NZR-RRR-Final-Review-Report.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
! ! ii! ! RESPECT!AND!RESPONSIBILITY!REVIEW!2!NEW!ZEALAND!RUGBY! ! ! ! ! Panel& ! Kathryn!Beck!(Chair)! Jackie!Barron! Lisa!Carrington! Kate!Daly! Liz!Dawson! David!HowMan! Sir!Michael!Jones! Keven!MealaMu! Dr!Deb!Robinson!! Robyn!Cockburn!(Researcher!and!Author)! Lucy!Atkinson!(Researcher!and!Author)! ! ! ! ! RESPECT!AND!RESPONSIBILITY!REVIEW!2!NEW!ZEALAND!RUGBY!! ! iii! ! ! ! & iv! ! RESPECT!AND!RESPONSIBILITY!REVIEW!2!NEW!ZEALAND!RUGBY! ! ! ! ! Table&of&Contents& 1! Introduction!.....................................................!1! 12! Prohibited!Substances!..................................!24! 2! The!Review!......................................................!2! 12.1! PerforMance!enhancing!drugs!!............!24! 2.1! The!Panel!.................................................!2! 12.2! Illicit!and!social/!party!drugs!.................!25! 2.2! Areas!of!focus!..........................................!2! 12.3!Sport!health!and!drugs!.........................!25! 2.3! Review!reports!........................................!2! 13! Being!Young!..................................................!28! 3! Approach!.........................................................!3! 13.1! DevelopMental!stages!for!young! 3.1! Evidence!and!international!research!......!3! people!...........................................................!28! 3.2! Stakeholder!engagement!.......................!3! 14! Gender!Equity!................................................!31! 3.3! Online!Mailbox!.........................................!4! 14.1! Perceiving!sport!as!a!Male!preserve!......!31! 3.4! Reporting!.................................................!5! 14.2!WoMen!in!rugby!....................................!32! 4! Review!of!2013!Review!of!Player!Welfare!.....!6! 14.3!Investing!in!girls!and!woMen!................!33! 5! Areas!of!Change!..............................................!8! 14.4!WoMen,!sport!and!the!Media!...............!34! 5.1! Personal!development!prograMMe!!......!8! 14.5!WoMen,!alcohol!and!rugby!...................!35! 5.2! Mental!health!and!wellbeing!..................!9! 15! Sexual!and!Gendered!Diversity!in!Sport!......!37! 5.3! Concussion!...............................................!9! 16! Ethnic!Identity!and!Sport!.............................!39! 5.4! Misconduct!..............................................!9! 17! Māori!.............................................................!40! 5.5! Relationships!prograMMe!......................!9! 17.1! A!snapshot!of!Māori!in!New!Zealand!...!40! 5.6! Sexual!orientation!.................................!10! 17.2!Tangata!Whenua!and!rugby!in!NZ!........!40! 5.7! Policies!and!protocols!...........................!10! 17.3!Haka!and!the!politics!of!identity!...........!41! 6! Other!reviews!................................................!11! 18! Pasifika!Peoples!............................................!43! 6.1! Bazley!report!..........................................!11! 18.1! A!snapshot!of!Pasifika!peoples!in!NZ!!!..!43! 6.2! Diversity!report!.......................................!11! 18.2!Pasifika!people!and!rugby!.....................!43! 7! 2017!Review!Focus!TheMes!...........................!13! 18.3!Pasifika!Men!in!global!sports!................!44! 8! Strategic!Alignment!.......................................!15! 18.4!Intervention!...........................................!45! 9! Positive!IMpact!of!Rugby!.............................!16! 19! Disability!and!Sport!.......................................!47! 9.1! Social!change!.........................................!16! 19.1! Disabled!people!in!NZ!...........................!47! 9.2! Rugby!values!..........................................!17! 19.2!Constraints!to!participation!..................!47! 9.3! Leadership!.............................................!18! 19.3!Disabled!people!and!sport!in!NZ!..........!48! 9.4! Impact!of!the!review!.............................!18! 20! Mental!Wellbeing!..........................................!50! 10! Evidence:!International!and!NZ!Research!...!19! 20.1!High!perforMance!athletes!and!Mental! 11! Alcohol!..........................................................!20! wellbeing!.......................................................!50! 11.1! Alcohol!consuMption!trends!................!20! 20.2!Concussion!.............................................!52! 11.2! Alcohol!consuMption!and!sports!.........!20! 21! Social!Mobility!in!Elite!Sport!.........................!54! 11.3! Alcohol!consuMption!and!violence!......!22! 22! Stardom!and!its!IMpact!................................!55! 11.4! Alcohol!sponsorship!..............................!23! 23! Sexual!Behaviour!..........................................!57! 