DOCSLIB.ORG

A Case Study of Environmental Justice and Learning for Biodiversity Conservation

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
A Case Study of Environmental Justice and Learning for Biodiversity Conservation Protected Area Planning and Management in the Kullu District of Himachal Pradesh, India: A case study of environmental justice and learning for biodiversity conservation by Ariane Dilay A Thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate Studies of The University of Manitoba In partial fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of MASTER OF NATURAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT Clayton H. Riddell Faculty of Environment, Earth, and Resources Natural Resources Institute University of Manitoba Winnipeg Copyright © 2020 Ariane Dilay ABSTRACT While Protected Areas (PAs) are essential for the preservation of biodiversity, conservation efforts should not impose injustices onto local communities. Using a qualitative case study that included document review, semi-structured interviews, participant observation and thematic analysis, the planning and management of a network of PAs in the Kullu District of Himachal Pradesh, India were examined. The study 1) describes the planning and management approach for PAs in Kullu, 2) explains how the planning and management approach has changed since the declaration of the first national park in 1984, 3) evaluates the integration of the four attributes of environmental justice (distributive, procedural, recognitional and restorative) in PA planning and management, and 4) identifies learning outcomes for those involved in or affected by PAs in the Kullu District and relates such outcomes to environmental justice. Overall, the data reveal that the planning and management of PAs in Kullu operates under an Exclusive Model that restricts local people from accessing and utilizing natural resources within PAs, while also excluding them from participating in planning and management activities. In terms of environmental justice, the data show that there is an uneven distribution of benefits from PAs and inequitable restrictions on resource use, a lack of early and ongoing consultation with locally affected communities, and uneven and inadequate compensation for loss of traditional rights. One important learning outcome identified by forest officers is a movement away from the practice of forced displacement of people. Although this suggests a transition toward a more inclusive model, much work remains to advance environmental justice in PA planning and management in the Kullu District. The data also indicate that inclusivity and advancement of environmental justice in PA planning and management could be achieved through: collaborative knowledge exchange between forest officers and community members; opportunities for community members to participate in planning and management activities; and the recognition of marginalized members of society in PA planning. ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS First, I would like to thank all of my research participants who took the time to share their invaluable knowledge and experiences with me. Thank you to Mehru Thakur for being my guide, interpreter and friend in the field and for your kindness and patience with me. I am beyond grateful to Mehru, Nisha, Siya and Shivam for welcoming me into their home and for providing me with the kindest hospitality. I look forward to the next time we can enjoy some dahl and subji together. My sincerest thanks are extended to my advisor and mentor, Dr. John Sinclair, for the unwavering support and guidance throughout my time as a master’s student. This research would not have been possible without your wealth of knowledge and expertise, your teachings on qualitative research and the Kullu valley and your connections in Kullu. Dr. Alan Diduck, I will be forever grateful for your support over the last few years and for introducing me to the topic of environmental justice and to India. I’m not sure where I would be today if you and Kirit hadn’t accepted me into your research project in 2017, so for that I am eternally grateful. Thank you to Dr. Jim Gardner for sharing your breadth of knowledge with me about the Kullu District and for providing critical insight throughout the research. I am truly honoured to have had the opportunity to learn from the three of you over the last two years. Thank you to the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council and the University of Manitoba for providing the funding that allowed me to go to India and conduct this research. To my best friends with whom I have shared so many laughs, adventures and endless conversations over the years, thank you for all of your encouraging words and listening ears. To my NRI friends, you have made this an unforgettable journey and I feel incredibly lucky to have started the program when I did. Finally, my deepest gratitude goes to my family. I will be forever indebted to my parents for providing me with the opportunities and experiences that have shaped who I am and to my sister for being the most inspiring role model. Your love and support is worth more than I can express on paper. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter 1: Introduction .......................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Background ......................................................................................................................... 1 1.2 Purpose and objectives ........................................................................................................ 3 1.3 Summary of methods ........................................................................................................... 4 1.4 Significance of the study ..................................................................................................... 5 1.5 Organization of the thesis .................................................................................................... 6 Chapter 2: Protected Areas, Environmental Justice and Learning .......................................... 