DOCSLIB.ORG

6 .Payment Cards and Interchange Non-Confidential

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
6 .Payment Cards and Interchange Non-Confidential Chapter 6 Payment Cards and Interchange Contents 6.1 Introduction and synopsis .....................................................................................228 6.1.1 Evolution of means of payment and arrangements between banks ..............228 6.1.2 What is interchange? ....................................................................................229 6.1.3 Three-party (“closed”) and four-party (“open”) card schemes........................230 6.1.4 Necessity of interchange in principle.............................................................232 6.1.5 Danger of abuse and how best to prevent it..................................................234 6.1.6 A transparent and objective interchange methodology..................................236 6.1.7 Interchange and other payment streams.......................................................237 6.1.8 Card scheme rules .......................................................................................237 6.2 Payment cards in South Africa ..............................................................................237 6.2.1 Types of cards and card transactions ...........................................................237 6.2.2 Global development of payment cards and electronic payments...................238 6.2.3 Card issuing in South Africa..........................................................................241 6.2.4 Continued predominance of cash .................................................................245 6.2.5 Global strength of Visa and MasterCard .......................................................256 6.2.6 Network advantages of four-party schemes..................................................257 6.3 Merchant acquiring and merchant service charges.............................................263 6.3.1 Merchant acquiring in the three-party and four-party schemes .....................263 6.3.2 Scheme rules and practices in the allocation and management of risk .........268 6.3.3 Flow of payments in three-party and four-party schemes..............................270 6.3.4 Merchants accepting cards ...........................................................................273 6.3.5 Interchange enters into consumer prices ......................................................277 6.3.6 Competition among acquirers in the four-party schemes ..............................278 6.3.7 Eligibility for participation as acquirers in the four-party schemes .................280 6.3.8 Restrictions on cashback at the point of sale ................................................291 6.4 The setting of payment card interchange .............................................................294 6.4.1 History and level of card interchange in SA ..................................................294 6.4.2 The “Edgar Dunn” process and the decision of the banks in 2003 ................295 6.4.3 The Visa exemption ......................................................................................298 6.4.4 The MasterCard advisory opinion .................................................................299 Banking Enquiry Report to the Competition Commissioner Contains confidential information Chapter 6 Payment Cards and Interchange 226 6.4.5 The current MasterCard / “Edgar Dunn” process ..........................................301 6.5 Revenues and profitability in issuing and acquiring............................................301 6.5.1 Banks’ revenue from card issuing and merchant acquiring ...........................301 6.5.2 Growth rates in costs, revenues and profits ..................................................305 6.5.3 Profits in card issuing without interchange ....................................................306 6.6 The necessity of interchange in principle.............................................................307 6.6.1 Competition policy and joint ventures ...........................................................307 6.6.2 Origins of interchange in card payment schemes .........................................308 6.6.3 Interchange is not a price for service ............................................................310 6.6.4 The nature of the joint venture in “open” (four-party) schemes......................311 6.6.5 Rules to enable co-operation ........................................................................312 6.6.6 Revenue allocation in a two-sided market.....................................................314 6.6.7 Default, multilateral and bilateral setting of interchange ................................321 6.6.8 The absence of interchange in some countries.............................................324 6.6.9 The profitability of issuing without interchange..............................................329 6.6.10 Conclusion on the necessity of interchange ..............................................330 6.7 The potential for abuse of interchange and the need for regulation...................331 6.7.1 The non-neutrality of interchange .................................................................331 6.7.2 Do market forces limit card interchange so it cannot be abused? .................333 6.7.3 The nature of the potential abuse .................................................................337 6.7.4 Unsatisfactory methodology..........................................................................342 6.7.5 Illegitimate benefits would extend to three-party schemes ............................350 6.7.6 The need for regulation.................................................................................350 6.8 Interchange in other payment streams .................................................................351 6.8.1 Introduction...................................................................................................351 6.8.2 Electronic funds transfer (EFT) .....................................................................352 6.8.3 Early debit orders (EDO) ..............................................................................359 6.9 Appropriate regulation of interchange..................................................................371 6.9.1 International experience ...............................................................................371 6.9.2 An independent, objective and transparent process......................................375 6.9.3 Participation in the process...........................................................................378 6.9.4 The