23.1!Sexual!orientation!and!identity! developMent!.................................................!57! 23.2!The!Influence!of!pornography!..............!57! ! ! RESPECT!AND!RESPONSIBILITY!REVIEW!2!NEW!ZEALAND!RUGBY! ! ! v! ! ! ! ! vi! ! RESPECT!AND!RESPONSIBILITY!REVIEW!2!NEW!ZEALAND!RUGBY! ! ! ! ! 24! Violence:!in!Relationships!and!in!Sport!.......!59! 32! Goal!Five:!Proactive!EngageMent!...............!114! 24.1!Violence!in!sport!....................................!60! 32.1!Current!situation!..................................!114! 24.2!Prevalence!of!violence!in!sport!............!61! 32.2!Rationale!...............................................!114! 24.3!Sexual!harassMent!and!women!in! 32.3!Underpinning!principles!.......................!115! sport!..............................................................!62! 32.4!OutcoMes!.............................................!115! 25! Education!and!Post2Rugby!Careers!..............!64! 32.5!ImpleMentation!....................................!116! 26! A!SuMMary!of!Potential!Interventions!........!67! 32.6!Action!....................................................!116! 27! Change!–!Evidence!into!Action!....................!78! 33! Goal!Six:!Accountable!and!Independent!....!117! 28! Goal!One:!Inclusive!Leadership!....................!79! 33.1!Current!situation!..................................!117! 28.1!Current!situation!...................................!79! 33.2!Rationale!...............................................!119! 28.2!Rationale!................................................!82! 33.3!Underpinning!principles!......................!120! 28.3!Underpinning!principles!........................!84! 33.4!OutcoMes!.............................................!121! 28.4!OutcoMes!..............................................!84! 33.5!ImpleMentation!....................................!121! 28.5!ImpleMentation!.....................................!85! 33.6!Action!....................................................!122! 28.6!Action!.....................................................!86! 34! Taking!action!................................................!123! 29! Goal!Two:!Developing!People!......................!87! 34.1!Build!capability!.....................................!123! 29.1!Current!situation!...................................!87! 34.2!Quick!wins!.............................................!123! 29.2!Rationale!................................................!91! 34.3!Investing!in!change!............................!123! 29.3!Underpinning!principles!........................!92! 35! Appendices!..................................................!124! 29.4!OutcoMes!..............................................!93! 35.1!AcknowledgeMents!.............................!125! 29.5!ImpleMentation!.....................................!93! 35.2!Conferences!and!workshops!..............!126! 29.6!Action!.....................................................!94! 35.3!Key!research!questions!........................!127! 30! Goal!Three:!Nurturing!Wellbeing!.................!96! 35.4!Interview!questions!.............................!127! 30.1!Current!situation!...................................!96! 35.5!Online!Mailbox!.....................................!128! 30.2!Rationale!..............................................!103! 35.6!Individual!PerforMance!Plan!–!Six! 30.3!Underpinning!principles!......................!106! Pillars!............................................................!137! 30.4!OutcoMes!............................................!106! 35.7Player!Education!Progression!Model!..!138! 30.5!ImpleMentation!...................................!106! 35.8!Policies!and!protocols!.........................!140! 30.6!Action!...................................................!107! 35.9!Rugby!docuMents!................................!141! 31! Goal!Four:!Gender!Equity!...........................!109! 35.10!Other!docuMents!..............................!146! 31.1! Current!situation!.................................!109! 35.11!SaMple!Codes!of!Conduct!in!sport!....!148! 31.2!Rationale!................................................!111! 36! Bibliography!................................................!149! 31.3!Underpinning!principles!.......................!112! 36.1!Web!sites!.............................................!156! 31.4!OutcoMes!.............................................!112! 31.5!ImpleMentation!....................................!112! 31.6!Action!....................................................!113! RESPECT!AND!RESPONSIBILITY!REVIEW!2!NEW!ZEALAND!RUGBY! ! ! vii! ! ! ! viii! ! RESPECT!AND!RESPONSIBILITY!REVIEW!2!NEW!ZEALAND!RUGBY! ! 1! Introduction& NZ!Rugby’s!Mission!is!to!Inspire(and(Unify.!For! This!Review!Report!for!rugby!in!New!Zealand!is! more!than!a!century!it!has!been!a!critical! designed!to!guide!the!NZ!Rugby!Board!through!