7 2.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 7 2.2 Protected Areas .......................................................................................................................... 8 2.2.1 History of PAs ............................................................................................................................................ 8 2.2.2 History of PAs in India ............................................................................................................................. 10 2.2.3 Planning and management frameworks of PAs ........................................................................................ 12 2.2.4 Conflicts in PAs ........................................................................................................................................ 14 2.3 Environmental Justice ............................................................................................................. 15 2.3.1 Environmental Justice framework ............................................................................................................ 15 2.3.2 Environmental justice in PAs ................................................................................................................... 17 2.4 Learning for NREM ................................................................................................................ 19 2.4.1 Learning concepts .................................................................................................................................... 19 2.4.2 Learning for NREM .................................................................................................................................. 20 2.4.3 Learning for biodiversity conservation .................................................................................................... 22 2.4.4 Learning for environmental justice .......................................................................................................... 23 2.5 Conceptual framework and chapter summary .......................................................................... 23 Chapter 3: Research Design and Methods ............................................................................ 27 3.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 27 3.2. Study Area .............................................................................................................................. 28 3.3 Social constructivist and transformative paradigms .................................................................. 31 3.4 Qualitative research approach ................................................................................................. 33 3.5 Case study strategy ................................................................................................................... 33 3.5.1 Case study: Network of PAs in the Kullu District .................................................................................... 34 3.6 Data collection and sampling procedures ................................................................................. 35 3.6.1 Document review ...................................................................................................................................... 36 3.7 Field Research ......................................................................................................................... 36 3.7.1 Semi-structured interviews ......................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Himachal Pradesh | Punjab
    PUNJAB HIMACHAL PRADESH Himalayas & North India +91 890 100 4567 | opulentroutes.com Welcome to Himachal Pradesh Unforgettable Himachal Table of Content The Story 1 Himachal Pradesh 2 Luxury Stays 5 - 18 Shimla - The Capital 19 - 20 Dharamshala 21 - 22 Lahaul & Spiti Valley 23 - 24 Amritsar - Punjab 25 - 26 Explore 27 - 44 Experiences 47 - 62 Fairs & Festivals 65 - 66 Activities 67 - 74 General Information 76 Luxury Journeys 79 - 84 Wedding & Events 87 - 88 Hola Mohalla Festival 89 - 90 Cricket in Dharamshala 93 - 94 Farm Stays in Punjab 95 - 96 Sanyog Gupta Voyages Luxury Destination Management Company As we have evolved as a company, we have come to realise that our love lies not in booking tour packages, but in showcasing the unique experiences across the nations we serve. We realised that there are many secret corners of our world, rare moments, mysteries and stories. Our company owned by a family, but run professionally. We have hierarchical systems which are driven by our core family values. We have come to understand we do not want to be the largest company globally. We have never tried to be the richest or the most influential. I say, we just want to be the bestest in what we do. We are a family tradition for over three decades that have been highlighting this part of the planet. All over Indian sub-continent, we have grown to become a popular, valued and autonomous DMC providing the finest cultural experiences, personal immersions and natural wonders. We are here to build stories for our clients, tales of love, of wonderful excitement.
    [Show full text]
  • International Journal of Multidisciplinary Approach and Studies Analyzing Resource Potential for Nature Based Tourism
    International Journal of Multidisciplinary Approach and Studies ISSN NO:: 2348 – 537X Analyzing Resource Potential for Nature Based Tourism: A Case Study of the State of Himachal Pradesh (India) Punit Gautam Associate Professor, Department of Tourism and Hotel Management, North-Eastern Hill University, Shillong, Meghalaya (India) ―Potential‖ broadly insinuates something promising but not yet (fully) exploited; it symbolizes the sum total of qualitative and quantitative values of the given resources on which the degree and extent of its exploitability depends (Kandari, 1984). In the context of tourism, assessing the resource potential in quantitative terms is highly complex process, if not impossible, as it involves the physical, psychological and spiritual demands on the people belonging to diverse geographical, socio-cultural and economic backgrounds who travel under different motives, interests, preferences and immediate needs. To quote Kandari (1984), ―potential for tourism development in any area depends on the availability of recreational resources in addition to the factors like climate, seasons, accessibility, proximity to market, political stability, state of economy and general infrastructure, quality of natural environment, attitude of the local people, travel trade entrepreneurs and tourism planners, the existing tourist plant facilities and the degree to which they can be further developed within the prevailing limitations of natural, cultural and financial environments. Healthy combination of all those and many other factors
