DOCSLIB.ORG

Big Tech Giants Summoned to Senate After 'Social Dilemma' Backlash

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Big Tech Giants Summoned to Senate After 'Social Dilemma' Backlash Big Tech giants summoned to Senate after 'Social Dilemma' backlash foxnews.com/tech/facebook-twitter-google-senate-social-dilemma TECHNOLOGIES Published October 27 'There's kind of a World War III of global information warfare that's happening right now,' an ex-Google staffer says The leaders of three of the biggest tech companies in the world are facing a dilemma of their own after a Netflix documentary about the issues caused by their services sparked a Senate hearing slated for later this week. The CEOs of technology giants Facebook, Google and Twitter are expected to testify for an Oct. 28 Senate hearing on tech companies’ treatment of speech and information on their platforms. EX-GOOGLE CONSULTANT SOUNDS ALARM ON NEGATIVE IMPACT OF BIG TECH IN ‘THE SOCIAL DILEMMA’ The Senate Commerce Committee voted last week to authorize subpoenas for Mark Zuckerberg of Facebook, Sundar Pichai of Google and Jack Dorsey of Twitter to force them to testify if they didn’t agree to do so voluntarily. Spokespeople for the companies said Monday that the CEOs will cooperate. The hearing comes on the heels of the recent release of "The Social Dilemma," a documentary that explores the negative impact social media and Big Tech can have on people, and focuses on how some tech companies use psychology to influence user habits for profit. “It’s because of this business model that’s at the heart of these technology companies, which is that they make more money the more time they get you to spend,” Tristan Harris, a former Google executive and co-founder of the Center for Humane Technology, said in a recent interview with Fox News' Bill Hemmer. EX-GOOGLE STAFFER WARNS SOCIAL MEDIA, APPS ARE 'BIG TOBACCO FOR OUR BRAINS' Harris, who is featured prominently in "The Social Dilemma," adds that people are more likely to spend time on content that affirms their prior beliefs. 1/4 Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg (left) and Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey will testify before the Senate Commerce Committee this week. “It’s bad for the collective ... no matter where you fall on all these sides, we need to be able to agree in society on what we want to do about various problems we have," He said. "Whether it’s poverty, or climate change or racism, whatever we care about, we all have to come together and have a shared set of facts ... technology makes us operate in narrower and narrower, incompatible views of reality." EX-FACEBOOK HONCHO TIM KENDALL SAYS BIG TECH IS A ‘THREAT TO DEMOCRACY,’ CALLS FOR SOCIAL MEDIA REFORM The Senate hearing comes less than a week before Election Day and marks bipartisan criticism of Big Tech companies, which have been under increasing scrutiny in Washington and from state attorneys general over issues of competition, consumer privacy, and hate speech. Republicans have kept up a barrage of criticism of Silicon Valley’s social media platforms, accusing them of deliberately suppressing conservative views, while Democrats have focused their criticism of social media mainly on hate speech, misinformation, and other content that can incite violence or keep people from voting. Facebook and Twitter faced widespread criticism earlier this month after each social media platform took steps to slow the spread of the New York Post’s report on emails found on a laptop that purportedly belonged to Hunter Biden. The emails detailed alleged overseas business dealings with contacts in China and Ukraine. 'THE SOCIAL DILEMMA' FILMMAKER SAYS ‘ANY COUNTRY’ COULD MEDDLE IN ELECTION WITH WEAPON OF MASS MISINFORMATION A Facebook representative said the company would limit the spread of the article until its claims could be fact-checked. Twitter blocked the article from being shared entirely, in a step it said was due to its "Hacked Materials Policy." Twitter also locked the New York Post’s account and others that attempted to share the report until their posts were deleted. Zuckerberg and Dorsey will voluntarily testify before the Senate Judiciary Committee next month to address allegations of bias in their handling of news coverage during the 2020 election cycle, committee Chairman Sen. Lindsey Graham announced last Friday. President Trump signed an executive order earlier this year challenging the protections from lawsuits under a 1996 telecommunications law that has served as the foundation for a more unfettered speech on the Internet. 