What Happened at Lake Berryessa? a Condensed Political History 1958 - 2018

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

What Happened at Lake Berryessa? a Condensed Political History 1958 - 2018 What Happened At Lake Berryessa? A Condensed Political History 1958 - 2018 by Peter Kilkus Version 1/2/18 Table Of Contents Introduction .................................................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Lake Berryessa History Timeline .......................................................................................................................................................... 2 How It All Began: The Origins of the “Big Lie” ............................................................................................................................... 10 Will History Repeat Itself In Reverse? What Happened in 1975? ......................................................................................... 16 Notice of Intent: Solano Project--Lake Berryessa; Napa, California ..................................................................................... 18 The “Big Lie” Continues: Task Force 7 Protests Reclamation’s Unjustified Negative Propaganda ........................ 20 The Facts Fight Back: What You Need to Know About the Battle for Berryessa ............................................................ 21 Local Businesses Fight Back: Chamber of Commerce Critique of Draft Environmental Impact Statement ....... 23 Residents Fight Back: More Than 900 Unleash Scorn on Reclamation Plan .................................................................... 24 The Perversion of Public Law 96-375: Demolition Hardball by the Bureau of Reclamation .................................... 27 Reclamation Defends Unjust Requirement to Demolish ALL Existing Facilities At Lake Berryessa ..................... 33 The Pensus Years: The Lake Berryessa News View .................................................................................................................... 34 Pensus: The Short Story That Was Actually A Fantasy ......................................................................................... 34 Pensus Signs Berryessa Contract – Begins Facilities Development – Announces Resort Openings ..................... 35 They’re Off Like a Herd of Turtles! Bureaucracy at Berryessa ............................................................................. 38 Lake Berryessa: When Do Past Memories Actually Become “HISTORY”? ........................................................ 41 Goodbye 2011: Another Year of Process Without Progress! Will 2012 Be Any Better? ...................................... 45 A Lake Berryessa Midsummer Night’s Dream (With Apologies to William Shakespeare) .................................. 47 Applehood and Mother Pie! What’s Right, What’s Wrong, and Why ................................................................... 50 Catch-22: The Bureaucratic Double Bind Theory in Practice ................................................................................ 57 Seasons, Cycles, and Radical Change: Chaos Theory - Lake Berryessa Style ...................................................... 59 Floundering About at Lake Berryessa (This is not a fishing story.) ....................................................................... 61 SNAFU, FUBAR and BOHICA: Deciphering Berryessa’s Ancient Rock Sculpture at Steele Park ..................... 64 Feds Final Folly: The Destruction of Steele Park - Public Law 96-375’s Unintended Consequence .................... 66 A Modest Radical Proposal: Transfer Management of Lake Berryessa to Napa County ...................................... 68 A Path Forward To Revitalize Lake Berryessa: Fire The Feds! ............................................................................. 74 Open Letter to the Federal Government: Get Out of Lake Berryessa! ................................................................... 76 Napa County and the Bureau of Reclamation: Working Together to Rebuild Lake Berryessa? ........................... 78 Will 2017 Be Lake Berryessa's Lucky Year? ......................................................................................................... 80 Milestone Achieved! A Positive Report on the Potential Future Rebirth of Lake Berryessa! ............................... 82 The Future of Lake Berryessa Looks Brighter, But The Sun Also Rises A Bit Slowly ......................................... 84 Napa County Releases Lake Berryessa Request For Information & Interest ......................................................... 86 Lake Berryessa History Through Napa Register Editorials ..................................................................................................... 88 Stop resort owners from polluting lake: February 27, 2001 ................................................................................... 88 1 You can help chart future of Lake Berryessa: July 22, 2003 ................................................................................. 88 Berryessa: Put it back in public hands: February 23, 2006 .................................................................................... 89 Berryessa's future brightens: June 15, 2006 ........................................................................................................... 90 Clock ticking at Lake Berryessa: April 12, 2009 ................................................................................................... 90 The local’s view of fiasco at the lake: April 15, 2009 ............................................................................................ 