RSC Advances
View Article Online PAPER View Journal | View Issue
Solubility temperature and solvent dependence and preferential solvation of citrus flavonoid Cite this: RSC Adv.,2017,7,14776 naringin in aqueous DMSO mixtures: an experimental and molecular dynamics simulation study
Morteza Jabbari,* Negar Khosravi, Mina Feizabadi and Davood Ajloo
This study describes the thermodynamics of dissolution of flavonoid naringin in different aqueous solutions of dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) containing 0–100% (w/w) under atmospheric pressure and over a temperature range of 298.15 to 325.15 K. The temperature dependence of solubility of naringin was analyzed using the modified Apelblat equation model, ideal model, and the lH equation model. In D a mean harmonic temperature, the dissolution thermodynamic parameters of naringin containing Gsol,
Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported Licence. D D ff Hsol and Ssol were also calculated. Furthermore, the e ects of solvent composition on the solubility of
this flavonoid were analyzed in terms of Hildebrand's solubility parameter (dH) and Kamlet, Abboud and Taft (KAT) solvatochromic parameters (a, b, and p*). Finally, the preferential solvation parameters of the
flavonoid naringin by DMSO (dxDMSO,S) were determined from experimental solubility data using the inverse Kirkwood–Buff integrals (IKBIs). It was found that water preferentially solvates naringin in water-
rich mixtures while DMSO forms local solvation shells in compositions from 50% (w/w) or xDMSO ¼ 0.19 Received 2nd January 2017 up to pure co-solvent. Moreover, the structure of solvation shells of naringin in the under study mixtures Accepted 27th February 2017 was obtained by molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. The computational results showed that in the DOI: 10.1039/c7ra00038c compositions xDMSO > 0.20, the probability of presence of the DMSO molecules in vicinity of naringin is This article is licensed under a rsc.li/rsc-advances more than water molecules. These findings are compatible with the available IKBI data.
pharmaceutical dissolutions.5,6 Furthermore, the solubility data Open Access Article. Published on 06 March 2017. Downloaded 9/29/2021 9:55:39 PM. Introduction of solutes in different solvents are necessary for determining the 0 Naringin (C27H32O14) with the chemical name 4 ,5,7- appropriate solvents for extraction, separation, production, and trihydroxyavanone-7-rhamnoglucoside, is a avanone glycoside purication of organic compounds.1 There are various mathe- that is frequently found in many citrus fruits especially grapefruit matical and empirical models to correlate and predict the and lemon, such that it is responsible for the fruit's bitter taste.1 It solubility of drug compounds in different solvents and temper- has been reported that naringin can show biological effects like atures. These models can solve issues such as expensive cost and antioxidant, anti-inammatory, anti-cancer (breast cancer), anti- long time in the solubility determination process.1 Dependence allergic, anti-diabetic, anti-angiogenesis and cholesterol-lowering of the solubility on the temperature allows thermodynamic activities.1–3 As a plant avonoid, naringin, has attracted signi- analysis to give us information about the mechanisms involved cant scientic and public interest in recent years due to its in the dissolution process.7 versatile health-promoting effects.4 However, due to very poor In addition to solubility, preferential solvation phenomenon in solubility of naringin in water at room temperature, its bioavail- which the solute is surrounded preferablybythecomponentofthe ability is low and this hinders further studies on its pharmaco- solvent mixture has not been studied in many pharmaceutical logical applications.2 compounds so far. The phenomenon can help in understanding The experimental solubility measurement of bioactive the molecular interactions involved in the dissolution process. compounds in the solution as a function of solvent composition Therefore, the present study rst focuses on measuring the equi- and temperature is valuable particularly for the pharmaceutical librium solubility of antioxidant avonoid naringin in aqueous co- and industrial product design, and also to obtain complete solvent systems of DMSO (0–100% by w/w) and different temper- information about physicochemical characteristics of atures (298.15 to 325.15 K) using an isothermal dissolution equi- librium method. It is noteworthy that the co-solvent DMSO is an
