Arxiv:2102.13124V1 [Math.GT] 25 Feb 2021

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Load more

SHEAR-SHAPE COCYCLES FOR MEASURED LAMINATIONS AND ERGODIC THEORY OF THE EARTHQUAKE FLOW AARON CALDERON AND JAMES FARRE Abstract. We extend Mirzakhani's conjugacy between the earthquake and horocycle flows to a bijection, demonstrating conjugacies between these flows on all strata and exhibiting an abundance of new ergodic measures for the earthquake flow. The structure of our map indicates a natural extension of the earthquake flow to an action of the the upper-triangular subgroup P < SL2R and we classify the ergodic measures for this action as pullbacks of affine measures on the bundle of quadratic differentials. Our main tool is a generalization of the shear coordinates of Bonahon and Thurston to arbitrary measured laminations. 1. Main results 1.1. Conjugating earthquake and horocycle flow. This paper deals with two notions of unipotent flow over the moduli space Mg of Riemann surfaces. The first is the Teichm¨uller horocycle flow, defined on the 1 bundle Q Mg of unit area quadratic differentials q by postcomposing the charts of the flat metric jqj by the 1 s parabolic transformation 0 1 . This flow is ergodic with respect to a finite measure induced by Lebesgue in local period coordinates [Mas82, Vee82] and is a fundamental object of study in Teichm¨ullerdynamics. 1 The second is the earthquake flow on the bundle P Mg, whose fiber is the sphere of unit-length measured geodesic laminations on a hyperbolic surface. The earthquake flow is defined as a generalization of twisting about simple closed curves, or by postcomposing hyperbolic charts by certain piecewise-isometric transfor- mations. While this flow is more mysterious, earthquakes are a familiar tool in Teichm¨ullertheory, playing a central role in Kerckhoff's proof of the Nielsen realization conjecture [Ker83], for example. These two flows are both assembled from families of Hamiltonian flows (extremal length for horocycle [Pap86] and hyperbolic length for earthquake [Ker83, Wol83, SB01]) and exhibit similar non-divergence properties [MW02], but the horocycle flow belongs properly to the flat-geometric viewpoint and the earth- quake flow to the hyperbolic one. All the same, in [Mir08, Theorem 1.1] Mirzakhani established a bridge between the two worlds, demonstrating a measurable conjugacy between the earthquake and horocycle flows. 1 Consequently, the earthquake flow is ergodic with respect to the measure class of Lebesgue on P Mg. In this article, we deepen this connection between flat and hyperbolic geometry, proving that the corre- spondence can be further upgraded to yield new results on both the ergodic theory of the earthquake flow and the structure of Teichm¨ullerspace. Theorem A. Mirzakhani's conjugacy extends to a bijection 1 1 O : P Mg $ Q Mg that conjugates earthquake flow to horocycle flow. 1 The moduli space of quadratic differentials is naturally partitioned into strata Q Mg(κ), disjoint subsets parametrizing unit-area differentials with zeros of order κ = (κ1; : : : ; κn). Similarly, for any κ we may 1 reg define the regular locus P Mg (κ) to be the set of (X; λ) where λ cuts X into regular ideal polygons with (κ1 + 2; : : : ; κn + 2) many sides. With this notation, Mirzakhani's conjugacy can more precisely be stated as the existence of a bijection arXiv:2102.13124v1 [math.GT] 25 Feb 2021 1 reg 4g−4 1 nsc 4g−4 P Mg (1 ) $ Q Mg (1 ) taking earthquake flow to horocycle flow, where the superscript nsc specifies the (full-measure) sublocus of the stratum consisting of those differentials with no horizontal saddle connections. One of our main applications of Theorem A is to produce an analogue of Mirzakhani's conjugacy for components of strata (even those coming from global squares of Abelian differentials), confirming a conjecture of Alex Wright [Wri18, Remark 5.6] (see also [Wri20, Problems 12.5 and 12.6]). Theorem B. For every κ, the map O restricts to a bijection 1 reg 1 nsc P Mg (κ) $ Q Mg (κ) that takes earthquake to horocycle flow and (generalized) stretch rays to Teichm¨ullergeodesics. Date: March 1, 2021. 1 2 AARON CALDERON AND JAMES FARRE While strata of holomorphic quadratic differentials are generally not connected, for g 6= 4 their connected components are classified by whether or not they consist of squares of abelian differentials and the parity of the induced spin structure (both of which depend only on the horizontal foliation when there are no horizontal saddles), as well as hyperellipticity [KZ03, Lan08]. 1 The bijection O respects both the horizontal direction and the Mod(S) action, so Theorem B can be refined to describe the preimages of these components. As an immediate consequence of Theorem B, the earthquake flow is ergodic with respect to the pushfor- ward by O−1 of the Masur-Veech measure on any component of any stratum of quadratic differentials. 