2/4 BIG TECH STAFFERS GAVE NEARLY $5M TO BIDEN, LESS THAN $250G TO TRUMP: REPORT "The Social Dilemma" docu-drama has struck a chord with many people as worries about social media's impact on society and political upheaval grows. Harris says that social media poses a safety and security risk from countries like China and Russia. "There's kind of a World War III of global information warfare that's happening right now," Harris said on a recent episode of the Fox News Rundown podcast. "If ... Russia, China try to fly a physical plane in the United States, we'd be shooting them down by the Department of Defense, but if they try to fly an information plane into the United States, they're met by a Facebook or Google algorithm that says, 'Which zipcode do you want to target?'" BRENT BOZELL: NY POST'S HUNTER BIDEN STORY CENSORED BY FACEBOOK, TWITTER -- BIG TECH VOTES FOR BIDEN Harris cited the debate over fracking as one example of how foreign entities use social media to manipulate public discourse in the United States. "Russia specifically has actually gone into, you wouldn't believe this, but anti-fracking and pro-environmentalist groups and actually tried to amplify environmentalists in the United States because if their voices are heard and saying we shouldn't frack in this country, it means that we have to buy more foreign Russian oil," he said. Facebook officials recently came out against the makers of "The Social Dilemma" with a public statement in which they claim that the documentary gives a "distorted view" of social media platforms. Watch Video At: https://youtu.be/uaaC57tcci0 "We should have conversations about the impact of social media on our lives. But ‘The Social Dilemma’ buries the substance in sensationalism," reads the post entitled "What 'The Social Dilemma' gets wrong." The social media giant also criticizes the documentary for only having former employees speaking about the platforms. "The film’s creators do not include insights from those currently working at the companies or any experts that take a different view to the narrative put forward by the film," reads the statement. "They also don’t acknowledge—critically or otherwise—the efforts already taken by companies to address many of the issues they raise. Instead, they rely on commentary from those who haven’t been on the inside for many years." 3/4 4/4.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Solving the Social Dilemma (Existential Threats and How to Deal with Them)
    Solving the Social Dilemma (Existential threats and how to deal with them) Cassandra Introduction Cassandra was a priestess to Apollo and sister to Hector of Troy. Apollo took a shine to her and gave her the gift of prophecy. When he realised his affections were not reciprocated he became very angry. He was not able to take back a gift from the Gods so instead he cursed her to make prophecies that were true but would never be believed. "The biggest mistake you can make is to be prematurely right" Peter Drucker In September this year a Netflix documentary called 'The Social Dilemma' (TSD) was given its worldwide release. It contains disturbing warnings about the human and societal impact of AI driven social media. Is the prophecy true or false? If true is it a tipping point or is it prematurely right? This article/paper is going to look at this in the context of two other 'existential threats', Climate Change and Pathogens. What are the patterns, how will the debate evolve, will it create change, what might the solutions be - what can we do about it? Here's what I'm going to cover:- • The meaning of 'Existential' • The Big 3 Existential Threats and the division of opinion • A dialectic process to reframe the debate • Why AI driven social media might be the priority • Some possible solutions My own personal position is irrelevant. It matters not whether my views concur with those expressed in 'The Social Dilemma' any more than it matters what I think about Climate Change or Covid 19.
