442 Minutes of a Meeting of the Planning And
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE - 10 AUGUST 2006 MINUTES OF A MEETING OF THE PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBER, CIVIC OFFICES, ANGEL STREET, BRIDGEND ON THURSDAY 10 AUGUST 2006 AT 2.00PM Present:- Councillor L Davies - Chairperson Councillors Councillors Councillors Councillors D T Anderson R M Granville G C Lewis G Thomas R D L Burns C A Green L Morgan M Thomas C Y Butcher M Gregory M E J Nott J H Tildesley H J David J J Hipkiss M Quick M C Voisey A E Davies C E Hughes J Radford MA K Watkins G Davies R G Hughes C Rees C Westwood K R T Deere K S Hunt K T Rowlands M C Wilkins P A Evans M Inglesant D Sage H M Williams W B Evans C J James J C Spanswick M Winter E P Foley R D Jenkins W H C Teesdale Officers: Mr M Hooker - Assistant Director - Planning Mr H Batten - Legal Officer Mr J Duddridge - Head of Transportation and Engineering Mr D Davies - Head of Development Control Miss N Morgan - Senior Planning Assistant Miss J Wharf - Clerical Assistant Mr G Jones - Principal Cabinet and Committee Mr M A Galvin - Senior Cabinet and Committee Officer 538 CHAIRPERSON’S ANNOUNCEMENT The Chairperson advised that she had accepted the Planning and Development Committee amendment sheet as a late item, in accordance with Rule 4 of the Council Procedure Rules, in order that Members could be brought up to speed with changes to certain applications detailed in the main report of the Executive Director - Environment. 539 APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE Apologies were received from the following Members and Officers:- Councillor M Jones - Other Council business Councillor W May - Prior engagement Councillor S B Smith - Work commitments Councillor C J Michaelides - Other Council business Councillor L Phillips - Hospital Councillor P A Hacking - Other Council business Councillor M M Bertorelli - Holiday Councillor E Mcllveen - Holiday Councillor M L Simmonds - Dentist Councillor B I Quennell - Constituency issues Councillor D A D Brett - Other Council business 442 PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE - 10 AUGUST 2006 540 DATE FOR PROPOSED SITE INSPECTIONS RESOLVED: That the date for any site inspections arising from the meeting, be confirmed as Friday, 24 August 2006. 541 MINUTES OF THE PREVIOUS COMMITTEE MEETING RESOLVED: That the minutes of the meeting of the Planning and Development Committee held on 13 July 2006, be approved as a true and accurate record. 542 LIST OF PUBLIC SPEAKERS The Chairman then read out for the benefit of those present, the names of the public speakers listed to address certain applications to be considered at today’s meeting. The names of the persons who spoke together with details of the applications, are hereby listed as follows:- D Davies P/06/446/FUL (Objector) C Lewis P/06/507/FUL (Objector) T Diaper P/06/691/FUL (Objector) G Jones P/06/691/FUL (Applicant) B Hayball Jones P/06/458/FUL (Objector) K Matthew P/06/458/FUL (Applicant) H Davies P/05/1112/FUL (Objector) Mr Williams P/05/1633/RLX (Objector) Mr Vining P/05/1633/OUT (Applicants Agent) 543 DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST (1) The following Members present, by virtue of them also being Town or Community Councillors, had interests in the undermentioned property/land so stated. Due to special dispensation however, having previously been granted by the Standards Committee, the Members so listed were entitled to both speak and vote on these applications, having confirmed that they had had no previous involvement in the consideration of them at Town or Community Council level:- Name Property/land in question Councillor R M Granville and - Bryn Eglwys, Mawdlam, Bridgend CF33 4PP Councillor J H Tildesley Land at Dol Gorwel, North Cornelly, Bridgend Land Alongside Wyndham Court, Fairways, North Cornelly. Councillor P A Evans - The White Horse, Coychurch, Bridgend CF35 5HD. Grass Verge, Kinsway, Bridgend Industrial Estate, Bridgend CF31 3SB R/O Décor Frame, Brocastle Avenue, Waterton Industrial Estate. Councillor M Thomas - Plot 3 Hillside Gardens, R/O 18-32 Lower Adare Street, Pontycymmer. 