September 1, 2018 Page 1

Phillip Hudok 15958 Seneca Trail Huttonsville, W.Va. [26273] Home 304-335-2826 Cell 304-940-9646

Office of the Senate President – Lt. Governor Room 229M, Building 1 State Capitol Complex Charleston, WV 25305

Dear Senator Mitch Carmichael,

I am compelled to notify you, members of the Senate, and House Judiciary Chairman John Shott of evidence of a crime having been committed by one or more of the following: current West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals Justice Margaret Workman and four former West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals Justices, Robin Jean Davis, Brent D. Benjamin, Menis E. Ketchum II, and Allen H. Loughry II in regards to Supreme Court of Appeals Case, # 15-0491.

West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals Case 15-0491 was originally filed May, 22, 2015. On September 4, 2015, Case # 15-0491 was amended to add and incorporate Justices, Margaret L. Workmen, Robin Jean Davis, Brent D. Benjamin, Menis E. Ketchum II, and Allen H. Loughry II as defendants in the Original Complaint and Demand.

I live-streamed and recorded the reading of the entire seven page amended Case # 15-0491 in the hallway outside the Supreme Court which is still posted on YouTube.

With Case 15-0491 amended as stated, the five named Justices could not adjudicate the case in any way and five Circuit Court Justices would have to be called upon to continue the case.

One of the three plaintiffs, Mr. Gene Stalnaker, received a letter after the September 4, 2015 suggesting a dismissal of Case # 15-0491 stamped by then Clerk, Rory L. Perry II. Page 2

To this date, I, Phillip Hudok, plaintiff in Case 15-0491, have never received any notification that the case was ever dismissed. In fact, over one month after the amended case filing on October 6, 2015, The Elkins Inter-Mountain, published the featured headlined front page story by Staff Writer, Tim MacVean, “Justices added to Hudok’s lawsuit.” There was no response to this story by any Justice or officers of the Supreme Court of Appeals.

To further substantiate that Case 15-0491 was not dismissed I present the following image snippet from Mr. Patrick Morrisey’s Facebook Page:

Page 3

You will note that the date is January 3. This is January 3, 2016. Notice that Mr. Morrisey questions me as to whether “you are involved in a pending case. As such, we will defer to communications with your attorney. If this is incorrect, please let us know.” Mr. Morrisey was and is indeed a respondent in Case 15-0491! His comments substantiates the Case # 15-0491 is indeed still lawfully active and a crime has been committed.

I want to stress the importance that you understand the implications involved. The Rule of Law is paramount. Black’s law dictionary defines an important term, “Misprision of felony. The offense of concealing a felony committed by another, but without such previous concert with or subsequent assistance to the felon as would make the party concealing an accessory before or after the fact.”

By taking this evidence to you, I cannot be guilty of a misprision of felony.

Please contact me with any questions or for additional evidence. I have access to all original stamped filings and other documents.

Sincerely,

Phillip Hudok

Cc John Shott, Lynne Arvon, , Stephen Baldwin, Robert D. Beach, , Donna J. Boley, , Charles H. Clements, , Mark Drennan, Douglas E. Facemire, Ryan Ferns, Ed Gaunch, , Robert L. Karnes, , , Mark R. Maynard, Richard Ojeda, , Robert H. Plymale, , , , , , , Dave Sypolt, , Charles S. Trump IV, John R. Unger II, ,