DOCSLIB.ORG

Moments with Madiba Jacques Moreillon 706.63 KB

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Moments with Madiba Jacques Moreillon 706.63 KB Moments with Madiba / Jacques Moreillon Le document, jusqu'aux chapitres sept et huit, est public, car il traite de faits contenus dans les archives publiques du CICR (1863-1975). Les chapitres 7 et 8 ont été supprimés car ils traitaient de faits postérieurs à 1975. L'auteur a souhaité que la table des matières et la pagination soient conservées telles quelles, pour justement indiquer que l'étude n'était pas complète. Internal study Moments with Madiba By Jacques Moreillon, LL.M., Ph.D May 2005 These pages tell the personal story of the author's fourteen conversations with Nelson Mandela: six when he visited Mandela in prison on Robben Island (1973–1975) in his capacity as Delegate-General for Africa of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), and eight after Mandela’s release (between 1990 and 2004) in various capacities, as representative of the ICRC or of the World Organization of the Scout Movement (WOSM), and in his private capacity. This book is also the account of the ICRC’s first visits to convicted political prisoners on Robben Island and an encouragement to today's South African authorities to open their archives to researchers seeking to know more about political detention in South Africa during the apartheid era, in the spirit of the Truth and Reconciliation process and of the Nelson Mandela Centre of Memory and Commemoration Project. As it focuses on Nelson Mandela as a convicted political prisoner in the years during which the author visited him on Robben Island (1973 to 1975), this work also deals with ICRC visits to the Island previous to that period, and in considerable details, with the conditions of detention there until 1975. However it only marginally deals with ICRC (vain) efforts to visit political detainees under interrogation and does not deal with ICRC visits to other convicted political prisoners (whites in Pretoria local prison and women in other prisons). It also barely deals with ICRC prison visits after 1975. This text is the sole responsibility of its author, who expresses his sincere appreciation to those who helped him in producing it, particularly Mrs Catherine Debraz. The ICRC is the exclusively humanitarian (independent, impartial, neutral and all Swiss) founding body of the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement and the originator of the Geneva Conventions. Based on these treaties it provides protection and assistance to victims of international and non international conflicts and (based on its traditional right of initiative recognized by the States and by the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement) of internal disturbances, violences and tensions, usually called "political" or "security" prisoners. To facilitate its access to such victims, its archives are not accessible to the public for a period of 40 years after the events. TABLE OF CONTENTS FOREWORD: “HAVE YOU SEEN MADIBA?” ...................................................................................... 5 INTRODUCTION: AN INCOMPLETE PICTURE .................................................................................... 7 1 A COMBINATION OF MANY FACTORS................................................................................................. 7 2 LIMITS TO PRISONERS' PERCEPTION .............................................................................................. 10 3 WHAT ROLE DID THE ICRC PLAY? ................................................................................................. 13 CHAPTER ONE: ICRC PRISON VISITS 1964-1971 ............................................................................ 19 1 THE FORMAT OF ICRC PRISON VISITS AND REPORTS ..................................................................... 19 2 VISIT TO ROBERT SOBUKWE (1963).............................................................................................. 20 3 THE FIRST SERIES OF VISITS TO PLACES OF DETENTION IN SOUTH AFRICA (1964) ........................... 22 3.1 The visits by Georg Hoffmann ........................................................................................... 22 3.2 Hoffmann's reports and his and the ICRC’s suggestions .................................................. 23 3.3 As the prisoners saw it ...................................................................................................... 25 3.4 Publication of Hoffmann's report by South Africa (1966–1967) ........................................ 28 4 SECOND SERIES OF VISITS TO PLACES OF DETENTION IN SOUTH AFRICA (1967) .............................. 30 4.1 The visits by Geoffrey Senn .............................................................................................. 