Asian J. Adv. Basic Sci.: 2016, 4(2), 08-19 ISSN (Print): 2454 – 7492 ISSN (Online): 2347 – 4114 www.ajabs.org Karyotype Analysis and Chromosome Evolution in Three Species of Genus Plantago L. in Egypt
Magda I. Soliman1, El-sayed E. Hafez2, Mohammed S. Zaghlol3, Linda Z. Samaan1 and Amira A. Ibrahim1*
1 Botany Department, Faculty of Science, Mansoura University, 35516, EGYPT 2 Molecular Plant Pathology Department, ALCADRI, City for Scientific Research and Technological Applications, 21934, EGYPT 3Botany Department, Faculty of Science, Suez Canal University, 41522, EGYPT * Correspondance: E-mail: [email protected]
(Received 13 Feb, 2016; Accepted 21 Feb, 2016; Published 24 Feb, 2016)
ABSTRACT: The karyotypic characters, mitotic metaphase chromosomes and karyograms of ten populations of three species of Plantago L. (P. lagopus L., P. major L. and P. squarrosa Murr.) in Egypt were determined and compared with each other. Analysis of somatic metaphase showed that the chromosome numbers were 2n = 12. Although all the species had the same chromosome number, they could be differentiated by their karyotype for- mula and quantitative parameters of the karyotypes. Ten different methods of karyotype asymmetry (TF%, As K%, Rec and Syi, A1 and A2, DI, A, AI and MCA) were determined for the elucidation of phylogenetic relationships and taxonomic treatments within a particular group or taxon. The highest value of Syi index was found in popula- tion of P. lagopus (P. lag1) collected from Abu AL-Matamir District (66.682). Population of P. squarrosa (P.sq1) collected from Qalabshu-bilqas District had the highest values of A1 (0.543), where the highest value of A2 (0.29) was recorded in population of P. lagopus (P. lag 2) collected from Ganaklis District. The highest positive correla- tion was observed between TF % and Syi index (0.997). P. lagopus population collected from Abu AL-Matamir District (P. lag1) was the most symmetrical karyotype may be considered as less evolved, while P. squarrosa popu- lation collected from Qalabshu- Bilqas District (P. sq1) was the most asymmetrical karyotype and may be consid- ered as more advanced than the rest of populations. Populations of P. lagopus delimitated in a separate group from the rest of studied populations. The center of rest populations was occupied by P. major populations using PERMAP-Biplot and Scatter diagrams.
Keywords: Plantago; Populations; Asymmetry index; Karyotype and Egypt.
INTRODUCTION: The genus Plantago L. of family they have proved effective against different diarrhea Plantaginaceae comprises about 483 species distribut- causing disease. The Plantago lagopus and P.major ed throughout the world and the genus is the prevalent are very important plant with strong cytotoxic and of the three genera on which family Plantaginaceae is radical scavenging activities that protect cells against based1 & 2. According to Pilger3 the genus is divided free radical injuries and have been used for the treat- into two subgenera: Euplantago Harms and Psyllium ment of ailments and diseases such as the common Harms. The genus subdivided into three subgenera cold, wounds, viral infection, depression and in addi- including Plantago, Coronopus Rahn and Psyllium tion to inhibition of cancer cells proliferation due to Rahn4. Recently, Rahn5 proposed a new original taxo- presence of pro-oxidant effect of phenolics in higher nomic scheme of the genus according to which genus concentrations6 & 7. Plantago includes six subgenera: Plantago, Previous cytological knowledge of Plantago L. has Coronopus Rahn, Albicans Rahn, Psyllium Juss, revealed that this genus has three different basic Littorella Rahn and Bougueria Rahn. The Plantago chromosome numbers of x=4, 5 and 6. The basic genera are small, annual and perennial herbs of warm number of x=6 is the original chromosome number temperate, sandy provinces and are widely allocated from which x=5 & x=4 have been derived. This num- this genus is with several critical groups, floral char- ber of x=6 is present in the majority of species 8-10. acters are sometimes subject to modification and the The first consistent chromosome counts in Plantago variations between populations of the same species were reported by MucCullagh11. Other studies were are often considerable2. made in connection with taxonomic studies to explain The seeds of several Plantago species have often been the relationships in particular groups of related spe- used medicinally due to their high mucilage content, cies12-15. Studies also covered the cytology of 8
