 future public needs. City’s rights to the Watershed’s water exist both as a result of the priority 17 and extent of its pueblo, appropriative, and prescriptive rights, and as a matter of law and public 18 policy of the State of California: “It is hereby declared to be the established policy of this State 19 that the use of water for domestic purposes is the highest use of water and that the next highest 20 use is for irrigation.” Cal. Water Code § 106.

21 144. California Water Code Section 106.5 provides: “It is hereby declared to be the 22 established policy of this State that the right of a municipality to acquire and hold rights to the use 23 of water should be protected to the fullest extent necessary for existing and future uses. . . .” 24 145. Under California Water Code Sections 106 and 106.5, City has a prior and 25 paramount right to Watershed water as against all non-municipal uses. 26 146. An actual controversy has arisen between City and Cross-Defendants. City 27 alleges, on information and belief, that Cross-Defendants dispute the contentions contained in the 28 preceding paragraphs of this Cross-Complaint. City is informed and believes, and on that basis - 71 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 alleges, that the certain Cross-Defendants utilize water from the Watershed for non-municipal 2 purposes. 3 147. City seeks a judicial determination as to the correctness of its contentions and to 4 the amount of water the parties may utilize from the Watershed. City also seeks a declaration of 5 its right to utilize water from the Watershed to meet its reasonable present and future needs, and 6 that such rights are prior and paramount to the rights, if any, of Cross-Defendants to use 7 Watershed water for non-municipal purposes. 8 9 EIGHTH CLAIM FOR RELIEF 10 (Declaratory Relief - Human Right to Water - Against All Cross-Defendants) 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 148. City incorporates by reference the allegations of paragraphs 1 through 110. O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 149. City has the right to utilize water from the Watershed to meet existing public water F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 needs to protect the human right to water and also to utilize increased amounts of water from the A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 Watershed as necessary to meet future public needs to protect the human right to water. City’s N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 rights to the Watershed’s water exist both as a result of the priority and extent of its pueblo, 17 appropriative, and prescriptive rights, and as a matter of law and public policy of the State of 18 California: “It is hereby declared to be the established policy of the state that every human being 19 has the right to safe, clean, affordable, and accessible water adequate for human consumption, 20 cooking, and sanitary purposes.” Cal. Water Code § 106.3.

21 150. Under California Water Code Section 106.3, City has a prior and paramount right 22 to Watershed water to protect the human right to water. 23 151. An actual controversy has arisen between City and Cross-Defendants. City 24 alleges, on information and belief, that Cross-Defendants dispute the contentions contained in the 25 preceding paragraphs of this Cross-Complaint. City is informed and believes, and on that basis 26 alleges, that the certain Cross-Defendants utilize water from the Watershed for purposes that are 27 inferior to the paramount human right to water. 28 - 72 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 152. City seeks a judicial determination as to the correctness of its contentions and to 2 the amount of water the parties may utilize from the Watershed to protect the human right to 3 water. City also seeks a declaration of its right to utilize water from the Watershed to meet its 4 reasonable present and future needs to protect the human right to water, and that such rights are 5 prior and paramount to the rights, if any, of Cross-Defendants to use Watershed water for 6 purposes that are inferior to the paramount human right to water. 7 8 NINTH CLAIM FOR RELIEF 9 (Declaratory Relief - Against All Cross-Defendants) 10 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 153. City incorporates by reference the allegations of paragraphs 1 through 110.

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 154. City contends, and is informed and believes that Cross-Defendants dispute, that: O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 (a) City’s use of the Ventura River Watershed as compared to all other users F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 and uses is reasonable and beneficial and does not violate the public trust doctrine. A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 (b) Cross-Defendants’ uses are not reasonable or beneficial and violate the N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 public trust doctrine as compared to City’s use of the Ventura River Watershed. 17 155. Therefore, an actual, present controversy exists between City and Cross- 18 Defendants concerning City’s and Cross-Defendant’s use of surface and/or subsurface water and 19 groundwater affecting the Ventura River Watershed. 20 156. City seeks a declaration and judicial determination as to the validity of its

21 contentions set forth in this Cross-Complaint. 22 23 PRAYER FOR RELIEF 24 25 WHEREFORE, City prays for the following relief: 26 1. For a preliminary and permanent injunction reducing Cross-Defendants’ uses of 27 surface water and groundwater affecting the surface and/or subsurface flow of the Ventura River 28 - 73 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl. 1 to a level of reasonable and beneficial use and a level that protects public trust resources after 2 consideration of all water uses and users in the Watershed; 3 2. For a physical solution allocating City’s and Cross-Defendants’ reasonable and 4 beneficial use of water affecting the Ventura River Watershed, and protecting the substantial 5 enjoyment of their water rights; 6 3. For judicial declarations consistent with City’s contentions in the Third, Fourth, 7 Fifth, Seventh, Eighth, and Ninth Claims for Relief in this Cross-Complaint; 8 4. For judgment against all named cross-defendants who fail to appear in this action 9 that they are bound by the judgment and physical solution, and their water rights in the Ventura 10 River Watershed, if any, are limited to the terms of the physical solution. 6 9 0 5 9 4 3

9 11 5. For judgment against all persons who, presently or in the future, own an interest in

P

L E A L T I

I N R U F E R S 12 real property overlying the Ventura River Watershed’s Groundwater Basins and who fail to O

, G O S T F E I I E E L R E C A I K R 13 appear in this action that they are bound by the judgment and physical solution, and their water F C

T & , F

S K

T O

E S N I E W E

A 14 rights in the Ventura River Watershed’s Groundwater Basins, if any, are limited to the terms of A R B

M L C

T

. S T N

E U 1

B 15 the physical solution. N 0 L 0 2 A W 16 6. For City’s costs incurred in this action; and 17 7. For such other and further relief as the Court deems just and proper. 18

19 Dated: ______, 2019 BEST BEST & KRIEGER LLP 20

21 By: GENE TANAKA 22 SHAWN HAGERTY SARAH CHRISTOPHER FOLEY 23 DAKOTAH BENJAMIN Attorneys for Respondent and Cross- 24 Complainant CITY OF SAN BUENAVENTURA 25 26 27 28 - 74 - 82470.00018\32392562.1 City’s 3rd Am. Cross-Compl.

EXHIBIT A PART 3 • 3.3 Hydrology • 3.3.3 Groundwater Hydrology 333

V E N T U R A C O U N T Y

r. C j a i l i t a M M k atil o r ija C or th F ree N n k o

y

n n

a o

on C y

y y n e

n l

a

a d C i C

t r

r r a G Matilija a o

c i

w n n

Reservoir e a e t r r S S A N T A S

a B k B A R B A R A n e C r re

o C o y e l k k

y n l e e C O U N T Y v e o a e e i N r

t Meiners C c Cree r

e C s k C R x M e

Oaks r v r e o e C e e o

Sa nta An a F Tha c h R m r a a e Cr eek r Upper c y e u Ojai S k t Ojai n Mir a e Monte V k þ e ek ·150 e n yo n C re r io n C a C L io n to Oak n View A n a S

Lake Casitas ek re Cas itas C Springs a g r a L d a Ca ña

·þ33

P a c i f ¤£101 i c O c e a ·þ126 n

Ventura Data Sources: CDWR Bulletin 118, Kear Groundwater, Ventur a River Ventura County Watershed Protection District, Estuary ¤£101 Ojai Basin GMA, Daniel B. Stephens & Associates, Inc. Miles Map Created by GreenInfo Network using Esri software, Jan. 2015 www.greeninfo.org ¯ 0 0.5 1 2 3 4 Groundwater Basins

Ventura River Watershed Sq. Shallow Depth Max. Avg. Well Active Approx. Groundwater Basin Acres Mi. to Water (ft.) Capacity Yield Wells Safe Yield Upper Ojai 2,840 4.4 0-40 5,681 AF 50 gpm 95 Unavail.

