Surgical Management of Sphenoid Ridge Meningioma En Plaque (Spheno-Orbital Meningioma) Gasser Hasan Al-Shyal, Mohamed Soliman Mohamed, Mohammad Fathy Eissa
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
[Downloaded free from http://www.azmj.eg.net on Monday, December 7, 2020, IP: 41.42.169.215] Original article 295 Surgical management of sphenoid ridge meningioma en plaque (spheno-orbital meningioma) Gasser Hasan Al-Shyal, Mohamed Soliman Mohamed, Mohammad Fathy Eissa Department of Neurosurgery, Faculty of Background and aim Medicine for Girls, Al-Azhar University, Cairo, The aim of the study was to investigate the surgical techniques to remove Egypt meningioma en plaque and to compare our technique and results with other Correspondence to Gasser H. Al-Shyal, MD, authors. PhD, FAANS, Department of Neurosurgery, Al- Patients and methods Azhar University Faculty of Medicine for Girls, Al-zahraa Hospital, Abbassya, Cairo, Egypt. This retrospective series case was done at our University Hospital. Eight patients Tel: +20-1006699718; were managed at Al-Zahraa University Hospital between March 2016 and March e-mail: [email protected] 2018. Preoperative and postoperative clinical and radiological assessments were Received: 14 January 2020 done for each patient. Revised: 11 May 2020 Results Accepted: 2 June 2020 There were eight patients in our study. All patients are women. The age range was Published: 30 October 2020 from 34 to 60 years and the mean was 45.4 years. Proptosis was the main clinical Al-Azhar Assiut Medical Journal 2020, manifestation and it was present in all eight patients. Three (37.5%) patients had 18:295–301 visual impairment while two (25%) of them had headache and retro-orbital pain. We achieved total resection in six (75%) out of our eight patients. All tumors were WHO grade 1 meningiomas. Regarding surgical outcome, proptosis improved in six (75%) of the eight cases. Visual impairment improved in two (66.7%) cases out of three who had visual declination preoperatively. Conclusion Meningioma en plaque can be safely removed without any morbidity or mortality. Proptosis and hyperostosis in the sphenoid bone are highly suggestive and this requires more accurate radiological studies. MRI with contrast is essential for these cases. Extensive bony drilling is required for gross total resection. It also facilitates resection of the soft part of the tumor with its dura. Some cases may need orbital wall reconstruction. Proptosis mostly improves after surgery. Keywords: meningioma, proptosis, pterional approach, skull base, sphenoid wing meningioma, spheno- orbital meningioma Al-Azhar Assiut Med J 18:295–301 © 2020 Al-Azhar Assiut Medical Journal 1687-1693 cavernous sinus, and temporal convexity. Hyperostosis Introduction may result in compression of the optic nerve and or Meningioma accounts for about one-third of the other cranial nerves. Also, it causes proptosis, visual primary brain tumors [1]. The term meningioma en deterioration, and cosmetic deformity [13,14]. plaque (MEP) was first described by Cushing [2], which is flat soft tumor that infiltrates the dura [3]. Proptosis is the most common presentation of MEP. It It invades the bone causing hyperostosis. This occurs is unilateral, nonpulsating, and irreducible. Other mostly along the sphenoid wing [4]. Two synonyms are manifestations include decreased visual acuity, used for the description of these tumors: MEP and headache, and limitation of extraocular muscle spheno-orbital meningiomas [5–8]. movements. Less frequently, swelling in the temporal region, seizure, and facial pain are seen [15]. These tumors are slowly growing, and it has either flat or slightly nodular shape [9]. MEPs are more likely to Differential diagnosis of these lesions is meningeal cause bony hyperostosis than are larger globular tumors sarcoidosis, osteoma, tuberculoma, and fibrous and the amount of hyperostosis is often dysplasia [16,17]. Choosing surgical approach and disproportionate to the relatively small tumor [10–12]. Hyperostosis may extend in the skull base involving the This is an open access journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 lateral and superior orbital walls of the optic canal and License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work the anterior clinoid process. The dural growth is usually non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new extensive and may include the basal sphenoid wing, creations are licensed under the identical terms. © 2020 Al-Azhar Assiut Medical Journal | Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow DOI: 10.4103/AZMJ.AZMJ_5_20 [Downloaded free from http://www.azmj.eg.net on Monday, December 7, 2020, IP: 41.42.169.215] 296 Al-Azhar Assiut Medical Journal, Vol. 18 No. 3, July-September 2020 strategy for removal of MEP are challenging, because it optic canal was opened to decompress the optic nerve has extensive orbital, bone, and dural involvement in cases with marked hyperostosis in the optic canal. If [18–21]. As a result, MEP has relatively high there was orbital infiltration, tumor in the orbit was recurrence rate than other types of meningioma [22]. followed and removed. We did not