methodology..........................................................................................379 6.9.5 Avoiding negative consequences of regulation .............................................385 6.10 Other rules of the schemes...............................................................................388 6.10.1 The “honour all cards” rule ........................................................................388 6.10.2 The “honour all products” rule ...................................................................390 6.10.3 The rule against surcharging.....................................................................392 Banking Enquiry Report to the Competition Commissioner Contains confidential information Chapter 6 Payment Cards and Interchange 227 Tables Table 1 Percentage share of debit and credit card market .................................................243 Table 2 Payment cards issued by the big four banks in SA................................................244 Table 3 Number of merchants acquired by the big four banks in South Africa ...................273 Table 4 Merchant service charges (MSC) ..........................................................................274 Table 5 Merchant classification..........................................................................................274 Table 6 Card interchange levels in South Africa.................................................................296 Table 7 Turnover, revenue, costs and profits from issuing and acquiring in 2006 ..............302 Table 8 Average revenue from interchange per transaction...............................................303 Table 9 Gross and net revenue from interchange fees: the big four banks.........................303 Table 10 Revenue from the MSC: the big four banks together...........................................304 Table 11 Profit growth rate in the acquiring market ............................................................305 Table 12 Profit growth rate in the issuing market ...............................................................306 Table 13 Profit to cost ratios ..............................................................................................306 Table 14 Issuing profits without interchange ......................................................................307 Table 15 EFT debit and EFT credit interchange or homing fees ........................................353 Table 16 Volume growth of EFT transactions ....................................................................357 Table 17 Participants in the EDO streams .........................................................................362 Table 18 AEDO interchange fees paid by Absa .................................................................363 Table 19 Interchange fees and user fees for successful AEDO and NAEDO transactions .366 Table 20 Split of user fees for successful AEDO transactions............................................367 Table 21 Fee and revenue split for AEDO and NAEDO – R500 transaction.......................370
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Savantor Marketeye: 17 October – 16 November 2020 2011
    ype text]pe text] [Type text] [Type text] Savantor MarketEye: 17 October – 16 November 2020 2011 Savantor Limited 68 Lombard St London EC3V 9LJ This is a high-level industry news and business intelligence update Tel: +44 20 7868 1734 bulletin. For further information on any of the items contained within the email: [email protected] bulletin or to discuss the potential impact of these items on your www.savantor.com business, please contact Savantor on [email protected]. Items in this issue: Savantor’s View ....................................................... 1 Vocalink wins Canadian clearing and settlement system Contactless and debit cards ............................................. 1 contract ............................................................................. 3 Norway – cash and digital currency ................................. 3 Products and Initiatives .......................................... 2 Visa Plaid acquisition opposed by Department of Standard Chartered to run customer-facing applications Justice .............................................................................. 3 in the cloud ....................................................................... 2 Shanghai Stock Exchange suspends Ant Group IPO ...... 3 Mastercard helps banks combat cyber risks using AI ....... 2 Visa to acquire YellowPepper for Latin America push ..... 4 Danske Bank to replace plastic payments cards .............. 2 UK retailers attack Visa and Mastercard over card fees .. 4 PayPal to support cryptocurrencies across consumer and
    [Show full text]
  • Glossary of Terms
    Glossary of Terms Term Definition ABCI Association of Bank Card Issuers and Merchant Acquirers ABSA Absa Bank Limited AEDO Authenticated Early Debit Order ACB Automated Clearing Bureau for the clearing of cheques and electronic payments ACSS Automated Clearing and Settlement System. ACSS is owned and operated by the Canadian Payments Association. (http://www.bank-banque-canada.ca/en/financial/financial_pay.html). Acquiring The service of accepting, processing, clearing and settling of payment transactions on the merchant’s or beneficiary’s side. Ad valorem fee A fee that varies according to the value of the transaction. ALLPS See Intecon AMEX American Express APACS Association for Payment Clearing Services. APACS is the UK trade association for payments and for those institutions that deliver payment services to customers. http://www.apacs.org.uk/media_centre/press/05_05_24.html APCA Australian Payments and Clearing Association APRA Australian Prudential Regulation Authority ASO Association of System Operators ATC Average Total Cost ATM Automated teller machine BACS (Originally an acronym for Bankers Automated Clearing Services). This is one of the three constituents of APACS and is responsible for bulk clearing of electronic payments between bank accounts by using direct debits and credits, as well as standing orders. http://www.competition- commission.org.uk/rep_pub/reports/2002/fulltext/462glossary.pdf Bankserv Bankserv is South Africa’s major Automated Payment Clearing House System Operator. http://www.bankserv.co.za/ BASA Banking Association of South Africa BESA Bond Exchange of South Africa BIN Bank Identification Number BIS Bank of International Settlements BSD Bank Supervision Department, a division of the SARB CAGR Compound Average Growth Rate Carriage fee In the case of ATM transactions, this represents the compensation paid from the issuing to the acquiring participant for the use of their infrastructure.