Ojai Valley 6,471 10.1 0-80 85,000 AF 383 gpm 149 5,026 AF a - Represents unconsolidated alluvium b - Preliminary estimate, based Upper Ventura River 9,360 14.6 0-5 35,118 AF 600 gpm 160 9,482 AF on groundwater balance for water years 1997-2007

6,090 9.5 3-13 8,743 AF a 20 gpm 16 2,130 AF b Source: Daniel B. Stephens & Lower Ventura River Associates, Inc. 2010 & 2013

Figure 3.3.3.2 Groundwater Basins Map Data sources: See Table 3.4.2.1.3 Groundwater Basins Map Data Sources in “3.4.2 Water Supplies” for an explanation of the various data in the table. 1 Pressure 2 Fillmore 3 Santa Paula 4 Piru 5 Pleasant Valley 6 Mound 7 East Las Posas 12 8 West Las Posas 9 Oxnard Plain Forebay 10 South Las Posas 31 11 Lower Ventura River 12 Cuyama Valley Cuyama River 13 Mugu Forebay Watershed 14 Simi Valley 19 23 15 Thousand Oaks 16 Tapo Gillibrand 17 Arroyo Santa Rosa 18 Ojai Valley 19 Lockwood Valley 20 Tierra Rejeda Valley 21 Upper Ventura River 22 South Coast 23 Hungry Valley 29 24 Russell Valley 25 Conejo Valley 26 North Coast 28 Upper Ojai Santa Clara 29 Mutau Flat 30 Sherwood River Watershed 31 Little Cuddy Valley Ventura River 32 Las Virgenes Cyn Watershed

18 28 21

4 2

26

3 16 7

11 8 6 10 14 20 9 Watershed 17 5

Watershed 25 1 15 32

30 24 Groundwater Basins 13 22 Watershed Boundaries Subwatersheds 22 Sources: Esri, DeLorme, NAVTEQ, TomTom, Intermap, iPC, USGS, FAO, NPS, NRCAN, GeoBase, IGN, Kadaster NL, Ordnance Survey, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China (Hong Kong), and the GIS User Community

0 2 4 8 Miles Ventura County Figure 3-8 Resource Management Agency Disclaimer: this map was created by the Ventura County Resource Management Agency, Mapping Services - GIS, which is designed Information Systems Department Groundwater Basins and operated solely for the convenience of the County and related Map created on 04/07/2014 public agencies. The County does not warrant the accuracy of this map and no decision involving a risk of economic loss or physical É injury should be made in reliance therein WCVC IRWM Region JM 248 VENTURA RIVER WATERSHED MANAGEMENT PLAN

V E N T U R A M a ti li ja C O U N T Y C r e e

k

k

e

e

r

C

a

j

i

l

i t

a . M r

C

k r a

j o i l

F i O t ld M N a an C er reek Upp M k r n rt Fo o M o h y a G tili N n j r a a Cre i ek C d t r l ek n e e Matilija o a n C r y a y ta n w c o t C y rie Reservoir a e n u t a n M C a n

S a r y l D

r C

l o

a r e n o r

B E D n o

a i r y n n

S A N T A z s C e t e C o o r O e S y v e ek n j B A R B A R A i e a k r

a i C

R l C k

C O U N T Y D l e S e

r e k

a x r e a N

Meiners a c Cr ee re o C k C n r s

i e e n M Oaks F v r t r o a e u ac h e R e am A t Th c Sy C n L Ojai a i n v o Upper O jai e C e

y O r

o e V

a e

B t k e k i C C Mir a Monte g

r

r e C k a

e e ek

e e yon Cre n

k k an y C o e n n r Lio ·þ150 C io n n o o Oak t y n View n a A C n n d a o S m m a Lake H Casitas C Cas itas S prings oyo n ek te yo re C n C r

e a a ¤£101 C e rg k a n L

o

d a l e d Detail Area Map ñ a W C a

Man ue l C a ny on n n ·þ33 nyo nyo Ca Ca y ell ned D . J oaq uin Ken k a n

y C S z e

ad a d o n C a n

o C y n D a e n t D r ain Rice Canyon d C McDonal ·þ126 Cany Meiners ills on W Oaks Ventura Hap Ventur a River py Va r lley D Estuary ¤£101 e rain v i Miles R ¯ 0 0.5 1 2 3 4 a r

u

t Mira

n L e Monte iv e V in Dra Drainage Network ·þ150 O ke a La k or C rr n M i k r i Ventura River Watershed e a e r e e k D r

e C n i l o y n i k i a n S r o D t Oak w n ie A View V n k a a S

O Data Source: Hydrologic Data: Ventura Watershed Protection District Map Created by GreenInfo Network using Esri software Jan. 2015 www.greeninfo.org

Figure 3.3.1.1.1 Drainage Network Map

EXHIBIT B

1 GENE TANAKA, Bar No. 101423 [email protected] 2 SARAH CHRISTOPHER FOLEY, Bar No. 277223 [email protected] 3 DAKOTAH BENJAMIN, Bar No. 316446 [email protected] 4 BEST BEST & KRIEGER LLP 2001 N. Main Street, Suite 390 5 Walnut Creek, California 94596 Telephone: (925) 977-3300 6 Facsimile: (925) 977-1870

7 SHAWN HAGERTY, Bar No. 182435 [email protected] 8 BEST BEST & KRIEGER LLP 655 West Broadway, 15th Floor 9 San Diego, California 92101 Telephone: 619.525.1300 10 Facsimile: 619.233.6118

11 Attorneys for Respondent and Cross-Complainant CITY OF SAN BUENAVENTURA 12 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 13 COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES 14

15 SANTA BARBARA CHANNELKEEPER, Case No. 19STCP01176 a California non-profit corporation, 16 Judge: Honorable William F. Highberger Petitioner, 17 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING LEAVE v. TO FILE THIRD AMENDED CROSS- 18 COMPLAINT STATE WATER RESOURCES 19 CONTROL BOARD, a California State Date: November 21, 2019 Agency; et al., Time: 10:00 a.m. 20 Dept.: SS10 Respondents. 21 Action Filed: September 19, 2014 Trial Date: Not Set 22 CITY OF SAN BUENAVENTURA, a California municipal corporation, 23 Cross-Complainant, 24 v. 25 DUNCAN ABBOTT, an individual; et al. 26 Cross-Defendants. 27

28

82470.00018\32489345.1 [Proposed] Order Grant. Leave to File 3d Am. Cross-Compl.

1 [PROPOSED] ORDER RE THIRD AMENDED CROSS-COMPLAINT

2 3 On November 21, 2019, the Court held a Status Conference, the Honorable William F. 4 Highberger, Judge presiding. The parties stated their appearances on the record. Defendant and 5 Cross-Complainant City of San Buenaventura (“City”) requested leave to file a Third Amended 6 Cross-Complaint (“3rd Am. Cross-Complaint”). The proposed 3d Am. Cross-Complaint was 7 discussed in and attached to the Joint Status Conference Statement, filed November 19, 2019. No 8 parties opposed filing the 3rd Am. Cross-Complaint. 9 10 Accordingly, it is HEREBY ORDERED that: 11

12 1. City is granted leave to file and serve the 3d Am. Cross-Complaint attached to the 13 Joint Status Conference Statement. 14

15 2. All Answers filed regarding City’s Second Amended Cross-Complaint, dated 16 September 20, 2018, shall be deemed to apply to the 3d Am. Cross-Complaint. 17 18 3. Cross-Defendants shall have 60 days to file a response following service of the 3rd 19 Am. Cross-Complaint by City. 20

21 4. City shall have 60 days after filing 3d Am. Cross-Complaint to file proofs of 22 service of the Summons and 3d Am. Cross-Complaint consistent with the Order Regarding 23 Respondent and Cross-Complainant City of San Buenaventura’s Second Application for 24 Extension of Time, issued by the San Francisco Superior Court and dated January 17, 2019. 25

26 27 28

82470.00018\32489345.1 -2- [Proposed] Order Grant. Leave to File 3d Am. Cross-Compl.

1 Dated: ______By: 2 The Honorable William F. Highberger Judge of the Superior Court 3 County of Los Angeles

4

5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14

15 16 17 18 19 20

21 22 23 24 25

26 27 28

82470.00018\32489345.1 - 3 - [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING CITY’S MOTION FOR APPROVAL

EXHIBIT C Santa Barbara Channelkeeper v. State Water Resources Control Board, et al Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. 19STCP01176 Riparian Landowners