remove any tumor However, with the development in microsurgical part infiltrated superior orbital fissure dura to avoid technique and craniofacial approaches it is possible cranial nerve deficits. The blood supply MEP usually to be more radical in the management of these arises from branches of the middle meningeal artery. tumors and many surgeons reported favorable We got good devascularization of the tumor by outcomes [15,23–25]. In our opinion, extensive bony cauterizing these branches after resection of the drilling of the affected bone and good exposure of the sphenoid wing with hyperostotic bone. Soft tumors soft tumor mass is the key to achieving favorable are removed with the dura. The excised dura is replaced surgical outcomes. with the artificial substitute. We removed the affected bone to avoid recurrence and this leads to defects in lateral and/or roof of the orbit. We used a titanium Patients and methods mesh plate to replace drilled bones in the temporal fossa, This retrospective study was conducted at Al-Zahraa but we did not reconstruct the superior wall of the orbit. University Hospital, after approval from the local ethics All cases were examined in the same day after surgery committee and after written informed consent was and were followed up for 1 year. Follow-up imaging obtained from each patient before surgery. Eight (CT bone window and MRI) to access residual and patients were managed at Al-Zahraa University recurrent tumors was done after 6 months and 1 year. Hospital in the interval between March 2016 and March 2018. We reviewed the preoperative clinical Statistical analysis assessment for each patient. We did ophthalmology The study is an observational retrospective case series consultation for each patient to access their visual acuity. study and descriptive statistics was used as follows: We did both MRI and computed tomography (CT) (1) Quantitative data: mean and SD were used to bone window (with 3D reconstruction) for every measure central tendency and dispersion. patient. We reviewed the preoperative images to (2) Qualitative data: the studied variables were access the location of the tumor, the site of analyzed using univariant analysis and presented hyperostosis, and to plan our surgical techniques. as frequencies and percentages (frequency distribution table) for qualitative variables. Axial and coronal CT scan images of the bone window were essential for visualization of hyperostosis. We found that contrast is essential for detecting the Results dural enhancing component of these lesions. In one There were eight patients in our study. All patients are of our cases, the lesion did not appear except in women. The age range was from 34 to 60 with a mean contrasted MRI. Large axial orbital cuts increase the age of 45.4 years (Table 1). sensitivity of picking up small dural enhancement. Clinical manifestations We did pterional craniotomy for all eight cases. Care Proptosis was the main clinical manifestation and it was taken to avoid injury of the frontal branch of the was present in all eight patients. One patient had facial nerve. In some patients, we removed the soft bilateral exophthalmos due to toxic goiter and the tumor that infiltrated the temporalis. After removal of tumor was accidently discovered after doing MRI on the extracranial component of the tumor and the orbits in the Ophthalmology Department. Three separation of temporalis, a high-speed drill was used (37.5%) patients had visual impairment while for removal of hyperostotic bone of the lesser and two (25%) of them had headache and retro-orbital greater sphenoid wings. In two cases, we flattened pain. the marginal tubercle (elevation of the posterior border of the zygomatic process of the frontal bone) Resection, pathological grading, and reconstruction to get good exposure of the lateral wall of the orbit and Gross total resection was done for six (75%) out of the anteroinferior part of the greater sphenoid wing eight patients (Fig. 2). In one of the other two patients, (Fig. 1). Then, the remaining part of the bone is we left the part invading the dura of the superior orbital elevated. We continued drilling of the pathological fissure and the residue did not increase in size within bone of sphenoid wings and roof of the orbit. The the follow-up period. In another one, we left a piece of [Downloaded free from http://www.azmj.eg.net on Monday, December 7, 2020, IP: 41.42.169.215] Surgical management of meningioma en plaque Al-Shyal et al. 297 Figure 1 Increasing exposure with marginal tubercle drilling. Arrow points to the marginal tubercle: (a) before drilling and (b) after drilling. Table 1 Summary of patients with meningioma en plaque Cases Age Sex Preoperative Grade of Tumor Bone Surgical results Complications clinical picture resection grade reconstruction WHO 1 55 F Proptosis, Total 1 Yes Headache and visual Subgaleal CSF collection headache, and impairment improved for 2 months, 3rd nerve visual impairment proptosis is the same palsy 2 45 F Proptosis Total 1 No Proptosis improved No 3 48 F Proptosis Total 1 Yes Proptosis improved No 4 50 F Proptosis, visual Total 1 No Proptosis improved, visual Frontal branch of VII n.