Rigged Hilbert Space Theory for Hermitian and Quasi-Hermitian Observables
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Load more
Recommended publications
-
Quantum Errors and Disturbances: Response to Busch, Lahti and Werner
entropy Article Quantum Errors and Disturbances: Response to Busch, Lahti and Werner David Marcus Appleby Centre for Engineered Quantum Systems, School of Physics, The University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia; [email protected]; Tel.: +44-734-210-5857 Academic Editors: Gregg Jaeger and Andrei Khrennikov Received: 27 February 2016; Accepted: 28 April 2016; Published: 6 May 2016 Abstract: Busch, Lahti and Werner (BLW) have recently criticized the operator approach to the description of quantum errors and disturbances. Their criticisms are justified to the extent that the physical meaning of the operator definitions has not hitherto been adequately explained. We rectify that omission. We then examine BLW’s criticisms in the light of our analysis. We argue that, although the BLW approach favour (based on the Wasserstein two-deviation) has its uses, there are important physical situations where an operator approach is preferable. We also discuss the reason why the error-disturbance relation is still giving rise to controversies almost a century after Heisenberg first stated his microscope argument. We argue that the source of the difficulties is the problem of interpretation, which is not so wholly disconnected from experimental practicalities as is sometimes supposed. Keywords: error disturbance principle; uncertainty principle; quantum measurement; Heisenberg PACS: 03.65.Ta 1. Introduction The error-disturbance principle remains highly controversial almost a century after Heisenberg wrote the paper [1], which originally suggested it. It is remarkable that this should be so, since the disagreements concern what is arguably the most fundamental concept of all, not only in physics, but in empirical science generally: namely, the concept of measurement accuracy. -
Math212a1403 the Spectral Theorem for Compact Self-Adjoint Operators
Outline Review of last lecture. The Riesz representation theorem. Bessel's inequality. Self-adjoint transformations. Compact self-adjoint transformations. The spectral theorem for compact self-adjoint operators. Fourier's Fourier series. Math212a1403 The spectral theorem for compact self-adjoint operators. Shlomo Sternberg Sept. 9, 2014 Shlomo Sternberg Math212a1403 The spectral theorem for compact self-adjoint operators. Outline Review of last lecture. The Riesz representation theorem. Bessel's inequality. Self-adjoint transformations. Compact self-adjoint transformations. The spectral theorem for compact self-adjoint operators. Fourier's Fourier series. 1 Review of last lecture. 2 The Riesz representation theorem. 3 Bessel's inequality. 4 Self-adjoint transformations. Non-negative self-adjoint transformations. 5 Compact self-adjoint transformations. 6 The spectral theorem for compact self-adjoint operators. 7 Fourier's Fourier series. Proof by integration by parts. Shlomo Sternberg Math212a1403 The spectral theorem for compact self-adjoint operators. This w is characterized as being the unique element of M which minimizes kv − xk; x 2 M. The idea of the proof was to use the parallelogram law to conclude that if fxng is a sequence of elements of M such that kv − xnk approaches the greatest lower bound of kv − xk; x 2 M then fxng converges to the desired w, The map v 7! w is called orthogonal projection of H onto M and is denoted by πM . Outline Review of last lecture. The Riesz representation theorem. Bessel's inequality. Self-adjoint transformations. Compact self-adjoint transformations. The spectral theorem for compact self-adjoint operators. Fourier's Fourier series. Orthogonal projection onto a complete subspace. -
The Notion of Observable and the Moment Problem for ∗-Algebras and Their GNS Representations