First Name / Organization Name Middle Name Last Name Suffix AKA /DBA Type (AKA / DBA) AKA / DBA First Name / AKA / DBA Middle AKA / DBA Last Name AKA / DBA Suffix Party Type Parcel # Parcel Address Organization Name Name 1970 Ranch Road, LLC XDEF 011-0-052-210 Ojai CA 93023 625 N Ventura Avenue, LLC XDEF 061-0-080-065 625 N Ventura St Ojai CA 93023- Abraham Munoz XDEF 060-0-252-070 611 Casitas Vista Rd Ventura CA 93001-9766 Ahde Lahti XDEF 009-0-121-025 16044 Maricopa Hwy Ojai CA 93023-9507 Ganea Lahti XDEF 009-0-121-025 16044 Maricopa Hwy Ojai CA 93023-9507 Alan James XDEF 031-0-222-075 53 W Catalina Dr Oak View CA 93022- Carol James XDEF 031-0-222-075 53 W Catalina Dr Oak View CA 93022- 060-0-230-080 Alessandro Lobba Trustee Looba-Jackson Family Trust XDEF 947 Casitas Vista Rd Ventura CA 93001-9738 060-0-230-080 Mary E. Jackson E Jackson Trustee Looba-Jackson Family Trust XDEF 947 Casitas Vista Rd Ventura CA 93001-9738 Alexander Doran XDEF 031-0-223-200 72 W Catalina Dr Oak View CA 93022-9570 Maria Doran Doran XDEF 031-0-223-200 72 W Catalina Dr Oak View CA 93022-9570 Alfredo Bello XDEF 033-0-270-595 11055 Creek Rd Ojai CA 93023-9411 Montelle Bello XDEF 033-0-270-595 11055 Creek Rd Ojai CA 93023-9411 Alvin Cunningham XDEF 060-0-252-710 591 Casitas Vista Rd Ventura CA 93001-9766 Claudia Cunningham XDEF 060-0-252-710 591 Casitas Vista Rd Ventura CA 93001-9766 Amy K Mattison Trustee Amy K Mattison Trust XDEF 022-0-012-030 1128 N Signal St Ojai CA 93023-1832 Anatoly Kozushin XDEF 034-0-250-015 10934 Alto Ct Oak View CA 93022-9533 Margarita Kozushin XDEF 034-0-250-015 10934 Alto Ct Oak View CA 93022-9533 Andrea Leigh Jensen Trustee Jensen Trust XDEF 061-0-090-260 Ojai CA 93022-9422 Andrew Holguin XDEF 034-0-250-155 623 Azure Ct Oak View CA 93022-9239 Jane Holguin XDEF 034-0-250-155 623 Azure Ct Oak View CA 93022-9239 032-0-221-235 Andrew D West Trustee West Family Revocable Trust XDEF 11575 Oakcrest Ave Ojai CA 93023-4016 032-0-221-235 Patricia G West Trustee West Family Revocable Trust XDEF 11575 Oakcrest Ave Ojai CA 93023-4016 Andrew Holguin XDEF 034-0-250-195 602 Azure Ct Oak View CA 93022-9239 009-0-110-355 Angie Marie Ganasei Trustee Genasei-Danch Family Trust XDEF 16196 Maricopa Hwy Ojai CA 93023- 009-0-110-355 Christopher Paul Danch Trustee Genasei-Danch Family Trust XDEF 16196 Maricopa Hwy Ojai CA 93023- 009-0-110-385 Angie Marie Ganasei Trustee Genasei-Danch Family Trust XDEF 16200 Maricopa Hwy Ojai CA 93023-9552 009-0-110-385 Christopher Paul Danch Trustee Genasei-Danch Family Trust XDEF 16200 Maricopa Hwy Ojai CA 93023-9552 Anne Lombard XDEF 034-0-250-135 825 Azure Ct Oak View CA 93022-9239 Frank Hanson XDEF 034-0-250-135 825 Azure Ct Oak View CA 93022-9239 Armando Sanchez XDEF 032-0-176-115 65 Valley Ridge St Ojai CA 93023-4039 Sendi Sanchez XDEF 032-0-176-115 65 Valley Ridge St Ojai CA 93023-4039 Arthur Timothy Foy XDEF 034-0-040-055 10832 Creek Rd Ojai CA 93023-9412 Maurya Kathleen Foy XDEF 034-0-040-055 10832 Creek Rd Ojai CA 93023-9412 Ashlen Aquila XDEF 034-0-105-020 75 E Short St Oak View CA 93022-9724 Ivy Aquila XDEF 034-0-105-020 75 E Short St Oak View CA 93022-9724 Aubrey Balkind XDEF 010-0-180-470 555 Camino Cielo Ojai CA 93023-9501 Auburn Oak Builders, Inc. XDEF 032-0-221-265 11571 Oakcrest Ave Ojai CA 93023-4016 Barry Ross XDEF 035-0-120-175 9725 Old Creek Rd Ventura CA 93001-1002 Angela Ross XDEF 035-0-120-175 9725 Old Creek Rd Ventura CA 93001-1002 Behrooz Jadidollahi XDEF 009-0-090-070 93023 Benjamin Vail XDEF 032-0-177-105 107 Willey St Ojai CA 93023-4028 Stacey Vail XDEF 032-0-177-105 107 Willey St Ojai CA 93023-4028 Berkley Baker XDEF 011-0-230-155 12101 Macdonald Dr Ojai CA 93023-9735 Suzanne Baker XDEF 011-0-230-155 12101 Macdonald Dr Ojai CA 93023-9735 Bettina Chandler Trustee Bettina Chandler Trust XDEF 011-0-230-105 1013 Shokat Dr Ojai CA 93023-9729 Blanche Chapler XDEF 060-0-260-020 Ventura CA 93001 Bradford Boyd XDEF 032-0-230-035 153 Crown St Ojai CA 93023-4005

32507873 1 Santa Barbara Channelkeeper v. State Water Resources Control Board, et al Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. 19STCP01176 Riparian and Overlying Landowners

First Name / Organization Name Middle Name Last Name Suffix AKA /DBA Type (AKA / AKA / DBA First Name / AKA / DBA Middle Name AKA / DBA Last Name AKA / DBA Suffix Party Type Parcel No. Parcel Address DBA) Organization Name 1300 Shippee Lane, LLC XDEF 029-0-010-185 1300 Shippee Ln, Ojai CA 93023-9330 3584 Calle Moreno, LLC XDEF 029-0-010-145 3584 Calle Moreno, Ojai CA 93023-9360 Aaron Hoekstra XDEF 018-0-200-135 1438 S La Luna Ave, Ojai CA 93023-3816 Angela Hoekstra XDEF 018-0-200-135 1438 S La Luna Ave, Ojai CA 93023-3816 Abel Carranza XDEF 017-0-121-100 819 W El Roblar Dr, Ojai CA 93023-2117 Lourdes Carranza XDEF 017-0-121-100 819 W El Roblar Dr, Ojai CA 93023-2117 Acslayton, LLC XDEF 017-0-210-190 307 E El Roblar Dr, Ojai CA 93023-2328 Adam Casey XDEF 018-0-182-095 1133 Capello Way, Ojai CA 93023-3433 Brittany Chisum XDEF 018-0-182-095 1133 Capello Way, Ojai CA 93023-3433 Adam Distl, Jr. and Barbara B. 017-0-230-350 488 S Rice Rd, Ojai CA 93023-3402 Adam Distl JR Trustee Distl 1998 Revocable Trust XDEF Adam Distl, Jr. and Barbara B. 017-0-230-350 488 S Rice Rd, Ojai CA 93023-3402 Barbara B. Distl Trustee Distl 1998 Revocable Trust XDEF Adrian Ogden XDEF 024-0-102-110 384 Avenida Del Recreo, Ojai CA 93023-9606 Aera Energy, LLC XDEF 063-0-190-165 Ventura CA 93001- Aera Energy, LLC XDEF 063-0-190-275 4092 N Ventura Ave, Ventura CA 93001- AJR Investment Partnership, LP XDEF 028-0-111-010 1887 E Ojai Ave, Ojai CA 93023-9625 Alan Sharon XDEF 031-0-210-075 419 Burnham Rd, Oak View CA 93022-9321 Deborah Sharon XDEF 031-0-210-075 419 Burnham Rd, Oak View CA 93022-9321 Alan Connell XDEF 017-0-051-290 280 N La Luna Ave, Ojai CA 93023-1534 Leslie Connell XDEF 017-0-051-290 280 N La Luna Ave, Ojai CA 93023-1534 Alan Kirby XDEF 024-0-142-055 131 Longhorn Ln, Ojai CA 93023-4201 Mary Kirby XDEF 024-0-142-055 131 Longhorn Ln, Ojai CA 93023-4201 Alan Ecker XDEF 018-0-230-015 815 Oakwood St, Ojai CA 93023-3567 Susan Ecker XDEF 018-0-230-015 815 Oakwood St, Ojai CA 93023-3567 Alan Walbridge XDEF 063-0-060-245 234 Canada Larga Rd, Ventura CA 93001-1050 Dorothy Fay Walbridge XDEF 063-0-060-245 234 Canada Larga Rd, Ventura CA 93001-1050 Alberto Montano XDEF 063-0-072-115 5233 Larkspur Dr, Ventura CA 93001-1039 Adriana Montano XDEF 063-0-072-115 5233 Larkspur Dr, Ventura CA 93001-1039 Alberto Zamora XDEF 069-0-164-125 324 Dakota Dr, Ventura CA 93001-1215 Hilda Zamora XDEF 069-0-164-125 324 Dakota Dr, Ventura CA 93001-1215 Albine Hopcus Trustee Al and Alva Trust XDEF 018-0-222-055 1166 Mariano Dr, Ojai CA 93023-3450 Alvaro Lydia Hopcus Trustee Al and Alva Trust XDEF 018-0-222-055 1166 Mariano Dr, Ojai CA 93023-3450 Alfonso Limon XDEF 018-0-111-235 1145 Tico Rd, Ojai CA 93023-3561 Alejandra Limon XDEF 018-0-111-235 1145 Tico Rd, Ojai CA 93023-3561 Allan Parkhurst XDEF 018-0-191-035 1224 Alviria Dr, Ojai CA 93023-3422 Janis Parkhurst XDEF 018-0-191-035 1224 Alviria Dr, Ojai CA 93023-3422 Allan Parigian XDEF 018-0-200-290 1458 S La Luna Ave, Ojai CA 93023-3816 Katharine Parigian XDEF 018-0-200-290 1458 S La Luna Ave, Ojai CA 93023-3816 Allan Doane XDEF 018-0-191-125 1123 Moreno Dr, Ojai CA 93023-3459 Mary Doane XDEF 018-0-191-125 1123 Moreno Dr, Ojai CA 93023-3459 Allen Vail XDEF 018-0-182-175 1031 Capello Way, Ojai CA 93023-3431 Alvaro Ruiz XDEF 017-0-051-270 219 Carrizo St, Ojai CA 93023-1511 Elva Ruiz XDEF 017-0-051-270 219 Carrizo St, Ojai CA 93023-1511 Alvin Cunningham XDEF 010-0-102-190 651 Fairview Rd, Ojai CA 93023-9505 Claudia Cunningham XDEF 010-0-102-190 651 Fairview Rd, Ojai CA 93023-9505 Alvin Cunningham XDEF 010-0-102-210 645 Fairview Rd, Ojai CA 93023-9505 Claudia Cunningham XDEF 010-0-102-210 645 Fairview Rd, Ojai CA 93023-9505 Alvin Cunningham XDEF 017-0-202-070 441 S Pueblo Ave, Ojai CA 93023-2242 Claudia Cunningham XDEF 017-0-202-070 441 S Pueblo Ave, Ojai CA 93023-2242 Ana Cross Trustee Ana Cross Family Trust XDEF 024-0-072-055 1484 E Ojai Ave, Ojai CA 93023-9623 Andre Keunzli XDEF 023-0-141-170 107 Bald St, Ojai CA 93023-3303 Fabrienne Keunzli-Monard XDEF 023-0-141-170 107 Bald St, Ojai CA 93023-3303 Andrew Maccalla XDEF 023-0-132-120 605 Pope Ln, Ojai CA 93023-4219 Melissa Maccalla XDEF 023-0-132-120 605 Pope Ln, Ojai CA 93023-4219 Andrew Chandler XDEF 017-0-051-460 316 N La Luna Ave, Ojai CA 93023-1536 Rebecca Chandler XDEF 017-0-051-460 316 N La Luna Ave, Ojai CA 93023-1536 Andrew Engel XDEF 032-0-020-065 2169 Los Encinos Rd, Ojai CA 93023-9734 Sharon Engel XDEF 032-0-020-065 2169 Los Encinos Rd, Ojai CA 93023-9734 Angela Jayne Gardner Trustee Pleasant Avenue Living Trust XDEF 022-0-192-125 502 Pleasant Ave, Ojai CA 93023-1922 John Percival Mawson Trustee Pleasant Avenue Living Trust XDEF 022-0-192-125 502 Pleasant Ave, Ojai CA 93023-1922 Anita J Diaz XDEF 069-0-164-015 210 Dakota Dr, Ventura CA 93001-1213