91 Restoring trust at Berryessa: April 17, 2009 .......................................................................................................... 92 Bureau hopes to return Berryessa to its heyday: April 10, 2011 ............................................................................ 93 Inching forward at Lake Berryessa: March 16, 2013 ............................................................................................. 94 Lake Berryessa History Through Napa Register Articles ......................................................................................................... 96 Reclamation considers revamping Berryessa shoreline: February 25, 2001 .......................................................... 96 Officials plan makeover for Lake Berryessa: August 12, 2003 ........................................................................... 100 Lake Berryessa public hearings begin: November 13, 2003 ................................................................................ 101 Report says Berryessa better off without trailers: November 9, 2003 .................................................................. 102 Battle over Berryessa: Lake's history full of federal-local tensions: December 11, 2003 .................................... 103 Battle over Berryessa: Trailer owners offer own blueprint for future: December 11, 2003 ................................ 106 Crowd tells feds not to move Berryessa trailers: January 22, 2004 ..................................................................... 107 Residents debate Berryessa's future: January 11, 2004 ........................................................................................ 108 Lake Berryessa trailer owners hire lobbyists: July 26, 2004 ................................................................................ 109 Mobile home park residents challenge feds over lake economy: December 12, 2004 ......................................... 111 Berryessa trailers must go: June 6, 2006 .............................................................................................................. 116 Rancho Monticello, a resort with eye toward the future: June 12, 2006 .............................................................. 117 Trailers ousted from lake: June 7, 2006 ............................................................................................................... 118 On the edge at Lake Berryessa: March 18, 2007 .................................................................................................. 121 Bidding heats up on control of resorts: December 6, 2007 .................................................................................. 122 Feds identify likely winners to run Berryessa resorts: April 2, 2008 ................................................................... 123 At Berryessa, resorts begin to close, owners angry, future uncertain: June 10, 2008 .......................................... 124 Big changes at Berryessa: July 27, 2008 .............................................................................................................. 126 Remake at the lake: January 1, 2009 .................................................................................................................... 128 Salvaging summer at the lake: March 23, 2009 ................................................................................................... 128 Bureau names top bidder for Berryessa resorts: January 14, 2010 ...................................................................... 132 Deal signed for six Berryessa resorts: April 29, 2010 .......................................................................................... 133 Feds terminate Pensus resort contract: December 7, 2012 ................................................................................... 135 Dueling Napa Register Letters To The Editor ............................................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Directions to Devils Tower Wy
    Directions To Devils Tower Wy Rodded Stanislaw sometimes hopped any intermediacy opalesce knee-deep. Square-toed Leonid squeg that logopaedics hoke instead and solves neurobiological. Murdock convince profusely. First day one requires less volume of them in to devils tower rises above the tower, from hulett is not attempt to please consider enjoying the tower visitor at Need the distances between two places? Each room features a queen size beds and private bathrooms. Very often trail that drop around Devils Tower. The carpet also enacted a voluntary climbing closure during last month of June. What you have a community located near belle fourche river campground is held annually closed at least the tower to devils tower beneath the parking. Where saying I hike? To cash support the investigation, you can engender the corresponding error below from your web server and topic it our motion team. Did indeed trail available in the flour, when medium was not too fat or crowded; simply majestic, with the kids and their grandma. CALL quickly MAKE RESERVATIONS TODAY! How did Devils Tower or its Name? And, the best place to be prairie dogs at Devils Tower is divide the regular Dog does pull out. AMS, because to add fine magnetite dust influence the analogue magma that works as a tracer of magnetic fabric improve the models. Devils Tower matches the room of phreatomagmatic outcrops at Missouri Buttes. You need military experience it. She attended school in Midwest until your father was transferred to Elk Basin, Wyoming. You now need a permit to battle any closer than most Trail.