[(Asian J. Adv. Basic Sci.: 4(2), 2016, 08-19) Karyotype Analysis and Chromosome Evolution in Three Specie of Genu…]
Plantago species from different phytogeographical ties namely, Abu AL-Matamir and Ganaklis Districts regions16 & 17. Badr and El-Kholy18 studied Plantago (El-Behiera Governorate), where Plantago major L. chromosomes in the Egyptian flora and the basic were collected from four localities namely, Mansoura chromosome number x=6 is the most common among and Aga Districts (El- Dakahlia Governorate), EL- the species Plantago which may be considered the Mahalla Al–Kubra District (El-Gharbia Governorate) ancestral number in the genus19. and Motubas District (Kafr El-Sheikh Governorate), and Plantago squarrosa Murr. were collected also Cytological techniques determine the chromosome from four localities namely, Qalabshu-Bilqas District constitution of an organism to facilitate recognition of (El-Dakahlia Governorate), Baltim District and Al– the individual chromosomes. In plant taxonomy, Aqulah-El-Borullus District (Kafr El-Sheikh Gover- breeding and genetic studies; information about chro- norate), and Idku District (El-Behiera Governorate) as mosome karyotype can be useful in species identifica- shown in Table 1. tion and analysis of hybrid populations20-23. Cytological studies: All seeds were germinated on Genetic variations defined as the variation of individ- moist filter paper in Petri dishes; 4–5 mm long root ual genotypes within and among species. It is im- tips were excised and pre-treated with aqueous solu- portant trait for long term survival of species and ena- tion of 0.002 M 8-hydroxyquinoline for 4 h at 4– bles a population to adapt to new conditions caused by 5°C34. The roots were fixed for 24 h in a mixture of environmental change24. Cytotaxonomy is a branch of ethanol: glacial acetic acid (3:1 v/v), and stored in the cytogenetics, devoted to the comparative study of refrigerator. Roots were rinsed in distilled water, hy- karyological features for systematic and evolutionary drolyzed with 1N HCl at 60°C for 8–9 minutes. Dif- purposes25. Today, a number of data can be obtained ferent staining techniques were used: 2% aceto-orcein by chromosome studies: chromosome number, karyo- after acid treatment35 and modified carbol fuchsin 36 & type structure, karyotype formula and asymmetry, 37. Deeply stained root tips were squashed on clean chromosome banding, FISH, GISH and chromosome 26-28 slides with a drop of 45% acetic acid then specimens painting . were squashed in a drop of 2% aceto-orcein. Cells Karyotype evolution is one of the most important with spread metaphase chromosomes were examined aspects of the whole evolutionary processes29 and and photographed by olympus photomicroscope, us- considered as an isolating mechanism in speciation ing 100-phase oil immersion lens and Kodak film. At and has its own evolutionary trends independent of least 10 metaphases were drawn for each population genetic evolution30. Stebbins31 pointed out that the (including 3–8 individuals), selecting the five best for pattern of karyotype evolution is generally from measurements. The nomenclature used for the descrip- symmetry to asymmetry in higher plants. Phenotypic tion of the chromosome morphology is that proposed traits are controlled by genes and affected by envi- by Abraham 38. ronment, but large numbers of accessions can adapt to 32 