INSTRUMENTAL MUSIC in the ROMAN AGE.1 the Cultivation Of
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
INSTRUMENTAL MUSIC IN THE ROMAN AGE.1 THE cultivation of instrumental music remained in a backward state among the Greeks in the fifth and fourth centuries, B.C. - This was certainly not due to any want of taste for music.as a whole, for-no race ever valued it higher than did the Greeks. The reasons seem to have been, first, the bondage of-the instrument to the voice, second, the unsettled state of the musical scale, and thirdly, the dislike of the Greeks for over-elaboration in music. • .. • .-..-. ' . These three points are well illustrated in. the Republic of Plato, In opening the discussion on the admissibility of certain modes,-Socrates is made to say that a musical composition is made up of three things, the 'words,' the 'harmony,' and the 'rhythm,' and that the musical "words' are in themselves in no way different from the words of. common speech.2 In another place much scorn is cast by Glaucon on the musicians that sought for the least perceptible interval to make that the unit of sound-measurementr some of the experimenters declaring that they could distinguish an intermed- iate note, where others insisted that the two sounds had passed into unison.3 Socrates answers 'You mean those gentlemen who tease and torture the strings, screwing them up on the pegs.' . • Socrates and Glaucon both speak as amateurs in music, and their feelings must have been shared by many Athenians at the time. Just as with us there are some who long for the return of Handel's 'noble harmonies,' as a relief from the chromatic aberrations of the Wagnerian school, so these two worthy Greeks looked back to the sturdy Dorian airs of Terpander as the true strains of the Hellenic muse, before she had learnt to voice the subtler moods of the heart of man. To such amateurs the refinements of the musical scale must have seemed base loans from the decadent 1 I wish to thank the following gentlemen 4; and Dr. W. H. p. Rouse for supplying me for their kind and valued help to me in with a modern example of a pan-pipe from collecting the materials for this article: M. Smyrna. A. Merlin, Head of the Department of With very few exceptions, the monuments Antiquities for Tunisia, for having specially referred to are known to me in the originals, had photographed for me the unpublished from my visits to the museums where they are statuette from the Sluse'e Alaoui, Tunis (Fig. to be found. 5) as well as for much other assistance; 2 iii. 398 D. Cf. Nettleship, Lectures on M. Gouvet, Director of the Museum at Susa Plato's Hep. 108. (Sousse) for the prints used in Figures 2 and 3 vii. 531 A. INSTRUMENTAL MUSIC IN THE ROMAN AGE. 161 art of the East; and if, as is now thought, the music of the fourth century used intervals of a quarter, three-eighths, a third, two-thirds, and three- quarters of a tone, this was no wonder.4 The contrast is drawn by Socrates between the school to which Aristo- xenus belonged, the cultivators of the enharmonic style, and the Pythagoreans, who based the scale on the harmonic relations of the octave, fourth, and fifth. Into the details of this controversy there is no need to enter, but it is clear that such a simple and easily-tuned instrument as the lyre was best fitted to this screwing-up process by which the minimum intervals were reached. A many-stringed instrument would have taken too long to adjust to any highly complicated system. By the time of Aristoxenus himself the enharmonic scale was nearly dead, as Aristoxenus himself regrets;5 and although the later musical writers repeat mechanically their account of it, there is not much reason for thinking that it was ever revived in practice. Aristoxenus complains that, if the enharmonic system was dropped, there would soon be nothing left but the diatonic and the ' highstrung' chromatic (j^pcbfxa crvvrovov or roviaiov 6), and these actually survived. The objection felt by many Greeks to variety of musical effect is voiced by Socrates soon after his remark first quoted. He banishes such many- stringed and various instruments as the 'Triangle,' the 'Pectis,' and all kinds of flutes,7 leaving only the lyre, cithara, and, for shepherds, the pan-pipe {syrinx). It is possible that in retaining the cithara, Socrates may have meant only the kind with few strings, for it would have been strange to admit a fourteen-stringed cithara, while condemning the flute for its too great variety of sound. Here Plato's views must have seemed very narrow even