HINDUSTAN TIMES, NEW 12 hindustantimes SATURDAY, SEPTEMBER 07, 2019 htnation Unnao survivor to record Ex-Assam CM writes to CJI on NRC HT Correspondents Now the question Supreme Court was not the n [email protected] implementing authority but the ›arises about the fates fact is that the Government of GUWAHATI/KOLKATA: Former India was the implementing Assam chief minister and senior of several lakh people who authority. In my view, it is noth- her statement at AIIMS Congress leader Tarun Gogoi ing but a total failure of the Gov- have been left out... due to has written to CJI Ranjan Gogoi, ernment of India,” he said. alleging that National Register the inefficiency of the NRC Chandra Mohan Patowary, DIRECTIONS Delhi HC allows holding court at hospital; SC gives CBI more time for accident probe of Citizens state coordinator senior cabinet minister and Prateek Hajela did not dis- authority spokesperson of the Assam gov- HT Correspondent Central Bureau of Investigation charge his duty efficiently while TARUN GOGOI, Ex-Assam CM ernment, too, could not be

n [email protected] (CBI) on Friday two more weeks preparing the final list pub- reached for a comment despite to complete its probe in the road lished last week, and requested several attempts. : The Delhi high court on accident case, and to file its final him to review the matter. crore was spent at the cost of voters’ lists of both 1966 and In West Bengal, chief minis- Friday approved the recording of investigation report (charge NRC in Assam was updated development work of the state. 2019. March 24, 1971, is the cut- ter Mamata Banerjee said on statement of a rape survivor at sheet) in the gang rape case under the monitoring of the “Now the question arises off date for making a legitimate Friday that the Trinamool Con- the trauma centre of All India lodged by her mother. Supreme Court and the final about the fates of several lakh claim to Indian citizenship. gress government will not allow Institute of Medical Science A bench led by Justice Deepak list, which validates bonafide people who have been left out of The final NRC has been implementation of NRC in the (AIIMS) by special judge Dhar- Gupta also gave more time to the Indian citizens of the state, the NRC and have to move to rejected by all political parties, state. mesh Sharma, who is conducting trial judge, who is to hear and excluded over 1.9 million appli- Foreigners Tribunals to prove social organisations and intel- The implementation of the trial in the case. decide all Unnao-related cases. cants. The final NRC list was their citizenship and face har- lectuals of the state, Tarun NRC is nothing but a political A notification to this effect was According to an earlier order, the published on August 31. assment, not due to their faults Gogoi said. vendetta of the Bharatiya Jan- issued by the Delhi HC late in the trial in all related had to conclude In the letter to the Cheif Jus- but due to the callousness and “The state government also, ata Party-led central govern- evening. in 45 days. But in his status report tice of India, Gogoi alleged that inefficiency of the NRC author- if I am not wrong, is trying to ment, she told the assembly. It said that chief justice DN given to the top court in a sealed Hajela did not follow the direc- ity,” he said. blame the Supreme Court as “This (NRC implementation) Patel and judges of the high court cover, the trial court judge has tion of the apex court although The three-time Congress they have been making allega- is nothing but an attempt to ordered that “Special Judge asked for a separate deadline for over 50,000 government officials chief minister said a number of tions that they had their limita- divert the attention of the people Dharmesh Sharma shall hold each case. were engaged in the NRC upda- people were excluded though tion due to interference of the from the ongoing economic cri- court for recording the testimony The bench also deferred the tion job and around Rs 1,200 their names were there in the Supreme Court while the sis in the country,” she said of the victim in the premises/ n People protest in front of India Gate for the Unnao rape victim in cross-examination of witnesses building of trauma centre of New Delhi on July 29, 2019. BURHAAN KINU/HT FILE in the rape case till CBI files its AIIMS in addition to the Tis charge sheet in the gang rape M A L A N K A R A CHURCH CASE Hazari District Court Complex decide on setting up a temporary The top court , on August 1, case. This was done after the AFTER NEW FIR, Goa swimming during trial of the cases”. court at AIIMS for recording the transferred all cases related to counsel for the accused said he The rape survivor is admitted statement of the Unnao rape sur- the matter from Uttar Pradesh to wanted to confront the prosecu- SC rebukes Kerala HC in AIIMS after she sustained inju- vivor. the court of District Judge Dhar- tion witnesses in the rape case, AJIT JOGI GETS coach, accused of ries during a road accident in The direction