30 4.2 Senn's first interview with Mandela ................................................................................... 32 4.3 Senn's remarks about conditions on Robben Island ......................................................... 35 4.4 Further visits by Senn to Robben Island (August and October 1967) ............................... 37 4.5 Follow-up from Geneva ..................................................................................................... 38 5 THE CONTINUATION OF ICRC VISITS (1969) .................................................................................. 39 5.1 Visits by Zuger, Senn and Dr Vuillet to convicted political prisoners ................................ 39 5.2 Conditions of detention ...................................................................................................... 39 5.3 The ICRC’s arguments ...................................................................................................... 40 5.4 Follow-up ........................................................................................................................... 41 6 TERRORISM ACT AND ICRC PRISON VISITS IN 1970 AND 1971 ....................................................... 41 6.1 Convicted prisoners versus prisoners under interrogation ................................................ 41 6.2 Zuger's 1970 visit ............................................................................................................... 42 6.3 Zuger's 1971 visit ............................................................................................................... 49 6.4 Where to go from here? ..................................................................................................... 54 CHAPTER TWO: MY FIRST MEETINGS WITH MADIBA ................................................................... 55 1 MY OWN PERCEPTION OF NELSON MANDELA THROUGH AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL .......................... 55 2 MY FIRST MEETINGS WITH MADIBA: 7 AND 10 MAY 1973 ................................................................ 57 3 AS THE PRISONERS SAW IT ........................................................................................................... 64 CHAPTER THREE: 1973, 1974, 1975 VISITS TO ROBBEN ISLAND AND CHANGES IN CONDITIONS OF DETENTION ............................................................................................................ 65 1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................ 65 2 SUMMARY OF ICRC 1973, 1974 AND 1975 VISITS ......................................................................... 66 2.1 1973 visits .......................................................................................................................... 66 2.2 1974 visits .......................................................................................................................... 67 2.3 1975 visits .......................................................................................................................... 67 3 A PROCESS OF REPETITION AND INSISTENCE ................................................................................. 68 3.1 Access to news .................................................................................................................. 68 3.2 Food ................................................................................................................................... 70 3.3 Studies ............................................................................................................................... 73 3.4 Work .................................................................................................................................. 77 3.5 Grading .............................................................................................................................. 79 3.6 Medical assistance ............................................................................................................ 82 3.7 Warder-prisoner relationship ............................................................................................. 87 3.8 Equipment and hygiene ..................................................................................................... 89 3.9 Leisure and sports ............................................................................................................. 90 CHAPTER FOUR: SECOND MEETINGS WITH MADIBA: 29 MAY AND 1ST JUNE 1974 ............... 92 CHAPTER FIVE: ICRC EFFORTS TO GAIN ACCESS TO NON-CONVICTED PRISONERS ........... 99 CHAPTER SIX: THIRD MEETINGS WITH MADIBA: 21 AND 25 APRIL 1975 ................................ 106 CHAPTER SEVEN: ICRC VISITS TO POLITICAL PRISONERS IN SOUTH AFRICA FROM 1976 TO 1992 .........................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Narratives of Madikizela-Mandela's Testimony in Prison
