Investigation of Host Genetic Factors in Infectious Disease
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Investigation of Priya Duggal, PhD, MPH Host Genetic Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health Factors in Infectious Disease: Acute July 23, 2019 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Flaccid Myelitis [email protected] @priya4genes Navigating the Human Genome WHY consider genetics in the study of infectious disease? HOW do we evaluate host genetic associations? WHAT are the implications of host genetic predispositions to infection? WHERE are the genes? 2 Traditional Infectious Path Infectious Pathogen Host Disease Do you Do you get get infected? disease? 3 Does it matter? Everyone gets infections. Heterogeneity Tuberculosis: Estimated that 1/3 of the worlds population is infected with mycobacteria, but among those infected only ~10% will develop clinical disease. Hepatitis B: 2 billion people (1 out of 3 people) have been infected with hepatitis B in the world, but ~10% will develop chronic disease. Lyme Disease: ~10-20% of people have continued symptoms and disease post antibiotic treatment HIV/AIDS: variability in time to AIDS (in the pre-HAART and controlled post-HAART era) 4 Other Factors What are you Age, Sex, exposed other Virulence to? covariates Infectious Pathogen Host Disease Do you Do you get get infected? Age, Sex, disease? other Genetics Genetics covariates 5 Why do we care? If we can understand why people have different outcomes---we will better understand the immune response and eventually exploit this understanding for therapeutics and vaccines. Our goals…are still to better understand disease so we can prevent and treat. 6 Infectious Disease: A complex trait? Infectious Disease is a perfect example of a complex trait Environmental Exposure: Exposure to a pathogen is critical. Redundancy and Complexity of the immune system suggest multiple genes may be involved in immune response. The pathogen (virus, bacteria, parasite) may also have genetic factors that are important. 7 Is there evidence of genetics influencing infectious disease? 8 Examples from the literature • Rare Mendelian Diseases • Natural Selection-Population Genetics • Vaccine controlled examples • Adoption studies 9 Rare Disorders of Immunity Mendelian susceptibility to mycobacterial disease (MSMD) Clinically described in 1951 Highly susceptible to weakly virulent mycobacteria but resistant to most other infectious diseases, except Salmonella. Multiple gene mutations in the IL-12/IL-23, IFN-γ mediated immunity pathway. This pathway is crucial for host defense of mycobacterium and Salmonella 10 Early Suggestions with ABO blood groups and infection Disease Blood Type Association Reference Cholera O Increased susceptibility Sircar, 1981 Clemens, 1989 Shigella O Increased susceptibility Robinson ,1971 Norovirus O Increased susceptibility Hutson, 2002 Hennessey, 2003 P. Falicparum O Protected Rowe, 2007 Cserti, 2007 Schistosomiasis A Increased Susceptibility Lima, 1979 Ndamba, 1997 Camus, 1977 11 Twin Studies Disease MZ DZ Country of Reference Concordance Concordance Study Leprosy* 52 22 India Chakravarti and Vogel 1973 HBV 35 4 Taiwan Lin, Anticancer Research, 1979 TB 65 25 Germany Diehl, 1936 32 14 UK Comstock, Am, Rev Respir Dis, 1978 * In cases where both twins had leprosy, the type of leprosy—tuberculoid or lepromataus was more likely to be concordant if the pair was monozygotic ** We expect MZ > DZ since they share the same alleles 12 Genetics or Environment or Pathogen? However, despite this noticeable heterogeneity in outcome (disease, response, etc) many consider that dose and environment likely explain many of these differences, NOT genetics. 13 Controlling Dose: We learn from our mistakes… 1926, Lubeck Germany 249 babies injected with the same live dose of virulent M. tuberculosis instead of BCG. Babies too young to have significant prior exposure to mycobacteria, and not previously vaccinated to BCG. All got the same strain, same dose. 76 babies died, 173 babies survived Dubos, The White Plague 1952 14 Adoption Studies Sorensen et al, NEJM 1988 . Followed 960 families that included children born between 1924-1926 who were placed with adoptive parents early in life. The adoptive parents were not related to them. Evaluated risk of dying between the ages of 16-58 years for adoptees with a biologic or adoptive parent who died of the same cause before age 50 and before age 70. This was compared to parents who were still alive at the ages of 50 and 70. 15 16 Is there a place for genetics? ✓ Rare Mendelian Diseases ✓ Natural Selection-Population Genetics ✓ Vaccine controlled examples ✓ Adoption studies 17 Navigating the Human Genome cont. WHY consider genetics in the study of infectious disease? HOW do we evaluate host genetic associations? WHAT are the implications of host genetic predispositions to infection? 