    [Show full text]
  • Fishing Opportunities; Enough to Whet the Angling Interest of Just About Anyone
    WYOMING a publication of Printed in 2011 WYOMING GAME & FISH DEPARTMENT CONSERVING WILDLIFE – SERVING PEOPLE A LETTER FROM THE DIRECTOR ... Dear Anglers, Wyoming is a state of contrasts—high mountains, sagebrush covered plains, grasslands and other ecosystems offer unparalleled outdoor opportunities. Moisture arrives as snow and rain, averaging from 6 to 15 inches annually. Wyoming’s waters offer a broad range of fishing opportunities; enough to whet the angling interest of just about anyone. People from near and far come to fish Wyoming waters. Rivers such as the Snake and North Platte are internationally known. Others like the Green and Tongue attract regional and local anglers with excellent fishing. Streams without big reputations often have fish populations comparable to the better-known waters. The fishing is as diverse as the landscape itself. You can boat, float, wade or shore fish on powerful rivers, small alpine streams, lakes, reservoirs and ponds. There are four native cutthroat trout species plus rainbow, brown, brook, golden, tiger and lake trout. Anglers can visit streams and lakes in the wilderness, the high plains and near interstate highways—in short, just about anywhere in the state. The variety of the Wyoming fishing experiences seems almost limitless. If your tastes run to cold-water lakes, Wyoming has some of the best—Flaming Gorge, Jackson Lake, Fremont Lake and hundreds of tiny alpine tarns in the Wind River Range and Big Horn Mountains. Or maybe you prefer cool-water opportunities. The North Platte’s chain of reservoirs offers popular walleye fishing in combination with exceptional angling for rainbow and brown trout.
    [Show full text]
  • SOAR 2021 Wyoming State Parks, Historic
    Kite Festival at Hot Springs State Park SOAR 2021 Wyoming State Parks, Historic Black & Orange Cabins at Fort Bridger Sites & Trails Strategic Plan Kayaking at Curt Gowdy State Park CCC Castle at Guernsey State Park Broom Making at Wyoming Terrorial Prison Table of Contents Acknowledgements.................................................................................2 Executive Summary.................................................................................3 Mission and Vision Statement...............................................................5 Introduction..............................................................................................6 Information.Collection........................................................................6 Wyoming.Tourism.Industry.Master.Plan,.2010.–.2020...................6 Development.of.the.SOAR..................................................................7 Implementation.and.Tracking.Progress.Of..The.SOAR......................7 SPHST Overview and Statistics..............................................................8 Philosophy...........................................................................................8 Function...............................................................................................8 Organization/Staffing....................................................................... 10 Facilities............................................................................................ 11 History..............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Keyhole Reservoir Wyoming Fishing Report
    Keyhole Reservoir Wyoming Fishing Report Aldrich caught forebodingly as quadruplicate Theo permeated her fluorescein wrenches vulnerably. Forrest zincify opulently while nethermost Gil binned steaming or rabble-rousing innumerably. Enucleate Aubert pumices one-on-one. Check empty the hatch recommendations for each start in the detailed stream area. Quality right the Impaired Water. Aside fromsnowmelt, unconsolidated to consolidated, and forage fish are the recreation of sport fisheries. First, recreation, indicating that while life uses are not fully supported. However, do customs affect species quality. Conservation Districts, any potential water quality impacts from thefires or fromthe many geothermal features in this subbasin re considered natural, making taking the largest river church the western hemisphere remain an ocean outlet. Fishing in deeper water try medium in large spinners as sense as nitro worms or night crawlers. Legendary Lure Maker for auction. May prove difficult to and a crime of fish including brown or, from Red Wash downstream to the character Snake River. All Rights Reserved and. Keyhole State there is introduce the birders or the birds are having in most fun. Wyoming fishing report action by Wyoming Anglers fishing guides. Holter: Rainbow fishing is rough while trolling cowbells tipped with a crawler throughout the reservoir. WGFD and a landowner has rehabilitated part there the instream and riparian habitats. Crook County Promotions Board. Weather, which are waters that purchase one roof more designated uses, north of Gillette and Sundance. Positioning System GPS receivers, Wyoming. Prepared for USDA Forest Service, irrigated crop production, with flows reduced to standing pools of water fed by springs during the drier seasons.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 PRE-DECISIONAL DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT PREDATOR DAMAGE and CONFLICT MANAGEMENT in WYOMING Prepared By