School of Chemistry, Damghan University, 36716-41167 Damghan, Iran. E-mail: important polar aprotic solvent with very low toxic and immense 6 [email protected] biological importance. It dissolves both polar and nonpolar
14776 | RSC Adv.,2017,7, 14776–14789 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 View Article Online Paper RSC Advances
compounds and is miscible in a wide range of organic solvents as aTeon-coated magnetic stirring bar running at 450 rpm for at well as water. In the following step, the effectoftemperatureon least 4 h plus 2 h of settling in order to achieve the solid–liquid the solubility of naringin in the binary aqueous mixtures is equilibrium. These times were chosen based on previous analyzed to evaluate the thermodynamic quantities involved in the investigations.1,2 Between the outer and inner walls of the ask process of solubility. It is important to emphasize that the was lled by temperature controlled circulating water. However, temperature range used in this work covers different room the actual temperature measurement was made using a mercury conditions as well as the normal human body temperature. We thermometer with an uncertainty of 0.1 K that was inserted in also determined the inuence of co-solvent composition on the the solution. Aer equilibration, three samples were taken out solubility of naringin by means of KAT equations. Finally, the carefully from the upper parts of the suspensions each with inverse Kirkwood–Buff integrals(IKBI)approachisappliedto different volumes and were ltered and transferred to volu- evaluate the preferential solvation of naringin in the binary metric tubes. In the next step, the solvent was evaporated under mixtures examined. On the other hand, the molecular dynamics reduced pressure and then the dried residue was dissolved with (MD) simulations which are based on a range of complementary a known volume of the pure co-solvent. Finally, in order to computational approaches provide a very powerful tool for inves- determine the avonoid concentration, absorbance spectrum of tigating the solvation phenomenon, especially preferential solva- the solutions was recorded using a UV-Vis spectrophotometer in tion, directly using computed radial distribution function the wavelength range of 200 to 450 nm and with 0.1 nm intervals. (RDF).8–10 We also characterized the structure of the solvation shell All the solubility experiments were run at least in triplicates and of the naringin molecule (preferential solvation) in the aqueous the mean values were reported. DMSO mixtures by calculating the RDFs. The results of preferen- Before preparation of the saturated solutions, a calibration tial solvation are then compared with the data obtained from the curve was constructed using standard solutions of naringin over inverse Kirkwood–Buff integrals (IKBI) approach. an appropriate concentration range in the pure co-solvent DMSO to determine the molar absorbance coefficient (3)of l ¼ Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported Licence. Experimental section naringin ( max 326.6 nm). From the regression equation of the linear calibration plot, the value obtained for 3 was 1.2726 Chemicals and apparatus 104 L mol 1 cm 1. The value of molar absorbance coefficient ff The avonoid used as solute in the experiments, naringin, was was used for quantitation of naringin in di erent co-solvent purchased from Acros as analytical reagent ($97.0% purity) and mixtures analyzed. was not puried prior to use. The molecular structure of this avonoid is presented in Scheme 1. The organic solvent DMSO was obtained from Merck, with pro analysis grade ($99.0% Theoretical calculations purity). All solutions were freshly prepared using ultrapure The Kirkwood–Buff approach This article is licensed under a water (with a specic resistance more than 18.2 MU cm) In a binary co-solvent mixture like water/DMSO system, the throughout. Absorbance measurements were conducted on preferential