came after the mesh Shama in Tis Hazari, New and this will only be possible only which MLA Kuldeep Singh Sen- top court took note of a status Delhi. when the charge sheet is filed. HOSPITALISED judge over ‘indiscipline’ molestation, held gar, who was expelled from the report filed by a trial court judge Expelled BJP legislator Kul- The bench also clarified that it Bharatiya Janata Party, is an requesting to set up a court in deep Singh Sengar, who repre- will be up to the trial judge to RAIPUR: Janata Congress Chhat- HT Correspondent THE TOP COURT SET Gerard de Souza accused. AIIMS. sents Bangarmau in the Uttar decide if such confrontation of tisgarh president and former n [email protected] n [email protected] She was air-lifted from Luc- The rape survivor, a resident Pradesh assembly, is the prime any witness was necessary. “It chief minister Ajit Jogi booked ASIDE THE KERALA HIGH know hospital to Delhi on the of Uttar Pradesh, and her lawyer accused in the rape case. The will be better to give the time than for cheating and forgery in a NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on COURT ORDER ON PANAJI: Goa swimming coach orders of the Supreme Court. were left critically injured on the woman’s family has alleged his pave the way an acquittal on tech- case related to allegedly obtain- Friday came down heavily on a Surajit Ganguly, accused of Earlier in the day, the road accident in which two of her role in the accident. nical grounds,” Justice Gupta ing a fake caste certificate has judge of the Kerala high court for MARCH 8 OVER PRAYER molesting a 15-year-old swim- Supreme Court directed the HC to aunts died. The top court also gave the remarked. been admitted to a private hos- issuing orders purportedly in SERVICES IN THE mer, was arrested in Delhi by a pital in Delhi-NCR on Thursday contravention to the top court’s joint team of the Goa and Delhi night after he complained of direction in the Malankara MALVANKARA CHURCH Police, bringing his over-24- shortstories breathing problem, a party church dispute case. hour run to an end. leader said here on Friday. It took strong exception to the formed in consonance with the Speaking to Hindustan EX-SC STAFFER: Ayodhya case: SC bench sends Hours after the police filed a HC’s tinkering of its 2017 verdict 1934 Malankara Church Consti- Times, police inspector of the fresh FIR on Thursday evening, on right to conduct administra- tution and guidelines. Mapusa Police station, Kapil DELHI POLICE Jogi was admitted to a private tion and prayers in churches in a Father Isaac Mattemmel Cor Nayak, said, “Based on our tech- PLEA REJECTED PIL for live-streaming to CJI hospital in Gurugram. dispute between two factions. Episcopa, the Vicar of St Mary’s nical surveillance and local His aide Nilesh Chauhan said Justice Arun Mishra, who led Orthodox Syrian Church, had intelligence, we managed to NEW DELHI: A Delhi court Friday HT Correspondent SENIOR ADVOCATE VIKAS ings in cases of national impor- Jogi was facing some breathing the bench, was so upset that he filed an appeal against the HC track him in Delhi. dismissed a plea for cancelling bail n [email protected] tance. The judgment is not yet problems. “Jogi ji is in ICU,” took the Kerala HC judge’s name order. On July 2, the SC had He was changing his location of the Supreme Court’s former SINGH SAID... IF NOT implemented. said Chauhan, who is also the in the open court and said: “Tell observed that “is Kerala above every time, we were tracking his woman employee, who had NEW DELHI: A Supreme Court LIVE-STREAMED, THE The case “famously known as spokesperson for Janata Con- the judges in Kerala that they are rule of law” and warned that chief location. Once we were able to levelled allegations of sexual bench on Friday referred a pub- the Ayodhya Ram Mandir mat- gress Chhattisgarh. Jogi’s party part of India.” “It is a very objec- secretary may be put behind bars zero down on his location we misconduct against Chief Justice lic interest litigation asking for PROCEEDINGS SHOULD ter” had created large-scale also released a photograph of tionable order. Who is this judge? for not implementing its 2017 sought the help of the local of India, in a cheating and criminal live-streaming of the hearing in AT LEAST BE AUDIO- interest across India, Govinda- Jogi being taken to hospital in Tell his name loud. Let everyone judgement. Jacobite church fol- police.” intimidation case. Supreme the ongoing Ayodhya land dis- charya stated in his petition. an ambulance. know. Who is this judge? What lowers have been accused of pre- He was picked up from Kash- Court’s 3-member In-House pute to the Chief Justice of India RECORDED AND “Live-streaming as an exten- The fresh case was filed in kind of judge is he?” he said, visi- venting access to the Orthodox mere Gate location of Old Delhi Inquiry Committee, headed by (CJI) even as it wondered if such TRANSCRIPTS MADE sion of the principle of open Bilaspur district on the com- bly angry with how “judicial faction, despite