Bulletin of the Psychoanalytic Association of New York
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Volume 58, Number 1 Spring 2020 Bulletin of the Psychoanalytic Association of New York VOL 58, NO.1 • Spring 2020 In This Issue… Bulletin of Editorial , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . 3 The Psychoanalytic by David Frank Association of PANY Director’s Announcement of New Rules and New York Guidelines During the Pandemic . .4 Bulletin Board . 5 PANDEMIC ISSUE Fast Times at PANY: A Timeline . .6 EDITOR 425 EAST 79TH STREET, #1N NEW YORK, NY by Barry Rand 212-472-8867 Doing Analysis and Psychotherapy in the e-mail: [email protected] Pandemic . 7 Editor Herbert H. Stein, M.D. Film Essay by Herbert H. Stein Assistant Editor Leslie Cummins, LCSW Twin Films: Bohemian Rhapsody and Blinded by the Light . .9 PANY Director PANY News David Frank, M.D. News and Notes of Members . 15 Chair, Education Committee PANY at the Winter Meeting . 16 M. Carmela Perez, Ph. D. Chair, Graduate Society Committee Aneil Shirke, M. D. Vice Chair, Graduate Society Committee Monica Michel, M.D. Councilor to the American Psychoanalytic Association Arthur Lew, M.D. Alternate Councilor Barry Rand, M.D. 2 Editorial Remembrances Pandemic I must begin with a sad and overdue note on At this time, we are in the midst of perhaps the death last August of Dr. Martin Silverman. the strangest period of our lives and profes- Shortly after his death, David Frank sent out sional careers, the Covid-19 pandemic. I am the following statement: writing this editorial at home, in relative volu- “We have received the sad news that Martin nary confinement in an attempt to avoid infec- Silverman, MD, PANY Faculty, passed away in tion with the virus and as part of the general late August, 2019. Martin (Marty) was a attempt to contain the spread. Training and Supervising Analyst and a Child Most, if not all of you are treating patients by Supervising Analyst, and Child Instructor in phone or electronically. “Distance Psycho- the ‘80’s. He was also the book review editor of analysis” and “Distance Psychotherapy” are the Psychoanalytic Quarterly for a number of now no longer a choice of parameters dis- years and recruited book reviews from our cussed in institutes and psychoanalytic organ- members.” izations attempting to define best practices for Marty was one of the primary teachers in the using them. Now, it is by necessity the norm. area of child development and child psycho- In fact, I write this amidst an everchanging analysis when I began my training. I remember landscape, so that you may be receiving it him from then and more recently at society under new conditions. Right now, classes at the and institute events and discussion groups as a institute and meetings of our members are warm, thoughtful and very knowledgeable conducted on-line or phone. We know each teacher and colleague. other as faces on a screen. Social contact has As I think about him now, I remember sitting been replaced by social distancing as the ideal. with him outside in the vicinity of the old Discussions are ongoing about how we can Bellevue doing a child observation of an unsus- offer our clinic services and evaluate new pecting child from the neighborhood. patients online, things that were almost He is and will be missed. unthinkable a month ago. In the spirit of it, this issue will include some As you probably know, we lost Len Shengold of our usual items, news and notes of members in January as well and will be honoring his life and PANY at the Winter Meeting this February and work with a panel in the fall. in another era, and a now seemingly especially lighthearted psychoanalytic film commentary And, practically as I write this, I have heard for your distraction. We also are including the very sad news that Marianne Goldberger some commentary on the response of PANY died the night of March 31st at the age of 89. during the current crisis. Her death was apparently not related to the pandemic. I’ll close with the greeting that is now the norm. A sad time. Be Well, HHS 3 PANY Director’s Announcement of New Rules and Guidelines During the Pandemic by David Frank This announcement was sent online on March 15th to all the members of PANY. As expected, the Covid 19 situation continues from PANY's Technology and Psychoanalysis to evolve rapidly. PANY leadership has been course, that was developed by several of our deeply engaged over the past day in carefully faculty members in recent years. Lena Ehrlich's thinking through our own stance as a commu- JAPA article on her work seeing patients nity and considering our roles as analysts, ther- remotely was sent out yesterday and should apists, educators, and as clinicians and citizens have been received by all members. who are thinking about the public