The notion of observable and the moment problem for ∗-algebras and their GNS representations Nicol`oDragoa, Valter Morettib Department of Mathematics, University of Trento, and INFN-TIFPA via Sommarive 14, I-38123 Povo (Trento), Italy. [email protected], [email protected] February, 17, 2020 Abstract We address some usually overlooked issues concerning the use of ∗-algebras in quantum theory and their physical interpretation. If A is a ∗-algebra describing a quantum system and ! : A ! C a state, we focus in particular on the interpretation of !(a) as expectation value for an algebraic observable a = a∗ 2 A, studying the problem of finding a probability n measure reproducing the moments f!(a )gn2N. This problem enjoys a close relation with the selfadjointness of the (in general only symmetric) operator π!(a) in the GNS representation of ! and thus it has important consequences for the interpretation of a as an observable. We n provide physical examples (also from QFT) where the moment problem for f!(a )gn2N does not admit a unique solution. To reduce this ambiguity, we consider the moment problem n ∗ (a) for the sequences f!b(a )gn2N, being b 2 A and !b(·) := !(b · b). Letting µ!b be a n solution of the moment problem for the sequence f!b(a )gn2N, we introduce a consistency (a) relation on the family fµ!b gb2A. We prove a 1-1 correspondence between consistent families (a) fµ!b gb2A and positive operator-valued measures (POVM) associated with the symmetric (a) operator π!(a). In particular there exists a unique consistent family of fµ!b gb2A if and only if π!(a) is maximally symmetric. -
Asymptotic Spectral Measures: Between Quantum Theory and E
Asymptotic Spectral Measures: Between Quantum Theory and E-theory Jody Trout Department of Mathematics Dartmouth College Hanover, NH 03755 Email: [email protected] Abstract— We review the relationship between positive of classical observables to the C∗-algebra of quantum operator-valued measures (POVMs) in quantum measurement observables. See the papers [12]–[14] and theB books [15], C∗ E theory and asymptotic morphisms in the -algebra -theory of [16] for more on the connections between operator algebra Connes and Higson. The theory of asymptotic spectral measures, as introduced by Martinez and Trout [1], is integrally related K-theory, E-theory, and quantization. to positive asymptotic morphisms on locally compact spaces In [1], Martinez and Trout showed that there is a fundamen- via an asymptotic Riesz Representation Theorem. Examples tal quantum-E-theory relationship by introducing the concept and applications to quantum physics, including quantum noise of an asymptotic spectral measure (ASM or asymptotic PVM) models, semiclassical limits, pure spin one-half systems and quantum information processing will also be discussed. A~ ~ :Σ ( ) { } ∈(0,1] →B H I. INTRODUCTION associated to a measurable space (X, Σ). (See Definition 4.1.) In the von Neumann Hilbert space model [2] of quantum Roughly, this is a continuous family of POV-measures which mechanics, quantum observables are modeled as self-adjoint are “asymptotically” projective (or quasiprojective) as ~ 0: → operators on the Hilbert space of states of the quantum system. ′ ′ A~(∆ ∆ ) A~(∆)A~(∆ ) 0 as ~ 0 The Spectral Theorem relates this theoretical view of a quan- ∩ − → → tum observable to the more operational one of a projection- for certain measurable sets ∆, ∆′ Σ. -
A Stepwise Planned Approach to the Solution of Hilbert's Sixth Problem. II: Supmech and Quantum Systems
A Stepwise Planned Approach to the Solution of Hilbert’s Sixth Problem. II : Supmech and Quantum Systems Tulsi Dass Indian Statistical Institute, Delhi Centre, 7, SJS Sansanwal Marg, New Delhi, 110016, India. E-mail: [email protected]; [email protected] Abstract: Supmech, which is noncommutative Hamiltonian mechanics (NHM) (developed in paper I) with two extra ingredients : positive ob- servable valued measures (PObVMs) [which serve to connect state-induced expectation values and classical probabilities] and the ‘CC condition’ [which stipulates that the sets of observables and pure states be mutually separating] is proposed as a universal mechanics potentially covering all physical phe- nomena. It facilitates development of an autonomous formalism for quantum mechanics. Quantum systems, defined algebraically as supmech Hamiltonian systems with non-supercommutative system algebras, are shown to inevitably have Hilbert space based realizations (so as to accommodate rigged Hilbert space based Dirac