    [Show full text]
  • Conservative Media's Coverage of Coronavirus On
    University of South Carolina Scholar Commons Theses and Dissertations Fall 2020 Conservative Media’s Coverage of Coronavirus on YouTube: A Qualitative Analysis of Media Effects on Consumers Michael J. Layer Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarcommons.sc.edu/etd Part of the Mass Communication Commons Recommended Citation Layer, M. J.(2020). Conservative Media’s Coverage of Coronavirus on YouTube: A Qualitative Analysis of Media Effects on Consumers. (Doctoral dissertation). Retrieved from https://scholarcommons.sc.edu/ etd/6133 This Open Access Dissertation is brought to you by Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. CONSERVATIVE MEDIA’S COVERAGE OF CORONAVIRUS ON YOUTUBE: A QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS OF MEDIA EFFECTS ON CONSUMERS by Michael J. Layer Bachelor of Arts Goucher College, 2017 Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of Master of Arts in Mass Communications College of Information and Communications University of South Carolina 2020 Accepted by: Linwan Wu, Director of Thesis Leigh Moscowitz, Reader Anli Xiao, Reader Cheryl L. Addy, Vice Provost and Dean of the Graduate School © Copyright by Michael J. Layer, 2020 All Rights Reserved. ii DEDICATION To the wonderful creators on the internet whose parasocial relationships have taught me so much about the world and myself - namely Olly Thorn, Philosophy Tube; Carlos Maza; Natalie Wynn, Contrapoints; Lindsey Ellis; Bryan David Gilbert; Katy Stoll and Cody Johnson, Some More News; and Robert Evans, Behind the Bastards - thank you. To Dr. Linwan Wu - I am profoundly grateful for your understanding, guidance, and patience.
    [Show full text]
  • The Social Dilemma (Netflix, 2020)
    Review: The Social Dilemma (Netflix, 2020) An uncomfortable observation Toward the beginning of 2020, I remember visiting my local VUE cinema and seeing a commercial starring John Boyega entitled ‘Get Lost in Great Stories’. It portrays a scene in which every person in a household is simultaneously viewing a different screen whilst going about their days; whether televisions, laptops, desktops or mobile phones. The door of the house opens and we enter another scene in the hustle and bustle of a city street, confronted with a picture of everyone walking with poor posture over their phones. A range of emoJis and reactions explode over the screen reflecting all that is going on in a relentless stream of data consumption. The commercial, interpreted simply, was indicating that cinema is the best way to watch a film and ‘step away from the outside world’. Nevertheless, the portrayal of everyday life disturbed me, not because it is portraying an imagined dystopia, but because in some ways such a dystopia is already here. We have become ape-like slaves of the very tools we invented and we are seeing health and cohesion in society suffer for it. The ongoing COVID-19 crisis has made people even more dependent on technology and probably even more addicted to screens as a result of isolation; if this is not swiftly identified as a problem, many will suffer as a result. Netflix’s 2020 documentary film, The Social Dilemma does a very good Job of highlighting what is going on behind the scenes of our screens and deserves consideration in developing a healthy pastoral theology of technology.
    [Show full text]
  • Your Undivided Attention Podcast Bonus Episode: the Social Dilemma
    Center for Humane Technology | Your Undivided Attention Podcast Bonus Episode: The Social Dilemma Tristan Harris: Today on Your Undivided Attention, instead of a podcast guest, we would like to tell you about something really exciting. Netflix just released a new documentary called The Social Dilemma. The film has been in the works for more than three years and includes appearances from me and from Aza and our co-founder, Randy Fernando. But what really has us excited is the incredible number of tech insiders at Facebook, Instagram, Twitter. They're all there in the film. Tristan Harris: What the film discloses, clearly from the people who built these systems, is how it is warping the collective consciousness of humanity. When you look outside and you see the madness of shortening attention spans, increasing irritability, increasing anxiety, more polarization escalating into conflict and you say, "Is this just natural? Is this just where we were headed from the start?" Or, if you rewind 10 years and you imagine putting on a pair of outrage and conflict colored glasses, so everywhere you looked, you went to your kitchen, you would see things you should be outraged about that your spouse left the cups in a different location than when you left it and you see the sneeze that someone sneezed unto the refrigerator handle before you walked in, what would your world be like if you wore those glasses for 10 years? Tristan Harris: Now, imagine that you didn't wear those glasses, but everyone else around you wore these outrage and conflict colored glasses.