health. PANY has purview over candidates' treat- Today we hosted a meeting of 25 faculty mem- ments of their analytic patients, as well as can- bers via Zoom. The Covid Task Force (Liz didates' own analyses and supervisions. It is Horwitz, Stephen Malach, Carmela Perez, now a PANY requirement that all of these Barry Rand, Susan Resek, Herb Stein, Jennifer encounters be done virtually. Stephenson and myself) has also conferred. In As Director, I recognize that individual mem- addition, I've been in communication with the bers’ (faculty and candidates) private practices leadership of NYPSI, the Columbia Institute, are subject to their own discretion, and there and also with Kerry Sulkowicz who is may be individual circumstances for particular President-Elect of ApsaA. patients that might alter how quickly the tran- Yesterday, in the memo we sent out, Carmela sition occurs. But the operating principle and I deferred on specific advice to our com- should be: as soon as possible. munity about whether to see any patients at all I believe we have a responsibility to our on an in-person basis. We are no longer defer- patients to model behavior that may help them ring: to do the same, and the positive ripple effect of I want to be clear and unambiguous about every therapist in our community influencing my recommendation, both personally and as each of our patients could be considerable; Director of PANY, as well as on behalf of the conversely, we need to consider the negative PANY COVID Task Force and the overwhelming ripple effect individually and to the communi- consensus of the faculty at the meeting today: ty when patients venture to and from our Effective immediately, I urge all PANY clini- offices. cians to conduct all treatment and supervision Altering our accustomed ways of engaging is by remote means, whether by HIPAA compli- not easy. As hardy New Yorkers we tend to ant video or by telephone. tough it out at our appointed posts. And as Below the signature is a list of software analysts we are accustomed to working options that work well for remote video/audio through thick and thin seeing patients in our sessions.1 Additionally, a memo will go out offices through all circumstances. Also, as ana- soon about an educational session that Dr. lysts we are probably more inclined than oth- Marina Mirkin will conduct, via Zoom, for all ers to prioritize thinking over action. But I PANY members—candidates and faculty—- believe that adapting smartly to the current cli- about tele-analysis and tele-therapy. Also, to be mate calls for us to safeguard our patients, sent to all members shortly is the reading list supervisees, the PANY community and the New York City community at large by not see- 1. in keeping with changes since mid-March, these are not included here. ing patients in person; and to do this now. The 4 March 15 Director’s Announcement Frank evidence so far suggests that those communi- imagined. But I believe that we will grow as ties in the world that continued to go about individuals and as a cohesive and loving com- their lives as usual are facing arduous circum- munity as we face these currents, help our stances. We should not repeat that mistake. patients and each other in the process, and The public health dimension must be consid- own a deeper appreciation of the value of our ered. Doing our part to “flatten the curve” and work, a value that I feel is infinitely deep. in so doing conserve medical resources is in The COVID task force will meet regularly. We my view a paramount duty as a citizen. will have an ongoing series of Zoom meetings I recognize that we will all be working for both faculty and for candidates to discuss through a shared loss, a loss of the ever-so-spe- so much that will arise, much of which is hard cial intimacy that develops in the room with to anticipate now—primarily to support one our patients, in the service of the deeply mean- another. ingful help that we provide. Conscious and Having come to this decision, we're halfway unconscious illusions of invulnerability and there. May everyone be well and safe, control (including in the therapeutic and ana- lytic situation) shared by all of us, are being David Frank confronted in ways none of us could have Bulletin Board PANY's Training Analyst and Certification PANY LGBTQ+ Study Group Study Group The PANY LGBTQ+ Study Group for the The Training Analyst and Certification study of clinical practice issues in psycho- Study Group is a faculty peer group that analysis and psychoanalytic psychotherapy meets monthly with the purpose of prepar- involving members of this group is continu- ing Faculty for American Board of ing to meet online during the current pan- Psychoanalysis (ABP) Certification and/or demic.We invite all faculty and all candi- the PANY Training Analyst process.