solvation parameter of the solute (avonoid nar- a Perkin-Elmer (Lambda 25) UV-Vis spectrophotometer in ingin) by co-solvent (DMSO) can be dened according to the Open Access Article. Published on 06 March 2017. Downloaded 9/29/2021 9:55:39 PM. conjunction with a LabTech LCB-R08 thermo-circulator, using following equation:11 quartz cells of 10 mm optical path. L dxDMSO,S ¼ xDMSO,S xDMSO,S (1) Measurement of naringin solubility where x is the mole fraction of co-solvent DMSO in the First, the saturated solutions of naringin in each mass DMSO,S bulk solution and xL is the local mole fraction of co- percentage of the co-solvent DMSO (0–100%) were prepared in DMSO,S solvent in the environment near to the solute (solvation a 20 mL dual-wall glass ask by adding an excess amount of the sphere). The dx parameter represents the excess or de- avonoid naringin to the ask containing a known volume of the DMSO,S ciency of organic co-solvent of the aqueous–organic mixture in pure or mixed solvents (5–10 mL). Then, the suspensions were the local region. Such that the solute is preferentially solvated constantly stirred at temperatures 298.15, 303.15, 310.15, 315.15, by co-solvent, when dx > 0, while in case dx < 0, the 320.15, 325.15 K under atmospheric pressure of 0.1 MPa using DMSO,S DMSO,S solute is said to be preferentially solvated by water. Neverthe- L less, if x DMSO,S z 1, then complete solvation of the solute is d performed by the co-solvent. The parameter xDMSO,S in co- solvent systems can be obtained from the inverse Kirkwood– Buff integrals (IKBI) for each solvent component as follows:12,13 D G ; ¼ RTkT V þ xH OV (2) DMSO S S 2 H2O Q
D G ; ¼ RTkT V þ x V (3) H2O S S DMSO DMSO Q
Scheme 1 Molecular structure of flavonoid naringin.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 RSC Adv.,2017,7, 14776–14789 | 14777 View Article Online RSC Advances Paper k Ex In these equations, T is the isothermal compressibility of solvents GDMSO=H O with respect to the water proportion in 2 binary water/DMSO mixtures free of the solute (in GPa 1). The the mixtures (in kJ mol 1):14 k ! dependence of T on composition of solvent mixture can be 2 Ex v G = approximated from individual isothermal compressibilities of Q ¼ RT þ x x DMSO H2O DMSO H2O 2 (10) 14 vx components as: H2O T;P X k ¼ x k+ T;mix i T;i (4) i In order to calculate the Q values, rst the excess molar + Ex k Gibbs energies of mixing, G = , should be evaluated at all Here, xi is the mole fraction of solvent i in the mixture and T;i is DMSO H2O Ex the temperatures considered. In this way, G = values (in the isothermal compressibility of the pure solvent i with the DMSO H2O 1 values 0.524 and 0.457 GPa 1, for DMSO and water, kJ mol ) are calculated at 298.15 K by means of eqn (11) as 11 Ex 13 reported by Marcus. Then, the G = values at the other respectively. DMSO H2O temperatures can be calculated by means of eqn (12): In eqn (2) and (3), V DMSO and V H2O are the partial molar 3 1 h volumes of the solvents in the binary mixture (in cm mol ). Ex G = ¼ xDMSOxH O 4:909 þ 2:168ð1 2xDMSOÞ DMSO H2O 2 Also, V S is the partial molar volume of the solute in these i 3 1 2 mixtures with the value 349.72 cm mol for naringin. The 0:005ð1 2xDMSOÞ (11) partial molar volumes of water and the co-solvent can be
calculated based on the following expressions: Ex Ex G = ðT2Þ¼G = ðT1Þ T DMSO H2O DMSO H2O dV ðT V ¼ V þ x 2 1 T DMSO m DMSO (5) HEx z 2GEx ðT Þ dxH O DMSO=H Od DMSO=H O 1 2 T 2 T T 2 1 1 T dV Ex 2 þ H = 1 V ¼ V þ x (6) DMSO H2O T H2O m H2O x 1
Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported Licence. d DMSO (12) where Vm is the molar volume of the mixtures and it is calcu- Ex ¼ $ $ where H = is the excess molar enthalpy of the co-solvent lated as Vm (xDMSO MDMSO + xH2O MH2O)/dmix. The values of DMSO H2O 1 mixtures, T is 298.15 K and T is one of the other temperatures MDMSO and MH O are 78.13 and 18.02 g mol , respectively. The 1 2 2 ¼ Ex under study. At T1 298.15 K, H = function is calculated density of the binary mixtures analyzed (dmix) has been gathered DMSO H2O 11 from the literature.15,16 according to the following equation: h In eqn (2) and (3), the parameter D is the rst derivative of HEx ðT Þ¼x x : : ð x Þ DMSO=H O 1 DMSO H2O 10 372 6 922 1 2 DMSO the standard molar Gibbs energies of transfer of the solute 2 i 2