32507123 1 EXHIBIT D Santa Barbara Channelkeeper v. State Water Resources Control Board, et al Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. 19STCP01176 Overlying Landowners

Owner1 First Owner1 Middle Owner1 Spouse First Owner2 Middle Owner2 Spouse First Owner Name Owner1 Last Name Owner2 First Name Owner2 Last Name Parcel Number Service Address 2 Name Name Name Name Name 1179 Mcnell Rd Ojai CA 029-0-010-810 1179 Mcnell Road Tr 1179 Mcnell Road Tr 93023-9317 1360 Shippee Ln Ojai CA 029-0-010-745 1360 Shippee Lane Llc 1360 Shippee Lane Llc 93023-9330 1563 Gridley Rd Ojai CA 028-0-010-040 1563 Home Acres Llc 1563 Home Acres Llc 93023-9620 1563 Gridley Rd Ojai CA 028-0-010-050 1563 Home Acres Llc 1563 Home Acres Llc 93023-9620 160 Besant Rd Ojai CA 93023- 017-0-260-060 160 Besant Rd Llc 160 Besant Rd Llc 2305

071-0-141-320 173 W Mission Ave Ventura 187 Mission Llc 187 Mission Llc CA 93001-6820 1980 N Ventura Ave Ventura 069-0-060-015 1980 Partners Llc 1980 Partners Llc CA 93001-

069-0-141-035 241 Delaware Dr Ventura CA 2018 3 Ihborrower Lp 2018 3 Ihborrower Lp 93001-1216

068-0-150-275 154 W Shoshone St Ventura 2018-1 Ih Borrower Lp 2018-1 Ih Borrower Lp CA 93001-0318

063-0-077-065 5310 Floral Dr Ventura CA 2018-4 Ih Borrower Lp 2018-4 Ih Borrower Lp 93001-1037 201 Bryant St Ojai CA 93023- 023-0-150-475 201A Bryant Street Partners 201A Bryant Street Partners 5003 1011 Grand Ave Ojai CA 028-0-173-010 23Rd Avenue Properties Llc 23Rd Avenue Properties Llc 93023-3036

069-0-052-325 265 Franklin Ln Ventura CA 269 Franklin Lane Llc 269 Franklin Lane Llc 93001-1417

071-0-010-150 303 W Ramona St Ventura CA 303 Ramona L P 303 Ramona L P 93001-4681

021-0-081-050 311 N Montgomery St Ojai CA 311 Montgomery Llc 311 Montgomery Llc 93023-2745 317 Grand Ave Ojai CA 93023- 021-0-051-270 317 Grand Ave Llc 317 Grand Ave Llc 1840

068-0-142-195 308 W Lewis St Ventura CA 320 West Llc 320 West Llc 93001-1335

068-0-142-175 320 W Lewis St Ventura CA 320 West Llc 320 West Llc 93001-1335

069-0-122-150 332 El Medio St Ventura CA 332 El Medio Street Llc 332 El Medio Street Llc 93001-1730 340 East Main Street, LLC, a 340 E. Main Street Ventura 073-0-033-030 California limited liability company 93001 365 E. Santa Clara LLC, a California 365 E. Santa Clara St. Ventura 073-0-033-230 limited liability company 93001 230 Holt St Ventura CA 93001- 063-0-172-170 392 Wall Llc 392 Wall Llc 1111 392 Wall St Ventura CA 071-0-152-180 392 Wall Llc 392 Wall Llc 93001-4904 401 Bryant St Ojai CA 93023- 023-0-173-030 401 Bryant Llc 401 Bryant Llc 3311

32508053 1

EXHIBIT E

1 GENE TANAKA, Bar No. 101423 [email protected] 2 SARAH CHRISTOPHER FOLEY, Bar No. 277223 [email protected] 3 DAKOTAH BENJAMIN, Bar No. 316446 [email protected] 4 Best Best & Krieger LLP 2001 N. Main Street, Suite 390 5 Walnut Creek, California 94596 Tel.: 925.977.3300; Fax: 925.977.1870 6 SHAWN HAGERTY, Bar No. 182435 7 [email protected] Best Best & Krieger LLP 8 655 West Broadway, 15th Floor San Diego, California 92101 9 Tel.: 619.525.1300; Fax: 619.233.6118

10 Attorneys for Respondent and Cross-Complainant CITY OF SAN BUENAVENTURA 11

12 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 13 COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES 14 LAW LAW OFFICES OF SANTA BARBARA CHANNELKEEPER, Case No. 19STCP01176

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 a California non-profit corporation,

2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 Judge: Honorable William F. Highberger WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 Petitioner, NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT OF 17 v. GROUNDWATER BASIN AND WATERSHED ADJUDICATION 18 STATE WATER RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD, a California State CMC:

19 Agency; Time: CITY OF SAN BUENAVENTURA, a Dept: SS10 20 California municipal corporation, incorrectly named as CITY OF Action Filed: Sept. 19, 2014 21 BUENAVENTURA, Trial Date: Not Set 22 Respondents.

23 CITY OF SAN BUENAVENTURA, a 24 California municipal corporation,

25 Cross-Complainant

26 v.

27 DUNCAN ABBOTT, an individual, et al.

28 Cross -Defendants.

82470.00018\32405188.3 -1- Notice of Commencement of Groundwater Basin and Watershed Adjudication

1 NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT OF 2 GROUNDWATER BASIN ADJUDICATION 3 4 5 THIS NOTICE IS IMPORTANT. ANY RIGHTS YOU CLAIM TO PUMP 6 OR STORE GROUNDWATER FROM THE BASINS IDENTIFIED IN THIS 7 NOTICE MAY BE AFFECTED BY A LAWSUIT INITIATED BY THE THIRD 8 AMENDED CROSS-COMPLAINT SUMMARIZED BELOW. 9 10 A copy of the Third Amended Cross-Complaint may be obtained by contacting 11 Cross-Complainant’s attorney identified in this notice. If you claim rights to pump or

12 store groundwater within the basins identified herein, either now or in the future, you 13 may become a party to this lawsuit by filing an answer to the lawsuit on or before the 14 deadline specified in this notice. You may file an answer by completing the attached LAW LAW OFFICES OF Form Answer, filing it with the court indicated in this notice, and sending a copy of the

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390

WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 Form Answer to the Cross-Complainant’s attorney identified below in this notice. 17 18 Failing to participate in this lawsuit could have a significant adverse effect on any right to pump or store groundwater that you may have. Specifically, a judgment 19 20 may be entered that prevents any person now or in the future, who owns your land

21 from ever pumping, extracting or storing groundwater from, under or on your land. 22 23 You may seek the advice of an attorney in relation to this lawsuit. Such 24 attorney should be consulted promptly. A case management conference (“CMC”) in 25 this groundwater basin adjudication proceeding is currently scheduled to occur on the

26 date specified on the cover page of this notice. If you intend to participate in the 27 groundwater adjudication proceeding to which this notice applies, you are advised to 28 attend the next case management conference in person or have an attorney represent

82470.00018\32405188.3 - 2 - Notice of Commencement of Groundwater Basin and Watershed Adjudication

1 you at the next case management conference. 2 3 Participation requires the production of all information regarding your 4 groundwater use. You must provide this information within six months of 5 appearing in the comprehensive adjudication, unless otherwise stipulated by the 6 parties or ordered by the Court pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 842. 7 8 A Form Answer is provided for your convenience. You may fill out the 9 Form Answer and file it with the Court. Should you choose to file the Form 10 Answer, it will serve as an answer to all complaints and cross-complaints filed in 11 this case.

