Disruptions in Retail Through Digital Transformation Reimagining the Store of the Future November 2017

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Disruptions in Retail Through Digital Transformation Reimagining the Store of the Future November 2017 Disruptions in Retail through Digital Transformation Reimagining the Store of the Future November 2017 Disruptions in Retail through Digital Transformation Message from ICC Retail Summit Chair The word “Innovative Disruption”, to Transformation in Retail” which will quote from Mr. Clayton Christensen, the immensely benefit the businesses, Start- Author of “Innovator’s Dilemma”, refers ups to SMEs to large enterprises and the to an organization or entrepreneur various stakeholders in their journey of anticipating Customer’s needs, exciting growth ahead. passionately falling in love with Customer and creating a market where We wish to thank the Deloitte leadership none existed. The rapid pace of such team for the extensive work done disruptions mostly shake up established including the interactions with Retail traditional business models and make industry leadership teams in various the earlier known Rules of Success or Companies. Growth redundant in today’s “Phygital” ICC is also delighted to host its First connected world especially Retail. Retail Summit in Southern India and Technology is getting intertwined and I thank the ICC leadership and MC becoming seamless in both B2B as well members for the Initiative! as B2C experiences. Cycle times and Planning times are expected to shrink All the best, as complex processes get reconfigured through Bots and concepts like AI and IOTs. With this backdrop and booming outlook for growth, Retail Sector in India is clearly poised to become one of the largest beneficiaries of the disruptive era that has begun. ICC is proud to associate with Deloitte team who have taken the efforts to bring out the S KANNAN “knowledge paper” on “Disruptive Digital SUMMIT CHAIR 01 Disruptions in Retail through Digital Transformation KONNECTED to consumers Foreword by Deloitte The modern economy has been built performance on these parameters. This digital technologies help to understand on the foundations of the industrial approach is an incremental response to consumer needs (e.g.: cognitive), revolution with its roots in scientific the opportunities presented by digital provide greater assortment (e.g.: Visual concepts of deductive reasoning and and is primarily driven by a low risk merchandising), help shoppers decide the economic logic of maximizing self- propensity to allocate scarce resources to (e.g.: Virtual Trial Rooms), lower cost interest. Digital has helped build a what can be a fundamental disruptor to (e.g.: robotics & process automation), parallel narrative of inductive doctrines the business model of retailers. However, increase loyalties (e.g.: blockchain) and where focus is on looking at convergence there have been a few retailers who enhance customer service (e.g.: AI base between sectors, breaking down have truly awoken to the possibilities self-learning systems). However the risk functional silos within organizations presented by Digital. They have seen is to view digital only through this prism by customer-centric, opportunities digital as an opportunity to shape a long of technology investments. At the core to collaborate even with competition term sustainable business model which of digital for any retailer is a wider ability by developing a co-opetition mindset, is a departure from the paradigms of the to build a culture of collaboration, the co-ownership of investments through past. capability of using data to break through franchisees/alliances for scalable growth functional and organizational boundaries, Integral to this digital approach is the with low levels of asset intensity, building the art of using technology to unearth view of the retail eco-system as a network relationships with the new generation new possibilities for enhanced customer of suppliers and franchisees supporting of inter-connected customers who are value and in the process completely the central actor (retailer) in orchestrating involved in co-creation of products/ reimagine the store of the future… a business model with the long term services and a long term orientation of objective of maximizing customer continuous learning through feedback lifetime value and not just focused on a to better improve the customer delivery transactional approach. The fundamental model. tenets of this approach is a collaborative Retailers have had two options in the mindset where the retailer is the first way they have responded to the digital among equals in the wider network opportunity. A vast majority have seen who invests in building the capabilities digital as an enabler of better customer of the entire network to be agile and service or greater operational efficiency responsive to consumer needs. Attracting and have hence implemented many and retaining shoppers is the shared Anand Ramanathan digital technologies to improve their objective of the entire network and Partner, Deloitte 02 Disruptions in Retail through Digital Transformation Executive Summary Digital provides opportunities for disciplinary view of implementation peers and is more willing than ever retailers to acquire new customers, with a mix of analytical and creative before to share experiences and let engage better with existing customers, capabilities others profit from his/her interactions reduce the cost of operations, and with products/services. Consumers • Customer Centricity: Functional improve employee motivation along help co-create the value proposition boundaries within organizations with various other benefits that have a basis their willingness to provide are also being