This article is licensed under a from pure water to binary water/DMSO mixtures : ð x Þ 2 466 1 2 DMSO DG ð ; / = Þ with respect to the co-solvent composi- t S H2O DMSO H2O (13) tion (in kJ mol 1): 0 1 Open Access Article. Published on 06 March 2017. Downloaded 9/29/2021 9:55:39 PM. vDG d ð ; / = Þ The preferential solvation parameter, xDMSO,S, can be @ t S H2O DMSO H2O A D ¼ (7) calculated from the Kirkwood–Buff integrals by means of the vxDMSO T;P following expression which proposed initially by Ben-Naim:17
x x ðG ; G ; Þ dx ¼ DMSO H2O DMSO S H2O S DMSO;S x G þ x G þ V (14) The standard molar Gibbs energy of transfer of the avonoid DMSO DMSO;S H2O H2O;S cor naringin, DG ð ; / = Þ, is calculated from the naringin t S H2O DMSO H2O where V represents the correlation volume and can be ob- solubility data and then correlated to specic polynomials as: cor ! tained as the following empirical equation:11 vx ; DG ¼ RT S H2O 3 ; / = ln V ¼ : r þ : xL V þ xL V tðS H2O DMSO H OÞ vx cor 2522 5 S 0 1363 ; DMSO ; H O 2 ; = DMSO S H2O S 2 S DMSO H2O ¼ a þ a x þ a x2 3 0 1 DMSO 2 DMSO 0:085 (15) þ a x3 þ a x4 3 DMSO 4 DMSO (8)
Thus, the D values are obtained from the rst derivative of In this equation, rS is the radius of the solute (in nm) which the above polynomial as follows: is calculated as: 1=3 3V ; D ¼ a +2a x +3a x2 +4a x3 (9) r ¼ m S (16) 1 2 DMSO 3 DMSO 4 DMSO S 4p The parameter Q in eqn (2) and (3) involves the second where Vm,S is the molecular volume of the solute with the value derivative of the excess molar Gibbs energy of mixing of the two 3 21 0.5816 nm for naringin. It is calculated as Vm,S ¼ 10 MS/dSNAv
in which MS and dS are the molar mass and the density of the
14778 | RSC Adv.,2017,7, 14776–14789 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 View Article Online Paper RSC Advances
27,28 solute, respectively and NAv is the Avogadro number. Since the constrained using the LINCS algorithm. Electrostatic inter- denitive correlation volume depends on the local mole frac- actions were determined using the particle mesh Ewald tions of the solvents (eqn (15)), it requires iteration. approach,29 with a 1.0 nm cut off for electrostatics and a 1.0 nm cut off for van der Waals interactions.
The molecular dynamics (MD) simulation Results and discussion MD simulations were performed using GROMACS 4.5.4.18–20 GROMOS96 force eld has been used for DMSO,21 whereas Solubility data of naringin water is modelled by SPC model.22 Force eld parameters and The solubility of avonoid naringin in different aqueous their geometries were generated using PRODRG2 server (http:// mixtures of DMSO was calculated in terms of molar concen-
davapc1.bioch.dundee.ac.uk/cgi-bin/prodrg_beta). trations of the solute (molar solubility, Sm) by using the absor- The energy of the system was minimized using 100 ps of the bance data obtained for the saturated solutions as well as the steepest descent method.23 Then 200 ps position restraint molar absorbance coefficient of naringin. The solubility was simulations were performed to relieve close contacts before the also obtained in terms of mole fraction of the solute (mole actual simulations. Finally, 5 ns MD simulations were accom- fraction solubility) using molar solubility data as follows: plished at the isothermal–isobaric (NPT) canonical ensemble.24 S x ¼ m The temperature was kept constant at 298.15 K by modied V- S (17) Sm þð1000d ½xH OMH O þ xDMSOMDMSO Þ rescale thermostat with the coupling constants of 0.1 and 2 2 pressure was controlled at 0.1 MPa by Parrinello–Rahman bar- where d is the density of the solvent mixtures free of the avo- 25 15,16 osta with the coupling constants of 2.0. The system was under noid which was taken from the literature, xH2O and xDMSO are
the periodic boundary conditions by applying the leap-frog the mole fraction of water and the co-solvent DMSO, MH2O and 26 algorithm with a time step of 2 fs and bond lengths MDMSO, respectively, represent the molar mass of water and the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported Licence.
Table 1 Experimental solubilities of naringin in molarity (Sm) and mole fraction (xS)atdifferent temperatures under atmospheric pressure p ¼ 0.1 MPa in aqueous DMSO mixturesa