    [Show full text]
  • Himachal Pradesh State Roads Project Phase 1 (Package 1)
    E1 540 L-,U V5 -~ . .F Public Disclosure Authorized ,ib Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Th Lous Bew G;^u - mI- II Public Disclosure Authorized I =U I I I I '' I I (Published in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part-lI, and Section 3, Sub-section (ii) MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT AND FORESTS New Delhi 14 'h September, 2006 Notification S.O. 1533 Whereas, a draft notification under sub-rule (3) of Rule 5 of the Environment (Protection) Rules, 1986 for imposing certain restrictions and prohibitions on new projects or activities, or on the expansion or modernization of existing projects or activities based on their potential environmental impacts as indicated in the Schedule to the notification, being undertaken in any part of India', unless prior environmental clearance has been accorded in accordance with the objectives of National Environment Policy as approved by the Union Cabinet on 18th May, 2006 and the procedure specified in the notification, by the Central Government or the State or Union territory Level Environment Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA), to be constituted by the Central Govemment in consultation with the State Government or the Union territory Administration concerned under sub-section (3) of section 3 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 for the purpose of this notification, was published in the Gazette of India ,Extraordinary, Part II, section 3, sub-section (ii) vide number S.O. 1324 (E) dated the 15 1hSeptember ,2005 inviting objections and suggestions from all persons likely to be
    [Show full text]
  • World Bank Document
    t' E1 540 t i St k Public Disclosure Authorized vi <S Public Disclosure Authorized t,.O- L ' t-v+; ^X>s _ _ _- Public Disclosure Authorized J! 1hAt +; So MSOONUM| '.~Et&wfS an q-4a p' 1s 4 -- S Public Disclosure Authorized AThelol Rsmrej Himachal Pradesh State Roads Project Environmental screening Report Table Contents EXECUTIVE SUMMARY CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION ............................................. 1.1 Introduction ................................................ 1 1.2 The project 1 ................................................ 1 1.3 objectives of the project ....................................... 1.3.1 General 2 ............................................... 2 1.4 Phasing of the project ......................................... 1.5 Environmental 2 Screening study .................................. 3 1.6 Studies carried out so far .............................................. 1.6.1 Strategic 4 Option Studies (SOS) ............................... 4 1.6.2 Feasibility Study .............................................. 1.6.3 Environmental 4 screening and scoping studies ..................... 5 1.7 Document Organisation ........................................... 5 CHAPTER 2: APPLICABLE LEGAL AND POLICIES ISSUES AND INSTITUTIONAL REQUIREMENTS .......................................... ............. 2.1 applicable Regulations 7 ........................................ 7 2.1.1 ENVIRONMENT ......................................... 2.1.2 7 EIA DOCUMENTATION & Environmental clearances (EC) ............ 2.1.3 Applicable 8 national
    [Show full text]
  • Conserving Protected Areas and Wildlife
    Enviro Legal Defence Firm The Enviro Legal Defence Firm (ELDF), India’s first environmental law firm established in 1999 aims at mainstreaming natural resource law, resolving conflicts over resources and strengthening environmental jurisprudence. CONSERVING PROTECTED AREAS Specifically, ELDF represents individuals and organizations in courts and before administrative agencies in cases that would have significant impact in protecting environment, resources and ecosystems and establish important precedents in case law; provides consultancy based research and training on CONSERVING PROTECTED AREAS natural resources law that can be used by others to protect both urban and rural environment; AND WILDLIFE AND WILDLIFE WWF-India World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) is one of the world’s largest and most respected independent conservation organizations. Its mission is to stop the degradation of the planet’s natural environment, which it addresses through its work in biodiversity conservation and reduction of humanity’s ecological footprint. It has been working on these issues in India for over four decades now. A JUDICIAL JOURNEY Contact Information: WWF-India Enviro Legal Defence Firm 172 B, Lodhi Estate 278, Sector 15-A, NOIDA-201301 New Delhi 110003, India Uttar Pradesh, India Phone: +91 11 41504775 Phone: +91-120-2517248 Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected], [email protected] A JUDICIAL JOURNEY CONSERVING PROTECTED AREAS AND WILDLIFE A JUDICIAL JOURNEY for a living planet ® Contact Information: Enviro Legal Defence Firm 278, Sector 15-A NOIDA-201301 Uttar Pradesh, India Phone: +91-120-2517248 Email: [email protected], [email protected] WWF India 172 B, Lodhi Estate New Delhi 110003 India Phone: +91 11 41504775 Email: [email protected] Citation: ELDF and WWF India 2009, Conserving Protected Areas and Wildlife: A judicial journey.
    [Show full text]