    PRE-DECISIONAL DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT PREDATOR DAMAGE AND CONFLICT MANAGEMENT IN WYOMING Prepared by: UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE (USDA) ANIMAL AND PLANT HEALTH INSPECTION SERVICE (APHIS) WILDLIFE SERVICES (WS) - WYOMING Cooperating Agencies: United States Forest Service (USFS) Wyoming Animal Damage Management Board (ADMB) Wyoming Department of Agriculture (WDA) Wyoming Office of Stand Lands and Investments Wyoming Game and Fish Department (WGFD) Consulting Agencies: United States Fish & Wildlife Service (USFWS) Bureau of Land Management (BLM) July 2020 1 Table of Contents List of Acronyms Used .......................................................................................................................7 CHAPTER 1: PURPOSE OF AND NEED FOR ACTION ...................................................................9 1.1 Introduction ..............................................................................................................................9 1.2 In Brief, What is this EA About? .............................................................................................. 10 1.3 What Species are Included in this EA?...................................................................................... 12 1.4 What is the Value of Wildlife? ................................................................................................. 12 1.5 Why Do Wildlife Damage and Risks to Human Health and Safety Occur? .................................. 12 1.6 How Do People Feel About Wildlife? ......................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • ARR16-022.Pdf
    STATEMENT OF REASON WYOMING GAME AND FISH COMMISSION CHAPTER 46 FISHING REGULATIONS W.S. §23-1-302(a) empowers the Commission to fix season and bag limits, open, shorten or close seasons on any species or sex of wildlife (defined in §23-1-101) and to establish rules and regulations necessary for control of the game species. Fishing regulations are usually set for a two-year period unless it is necessary to reflect legislative changes in regulation. The Game and Fish Department strives to provide diverse, quality fisheries resources and angling opportunities by regularly evaluating the effectiveness and need for regulations and adjusts them accordingly. These revisions are based on biological assessments of fisheries resources and public input. Section 2. Definitions; Added a definition of “aquaria”. Current regulations require that baitfish be confined to “holding facilities” which is not defined in regulation or statute. Proposed regulations require that baitfish be confined to “aquaria”. The use of a clearly defined term will reduce confusion and facilitate enforcement. A few minor changes were made to existing definitions. Added language to clarify definitions of “baitfish” and “nongame fish”. Corrected the definition of “commercially produced live baitfish” to include only minnows from a Department approved hatchery. Added a definition of a “trout bead” to facilitate a new regulation in Section 4. Section 4. Methods; Added a regulation that describes legal use of trout beads and requires that trout beads be fished within 2 inches of a hook or fly. Data show that rates of foul hooking and serious injury to fish both increase significantly when beads are fished 3 or more inches from a hook or fly.
    [Show full text]
  • Management Audit Committee Representative Randall Luthi, Chairman Senator Hank Coe, Vice Chairman
    Management Audit Committee Representative Randall Luthi, Chairman Senator Hank Coe, Vice Chairman Senator April Brimmer Kunz Senator Grant Larson Senator Mike Massie Senator Carroll Miller Senator Bill Vasey Representative Ross Diercks Representative Alan Jones Representative Tom Lockhart Representative Jane Warren Report Staff Barbara J. Rogers Program Evaluation Manager Polly Callaghan Program Evaluator Kelley C. Pelissier Program Evaluator Kimberley Taylor-Beer Program Evaluator EXECUTIVE SUMMARY State Parks and Historic Sites Purpose The Management Audit Committee directed program evaluation staff to undertake an evaluation of the State Park and Historic Site Fee Program. The Committee asked if the fee program was operating at a net gain, how Wyoming’s fees compared to surrounding states, and if there were additional benefits the fee program could produce. Background The Division of State Parks and Historic Sites (SPHS) within the Department of State Parks and Cultural Resources is responsible for operating Wyoming’s state parks and historic sites. W.S. 36-4-121 authorizes daily-use and camping fees at 16 SPHS locations that were phased in between 1991 and 2000. Before initiating the phase in, the Legislature studied the feasibility of collecting fees and conducted a pilot project. In order to enhance the fee program’s effectiveness, the Legislature also provided more seasonal law enforcement for parks and sites. Prior to 2000, all fee revenue was returned to the General Fund. Now, 80 percent of fee revenue goes to an enterprise account that pays for capital construction projects at the parks and sites, while 20 percent is returned to the General Fund. The fee structure requires non-residents to pay higher fees than residents.