dismantled to align positive influence from a revenue and feedback which helps refine delivery structures to customer needs. The margin perspective. models on an ongoing real time basis. process has been further accelerated For the purpose of this report, digital through digital as big data is now • Continuous learning: Self learning has been defined as a technology making it possible to analyze shopper systems through AI and cognitive enabled combination of resources (can behavior in great detail and customize modelling has enabled feedback from include instruments, devices, bots, the delivery format to individual past experiences to optimize the tools, teams, protocols, processes, consumer requirements through shopping experience for consumers networks, methodologies) which enables personalization and hence impacting satisfaction and loyalty to be enhanced. the availability of content (can be data, • Co-opetition: This is a revolutionary information, expert/social reviews, mindset that combines competition This report focuses on the impact of reports, analysis, games) for the user with collaboration. Suppliers and Digital on three key elements of the (employee or customer) to make more retailers are no longer competing for retail business & operating model: productive (can impact cost, time or limited resources but are working 1. Strategy – includes elements of service level) decisions and satisfying together to profit from enhanced segmentation, positioning, operating choices. customer value being delivered. formats and business models There have been several instances of The ability to collect, process and share (location, assortment, size, pricing) collaboration between retailers even large quantities of data has led to some from an India context (e.g.: Future 2. Front end - Customer facing fundamental disruptions in the design Group and Flipkart) operations including store front, of business models. The key factors Merchandising & Promotion, impacting this change include: • Co-ownership: From a retail context Customer experience including digital has helped monitor and control • Convergence: The traditional Loyalty, Marketing and quality in franchising agreements boundaries between sectors Communications, Pricing & POS to achieve greater alignment of is collapsing. Innovation at the Solutions the business model to shopper boundaries of sectors such as requirements presenting an enhanced 3. Back end – Supply Chain, Logistics & payment systems (Financial Services opportunity for retailers to drive scale Warehousing, Digital Procurement & Telecom), e-commerce (Retail at a fast clip without compromising & Vendor management, Assortment & Telecom), Industry 4.0 (ICT and on the brand promise and sharing the mix & planning, People, Finance Manufacturing) etc. is fundamentally investment burden with their partners Automation disrupting businesses. Any disruptive approach in digital transformation for • Co-creation: The new digital shopper retail hence, needs to factor in a multi- is highly interconnected with his social 03 Disruptions in Retail through Digital Transformation Traditional Retailers… Store of the future... Illustrative Examples Where to Play? Segmentation Adopt mass, demography Use data Analytics for micro- Advanced AI based based segmentation segmentation analytics to create customer • Provide personalized microsegments offerings • Targeted communication Positioning Compete on price and quality • Offer additional services & Theme-based digitally- alone facilities enhanced experiential stores • Leisure provisions and Strategy shopping environment • Convenience Operating Predominantly Brick & Mortar Disruptive & innovative On-demand grocery delivery Formats led with a catchment-focus formats aided by digital- initiatives to expand reach (Omni channel approach) Business Models Adopt single dimensional Disruptive business models Subscription model, business models using digital enablers Hypermarket model Traditional Retailers… Store of the future... Illustrative
Recommended publications
  • Data in the Digital Age
    March 2019 Data in the Digital Age The growing interactions between data, algorithms and big data analytics, connected things and people are opening huge new opportunities. But they are also giving rise to issues around “data governance” at the national and international levels. These include questions around the management of data availability, accessibility, usability, integrity and security, as well as concerns about ownership, impacts on trade and competition, implications for personal privacy, and more. Policy makers across government are grappling with these issues. The use of digital technologies and data underpins digital transformation across all sectors of economies and societies, meaning that any policy decisions on data can have wide effects. Instilling trust in the use of data is a pre-condition for fully realising the gains of digital transformation. This in turn calls for policy makers to better understand and account for the heterogeneity of data, to take a strategic approach to its governance and ensure all policy objectives are considered, and to upgrade their own capabilities to harness data for better policy making. Key policy directions Recognise that there are different types of data, and measure the economic and social value of data and data flows. Many different types of data are collected and used, and their purpose and value can differ widely. Without recognising these different kinds of data, governments will not be able to effectively address issues such as personal data protection or competition. Better measurement of data and data flows and their role in production and value chains will also help support policy making. Develop national data strategies.