    The Power Dynamics and ‘Silent’ Narratives of Madikizela-Mandela’s Testimony in Prison Lebohang Motsomotso Abstract This article explores the underlying ontological violence that occurs in the oppressive structure of prisons. As a site of power dynamics, prisons are naturally defined based on inequalities and hierarchies. As such, they are marked by relationships of domination and subordination of prison wardens and prisoners respectively. Winnie Madikizela-Mandela’s actions of resisting the power of the prison wardens becomes an instrument of challenging power. This power will be examined as phallic power and it signifies the overall oppressive systems. The prison experience becomes a mute narrative for Winnie Madikizela-Mandela who is imprisoned by a phallic power- driven system. It is a system that advocates for exercising control over prisoners by silencing and suppressing political convictions through a (il)legitimate system. Winnie Madikizela-Mandela functions as the focal point of discussion in this article through her experience, the argument that unfolds in this article illustrates the prime objective of the mechanics of power that operate in prison is to create docile bodies through, discipline that occurs by means of regulation, surveillance and isolation. Firstly, this article will outline how men monopolise power and how it is expressed and (re)presented through authority, reason, masculinity and dominance. Women are re(presented) through femininity, inferiority and lack of reason. Secondly, it explains and contextualises
    [Show full text]
  • John Brown's Body Lies A-Mouldering in Its Grave, but His Soul Goes
    52 I THE NEW AFRICAN I MAY 1965 struggle of the South African people this man, a member of the privileged group. gave his life because of his passionate belief in racial equality. This will serve to strengthen the faith of all those who fight against the danget of a "race war" and retain their faith that all human beings can live together in dignity irrespective of the colour of their skin. I have, of course, known of Mr. John Harris and his activity in the movement against apartheid in sports for some time. Last July, a few days before his arrest, the attention of the Sub-Com­ mittee was drawn to a confidential A THIRD-GENERATION SOUTH AFRICAN, message from him on the question of Frederick John Harris was born in sports apartheid. 1937 and spent part of his childhood I have recently received a message on a farm at Eikenhof in the Transvaal. sent by him from his death cell in From earliest days his intellectual Pretoria Central Prison in January. He brilliance was recognised in the family wrote: circle. He became a radio "Quiz kid" "The support and warm sympathy of and his relatives, several of whom were friends has been and is among my basic teachers, used to say half-seriously of reinforcements. I daily appreciate the him that he would one day be Prime accuracy of the observation that when Minister. From an early age his main one really has to endure one relies ultimately on Reason and Courage. I've dream was of himself as a statesman been fortunate in that the first has stood in an ideal South Africa.
    [Show full text]
  • Madikizela's a Human Being Died That Night
    History, memory and reconciliation: Njabulo Ndebele’s The cry of Winnie Mandela and Pumla Gobodo- Madikizela’s A human being died that night Ralph Goodman Department of English University of Stellenbosch STELLENBOSCH E-pos: [email protected] Abstract History, memory and reconciliation: Njabulo Ndebele’s The cry of Winnie Mandela and Pumla Gobodo-Madikizela’s A human being died that night This article deals with two texts written during the process of transition in South Africa, using them to explore the cultural and ethical complexity of that process. Both Njabulo Ndebele’s “The cry of Winnie Mandela” and Pumla Gobodo-Madikizela’s “A human being died that night” deal with controversial public figures, Winnie Mandela and Eugene de Kock respectively, whose role in South African history has made them part of the national iconography. Ndebele and Gobodo-Madikizela employ narrative techniques that expose and exploit faultlines in the popular representations of these figures. The two texts offer radical ways of understanding the communal and individual suffering caused by apartheid, challenging readers to respond to the past in ways that will promote healing rather than perpetuate a spirit of revenge. The part played by official histories is implicitly questioned and the role of individual stories is shown to be crucial. Forgiveness and reconciliation are seen as dependent on an awareness of the complex circumstances and the humanity of those who are labelled as offenders. This requirement applies especially to the case of “A human being died that night”, a text that insists that the overt Literator 27(2) Aug. 2006:1-20 ISSN 0258-2279 1 History, memory and reconciliation: Njabulo Ndebele ..
