Growing a Culture of Social Impact Investing in the UK
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Growing a culture of social impact investing in the UK Contents PREFACE BY ELIZABETH CORLEY 4 MINISTERIAL FOREWORD 6 BACKGROUND AND THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE TASKFORCE 8 THE VIRTUOUS CYCLE 10 1. PEOPLE – INTEREST IN INVESTING FOR POSITIVE SOCIAL IMPACT 12 2. INDEPENDENT FINANCIAL ADVISERS (IFAs)/PENSION TRUSTEES 14 3. QUALITY PRODUCT/FUND OFFERINGS 16 4. SEARCH AND ASSESSMENT OF INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES 18 5. A – INVESTEE ENGAGEMENT – SOCIAL ENTERPRISE CHARITIES 20 5. B – INVESTEE ENGAGEMENT – PURPOSEFUL BUSINESS 22 6. INVESTMENT EVALUATION 23 7. REPORTING OF IMPACT 26 8. ECOSYSTEM INCLUDING GOVERNMENT AND REGULATION 28 CONCLUSION AND NEXT STEPS 30 APPENDIX 1: LIST OF TASKFORCE MEMBERS AND CONTRIBUTORS 31 APPENDIX 2: LIST OF SIGNATORIES 38 3 Preface by Elizabeth Corley It was a privilege to be delighted to contribute regularly to those organised asked in 2017 to chair by others. We have commissioned new research and an advisory group to built networks and coalitions to push things forward look at how we can in key areas, such as impact reporting and the views build a culture of social of consumers. We have developed practical tools impact investing in the for use by others in the field, and worked to identify UK. Our final report joint opportunities to scale impact and demonstrate detailed more than what is possible. 50 recommendations I am hugely grateful to the many volunteers, well on how this could be over 160, who have committed their energy, intellect achieved and thus and passion to our work and to the firms who have enable more people to support more easily the been supportive of their engagement with us. Thank things they care about through their savings and you. In particular the leaders of work streams and investments. What the advisory group also built members of the steering committee have engaged was a strong network of committed advocates for continuously and to great effect to carry through social impact investment and momentum to get some of our recommendations. We have also things done So we were delighted to be asked by the benefitted from sustained support and interest from Prime Minister in 2018 to form an Implementation government, most notably from our sponsors – the Taskforce that would focus on the recommendations Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport in order to turn words into deeds. and Her Majesty’s Treasury – as well as from across In this report we have highlighted some of our work other departments, particularly the Department for and the progress that has been made, not least International Development and the Department for in the development of practical tools, sustained Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy. engagement across a broad set of practitioners, As we said in our original advisory report, surveys and contributions to an increasing number transforming the culture and practice of investment of consultations. We have seen mainstream is not a year-long exercise, nor something that can investment bodies launch guides and glossaries, be achieved by one body alone. While I am pleased create committees to focus on impact and responsible with the progress we have made with our peers and investing, gather information to deepen understanding partners, there remains much to do to achieve that and form coalitions to focus on specific topics of original goal of every person being able to save and opportunity or challenge. More than 50 leading invest more easily into what they care about. The financial and social sector bodies have pledged to urgency of the problems and challenges we face, support our work (see appendix 1). An even greater both environmental and social, remains. So. while this number have been engaged in the workstreams set report reflects the achievements and insights from up to drive action on the recommendations forward a year of sustained activity, it also highlights areas (see appendix 2). The taskforce has contributed to the where we consider that sustained focus is required. development of an increasingly supportive regulatory and policy-making environment both through direct Impact investing is growing rapidly in the UK and engagement and through response to consultations. around the world. This growth reflects the depth and breadth of social need, particularly in disadvantaged Working with others also committed to growing areas, and an increasing desire by individual savers impact investing with integrity, we have been pleased and investors to use their capital to contribute to see increased awareness and interest among to social challenges while generating a financial leading groups of professionals who have the ability return. Impact investing goes beyond avoiding to accelerate positive developments in the sector. harm and mitigating risks. But it is part of a wider The taskforce has run multiple events and been 4 movement towards more responsible investing, which incorporates environmental, social and governance considerations into investment decisions. Continued active focus on impact investing integrity, and how it relates to broader values-based investing, will be needed to keep pace with its growing popularity. The UK has a strong tradition of innovation in finance to deliver impact as well as financial return. We are well placed to play a global leadership role in the growing impact investment market given our financial services scale, reach and expertise. Whilst the taskforce has reached a natural conclusion one year on, work and ideas to grow a culture of impact investing will continue. Many of us who have had the chance to contribute are excited at the prospect that there is appetite and interest to find more sustainable ways to continue our work and looking forward to that opportunity. The ideas and ways forward highlighted in this report will therefore form a foundation for continued progress. Elizabeth Corley Chair of the Implementation Taskforce on Growing a culture of social impact investing in the UK 5 Ministerial Foreword Social Impact Investment is one of the most exciting Further growth in the market will require continued developments in the finance sector today, allowing leadership and innovation from the financial sector in investments to deliver a financial return while partnership with the social sector and Government. ensuring that they drive a positive social impact. The government remains committed to advancing Impact investing can increase the opportunities this important agenda and building on the Taskforce’s individuals have to invest in line with their values substantial progress, including by co-ordinating across and enhance the UK’s position as a leader in financial the relevant government departments and continuing services. It has the potential to drive sustainable to work with industry to bring social impact investing economic growth, help to tackle entrenched social into the mainstream. challenges and support transformation in the way We would like to thank Elizabeth Corley and the public services are commissioned. members of the Taskforce for their considerable work The UK has a strong foundation to build on and outlined in this report. We look forward to supporting the leadership and efforts demonstrated by this the continued evolution of social impact investing. Taskforce have been invaluable in further catalysing the drive behind Social Impact Investment and raising its profile. This report highlights that tangible progress is already being made in advancing the 53 recommendations of the Advisory Group on social impact investing. John Glen MP The Rt Hon Jeremy Wright QC MP Economic Secretary to the Treasury Secretary of State, DCMS 6 The Growing a Culture of Impact Investing Taskforce Conference on 12 June 2018. 7 Background and the establishment of the taskforce In 2016, the UK government set up an independent This definition remains compatible with the Global advisory group of senior financial industry Impact Investing Network (GIIN)’s more recent Core practitioners to answer an important question: How Characteristics of Impact Investing, which provide the can the providers of savings, pensions and investments four tenets that define impact investing2. engage with individuals to enable them to support more The report authors went on to make 53 easily the things they care about through their savings recommendations aimed at encouraging and guiding and investment choices? action across all industry participants, regulators, and The question was motivated by growing interest in government. These recommendations aim to build the UK in social impact investing. The sentiments on the UK’s established commitment to investing that drove that demand were familiar. They included in social causes. As early as 2000, HMT launched a a desire to help others and to make private money taskforce to investigate how to help the community a force for public good. However, despite growing finance sector grow. In 2013 the Cabinet Office enthusiasm, investors continued to find it challenging established Big Society Capital, the world’s first social to invest in line with their values. investment institution of its kind, funded with the proceeds of dormant bank accounts and donations Several factors were at play. One was that people from four UK banks. struggled to identify liquid social impact investment opportunities. In addition, where investments were The recommendations recognised that there is an offered, the definition and measurement of “impact” investment continuum, with different interventions was often unclear. finding their