    [Show full text]
  • The Social Dilemma
    Journal of Religion & Film Volume 24 Issue 1 April 2020 Article 22 January 2020 The Social Dilemma Jodi McDavid Cape Breton University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unomaha.edu/jrf Part of the Film and Media Studies Commons Recommended Citation McDavid, Jodi (2020) "The Social Dilemma," Journal of Religion & Film: Vol. 24 : Iss. 1 , Article 22. Available at: https://digitalcommons.unomaha.edu/jrf/vol24/iss1/22 This Sundance Film Festival Review is brought to you for free and open access by DigitalCommons@UNO. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Religion & Film by an authorized editor of DigitalCommons@UNO. For more information, please contact [email protected]. The Social Dilemma Abstract This is a film review of The Social Dilemma (2020) directed by Jeff Orlowski. Keywords Social Media, Artificial Intelligence, Advertising Author Notes Jodi McDavid is an instructor in folklore and gender and women's studies at Cape Breton University. This sundance film estivf al review is available in Journal of Religion & Film: https://digitalcommons.unomaha.edu/jrf/ vol24/iss1/22 McDavid: The Social Dilemma The Social Dilemma (2020) dir. Jeff Orlowski The Social Dilemma is a documentary which interviews executives and programmers who left social media sites such as Pinterest, Facebook, Instagram and Twitter for ethical reasons. It treads the familiar ground that you might expect about the addictiveness of social media, however, it does give in-depth information about how the artificial intelligence works. Tristan Harris, co-founder of the Centre for Humane Technology and previous Google employee, figures prominently in the film.
    [Show full text]
  • The Social Dilemma, by Jeff Orlowski, Netflix, 2020
    The Political Economy of Communication 8(2), 75–103 © The Author 2020 http://www.polecom.org SPECIAL SECTION The Social Dilemma, by Jeff Orlowski, Netflix, 2020 Film reviews with section editor’s introduction Editor: Paschal Preston, School of Communication, Dublin City University, Dublin Review I: The Social Dilemma: A Contradictory Narrative About Platform Power Robin Mansell, Department of Media and Communications, London School of Economics and Political Science Review II: Missing in Action: Silences and Evasions in The Social Dilemma Graham Murdock, Centre for Research in Communication and Culture, Loughborough University, UK Review III: Escaping the Matrix or Repeating Liberal (Techno)Solutions? Eugenia Siapera, Information and Communication Studies, University College Dublin Review IV: The Social Dilemma's Dilemma: Challenging and Reproducing Social Media Myths Yuqi Na, CAMRI, University of Westminster SPECIAL SECTION 76 The Social Dilemma: Partial Insights Amidst Fuzzy Frames Paschal Preston, School of Communication, Dublin City University, Dublin Keywords: social dilemma; social media; media theory; political economy of communication; critical theory; technology and society; AI; algorithms; digital media; media policy The core concerns of this journal, a specific niche within the broad field of media and communication studies, have become ever more mainstream of late. Indeed, whilst concerns about the evolving scope, role, influence, operations, control and regulation of the media of public communication have always been central features of modern capitalism, they have come to occupy a prominent spot in public attention and debate. This has little to do with spectacular, media-friendly, enterprising boosterism or knowledge- based entrepreneurship, or related efforts in celebrity promotion on the part of key researchers and authors from the political economy of communication.
    [Show full text]
  • Depictions of Social Media Using the Social Construction of Technology Concept
    Depictions of Social Media Using the Social Construction of Technology Concept A Research Paper submitted to the Department of Engineering and Society Presented to the Faculty of the School of Engineering and Applied Science University of Virginia • Charlottesville, Virginia In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Bachelor of Science, School of Engineering Alexa Guittari Spring, 2021 On my honor as a University Student, I have neither given nor received unauthorized aid on this assignment as defined by the Honor Guidelines for Thesis-Related Assignments Signature ________________________________________________ Date ______________ Alexa Guittari Approved ___________________ ______________ Date __5/4/2021___ Hannah Rogers, Department of Engineering and Society Abstract The sociotechnical relationship between human activity on social media and the depiction of social media is a complex subject and has many opposing views. In general, individuals either praise or criticize the usage of social media. Some are not in favor of social media as it can often lead to negative outcomes, such as decreasing one’s feelings of self-worth. There is often a presence of a skewed reality on social media. On the other hand, others admire social media as a positive concept. They feel as though they may benefit using social media by expanding their means of connecting with others and networking. These two different views can be acknowledged as to how behavior has ultimately shaped some of the platforms of social media. This paper will explore these two different outcomes and will be using the Science and Technology studies (S&TS) framework, social construction of technology (SCOT) concept to better understand these two perspectives.