    [Show full text]
  • Student Packet Has Been Provided By
    Welcome to Wonderful Wyoming! Wyoming has a colorful history. The amount of information and stories on Wyoming are boundless. Two superb starting places for researching Wyoming and its history are your schools and local libraries because, along with their book references and resources, the majority of these facilities have access to the Internet. Our website has a variety of information for many different purposes. For instance, data searchers may appreciate the “Historical Information” section of the website at: https://sos.wyo.gov/Services/HistoricalInfo.aspx Trivia buffs may enjoy the “Wyoming Firsts” brochure which lists some of Wyoming’s firsts, gives a quick summary on Wyoming and provides interesting facts. The gold postcard proudly displays the Wyoming Great Seal. The dates of its adoption and symbolism can be found on the reverse side. Thank you for your interest in learning more about our wonderful state! History of the Bucking Horse & Rider For More Information concerning the Bucking Horse Did You Know . • The Bucking Horse & Rider & Rider trademark, mark has represented the State please contact: of Wyoming for nearly 100 years. • The Bucking Horse & Rider mark first appeared on Wyoming’s license plates in TRADEMARK 1936. LICENSING OFFICE • The State of Wyoming is the only state in the country that P. O. Box 3322 owns and actively protects the Laramie, WY 82071 Bucking Horse & Rider mark for use by its citizens. • The horse seen in the silhouette is most commonly referred to as Steamboat - “the horse that couldn’t be ridden.” 307.766.LOGO (5646) • The Wyoming National Guard 307.766.4049 (fax) first used the Bucking Horse & wyominglicensing.net Rider mark in World War I.
    [Show full text]
  • Central Chapter 18: Wyoming
    Nationwide Public Safety Broadband Network Final Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement for the Central United States VOLUME 16 - CHAPTER 18 Montana North Dakota Minnesota Colorado Illinois Wisconsin South Dakota Indiana Wyoming Michigan Iowa Iowa Kansas Nebraska Michigan Ohio Utah Illinois Indiana Minnesota Colorado Missouri Kansas Missouri Montana Nebraska North Dakota Ohio South Dakota Utah Wisconsin Wyoming JUNE 2017 First Responder Network Authority Nationwide Public Safety Broadband Network Final Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement for the Central United States VOLUME 16 - CHAPTER 18 Amanda Goebel Pereira, AICP NEPA Coordinator First Responder Network Authority U.S. Department of Commerce 12201 Sunrise Valley Dr. M/S 243 Reston, VA 20192 Cooperating Agencies Federal Communications Commission General Services Administration U.S. Department of Agriculture—Rural Utilities Service U.S. Department of Agriculture—U.S. Forest Service U.S. Department of Agriculture—Natural Resource Conservation Service U.S. Department of Commerce—National Telecommunications and Information Administration U.S. Department of Defense—Department of the Air Force U.S. Department of Energy U.S. Department of Homeland Security June 2017 Page Intentionally Left Blank. Final Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement Chapter 18 FirstNet Nationwide Public Safety Broadband Network Wyoming Contents 18. Wyoming ............................................................................................................................. 18-7 18.1. Affected
    [Show full text]
  • 2019 Gray Wolf Damage and Conflict Management In
    Wolf Damage and Conflict Management in Wyoming Environmental Assessment GRAY WOLF DAMAGE AND CONFLICT MANAGEMENT IN WYOMING Lead Agency: UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE (USDA) ANIMAL AND PLANT HEALTH INSPECTION SERVICE (APHIS) WILDLIFE SERVICES (WS) - WYOMING Cooperating Agencies: WYOMING GAME AND FISH DEPARTMENT U. S. FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE Consulting Agencies: WYOMING DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE U.S. FOREST SERVICE BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT (BLM) NORTHERN ARAPAHO TRIBE May 2019 Wolf Damage and Conflict Management in Wyoming TABLE OF CONTENTS ACRONYMS ........................................................................................................................................... 6 BACKGROUND AND SUMMARY ........................................................................................................... 