12 13 The following information is provided pursuant to Code of Civil 14 Procedure section 836(a)(1)(B): LAW LAW OFFICES OF

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 (i) Names of Basins: 17 a. Upper Ventura River Groundwater Basin (Department of Water 18 Resources’ (“DWR”) Bulletin 118 Groundwater Basin Number

19 4-3.01); 20 b. Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin (DWR’s Bulletin 118 21 Groundwater Basin Number 4-2); 22 c. Lower Ventura River Groundwater Basin (DWR’s Bulletin 118 23 Groundwater Basin Number 4-3.02); and 24 d. Upper Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin (DWR’s Bulletin 118 25 Groundwater Basin Number 4-1) 26 (collectively “Ventura River Watershed Groundwater Basins”). 27 28

82470.00018\32405188.3 - 3 - Notice of Commencement of Groundwater Basin and Watershed Adjudication

1 A map of each of the Ventura River Watershed Groundwater Basins is 2 available at https://gis.water.ca.gov/app/bbat/. 3 4 (ii) Case No. 19STCP01176, Los Angeles County Superior Court, 5 Complex Civil Litigation Division, Department No. 010, Judge William F. 6 Highberger presiding, located at 312 North Spring Street, Los Angeles, 7 California 90012. 8 9 (iii) Cross-Complainant’s counsel may be contacted at the following 10 mailing address, telephone number, and email address: 11

Dakotah Benjamin 12 Best Best & Krieger LLP 2001 N. Main Street, Suite 390 13 Walnut Creek, California 94596 Telephone: 925.977.3330 14 [email protected] LAW LAW OFFICES OF

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 (iv) The Third Amended Cross-Complaint initiating this action for a 17 comprehensive adjudication of the Ventura River Watershed including the Ventura 18 River Watershed Groundwater Basins alleges nine claims for relief: (1)

19 preliminary and permanent injunction reducing Cross-Defendants’ use of surface 20 and/or subsurface water and groundwater affecting the surface and/or subsurface 21 flow of the Ventura River to a level of reasonable and beneficial use under 22 California Constitution Article X, Section 2; (2) preliminary and permanent 23 injunction reducing Cross-Defendants’ use of surface and/or subsurface water and 24 groundwater affecting the surface and/or subsurface flow of the Ventura River to a 25 level of reasonable and beneficial use and a level that protects public trust 26 resources under the public trust doctrine; (3) declaratory relief for pueblo and/or 27 treaty water rights; (4) declaratory relief for prescriptive water rights; (5) 28 declaratory relief for appropriative water rights; (6) comprehensive adjudication

82470.00018\32405188.3 - 4 - Notice of Commencement of Groundwater Basin and Watershed Adjudication

1 and physical solution; (7) declaratory relief for municipal priority; (8) declaratory 2 relief for the human right to water; and (9) declaratory relief regarding the Cross- 3 Complainant’s use of surface and/or subsurface water and groundwater affecting 4 the Ventura River Watershed and declaratory relief that Cross-Defendants’ water 5 uses are not reasonable or beneficial and violate the public trust doctrine. This 6 Third Amended Cross-Complaint includes claims regarding the groundwater uses 7 in the Ventura River Watershed Groundwater Basins. The Third Amended Cross- 8 Complaint also includes claims regarding surface water uses from the Ventura 9 River and its tributaries, which may be governed by future court orders. 10 11 (v) Date by which persons receiving this notice must appear in

12 comprehensive adjudication: Pursuant to Judge Highberger’s Order, within sixty 13 (60) days of receipt of this notice and accompanying form answer, either by filing 14 the attached form answer or other appearance authorized by law. LAW LAW OFFICES OF

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 (vi) Service and Filing of Court Documents. You must serve your Form 17 Answer and any other court documents by electronic service through the provider 18 File & ServeXpress. To register, visit their website,

19 https://os.fileandservexpress.com/web/ui/welcomepage.aspx, or call 1-888-529- 20 7587. 21 22 You must file your Form Answer and any other court documents in this case 23 by one of three ways at the Stanley Mosk Courthouse, located at 111 North Hill 24 Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012, http://www.lacourt.org/courthouse/info/address/la. 25 a. Deliver in person to: Stanley Mosk Courthouse, Complex Civil 26 Filing Window, First Floor, Room 102, between the hours of 27 8:30 a.m. and 4:30 p.m., Monday through Friday, except for 28 Court Holidays;

82470.00018\32405188.3 - 5 - Notice of Commencement of Groundwater Basin and Watershed Adjudication

1 b. Mail to: Stanley Mosk Courthouse, 111 North Hill Street, Room 2 102, Los Angeles, CA 90012; or 3 c. Fax filing: Stanley Mosk Courthouse, General Jurisdiction- 4 Complex (Room 102), Facsimile Telephone Number: (442) 247- 5 3769. 6 7 The Courthouse where documents will be filed is different than the 8 Courthouse where this matter will be heard. See (ii) above. 9 10 (vii) Court fees. A first appearance fee of $435 will be required for all 11 newly appearing cross-defendants, subject to any applicable waiver. If you cannot

12 afford the first appearance fee, you may seek a waiver by filling out the form 13 available at: https://www.courts.ca.gov/forms.htm?filter=FW, and serving and 14 filing it as described in (vi) above. LAW LAW OFFICES OF

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 a. If the Court grants your request for a fee waiver, you may e-mail 2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 the order to File & ServeXpress at [email protected] , 17 and File & ServeXpress will waive document service fees. 18 b. No additional complex fees are required in accordance with

19 California Government Code section 70616. 20 21 (viii) Public Meetings. The City of San Buenaventura will hold three public 22 community meetings to explain the proceedings in this comprehensive adjudication 23 of the Ventura River Watershed. The meetings shall take place on:

24 ______, February ___, 2019, 6:00 p.m. - 8:00 p.m. Matilija Junior High School, Auditorium 25 703 El Paseo Road Ojai, CA 93023 26

27 Wednesday, February 12, 2019, 6:00 p.m. - 8:00 p.m. Bell Arts Factory, Community Room 28

82470.00018\32405188.3 - 6 - Notice of Commencement of Groundwater Basin and Watershed Adjudication

1 432 N. Ventura Ave Ventura, CA 93001 2 Thursday, February 13, 2019, 6:00 p.m. - 8:00 p.m. 3 Oak View Community Center, Kunkle Room 4 18 Valley Road Oak View, CA 93022 5

6 Dated: November 19, 2019 BEST BEST & KRIEGER LLP

7

8 By: GENE TANAKA 9 SHAWN HAGERTY SARAH CHRISTOPHER FOLEY 10 DAKOTAH BENJAMIN Attorneys for Respondent and Cross- 11 Complainant CITY OF SAN

BUENAVENTURA 12 13 14 LAW LAW OFFICES OF

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390

WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 17 18

19 20

21 22 23 24 25

26 27 28

82470.00018\32405188.3 - 7 - Notice of Commencement of Groundwater Basin and Watershed Adjudication

EXHIBIT F

1 GENE TANAKA, Nro. de matrícula 101423 [email protected] 2 SARAH CHRISTOPHER FOLEY, Nro. de matrícula 277223 3 [email protected] DAKOTAH BENJAMIN, Nro. de matrícula 316446 4 [email protected] Best & Krieger LLP 5 2001 N. Main Street, Suite 390 Walnut Creek, California 94596 6 Tel.: 925.977.3300; Fax: 925.977.1870

7 SHAWN HAGERTY, Nro. de matrícula 182435 [email protected] 8 Best & Krieger LLP 655 West Broadway, Piso15vo. 9 San Diego, California 92101 Tel.: 619.525.1300; Fax: 619.233.6118 10 Abogados del demandado y Contrademandante

11 CIUDAD DE SAN BUENAVENTURA 12 TRIBUNAL SUPERIOR DEL ESTADO DE CALIFORNIA 13 CONDADO DE LOS ANGELES 14

DESPACHO JURÍDICO DE

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 SANTA BARBARA CHANNELKEEPER, Caso No. 19STCP01176

2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 una corporación sin fines de lucro de WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 California Juez: Honorable William F. Highberger

17 Demandante AVISO DE INICIO DE ADJUDICACIÓN DE CUENCAS Y CUENCAS SUBTERRÁNEAS 18 v. CMC:

19 JUNTA ESTATAL DE CONTROL DE Hora: RECURSOS HÍDRICOS, una dependencia Dept: SS10 20 estatal de California; CIUDAD DE SAN BUENAVENTURA, Acción presentada: 19 de septiembre de 2014 21 una corporación municipal de California, Fecha del juicio: Por definir nombrada de manera incorrecta como 22 CIUDAD DE BUENAVENTURA, 23 Demandados.