1.2. Geodesic flows and P -invariant measures. Pulling back the Teichm¨ullergeodesic flow via O allows us to specify a family of \dilation rays" which serve as a geodesic flow for the earthquake flow's parabolic action and in many cases project to geodesics for Thurston's Lipschitz asymmetric metric. Combining dilation rays and the earthquake flow therefore gives a action of the upper triangular subgroup P < SL2R 1 on P Mg by \stretchquakes." See Section 15.3. 1 Due in part to the failure of O to be continuous, the stretchquake action on P Mg is not by homeomor- phisms but rather by measurable bijections. More precisely, it preserves the σ-algebra obtained by pulling back the Borel σ-algebra of Q1M(S) along O. In a forthcoming sequel [CF], the authors show that O is 1 actually a measurable isomorphism with respect to the Borel σ-algebra on P Mg and that the stretchquake 1 reg action restricted to each P Mg (κ) is by homeomorphisms; see also Remark 2.2. In their foundational work on SL2R-invariant ergodic measures on the moduli space of flat surfaces, Eskin 1 and Mirzakhani [EM18, Theorem 1.4] proved that the support of any P -invariant ergodic measure on Q Mg is locally an affine manifold cut out by linear equations in period coordinates. Our conjugacy translates this classification into a classification of ergodic measures for the extension of the earthquake flow defined above: Theorem C. Every stretchquake-invariant ergodic measure is the pullback of an affine measure. 1 Proof. If ν is a stretchquake-invariant ergodic measure on P Mg, then O∗ν is a P -invariant ergodic measure 1 on Q Mg, which is affine by [EM18, Theorem 1.4]. Using this correspondence we obtain a geometric rigidity phenomenon for stretchquake-invariant ergodic 1 measures on P Mg: the generic point is made out of a fixed collection of regular ideal polygons. 1 Corollary 1.1. For any stretchquake-invariant ergodic probability measure ν on P Mg, there is some κ so 1 reg that ν-almost every (X; λ) lies in P Mg (κ). This in particular implies that the dynamics of the stretchquake action with respect to any ergodic probability measure are measurably the same as its restriction to a stratum, on which we can identify dilation rays as (directed, unit-speed) geodesics for the Lipschitz asymmetric metric on T (S) (see Proposition 15.12). Remark 1.2. We note that general ergodic measures for the stretchquake action can look quite different 1 than the Lebesgue measure class on P Mg, even when pushed down to Mg. 1 reg For example, if ν gives full measure to P Mg (4g − 4) then a ν-generic point is obtained by gluing together a single regular ideal (4g − 2)-gon; in particular, the injectivity radius at the center of the polygon 1 can be arbitrarily large, allowing g ! 1. This implies that ν gives zero mass to (the restriction of P Mg to) sufficiently thin parts of moduli space, as any (X; λ) where X has a very short pants decomposition has injectivity radius uniformly bounded above. 1 Remark 1.3. While an important result of [EM18] is that any P -invariant ergodic measure on Q Mg is 1 actually SL2R-invariant, the circle action on Q Mg (corresponding to rotating a quadratic differential) does 1 not have an obvious geometric interpretation on P Mg. See also [Wri20, Problems 12.3 and 12.4] 1.3. Dual foliations from hyperbolic structures. A foundational result of Gardiner and Masur (The- orem 2.1 below) states that quadratic differentials are parametrized by their real and imaginary parts; equivalently, their vertical and horizontal foliations (or laminations). In particular, the set F uu(λ) of all quadratic differentials with horizontal lamination λ is the same as the space MF(λ) of foliations that bind together with λ. As the horocycle flow preserves the horizontal foliation, it induces a flow on MF(λ). Mirzakhani's conjugacy and our extension therefore both follow from the construction of flow-equivariant maps that assign to a hyperbolic surface X and a measured lamination λ a \dual" measured foliation. 1In genus 4, there are certain strata whose components have only been characterized via algebraic geometry [CM14]. SHEAR-SHAPE COCYCLES FOR MEASURED LAMINATIONS 3 For maximal laminations λ, this dual is the horocyclic foliation Fλ(X) introduced by Thurston [Thu98], obtained by foliating the spikes of each triangle of X n λ by horocycles and extending across the leaves of λ. The measure of an arc transverse to Fλ(X) is then the total distance along λ between horocycles meeting the arc at endpoints. As Fλ(X) necessarily binds S together with λ, this defines a map Fλ : T (S) ! MF(λ); where MF(λ) is the space of measured foliations that bind together with λ.
Recommended publications
  • On the Geometry of the Thurston Metric on Teichmüller Spaces: Geodesics That Disobey an Analogue of Masur’S Criterion