    [Show full text]
  • Thematic Report on Criminal Justice and Human Rights In
    THEMATIC REPORT ON CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND HUMAN RIGHTS IN SOUTH AFRICA A Submission to the UN Human Rights Committee in response to the Initial Report by South Africa under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights at the 116th session of the Human Rights Committee (Geneva March 2016) By the following organisations : Civil Society Prison Reform Initiative Just Detention International Lawyers for Human Rights NICRO 1 Contents Executive summary ................................................................................................................................. 3 Contact details of contributing organisations .......................................................................................... 5 Introduction ............................................................................................................................................. 7 Methodology and limitations .................................................................................................................. 8 Arbitrary arrest and detention ................................................................................................................. 8 Arrest without a warrant ..................................................................................................................... 8 Pre-trial detention .............................................................................................................................. 10 Delays in bail applications ...................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Restorative Justice Programmes in a Prison Environment: a Qualitative Enquiry
    RESTORATIVE JUSTICE PROGRAMMES IN A PRISON ENVIRONMENT: A QUALITATIVE ENQUIRY BY CLARICE ZIMBILI ZONDI, MA (UNIZUL) Submitted in fulfilment of the requirement for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY In the Department of Criminal Justice University of Zululand Promoter: Prof. J.M. Ras Date of submission: April 2014 DECLARATION I declare that the thesis “Restorative Justice programmes in a prison environment: A qualitative enquiry”, is my own work both in conception and in execution. As far as possible and where applicable, I have acknowledged all my sources by means of complete references. …………………………………………… MISS. C. Z. ZONDI (Student nr. 840710) i DEDICATION This thesis is dedicated to my grandson Loyiso and his parents Ayanda and Kutele Mabude for their love and support in my academic endeavours. Soli Deo Gloria! ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I wish to express my sincere gratitude to the following persons and institutions for their assistance: The Lord my Saviour, without His intervention this study was not possible. I have always depended on Him and He has never let me down. To Him be the glory. My promoter, Prof. J. M. Ras for his inspiration, guidance, understanding and never ending support. Baie dankie Prof. Phoenix Zululand, with special reference to Richard Aitken and Nonceba Lushaba for providing information regarding their restorative justice programmes. DCS officials who have contributed to this research in one or other way. DCS Regional Office in Pietermaritzburg for providing statistical information on the prisons. Friends and family who have supported me during this study. My late mother, Kessiah Zondi, who always proudly had enjoyed every step that I take towards reaching my dream of completing the thesis FACASA staff for their assistance during this study.
    [Show full text]
  • Prisons – a Call to Action for Post-Apartheid Administrative Lawyers Keynote by Justice Edwin Cameron
    Administrative Justice Association of South Africa AGM Thursday 4 March 2021, 18h00 Prisons – A call to action for post-apartheid administrative lawyers Keynote By Justice Edwin Cameron • Introduction 1. It is a pleasure and an honour to address your Annual General Meeting. My chosen topic is prisons. This is not only because, for the last fourteen months I’ve been Inspecting Judge of Prisons. It’s also because the very concept of prisons is arrestingly forbidding, even alarming – and rightly so. Mass confinement of mostly adult males is a relatively recent phenomenon, about two centuries old.1 It has overtones of horror which future generations may look back on with moral censure. 2. In South Africa, there is an additional concern – that, as under apartheid, our prisons are becoming dark, closed and punitive institutions. 3. The concept of prisons and our prisons practice in South Africa urgently need attention from public interest lawyers and academics. Yet public debate about prisons and the utility of our sentencing regime is conspicuously lacking. 4. Why do we turn our gaze away from the evident problems? Where, in particular, are the administrative lawyers? What role can they play? 5. There are some legitimate reasons. 1 Other punitive methods, including execution, were used. And from 1788 to 1868, about 162 000 convicts were transported from Britain and Ireland to Australia. The British Government first transported convicts to American colonies in the early 18th century. See archives from the Australian Government “Convicts and the British Colonies in Australia” available at https://web.archive.org/web/20160101181100/http://www.australia.gov.au/about- australia/australian-story/convicts-and-the-british-colonies (accessed 5 March 2021).
    [Show full text]
  • Truth and Reconciliation Commission of South Africa Report
    VOLUME THREE Truth and Reconciliation Commission of South Africa Report The report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission was presented to President Nelson Mandela on 29 October 1998. Archbishop Desmond Tutu Ms Hlengiwe Mkhize Chairperson Dr Alex Boraine Mr Dumisa Ntsebeza Vice-Chairperson Ms Mary Burton Dr Wendy Orr Revd Bongani Finca Adv Denzil Potgieter Ms Sisi Khampepe Dr Fazel Randera Mr Richard Lyster Ms Yasmin Sooka Mr Wynand Malan* Ms Glenda Wildschut Dr Khoza Mgojo * Subject to minority position. See volume 5. Chief Executive Officer: Dr Biki Minyuku I CONTENTS Chapter 1 Introduction to Regional Profiles ........ 1 Appendix: National Chronology......................... 12 Chapter 2 REGIONAL PROFILE: Eastern Cape ..................................................... 34 Appendix: Statistics on Violations in the Eastern Cape........................................................... 150 Chapter 3 REGIONAL PROFILE: Natal and KwaZulu ........................................ 155 Appendix: Statistics on Violations in Natal, KwaZulu and the Orange Free State... 324 Chapter 4 REGIONAL PROFILE: Orange Free State.......................................... 329 Chapter 5 REGIONAL PROFILE: Western Cape.................................................... 390 Appendix: Statistics on Violations in the Western Cape ......................................................... 523 Chapter 6 REGIONAL PROFILE: Transvaal .............................................................. 528 Appendix: Statistics on Violations in the Transvaal ......................................................