443 PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE - 10 AUGUST 2006 Councillor C A Green, - Plot Adj. Llanmoor Dev. Broadlands Estate Councillor C E Hughes and Bridgend CF31 Councillor J J Hipkiss Stormy Down, Pyle, Bridgend Councillor W B Evans and - Unit 7, Spelter Industrial Estate, Maesteg, Councillor W H C Teesdale Bridgend CF34 0TD Maesteg Washery Land Reclamation, Maesteg. (2) The following Members declared interests in the undermentioned applications/items so stated:- Councillor L Davies - P/06/596/FUL - As an objector to the application is a close relative of hers. Councillor Davies left the Chamber whilst the application was being considered. Councillor C A Green - P/06/622/OUT - As the applicant is a friend of hers. Councillor Green left the Chamber whilst the application was being considered. Councillor P A Evans - P/06/251/RLX - As he frequents the premises subject of the application and he knows one of the objectors. Councillor Evans left the Chamber whilst the application was being considered. Councillor A E Davies - P/06/707/FUL, P/06/733/FUL, P/06/888/FUL, P/06/343/FUL, P/06/520/FUL, P/06/558/FUL, P/06/566/FUL, P/06/691/FUL and P/05/1633/FUL - As she recently chaired a meeting of the Porthcawl Town Council who are a consultee on planning applications. Councillor Davies left the Chamber whilst the above applications were being considered. Councillor M E J Nott - P/06/675/OUT - As the applicant is a friend of his. Councillor Nott left the Chamber whilst the application was being considered. Councillor W H C Teesdale - P/06/507/FUL - As the owners of the property subject to the application are known to him. Councillor Teesdale left the Chamber whilst the application was being considered. Councillor M C Voisey - P/06/804/FUL - Due to a business connection. Councillor Voisey left the Chamber whilst the application was being considered. Councillor C Y Butcher - P/06/251/RLX - Due to her son living in one of the streets mentioned in the report . Councillor R M Granville - P/06/499/FUL - As a member of the Kenfig Corporation Trust. 444 PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE - 10 AUGUST 2006 Councillor D Buttle - P/06/675/OUT - As the applicant is a former work colleague of his. Councillor J H Tildesley - P/06/499/FUL - As a member of the Kenfig Corporation Trust. Councillor K S Hunt - P/06/868/RLX - As a landowner of the site subject part of the site subject to the application. Councillor Hunt left the Chamber whilst the application was being considered. Councillor M C Wilkins - P/05/1633/FUL - As an objector to the application is known to her. Councillor Wilkins left the meeting whilst the application was being considered. Councillor K R T Deere - P/06/343/FUL - As Director of the applicant company and P/05/1633/FUL - As a partner in one of the selling agents of any future on site development. Councillor Deere left the Chamber when the above applications were being considered. Councillor M Thomas - P/06/714/FUL - As two objectors to the application are known to her. Councillor Thomas left the meeting whilst the application was being considered. Councillor K T Rowlands - P/06/868/RLX - Due to him being a member of the Board of Governors of Maesteg Comprehensive School. Councillor Rowlands left the Chamber whilst the application was being considered. Councillor C E Hughes - P/06/458/FUL - As he has a business interest in the application. Councillor Hughes left the Chamber whilst this item was being considered. Councillor C J James - P/06/589/OUT - As a Director of V 2 Coast. Councillor James left the Chamber whilst this item was being considered. Councillor L C Morgan - P/06/589/OUT - As a Director of V 2 Coast. Councillor Morgan left the Chamber whilst this item was being considered. 544 TOWN AND COUNTRY PLANNING ACT 1990 PLANNING APPLICATIONS GRANTED UNCONDITIONALLY RESOLVED: That the following applications be granted:- Code No. Proposal P/06/24/FUL Plot 20/21 (known as 20) Andrews Close, Tondu, Bridgend CF32 9EQ - Detached Garage. 445 PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE - 10 AUGUST 2006 P/06/707/FUL 42 Severn Road, Porthcawl CF36 3LN - Alterations to proposals/drawings previously approved - P/05/965/FUL (13-09-05). P/06/733/FUL 19 Neville Road, Porthcawl, Bridgend CF36 5LW - French doors and balcony amendments to previous approval 05/193. P/06/888/FUL Grove House, South Cornelly, Pyle, Bridgend CF33 4RP - Extension to side of property providing lounge/living area and bedroom over. Subject to the inclusion of the following Note:- Note: The presence of any significant unsuspected contamination which becomes evident during the development of the site shall be brought to the attention of the Public Protection Department. 545 TOWN AND COUNTRY PLANNING ACT 1990 PLANNING APPLICATIONS GRANTED CONDITIONALLY RESOLVED: That the following applications be granted, subject to the Conditions contained in the report of the Executive Director - Environment:- Code No. Proposal P/06/343/FUL Land east of 296 New Road, Porthcawl CF36 5PL - Erect 1 detached house and garage inc. demolition of existing building - amended plans. P/06/374/FUL Plot adj. Llanmoor Dev.Broadlands Estate, Bridgend CF31 - Construction of two dwellings. Subject to Condition 4 of the report being deleted, and Condition 7 being amended as follows:- 7. No dwelling shall be brought into beneficial use until the driveway and parking bays serving that dwelling have been completed in permanent materials and at gradients that do not exceed 12.5% (1 in 8).