orders of the high and will be brought to Goa, the Justice S A Bobde, had in May this a plea could be accepted in view courts will ensure that the inter- plaint of Sameera Paikra, who indiscipline was developing.” court and the Supreme Court. police said. year given clean chit to the CJI as of the sensitivity of the case. AVAILABLE face between a court hearing contested the Marwahi seat in The top court set aside the Ker- The St Mary’s Orthodox The Goa Police were on the it “found no substance” in the A bench led by Justice RF Nar- with virtual reality will result in 2013 assembly polls on a Bharat- ala High Court order on March 8 Church and others in its appeal lookout for Ganguly ever since allegations levelled against him by the woman. Chief Metropoli- iman posted activist KN Govin- not a matter of national or consti- the dissemination of information iya Janata Party (BJP) ticket. that prayer services at the had said the HC had “closed” the 15-year-old swimmer went tan Magistrate Manish Khurana dacharya’s petition before CJI tutional importance,” the court in the widest possible sense, In his complaint to the police, churches should be performed their two writ petitions on the public accusing him of molest- on Friday dismissed the applica- Ranjan Gogoi’s court and fixed added. imparting transparency and BJP’s Sameera Paikra had cited alternately by the two rival fac- issue, after taking note of argu- ing her on multiple occasions in tion filed by Delhi Police after September 11 for it to be heard. Senior advocate Vikas Singh accountability to the judicial an affidavit filed by a govern- tions of the Malankara Church. ments of the counsel appearing Mapusa in North Goa, where he being informed by advocate V K “The ‘open court system’ did said the issue was one of social process,” the petition said. ment official Patras Tirkey The bench, also comprising for the state that earnest steps Ganguly stays. Ohri, appearing for the accused, not mean outsiders are privy to and constitutional gravity. If not A five-judge Constitution posted in Bilaspur 50 years Justice MR Shah, was hearing the have been taken by them for an The girl’s family initially that the notice of the application proceedings. It merely meant the live-streamed, the proceedings bench is hearing the Ayodhya ago. matter related to the implemen- amicable resolution of the dis- approached the police in Kolk- could not be served to the court was open to litigants to should at least be audio-recorded case from August 6 to decide the Last week, a separate FIR was tation of the SC order on giving putes between the factions. ata on Wednesday night, and complainant in the case despite attend proceedings,” the court and transcripts made available. politically-sensitive Ram Jan- registered against Ajit Jogi with control of 1,100 parishes and their The petitioners have claimed lodged first information report several attempts since earlier this remarked, asking whether it Govindacharya has in his mabhoomi-Babri Masjid land the Civil Lines police station in churches under the Malankara in the top court that some of the (FIR). year. “In these circumstances, no would be right to live-stream petition referred to the Supreme dispute, after the efforts to arrive Bilaspur after a government-ap- Church to the Orthodox faction. directions passed by the high Earlier in the day, Nayak fruitful purpose will be served by Ayodhya proceedings. “It can- Court’s 2018 judgment that at an amicable settlement pointed committee rejected his The apex court in 2017 said court in the matter were contrary expressed confidence that the keeping the application for not be said that this (Ayodhya) is ordered live-streaming of hear- through mediation failed. claim of being a tribal. HTC prayer services have to be per- to the top court’s directive. police were close to nabbing cancellation of bail of accused Ganguly. pending and the same is accord- Ganguly has been booked ingly dismissed...,” the court said. P C , KARTI ACCUSED under sections 376 (rape), Humiliated, UP Dalit 354(molestation), 361 (kidnap- ping), 506 (II) (criminal intimi- Court adjourns Aircel-Maxis case sine die dation) of the Indian Penal Code as well as Section 8 of the Goa officer kills himself Children’s Act (Child Abuse) as LAKHIMPUR KHERI (UP): A 23-year-old man could be heard calling him a Press Trust of India THE COURT GRANTED proceedings till the time investi- signed to Record Room sine well as Section 6 and 8 (aggra- Dalit officer has committed sui- ‘kaamchor’ (shirker), and also n [email protected] gating agencies gather further die,” the court said. vated penetrative sexual cide in Uttar Pradesh’s Lakhim- saying such officers should be LIBERTY TO THE PROBE material. The agencies also told The agencies requested the assault) under the Prevention of pur Kheri district, alleging thrashed and kicked out. NEW DELHI: A Delhi court Friday AGENCIES TO APPROACH the court that Letters Rogatory court to adjourn the matter for Children from Sexual Offences