to his own age. In making music a means of moral upbuilding he not only struck at virtuosity and over-refinement, but would have checked the progress of the art along its most promising lines. His beliefs do not seem to have had much effect, for the very instruments that he excluded were culti- vated with growing zeal. In Greece itself however the double-flute, lyre, and cithara remained the favourites. At Athens every boy was taught the lyre, and 4 Cf. Westphal, Harm,, u. Mel. d. Gr. 45-47. chromatic could be played on a piano ; and AVestphal's view holds the field, but it needs although Ptolemy lias three kinds of diatonic some faith to believe that these ear-splitting scale, it would still seem that the music of his dissonances were commonly played and sung. day would not have sounded utterly barbarous The so-called enharmonic mode of the modern to our ears. A form of chromatic mode is in Eastern Church fH^os rplros ; cf. I. Th. use in the Eastern Church, and is often heard Sakellarides 'Iepa 'T/IVIJISIO 95) is sung like in Romaic folk-songs: it has an austere and the major scale of F ; and it has been supposed striking effect. A ' soft' diatonic is sung in by Dom Gaisser {La Musique Eccl. Gr. d' apres some Greek churches as the second Byzantine la Tradition) that the ancient enharmonic was mode; but few western listeners find much in practice the same as this, the two quarter- sweetness in it. We ourselves allow both the tones being always sung together, and the ' just' and the ' tempered' intonation ; the double tone being divided. It is impossible bagpipes, I believe, are tuned to neither of now to go into this interesting theory. these, and their effect is not always disliked. 5 Quoted in Plut. de Mus. 38. Cf. Aristox. 7 iii. 399 c and D. Arist. Pol. viii. 6 will not Harm. i. 23. allow these instruments in the training of the 6 This is stated by Ptolemy. Cf. Monro, young. -ModesofAncicntGr.Mus.nl. The highstrung H.S.— VOL. XXVII. M 162 H. J. W. TILLYARD the use of the flute was by no means confined to professionals : Alcibiades, for example, is said to have studied on it.8 Again Epaminondas not only played the flute like other Thebans, but learnt the lyre also. The cithara, which had been perfected by Timotheus,9 was chiefly played by professionals. These three instruments are common subjects on Attic vases, and late monuments and authorities show that their use went on through the Roman age : their nature however is so well known that there is no need to say more about them. The kinds of harp called ' Triangle' and ' Pectis' by Plato seem to have been of Lydian origin. Athenaeus, who has a long discussion on the subject, says'that the Magadis was a stringed instrument, later called Sambuca, while the Pectis was the same.10 It is possible that the ' Triangle ' was also similar, and that the names of Trigonon and Pectis were meant as Greek renderings for the foreign words Magadis and Sambuca. This harp, as it may safely be called, is often seen in Egyptian art, and must have been widespread over the East. It appears on a fine red-figured vase in conjunction with the lyre and cithara.11 Athenaeus says that Sappho brought in its use from Lydia, and Anacreon, as his own words record, played a harp with twenty strings.12 The instrument embraced the whole compass of the singing voice, and had high notes beyond the range of the cithara.18 It could be used without a striker. One of its peculiarities was that the sound-box was on the upper side. FIG. 1.—TKIGONUM OK SAMBITCA. Smaller sizes with nine or even five strings were sometimes made. Examples of such miniature harps are seen in some of the wall-paintings now in the Naples Museum: one of these, played by a Cupid, is here illustrated. (Fig. I)14 Another stringed instrument of the same class, more like a zither, became popular in the Roman Age. But, while the use of the harp called for great skill, and gave full scope for rich and splendid effects, the zither can only have yielded a thin and twanging tone, especially as the ancient instrument often had no sound-box. This instrument is nearly always played by women, who often wear a carelessly sumptuous dress, suited rather to paid performers than to freewomen. Examples are again seen in Roman wall-paintings. In 8 Duris ap. Athen. iv. 84, 184 D, where it is speaks of the Pectis. said that the famous flute-player Pronomus was 13 Telestes 4 (5j (Bergk) TO! 8' o^vcpdi/ots Alcibiades' master. vrjuriSav ij/aA./*o(<s> Kpt/cov AiSiov VJXVOV. 9 Cf. Paus. iii. 12. 8. 14 For other examples cf.