    [Show full text]
  • The Practice of Advertising to Jan, Always the Practice of Advertising
    The Practice of Advertising To Jan, always The Practice of Advertising Edited by Adrian R. Mackay Fifth edition AMSTERDAM ● BOSTON ● HEIDELBERG ● LONDON ● NEW YORK ● OXFORD PARIS ● SAN DIEGO ● SAN FRANCISCO ● SINGAPORE ● SYDNEY ● TOKYO Elsevier Butterworth-Heinemann Linacre House, Jordan Hill, Oxford OX2 8DP 30 Corporate Drive, Burlington, MA 01803 First published 1978 Reprinted 1981 Second edition 1983 Reprinted 1984, 1985, 1986 Third edition 1990 Reprinted 1990, 1993 Fourth edition 1995 Reprinted 1996, 2001 Fifth edition 2005 Copyright © 2005, Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced in any material form (including photocopying or storing in any medium by electronic means and whether or not transiently or incidentally to some other use of this publication) without the written permission of the copyright holder except in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 or under the terms of a licence issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London, England W1T 4LP. Applications for the copyright holder’s written permission to reproduce any part of this publication should be addressed to the publisher Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science & Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone: (ϩ144) 1865 843830, fax: (ϩ144) 1865 853333, e-mail: [email protected]. You may also complete your request on-line via the Elsevier homepage (http://www.elsevier.com), by selecting ‘Customer Support’ and then ‘Obtaining Permissions’
    [Show full text]
  • 2019 Retail Outlook
    RETAIL OUTLOOK 2019 TRENDS IMPACTING RETAIL M & A +1 212 508 1600 www.pjsolomon.com New York | Houston [email protected] JANUARY 2019 PJ SOLOMON GLOBAL RETAIL, CONSUMER, FOOD RETAIL & RESTAURANTS GROUPS MARC S. COOPER DAVID A. SHIFFMAN CATHY LEONHARDT [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] +1.212.508.1680 +1.212.508.1642 +1.212.508.1660 JEFFREY DERMAN SCOTT MOSES MICHAEL GOTTSCHALK GREG GRAMBLING [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] +1.212.508.1625 +1.212.508.1675 +1.212.508.1649 +1.212.508.1674 The wave of disruption to the retail industry continues, but retailers and stakeholders now have a clearer vision of where the industry is headed. Against the backdrop of the strongest consumer market in over a decade, supported by near 50 year-low unemployment, robust consumer spending and strong 18 year-high consumer confidence, the 2018 holiday season brought healthy results for a select number of retailers, particularly those executing a strategy designed for the new world order of retailing. It also amplified the ongoing narrative of the industry’s big getting stronger – one of the themes highlighted in this paper. Despite this reasonably positive setting, we have entered 2019 amidst market volatility, a nascent trade war with China and the prospects of a slowdown in global growth, particularly in China and Europe. Any combination of such factors could once again cloud the retail sector picture and challenge retailers less prepared for change. With an eye towards these developing factors, we evaluate the trends shaping retail today and spotlight the critical themes we believe will impact retail deal-making in 2019.
    [Show full text]
  • A Resource Guide for Transitioning Your Class Online
    A Resource Guide for Transitioning Your Class Online SPECIAL REPORT MAGNA PUBLICATIONS CONTENTS Education Initiatives: A Mashup of Emergency A Checklist for Moving Your Resources and Other Great Course Online 03 Tips 13 How Teaching Online Can Eight Steps for a Smoother Improve Your Face-to-Face Transition to Online Teaching 05 15 Classes Five Ways to Foster Seven Ways to Facilitate Creativity in Your Online Effective Online Discussions 07 Classroom 19 Online Discussions: Would Simple Animation for Your Changing the Environment Courses 09 23 Help? What Do Students Really Want from Online Instruc- 11 tors? Education Initiatives: A Mashup of Emergency Resources and Other Great Tips Faculty Focus n response to COVID-19, we’ve seen in- links to educational resources from all over the structors and universities from around the world. Iworld come together to compile numer- ous resources and lists. Although we’ve only 4. Mandy Berry: A Facebook Post on skimmed the surface, we believe the following Remote Teaching links provide insight on different perspectives A public Facebook post from Amanda Berry, that institutions and staff are currently go- an assistant professor of literature at American ing through. From transitioning to an online University. course to fostering a productive conversation with your students, these resources shed light 5. Resources for Disruptions on education initiatives we hope you find use- A list of resources compiled by Ollie Dreon ful during this time of uncertainty. on his blog pertaining to transitioning to online teaching and coping with education initiatives 1. Remote Teaching Strategies— during this time of disruption.