24 CIUDAD DE SAN BUENAVENTURA, 25 una corporación municipal de California,

26 Contrademandante v. 27 DUNCAN ABBOTT, un individuo et al.

28 Contrademandados.

82470.00018\32506983.1 -1- Aviso de Inicio de Adjudicación de Cuencas y Cuencas Subterráneas

1 AVISO DE INICIO DE ADJUDICACIÓN DE 2 CUENCA SUBTERRÁNEA 3 4 5 ESTE AVISO ES IMPORTANTE. TODO DERECHO QUE USTED 6 RECLAME PARA BOMBEAR O ALMACENAR AGUA SUBTERRÁNEA DE 7 LAS CUENCAS IDENTIFICADAS EN ESTE AVISO PUEDE SER AFECTADO 8 POR UNA DEMANDA INICIADA POR LA TERCERA CONTRADEMANDA 9 MODIFICADA QUE SE RESUME A CONTINUACIÓN. 10 Se puede obtener copia de la Tercera Contrademanda Modificada contactando al

11 12 abogado del Contrademandante identificado en este aviso. Si usted reclama derechos 13 para bombear o almacenar agua subterránea dentro de las cuencas identificadas en el 14 presente, ya sea ahora o en un futuro, usted puede pasar a ser parte de esta demanda al

DESPACHO JURÍDICO DE presentar una respuesta a la demanda en o antes de la fecha límite especificada en este

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390

WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 aviso. Usted puede presentar una respuesta completando el Formulario de respuesta 17 adjunto, presentándolo ante el juzgado indicado en este aviso y enviando una copia al 18 abogado del Contrademandante identificado a continuación en este aviso.

19 20 El no participar en esta demanda podría tener un efecto adverso importante

21 sobre los derechos a bombear o almacenar agua subterránea que usted pudiera tener. 22 Específicamente, se podría dictar un fallo que evite que cualquier persona que sea 23 dueña de su tierra, ahora o en el futuro, bombee, extraiga o almacene agua subterránea 24 de, debajo o en su tierra. 25

26 Usted puede buscar asesoría legal al respecto. En dado caso deberá hacerlo de 27 manera expedita. Actualmente hay una conferencia de manejo de caso ("CMC") en 28 este procedimiento de adjudicación de cuencas de agua subterránea programada para

82470.00018\32506983.1 - 2 - Aviso de Inicio de Adjudicación de Cuencas y Cuencas Subterráneas

1 la fecha especificada en la portada del presente. Si tiene la intención de participar en 2 el procedimiento de adjudicación de agua subterránea aplicable a este aviso, se le 3 sugiere asistir personalmente a la siguiente conferencia de manejo de caso, o estar 4 representado por un abogado en la siguiente conferencia de manejo de casos. 5 6 Para participar se exige que presente toda la información relacionada con su 7 uso de agua subterránea. Usted deberá proporcionarla en un plazo de seis meses a 8 partir de la fecha en que aparezca en la adjudicación integral, salvo que las partes 9 estipulen lo contrario o que el Tribunal lo haya ordenado de conformidad con la 10 sección 842 del Código de Procedimientos Civiles.

11 12 Para su conveniencia, se proporciona un Formulario de respuesta. Usted 13 puede llenarlo y presentarlo ante el juzgado. Si decide llenar el Formulario de 14 respuesta, este servirá como respuesta a todas las demandas y contrademandas DESPACHO JURÍDICO DE

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 relativas a este caso. 2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 17 Se proporciona la siguiente información de conformidad con el Código de 18 Procedimientos Civiles, sección 836(a)(1)(B):

19 20 (i) Nombres de las Cuencas: 21 a. Upper Ventura River Groundwater Basin (Cuenca subterránea 22 superior del Río Ventura), (Boletín 118 Cuenca subterránea 23 Número 4-3.01 del Departamento de Recursos Hídricos “DWR”); 24 b. Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin (Cuenca subterránea del Valle de 25 Ojai), (Boletín 118 Cuenca Subterránea Número 4-2 del DWR); 26 c. Lower Ventura River Groundwater Basin (Cuenca subterránea 27 inferior del Río Ventura), (Boletín 118 Cuenca subterránea 28 Número 4-3.02 del DWR); y

82470.00018\32506983.1 - 3 - Aviso de Inicio de Adjudicación de Cuencas y Cuencas Subterráneas

1 d. Upper Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin (Cuenca subterránea 2 superior del Valle de Ojai), (Boletín 118 Cuenca subterránea 3 Número 4-1 del DWR) 4 (colectivamente se las denomina Upper Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin, “Cuencas 5 subterráneas de la Cuenca del Río Ventura”). 6 7 8 Un mapa de cada una de las Cuenca Subterráneas de la Cuenca del Río Ventura 9 está a su disposición en https://gis.water.ca.gov/app/bbat/. 10

11 (ii) Caso No. 19STCP01176, Tribunal Superior del Condado de Los 12 Ángeles, División de Litigios Civiles Complejos, Departamento No. 010, 13 presidiendo el Juez William F. Highberger, ubicado en 312 North Spring Street, 14 Los Angeles, California 90012. DESPACHO JURÍDICO DE

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 (iii) El abogado del Contrademandante puede ser contactado en la siguiente 17 dirección, número de teléfono, y correo electrónico: 18 Dakotah Benjamin

19 Best & Krieger LLP 2001 N. Main Street, Suite 390 20 Walnut Creek, California 94596 Teléfono: 925.977.3330 21 [email protected] 22 23 (iv) La Tercera Contrademanda Modificada que inicia esta acción para una 24 adjudicación integral de la Cuenca del Río Ventura, incluyendo las Cuencas 25 Subterráneas de la Cuenca del Río Ventura, alega nueve reclamaciones de 26 indemnización: (1) orden judicial preliminar y permanente que reduce el uso, por 27 parte de los Contrademandados, del agua superficial y/o subsuperficial y del agua 28 subterránea que afecta el flujo superficial y/o subsuperficial del Río Ventura a un

82470.00018\32506983.1 - 4 - Aviso de Inicio de Adjudicación de Cuencas y Cuencas Subterráneas

1 nivel de uso razonable y benéfico de acuerdo con el Artículo X, Sección 2 de la 2 Constitución de California; (2) orden judicial preliminar y permanente que reduce el 3 uso, por parte de los Contrademandados, del agua superficial y/o subsuperficial y del 4 agua subterránea que afecta el flujo superficial y/o subsuperficial del Río Ventura a un 5 nivel de uso razonable y benéfico y a un nivel que proteja los recursos del fideicomiso 6 público de acuerdo con la doctrina del fideicomiso público; (3) medidas declaratorias 7 para los derechos de agua de los pueblos y/o tratados; (4) medidas declaratorias para 8 los derechos de agua prescriptivos; (5) medidas declaratorias para los derechos de 9 agua apropiados; (6) adjudicación integral y solución física; (7) medidas declaratorias 10 para prioridad municipal; (8) medidas declaratorias para el derecho humano al agua; y

11 (9) medidas declaratorias con respecto al uso, por la parte Contrademandante, del 12 agua superficial y/o subsuperficial y del agua subterránea que afecta la Cuenca del 13 Río Ventura y una medida declaratoria de que los usos del agua, por la parte 14 Contrademandada, no son razonables ni benéficos y violan la doctrina del fideicomiso DESPACHO JURÍDICO DE

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 público. Esta Tercera Contrademanda Modificada incluye reclamos relacionados con 2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 los usos del agua subterránea en las Cuencas Subterráneas de la Cuenca del Río 17 Ventura. La Tercera Contrademanda Modificada también incluye reclamos 18 relacionados por los usos de aguas superficiales del Río Ventura y sus afluentes, los

19 cuales pueden ser regulados por futuras órdenes judiciales. 20 21 (v) Fecha límite para que las personas que reciben este aviso deban 22 comparecer en la adjudicación integral: De conformidad con la Orden del Juez 23 Highberger, deberá ser dentro de los sesenta (60) días siguientes a la recepción de esta 24 notificación y formulario de respuesta que lo acompaña, sea al presentar el formulario 25 de respuesta adjunto u otra comparecencia autorizada por la ley. 26 27 (vi) Notificación y presentación de los documentos de la Corte. Debe enviar 28 su Formulario de respuesta y cualquier otro documento para la corte por servicio

82470.00018\32506983.1 - 5 - Aviso de Inicio de Adjudicación de Cuencas y Cuencas Subterráneas

1 electrónico a través del proveedor File & ServeXpress. Para registrarse, visite su sitio 2 web, https://os.fileandservexpress.com/web/ui/welcomepage.aspx, o llame al 1-888- 3 529-7587. 4 5 Debe presentar su Formulario de respuesta y cualquier otro documento para la 6 corte en este caso mediante una de las siguientes tres modalidades ante el Juzgado de 7 Stanley Mosk, ubicado en 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012, 8 http://www.lacourt.org/courthouse/info/address/la. 9 a. En persona en: Juzgado de Stanley Mosk, Ventana de Archivo 10 Civil Complejo, Primer Piso, Cuarto 102, de las 8:30 a.m. a las