humiliation and mental harass- In the note, Gautam alleged adjourned sine die the Aircel- (LRs) have been sent to different six weeks. (Pocso) Act. BSP TO FIGHT ment by a village head, a leader of that they had humiliated and Maxis case, involving former THE COURT AND GET THE countries and response to them They were also represented HARYANA a farmers’ outfit and others, mentally harassed him. He also finance minister P Chidam- CASE REVIVED AS AND is still awaited. by Special Public Prosecutors police said on Friday. stated that he was subjected to baram and his son Karti, noting “Since further investigation Nitesh Rana and NK Matta and POLLS ALONE Trivendra Kumar Gautam, abuses and targeted over reser- that the Central Bureau of WHEN THEY COMPLETE is pending since long and the advocate Noor Rampal. CBI and Chinmayanand LUCKNOW: The Bahujan who had started his service as a vation, which, he said, was Investigation (CBI) and the THE INVESTIGATION prosecution has been seeking the ED are probing how Karti Samaj Party will go it alone village development officer last wrong. He was troubled and felt (ED) adjournment after adjourn- Chidambaram received clear- in the Haryana assembly year and was posted at Kumbhi that he was a failure, he added. were seeking “adjournment Chidambarams in the corrup- ment, it would be in the interest ance from the Foreign Invest- case: SIT reaches polls later this year and block, hanged himself on Five people have been after adjournment”. tion case filed by the CBI as well of justice, if the instant cases are ment Promotion Board (FIPB) field candidates on all Wednesday. His body was recov- arrested, additional SP Shailen- Special Judge O P Saini as in the money laundering mat- adjourned sine die, with liberty for the Aircel-Maxis deal in 2006 Shahjahanpur seats, party supremo ered on Thursday from the rented dra Lal said, adding, an FIR has adjourned the matter without ter lodged by the Enforcement to the prosecution to get it when his father was Union Mayawati said. “BSP is a accommodation at Shivsagar been lodged under IPC section giving any date for further hear- Directorate (ED) in relation to revived as soon as they are able finance minister. SHAHJAHANPUR (UP): A special national party, accordingly locality of Lakhimpur town, 130 306 (abetment to suicide) and sec- ing, saying it would save the the Aircel-Maxis deal. to complete the investigation on CBI and the Enforcement investigation team (SIT), which we inked an agreement km north of Lucknow, police said. tions of Scheduled Castes and time of the court and the probe The matter was listed for collection of further evidence Directorate had alleged that the was constituted by the Uttar Pra- with Dushyant Chautala’s In his last note addressed to his Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of agencies. The court granted lib- arguments on the cognisance of and/or receipt of response to Congress leader, as finance desh government on the orders of party for Haryana Assem- father, Gautam held district pres- Atrocities) Act, and IT Act. erty to the probe agencies to charge sheet in the case. LRs,” the court said in its order. minister during the United Pro- the Supreme Court, has arrived bly elections. We have ident of a farmers’ outfit, head of Meanwhile, Gautam’s col- approach the court and get the However, Solicitor General “Adjourning the matter sine die gressive Alliance (UPA) regime, in Shahjahanpur to probe the ended our alliance with Rasoolpur village and son of leagues held a protest at Vikas case revived as and when they Tushar Mehta and senior advo- would save the time of the court granted approval to the deal harassment charges levelled by a them on the suggestions of BSP Haryana unit due to another village head responsible. Bhawan and threatened to boy- complete the investigation. cate Sonia Mathur, appearing and that of the prosecutors and beyond his capacity benefitting woman law student against BJP their inappropriate A video has gone viral, pur- cott work if the guilty were not The court on Thursday for the CBI and the ED respec- investigators... Applications certain persons, and received leader Swami Chinmayanand. behaviour in seat-sharing,” portedly showing the young offi- held. “A probe is on and no one granted anticipatory bail to the tively, sought deferment of the stands disposed of. Files be con- kickbacks. The SIT, headed by Inspector she tweeted. On August 11, cer being humiliated in public. A will be spared,” Lal said. PTI General Naveen Arora, arrived BSP’s Satish Mishra and on Thursday night and will start Jannayak Janata Party’s its investigation after looking Dushyant Chautala had Cong team fails to meet Chidambaram at Tihar into the details of the probe con- announced that the Cops paste summons ducted by the local police. parties entered an alliance. “The investigations will start HT Correspondent other inmates he has access to the once we go through the evidences