18 How do we evaluate genetic associations? HBV ADMIXTURE FAMILY SEQUENCING BASED HIV DENGUE LINKAGE MALARIA GWAS Tuberculosis POPULATION BASED HCV Genetics and Infectious Disease: What do we already know? HIV: HLA, CCR5, Cullin 5 Pulmonary TB: MFN2, HLA, RPS4XP18 Malaria: HBB, ABO, ATP2B4 Dengue: MICB, PLCE1 HCV: Interferon Lambda, HLA, GPR158 Genetic links between symptomatic Entamoeba histolytica infection and inflammatory bowel disease Entamoeba Histolytica • Protozoan parasite • Fecal-oral transmission route • Causative agent of amebiasis • Colonic mucosal invasion and tissue destruction STUDY POPULATIONS • Birth cohort, with all infants recruited from small area of Mirpur in Dhaka, Bangladesh • All children received all EPI vaccinations and tOPV • Biweekly home visits with extensive characterization of symptomatic enteric and respiratory infections • Anthropometric measurements, including stunting and wasting status • Biomarkers of environmental enteropathy, including intestinal permeability 0 6 10 14 17 18 39 40 52 53 Week Week Week Week Week Week Week Week Week Week EPI Vaccines tOPV Anthropometry Serum Biomarkers )Enteric Co-Pathogens STUDY POPULATIONS cont. Both the NIH Birth Cohort (DBC) and PROVIDE are birth cohorts in Mirpur, Study EH No EH Total Dhaka, Bangladesh. Case definition: A symptomatic infection DBC (diarrheal episode) within the first year of 60 252 312 life, as detected by RT-PCR or ELISA Control definition: No diarrheal episodes PROVIDE 110 322 432 or monthly visits positive for E. histolytica within the first year of life Total 170 574 744 POTENTIAL COVARIATES DBC DBC DBC PROVIDE PROVIDE PROVIDE cases cases Covariate Mean Mean P Mean Mean P Phet Controls Controls HAZ12 months -2.02 -2.02 0.99 -1.45 -1.47 0.83 0.85 Number of days of exclusive 122.7 130.54 0.42 125.5 123.0 0.69 0.41 breastfeeding Sex 56.3% 56.7% 0.96 54.7% 52.7% 0.73 0.79 GENETIC ANALYSIS METHODS Test for association at 6.7 million sites genome-wide. Gen Wojcik GENOME-WIDE RESULTS FOR DIARRHEAL EPISODES POSITIVE FOR E. HISTOLYTICA 5 x 10-7 VALUE - LOG P - Gen Wojcik CHROMOSOME TOP ASSOCIATIONS NIH Birth Cohort 2.34 [1.46, 3.74] rs58000832 PROVIDE 2.53 [1.73, 3.69] -9 Pmeta=2.4x10 Meta-Analysis 2.45 [1.83, 3.29] NIH Birth Cohort 2.42 [1.51, 3.88] rs11599920 -8 PROVIDE 2.26 [1.55, 3.29] Pmeta=2.4x10 Meta-Analysis 2.32 [1.73, 3.11] GENETIC RECOMBINATION MAP CUL2 CREM CCNY ASSOCIATION RESULTS GENETIC RECOMBINATION MAP Gen Wojcik How do we disentangle which gene is responsible for the signal? We can look to databases of what is known about this genetic region. Specifically, are these SNPs known to OUR ASSOCIATION RESULTS influence the expression of a specific gene? VALUE - CREM seems more likely. LOG P cAMP responsive element modulator - This gene encodes a bZIP transcription factor that binds to the cAMP responsive element found in many viral and cellular promoters. KNOWN GENE EXPRESSION LOCI EH activates CRE-regulated gene expression in intestinal epithelial cells Silencing CREM decreases CRE reporter induction by EH CREM expression is induced in early infection in mice by EH Bill Petri and Chelsea Marie CREM-/- MICE ARE MORE SUSCEPTIBLE TO AMEBIC COLITIS CREM -/- more Apoptotic death of cecal susceptible to infection intestinal epithelial cells CREM -/- with increased apoptosis Mayuresh Abhyankar, Bill Petri, and Chelsea Marie KNOWN ASSOCIATIONS OF GENETIC LOCI Risk Allele P OR Risk Functional SNP Reference Disease (Previous (Previous (Previous Allele P (EH) OR (EH) Class GWAS) GWAS) GWAS) (EH) Downstream Liu JZ Crohn’s rs11010067 G 1x10-26 1.142 G 4.5x10-6 1.82 Gene Variant (2015) Disease Inflammatory Downstream Jostins L rs11010067 Bowel G 2x10-25 1.115 G 4.5x10-6 1.82 Gene Variant (2012) Disease Inflammatory Liu JZ rs34779708 Intron (CREM) Bowel 2x10-25 - G 1.2x10-6 1.88 (2015) Disease Anderson Ulcerative rs12261843 Intron (CCNY) G 7x10-7 1.07 G 8.2x10-5 1.69 CA (2011) Colitis Upstream Franke A Crohn’s rs12242110 G 1x10-9 1.15 G 8.4x10-5 1.70 (CREM) (2010) disease Barrett JC Crohn’s rs17582416 intergenic G 2x10-9 1.16 G 4.0x10-6 1.83 (2008) disease The same loci predispose both inflammatory bowel disease and amebiasis. Genome-wide association study (GWAS) shows association of CREM with symptomatic E. CONCLUSIONS histolytica infection. Risk alleles also predispose individuals for inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). Potential role for shared immune response between amebiasis and IBD. Amebiasis is one infectious disease, many other diarrheal outcomes in this population have resulted in other genome wide associations. How to we evaluate genetic associations? HBV ADMIXTURE FAM ILY SEQUENCING BASED HIV DENGUE LINKAGE MALARIA GWAS Tuberculosis AMEBIASIS POPULATION BASED HCV AFM Mystery paralysis in children in perplexing