11 4:30 p.m., lunes a viernes, excepto en vacaciones de la Corte; 12 b. Por correo postal a: Juzgado de Stanley Mosk, 111 de la calle 13 North Hill, (Cuarto 102), Los Angeles, CA 90012; o 14 c. Presentación por Fax: Juzgado de Stanley Mosk, Complejo de DESPACHO JURÍDICO DE

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 Jurisdicción General (Cuarto 102), Número de teléfono para 2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 Facsímile: (442) 247-3769 17 18 El Juzgado donde se presentarán los documentos es diferente que el Juzgado

19 donde se atenderá este caso. Consulte el apartado (ii) anterior. 20 21 (vii) Honorarios judiciales. Se requerirá una cuota por primera comparecencia 22 de $435 a todos los Contrademandados que comparezcan por primera vez, sujeta a 23 cualquier dispensa exención aplicable. Si no puede pagar la cuota de la primera 24 comparecencia, puede solicitar una exención completando el formulario disponible en: 25 https://www.courts.ca.gov/forms.htm?filter=FW, y enviándolo y presentándolo como 26 se describe en el apartado (vi) anterior. 27 a. Si la Corte le concede su solicitud de una exención de la cuota, 28 puede enviar la orden por correo electrónico a File & ServeXpress

82470.00018\32506983.1 - 6 - Aviso de Inicio de Adjudicación de Cuencas y Cuencas Subterráneas

1 a [email protected], y File & ServeXpress le eximirá 2 del pago de las cotas de presentación de los documentos. 3 b. No se requieren cargos compuestos adicionales de acuerdo con la 4 sección 70616 del Código de Gobierno de California. 5 6 (viii) Reuniones públicas. La Ciudad de San Buenaventura realizará tres 7 reuniones públicas comunitarias para explicar los procedimientos en esta adjudicación 8 integral de la Cuenca del Río Ventura. Las reuniones se realizarán en:

9 , el ____ de Febrero de 2020, de 6:00 p.m. a 8:00 p. m. Matilija Junior High School, Auditorio 10 703 Calle El Paseo Ojai, CA 93023 11 Miercoles, el 12 de Febrero de 2020, de 6:00 a 8:00 p. m. 12 Bell Arts Factory, Sala de comunidad 432 N. Ventura Ave 13 Ventura, CA 93001 14 Jueves, el 13 de Febrero de 2020, de 6:00 a 8:00 p. m. DESPACHO JURÍDICO DE

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 Oak View Community Center, cuarto Kunkle

2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 18 Calle Valley WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 Oak View, CA 93022 17 Fechado: , de 2019 BEST BEST & KRIEGER LLP 18

19 Por: 20 GENE TANAKA SHAWN HAGERTY 21 SARAH CHRISTOPHER FOLEY DAKOTAH BENJAMIN 22 Abogados de la Parte Demandada y Contrademandante CIUDAD DE SAN 23 BUENAVENTURA

24 25

26 27 28

82470.00018\32506983.1 - 7 - Aviso de Inicio de Adjudicación de Cuencas y Cuencas Subterráneas

EXHIBIT G

1 ______Name of Owner/Cross-Defendant/Attorney 2 ______3 Address ______4 Address ______5 Phone Number 6

7 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 8 COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES 9 SANTA BARBARA CHANNELKEEPER, Case No. 19STCP01176 10 a California non-profit corporation, Judge: Honorable William F. Highberger 11 Petitioner,

FORM ANSWER 12 v. Action Filed: Sept. 19, 2014 13 STATE WATER RESOURCES Trial Date: Not Set CONTROL BOARD, a California State 14 Agency; LAW LAW OFFICES OF CITY OF SAN BUENAVENTURA, a

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 California municipal corporation,

2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 incorrectly named as CITY OF WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 BUENAVENTURA, 17 Respondents.

18 CITY OF SAN BUENAVENTURA, a

19 California municipal corporation,

20 Cross-Complainant

21 v. 22 DUNCAN ABBOTT, an individual, et al. 23 Cross -Defendants. 24 25 26 27 28

82470.00018\31996300.1 -1- Answer to Adjudication Cross-Compl.

1 ANSWER TO ADJUDICATION 2 CROSS-COMPLAINT 3

4 The undersigned denies all material allegations in the cross-complaint in this 5 action that seeks to adjudicate rights in the Ventura River Watershed, including its 6 groundwater basins, which are the (1) Upper Ventura River Groundwater Basin 7 (Department of Water Resources’ (“DWR”) Bulletin 118, Groundwater Basin 8 Number 4-3.01); (2) Ojai Valley Groundwater Basin (DWR’s Bulletin 118, 9 Groundwater Basin Number 4-2); (3) Lower Ventura River Groundwater Basin 10 (DWR’s Bulletin 118, Groundwater Basin Number 4-3.02); and (4) Upper Ojai 11

Valley Groundwater Basin (DWR’s Bulletin 118 Groundwater Basin Number 4-1) 12 and asserts all applicable affirmative defenses to that cross-complaint. 13 14

LAW LAW OFFICES OF Date :

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 Signature 2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390

WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16

17 Name – Printed

18

19 Cross -Defendant Name

20 Mailing Address:

21 Street 22

23 City

24 State, Zip Code 25

26 Phone Number

27 Email Address 28

82470.00018\31996300.1 - 2 - Answer to Adjudication Cross-Compl.

1 Property Address :

2 Parcel No.(s):______

3 Street 4

5 Street

6 City 7

8 State, Zip Code

9 Attorney Information (if applicable): 10

11 Company/Firm Name

12 Attorney Name 13

14 Street Address LAW LAW OFFICES OF

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15

2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 City WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16

17 State, Zip Code

18 Phone Number

19

20 Fax Number

21 Email Address 22 23 24 25

26 27 28

82470.00018\31996300.1 - 3 - Answer to Adjudication Cross-Compl.

EXHIBIT H

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

9 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 10 COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES 11 SANTA BARBARA CHANNELKEEPER, Case No. 19STCP01176 12 a California non-profit corporation, Judge: Honorable William F. Highberger 13 Petitioner, [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING 14 v. RESPONDENT AND CROSS- COMPLAINANT CITY OF SAN 15 STATE WATER RESOURCES BUENAVENTURA’S MOTION FOR CONTROL BOARD, a California State APPROVAL OF NOTICE AND FORM 16 Agency; et al., ANSWER 17 Respondents. Date: November 21, 2019 Time: 2:00 p.m. 18 Dept.: SS10 CITY OF SAN BUENAVENTURA, a 19 California municipal corporation, Action Filed: September 19, 2014 Trial Date: Not Set 20 Cross-Complainant, 21 v. 22 DUNCAN ABBOTT, an individual; et al. 23 Cross-Defendants.

24 25

26 27 28

82470.00018\32405243.1 [Prop.] Order Grant. City’s Mot. for Approval of Notice and Form Answer

1 [PROPOSED] ORDER

2 3 On November 21, 2019, in Department 10 of the above-entitled Court, the Motion for 4 Approval of Notice and Form Answer (“Motion”) by Respondent and Cross-Complainant City of 5 San Buenaventura (“City”) came on for hearing, the Honorable William F. Highberger, Judge 6 presiding. The parties stated their appearances on the record. 7 8 After consideration of the papers filed in connection with the Motion and arguments of 9 counsel, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED: 10

11 1. City’s Motion is granted. 12

13 2. The Court approves the revised Notice of Commencement of Groundwater 14 Adjudication (“Notice of Adjudication”), revised Notice of Adjudication in 15 Spanish, and form answer (“Form Answer”), attached as exhibits A, B, and C 16 respectively. 17 18 3. The Court authorizes service of the revised Notice of Adjudication and Form 19 Answer in accordance with California Civil Procedure Code section 836(d). The 20 Court excuses the City from serving the Third Amended Cross-Complaint along

21 with the Notice of Adjudication and Form Answer in accordance with California 22 Civil Procedure Code section 836(i). 23 24 4. All those receiving the Notice of Adjudication and Form Answer shall have sixty 25 (60) days to respond to the Third Amended Cross-Complaint and may respond to

26 the Third Amended Cross-Complaint by completing, filing, and serving the Form 27 Answer. 28

82470.00018\32405243.1 -2- [Prop.] Order Grant. City’s Mot. for Approval of Notice and Form Answer

1 5. All service shall be made by electronic service through the provider File &

2 ServeXpress. To register, visit their website, 3 https://os.fileandservexpress.com/web/ui/welcomepage.aspx , or call 1-888-529- 4 7587. 5 6 6. Filing in this case must be done in one of three ways at the Stanley Mosk 7 Courthouse, located at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012, 8 http://www.lacourt.org/courthouse/info/address/la : 9 10 a. Deliver in person to: Stanley Mosk Courthouse, Complex Civil Filing 11 Window, First Floor, Room 102, between the hours of 8:30 a.m. and 4:30 12 p.m., Monday through Friday, except for Court Holidays; 13 14 b. Mail to: Stanley Mosk Courthouse, 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA

15 90012; or 16 17 c. Fax filing: Stanley Mosk Courthouse, General Jurisdiction-Complex 18 (Room 102), Facsimile Telephone Number: (442) 247-3769. 19 20 7. A first appearance fee of $435 will be required for all newly appearing cross-

21 defendants, subject to any applicable waiver. 22 23 8. No additional complex fees are required in accordance with California 24 Government Code section 70616. 25

26 9. A case management conference (“CMC”) in this proceeding is scheduled to occur 27 on ______. 28

82470.00018\32405243.1 - 3 - [Prop.] Order Grant. City’s Mot. For Approval Of Notice And Form Answer

1

2 Dated: ______By: The Honorable William F. Highberger 3 Judge of the Superior Court County of Los Angeles 4

5

6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14

15 16 17 18 19 20

21 22 23 24 25

26 27 28

82470.00018\32405243.1 - 4 - [Prop.] Order Grant. City’s Mot. For Approval Of Notice And Form Answer

1 PROOF OF SERVICE 2 I am a resident of the State of California and over the age of eighteen years, and 3 not a party to the within action; my business address is Best Best & Krieger LLP, 2001 N. Main 4 St. Suite 390, Walnut Creek, CA 94596. On November 19, 2019, I served the within 5 document(s): 6 JOINT STATUS CONFERENCE STATEMENT 7

8 £ by placing the document(s) listed above in a sealed envelope with postage thereon fully prepaid, in the United States mail at Walnut Creek, California addressed as 9 set forth below. I am readily familiar with the firm's practice of collection and 10 processin g correspondence for mailing. Under that practice it would be deposited with the U.S. Postal Service on that same day with postage thereon fully prepaid in 11 the ordinary course of business.