    [Show full text]
  • An Empirical Analysis of New Zealand Bank Customers' Satisfaction
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Lincoln University Research Archive Lincoln University Digital Thesis Copyright Statement The digital copy of this thesis is protected by the Copyright Act 1994 (New Zealand). This thesis may be consulted by you, provided you comply with the provisions of the Act and the following conditions of use: you will use the copy only for the purposes of research or private study you will recognise the author's right to be identified as the author of the thesis and due acknowledgement will be made to the author where appropriate you will obtain the author's permission before publishing any material from the thesis. AN EMPIRICAL ANALYSIS OF NEW ZEALAND BANK CUSTOMERS’ SATISFACTION _______________________________________________________ A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Master of Commerce and Management at Lincoln University by Jing Wei _______________________________________________________ Lincoln University 2010 Abstract of a thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of M.C.M AN EMPIRICAL ANALYSIS OF NEW ZEALAND BANK CUSTOMERS’ SATISFACTION By Jing Wei It is important that banks deliver quality services which in turn results in customer satisfaction in today’s competitive banking environment. Within the New Zealand financial service market, competition is deemed to be strong given that there have been new entrants into the market as well as mergers and acquisition and exits over the last ten years (Chan, Schumacher, and Tripe, 2007). In order to retain the customers, customer satisfaction becomes a crux issue to bank management.
    [Show full text]
  • Report on the Role of Cash in Society
    DANISH PAYMENTS COUNCIL REPORT ON THE ROLE OF CASH IN SOCIETY August 2016 Report on the Role of Cash in Society Text may be copied from this publication provided that the Danish Payments Council is specifically stated as the source. Changes to or misrepresentation of the contents are not permitted. The Report can be downloaded from Danmarks Nationalbank's website, www.nationalbanken.dk, under Banking and payments, Danish Payments Council. The Report is based on information available up to 23 June 2016. Inquiries about the Report should be directed to: Danmarks Nationalbank Communications Havnegade 5 DK-1093 Copenhagen K Telephone +45 33 63 70 00 (direct) or +45 33 63 63 63 Inquiries: Monday-Friday 9:00 am-4:00 pm Email: [email protected] www.nationalbanken.dk 2 CONTENTS 1 Summary and deliberations on the cash rule ........................................................................5 2 The role of cash today ..........................................................................................................11 2.1 Introduction ....................................................................................................................11 2.2 What is cash? ................................................................................................................11 2.3 Use of cash as a means of payment .............................................................................. 12 2.4 Digitisation and the use of cash ......................................................................................15
    [Show full text]
  • Interchange Fee Na Rynku Polskim
    National Bank of Poland Payment Systems Department Analysis of the functioning of the interchange fee in cashless transactions on the Polish market Warsaw, January 2012 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 4 Chapter 1. Description of the payment card market ......................................................... 6 1.1. Types of payment cards .......................................................................................... 6 1.2. Payment card systems ............................................................................................ 7 1.2.1. Types of systems and business models ............................................................... 7 1.2.2. Examples of schemes .........................................................................................10 1.3. Importance of the payment card market for its participants and the development of cashless transactions .........................................................................................11 Chapter 2. The development of the payment card market in Poland compared to other countries ............................................................................................17 2.1. Selected indicators of the development of the Polish payment card market ...........17 2.2. Selected indicators of the development of the payment card market - Poland against other EU countries .....................................................................................22
    [Show full text]
  • How Will Traditional Credit-Card Networks Fare in an Era of Alipay, Google Tez, PSD2 and W3C Payments?