Karyotype analysis: Karyotype analysis was carried environments . Populations often go extinct follow- out using "Micro Measure 3.3" computer software47 ing discrete changes in the environment. However, Karyotype asymmetry was estimated by many differ- populations may avoid extinction by rapidly adapting ent methods, the karyotype asymmetry index (As K to their altered environment33. %), the total form percent (TF %), the Rec and Syi The aims of this investigation are to: (1) report karyo- indices, the intrachromosomal asymmetry index (A1) type data on the ten populations of three species of and interchromosomal asymmetry index (A2), the genus Plantago (P. lagopus, P. major, and P. dispersion index (DI), the degree of asymmetry of squarrosa), (2) contribute to the statistical correlations karyotype (A index) and the asymmetry index (AI). between the studied populations to elucidate the pos- Equations and calculations of these parameters and sible evolutionary trend, (3) examine the patterns of their references were shown in Table 2. chromosome and genetic variability of Plantago L. populations growing naturally in Egypt which corre- RESULTS AND DISCUSSION: All ten populations late with environmental adaptation and its impact on are diploid and have 2n=2x=12 in somatic cells and conservation strategies of gene banks. represented in Figures 1 & 2. Karyotypic characters, mitotic metaphase chromosomes, karyograms and MATERIALS AND METHODS: haploid ideograms are shown in Figures 1, 2 & 3. Populations sampling: In this study plant materials Analysis of somatic metaphases showed that the kary- were collected from ten populations of three Plantago otype formula is nsm(-) & nm in all ten populations, L. species growing naturally in Egypt. The seeds of while nsm(+) formula recorded in populations P. m3, P.sq 1, P. sq3 and P.sq4, nst(-) observed only in P. sq Plantago lagopus L. were collected from two locali- 9
[(Asian J. Adv. Basic Sci.: 4(2), 2016, 08-19) Karyotype Analysis and Chromosome Evolution in Three Specie of Genu…]
1. The highest total chromosome length (TCL) found centromeric index of all populations are observed in in P. sq 4 (32.676 µm), on the other hand the lowest Tables 3 to12. TCL in P. lag 2 (9.985 µm), the TCL, arm ratio and Table 1: Location and Habitat type of the ten collected populations from genus Plantago L. in Egypt. Life GPS Data Population Location Species Code Form Governorate Habitat Type No. (District) Latitude Longitude (N) (E) Annual Abu AL- P.lg 1 1 or short El -Beheira 30°54'15.30" 30°10'46.28" Orchards Matamir Perennial Annual lagopus Plantago Plantago p. lg 2 2 or short Ganaklis El -Beheira 31° 7'14.66" 31° 7'50.15" Orchards Perennial
P.m 1 3 Perennial Mansoura El-Dakahlia 31° 2'25.67" 31°21'30.43" Canal banks Cultivated P. m 2 4 Perennial Aga El-Dakahlia 30°56'30.29" 31°17'36.35" lands EL- Mahalla P.m 3 5 Perennial El-Gharbia 30°58'42.35" 31° 9'50.18" Garden Al- Kubra Kafr El- Plantago major Plantago P.m 4 6 Perennial Motubas 31°17'36.07" 30°31'19.51" Canal banks Sheikh Qalabshu- P. sq 1 7 Annual El -Dakahlia 31°29'3.36" 31°19'53.14" Sand flats Bilqas Kafr El - P.sq 2 8 Annual Baltim 31°33'17.48" 31° 5'28.09" Sand dunes Sheikh Al –Aqulah- Kafr El - Cultivated P. sq 3 9 Annual 31°13'15.89" 30°54'45.92" El-Borullus Sheikh sandy soils P.sq 4 10 Annual Idku El - Beheira 31°19'55.93" 30°17'31.59" Sand dunes Plantago Plantago squarrosa
Figure 1: Somatic chromosomes of Plantago L., all populations with 2n =12. (A & B) P. lag.1; (C & D) P. lag. 2; (E & F) P. m. 1; (G & H) P.m. 2; (I & J) P.m. 3, (X=1000). 10
[(Asian J. Adv. Basic Sci.: 4(2), 2016, 08-19) Karyotype Analysis and Chromosome Evolution in Three Specie of Genu…]
Figure 2: Somatic chromosomes of Plantago L., all populations with 2n =12. (K & L) P.m. 4; (M & N) P. sq. 1; (O & P) P. sq. 2; (Q &R) P. sq. 3; (S & T) P.sq. 4., (X = 1000).
Table 2: Calculations of karyotype asymmetry indices.
Karyotype asym- Formula Reference metry type