    On the Geometry of the Thurston Metric on Teichmüller Spaces: Geodesics That Disobey an Analogue of Masur’S Criterion

    On the geometry of the Thurston metric on Teichmüller spaces: geodesics that disobey an analogue of Masur’s criterion. by Ivan Telpukhovskiy A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Department of Mathematics University of Toronto © Copyright 2021 by Ivan Telpukhovskiy On the geometry of the Thurston metric on Teichmüller spaces: geodesics that disobey an analogue of Masur’s criterion. Ivan Telpukhovskiy Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Department of Mathematics University of Toronto 2021 Abstract We construct a counterexample for an analogue of Masur’s criterion in the setting of Teichmüller space with the Thurston metric. For that, we find a minimal, filling, non-uniquely ergodic lamination λ on the seven-times punctured sphere with uni- formly bounded annular projection distances. Then we show that a geodesic in the corresponding Teichmüller space that converges to λ, stays in the thick part for the whole time. ii iii Dedication iv Acknowledgments Acknowledgements v Contents 1 Introduction1 2 Background4 2.0.1 Notation..............................4 2.0.2 Curves and markings........................4 2.0.3 Curve graph............................5 2.0.4 Measured laminations and measured foliations..........5 2.0.5 Teichmüller space and Thurston boundary............6 2.0.6 The action of the mapping class group on the Thurston boundary.6 2.0.7 Subsurface projections.......................7 2.0.8 Relative twisting..........................9 2.0.9 Thurston metric on Teichmüller space..............9 2.0.10 Twisting parameter along a Thurston geodesic......... 10 3 Exposition on “Minimal stretch maps between hyperbolic surfaces” 11 3.0.1 Introduction...........................
  • A Translation-Invariant "Almost Every" on Infinite Dimensional Spaces

    A Translation-Invariant "Almost Every" on Infinite Dimensional Spaces

    BULLETIN(New Series) OF THE AMERICANMATHEMATICAL SOCIETY Volume 27, Number 2, October 1992 PREVALENCE: A TRANSLATION-INVARIANT"ALMOST EVERY" ON INFINITE-DIMENSIONAL SPACES BRIAN R. HUNT, TIM SAUER, AND JAMES A. YORKE Abstract. We present a measure-theoretic condition for a property to hold "almost everywhere" on an infinite-dimensional vector space, with particular emphasis on function spaces such as Ck and LP . Like the concept of "Lebesgue almost every" on finite-dimensional spaces, our notion of "preva- lence" is translation invariant. Instead of using a specific measure on the entire space, we define prevalence in terms of the class of all probability measures with compact support. Prevalence is a more appropriate condition than the topological concepts of "open and dense" or "generic" when one desires a prob- abilistic result on the likelihood of a given property on a function space. We give several examples of properties which hold "almost everywhere" in the sense of prevalence. For instance, we prove that almost every C1 map on R" has the property that all of its periodic orbits are hyperbolic. 1. Introduction Under what conditions should it be said that a given property on an infinite- dimensional vector space is virtually certain to hold? For example, how are statements of the following type made mathematically precise? (1) Almost every function /: [0, 1] —►R in Ll satisfies /J f(x)dx ^ 0. (2) Almost every sequence {a,}^ in I2 has the property that ]T°^i a¡ di- verges. (3) Almost every C1 function /:R-»R has the property that f'(x) ^ 0 whenever f(x) = 0.
  • Measure-Theoretic Notions of Prevalence