    How will traditional credit-card networks fare in an era of Alipay, Google Tez, PSD2 and W3C payments? Eric Grover April 20, 2018 988 Bella Rosa Drive Minden, NV 89423 * Views expressed are strictly the author’s. USA +1 775-392-0559 +1 775-552-9802 (fax) [email protected] Discussion topics • Retail-payment systems and credit cards state of play • Growth drivers • Tectonic shifts and attendant risks and opportunities • US • Europe • China • India • Closing thoughts Retail-payment systems • General-purpose retail-payment networks were the greatest payments and retail-banking innovation in the 20th century. • >300 retail-payment schemes worldwide • Global traditional payment networks • Mastercard • Visa • Tier-two global networks • American Express, • China UnionPay • Discover/Diners Club • JCB Retail-payment systems • Alternative networks building claims to critical mass • Alipay • Rolling up payments assets in Asia • Partnering with acquirers to build global acceptance • M-Pesa • PayPal • Trading margin for volume, modus vivendi with Mastercard, Visa and large credit-card issuers • Opening up, partnering with African MNOs • Paytm • WeChat Pay • Partnering with acquirers to build overseas acceptance • National systems – Axept, Pago Bancomat, BCC, Cartes Bancaires, Dankort, Elo, iDeal, Interac, Mir, Rupay, Star, Troy, Euro6000, Redsys, Sistema 4b, et al The global payments land grab • There have been campaigns and retreats by credit-card issuers building multinational businesses, e.g. Citi, Banco Santander, Discover, GE, HSBC, and Capital One. • Discover’s attempts overseas thus far have been unsuccessful • UK • Diners Club • Network reciprocity • Under Jeff Immelt GE was the worst-performer on the Dow –a) and Synchrony unwound its global franchise • Amex remains US-centric • Merchant acquiring and processing imperative to expand internationally.
    [Show full text]
  • ID Proxy Initiatives Across the Globe an Analysis
    ID proxy initiatives across the globe An analysis November 2019 Authors Barry Cooper Laura Muñoz Perez Antonia Esser Michaella Allen Nolwazi Hlophe Matthew Ferreira Cenfri Tel. +27 21 913 9510 Email: [email protected] The Vineyards Office Estate Farm 1, Block A 99 Jip de Jager Drive Bellville, 7530 South Africa PO Box 5966 Tygervalley, 7535 South Africa www.cenfri.org i Foreword by BankservAfrica A transformed payments ecosystem is imminent in South Africa. Following the impetus created by the South African Reserve Bank’s Vision 2025, BankservAfrica and the Payments Association of South Africa, together with the South African payments industry, have been clarifying and defining a plausible path for transformation in South Africa. Beginning in 2017 with the joint BSA-PASA research programme that produced our 3-part study of modernization efforts world-wide (brought together under the heading “Modernising Payments Systems” and available on our web-site), BankservAfrica has taken a key role in providing research to the industry that it topical, pertinent, and applicable. In the last year, the South African payments industry has increasingly shifted its focus towards instant payments for the digitally connected economy, while addressing the persisting issue of financial inclusion in South Africa. Through extensive work done in the industry, co-ordinated and facilitated by the Payments Association, proxy and addressing services have been identified as a critical lever for adoption of instant or near-instant payments services. Proxy services allow payments to be successfully made using only an agreed identifier, such as mobile number, or a national identity number. By doing so, they remove much of the consumer friction currently associated with electronic payments.