bra-ket formalism), generally admitting commutative su- perselection rules. Traditional features of quantum mechanics of finite parti- cle systems appear naturally. A treatment of localizability much simpler and more general than the traditional one is given. Treating massive particles as localizable elementary quantum systems, the Schr¨odinger wave functions with traditional Born interpretation appear as natural objects for the descrip- tion of their pure states and the Schr¨odinger equation for them is obtained without ever using a classical Hamiltonian or Lagrangian. A provisional set of axioms for the supmech program is given. arXiv:1002.2061v4 [math-ph] 18 Dec 2010 1 I. Introduction This is the second of a series of papers aimed at obtaining a solution of Hilbert’s sixth problem in the framework of a noncommutative geome- try (NCG) based ‘all-embracing’ scheme of mechanics. -
Riesz-Like Bases in Rigged Hilbert Spaces, in Preparation [14] Bonet, J., Fern´Andez, C., Galbis, A
RIESZ-LIKE BASES IN RIGGED HILBERT SPACES GIORGIA BELLOMONTE AND CAMILLO TRAPANI Abstract. The notions of Bessel sequence, Riesz-Fischer sequence and Riesz basis are generalized to a rigged Hilbert space D[t] ⊂H⊂D×[t×]. A Riesz- like basis, in particular, is obtained by considering a sequence {ξn}⊂D which is mapped by a one-to-one continuous operator T : D[t] → H[k · k] into an orthonormal basis of the central Hilbert space H of the triplet. The operator T is, in general, an unbounded operator in H. If T has a bounded inverse then the rigged Hilbert space is shown to be equivalent to a triplet of Hilbert spaces. 1. Introduction Riesz bases (i.e., sequences of elements ξn of a Hilbert space which are trans- formed into orthonormal bases by some bounded{ } operator withH bounded inverse) often appear as eigenvectors of nonself-adjoint operators. The simplest situation is the following one. Let H be a self-adjoint operator with discrete spectrum defined on a subset D(H) of the Hilbert space . Assume, to be more definite, that each H eigenvalue λn is simple. Then the corresponding eigenvectors en constitute an orthonormal basis of . If X is another operator similar to H,{ i.e.,} there exists a bounded operator T withH bounded inverse T −1 which intertwines X and H, in the sense that T : D(H) D(X) and XT ξ = T Hξ, for every ξ D(H), then, as it is → ∈ easily seen, the vectors ϕn with ϕn = Ten are eigenvectors of X and constitute a Riesz basis for . -
Spectral Theory
SPECTRAL THEORY EVAN JENKINS Abstract. These are notes from two lectures given in MATH 27200, Basic Functional Analysis, at the University of Chicago in March 2010. The proof of the spectral theorem for compact operators comes from [Zim90, Chapter 3]. 1. The Spectral Theorem for Compact Operators The idea of the proof of the spectral theorem for compact self-adjoint operators on a Hilbert space is very similar to the finite-dimensional case. Namely, we first show that an eigenvector exists, and then we show that there is an orthonormal basis of eigenvectors by an inductive argument (in the form of an application of Zorn's lemma). We first recall a few facts about self-adjoint operators. Proposition 1.1. Let V be a Hilbert space, and T : V ! V a bounded, self-adjoint operator. (1) If W ⊂ V is a T -invariant subspace, then W ? is T -invariant. (2) For all v 2 V , hT v; vi 2 R. (3) Let Vλ = fv 2 V j T v = λvg. Then Vλ ? Vµ whenever λ 6= µ. We will need one further technical fact that characterizes the norm of a self-adjoint operator. Lemma 1.2. Let V be a Hilbert space, and T : V ! V a bounded, self-adjoint operator. Then kT k = supfjhT v; vij j kvk = 1g. Proof. Let α = supfjhT v; vij j kvk = 1g. Evidently, α ≤ kT k. We need to show the other direction. Given v 2 V with T v 6= 0, setting w0 = T v=kT vk gives jhT v; w0ij = kT vk. -
Quantum Mechanical Observables Under a Symplectic Transformation