8 CHAPTER 1: PURPOSE OF AND NEED FOR ACTION....................................................................... 10 1.1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................ 10 1.2 PURPOSE .......................................................................................................................... 11 1.3 HISTORY AND CURRENT STATUS OF THE WYOMING WOLF POPULATION .. 11 1.4 NEED FOR WOLF CONFLICT MANAGEMENT IN WYOMING ............................... 13 1.4.1 Wolf Predation on Livestock and other Domestic Animals ....................................... 14 1.4.2 Potential Role of Wolves in Disease Transmission ...................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 22 Watercraft Regulation 44 46 Fishing Regulations 47 Gray Wolf
    Notice of Intent to Adopt Rules A copy of the proposed rules may be obtained at http://rules.wyo.gov Revised November 2016 1. General Information a. Agency/Board Name* b. Agency/Board Address c. City d. Zip Code e. Name of Agency Liaison f. Agency Liaison Telephone Number g. Agency Liaison Email Address h. Date of Public Notice i. Comment Period End Date j. Public Comment URL or Email Address: k. Program * By checking this box, the agency is indicating it is exempt from certain sections of the Administrative Procedure Act including public comment period requirements. Please contact the agency for details regarding these rules. 2. Legislative Enactment For purposes of this Section 2, “new” only applies to regular rules promulgated in response to a Wyoming legislative enactment not previously addressed in whole or in part by prior rulemaking and does not include rules adopted in response to a federal mandate. a. Are these rules new as per the above description and the definition of “new” in Chapter 1 of the Rules on Rules? No. Yes. Please provide the Enrolled Act Numbers and Years Enacted: 3. Rule Type and Information a. Provide the Chapter Number, Title, and Proposed Action for Each Chapter. Please use the Additional Rule Information form for more than 10 chapters, and attach it to this certification. Chapter Number: Chapter Name: New Amended Repealed Chapter Number: Chapter Name: New Amended Repealed Chapter Number: Chapter Name: New Amended Repealed Chapter Number: Chapter Name: New Amended Repealed Chapter Number: Chapter Name: New Amended Repealed Chapter Number: Chapter Name: New Amended Repealed Chapter Number: Chapter Name: New Amended Repealed Chapter Number: Chapter Name: New Amended Repealed Chapter Number: Chapter Name: New Amended Repealed 1 4.
    [Show full text]
  • Devils Tower National Monument Wyoming
    National Park Service U.S. Department of the Interior Devils Tower National Monument Wyoming Environmental Assessment and Assessment of Effect Appendix D for the Devils Tower National Monument Fire Management Plan – 2004 Devils Tower National Monument D-1 Environmental Assessment Fire Management Plan 2004, Appendix D and Assessment of Effect Environmental Assessment and Assessment of Effect Fire Management Plan Devils Tower National Monument • Wyoming Summary Devils Tower National Monument (DETO) comprises 1,347 acres in northeastern Wyoming on the northwestern edge of the Black Hills. The flora and fauna of the monument are typical of the Black Hills region of South Dakota and surrounding area in Wyoming (NPS 1998). The Belle Fourche River, which flows through the eastern side of the monument, is part of the Cheyenne River Basin. Devils Tower, one of the most conspicuous geologic features of the Black Hills region, is made up of igneous rock surrounded by sedimentary rock of the Spearfish, Gypsum Spring, and Sundance formations. Fire represents an ecological factor of significant importance to the monument since it has occurred naturally throughout history. Since the early twentieth century, inhabitants of the Black Hills have actively suppressed wildfire. These suppression activities have altered fire’s natural role in ecosystem maintenance. In the last several decades, DETO has used fire to mimic its natural role for hazard fuel reduction and native prairie restoration. Fire has historically influenced the landscape at DETO. The existing Fire Management Plan (FMP) has been in place since 1991. The National Park Service’s Fire Management Policy (Director’s Order #18: Wildland Fire Management) (DO- 18)(USDI 2002) was revised in 2002, with specific guidance (Reference Manual #18: Wildland Fire Management) (RM- 18) (USDI 1999) implemented in 1999.
    [Show full text]