    [Show full text]
  • Appendices 2 - 7
    UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ x : In re : Chapter 11 Case No. : LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC., : 08‐13555 (JMP) et al., : : (Jointly Administered) Debtors. : ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ x REPORT OF ANTON R. VALUKAS, EXAMINER Jenner & Block LLP 353 N. Clark Street Chicago, IL 60654‐3456 312‐222‐9350 919 Third Avenue 37th Floor New York, NY 10022‐3908 212‐891‐1600 March 11, 2010 Counsel to the Examiner VOLUME 7 OF 9 Appendices 2 - 7 EXAMINER’S REPORT TABLE OF APPENDICES VOLUME 6 Tab 1 Legal Issues VOLUME 7 Tab 2 Glossary, Acronyms & Abbreviations Tab 3 Key Individuals Tab 4 Witness Interview List Tab 5 Document Collection & Review Tab 6 Lehman Systems Tab 7 Bibliography VOLUME 8 Tab 8 Risk Management Organization and Controls Tab 9 Risk Appetite and VaR Usage Versus Limits Chart Tab 10 Calculation of Certain Increases in Risk Appetite Limits Tab 11 Compensation Tab 12 Valuation - Archstone Tab 13 Survival Strategies Supplement Tab 14 Valuation - CDO Tab 15 Narrative of September 4 Through 15, 2008 Tab 16 Valuation - Residential Whole Loans i Tab 17 Repo 105 Tab 18 Summary of Lehman Collateral at JPMorgan Tab 19 Lehman’s Dealings with Bank of America Knowledge of Senior Lehman Executives Regarding The Tab 20 Inclusion of Clearing-Bank Collateral in the Liquidity Pool Tab 21 LBHI Solvency Analysis Tab 22 Preferences Against LBHI and Other Lehman Entities VOLUME 9 Analysis of APB, Journal Entry, Cash Disbursement, and Tab
    [Show full text]
  • RDC Summit 2011 – Attendee List
    RDC Summit 2011 – Attendee List Company Title City State 1st Constitution Bank Vice President/Head of Deposit Operations Cranbury NJ 1st Constitution Bank Vice President Cranbury NJ 1st Enterprise Bank Vice President/Electronic Banking Manager Los Angeles CA 3i Infotech First Vice President Blue Bell PA 3i Infotech Vice President of Sales Blue Bell PA 3i Infotech Senior Project Manager Blue Bell PA 3i Infotech Business Development Specialist Blue Bell PA AlixPartners, LLP Managing Director Boston MA All My Papers Product Support Specialist Gualala CA All My Papers Marketing & Sales Gualala CA Ally Bank Charlotte NC Andrews Federal Credit Union Payment Systems Manager Waldorf MD Bank Midwest Electronic Banking Sales Manager Fairmont MN Bank of America Senior Vice President Jacksonville FL Bank of America VP, Senior Product Manager East Bridgewater MA Bank of America Vice President- SB eProduct Manager Charlotte NC Bank of the West Lockbox Product Manager, VP Monterey Park CA BankFIRST VP, Business Solutions Manager Orlando FL BankNews Media Executive Editor Shawnee Mission KS BankServ VP, Sales, West Las Vegas NV BankServ Sales Las Vegas NV Bay Cities Bank VP, Cash Management Tampa FL Benchmark Technology Group Product Manager Alpharetta GA Benchmark Technology Group Customer Support Director Alpharetta GA BLM Technologies VP, Sales & Marketing Plymouth MN BLM Technologies Senior Sales Representative Chesterfield MO Bluepoint Solutions Executive Vice President Vista CA Page 1 RDC Summit 2011 – Attendee List Bluepoint Solutions Communications
    [Show full text]
  • Report on Non-Banks in the Payments Market
    DANISH PAYMENTS COUNCIL REPORT ON NON-BANKS IN THE PAYMENTS MARKET September 2016 Report on non-banks in the payments market Text may be copied from this report provided that the Danish Payments Council is specifically stated as the source. Changes to or misrepresentation of the contents are not permitted. The report can be downloaded from Danmarks Nationalbank's website, www.nationalbanken.dk, under Banking and payments, Danish Payments Council. The report is based on information available up to 19 August 2016. Inquiries about the report should be directed to: Danmarks Nationalbank Communications Havnegade 5 DK-1093 Copenhagen K Telephone +45 33 63 70 00 (direct) or +45 33 63 63 63 Inquiries: Monday-Friday 9:00 am-4:00 pm Email: [email protected] www.nationalbanken.dk 2 CONTENTS 1 Introduction and conclusions.................................................................................................5 1.1 Conclusions .....................................................................................................................5 1.2 Background .....................................................................................................................6 1.3 Definition and scope ........................................................................................................7 1.4 Contents ..........................................................................................................................7 2 The payments market undergoing change ............................................................................9