Quantum Mechanical Observables under a Symplectic Transformation of Coordinates Jakub K´aninsk´y1 1Charles University, Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, Institute of Theoretical Physics. E-mail address: [email protected] March 17, 2021 We consider a general symplectic transformation (also known as linear canonical transformation) of quantum-mechanical observables in a quan- tized version of a finite-dimensional system with configuration space iso- morphic to Rq. Using the formalism of rigged Hilbert spaces, we define eigenstates for all the observables. Then we work out the explicit form of the corresponding transformation of these eigenstates. A few examples are included at the end of the paper. 1 Introduction From a mathematical perspective we can view quantum mechanics as a science of finite- dimensional quantum systems, i.e. systems whose classical pre-image has configuration space of finite dimension. The single most important representative from this family is a quantized version of the classical system whose configuration space is isomorphic to Rq with some q N, which corresponds e.g. to the system of finitely many coupled ∈ harmonic oscillators. Classically, the state of such system is given by a point in the arXiv:2007.10858v2 [quant-ph] 16 Mar 2021 phase space, which is a vector space of dimension 2q equipped with the symplectic form. One would typically prefer to work in the abstract setting, without the need to choose any particular set of coordinates: in principle this is possible. In practice though, one will often end up choosing a symplectic basis in the phase space aligned with the given symplectic form and resort to the coordinate description. -
Operators in Rigged Hilbert Spaces: Some Spectral Properties
OPERATORS IN RIGGED HILBERT SPACES: SOME SPECTRAL PROPERTIES GIORGIA BELLOMONTE, SALVATORE DI BELLA, AND CAMILLO TRAPANI Abstract. A notion of resolvent set for an operator acting in a rigged Hilbert space D⊂H⊂D× is proposed. This set depends on a family of intermediate locally convex spaces living between D and D×, called interspaces. Some properties of the resolvent set and of the correspond- ing multivalued resolvent function are derived and some examples are discussed. 1. Introduction Spaces of linear maps acting on a rigged Hilbert space (RHS, for short) × D⊂H⊂D have often been considered in the literature both from a pure mathematical point of view [22, 23, 28, 31] and for their applications to quantum theo- ries (generalized eigenvalues, resonances of Schr¨odinger operators, quantum fields...) [8, 13, 12, 15, 14, 16, 25]. The spaces of test functions and the dis- tributions over them constitute relevant examples of rigged Hilbert spaces and operators acting on them are a fundamental tool in several problems in Analysis (differential operators with singular coefficients, Fourier trans- arXiv:1309.4038v1 [math.FA] 16 Sep 2013 forms) and also provide the basic background for the study of the problem of the multiplication of distributions by the duality method [24, 27, 34]. Before going forth, we fix some notations and basic definitions. Let be a dense linear subspace of Hilbert space and t a locally convex D H topology on , finer than the topology induced by the Hilbert norm. Then D the space of all continuous conjugate linear functionals on [t], i.e., D× D the conjugate dual of [t], is a linear vector space and contains , in the D H sense that can be identified with a subspace of . -
Mathematical Work of Franciszek Hugon Szafraniec and Its Impacts
Tusi Advances in Operator Theory (2020) 5:1297–1313 Mathematical Research https://doi.org/10.1007/s43036-020-00089-z(0123456789().,-volV)(0123456789().,-volV) Group ORIGINAL PAPER Mathematical work of Franciszek Hugon Szafraniec and its impacts 1 2 3 Rau´ l E. Curto • Jean-Pierre Gazeau • Andrzej Horzela • 4 5,6 7 Mohammad Sal Moslehian • Mihai Putinar • Konrad Schmu¨ dgen • 8 9 Henk de Snoo • Jan Stochel Received: 15 May 2020 / Accepted: 19 May 2020 / Published online: 8 June 2020 Ó The Author(s) 2020 Abstract In this essay, we present an overview of some important mathematical works of Professor Franciszek Hugon Szafraniec and a survey of his achievements and influence. Keywords Szafraniec Á Mathematical work Á Biography Mathematics Subject Classification 01A60 Á 01A61 Á 46-03 Á 47-03 1 Biography Professor Franciszek Hugon Szafraniec’s mathematical career began in 1957 when he left his homeland Upper Silesia for Krako´w to enter the Jagiellonian University. At that time he was 17 years old and, surprisingly, mathematics was his last-minute choice. However random this decision may have been, it was a fortunate one: he succeeded in achieving all the academic degrees up to the scientific title of professor in 1980. It turned out his choice to join the university shaped the Krako´w mathematical community. Communicated by Qingxiang Xu. & Jan Stochel [email protected] Extended author information available on the last page of the article 1298 R. E. Curto et al. Professor Franciszek H. Szafraniec Krako´w beyond Warsaw and Lwo´w belonged to the famous Polish School of Mathematics in the prewar period. -