    [Show full text]
  • South African Crime Quarterly, No 48
    CQ Cover June 2014 7/10/14 3:27 PM Page 1 Reviewing 20 years of criminal justice in South Africa South A f r i c a n CRIME QUA RT E R LY No. 48 | June 2014 Previous issues Stacy Moreland analyses judgements in rape ISS Pretoria cases in the We s t e r n Cape, finding that Block C, Brooklyn Court p a t r i a rchal notions of gender still inform 361 Veale Street judgements in rape case. Heidi Barnes writes a New Muckleneuk case note on the Constitutional Court case Pretoria, South Africa F v Minister of Safety and Security. Alexander Tel: +27 12 346 9500 Hiropoulos and Jeremy Porter demonstrate how Fax:+27 12 460 0998 Geographic Information Systems can be used, [email protected] along with crime pattern theory, to analyse police crime data. Geoff Harris, Crispin Hemson ISS Addis Ababa & Sylvia Kaye report on a conference held in 5th Floor, Get House Building Durban in mid-2013 about measures to reduce Africa Avenue violence in schools; and Hema Harg o v a n Addis Ababa, Ethiopia reviews the latetest edition of Victimology in Tel: +251 11 515 6320 South Africa by Robert Peacock (ed). Fax: +251 11 515 6449 [email protected] Andrew Faull responds to Herrick and Charman ISS Dakar (SACQ 45), delving into the daily liquor policing 4th Floor, Immeuble Atryum in the Western Cape. He looks beyond policing Route de Ouakam for solutions to alcohol-related harms. Claudia Forester-Towne considers how race and gender Dakar, Senegal influence police reservists' views about their Tel: +221 33 860 3304/42 work.
    [Show full text]
  • This Winnie and Arson During the 1980S
    lifeopera 3 THE SUNDAY INDEPENDENT MAY 8 2011 Tsakane Madwanganyi as Winnie OBURG, 1998. Journalists, pho- tographers and cameramen crowd outside the Johannesburg Central Methodist Church for the next round of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s Jhearings into atrocities committed under Winnie is interrogated by her accusers, above. Cover picture: Mothers of the Missing (who act as spirit guides) with Winnie while she is in apartheid. Everyone is scrambling for solitary confinement at Pretoria Central Prison. their close-up, the right angle, their sound- bite as Winnie Madikizela-Mandela, the former wife of then-president Nelson Mandela, is set to testify about allegations that she was complicit in murder, torture This Winnie and arson during the 1980s. This is the opening scene of Act One in Winnie the Opera, a local production about one of South Africa’s most divisive political figures. The opera, which opened to a standing ovation at the State Theatre in Pretoria on April 28, takes a snapshot look at Winnie’s life. Writer, Warren Wilensky leads the audience into the past, highlighting certain events he believes shaped history to bring Winnie to this Soars point, where she is flayed by international media and despised by many. Opera is not often based on the lives of actual people and so, it may seem an odd Review by Andrea van Wyk way to depict someone’s life story. But, it is an art form that is highly emotive and Winnie’s story is nothing if not dramatic. In their heavy bass voices, lawyers fling accusation upon accusation at Winnie musical show but a visual spectacle as nie nor about defending her.