    [Show full text]
  • List of Charges for Mastercard Direct Effective from 1 January 2018
    List of charges for Mastercard Direct Effective from 1 January 2018 Annual card fee (standard) DKK 60 Contactless debit function of MasterCard Fee per cash withdrawal of foreign exchange for - with Danske Hverdag1 DKK 0 Direct travel at Danske Bank's ATMs in Denmark - with Danske Hverdag+2 DKK 0 The limit on amounts of purchases made in Standard fee DKK 35 shops without the use of a PIN is DKK 200 - with Danske Hverdag DKK 35 Other fees per purchase. You may occasionally be - with Danske Hverdag+ DKK 0 Establishment fee DKK 0 asked to confirm your transaction by means The conversion rate is Danske Bank's cash selling rate (notes). of your chip or PIN. Express order DKK 200 Conversion rates for use outside Denmark Fee per cash withdrawal at International courier service DKK 150 Conversion is based on the exchange rates Danske Bank's ATMs in Denmark Replacement card DKK 100 set by Mastercard at any time plus a - Standard fee DKK 0 variable margin set by Danske Bank, - with Danske Hverdag DKK 0 Copy of receipts (per receipt) DKK 200 currently 1.5% for European* and - with Danske Hverdag+ DKK 0 - We charge this fee only if the 2,0% for other currencies. amount stated in the copy of the receipt is equal to the disputed Other ATMs in Denmark Conversion takes place at the exchange rate amount withdrawn from the Standard fee DKK 10 prevailing on the same business day as the account. - with Danske Hverdag DKK 10 transaction is completed in Nets. The - with Danske Hverdag+ DKK 0 exchange rates applicable at any time are København Transaction fee – available at nets.eu/valutakurser (website in Using the card function is free of charges, Fees for use of MasterCard Direct Danish only).
    [Show full text]
  • Conditions for Dankort and Visa/Dankort
    1 Conditions for Dankort and Visa/Dankort Effective from 1. January 2019 “This document has been translated from Danish into English. About your Dankort and Visa/Dankort However, the original Danish text is the governing text for all Keep your card safe purposes, and in case of discrepancy the Danish wording will be Check at regular intervals that you have not lost your card. It is applicable.” just as personal as a passport, driver’s licence, national health insurance card and the like. Contents Memorise your PIN If you need to make a note of your personal identification 1 Visa/Dankort conditions ................................................... 2 number (PIN), you can ask Nordea for a PIN-memorising card. Your PIN must always be kept separate from your card and 2 What can you use the card for? ........................................ 2 never be written on your card. 3 Safeguarding your card, PIN and Verified Do not reveal your PIN to any other person by Visa password ............................................................. 2 The PIN is your electronic signature. No matter what happens and 4 Verified by Visa ................................................................ 2 where you are in the world, never reveal your PIN to any other 5 Use of the card ................................................................ 2 person. Never choose your PIN as a password for a PC or any other system operated by means of a code chosen by yourself. 6 Cheking entries to your account ....................................... 3 Likewise, do not key in your PIN on a telephone keypad or the 7 Reversal of payments which you have approved .............. 3 like. 8 Reversal of payments which you have not approved ........ 3 Be careful when using your PIN 9 Your obligation to block your card ....................................
    [Show full text]