    [Show full text]
  • Comércio Eletrônico
    Comércio Eletrônico Aula 1 - Overview of Electronic Commerce Learning Objectives 1. Define electronic commerce (EC) and describe its various categories. 2. Describe and discuss the content and framework of EC. 3. Describe the major types of EC transactions. 4. Describe the drivers of EC. 5. Discuss the benefits of EC to individuals, organizations, and society. 6. Discuss social computing. 7. Describe social commerce and social software. 8. Understand the elements of the digital world. 9. Describe some EC business models. 10. List and describe the major limitations of EC. Case: Starbucks Electronic Commerce (EC) EC refers to using the Internet and other networks (e.g., intranets) to purchase, sell, transport, or trade data, goods, or services. e-Business • Narrow definition of EC: buying and selling transactions between business partners. • e-Business refers to a broader definition of EC: – buying and selling of goods and services – Servicing customers – collaborating with business partners, – delivering e-learning, – conducting electronic transactions within organizations. – Among others e-Business Note: some view e-business only as comprising those activities that do not involve buying or selling over the Internet, i.e., a complement of the narrowly defined EC. Major EC Concepts: Non-EC vs. Pure EC vs. Partial EC • EC three major activities: – ordering and payments, – order fulfilment, and – delivery to customers. • pure EC: all activities are digital, • non-EC: none are digital, • otherwise, we have partial EC. Major EC Concepts: Pure
    [Show full text]
  • Electronic Commerce in the Gaming Industry. Legal Chal- Lenges And
    Pécs Journal of International and European Law - 2019/I-II. Electronic Commerce in the Gaming Industry. Legal Chal- lenges and European Perspective on Contracts through Elec- tronic Means in Video Games and Decentralized Applications Olena Demchenko PhD student, University of Pécs, Faculty of Law The present paper explains the need in the application of electronic commerce regulations to the so-called in-game purchasing activity in video games, particularly, purchase of intangible items, where such game is commoditized, focusing on the legislation of the European Union. It examines in detail the various applications of European regulations to the issues connected to the gaming industry in the European Union - gambling regulations, geo-blocking, data protection, smart con- tracts validity and enforcement, virtual currencies regulation in the scope of contractual law, and shows a possible way to adapt the national legislation of the Member States and European legis- lation in order to secure electronic commerce in the gaming industry. The present paper analyses gaps in existing legal procedures, stresses the necessity of new legal models in order to regulate the purchase of intangible items in video games and decentralized applications and underlines the importance of amendments to current European legislation with particular focus on new devel- opments of Create, Retrieve, Append, Burn technology and commoditized video games in order to protect consumer rights and the free movement of digital goods and to accomplish the Digital Single Market Strategy of the European Union. Keywords: video games, Blockchain, smart contract, electronic commerce, decentralized applica- tions 1. Introduction Since 1961, when MIT student Steven Russel created the first-ever video game “Spacewar”, which inspired the creation of such popular video games as “Asteroids” and “Pong”,1 technology went much further.