12 £ I caused such envelope to be delivered via overnight delivery. Such envelope was deposited for delivery by United Parcel Service following the firm’s ordinary 13 business practices. 14 LAW LAW OFFICES OF W by transmission via E-Service to File & Serve Xpress to the person(s) set forth below. Local Rules of Court 2.10 (P).

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 W By e -mail or electronic transmission. I caused the documents to be sent to the persons at the e-mail addresses listed below. I did not receive, within a reasonable 17 time after the transmission, any electronic message or other indication that the transmission was unsuccessful. 18

19 Daniel Cooper Matthew Bullock Cooper & Lewand-Martin, Inc. Deputy Attorney General 20 1004B O’Reilly Avenue California Department of Justice San Francisco, CA 94129 Natural Resources Law Section 21 Tel: (415) 360-2962 455 Golden Gate Ave., Suite 11000 [email protected] San Francisco, CA 94102-7004 22 Tel: (415) 510-3376 [email protected] 23

24 Attorneys for Petitioner and Plaintiff Attorneys for Respondent and Defendant State 25 Santa Barbara Channelkeeper Water Resources Control Board

26 27 28

82470.00018\32518138.1 - 1 - Proof of Service

1 Marc N. Melnick Eric M. Katz 2 Deputy Attorney General Supervising Deputy Attorney General Attorney General's Office Noah Golden – Krasner 3 1515 Clay Street, 20th Floor Deputy Attorney General P.O. Box 70550 300 South Spring Street, Suite 1702 4 Oakland, CA 94612-0550 Los Angeles, CA 90013 Tel: 510-879-0750 Tel. (213) 269-6343 5 [email protected] Fax (213) 897-2802 [email protected] 6 Attorneys for Respondent and Defendant [email protected] State Water Resources Control Board 7 Attorneys for Proposed Intervenor California Department of Fish & Wildlife 8

9 Edward J. Casey Paul Blatz Clynton Namuo Ryan Blatz 10 Alston & Bird LLP Blatz Law Firm 333 South Hope Street, 16th Floor 206 N. Signal St. Suite G 11 Los Angeles, CA 90071 Ojai, CA 93023 Tel: 213.576.1000 Tel: (805) 646-3110 12 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] 13 Attorneys for Cross-Defendants Bentley Attorneys for Cross-Defendants Troy Becker, 14 Family Limited Partnership and AGR Janet Boulten, Michael Boulten, Michael LAW LAW OFFICES OF Breeding, Inc. Caldwell, Joe Clark, Michael Cromer; Linda

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 Epstein, Etchart Ranch, Lawrence Hartmann,

2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 Ole Konig, Krotona Institute of Theosophy; WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 Stephen Mitchell; North Fork Springs Mutual Water Company, Rudd Ranch, LLC; Shlomo 17 Raz, Sylvia Raz, Senior Canyon Mutual Water Company, Siete Robles Mutual Water 18 Company, Soule Park Golf Course, Ltd., Telos, LLC, Victor Timar, John Town and Trudie

19 Town

20 Anthony Lee Francois William G. Short, Esq. Jeremy Talcott 21 Law Offices of William G. Short David Deerson Post Office Box 1313 Pacific Legal Foundation 22 Ojai, California 93024-1313 930 G Street Tel: (805) 490-6399 Sacramento, CA 95814-1802 23 Fax: (805) 640-1940 Tel: (916) 419-7111 [email protected] Fax: (916) 419-7111 24 [email protected] [email protected] 25 Attorney for Cross-Defendant Robin [email protected] Bernhoft [email protected] 26 Attorney for Cross -Defendant Robin Bernhoft 27 28

82470.00018\32518138.1 - 2 - Proof of Service

1 Robert N. Kwong Patrick Loughman Dennis O. La Rochelle Cristian Arrieta 2 Arnold Larochelle Mathews Vanconas & Lowthorp, Richards, McMillan, Miller & Zirbel, LLP Templeman 3 300 Esplanade Dr Ste 2100 300 Esplande Drive, Suite 850 Oxnard, CA 93036 Oxnard, CA 93036 4 Tel: (805) 988-9886 Tel: 805.804.3848 [email protected] [email protected] 5 [email protected]

6 Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Casitas Attorneys for Cross-Defendants Ernest Ford and Municipal Water District Tico Mutual Water Company 7

8 Gregory J. Patterson Lindsay F. Nielson Musick, Peeler & Garrett LLP Law Office of Lindsay F. Nielson 9 2801 Townsgate Road, Suite 200 845 E Santa Clara Street Westlake Village, CA 91361 Ventura, CA 93001 10 Tel: (805) 418-3103 Tel: 805-658-0977 Fax: (805) 418-3101 [email protected] 11 [email protected]

12 Attorneys for Cross-Defendants Robert C. Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Meiners Oaks Davis, Jr., James Finch, Friend's Ranches, Water District and Ventura River Water District 13 Inc., Topa Topa Ranch Company, LLC, The Thacher School, Thacher Creek Citrus, 14 LLC LAW LAW OFFICES OF

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 Jeanne Zolezzi Neal P. Maguire

2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 Herum Crabtree Suntag Ferguson Case Orr Patterson LLP WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 5757 Pacific Avenue, Suite 222 1050 South Kimball Road Stockton, CA 95207 Ventura, CA 93004 17 Tel: (209) 472-7700 Tel: (805) 659-6800 Fax: (209) 472.7986 [email protected] 18 [email protected] Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Rancho Matilija

19 Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Meiners Mutual Water Company Oaks Water District and Ventura River 20 Water District

21 22 23 24 25

26 27 28

82470.00018\32518138.1 - 3 - Proof of Service

1 Thomas S . Bunn III Michael J. Van Zandt Elsa Sham Nathan A. Metcalf 2 Lagerlof Senecal Gosney & Kruse LLP Sean G. Herman 301 N. Lake Avenue, 10th Floor Hanson Bridgett LLP 3 Pasadena, CA 91101-5123 425 Market Street, 26 Floor Tel.: (626) 793-9400 San Francisco, CA 94105 4 Fax: (626) 793-5900 Tel: 415-777-3200 [email protected] Fax: 415-541-9366 5 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] 6 [email protected]

7 Attorneys for Cross-Defendant St. Joseph’s Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Ventura County Associates of Ojai, California, Inc. Watershed Protection District 8

9 Scott Slater Joseph C. Chrisman Bradley Herrema Hathaway, Perrett, Webster, Powers, Chrisman 10 Christopher Guillen & Gutierrez Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck LLP 5450 Telegraph Road 11 1021 Anacapa Street, 2nd Floor Ventura, CA 93003 Santa Barbara, CA 93101 (805) 644-7111 12 Tel: (805) 963-7000 [email protected] Fax: (805) 965-4333 13 [email protected] [email protected] 14 [email protected] LAW LAW OFFICES OF

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Wood- Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Wood-

2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390 Claeyssens Foundation Claeyssens Foundation WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16

17 David B. Cosgrove Jeffrey M. Oderman 18 Douglas J. Dennington Jeremy N. Jungreis

19 Rutan & Tucker, LLP 611 Anton Boulevard, Suite 1400 20 Costa Mesa, CA 92626-1931 Tel: 714-641-5100 21 Fax: 714-546-9035 [email protected] 22 [email protected] [email protected] 23 [email protected]

24 Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Casitas 25 Municipal Water District

26 27 28

82470.00018\32518138.1 - 4 - Proof of Service

1 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the 2 above is true and correct. 3 Executed on November 19, 2019 at Walnut Creek, California. 4

5

6 Irene Islas 7 8 9 10 11

12 13 14 LAW LAW OFFICES OF

BEST BEST& KRIEGER LLP 15 2001 N. MAIN STREET, SUITE 390

WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 94596 16 17 18

19 20

21 22 23 24 25

26 27 28

82470.00018\32518138.1 - 5 - Proof of Service