The Prehistory and Reception of Leonard Bernstein's Missa
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The prehistory and reception of Leonard Bernstein’s Missa Brevis (1988) by Patrick Connor Dittamo B.A., College of William and Mary, 2013 A THESIS submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree MASTER OF MUSIC School of Music, Theatre, and Dance College of Arts and Sciences KANSAS STATE UNIVERSITY Manhattan, Kansas 2019 Approved by: Major Professor Craig Weston Copyright © 2019 Patrick Connor Dittamo. All rights reserved. Abstract Leonard Bernstein (1918-1990) commonly repurposed previously-written material in new compositions, including his Missa Brevis (1988), which adapted significant portions of his incidental music for Lillian Hellman’s play The Lark (1955), itself an adaptation of French playwright Jean Anouilh’s play L’Alouette (1953) about the trial of Joan of Arc. Based on an assessment of The Lark’s mixed reception history as a play, Bernstein’s score, recorded by the New York Pro Musica, deserves some credit for the original Broadway run’s considerable success. Bernstein’s Medieval- and Renaissance-inflected score was written shortly before the play’s tryout run in Boston, and used fragments of verse by Adam de la Halle (c. 1245-1288/1306) and Jean-Antoine de Baïf (1532-1589), as well as the tune of the French folksong “Plantons la Vigne,” and not the commonly-cited “Vive la Grappe.” Bernstein and the New York Pro Musica were well- compensated for their contributions to The Lark; however, during the play’s national tour, there was a pay dispute over reduced royalties between Bernstein’s agent and the play’s management. Before the New York premiere of The Lark, Bernstein expressed a belief that its incidental score held a viable “kernel of a short mass,” and considered using a Lark-based missa brevis to fulfill a commission for Juilliard’s fiftieth anniversary, an idea he ultimately abandoned. This idea was in his mind before the eminent conductor Robert Shaw attended a performance of the play. The traditional account that the idea was brought to him by Shaw is not borne out by the available evidence, although Shaw did approach Bernstein about programming the Lark choruses for a concert tour, an idea that was also abandoned. The subsequent Missa Brevis commissioned by the Atlanta Symphony for Shaw’s retirement in 1988 was a substitute for an orchestral work originally requested in 1983, and is almost a straight contrafactum of music from the original Lark score, with some fine-tuning of interpretive markings. The Missa Brevis was expanded to utilize the full liturgical Ordinary text, sans Credo, by Bernstein’s musical assistant George Steel, and was published in 1990. While the Missa Brevis is not typical of Bernstein’s oeuvre, recordings in recent years have garnered moderate praise from reviewers. Table of Contents List of Figures ................................................................................................................................................... vii List of Tables .................................................................................................................................................... viii Acknowledgements ........................................................................................................................................... ix Dedication .......................................................................................................................................................... xi Preface ................................................................................................................................................................ xii Introduction ........................................................................................................................................................ 1 Chapter 1 - Hatching The Lark ......................................................................................................................... 3 Bernstein at the Time of The Lark .............................................................................................................. 3 An Exaltation of Larks: Anouilh, Fry, Hill, and Hellman ....................................................................... 7 The Reception of Hellman’s Lark ............................................................................................................. 12 The Initial Reception of Bernstein’s Incidental Music for The Lark ................................................... 19 Chapter 2 - Anatomy of a Lark ...................................................................................................................... 25 “Doing the Incidentals:” Composing The Lark ...................................................................................... 25 “A Lark that is Learning to Pray:” Early Musical Cues in The Lark .................................................... 26 “Credo? Exaudi?:” Texting Cues for The Lark ...................................................................................... 28 Musical and Textual Borrowing in The Lark ........................................................................................... 35 Recording and Performing The Lark ........................................................................................................ 45 The Musical Finances of The Lark ............................................................................................................ 48 Bernstein, Oberlin, and the New York Pro Musica ............................................................................... 53 Chapter 3 - The Lark Takes Flight?: The Initial Afterlife of The Lark ..................................................... 59 The Kernel of a Short Mass? ..................................................................................................................... 59 The Shaw Connection ................................................................................................................................. 61 The Specter of the Sabbath Service .......................................................................................................... 63 The Publication and Reception of the Lark Choruses .......................................................................... 67 Chapter 4 - The Lark Resurrected: Bernstein’s Missa Brevis (1988) ........................................................... 70 Bernstein, Shaw, and the Atlanta Symphony: “When the Muse Descends” ...................................... 70 Creating the Missa Brevis, Contrafacting The Lark ................................................................................... 75 The Origin Question Revisited .................................................................................................................. 78 A Less-Brief Missa Brevis (1988-1990) ....................................................................................................... 80 The Reception of the Missa Brevis .............................................................................................................. 83 Conclusion ......................................................................................................................................................... 88 Bibliography ...................................................................................................................................................... 89 Discography ...................................................................................................................................................... 95 The Lark ......................................................................................................................................................... 95 Missa Brevis ..................................................................................................................................................... 95 Other ............................................................................................................................................................... 96 Appendix A - Text and Translation for The Lark (1955) ........................................................................... 97 Appendix B - Sound Cues for The Lark (1955) ........................................................................................... 99 Appendix C - Broadway Production Credits for The Lark (1955) .......................................................... 101 Appendix D - Hallmark Hall of Fame Telecast Credits (1957) .............................................................. 105 Appendix E - Disparities between the Published Score of The Lark (1964) and the New York Pro Musica Tape (1955) ................................................................................................................................ 106 Appendix F - Text and Translation for the Missa Brevis (1988) ............................................................... 108 Appendix G - Text and Translation for the Revised Missa Brevis ........................................................... 109 Appendix H - Concordance of The Lark and the Missa Brevis ................................................................. 111 v General Notes ............................................................................................................................................ 111 1. Kyrie ........................................................................................................................................................ 111