    [Show full text]
  • The Marketing & Advertising Technology Report
    The Marketing & Advertising Technology Report: New & future trends to leverage 5 Foreword/About This Study This report is intended to provide recipients with a deeper understand of the fast changing landscape that is the convergence of technology and marketing/advertising. This document offers not current digital intelligence but also cultural intelligence around consumer behavior and mindset, now and trending in the future. Lauren deLisa Coleman, digi-cultural trend analyst, along with Lnk Agency, specialists in deciphering and forecasting trends within the convergence of culture & emerging technology and studying the impact of such on business and governance, have tracked, analyzed and interviewed key researchers, C-Suite executives, data science trends, and ethnographic settings to create a unique offering that provides opportunity identification, analysis and outook for the coming year period. It is no longer sustainable to solely do studies over a year(s) long period when the industry is moving at such a rapid pace, therefore, our reports are intended for real-time, of-the-moment snapshots to more completely support today’s executive demands. Further, presentation of hard statistics without true cultural intelligence applications and observations around them are not holistic enough for the skill that is needed today to truly engage with today’s popular culture, tech-savvy individuals. Thus, we are presenting a newer style in professional report documentation. This study reflects some of the key findings. 2 Executive summary: Digital Advertising/Marketing and consumer engagement in the United States is a massive, growing market undergoing a significant technology-driven evolution. Technology is reshaping the way consumers engage with advertising and marketing messages and, in turn, how media, advertising companies, and marketing profes- sionals create and delivery strategy.
    [Show full text]
  • Six-Gear Roadmap Towards the Smart Factory
    applied sciences Review Six-Gear Roadmap towards the Smart Factory Amr T. Sufian 1,*, Badr M. Abdullah 1 , Muhammad Ateeq 1 , Roderick Wah 2 and David Clements 2 1 Faculty of Engineering and Technology, Liverpool John Moores University, Liverpool L3 3AF, UK; [email protected] (B.M.A.); [email protected] (M.A.) 2 Beverston Engineering Ltd., Prescot L34 9AB, UK; [email protected] (R.W.); [email protected] (D.C.) * Correspondence: a.t.sufi[email protected] Featured Application: This work is beneficial to bridge the gap between advanced technologies and their applications in the manufacturing industry, especially for SMEs. Abstract: The fourth industrial revolution is the transformation of industrial manufacturing into smart manufacturing. The advancement of digital technologies that make the trend Industry 4.0 are considered as the transforming force that will enable this transformation. However, Industry 4.0 digital technologies need to be connected, integrated and used effectively to create value and to provide insightful information for data driven manufacturing. Smart manufacturing is a journey and requires a roadmap to guide manufacturing organizations for its adoption. The objective of this paper is to review different methodologies and strategies for smart manufacturing implementation to propose a simple and a holistic roadmap that will support the transition into smart factories and achieve resilience, flexibility and sustainability. A comprehensive review of academic and industrial literature was preformed based on multiple stage approach and chosen criteria to establish existing knowledge in the field and to evaluate latest trends and ideas of Industry 4.0 and smart manufacturing technologies, techniques and applications in the manufacturing industry.
    [Show full text]
  • Defining the Digital Services Landscape for the Middle East
    Defining the Digital Services landscape for the Middle East Defining the Digital Services landscape for the Middle East 1 2 Contents Defining the Digital Services landscape for the Middle East 4 The Digital Services landscape 6 Consumer needs landscape Digital Services landscape Digital ecosystem Digital capital Digital Services Maturity Cycle: Middle East 24 Investing in Digital Services in the Middle East 26 Defining the Digital Services landscape for the Middle East 3 Defining the Digital Services landscape for the Middle East The Middle East is one of the fastest growing emerging markets in the world. As the region becomes more digitally connected, demand for Digital Services and technologies is also becoming more prominent. With the digital economy still in its infancy, it is unclear which global advances in Digital Services and technologies will be adopted by the Middle East and which require local development. In this context, identifying how, where and with whom to work with in this market can be very challenging. In our effort to broaden the discussion, we have prepared this report to define the Digital Services landscape for the Middle East, to help the region’s digital community in understanding and navigating through this complex and ever-changing space. Eng. Ayman Al Bannaw Today, we are witnessing an unprecedented change in the technology, media, and Chairman & CEO telecommunications industries. These changes, driven mainly by consumers, are taking Noortel place at a pace that is causing confusion, disruption and forcing convergence. This has created massive opportunities for Digital Services in the region, which has in turn led to certain industry players entering the space in an incoherent manner, for fear of losing their market share or missing the opportunities at hand.