    Measure-Theoretic Notions of Prevalence

    Measure-theoretic notions of prevalence Hongjian Shi B. Sc., Henan Normal University, China, 1984 M. Sc., Simon Fraser University, Canada, 1995 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOROF PHEOSOPHY in the Department of Mathematics and Statistics @ Hongjian Shi 1997 SIMON FRASER UNIVEXSITY October 1997 AU rights reserved. This work may not be reproduced in whole or in part, by photocopy or other means, without the permission of the author. National Library Bibliothèque nationale 1*1 OfCrna* du Canada Acquisiüons and Acquisiins et Bibliographie Senrices services bibliographiques 395 WelIington Street 395. rue Wdlingm Ottawa ON K1A ON4 Cntawa ON KlA ON4 canada canada The author has granted a non- L'auteur a accordé une licence non exclusive licence allowing the exclusive permettant a la National Library of Canada to Bibliothèque nationale du Canada de reproduce, loan, distriiute or sell reproduire, prêter, distriibuer ou copies of this thesis in microform, vendre des copies de cette thèse sous paper or electronic formats. la forme de microfichelfilm, de reproduction sur papier ou sur format électronique. The author retains ownership of the L'auteur conserve la propriété du copyright in this thesis. Neither the droit d'auteur qui protège cette thèse. thesis nor substantial extracts fiom it Ni la thèse ni des extraits substantiels may be printed or otherwise de celle-ci ne doivent être imprimés reproduced without the author' s ou autrement reproduits sans son permission. autorisation. Abstract Haar null sets (or shy sets) play an important role in studying properties of function spaces. In this thesis the concepts of transverse measures, left shy sets and right shy sets are studied in general Polish groups, and the basic theory for the left shy sets and right shy sets is established.
  • Laminations with Transverse Structurer

    Laminations with Transverse Structurer

    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk Topology Vol. 38, No. 1, pp. 141Ð165,brought 1999 to you by CORE ( 1998 Elsevier Science Ltd All rights reserved. Printedprovided in Great by BritainElsevier - Publisher Connector 0040-9383/99 $19.00#0.00 PII: S0040-9383(98)00007-X LAMINATIONS WITH TRANSVERSE STRUCTUREs A. CANDEL (Received 18 August 1996; in revised form 20 January 1998) 1. INTRODUCTION In this paper we study laminations by surfaces of three-dimensional manifolds and some of their properties. These are very interesting objects, particularly useful in understanding the topology of the manifold which has no incompressible surface. Gabai and Oertel have shown in [9] that many familiar properties of su¦ciently large three manifolds continue to hold in the more general setting of ‘laminated’ manifolds. A lamination of a three manifold has associated with it certain transverse structure, roughly the action of the fundamental group of the ambient manifold on the space of leaves of the lamination lifted to the universal cover. This space of leaves can be improved to a tree- like object [9, 17]. In a few words, one starts with a lamination of M, having nowhere dense support (and some other properties to be made precise later), and passes to the universal cover and a tree is constructed by taking one point for each gap or non-boundary leaf of the lamination. The action of the fundamental group of M permutes the leaves and the gaps of the lamination, so it induces an action on the tree. If the lamination has an invariant transverse measure, as is the case of laminations of surfaces, the tree has a metric which is left invariant by the action of the fundamental group of the ambient manifold.