n [email protected] prison’s library and can watch collected by the local police as UJJWALA SCHEME on Azam’s residence television in the common area,” well as the documents sent to the NEW DELHI: Former finance minis- said a second jail official. Supreme Court,” Arora said. ACHIEVES TARGET BAREILLY: The Rampur police on warrants have been issued, ter P Chidambaram spent his first Later in the day, Chidam- The officer said the team had BEFORE SCHEDULE Friday pasted a court notice on include the one in which Khan night in sleeping on a baram’s son seen the papers related to the the house of Samajwadi Party allegedly made derogatory rug spread on the floor of his cell visited Tihar to meet him. A dele- ‘rangdari’ (extortion) case filed NEW DELHI: The government will leader Azam Khan, asking him to remarks against Bharatiya Jan- and did not participate in the gation of Congress leaders by Chinmayanand’s counsel and achieve the target of giving 8 crore appear before the court on Sep- ata Party candidate Jaya Prada optional morning prayers with including party general secre- the case filed by the father of the free cooking gas (LPG) connections tember 11. As many as 80 cases during the Lok Sabha elections other inmates. Because the jail tary Mukul Wasnik, Rajasthan law student, and deliberated on to the poor nearly seven months ahead of schedule with Prime have been registered against 2019. Khan has been denied antic- authorities are yet to decide on Congress in-charge Avinash them. “We have included legal Minister Narendra Modi set to Khan and arrest warrants issued ipatory bail in five other cases. whether to provide Chidam- Pande, Delhi in-charge PC and surveillance experts in the handover the 8-croreth connec- in three cases. On Friday, the Rampur elec- baram a bed, he slept on the rug Chacko and Manikkam Tagore team and, if required, a forensic tion on Saturday. Pradhan Mantri Rampur superintendent of tricity department slapped a fine and was given a blanket, jail offi- also visited Tihar to meet Chi- expert will also be called,” Arora Ujjwala Yojana (PMUY) was police (SP) Ajay Pal Sharma con- of ₹30 lakh on Khan’s wife Tazin cials said. dambaram but were not allowed said, adding that police officers launched on May 1, 2016, with a firmed that the summons was Fatima, also a lawmaker. A team Chidambaram, 73, woke up at to because the allotted time had having “upright and clean target to give 5 crore connections pasted on Khan’s house as of the electricity department little after 6 am, the usual time for lapsed. image” are part of the team. to women members of poor nobody in his family was willing raided the ‘Humsafar’ resort, the inmates to get up, the officials Chidambaram was sent to 14 He added that the report would households by March 2019. The to receive it. owned by Khan’s kin, following a at Tihar said on condition of ano- n Congress leader and former finance minister P Chidambaram being day’ judicial custody on Thurs- be submitted to the Supreme target was later raised to 8 crore The Rampur MP has been complaint against it by local BJP nymity. He did not visit the pray- taken to Tihar jail in connection with the INX Media case, in New day in the INX Media corruption Court in a sealed envelope after connections by March 2020. “Prime summoned by additional chief leader Akash Saxena and regis- ing area, which most inmates Delhi on September 5. PTI FILE case. A Delhi court allowed him to the inquiry. Minister Narendra Modi will be judicial magistrate (I) to appear tered a case of electricity theft routinely do. Officials said partic- carry his spectacles and pre- The SIT was formed on Tues- handing over the 8 croreth before him on September 11 in a against Fatima. The officials also ipation in the morning prayer is like other inmates, Chidam- “For lunch he had chapatti, scribed medicines to the jail. For day, a day after the SC directed connection under PMUY at an case registered against him in found that 33,870 unbilled units optional and not compulsory for baram ate poha, tea and porridge sabzi, daal and rice. He was security reasons Chidambaram the state government to do so to event which will be organised in 2010 in connection with giving a and imposed a fine of ₹3 million, the inmates. “Not every inmate for breakfast. He spent most of his served food in same utensils as has been kept in a separate cell investigate the charges levelled Sendra, Aurangabad, Maharashtra false statement during election which includes ₹340,000 com- attends the morning prayers,” an time walking around the complex used by other inmates. He made with an attached western toilet in by the woman, who is a postgrad- on September 7,” an official campaigning. pounding fee and ₹2.62 million of official said. and reading newspapers, the offi- no special demands and did not jail number seven of the Tihar uate student at a college run by statement said here. Other cases, in which an arrest revenue arrears. HTC & PTI After stepping out of his cell cials said. complain about anything. Like complex. Chinmayanand’s trust. PTI