    [Show full text]
  • Rutledge 1 Sarah Rutledge Bias, Politics, and Identity in the News
    Rutledge 1 Sarah Rutledge Bias, Politics, and Identity in the News and YouTube Introduction Media bias has been a thoroughly studied issue, especially in connection with politics. In fact, “nowadays we cannot talk about politics without invoking media, and we cannot understand contemporary media without appreciating the role they play in the political system” (Perloff 7). In other words, we cannot look at media without politics being involved somehow. A study done by Elejalde et al. looks at Chilean newspapers for media bias. They show that “There is a growing body of evidence of bias in the media caused by underlying political and socio- economic viewpoints…Results show that the media have a measurable bias, and illustrated this by showing the favoritism of Chilean media for the ruling political parties in the country” (Elejalde et al. 1). Mark Dice, though extremely conservatively biased, makes a few interesting points in his book, The True Story of Fake News. He states, “Famed media analyst Neil Postman explains in his historic work Amusing Ourselves To Death that a drastic shift took place when Americans began getting their news from television instead of from newspapers, magazines and books…the reason for this is that the very nature of the television business is to get people to watch by any means necessary” (Dice 30). Dice, in this point, emphasizes the importance of shifting mediums. A different study, done by Bessi et al., establishes bias in social media, but more importantly, focuses on echo chambers. They conclude “that the early interaction of users with contents is an accurate predictor for the preferential attachment to a community and thus for the emergence of echo chambers.
    [Show full text]
  • The Dangers of Social Media As Told by the Social Dilemma: Direct Media Effects and Cinematic Videogame Aesthetics
    THE DANGERS OF SOCIAL MEDIA AS TOLD BY THE SOCIAL DILEMMA: DIRECT MEDIA EFFECTS AND CINEMATIC VIDEOGAME AESTHETICS LAURA ÁLVAREZ TRIGO INSTITUTO FRANKLIN–UAH The Social Dilemma is a Netflix docudrama directed by Jeff Orlowski and released in September 2020. The film aims to convey the dangers of careless use of technology, the tech industry’s current issues with privacy regulations, and society’s unhealthy de- pendency on social media platforms that, by enforcing addiction, prevent users from developing real interpersonal relationships. The film conveys these messages by em- ploying two central narrative modes: firstly, interviews with experts within the tech- nology industry, and second, a fictional narrative that exemplifies the dire conse- quences of our everyday mindless use of social media. The docudrama as a genre is first and foremost a narrative of persuasion. Rather than representing reality its “basic purpose is to envelop us in the experience of its story. The overall thrust of docudrama is neither exposition nor logical argumentation, but persuasion” (Lipkin 2002, ix). The genre often entails persuasive discourse about moral implications and audiences tend to respond differently to a story than they would to argumentation—with the latter being characteristic of documentary style. Ultimately, docudrama is a strategy that, “at its most powerful, convinces us that it is properly both logical and emotional to associate cinematic proximity with moral truth” (Lipkin 2002, 31). Keeping this in mind and focusing on the fictionalized sections in The Social Di- lemma, this article shows how, in order to construct its persuasive message, this docu- drama establishes a storyline that relies on a traditional understanding of direct media effects, as well as on a cinematic approach inspired by videogame narratives.