    [Show full text]
  • Human Rights and Mental Health in Post-Apartheid South Africa
    Bantjes et al. BMC International Health and Human Rights (2017) 17:29 DOI 10.1186/s12914-017-0136-0 RESEARCHARTICLE Open Access Human rights and mental health in post-apartheid South Africa: lessons from health care professionals working with suicidal inmates in the prison system Jason Bantjes* , Leslie Swartz and Pieter Niewoudt Abstract Background: During the era of apartheid in South Africa, a number of mental health professionals were vocal about the need for socio-economic and political reform. They described the deleterious psychological and social impact of the oppressive and discriminatory Nationalist state policies. However, they remained optimistic that democracy would usher in positive changes. In this article, we consider how mental health professionals working in post-apartheid South Africa experience their work. Methods: Our aim was to describe the experience of mental health professionals working in prisons who provide care to suicidal prisoners. Data were collected from in-depth semi-structured interviews and were analyzed using thematic content analysis. Results: Findings draw attention to the challenges mental health professionals in post-apartheid South Africa face when attempting to provide psychological care in settings where resources are scarce and where the environment is anti-therapeutic. Findings highlight the significant gap between current policies, which protect prisoners’ human rights, and every-day practices within prisons. Conclusions: The findings imply that there is still an urgent need for activism in
    [Show full text]
  • Health, Human Rights, and the Transformation of Punishment
    HHr Health and Human Rights Journal Health, Human Rights, and the TransformationHHR_final_logo_alone.indd of 1 10/19/15 10:53 AM Punishment: South African Litigation to Address HIV and Tuberculosis in Prisons emily nagisa keehn and ariane nevin Abstract South Africa experiences the world’s highest HIV burden and one of the highest burdens for tuberculosis (TB). People in prison are particularly vulnerable to these diseases. Globally, and internally in South Africa, increased attention is being paid to HIV and TB treatment and prevention in prisons, with the public health community arguing for reforms that improve respect for the human rights of incarcerated people, for example, by calling for the reduction of overcrowding and unnecessary incarceration. Despite the retributive rhetoric that is popular among politicians and the public, the constitution mandates and recognizes the right of people in prison to humane and dignified conditions of detention. These values are diffused through law and policy, supported by an independent judiciary, and monitored by a small but vigilant prisons-focused human rights community. These factors enable the courts to make decisions that facilitate systemic improvements in prison conditions—counter to popular sentiment favoring punitive measures—and increase access to HIV and TB services in detention. This article examines a series of strategic litigation cases that illustrate this process of change to remedy disease-inducing and rights-violating conditions in South African prisons. emily nagisa keehn, J.D., is associate director of the Academic Program at Harvard Law School’s Human Rights Program in Cambridge, MA, USA. ariane nevin, LL.M., is a national prisons specialist at Sonke Gender Justice in Cape Town, South Africa.
    [Show full text]
  • A Story for Denis - an Unusual Friendship
    9. A story for Denis - an unusual friendship By Hillary Hamburger It was on October 6, 2012 that my husband and I were invited to a dinner given in honour of our friend Denis Goldberg. The Randburg ANC Branch renamed their Branch after him. He gave the first annual lecture that was named after him. Denis loves talking, especially about the topic that is never far from his mind - South Africa and our struggle for freedom and our triumph over the dark forces of racism in 1994. We were not disappointed by his hard-hitting lecture He emphasized the inequality gap between the rich and the poor that remains a scourge in our country. He reminded his comrades that our struggle was against the greedy accumulation of wealth. He talked about the striking miners of Marikana and their exploitative low wages. His audience was riveted and when he was finished, the applause was rousing. The Denis Goldberg ANC branch had heard him. On the drive home that night from the Walter Sisulu Hall, I reflected on the long journey that Denis had been on and how privileged I felt to have been a witness to a part of it. I remember that winter’s day on the 12 July 1964, sitting in a chilled Pretoria Supreme Court, when the Rivonia Trialists were sentenced to life imprisonment. I knew that I was being a witness to a significant and painful chapter in our country’s history. Our courageous leaders held their heads high in the knowledge that even if they were executed the struggle would continue.
    [Show full text]