Restoring the Biodiversity of Canopy Species Within Degraded Spekboom Thicket
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Restoring the Biodiversity of Canopy Species within Degraded Spekboom Thicket By Marius Lodewyk van der Vyver Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree Magister Scientae in the faculty of Science at the Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University January 2011 Supervisors: Prof. R.M. Cowling & Prof. E.E. Campbell 1 Acknowledgements “In the name of Allah, the most compassionate, the merciful”. Firstly I would like to thank the One, the All-Knowing, the All-Mighty, to whom all praise is due. I am very grateful to my parents for their unconditional love and support, I know I don‘t appreciate them enough. Prof. Richard Cowling, my supervisor, who had been instrumental in making this thesis happen, has opened up for me wonderful new worlds and horizons on many levels. I would like to thank him and his wife Shirley for their love, support and guidance, without which this thesis would not have been possible. Prof. Eileen Campbell is thanked for her encouragement, valuable advice and direction. I thank the Restoration Research Group that provides scientific oversight of the Subtropical Thicket Restoration Project (STRP). Dr. Anthony Mills, whose work has been a model of excellence to aspire to, deserves thanks for his valuable comments and help with the soil sampling procedures, carbon sequestration analyses and his sympathetic ear. Dr. Ayanda Sigwela is thanked for his valuable questions, help and comments. Mike Powell is thanked for his help and suggestions regarding the allometric sampling procedures. Funding for this research was provided by the Department of Water and Environment‘s (DWE) Working for Woodlands which initiated the subtropical thicket restoration project (STRP) of which Gamtoos Irrigation Board (GIB) is the implementing agent. I sincerely would like to thank these organizations for the opportunity and their assistance with the project. Dr. Christo Marais from DWE, and Andrew Knipe, Yolande Vermaak, Pippa Holm, and Victoria Wilman of GIB are thanked in this regard and also the Working for Woodlands contractor teams that fenced off my experimental plots and performed the practical soil sampling procedures. Victoria Wilman is especially thanked as she was instrumental in the propagation and preparation of the propagules, and has provided valuable advice and encouragement. Yolande Vermaak has helped considerably with organizing the fencing of my experimental plots and Pippa Holm has been a great help with handling and sorting the soil samples. I want to thank Dr. Mark Difford for his guidance with statistical analyses, he has proven himself to be a true guru, not just through his thorough analyses and knowledge of statistical intricacies, but also displaying superior patience and i providing clear guidance to an inspired but mostly confused R novice. The late Graham Slater and his wife Rhoda are thanked for their cheerful assistance, friendly conversation and many cups of tea during my fieldwork at Krompoort. I would also like to thank Mr. Desmond Slater for his advice and friendly conversation during long hours of solitary fieldwork. I thank Mr. Warren Rudman and his wife Belinda for their encouragement and their warm, hospitable reception and treatment of me on their farm Rhinosterhoek. Both Mr. Warren Rudman and Mr. Desmond Slater have provided valuable rainfall data, practical advice and personal observations of the ecosystem within which they have grown up and make a living in. Without Mr. Rudman (snr.) and Mr. Graham Slater‘s vision to plant spekboom 50 and 33 years ago respectively, this research and our better understanding of biodiversity regeneration within spekboom thicket would not have been possible. I hereby would like to thank them for this, albeit posthumously. Clayton Weatherall-Thomas and Merika Louw are thanked for their camaraderie and help with fieldwork. Everybody in the Botany Department at NMMU with whom I had dealings with is also thanked for their overall friendly and prompt assistance, enlightening conversation and the occassional lighter moments we shared. I would also like to thank all my friends and family who had to tolerate my rebuffs when I was invited for social gatherings or outings. Thanks especially to Gillian MacGregor, Robert Dugtig, Andre Stahmer, Etienne van der Vyver, Jacqueline Brown, Colette Stoltz, Faadil Khan, Margherita Razza, Steve Kalule, Cornel du Toit, Sadia Bundgaard, Luke Hutchinson, Eduard Lewis and Andon van der Merwe for their precious friendship and encouragement. ii Table of Contents Acknowledgements .................................................................................................. i Table of Contents .................................................................................................... iii List of Figures ......................................................................................................iv List of Tables .......................................................................................................vi Summary ................................................................................................................. 1 Chapter 1 – General Introduction ............................................................................ 3 Introduction .......................................................................................................... 3 Restoration and Ecology ..................................................................................... 4 Spekboom Thicket ............................................................................................... 6 Restoration of Spekboom Thicket ........................................................................ 9 Chapter 2 .............................................................................................................. 11 Restoring biodiversity by planting propagules of canopy species in degraded spekboom thicket is neither ecologically nor economically feasible. ..................... 11 Abstract ............................................................................................................. 11 Introduction ........................................................................................................ 12 Materials and Methods ...................................................................................... 15 Study Site....................................................................................................... 15 Nursery Propagation and Planting ................................................................. 18 Survival and Growth Assessment .................................................................. 19 Restoration Costs .......................................................................................... 20 Statistical Analysis ......................................................................................... 21 Results .............................................................................................................. 22 Survival and Growth Analysis ........................................................................ 22 Restoration costs ........................................................................................... 27 Discussion ......................................................................................................... 27 Chapter 3 .............................................................................................................. 31 Biodiversity Regeneration and Carbon Sequestration on Restored Spekboom Thicket Landscapes – Portulacaria afra Jacq. as an Ecological Engineer. ........... 31 Abstract ............................................................................................................. 31 Introduction ........................................................................................................ 32 iii Methods ............................................................................................................. 37 Site Description .............................................................................................. 37 Data collection ............................................................................................... 39 Statistical analysis .......................................................................................... 44 Results .............................................................................................................. 45 Carbon ........................................................................................................... 45 Floristics ......................................................................................................... 49 Discussion ......................................................................................................... 54 Chapter 4 – General Discussion ........................................................................... 58 Research significance of this study ................................................................... 60 Shortcomings and limitations of this study ......................................................... 60 What are the next steps ? .................................................................................. 61 Literature cited ................................................................................................... 66 APPENDIX A......................................................................................................... 75 APPENDIX B........................................................................................................