    [Show full text]
  • Human Cooperation and the Crises of Climate Change, COVID-19, and Misinformation
    HUMAN COOPERATION 1 Human Cooperation and the Crises of Climate Change, COVID-19, and Misinformation Paul A. M. Van Lange David G. Rand Annual Review of Psychology (in press) Author Note Paul Van Lange, Department of Experimental and Applied Psychology, Institute for Brain and Behavior Amsterdam (IBBA), Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, The Netherlands; David Rand, Sloan School of Management and Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), Cambridge, USA. Address correspondence to either Paul Van Lange, Department of Experimental and Applied Psychology, VU Amsterdam, Van der Boechorststraat 7, 1081 BT Amsterdam, the Netherlands. Tel. : +31 20 5988852. E-mail: [email protected] ; or David Rand, Sloan School of Management, MIT, 100 Main St, Cambridge MA 02142. Tel: +1 617-324-4253. E-mail: [email protected] HUMAN COOPERATION 2 Abstract Contemporary society is facing many pressing challenges, including climate change, Covid- 19, and misinformation. Here we illustrate how these three crises are each social dilemmas, characterized by a conflict between short-term self-interest and longer-term collective interest. The climate crisis requires paying costs today to benefit distant others in the future. The Covid-19 crisis requires the less vulnerable to pay costs to benefit the more vulnerable, in the face of great uncertainty. The misinformation crisis requires investing effort to assess truth, as well as resisting the temptation to spread attractive falsehoods. Addressing these crises therefore requires
    [Show full text]
  • The Dilemma of Social Media
    94 The Dilemma of Social Media: Perceptions and Ethics of AI. Noha Samir, Mahgoub Faculty of Mass Communication, Cairo University, MSA University Abstract Social media networks are extensively using artificial intelligence tools (AI) fed with huge data about users’ preferences, mental state, mood, health, and other. The potential risk of manipulating this “Big Data” to predict users‘ behavior, customize users’ profiles and create a “Virtual social world” for each one is of major 2020 importance. Using algorithms to make sense of streams of data, known as the discipline of data ( أكتوبر / ديسمرب - analytics, and how it’s applied in social media platforms and decision-making rises ethical concerns about data privacy and data protection. The debate about the negative effects of social 31 media on users’ psychology, how it affects a person’s image of himself and the world واﻻتصال - العدد ) اﻻعﻻم لبحوث العربية املجلة العربية لبحوث اﻻعﻻم واﻻتصال - العدد ) will be tackled from the perspective of users‘ perception of the risks of using social media. This research is conducted to answer questions related to users’ perceptions of privacy, risk of sharing personal data on social media and to what extent are people aware of the use of AI and the risks they face while using SNSs, as well as the ethical issues related to the use of artificial intelligence in social media. Introduction: 2020 Artificial intelligence technologies have been an issue of recent debate, ( أكتوبر / ديسمرب - perceptions about AI were generally connected to computer science field for a long time, but in the past few years, interest has been focused on the implications of AI in people’s life and the future of human relations.
    [Show full text]
  • Social Media & US Democracy
    MISINFORMATION, SOCIAL MEDIA & THE CRISIS OF AMERICAN DEMOCRACY HI501-04 Senior Seminar: Media Studies & Popular Culture Graduation Dissertation | Fall 2020 1M150290 KWON, Soongyu School of International Liberal Studies | Waseda University ABSTRACT The main objectives of this paper are as follows: (1) explain the concept of tribalism and describe the relationship that it possesses with American society and politics, (2) discuss how present-day developments in the world of contemporary media have been accelerating the phenomenon of polarization within the United States, (3) present different case studies in which social media has and still continues to have a significant impact on public discussion surrounding current events in America and (4) propose a variety of solutions to the relevant stakeholders who should be held accountable for the problematic status quo so as to help restore the key values of democracy upon which the United States has been founded. The paper will include a personal analysis of certain Netflix documentaries that have reference to two of the recently contested events: Karim Amer and Jehane Nouhaim’s The Great Hack for the 2016 presidential election involving Hillary Rodham Clinton and Donald John Trump, and Jeff Orlowski’s The Social Dilemma for the 2020 presidential election involving Joseph Robinette Biden Jr. and Donald John Trump. Not only will it be of assistance to one’s comprehension concerning the background information of what had happened during the entire course of the election, but it will also give strength to the reasoning that social media plays an undeniably important role in shaping the circumstances of the American public sphere.
    [Show full text]