    [Show full text]
  • Online Shopping Customer Experience Study Commissioned by UPS May 2012
    Online Shopping Customer Experience Study Commissioned by UPS May 2012 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION, PLEASE CONTACT: Susan Kleinman comScore, Inc. 212-497-1783 [email protected] © 2012 comScore, Inc. Contents Introducing the Online Shopping Customer Experience Study..................................................................... 3 Key Findings .............................................................................................................................................. 3 Online Shopping Industry Snapshot ............................................................................................................. 4 Online Shopping Experience and Satisfaction .............................................................................................. 5 Discounts and Specials ............................................................................................................................. 7 Comparison Shopping ............................................................................................................................... 8 Retailer Recommendation ......................................................................................................................... 9 Check-Out Process ....................................................................................................................................... 9 Delivery Timing ........................................................................................................................................ 11 Shipping and Delivery
    [Show full text]
  • Brand Touchpoints' Orchestration: Understanding the Impact of Digital
    Brand touchpoints’ orchestration: understanding the impact of digital, traditional and mobile touchpoints on customer journey Grégoire Bothorel, Paris Sorbonne University, Numberly (1000 mercis Group) Régine Vanheems, IAE Lyon-Lyon 3 University Anne Guerin, Numberly (1000 mercis Group) Brands interact with their customers through multiple channels and a myriad of touchpoints. Identifying the right combination of touchpoints to better guide customers’ path to purchase is critical for many brands and retailers. This paper reports two field experiments in which a French click-and-mortar retailer’s email-only advertising strategy was substituted by i) a print-and-email strategy and ii) an SMS-and-email strategy. On large sample sizes of 128,000 and 37,000 individuals, both experiments improved conversion but impacted channel-specific distribution of customers. Print mainly drove offline incremental sales, while SMS equally drove offline and online incremental sales. The nature of firm-initiated touchpoints (email, SMS and print) has a significant influence on the customer purchase channel. 1 Brands aim at interacting with their customers through many touchpoints to engage them in profitable paths to purchase. Understanding customers’ paths to purchase thanks to the activation of specific “touchpoints” (Verhoef, Kannan, and Inman, 2015) has become a critical issue in omni-channel research (Lemon and Verhoef, 2016). As a matter of fact, firms need to be able to evaluate and to understand how the activation of different touchpoints’ may impact customers’ journey. Touchpoints which customers may be exposed to whilst shopping can be of great heterogeneity (Lemon and Verhoef, 2016) namely brand-owned, partner-owned, customer- owned and social touchpoints.
    [Show full text]
  • Mobile Developer's Guide to the Galaxy
    Don’t Panic MOBILE DEVELOPER’S GUIDE TO THE GALAXY U PD A TE D & EX TE ND 12th ED EDITION published by: Services and Tools for All Mobile Platforms Enough Software GmbH + Co. KG Sögestrasse 70 28195 Bremen Germany www.enough.de Please send your feedback, questions or sponsorship requests to: [email protected] Follow us on Twitter: @enoughsoftware 12th Edition February 2013 This Developer Guide is licensed under the Creative Commons Some Rights Reserved License. Editors: Marco Tabor (Enough Software) Julian Harty Izabella Balce Art Direction and Design by Andrej Balaz (Enough Software) Mobile Developer’s Guide Contents I Prologue 1 The Galaxy of Mobile: An Introduction 1 Topology: Form Factors and Usage Patterns 2 Star Formation: Creating a Mobile Service 6 The Universe of Mobile Operating Systems 12 About Time and Space 12 Lost in Space 14 Conceptional Design For Mobile 14 Capturing The Idea 16 Designing User Experience 22 Android 22 The Ecosystem 24 Prerequisites 25 Implementation 28 Testing 30 Building 30 Signing 31 Distribution 32 Monetization 34 BlackBerry Java Apps 34 The Ecosystem 35 Prerequisites 36 Implementation 38 Testing 39 Signing 39 Distribution 40 Learn More 42 BlackBerry 10 42 The Ecosystem 43 Development 51 Testing 51 Signing 52 Distribution 54 iOS 54 The Ecosystem 55 Technology Overview 57 Testing & Debugging 59 Learn More 62 Java ME (J2ME) 62 The Ecosystem 63 Prerequisites 64 Implementation 67 Testing 68 Porting 70 Signing 71 Distribution 72 Learn More 4 75 Windows Phone 75 The Ecosystem 76 Implementation 82 Testing
    [Show full text]