ASYMPTOTICALLY ISOSPECTRAL QUANTUM GRAPHS and TRIGONOMETRIC POLYNOMIALS. Pavel Kurasov, Rune Suhr
ISSN: 1401-5617 ASYMPTOTICALLY ISOSPECTRAL QUANTUM GRAPHS AND TRIGONOMETRIC POLYNOMIALS. Pavel Kurasov, Rune Suhr Research Reports in Mathematics Number 2, 2018 Department of Mathematics Stockholm University Electronic version of this document is available at http://www.math.su.se/reports/2018/2 Date of publication: Maj 16, 2018. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification: Primary 34L25, 81U40; Secondary 35P25, 81V99. Keywords: Quantum graphs, almost periodic functions. Postal address: Department of Mathematics Stockholm University S-106 91 Stockholm Sweden Electronic addresses: http://www.math.su.se/ [email protected] Asymptotically isospectral quantum graphs and generalised trigonometric polynomials Pavel Kurasov and Rune Suhr Dept. of Mathematics, Stockholm Univ., 106 91 Stockholm, SWEDEN [email protected], [email protected] Abstract The theory of almost periodic functions is used to investigate spectral prop- erties of Schr¨odinger operators on metric graphs, also known as quantum graphs. In particular we prove that two Schr¨odingeroperators may have asymptotically close spectra if and only if the corresponding reference Lapla- cians are isospectral. Our result implies that a Schr¨odingeroperator is isospectral to the standard Laplacian on a may be different metric graph only if the potential is identically equal to zero. Keywords: Quantum graphs, almost periodic functions 2000 MSC: 34L15, 35R30, 81Q10 Introduction. The current paper is devoted to the spectral theory of quantum graphs, more precisely to the direct and inverse spectral theory of Schr¨odingerop- erators on metric graphs [3, 20, 24]. Such operators are defined by three parameters: a finite compact metric graph Γ; • a real integrable potential q L (Γ); • ∈ 1 vertex conditions, which can be parametrised by unitary matrices S. -
A Nonstandard Proof of the Spectral Theorem for Unbounded Self-Adjoint
A NONSTANDARD PROOF OF THE SPECTRAL THEOREM FOR UNBOUNDED SELF-ADJOINT OPERATORS ISAAC GOLDBRING Abstract. We generalize Moore’s nonstandard proof of the Spectral theorem for bounded self-adjoint operators to the case of unbounded operators. The key step is to use a definition of the nonstandard hull of an internally bounded self-adjoint operator due to Raab. 1. Introduction Throughout this note, all Hilbert spaces will be over the complex numbers and (following the convention in physics) inner products are conjugate-linear in the first coordinate. The goal of this note is to provide a nonstandard proof of the Spectral theorem for unbounded self-adjoint operators: Theorem 1.1. Suppose that A is an unbounded self-adjoint operator on the Hilbert space H. Then there is a projection-valued measure P : Borel(R) B(H) such that A = id dP. → ZR Here, Borel(R) denotes the σ-algebra of Borel subsets of R and id denotes the identity function on R. All of the terms appearing in the previous theorem will arXiv:2104.01949v1 [math.FA] 5 Apr 2021 be defined precisely in the next section. We refer to the expression A = R id dP as a spectral resolution of A. Thus, the theorem says that every unboundedR self-adjoint operator admits a spectral resolution. In fact, this spectral resolu- tion is unique (that is, the projection-valued measure yielding the resolution is unique), although we will not address the uniqueness issue here. The Spectral theorem for unbounded operators is especially important in quantum mechan- ics, for it provides one with the probability distributions for measuring observ- ables with continuous spectra such as position and momentum.